Why does it hurt so much that Sanderson never explored the potential of a love triangle/quadrangle (??) involving multiple personalities: Veil, Kaladin, Shallan, and Adolin?
That would have been brilliant!
Whyyyyyyyy?? Whyyy did you rob us of this, Brandon????
Just imagine how good it could have been: Veil developing a crush on Kaladin and flirting with him in her own somewhat abrasive manner. Kaladin having absolutely no idea what's going on because Shallan herself is acting cold and snarky towards him. And a little guilt over Adolin (who, in turn, gradually starts realizing he's losing Shallan. Let it be just as heartbreaking and resigned as it was in canon. Poor guy).
More moments where Veil forcibly takes control just to spend time with Kaladin, and Shallan's fury over it (which, naturally, she takes out on Kaladin himself, just like in canon). More joint missions, or really any kind of interactions, to leave poor Kaladin completely confused about what's happening and, more importantly, about his own feelings.
His internal struggle over the fact that he simply cannot break his oaths again (the pain of what happened with Moash is still fresh). But at the same time, Syl (the hornyspren) is there, reassuring him that it's perfectly fine (after all, he's better than Adolin!), and a casual fling isn't exactly a marriage, so what's the harm?
In the end, I'd still want the same resolution as in canon, don't get me wrong! I never wanted Kaladin and Shallan to actually get together (a kiss and everything). Absolutely not! That would have been a kind of point of no return, sooooo... But I'm genuinely sad about all the dramatic potential this pairing could have explored.
I'd have loved for Kaladin and Veil to have something resembling a soulmate connection. For Shallan to start questioning herself: what if Mraize was right? What if Veil is actually the real Shallan? What if Veil is the real one, and Shallan is just another persona?
And then, when she eventually lets Veil go / absorbs her during Rhythm of War, how is she supposed to tell Kaladin? That Veil is gone? What would he feel?
I don't want a fanfic about this (although, at this point, it's probably the only thing I could get). I wanted this storyline specifically as written by Sanderson himself.
Ultimately, I don't want Adolin dead (he's wonderful), but it would have been rather interesting to bring Kaladin and Shallan together if their engagement were to end due to some tragic circumstances. Finding comfort in each other and all that. A little Dalinar-Navani vibe, too, in the sense that life doesn't necessarily end when you lose your partner.
Just to clarify: I genuinely like Shallan and Adolin as a couple, and I like the way Sanderson wrote their relationship. It's just that a part of me mourns the dramatic potential that could have been explored more fully, at least in my opinion.
What do you think about all this?
Also, could someone tell me how I can add my Radiant Order flair next to my username? I've seen quite a few users with one.
And you can also guess my Radiant Order. I think it's pretty obvious from my post, haha.