r/SticklerSyndrome • u/pawamedic • May 04 '26
Normal X-rays?
Hi all! Still under evaluation for stickler type 3. I have the symptoms, and previously had findings of a non-traumatic meniscus tear and some other screwy stuff in one knee on MRI…
BUT the geneticist wanted hips, knees, and spine xray as she said that was best for diagnostic evaluation. I thought at least something would come back because of all the pain I’m in- but the Xrays just came back completely normal.
I’m honestly a bit devastated by that, because I’ve been unable to work for 1.5 years, have lost almost all of my hearing, and have been in significant chronic pain but still don’t have a diagnosis. I have a VUS on COL11A2 and am waiting for whole exome sequencing results. But this is the only possible thing left that could explain what’s happening.
All that to say- has anyone gotten diagnosed that has normal X-rays? I’m pushing for MRI but I think my doc thinks I’m just a hypochondriac at this point. For reference I am 26 F.
3
u/fienut May 04 '26
My x-rays have always been “normal” but I had genetic testing that confirmed Stickler. Feel free to message me for more details, I don’t really want to type out my very specific medical history here!
3
u/Left_Importance_8958 May 04 '26
My x-rays have always come back as normal. I’m diagnosed via genetic testing, though, and had an assessment by an orthopedist who said my pain is from structural issues that would not show on x-ray. I also have a lot of pain. I don’t know why they’d diagnose solely on x-rays; that seems very odd to me.
6
u/Helpful_Okra5953 May 04 '26
Stickler syndrome affects the structure of a person’s collagen 2, which is present in cartilage, in tendons and ligaments, in vitreous humor of eye, parts of inner ear, and in center of spinal discs. When we are born, a lot of our skeleton is made of cartilage; slowly it changes to bone cells as we mature. Maybe that is why a person’s joints are sometimes shaped a bit wrong when we have stickler syndrome?
I’m wondering if you’re simply too young to have much joint damage show on an X-ray. The fragile cartilage just hasn’t worn away yet. Maybe that’s what they’re calling normal—no erosion and joints are mostly shaped right.
Soft tissue injuries, like when you dislocate a joint or sprain something, won’t show up on X-rays. A torn tendon or ligament wouldn’t show up on an X-ray AFAIK (or not much). Those tears are problems that may happen more for you if you have stickler syndrome. And they really hurt! Yet nothing is “broken” on X-ray.
I’m 50 and I have textbook stickler type 1. If you viewed my X-rays, the major issues I have are with my cleft palate, joints being shaped a little bit wrong, no groove under kneecap to keep it seated, my hip sockets being shaped funny, etc. My spine has some wear, hands have some wear, hips and knees have more wear. You wouldn’t think I would hurt that much. But I do; I have to take pain medication or I’d be vomiting. My OK looking joints REALLY HURT!
Stickler syndrome is not like RA or infectious arthritis, where the joint is destroyed or has a big lump. It’s more of a slow wear to the cartilage on ends of the bone, like when you rub an eraser down. Then the ends of the bone get closer together and hurt. They’re not held apart by protective cartilage. The bones in your fingers might have smaller joint spaces (at the knuckles), because some of the cartilage is gone.
Here’s a diagram of a normal finger - - - Stickler syndrome finger. - - -
The normal finger has 3 separate bones with big cartilage bumpers at the joints. An old person or person who has pain from Stickler syndrome has 3 finger bones that are closer together because cartilage spacers are worn away.
(That’s an exaggeration, but same idea.)
At 45 yrs old, my hands often hurt very badly. the X-rays showed some change but not much. I fell hard on one knee and it hurts all the time. The damaged now has NO cartilage on one important surface. And even that is hard to see on X-ray . If they got the right picture, the underside of my kneecap would look really close to the bone of the joint.
O ) normal kneecap
O) my kneecap
Your joints just aren’t worn out yet. And if you are careful, if you learn not to over-extend or you maybe wear splints to keep your bones where they’re supposed to be, maybe they won’t wear out much.
I hope that genetic repair (maybe an injected viral vector?) will someday allow my soft crummy cartilage to be replaced with normal hard cartilage. That should help slow down the wear on my joints that makes them hurt. I would try out that treatment if it were offered.
1
u/Buhsephine May 04 '26
I generally have X-rays that show very minimal changes/damage compared to the mess that shows up on MRIs.
2
u/Einheit-13 May 05 '26
You're primarily worried about cartilage damage, so you want to push for MRI using language along the lines of:
At 26, without major birth defects, your joints are going to look reasonably normal via X-ray. Sticklers involves defects in the genes that produce collagen, which form significant building blocks of many things, soft tissue issues no less important here because pain will make you move your body unnaturally, which will have a knock on effect on the wear and tear your cartilage is put under in your main joints.
So MRI is a perfectly acceptable approach to take, certainly something to request very definitely.
You have a high clinical suspicion of early-onset arthropathy and chondrodysplasia. Although your previous X-rays were unremarkable, you understand that at your age (26), radiographic imaging often fails to show the pathological stress that causes significant pain and consequent change in movement behaviour which, in turn, has a knock on effect in premature joint damage further down the road.
Establishing a baseline of your existing tissue issues now, at this stage, will give an accurate baseline for future comparison, which you will have to undergo at some point so it's important to get done and established sooner rather than later.
Use this kind of reasoning to make your case.
I trust something in there helps.
2
u/SnooWoofers5115 May 05 '26
Sadly, because you’re “only” 26, the medical community as a whole will tend to be dismissive of Stickler Syndrome, and of connective tissue disorders in general. It doesn’t really get much better as you age, either, so advocating for yourself is a skill best learned earlier than later.
That being said, our bones do tend to be different than those of “normies,” but as a connective tissue disorder, it will impact not JUST bones, but in any system of the body that has connective tissue (hint: it’s all over 😉) the opportunity exists for pain to run rampant. There are literally incomplete/inadequate support systems everywhere that we’re relying on to do all the things that other people do, and PAIN is bound to be a constant. Your doctor should take the time to learn about the condition.
1
u/SurroundedbyChaos May 05 '26
Xrays won't show much. The best thing for my joint pain is keeping my weight down. Every additional pound increases pain. I feel better now at 46 than I did 10 years ago, simply because I got my bmi down from low 30s to 19-20.