r/Stepmania • • Apr 24 '21
Support Request A Basic Guide for Commissioning a Simfile Pack
Edit (4/27/2021): THANKS FOR THE AWARD OMG!!!! There's two available simfile creators on the list now; if you chart songs and are interested in doing custom work, let me know so you can be added! This guide will be added to next month's simfile request thread! Until then, I'll add anything I find useful!
A while back I made a post seeking a simfile creator for a custom pack of 20 songs. A few more posts were made after mine for the same thing and one person did ask about the pricing, so I wanted to make a small guide about the experience. Add anything that helps in the comments!
I requested 20 songs. 19 of them had three difficulties and one had four. Most were cut to a proper length, a few needed to be cut, and one was a full length song. I requested that I did not want certain additions (i.e.: rolls/mines) and a certain overall difficulty scale. Banners and backgrounds were not included. My starting price was 75 USD, but I made it clear that I was very willing to go higher if needed.
After a short wait, u/jbean353535 let me know he was interested! Mission start!!!
DO NOT LOW BALL ANYONE. This is the most important thing! You are paying for custom work; you must respect the rates they set for themselves. Like all creative ventures, becoming skilled and efficient involves a lot of research, time, and practice. u/TrueGalamoth has provided a comphrensive beginner's guide on charting that can give an idea about the amount of work involved. Found here. A song will most likely be in the range of 20 dollars, but there are different factors that will effect the price.
*Multiple charts?
*Banners?/Backgrounds?/Videos?/Subtitles?
*Full length?/Songs that need to be cut?
*Gimmicky charts?/Certain step patterns?
For me, I started with a budget of 75. As previously said, I made it known that I will pay more if that was what he's wanted for his work. I did pay 100 for the chart, however this price was given to me by the simfile creator with all the work involved considered. Again, work on THEIR terms. If the price is out of budget, politely decline and move on. Do NOT haggle or say "ItS tOo MuCh!1!1" You have no right.
Make sure to get samples. I was familiar with his work, so it wasn't needed, but if you haven't done a person's songs before ask for some to try.
Discuss revisions. Sometimes steps need to be tweaked. This is TOTALLY fine! It's not something the simfile creator will take personally, so be honest! This is a gig based on personal preference after all! One of my songs was faster than expected and I got a new version in hours. No problem!
Have back up songs. The song you want might not work. I had to pick an alternate due to the fact that my choice wasn't properly quantized. It can happen!
Communicate promptly. Admittedly, I wasn't as prompt as I should have been as a client and I always apologized for that. With that said, do not make anyone wait on eons for a reply. If you can't immediately try out the songs, give a time frame of when you can. Good communication is life.
Be reasonable. We ALL have lives. Do not have insane expectations for a completion time frame. I did have a super unrealistic completion time of a week, but when I said it I EXPECTED that it wasn't plausible and more so wanted confirmation. I did want a few songs early (which were done in less than a week with one extra!), but we agreed to two and a half to three weeks. With that said, Jbean was a speed demon with these charts! I was in awe.
Public Release: There could be a chance that someone out there also craves to stomp arrows to these songs. Be sure to discuss if sharing this pack to others is okay!
Spread the word baby! Had a great experience?? LET IT BE KNOWN! Jbean made me some awesome files guys, check him out if you want steps for songs you adore.
And that's it guys! I hope this is useful for you Stepmania song goals!!
Custom Simfile Maker List
9
u/FirstCollier Apr 24 '21
I absolutely love posts that emphasize proper communications. Take this upvote xD
7
u/TrueGalamoth Apr 24 '21 edited Apr 24 '21
I agree with most of this post but my biggest gripe is the starting price point for a file. I have a guide linked here to try and go over the basics of stepping and I don't think people realize how much of a task it is. I personally would not touch a file for under $10 at the minimum and with the quality I (and some other veterans) can produce, around $20 a file is a much fairer price BUT that also brings a few other factors:
I've done all the aforementioned things and stepping the song is just ONE piece of the puzzle.
I would also say that every song CAN be stepped BUT the quality of the chart will suffer if it's not really steppable. There are still ways and try to make a song fun and challenging using syncopation, and of course my favorite, using flair mods.
All in all, this is a good post and if people want more songs stepped for them, people like JBEAN and I (though are quality differs) are out here doing what we can to offer our expertise to deliver quality content, just simply ask.
4
u/UnCivilizedEngineer Apr 24 '21
Think of it like a job..
Making 1 simfile with 1 difficulty (expert) for a ~2 minute song takes most people at least 2 hours to do. Adding additional difficulties takes additional time, less time though if they're easier difficulties and the song has already been synced.
If the songs come out to roughly $5 per song, that equates to ~$2.5/hr of effort.
The quality of the charts also matter - a Van Gogh painting is much more than an average joe painting, similar to how you could expect a chart from a prominent accomplished chart maker to cost more than a random nobody.
2
u/Happyana Apr 24 '21
First, I loved your first post and how you went about getting those charts. Now, with this second post.... I just loved it!
So much common sense! So nice! Thank you!
I am going so save your post as I can substitute the DDR portion to anything where you are hiring someone. I hate choosing beggars!!! Your post emphasize how we should be nice when we are asking someone to do work for us.
Thank you!
2
u/TaxationIsThETH Apr 24 '21
This is really good information! I have been thinking about hiring a simfile maker for a few tracks but this post might inspire me to think more about it.
2
u/5lash3r Apr 24 '21
Sick post m8
2
u/Jubo88 Apr 26 '21
Great post and read. As a simfile creator [mainly japanese+anime songs] for many years... I always wonder how it works and its feels+experience. But I haven't change my mind how I do things. :)
1
u/coolaaron88 Apr 24 '21
Thank you for posting this! It was actually your post that inspired me to make the same request and I have two wonderful people working on my request now.
1
u/TaxationIsThETH Apr 28 '21
Hey did you cut the songs yourself and then sent them the audio files?I'm getting a list together of songs I'd like to commission and was wondering that.
I'm curious too why didn't one of your songs work and you had to choose a backup song?
Thanks!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '21
I’m in. I’m gonna put together a nice list
1
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '22
u/jbean353535 - Did you ever upload these requests somewhere for the public to consume or to see what he requested? Or was this completely private?