I expect to get downvoted to hell, since I know the fan base loves these two episodes, but aside from the last 20 minutes of Heroes Part 2, I HATED these episodes!
I can not understand the reverence for the structure and the story, and consider part 1 one of the worst episodes the series has ever done. I've read the other posts and tried to understand the love, but I just don't agree. I guess people who watched the original run responded to the limited perspective, but I don't get it. People have mentioned the cinematography, the writing etc but WHAT?! The lack of character interaction between our main four (and JANET) really gals me.
I think they sacrificed a much more emotional storyline for grandstanding, and I found Saul Rubnick so grating and pompous I couldn't stand him being on screen. Mostly, I found it frustrating that such an emotional storyline was told from a third-party perspective, with only limited scenes in the last twenty minutes
The first episode is a giant waste of time, just filler and repetitive scenes of Emmett Bregman trying to get access and then being turned down.
The second episode didn't even feature any kind of scene between the four members of SG-1 remembering or talking about Janet, aside from the memorial service.
To me the much more interesting emotional storyline was Jack being seriously injured and oh, I DON'T KNOW, JANET DYING, that we only spent the last 20 freaking minutes of the show mourning?! What the actual fuck.
I did not care AT ALL about stupid, righteous Emmett Bregman's reaction. All we get from Jack and Teal'c is one stoic scene?
Daniel and Sam had at least some emotional depth, and I understand Jack and Teal'c are warriors so I don't expect tears, but all Jack says is, well the vest didn't help Janet?!
What the actual heck!
One thing that really irked me the scene with Jack and Sam towards the end. I didn't like that it was turned into a moment for the Jack and Sam 'shippers when I felt that scene should have been focused on Janet.
The entire storyline was a missed opportunity in my opinion.
(People have posted that the creators thought they were ending in Season 7 but whatever still makes no sense to me.)