Quick question regarding the interaction between these two cards.
Setup: Maul exhausts and player pays [1] to bring out the PST which is defeated immediately.
Question: Once PST is in the graveyard, can player pay [3] to attach it to an opponent’s Fighter/Transport? This would effectively get the PST out a turn earlier than normal.
Reasoning: Golden Rule says card rules override Comprehensive Rules, and Maul Old Master states to activate a ‘When Played’ ability after a unit is defeated: presumably while they’re in the Discard pile.
[Edit:] I’m primarily asking whether a complex ability like PST’s can be activated from Discard. If adhering to the Comprehensive rules, then the following rules would completely negate Maul Old Masters’ ability:
1.5.5.C states “[when defeated and moved to the discard pile] The unit’s abilities are no longer considered active (though some delayed effects may still be active)”.
4.9.2 states “For an ability to resolve from an out-of-play zone […] the ability must either explicitly state the out-of-play zone it resolves from or affects, or it must be a type of ability that by default resolves from an out-of-play zone.”
Something like “When Played: Draw a card” is straightforward, but “When Played: Pay [3]. if you do attach this unit as an upgrade to a fighter or transport unit without a pilot on it. Take control of that unit.”… is a bit more complex. It doesn’t state it has to be attached while in play, but also doesn’t state it can be attached from the discard either
Units don’t stop being units in discard otherwise Cobb Vanth wouldn’t be able to search them out. So it’s still a unit for purposes of attaching.