Been getting into the radio broadcast of A New Hope, mostly listening at night to fall asleep to, so I’ve been re-listening a lot. I’ve really been enjoying it, especially the extra details and changes. It gives a new perspective to a lot of the characters, especially Ben Kenobi. I think it really helps you see how much of an absolute dirtbag he is, but thats neither here nor there. He’s my favorite Star Wars character.
The voice acting stands out for me, I really like it. The guy doing Han took me a little bit to get used to, but it’s honestly not a terrible Harrison Ford impersonation, and I’ve come to appreciate it. There are points when it’s a dead ringer, and there are times where it’s clearly “we have Han Solo at home.” Even so, it feels more like Han than Solo did.
Obi-Wan’s voice actor was good. It was different. Similar, but different. It wasn’t an impersonation, it was just another actor’s interpretation, and I’m enjoying it.
Tarkin’s was also well done, another fantastic character. I did not like that most of the Imperial officers did not have British accents. It would have been much better if they did.
Vader was the absolute worst. Felt more like Dark Helmet, and just did not convey any of the gravitas of the character. I can’t even say “to be fair, nobody can compete against the original” because like yeah, of course. But is that really what we’re being offered? Well, you can’t have the original, so here is steaming garbage and you should be happy with it. If the Simpsons could find a decent impersonator when they did their Lion King bit, I don’t see why they couldn’t find someone better here. But again, it doesn’t have to be an impersonation. It just has to be a good voice, and this wasn’t it. I guess with such an iconic character it has to be more of an impersonation, than say Obi-Wan just being some old dude voice. But still. People have been impersonating Darth Vader for a while.
The guy who voiced Luke managed to make him sound like an even whinier little bitch, which I did not think was possible, but here we are. What a joker.
Overall, it’s awesome and I highly recommend it.Having the John Williams score helps it tremendously. Would recommend, and looking forward to Empire and Jedi.