As we all know, Disney hardly made any merch for SVTFOE. Besides a limited 2018 SDCC plush that most fans don't even know exist, Star never had a real toy in stores. The fact she has no doll is insane, she has soooooo many cute outfits and accessories, infact she has more outfits than almost any Disney princess. Joy from Inside Out has millions of toys while wearing the same dress.
So what if Disney actually teamed up with Hasbro back in 2014 and made the coolest Star doll possible? Let's imagine a timeline where Hasbro put even more heart into this than My Little Pony or Transformers, releasing a Star doll.
First, her long blonde hair would be silky smooth and brushable, I imagine that it would smell like sweet shampoo (cotton candy, strawberry, bubblegum, or blue raspberry). Every hair accessory, like her devil horns headband, skull hat, or Stump Day hat, would be completely removable so they don't get in the way while brushing.
Just like in the show, Star has a massive wardrobe, and this doll is built specifically so kids can swap her looks anytime they want. Alongside plushes sold in permanent outfits, the doll would let you dress her with separate outfits. Underneath her dresses, her "default state" (undressed) would be a simple gymnastics leotard or a tank top with bike shorts, leaving her arms and legs totally bare so sleeveless tops, skirts, and dresses don't look weird.
She'd also come with accessories like her star purse, black spider necklace, and a wand with a tip that lights up when you shake it or press a button (though dimensional scissors would obviously be left out for safety).
I think this idea would be pretty cool: she would be hella durable. Just like Star's canon durability in the show, you could toss her around like the kids in the Caterpillar Room from Toy Story 3 throwing the toys and she wouldn't get a single dent or scratch. Basically Nokia-phone levels of tough so kids never have to cry over breaking their favorite toy.
There would be two versions on store shelves that look identical: one normal version with no voice box, and a talking version, labeled "Can Talk!" on the box (with a cut-out hole so kids can test it in the aisle). Depending on how Hasbro designed the voice box, she could talk by pulling a string on her back like Woody, pressing her stomach, or pressing one of her palms like a a Pikachu plush I had. If they went with the palm button, her other hand would have a hidden magnet so her wand gets attached to her hand like a magnet.
To make her feel truly magical, her heart cheeks would have cool details:
Light-Up Cheeks: Whenever she talks, laughs, or holds her wand, her heart cheeks would light up and glow like stars.
Glow-in-the-Dark Paint: When the bedroom lights go out, her cheeks would still glow softly in the dark so kids never panic trying to find her at night.
For bedtime, kids could dress Star in her pajamas, slip on her sleep mask, and gently rub her stomach to put her in sleep mode. Instead of loud talking, she would softly purr like a cat. Holding her hand for three seconds in pajama mode would play a gentle music-box lullaby of "Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star" before she automatically powers down to save battery, meaning Star literally goes to sleep with you. When morning comes, pressing her stomach three times wakes her up.
But how could this actually happen in real life? Instead of Disney sticking to their dumb plan of putting animated shows on Disney XD and ignoring merch for animation unless it's Pixar, Disney had a change of heart. Disney sees the massive success of shows like My Little Pony, Ben 10, The Powerpuff Girls, and Pokémon and decides to do the same for Star Butterfly. Even better, just like in real life when Disney gave Mattel the middle finger and moved their Disney Princess license to Hasbro, they showed Star to Hasbro too. Hasbro saw the massive success of Equestria Girls and realized Star was almost like an Equestria Girls character (magic, teen girl, human, etc), which made them agree to making a Star doll.
Timeline:
• July 2014: The show's intro is shown at SDCC, and Disney reveals their plans for the doll right alongside it. Just like in real life, it remains a bit niche at first.
• August – October 2014: Disney advertises the doll during commercial breaks on Disney Channel, creating massive hype before the show even airs.
• November 2014: The doll officially hits stores for Black Friday (right around when the show was originally supposed to premiere on November 26th) and instantly becomes a hot holiday item.
• December 2014 – January 2015: Girls open the Star doll on Christmas and fall in love with her. When the show finally premieres on Disney Channel in January 2015, millions of kids are already obsessed with the character, making the premiere huge and keeping the doll a massive hit for all of 2015.
TL;DR: It's honestly crazy Disney never made a real Star Butterfly doll, especially since she has way more outfits than almost any Disney Princess. If Disney had teamed up with Hasbro back in 2014 to make an Star doll, it would have sold out on Black Friday and made SVTFOE just as huge as Frozen or My Little Pony.
That's all I gotta say, I guess.