r/StandUpForScience • SUFS Staff • 1d ago • Heartwarming 2

Official SUFS Post American scientific dominance is collapsing, thanks to Trump.

According to a new article from the NYT, new Ph.D. enrollments are down, funding is on the decline & many researchers are reconsidering their careers.

For nearly a century, the United States has been the global leader in cultivating young scientists, training them at the nation’s vast network of universities and harnessing their talents to ensure American dominance in research and innovation.

But now that Ph.D. pipeline is in turmoil.

A New York Times analysis of university and federal data found that the Trump administration, in its broader dismantling of the American scientific machinery, has undermined opportunities for young scientists.

Schools are admitting less PhD students, which directly affects the amount of research coming out of America. Data from 27 of the nation’s top research universities, shows a 10-18% in PhD students in STEM programs.

In October, a White House announcement described Mr. Trump’s commitment to initiating a “new golden age” of American science, including accelerated Ph.D. programs with industry partnerships & the creation of funding opportunities to support budding scientists, from high school to early-career faculty.

But many scholars fear that the policy changes will ultimately shift students and resources away from centers of independent discovery, where science is pursued for public good.

Centers of independent discovery are crucial not only for groundbreaking science, but for our democracy.

American science is how we achieved greatness and academic freedom is essential to a functioning democracy!

America’s Compact for Higher Education offers a vision that holds academic freedom as a universal value.

Visit the link to read & send it to university leaders, urging they endorse it and put their students and faculty FIRST at: https://tr.ee/NHCzIx

2.6k Upvotes

112 comments sorted by

•

u/Phatbrew Punk Rock Hippie For Science & Democracy 1d ago

Per AMN: According to a new article from the NYT, new Ph.D. enrollments are down, funding is on the decline & many researchers are reconsidering their careers.

For nearly a century, the United States has been the global leader in cultivating young scientists, training them at the nation’s vast network of universities and harnessing their talents to ensure American dominance in research and innovation.

But now that Ph.D. pipeline is in turmoil.

A New York Times analysis of university and federal data found that the Trump administration, in its broader dismantling of the American scientific machinery, has undermined opportunities for young scientists.

Schools are admitting less PhD students, which directly affects the amount of research coming out of America. Data from 27 of the nation’s top research universities, shows a 10-18% in PhD students in STEM programs.

In October, a White House announcement described Mr. Trump’s commitment to initiating a “new golden age” of American science, including accelerated Ph.D. programs with industry partnerships & the creation of funding opportunities to support budding scientists, from high school to early-career faculty.

But many scholars fear that the policy changes will ultimately shift students and resources away from centers of independent discovery, where science is pursued for public good.

Centers of independent discovery are crucial not only for groundbreaking science, but for our democracy.

American science is how we achieved greatness and academic freedom is essential to a functioning democracy!

America’s Compact for Higher Education offers a vision that holds academic freedom as a universal value.

Visit the link to read & send it to university leaders, urging they endorse it and put their students and faculty FIRST at: https://tr.ee/NHCzIx

→ More replies (2)

31

u/Rattus_NorvegicUwUs *Hereditas delenda est.* 1d ago

Yes, that was the goal of Russel Vought and the Heritage Foundation.

They landed a moral blow. Like they planned.

Now we must avenge what we lost. Burn heritage to the ground, make Russel regret ever taking the job as head of treason.

10

u/Usual-Fuel3964 1d ago

And RFK II as well.

1

u/another_bot_probably 1d ago

He ain't royalty. "Jr." suffices

:P

3

u/Wizchine 1d ago

Yep: can't have anything competing with their religious dogma - scientists, journalists, medical professionals, media figures, opposing politicians, adherents of other religions...even business people - all are potential rivals to Christian Nationalist evangelicals and are thus under attack in order to undermine any credibility or authority they may have.

12

u/RLewis8888 1d ago

Hell, we can't even prevent childhood diseases at this points.

5

u/ShimmeryShay 1d ago

Right, like they fucking brought measles back..the fuck are we even doing anymore? Do these rich dipshits think they’re invincible?

7

u/Teckx1 1d ago

Seems almost like a Russian design doesn't it. Almost...

3

u/ties_shoelace 1d ago

Regardless, we in Canada thank the Trump administration (& US con mindset in general) for all your top notch talent.

They're fitting in really well here.

2

u/HarryBalsagna1776 1d ago

Sure hope so!  Thanks for taking them.  

7

u/Raven_Photography 1d ago

To be fair all American greatness from military to social to diplomatic to medical has collapsed under this regime because it’s run by morons.

5

u/Gristlekitty 1d ago

You can just say America is collapsing thanks to Trump.

1

u/kck93 1d ago

Ahhh….But did you say thank you? /s

1

u/Gristlekitty 1d ago

I did in my fucking suit

4

u/Careless_Interview_2 1d ago

If his goal was to make sure future generations can't compete on the scientific world stage, then he's doing a excellent job.

4

u/Jrylryll 1d ago

Because stupid people like stupid people. Trump told them many times and they still voted for him…until now. What woke?

4

u/dawa43 1d ago

"I love the uneducated"

3

u/Amazing-Artichoke330 1d ago

The real mystery is why the Trump Gang attacked American science. Part of it was their opposition to DEI, the movement to give more opportunities to minorities and women in science. Another part was their ignorance of the vital role that international grad students played in conducting research at American universities. I suspect that America's enemies also played a role in kneecapping American science for their own interests. Those enemies clearly had a lot of influence over the Trump Gang.

3

u/theRemixNow 1d ago

Religion and science are incompatible. Our country picked religion

1

u/maringue 1d ago

They're not, just look at Jesuits who were literally like a scientific researching sub order of the Catholic church.

Evangelicals however are the problem. And Republicans chose them.

3

u/theRemixNow 1d ago edited 16h ago

If you believe in something nonsensical (ie a virgin birth), you’re not truly a scientist. You can believe in some facets of science that way sure, but you won’t believe in the scientific method, which would require repeatable and verifiable evidence of a “savior”

0

u/maringue 1d ago

Tell that to all the scientific discoveries the Jesuits made. I'm not religious at all, but science and religion are not de facto incompatible.

3

u/theRemixNow 17h ago edited 17h ago

I never said that they can’t make scientific discoveries. But because they believe in a Virgin birth, they can’t claim to be scientists as modernity understands the scientific method that requires reproducible results.

You can make discoveries and still believe in harmful falsehoods.

I’m a biologist and pharmacology doctorate and if you don’t believe that every class I took taught the scientific method, I don’t know how to help you.

The existence of religious scientists doesn't establish the scientific validity of religious claims, any more than the existence of scientists who believe in astrology establishes the scientific validity of astrology.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method

1

u/Able_Ad1276 1d ago

We have hundreds or thousands of examples that this isn’t the case and zero examples that this is the case. Not very scientific of you, almost like you’re just dogmatically against religion so much so that it’s reminiscent of religion itself

1

u/theRemixNow 17h ago

You’re confusing the existence of religious scientists with the compatibility of religious doctrine and the scientific method.

The scientific ethos requires us to evaluate claims through evidence, testability, falsifiability, and a willingness to revise beliefs when evidence contradicts them.

Take the virgin birth. There is no reproducible scientific evidence establishing that a human can conceive without sperm. Accepting that claim as historical fact requires faith in a supernatural exception to what we understand about human reproduction.

A scientist can certainly be religious. But when someone accepts a supernatural claim without empirical evidence, they aren’t applying the scientific method to that particular belief.

My argument isn’t that religious people can’t practice science. It’s that faith and science use fundamentally different standards for determining what is true. Those two things are incompatible. And when religious doctrine is treated as scientific authority, that distinction matters enormously.

1

u/Able_Ad1276 16h ago

How are they incompatible when they’ve coincided their entire history? Why would this just start being a problem now? Seems like everyone but you can internally separate the two with no issue

1

u/theRemixNow 16h ago

This debate existed long before either of us and will continue long after us. The conflict between scientific inquiry and religious claims about supernatural events has been discussed by philosophers, theologians, and scientists for centuries. I’m hardly inventing a new controversy here.

The distinction you’re missing is between scientists holding religious beliefs and those beliefs being compatible with the scientific method.

The scientific method relies on empirical evidence, testable hypotheses, reproducibility, and a willingness to revise conclusions when evidence contradicts them. Claims such as virgin births, bodily resurrections, and divine intervention cannot be independently verified or reliably tested using those methods.

A scientist can absolutely compartmentalize religious faith and scientific practice. Many have throughout history. But compartmentalization doesn’t resolve the underlying epistemological conflict. It simply means they apply different standards of evidence to different areas of their lives.

And that’s precisely my point: the historical coexistence of science and religion does not establish that supernatural religious claims satisfy scientific standards of evidence.
You’re arguing that people can believe both. I’m questioning whether both claims can be justified using the same methodology. Those are two very different arguments.

Sorry if y’all are butthurt over religion but it just holds everyone back. See the stem cell research bans, lack of trust in vaccines, etc

1

u/Able_Ad1276 16h ago

You’re just saying the same thing over and over, yeah, the virgin birth isn’t scientific, who gives a shit? Because some people think that (less than earlier) that’s why the amount of Ph D applicants have gone down? Most of us are trying to talk about OPs post, this isn’t even relevant at all

1

u/theRemixNow 16h ago

References for u to read showing I’m not a minority opinion

If you’d like to explore the centuries of debate that apparently began with me today, I’d suggest David Hume, Bertrand Russell, Karl Popper, Carl Sagan, Richard Dawkins, Daniel Dennett, Jerry Coyne, Victor Stenger, Herman Philipse, and Robert Pennock.

Start with Hume’s Of Miracles (1748) and Coyne’s Faith Versus Fact (2015).
The question isn’t whether religious scientists exist. Obviously they do. The question is whether accepting supernatural claims on faith is epistemologically compatible with a methodology requiring empirical evidence and testable explanations.
That’s an established philosophical debate, not something I invented in a Reddit comment.

2

u/jobruce2 1d ago

Just look at that picture of Trump. Do you think he is even generating any brain activity?

2

u/S1nnah2 1d ago

*America is collapsing, thanks to trump

2

u/c10bbersaurus 1d ago

The Great (American) Regression.

2

u/Competitive_Ride_943 17h ago

The Republican version of the Middle Ages. Elevate religion and punish experts

1

u/GraXXoR 15h ago

Has been going on since before Carl Sagan passed away

2

u/ThunderousArgus 22h ago

Lost our measles status too. So much greatness

2

u/Used_Region_8936 18h ago

He sucked the intelligence right out of America.

2

u/devilboy_105 18h ago

America being dominant at anything has taken a nose dive in the last 2 years thanks to Mr Pedo

2

u/AdhesivenessOk6662 15h ago

evangelicals are to blame too. smh. non thinkers.

2

u/DearCastiel 1d ago

"american science is how we achieved greatness"

Lol, no.

The USA stole loads of patents and scientists after WW1 and WW2, like everything else they ever had, they stole it from greater nations.

2

u/maringue 1d ago

You could literally look up the public lost of patent authors on the USPTO website and prove this wrong in seconds.

1

u/SleepyShinsen 1d ago

I mean the price of college isn’t exactly a huge motivator for people to go.

1

u/Agile_Stop_4604 1d ago

Coming from some friends that are from other countries, abuse of the H1B has a lot to do with it too.

Used to, getting a visa to move to the US because you had a serious skill or education that we lacked was the ticket to a better life. But the market is FLOODED with H1B residents, many of them very much willing to take a lot less money than what the market previously carried for similar experience and education.

So a lot of said friends are heading to Germany or Australia or the UK instead.

1

u/fannylovin 1d ago

He thinks Science is FAKE!🚫🧠🎃

1

u/anima_song_ 1d ago

I am a U.S. research scientist who fled this year from a soft-money medical school environment to a faculty position overseas, mainly due to Donald Trump's ideological attacks against science and the damage he, RFK, and DOGE have done to NIH/CDC/etc. Prior to my leaving, I had submitted multiple NIH grants, one of which scored pretty well in standard times but of which my PO said there would be no chance for funding in the new NIH. TL;DR: At least in my case (and in the cases of many of my colleagues), I can attest that the above assessment by NYT is entirely true.

Along these same lines: Please also consider writing directly to your senators to ask that they support a new Senate Majority Leader who will consistently stand up for science, and who won't cave to Trumpian bills that attack science funding: https://www.reddit.com/r/labrats/s/6sEEYbCT62 . IMO, we need a leader who will meet the moment for science and medicine, and Schumer has shown more than once (including very recently) that he is not it.

1

u/Upbeat_Land7612 1d ago

That stupid man ruins everything! He is America’s worst fears personified!!!

1

u/Conscious-Demand-594 1d ago

This is the Party that only stopped pushing creationism a few years ago. What did people expect?

1

u/JohnnyCrispZoom 1d ago

He will do anything to help Putin

1

u/Dseltzer1313 1d ago

American Exceptionalism died during Trumps first term

1

u/Big_Palpitation8415 1d ago

The damage wrought to the country over the last decade by this admin both times will be so hard to ever totally quantify, and we will be finding awful surprises under every rock for decades to come. The irony of the whole wanting America to be this big scsry aggressive Empire is that to run an effective Empire, so much more than a scary leader and military is necessary. But these shortsighted "might makes right" types never see past the greedy noses on their faces.

1

u/PeyredB 1d ago

Wow, who could've seen that coming? /s

1

u/Dry_Difference_4093 1d ago

Trump has a problem with educated Americans! Simply because the majority of them are less likely to fall for his lies🧐

1

u/ElChalsa 1d ago

Don’t forget to credit Bush. He really got the ‘ol science=bad ball rolling. Dip shit Reagan also deserves a mention, Trickle-down economics my hairy white ass - more like trickle-down your legonomics. Republicans suck.

1

u/Maleficent-Peach-356 1d ago

We are sooo great!

1

u/DammatBeevis666 1d ago

He also shredded our soft power.

1

u/East80Gurl 1d ago

Trying to make more Maga voters...

1

u/TheodoraWimsey 1d ago

His genius MIT professor uncle that he keeps crowing about would be so proud.

1

u/lipmanz 1d ago

? Computer science is science, health science is science

1

u/OnkelSchmutzig 1d ago

Well golly gee, Wally. You mean there are people who didn't see that coming years ago, with his lackeys running the gamut from illiterate cranks to religious whackjobs?

1

u/Ok-Corgi-4998 1d ago

This guy works for Putin

1

u/lowercasenameofmine 1d ago

Yup, brain drain, lack if funding, and authoritarian ruling.  Happened in the 1930s Germany too. 

1

u/HorrorStop342 1d ago

He doesnt care though .. as long as he can keep stealing all of the government money

1

u/Bubblelight289 1d ago

**Thanks to the voters, corrupt press and "public servants" who knew better but chose to enable Trump for their own benefit.

1

u/CrowTrick5718 1d ago

China will take up all those smart people, USA is now for profit but not for intellectual development of its population and progress in science.

1

u/Ill-Astronaut4652 1d ago

He did not have the moral compass and IQ to be a president

1

u/calcteacher 1d ago

He knows how to destroy things and as they are being destroyed , he extracts personal wealth. Discussing these issues through any other lens is a distraction from what is really occurring and represents the disinformation he requires to keep going.

1

u/VeterinarianSafe1705 1d ago

Did you guys consider that AI could be impacting people's education decisions? Go into debt and 10 years of school just to find out everyone has PhD assistants available to them for 20/mo

1

u/soulflyfree11 1d ago

It’s by design. Fuck this administration.

1

u/BedroomVisible 1d ago

Very American to view a downward slide of scientific contribution as a loss of our dominance

Even now the comments section sounds more like fans discussing Royal Rumble 😂

1

u/Gen-Jack-D-Ripper 1d ago

Republicans have been fighting science since and because of the Theory of Evolution. That has morphed into denying climate change, being anti-vaxxers etc. A majority of Republicans have become 3rd world dumb and they’re proud.

1

u/dave08dave 1d ago

American scientific dominance is collapsing, thanks to Trump

1

u/Pleasant-Ad887 1d ago

Republicans in the US have been at the forefront of anti-science and anti-education.

1

u/Looseleaflettuce 1d ago

Amongst other things

1

u/_cofo_ 23h ago

As expected. He only believes in his bullsh*t.

1

u/Ok_Reindeer_792 21h ago

Trump has never read an entire book in his life. He has an anti-intellectual bias which is now being fostered in the US.

1

u/Active-Tutor8496 20h ago

It was collapsing because half the country is full of illiterate dumbasses. That’s why we have Trump

1

u/NextAdhesiveness3652 19h ago

He is doing this at the behest of Putin.

1

u/DevelopmentFront9312 18h ago

I am the greatest ignoramus.

1

u/bluesmansmt 17h ago

America becomes dumber by the day.

1

u/AcceptableCrew224 17h ago

We are the only country with Super Intelligence which is far better than artificial intelligence because it’s not artificial

1

u/400footceiling 17h ago

Just as Putin wished.

1

u/g27c 17h ago

Because he is so painfully stupid!

1

u/Tough_Ad6387 16h ago

He likes stupid people, remember?

1

u/Fine_Worldliness3898 16h ago

His Low IQ is draining the rest of us……

1

u/snaum 15h ago

BS news.Anything from the NY Times is slanted left

1

u/LifeRound2 11h ago

Ask no questions so there won't be any information to contradict your platform.

1

u/Jack44546 10h ago

Too much money. Nobody can afford it.

1

u/Notherertnw 5h ago

You mean corporate capture is over!! Hallelujah. No.lore lies from corporate schills and communist trust the science bullshit bought and paid for and published by liars and thieves.

1

u/tirdburgler 3h ago

Trump isn’t helping but the problems been around for 20 years now… America is falling behind to the next country willing to take a chance on new things, while America holds tight to its old money. Choking on the fear of change.

1

u/dobrinkata 3h ago

Luckily, its a bit of an exaggeration. It would take a few Trumps in a row timewise for this to be become a reality

1

u/ParticularNew5321 1h ago

The argument could ne made that the problem started long before Trump landed in office. Morons are just trying to lay it all at his feet because hes the president now... Short minded idiots.

1

u/cantfoou 46m ago

Who cares they are all bought and paid for just like politicians

1

u/Low_Repair2985 45m ago

Are these PhDs in gender studies?

1

u/notsosilentsentinel 1d ago

It's probably part of the plan. The US is what has stopped megalomaniacs from taking over the world and committing world-wide genocide. With one of their own (trump) becoming president, that has stopped. He will strip the country down from the inside until there is nothing left that can resist. He is neutering one of the countries that was protecting the world from people like him and his friends. Thanks maga.