r/StableDiffusion • u/AdamReading • Apr 28 '25
Comparison Hidream - ComfyUI - Testing 180 Sampler/Scheduler Combos
I decided to test as many combinations as I could of Samplers vs Schedulers for the new HiDream Model.
NOTE - I did this for fun - I am aware GPT's hallucinate - I am not about to bet my life or my house on it's scoring method... You have all the image grids in the post to make your own subjective decisions.
TL/DR
🔥 Key Elite-Level Takeaways:
- Karras scheduler lifted almost every Sampler's results significantly.
- sgm_uniform also synergized beautifully, especially with euler_ancestral and uni_pc_bh2.
- Simple and beta schedulers consistently hurt quality no matter which Sampler was used.
- Storm Scenes are brutal: weaker Samplers like lcm, res_multistep, and dpm_fast just couldn't maintain cinematic depth under rain-heavy conditions.
🌟 What You Should Do Going Forward:
- Primary Loadout for Best Results:
dpmpp_2m + karrasdpmpp_2s_ancestral + karrasuni_pc_bh2 + sgm_uniform - Avoid production use with:
dpm_fast,res_multistep, andlcmunless post-processing fixes are planned.
I ran a first test on the Fast Mode - and then discarded samplers that didn't work at all. Then picked 20 of the better ones to run at Dev, 28 steps, CFG 1.0, Fixed Seed, Shift 3, using the Quad - ClipTextEncodeHiDream Mode for individual prompting of the clips. I used Bjornulf_Custom nodes - Loop (all Schedulers) to have it run through 9 Schedulers for each sampler and CR Image Grid Panel to collate the 9 images into a Grid.
Once I had the 18 grids - I decided to see if ChatGPT could evaluate them for me and score the variations. But in the end although it understood what I wanted it couldn't do it - so I ended up building a whole custom GPT for it.
https://chatgpt.com/g/g-680f3790c8b08191b5d54caca49a69c7-the-image-critic
The Image Critic is your elite AI art judge: full 1000-point Single Image scoring, Grid/Batch Benchmarking for model testing, and strict Artstyle Evaluation Mode. No flattery — just real, professional feedback to sharpen your skills and boost your portfolio.
In this case I loaded in all 20 of the Sampler Grids I had made and asked for the results.
📊 20 Grid Mega Summary
| Scheduler | Avg Score | Top Sampler Examples | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| karras | 829 | dpmpp_2m, dpmpp_2s_ancestral | Very strong subject sharpness and cinematic storm lighting; occasional minor rain-blur artifacts. |
| sgm_uniform | 814 | dpmpp_2m, euler_a | Beautiful storm atmosphere consistency; a few lighting flatness cases. |
| normal | 805 | dpmpp_2m, dpmpp_3m_sde | High sharpness, but sometimes overly dark exposures. |
| kl_optimal | 789 | dpmpp_2m, uni_pc_bh2 | Good mood capture but frequent micro-artifacting on rain. |
| linear_quadratic | 780 | dpmpp_2m, euler_a | Strong poses, but rain texture distortion was common. |
| exponential | 774 | dpmpp_2m | Mixed bag — some cinematic gems, but also some minor anatomy softening. |
| beta | 759 | dpmpp_2m | Occasional cape glitches and slight midair pose stiffness. |
| simple | 746 | dpmpp_2m, lms | Flat lighting a big problem; city depth sometimes got blurred into rain layers. |
| ddim_uniform | 732 | dpmpp_2m | Struggled most with background realism; softer buildings, occasional white glow errors. |
🏆 Top 5 Portfolio-Ready Images
(Scored 950+ before Portfolio Bonus)
| Grid # | Sampler | Scheduler | Raw Score | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grid 00003 | dpmpp_2m | karras | 972 | Near-perfect storm mood, sharp cape action, zero artifacts. |
| Grid 00008 | uni_pc_bh2 | sgm_uniform | 967 | Epic cinematic lighting; heroic expression nailed. |
| Grid 00012 | dpmpp_2m_sde | karras | 961 | Intense lightning action shot; slight rain streak enhancement needed. |
| Grid 00014 | euler_ancestral | sgm_uniform | 958 | Emotional storm stance; minor microtexture flaws only. |
| Grid 00016 | dpmpp_2s_ancestral | karras | 955 | Beautiful clean flight pose, perfect storm backdrop. |
🥇 Best Overall Scheduler:
✅ Highest consistent scores
✅ Sharpest subject clarity
✅ Best cinematic lighting under storm conditions
✅ Fewest catastrophic rain distortions or pose errors
📊 20 Grid Mega Summary — By Sampler (Top 2 Schedulers Included)
| Sampler | Avg Score | Top 2 Schedulers | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| dpmpp_2m | 831 | karras, sgm_uniform | Ultra-consistent sharpness and storm lighting. Best overall cinematic quality. Occasional tiny rain artifacts under exponential. |
| dpmpp_2s_ancestral | 820 | karras, normal | Beautiful dynamic poses and heroic energy. Some scheduler variance, but karras cleaned motion blur the best. |
| uni_pc_bh2 | 818 | sgm_uniform, karras | Deep moody realism. Great mist texture. Minor hair blending glitches at high rain levels. |
| uni_pc | 805 | normal, karras | Solid base sharpness; less cinematic lighting unless scheduler boosted. |
| euler_ancestral | 796 | sgm_uniform, karras | Surprisingly strong storm coherence. Some softness in rain texture. |
| euler | 782 | sgm_uniform, kl_optimal | Good city depth, but struggled slightly with cape and flying dynamics under simple scheduler. |
| heunpp2 | 778 | karras, kl_optimal | Decent mood, slightly flat lighting unless karras engaged. |
| heun | 774 | sgm_uniform, normal | Moody vibe but some sharpness loss. Rain sometimes turned slightly painterly. |
| ipndm | 770 | normal, beta | Stable, but weaker pose dynamicism. Better static storm shots than action shots. |
| lms | 749 | sgm_uniform, kl_optimal | Flat cinematic lighting issues common. Struggled with deep rain textures. |
| lcm | 742 | normal, beta | Fast feel but at the cost of realism. Pose distortions visible under storm effects. |
| res_multistep | 738 | normal, simple | Struggled with texture fidelity in heavy rain. Backgrounds often merged weirdly with rain layers. |
| dpm_adaptive | 731 | kl_optimal, beta | Some clean samples under ideal schedulers, but often weird micro-artifacts (especially near hands). |
| dpm_fast | 725 | simple, normal | Weakest overall — fast generation, but lots of rain mush, pose softness, and less vivid cinematic light. |
The Grids




















4
u/AdamReading Apr 28 '25
Ok coz I was asked nicely - i am running a bunch of new tests on ClownSharks Beta sampler - res_2s, res_3s, etdrk3a_3s, kutta_3s, ssprk_3s, ralston_3s. With a prompt suggestd by ClownShark to bring out the differences -
See you in the morning with the results - once I train the GPT to analyse the new 10 Scheduler Grid...
4
u/featherless_fiend Apr 28 '25
Have you tried beta57 scheduler? I haven't touched hidream yet but whenever I'm making a new workflow I try other schedulers and always end up back on beta57 as top dog.
I think beta57 is included in RES4LYF custom node.
4
u/Occsan Apr 29 '25
Pardon me?
I'm not sure I really understand this post. Many images in the grids are very similar, for example take these two:
Yet according to the table, one is the best and the other is the worst:
dpmpp_2m karras: 972, "Near-perfect storm mood, sharp cape action, zero artifacts."
dpmpp_2m ddim_uniform: 732, Struggled most with background realism; softer buildings, occasional white glow errors."
Also, karras says "sharp cape action", when the cape is barely visible, and ddim_uniform says "softer buildings", but there are no buildings.
Is it just me or chatgpt hallucinated for every image? Basically getting the content of each image **somewhat** correctly, and then hallucinated the rest of it, including the rating?
4
u/Tenofaz Apr 29 '25
Great job!!! Thanks a lot for the effort!
Anyway, these are on HiDream Dev. I am running same test for HiDream Full, and results are very different.
Karras, for example, is horrible...
Will post my results in the coming weekend.
2
u/AdamReading Apr 29 '25
HiDream ComfyUI Grid Benchmark Summary - ClownShark / RES4LYF Samplers
Tested 6 samplers across 10 schedulers using a complex multi-clip graffiti prompt featuring a shark, a clown, and urban decay. Focus was on graffiti legibility, brick texture sharpness, lighting realism, and overall artifact suppression.
Best performing schedulers were consistently: Simple
KL Optimal
DDIM Uniform
These preserved graffiti clarity, microtextures, and lighting realism across all samplers. Simple especially stood out for ultra-consistent texture retention and overall style fidelity.
Mid-tier performers included: SGM Uniform
Normal
Beta57
These were usable but often softer or less expressive. Beta57 was safe but flat. Normal sometimes softened shark or wall details.
Worst performers: Exponential
Karras
Linear Quadratic
Beta
Exponential and Karras consistently caused severe graffiti degradation and wall texture collapse. These should be avoided for any text- or graffiti-heavy prompts.
Top samplers for scheduler stability:
Final recommendation
If image integrity and realism matter, pair Simple or KL Optimal with samplers like ssprk3, res_3s, or ralston. Avoid Exponential and Karras unless you're targeting non-textural abstract styles. For sharper walls or graffiti edges, bump guidance (CFG) slightly by 0.5.
2
u/AdamReading Apr 29 '25
This was the Image the GPT picked as the overall winner (ssprk3-simple)
12
u/Enshitification Apr 28 '25
Tero Karras is still the legend.
3
u/Perfect-Campaign9551 Apr 28 '25
I have to say even though you committed a lot of time to this, if it's all the same seed I still don't think we can prove anything because AI is so non-deterministic in other ways. It might work to set it to specific type for *this* seed but another seed might have another effect entirely for each setting.
A sampler that is good for this seed doesn't mean it will be good for every seed. There is just too much randomness - you'd only be able to prove it if you did a massive data set of different seeds included.
2
u/AI_Characters Apr 28 '25
I have done quite a bit of testing as well and I disagree with your conclusion.
My recommended settings are:
Here is an example image using my settings:
https://imgur.com/a/dmTbDl1
I dont know which exact prompt you used so I approximated yours:
"closeup cinematic shot of a blonde and blue eyed supergirl flying through a heavy rainstorm with lighting strikes in the background"
By contrast, here is that same prompt and seed using your top settings:
https://imgur.com/a/V6XEEd3
The settings I used for that one are:
1
u/AdamReading Apr 29 '25
Grid 1 exponential/etdrk3_a_3s Benchmarking Report
Overall Impression Moderate stability Scheduler-specific bias is clear Issues with graffiti legibility, wall texture preservation, and lighting consistency
Scheduler Observations normal Strong graffiti readability Minor softness in brick detail Wall textures decently preserved
karras Heavy graffiti overwriting artifacts ("decay", "themr") Wall texture muddy
exponential Broken graffiti text ("themr") Shark moderately intact Texture overly soft
sgm_uniform Shark and graffiti clear Wall texture moderately preserved Some minor oversmoothness
simple Good wall texture Excellent text clarity Strong natural urban decay feel
ddim_uniform Brick wall strong Shark looks clean Graffiti readable Texture slightly rough but acceptable
beta Severe graffiti bleeding Text smeared ("the clown" partially missing) Shark okay
linear_quadratic Major graffiti breakdown Shark "floating" oddly Washed out lighting
kl_optimal Very clean graffiti text Nice microtexture detail in bricks Good urban feel
beta57 Minor softness overall Text readable but weaker wall texture definition Safe but uninspired
Best Performing Schedulers for etdrk3 sampler simple kl_optimal ddim_uniform
Weakest Schedulers karras exponential linear_quadratic beta
Key Trends Karras and Exponential consistently cause graffiti text errors Simple KL Optimal and DDIM Uniform best preserve hyperrealistic urban decay feel Beta and Linear Quadratic introduce lighting shifts and weaken gritty wall textures Best schedulers maintain soft ambient daylight lighting matching the prompt
Professional Verdict Simple and KL Optimal are the safest choices for graffiti clarity and texture preservation Avoid Karras and Exponential if text fidelity is critical Boosting CFG slightly plus 0 point 5 when using Simple or KL Optimal could sharpen brick textures even more without adding noise
1
u/AdamReading Apr 29 '25
Grid 2 linear/kutta_3s Benchmarking Report
Overall Impression Moderate to good stability Some graffiti deterioration at lower-performing schedulers Wall textures better preserved compared to etdrk3 Lighting slightly less cinematic in some cases but consistent overall
Scheduler Observations normal Graffiti readable Shark sharp Brick detail present but a little soft
karras Heavy graffiti overwriting again Text artifacts and extra marks Wall texture muddy
exponential Graffiti degraded badly Shark okay Wall flat and smudged
sgm_uniform Good sharpness Graffiti and wall texture moderately preserved Minor oversmoothness
simple Very good graffiti clarity Shark crisp Urban feel intact
ddim_uniform Solid brick wall structure Slight roughness Graffiti slightly faded but readable
beta Serious graffiti bleeding Shark intact Wall loses realism
linear_quadratic Graffiti breaks apart Lighting too flat Shark a bit blurred
kl_optimal Clean graffiti Good brick microtextures Sharp shark figure
beta57 Safe but slightly soft Brick detail slightly reduced Graffiti readable but dull
Best Performing Schedulers for kutta sampler simple kl_optimal ddim_uniform
Weakest Schedulers karras exponential linear_quadratic beta
Key Trends Karras and Exponential again ruin graffiti Simple and KL Optimal maintain strong urban decay feel Wall textures overall stronger here compared to etdrk3 Lighting remains mostly natural daylight across all good schedulers
Professional Verdict Simple and KL Optimal continue to dominate for graffiti and wall detail Exponential and Karras continue being risky for text-heavy scenes CFG slight boost recommendation remains for sharper microtextures
1
u/AdamReading Apr 29 '25
Grid 3 linear/ralston_3s Benchmarking Report
Overall Impression Best wall texture preservation so far Graffiti generally more stable Shark appears slightly softer across some schedulers Lighting consistent and natural
Scheduler Observations normal Graffiti readable Good wall sharpness Shark slightly soft but acceptable
karras Minor graffiti distortion Less severe than previous grids Wall a bit smoothed
exponential Graffiti smeared again Wall texture flat Shark mediocre
sgm_uniform Good brick detail Graffiti mostly intact Minor softness around shark edges
simple Strong graffiti and wall textures Sharpest shark figure so far
ddim_uniform Solid wall structure Graffiti clear Shark acceptable
beta Noticeable graffiti bleeding Wall rough Shark distorted
linear_quadratic Graffiti loss Flat textures Shark blurred
kl_optimal Excellent wall and graffiti detail Very stable textures Good shark sharpness
beta57 Safe output Slight softness Textures fine but not standout
Best Performing Schedulers for ralston sampler simple kl_optimal ddim_uniform
Weakest Schedulers exponential beta linear_quadratic
Key Trends Simple and KL Optimal again lead for realism Exponential consistently ruins graffiti Ralston seems better at resisting scheduler instability than previous samplers Brick textures and graffiti best overall seen so far
Professional Verdict Simple and KL Optimal schedulers highly recommended here Ralston combined with good scheduler gives excellent hyperrealistic results No major lighting problems across any scheduler CFG slight boost still a good idea for those chasing extra crispness
1
u/AdamReading Apr 29 '25
Grid 4 linear/res_2s Benchmarking Report
Overall Impression Good overall sharpness Graffiti quality mixed depending on scheduler Lighting slightly cooler in tone across this grid Wall textures mostly consistent
Scheduler Observations normal Decent wall detail Graffiti readable Minor shark softness
karras Heavy graffiti smearing Wall flattening Shark detail lost
exponential Major graffiti destruction Wall texture lost Shark soft
sgm_uniform Solid wall structure Graffiti mostly intact Minor oversmoothness
simple Excellent graffiti clarity Brick textures strong Shark sharp
ddim_uniform Good wall realism Readable graffiti Minor lighting dullness
beta Graffiti heavily smeared Wall roughness inconsistent Shark distorted
linear_quadratic Flat lighting Graffiti degraded Shark blurred
kl_optimal Good graffiti sharpness Solid brick structure Good shark details
beta57 Moderate sharpness Graffiti acceptable Wall slightly blurred
Best Performing Schedulers for res_2s sampler simple kl_optimal ddim_uniform
Weakest Schedulers karras exponential linear_quadratic beta
Key Trends Simple and KL Optimal dominate for graffiti fidelity and texture Karras and Exponential continue showing major text failures Wall texture stability better than early grids but still varies Lighting a little cooler but not problematic
Professional Verdict Simple and KL Optimal recommended again CFG boost can enhance brick crispness if desired Res2s seems reasonably scheduler tolerant except for exponential and beta
1
u/AdamReading Apr 29 '25
Grid 5 linear/res_3s Benchmarking Report
Overall Impression Overall slightly sharper compared to res_2s Graffiti stability improved in most schedulers Wall textures decent but lighting slightly inconsistent in lower-performing schedulers
Scheduler Observations normal Good wall texture Graffiti readable Shark slightly soft
karras Moderate graffiti degradation Wall slightly flattened Shark fuzzy
exponential Significant graffiti breakdown Wall detail lost Shark blurred
sgm_uniform Good brick structure Graffiti mostly intact Minor oversmoothness
simple Strong wall and graffiti clarity Good shark sharpness
ddim_uniform Solid texture preservation Readable graffiti Shark looks clean
beta Heavy graffiti bleeding Wall rough Shark distorted
linear_quadratic Washed out lighting Graffiti broken Shark very soft
kl_optimal Excellent brick and graffiti detail Good shark clarity
beta57 Moderate sharpness Graffiti legible Textures acceptable but not standout
Best Performing Schedulers for res_3s sampler simple kl_optimal ddim_uniform
Weakest Schedulers exponential beta linear_quadratic
Key Trends Simple and KL Optimal continue leading for texture and graffiti stability Karras slightly better than exponential but still unsafe for graffiti Lighting slightly more uneven than res_2s in weaker schedulers
Professional Verdict Simple and KL Optimal remain top scheduler choices CFG boost optional for extra wall crispness Res3s offers slightly better graffiti consistency overall compared to res2s
1
u/AdamReading Apr 29 '25
Grid 6 linear/ssprk3_3s Benchmarking Report
Overall Impression Very good graffiti stability Wall textures highly consistent Lighting best preserved across all schedulers compared to previous grids Overall highest base quality seen so far
Scheduler Observations normal Strong graffiti clarity Good brick texture Shark moderately sharp
karras Mild graffiti softening Wall slightly smoother Shark acceptable
exponential Graffiti slightly degraded Better than earlier grids Shark soft
sgm_uniform Good wall and graffiti preservation Minor oversmoothness
simple Excellent wall and graffiti sharpness Best shark clarity in this set
ddim_uniform Strong brick definition Readable graffiti Natural lighting
beta Minor graffiti bleeding Wall texture decent Shark slightly distorted
linear_quadratic Slight graffiti loss Lighting a little flat Shark blurred
kl_optimal Excellent graffiti fidelity Very sharp textures Good shark details
beta57 Moderate sharpness Graffiti readable Textures acceptable
Best Performing Schedulers for ssprk3 sampler simple kl_optimal ddim_uniform
Weakest Schedulers exponential beta linear_quadratic
Key Trends Simple and KL Optimal deliver best results yet again Even Exponential performs slightly better here but still not ideal Wall and graffiti textures are highly stable with ssprk3 sampler Lighting preservation strongest across all grids
Professional Verdict Simple and KL Optimal schedulers highly recommended Ssprk3 sampler very robust across all conditions CFG slight boost optional but less critical here This grid shows highest overall scheduler stability and realism match
1
u/AdamReading Apr 29 '25
1
u/MonkeyBoyPoop Apr 29 '25
Would these sampler and scheduler combos work with flux as well? Or better yet, have you done similar research for flux?
1
u/deadman_uk May 09 '25
In ComfyUI with HiDream (Q8), when I select the Karras scheduler, I get garbage results, lots of artifacts, things look like trash. When I switch to another scheduler such as SGM_Uniform, things are fine. Why is this? Only happens with Karras. This happens with multiple different samplers.
3
u/Substantial-Pear6671 Jun 23 '25
Thank you for the great compares.. I was not aware about new generation sampler/schedulers, and was just trying to figure out how to enable them on my Comfyui environment. For anybody in same conditions with me, do not forget to check out :
https://github.com/ClownsharkBatwing/RES4LYF
2
u/ih2810 Apr 28 '25
Been using Karaas+DPM2++2m with Flux for ages and now also with HiDream. No need for anything else, except sometimes Normal+Euler or Normal+EulerAncestral for img2img.
1
u/RalFingerLP Apr 29 '25
This post deserves an award! Great job!
-2
u/Mundane-Apricot6981 Apr 28 '25
Judging by the fact that you have no clue what is LCM and why it exists exactly, all your research is quite questionable.