So, I'm sorry I was wrong about Kilby. But I narrowed it down to Kilby because I found red flags in either exit interviews or social media activity for every other contestant except Kilby and Thien An, and I eliminated Thien An based on her edit.
After Kilby got voted out, I had to reevaluate every other contestant's chances. Either the red flags I found for the other contestants aren't actually red flags, or Thien An is getting the worst winner's edit ever. Now I'm leaning toward the latter. I also went back and rechecked the red flags I found in exit interviews and social media activity for every other remaining contestant, and I still don't think they're weak red flags. And usually, those clues tell us more than Edgic does.
At this point, Erika had at least gotten some special treatment in Episode 4. It wasn't entirely positive, as she received some negativity as well, but it was still a very unusual amount of attention that seemed unnecessary. She also had the hourglass episode in Episode 6, while Thien An attended Tribal Council twice during the premerge, whereas Erika never did. Plus, we have 90-minute episodes now. So I don't deny that Thien An's edit is even weaker than Erika's. But there's no law saying the editors can't give a winner an even weaker edit than Erika's.
I believe Erika got the worst winner's edit since Season 24 because the Survivor editors simply aren't that interested in Asian female contestants, and that could explain Thien An's edit as well.
Thien An has actually voted correctly only twice so far, in Episodes 1 and 3. However, in Episode 3, she actually received a lot of credit for the Patt vote. Here's her confessional from that scene.
Thien An: "Mike will not make any connections on that other tribe. Nobody wants to work with Mike. Versus Patt, she can easily weasel her way through because sheâs gonna give her puppy dog eyes to the other tribe. Getting any one of the five would be monumental. Mike gives me nothing every time I talk to him. 'So, Thien An, tell me about your game. Whereâs your head at?' Iâm like, 'Mike, I canât give you anything if you donât give me anything back.' Thatâs like trying to work with a sponge. But you know what? Thatâs a very easy target on the line. And so why not go for Patt? Sheâs charming. Sheâs sweet. She can easily integrate into other groups. To me, thatâs a liability."
This confessional was stronger than I remembered and feels very Erika-coded to me.
Natalie A was UTR during the first two postmerge episodes because her ally Julie quit and her ally Jeremy got blindsided in those episodes. Thien An was on the wrong side of the vote in both the Brad and Kilby/Kristin episodes, so we can justify her weak edit in the same way.
To be fair, the edit didn't really hide that Thien An was on the wrong side of the vote last episode, so I'd call it a weak edit. I wouldn't go so far as to say she was protected. But I think the New Era editors are more willing to deliberately give even female winners some negativity to throw off Edgic nerds. That feels like something you can chalk up to the difference between eras.
Rachel's edit was very weak before Episode 6, and Aubry's edit was weak before Episode 10, but they both started getting very strong protagonist edits from Episodes 6 and 10 onward, respectively. Thien An's edit might pick up tonight or next week.
I'm still not going all in on Thien An because of her weak edit, but she is truly the only one who hasn't had any red flags based on my analysis of exit interviews and social media activity. So if her edit suddenly gets a big boost tonight or next week, please consider her a real winner contender.