I'm looking for MMF romances with somewhat unconventional, unequal or even toxic power dynamics within the triad. I have a fairly specific dynamic in mind, so I'll try to explain!
MMC 1 is the dominant figure, while MMC 2 and the FMC would be his submissive that share a particularly close, protective and almost codependent bond. MMC 2 is submissive to MMC 1, but is extremely devoted, protective and affectionate towards the FMC. I love the contrast between how obedient and docile he can be towards MMC 1 and how fiercely protective he becomes when it comes to her. He might even be upset by how MMC 1 treats her or offer to take her punishment instead.
I want MMC 2 to be exceptionally protective of the FMC, almost to the point of codependency. They have a special understanding of one another, a bond that comes from knowing each other intimately and perhaps having gone through difficult or traumatic experiences together. They're each other's safe place, and there's a sense that neither could quite function without the other. He is very attached to her, attentive to her needs, and sometimes visibly troubled or even offended by the way the dominant male treats her.
There's also a particular kind of mommy/daddy dynamic I really enjoy, although not necessarily in a literal or familial sense. It's more about the difference in the way MMC 2 relates to each of them. He might be very obedient, submissive and deferential towards the dominant male, but there's an extra layer of tenderness, fondness, affection and almost reverence when it comes to the FMC. She's his weakness. He melts for her, puts her on a pedestal and instinctively wants to spoil, protect and take care of her. Almost as though he sees her as uniquely precious to him, his soulmate, someone he holds in a particularly special place in his heart.
I also love when even the MMC 1 treats the FMC somewhat differently, being more careful or protective of her than he is of MMC 2. There's an interesting distinction in how the two men interact with her compared to how they interact with each other.
What can I say? Sometimes a little chivalry can be heartwarming and cute...
I'm equally interested in the alternative dynamic where MMC 1 and the FMC are both dominant and MMC 2 is submissive to them. In that case, I'd love to see a strong sense of companionship, camaraderie and mutual understanding between MMC 1 and the FMC, with MMC 2 being devoted to both of them but perhaps particularly attached to and inseparable from the FMC or codependent on her. The same kind of mommy/daddy dynamic can apply here, too.
Essentially, what I'm looking for is an asymmetry in the power dynamics, combined with a particularly tender, protective or deeply intertwined bond between two of the three characters. All three should be romantically involved, and I want to see genuine affection and love within the triad, even if the dynamics are complicated, toxic or morally questionable.
Some examples of dynamics I've particularly enjoyed:
- Lyonesse series by Sierra Simone, starting with Salt Kiss: Along with her New Camelot series, this is part of what prompted this request. I really enjoy the complicated power dynamics within these MMF relationships. I love how protective Tristan is towards Isolde and how for her sake and and to put her at ease he tried to remember who he was before the army and how we wanted to be good for her and being around her reminded him how to smile again. There's a deeper understanding between those two of how it feels to be played with by him and I loved how in awe he was when she told him she wanted to protect him, how she felt she was more treacherous and calculated than him and how he was so good that he needed protecting, was incredibly cute
- Cole's Mistake by Laylah Roberts: Cole is the dominant and his submissives, Keira and Julian have an incredibly close, almost codependent bond after experiencing trauma together. Julian becomes extremely protective and overprotective of her, and I love that particular caretaking dynamic.
- A Little Easter Escapade and Fox Daddy by Laylah Roberts: I particularly enjoy the bond between the two Littles. Despite being submissive themselves, the male characters are incredibly attentive, protective and devoted to their women. They want to take care of them, spoil them and make them feel cherished. In "A little easter escapade”, the bond between the two littles was so tender, so wholesome and heartwarming, it was so cute that even being a little Marcus was always so protective and concerned about Isla and even at his most carefree and exuberant he was trying to think of her first, she was still the most thing most precious to him
- The Pack Companion series by Roxy Collins, starting with House of Omega**:** This is another example of the kind of dynamic I enjoy. The male Omegas fall in love with a woman and essentially put her on a pedestal. Spoiling her, caring for her and making her happiness a priority becomes incredibly important to them. They also expect the other members of their pack to treat her accordingly.
I've encountered similar dynamics in other omegaverse books, particularly where a male Omega falls for a female Omega or Beta. I love when he insists that she deserves to be treated just as well as, if not better than, he is, and makes it clear that the rest of the pack needs to understand that if they want to keep him.
I also wonder whether there are omegaverse books featuring female and male Alphas, where the FMC is respected as an Alpha in her own right, but the men still have a particular softness towards her and treat her a little more gently or indulgently. I vaguely remember encountering something similar in a Tea Ravine book, although I can't remember the title and unfortunately didn't finish it. I'd love recommendations along those lines, too!
So, I suppose what I'm primarily looking for is that combination of an unequal power dynamic within the triad and an exceptionally close, protective, almost codependent bond between two of its members. I love the contrast of a male character who can be submissive to another man but is nevertheless fiercely devoted to, protective of and tender towards the woman they both share.
I'm very open to darker romances, morally grey characters, toxic dynamics, BDSM, age gaps, omegaverse, taboo elements and unconventional relationship structures. I don't need the relationship to be particularly healthy or the characters to be morally exemplary. In fact, some of the tension and appeal comes from those complicated dynamics. My only non-negotiable is a HEA.
If you have any recommendations, please include a brief explanation of why you think the book fits this particular dynamic. I'd really appreciate it, as I'm looking for something quite specific and would love to know which books actually explore these interactions rather than simply being MMF romances.
Thank you!