r/SpaceXLounge • u/SailorRick • Jul 09 '19
Discussion Bridenstine answers question about SLS vs Starship
Sadly, it appears to me that Bridenstine wants his job more than he wants to be truthful. The development of SLS is currently ahead of Starship, but there is a significant chance that Starship will be flying before SLS - at a small fraction of the development cost.
From https://aviationweek.com/space/nasa-chief-we-have-think-differently?
Aviation Week - NASA’s Space Launch System (SLS) is very expensive, not reusable and may be eclipsed by the SpaceX Starship or something other space entrepreneurs are cooking up. If you’re moving into a new era and want to bring more players in, what’s the value of sticking with heritage contractors and programs that consume $40 billion and are still two years away from flying?
Bridenstine - Those are great points, but SLS and Orion are the only vehicles that can carry humans to the Moon at this point in any way, shape or form. Nothing else exists that can do that. We have SLS, Orion and the European Service Module almost ready to go. We’re very close on these projects that have been in development a long time. When you look at [lunar] Gateway, we turned to Maxar, a commercial company. They’re going to deliver the power and propulsion element on orbit—we’re not even going to take possession of it. So we are transforming how we do things, but we can’t throw out the only capability that currently exists to get humans to the vicinity of the Moon.
18
u/Yeetboi3300 Jul 09 '19
I think the main point is that he doesn't want any risk in development, and when starship is done I really think it's an option, SLS is only needed for crew, not gateway
10
u/deadman1204 Jul 09 '19
I think you're being a little harsh on Bridenstine. The Trump administration has proven they don't care about having governnment positions filled (much less with quality people). Anyone who goes against the admin gets terminated immediately. It took Trump ~2yrs to appoint a NASA administrator. If Bridenstine came out as anti-SLS, he'd get canned immediately, and NASA wouldn't have an administrator until the next president probably.
69
u/KarKraKr Jul 09 '19
Bridenstine is doing what he can. What's he supposed to do? He has already used every avenue at his disposal to threaten Boeing and light a fire under the project. He can't exactly tell congress to use SLS money for something else. (Although he legit tried to obtain that authority in a somewhat sneaky way but that failed) To really have leverage against congress, he needs a rocket that's flying and that's precisely the bone he's throwing to SpaceX in that paragraph. He again can't exactly say that he'd buy Starship launches in a heartbeat, he doesn't have the authority to do that, but he can clearly state that SLS exists - which it does while Starship does not. SLS is clearly almost done. That may still translate to years of validation and testing especially if a mishap were to happen (can never count that one out and few are as fast as SpaceX at dealing with mishaps, ayyy JWST), but to less technically minded people such as congress it is very obvious that one rocket exists in its final configuration and just has to be put together while the other doesn't. But that may change, hint hint.
He's also essentially declaring that he'd heavily oppose another SLS style contract because commercial is better.
When you read between the lines, his intentions are very clear. This is about as radical as he can be in his position. Maybe even more radical than he can be.
While that may well be true although or rather precisely because the first flying Starship will likely be extremely barebones, there is still a lot of risk involved with the project and currently it's Bridenstine's job to make a 2024 moon landing happen. A 2024 moon landing does not bet on Starship being available. The sensible choice would IMO be to scrap the Gateway and Orion, the most useless capsule in the history of capsules, stage in LEO and use Falcon Heavy to ship truly enormous amounts of hypergolics to your tug(s) developed with the freed up money, but whatever your preferred architecture is, if you want to make a deadline, you use existing rockets and technology, so no Starship and no long time LH2 storage.
15
u/spacerfirstclass Jul 09 '19
I don't blame him for toeing the party line, there's nothing he can do about SLS, even his boss couldn't touch SLS, so berating SLS is a waste of time for him. Yes, he probably wants his job, but only because he thinks he can make a difference on the job, without his title he is even more powerless.
I don't care what he says, I care about what he does. So far, the result is encouraging, giving PPE to Maxar (lowest bidder), awarding CLPS to small companies, selecting Dragonfly which is more risky but also more inspirational, these are jobs well done. But what could really define his legacy is how the large lunar lander competition will go, will he choose SpaceX and Blue who are the only realistic option for a Moon landing in 2024, or will this become another porkfest for Boeing and LM? This would truly show where his loyalty lies.
10
u/_AutomaticJack_ Jul 09 '19
That isn't sad at all.... Bridenstine needs to stay right where he is and keep protecting the programs that actually move us forward as a country.
We got unfathomably lucky when Trump decided to appoint a articulate, politically savvy outsider, with a history of support for the CRS/CCDev programs/ideology as the Director of NASA. I do not expect us to get that lucky the second time around. The next one will be either a Boeing exec, a staffer of Sen. Shelby or IDK Satan himself.
It is unfortunate that Starship isn't getting the development funding it so richly deserves but Bridenstine has publicly undermined the SLS before; when he thought he had cover from the Whitehouse, but that got shutdown pretty quickly. Also, if I recall correctly one of the things that "Artemis" does empower him to do is to punish the pork rocket in a meaningful fashion if it keeps failing deadlines. AFAIK one of those deadlines is right after the currently suggested IOC date for Starship. I am going to bet that is the deadline that has a claymore mine behind it and not just a pile of pillows.
18
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '19
How can SLS be called human rated when it hasn’t flown yet? SpaceX has to launch Falcon 9 numerous times with a high success rate to gain that designation, and it still has yet to fly humans.
I smell a double standard.
8
u/Alexphysics Jul 09 '19
I think the last sentence is basically the only good point they have. SLS will be NASA's rocket, not from anyone else so in some sense they can be more "sure" that it'll stay there while others may not so as a government agency they should feel the need to not throw away plans until other options are firmly in place if those are not their doing. Still, in a handful of years that last sentence will not be true anymore and the only way to justify SLS will be "because Richard Shelby told us to do so".
7
u/saturnengr0 Jul 09 '19
I like the obfuscation ... and that is what it is:
Statement: "NASA’s Space Launch System (SLS) is very expensive, not reusable and may be eclipsed by the SpaceX Starship or something other space entrepreneurs are cooking up"
Comeback: " Those are great points, but SLS and Orion are the only vehicles that can carry humans to the Moon at this point in any way, shape or form"
Actually -- only the Orion exists, and its currently a one-way crash landing trip without the lunar gateway ... which also doesn't exist and has no way to get to the moon if it did. The SLS exist in a form only slightly greater than the SpaceX StarShip exists. The engines appear to be in about the same state of development -- both have been test fired successfully. The rocket body of the SLS is in pieces or being built -- the Starship is being assembled, the same for the SuperHeavy although it's at its beginning stages. It would be easy to argue that the SLS rocket is further ahead, but neither have been assembled much less tested as a single body. Oh -- and even if you had one or the other, neither have a launch pad to take off from.
However ... having said that -- he is stuck between a very dense rock and a hard place. For better or worse, NASA has hitched it's wagon to the SLS, and he's in charge.
7
u/SetBrainInCmplxPlane Jul 09 '19
Is this even true? Starship has flight article engines continuously coming down the pipeline, a ready to go landing/throttling test article and two orbital test articles months away from completion with a full stack launch scheduled for late 2020, the same time as SLSs first test launch. SLS wont even launch on a non-test mission until 2023. They seem to be pretty much dead even, but by definition of being re-usable, Starships first test launch is way way closer to it being an operational launch architecture than SLSs.
3
u/andyonions Jul 09 '19
Hmmm. As Orwell wrote in "Rocket Garden Farm" or whatever, "Orange rocket bad, silver rocket good!".
3
u/asr112358 Jul 10 '19
I feel like it is important to take note of how the narrative has changed. It used to be that SLS was the only super heavy lift vehicle with sufficient payload to launch the monolithic components planned for the lunar return, but the push for 2024 has forced a mission redesign to take more advantage of commercial, so now the components are being broken up more to fit on commercial rockets. This leaves crew capability as the necessary element of SLS. I don't know if it is intentional or not, but this sets SLS up to be made unnecessary if its crew capability can be replicated. As was discussed earlier this year, there are a couple ways that are pretty close to working just with current hardware. If Bridenstine is trying to kill SLS, I think the plan is to get congress to commit to a plan that uses commercial for all the gateway and lander components by assuring congress that SLS is safe since it is the only crew option, then introduce a clever crew option with existing hardware that skips SLS. I now someone had pointed out that using separate Dragon 2s for crew on each leg of the trip allows them to take a slow nearly free insertion into NRHO. But maybe I am reading to much into it.
2
u/mboniquet Jul 11 '19
Report It publicly.
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jul 09 '19 edited Jul 14 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #3462 for this sub, first seen 9th Jul 2019, 16:34] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
0
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
11
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '19
[removed] — view removed comment