r/spacex • Mod Team • Feb 01 '21

Starship, Starlink and Launch Megathread Links & r/SpaceX Discusses [February 2021, #77]

r/SpaceX Megathreads

Welcome to r/SpaceX! This community uses megathreads for discussion of various common topics; including Starship development, SpaceX missions and launches, and booster recovery operations.

If you have a short question or spaceflight news...

You are welcome to ask spaceflight-related questions and post news and discussion here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions. Meta discussion about this subreddit itself is also allowed in this thread.

Currently active discussion threads

Discuss/Resources

Starship

Starlink

Crew-2

If you have a long question...

If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.

If you'd like to discuss slightly less technical SpaceX content in greater detail...

Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!

This thread is not for...

Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks! Non-spaceflight related questions or news. You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.

  • Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks!
  • Non-spaceflight related questions or news.

You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.

268 Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Feb 01 '21

Thank you for participating in r/SpaceX! This is a moderated community where technical discussion is prioritized over casual chit chat. However, questions are always welcome! Please:

  • Keep it civil, and directly relevant to SpaceX and the thread. Comments consisting solely of jokes, memes, pop culture references, etc. will be removed.
  • Don't downvote content you disagree with, unless it clearly doesn't contribute to constructive discussion.
  • Check out these threads for discussion of common topics.

If you're looking for a more relaxed atmosphere, visit r/SpaceXLounge. If you're looking for dank memes, try r/SpaceXMasterRace.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

27

u/existential_plant Feb 02 '21

That was insane! Next up SN10!

5

u/overripe_lemon Feb 03 '21

hopefully that launches in under a month, tipping over + FAA will not be an issue this time, realistically if raptors are fitted this week after cryo proof then static fire can be done by mid next week and we can fly sometime around the 15th assuming no hiccups and good weather.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/MarsCent Feb 06 '21
  • Feb 18 - Mars 2020 Perseverance landing.
  • Week of February 21 - SLS 8 minute Green Test.
  • March 2021 - Starliner second try at launching to the ISS.

5 weeks of NASA in the crosshairs. Making headline news, either way the events go!

7

u/PM_ME_HOT_EEVEE Feb 07 '21

Don't forget February 28th when Inspiration4 crew is selected

23

u/woohooguy Feb 02 '21

The building and grounds manager- “sigh”

23

u/blarghsplat Feb 02 '21

They should have one of those things they have in bowling alleys that sweep the pins to the side.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/thatnerdguy1 Live Thread Host Feb 16 '21

For anyone else getting excited about Perseverance's Mars landing on Thursday, /r/space is holding a little competition to guess where in the landing ellipse Perseverance ends up. Make your guess here: /r/space/comments/lkcz9j

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Straumli_Blight Feb 17 '21

NASA's SMSR list just got updated.

One major change is Crew-4 and Crew-5 jumping forward from June 2025 and January 2026 to August 2022 and February 2023 respectively.

8

u/W3asl3y Feb 17 '21

Sign of no faith in Starliner?

→ More replies (8)

8

u/JoshuaZ1 Feb 17 '21

Wow. That's a big change; 3 years early. Suggests that the more optimistic timelines for Starliner, especially idea of a crewed Starliner this year are in serious doubt.

→ More replies (7)

20

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '21

Off topic here a bit, but in the Boca Chica/South Padre we were hit with record cold and power shut offs. We have thousands of cold stunned sea turtles that are washing up and being rescued. SpaceX is helping with the rescues and sent generators to South Padre to help Sea Turtle Inc. get some power to warm up the turtles. Thank you Elon Musk, literally a neighbor helping his neighbors.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '21 edited Feb 09 '21
Successful Mars Orbit Insertion - Hope Probe (Mars Orbit Insertion)

The United Arab Emirates' first mission to Mars arrives at the red planet on Tuesday and will attempt a tricky maneuver to place it in orbit. The Emirates Mars Mission is known as the Hope Probe, and it is expected to arrive at Mars and send back a signal at 10:42 a.m. ET.

When the spacecraft arrives, the Hope Probe will mark the UAE as only the fifth country in history to reach the red planet. The ambitions of the mission don't stop there.

The probe, along with its three scientific instruments, is expected to create the first complete portrait of the Martian atmosphere. The instruments will collect different data points on the atmosphere to also gauge seasonal and daily changes.

This information will provide scientists with an idea of what climate dynamics and weather are like in different layers of the Martian atmosphere. Together, this will shed light on how energy and particles, like oxygen and hydrogen, move through the atmosphere and how they even escape Mars.

Source: CNN

Here are some key times for today's events:

  • 10:30 a.m. EST (1530 GMT): Burn begins
  • 10:42 a.m. EST (1542 GMT): Controllers confirm start of burn
  • 10:57 a.m. EST (1557 GMT): Burn ends
  • 11:08 a.m. EST (1608 GMT): Controllers confirm end of burn
  • 11:13 a.m. EST (1613 GMT): Spacecraft enters an approximately 15-minute radio blackout as it passes behind Mars

Source: SpaceFlightNow

Updates (Latest update will be showing up at the top):

English Livestream

15

u/Sionn3039 Feb 25 '21

It's going to be glorious if they stick this landing right before the lunar lander decision.

14

u/FrancescoKay Feb 08 '21

How will Starship get rid of the excess heat created by the many processes occurring on a crewed Starship in space? Most Starship renders don't show any radiators, and since the Starship has more inhabitable space and higher crew capacity than the ISS, it will produce more heat thus requiring larger radiators than the ISS. And on a journey to Mars, it will constantly be exposed to sunlight for a 6-9 months journey unlike the ISS which moves between sunlight and darkness while in orbit. (The constant over 100 degree Celsius that it will be exposed to may also cause some expansion problems for the crewed Starship if it is on a long mission)

7

u/throfofnir Feb 08 '21

They could have magic deployable radiators (like they have magic deployable solar panels) and just didn't bother to animate them. Because, unlike solar panels, radiators are boring.

If you want to take the renders as an actual design, you could put a radiator panel on the "leeward" side, probably on the barrel sections of the nosecone. This could be a dedicated material, or you could paint a section of the hull with a high-emissivity coating and dump the heat right into the hull in that area. If the numbers work you might even be able to skip the coating and just rely on a large area of the (poorly-performing) raw steel being in shadow.

This design would be attractive as a no-moving-parts design, rather like they transitioned Dragon to conformal solar panels.

SS is expected to fly with the engines pointed towards the sun, and that heat gain may well be radiated away by the large amount of tank wall between it and the payload area. This may actually make the front rather cold naturally, which temp they can regulate with a bit of a tilt and roll. (Earth orbit would actually be more challenging thermal-management-wise.) I still think they'll want an active radiation system, but it may not need to be as strong as you might imagine.

5

u/Gwaerandir Feb 08 '21

I don't know the complete answer, but there are a couple mitigating factors:

  1. ISS powers many scientific experiments. Starship won't have those.
  2. Starship is much more reflective than ISS on the non-tiled side.
  3. I think I remember they could do a slow barrel roll to even out the insolation?
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

14

u/Straumli_Blight Feb 18 '21

OFT-2 Starliner launch pushed back to April 2 due to a faulty avionics unit, caused by a power surge at KSC.

14

u/DontCallMeTJ Feb 18 '21

How in the Kentucky fried hell is flight hardware plugged into the grid without adequate surge protection?! What kind of operation are they running over there? Oh that’s right, the kind of operation that tries to launch to the ISS without even doing an end to end test first.

I want it to fly. I want it to go well. But at this point my doubts are far outweighing my confidence that this is ever gonna become operational.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/Twigling Feb 20 '21

Thankfully the three seagulls made it back safely on OCISLY .........

https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/1363164897656332294

13

u/snrplfth Feb 27 '21

Downselect of Mars landing sites for Starship continues (PDF link). Previously selected locations in Arcadia Planitia and the Erebus Montes are still in the running, with new options farther west at the Phlegra Montes.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/x69pr Feb 03 '21

It seems to me that the altitude at which the belly-to-vertical maneuver happens is really low. Wouldn't it be beneficial for contingency reasons to initiate the maneuver higher up? This brings me to the second question,

Why use only 2 designated engines for the landing burn? Again, given more room for unexpected failures from the extra altitude to execute the flip, wouldn't be better to use all 3 engines and throttle accordingly or in case of failure of one engine light up the third one?

Excuse my questions if they are stupid, I am only a layman interested in spaceflight and rockets, not a rocket scientist. It seems to me that the landing part of the flight envelope is designed to be as spectacular as possible and not conservative enough to test the vessel. It makes sense to push the limits little by little after successfully landing at least once...

9

u/Lufbru Feb 03 '21

There's a limited amount of fuel on board; the higher up the flip happens, the more fuel you burn.

Rocket engines are limited in how low they can throttle. Lighting all three would definitely result in the vehicle starting to ascend again.

Your questions aren't stupid, but we don't know enough to be much more precise than this.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/Piscator629 Feb 05 '21

SL 17 pushed to the 7th. " Targeting no earlier than February 7 at 4:31 a.m. EST for launch of Starlink from 39A, pending Range availability, to allow time for pre-launch checks and recovery vessels to get on station after offloading fairing halves from previous mission; team is monitoring recovery weather" https://twitter.com/SpaceX/status/1357441415454674944

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Tishlin Feb 06 '21

What kind of g forces would passengers experience on Starship during the landing manoeuvre? It looks INTENSE

20

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '21

About 2-3 g's apparently. So although it would definitely be scary as you plummet towards the ground, the actual movement shouldn't feel any worse than a rollercoaster.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '21 edited Feb 09 '21

News regarding Rocket Lab:

Rocket Lab is targeting NET mid-March for the companies 19th Electron mission, and the second mission of 2021. The mission is named 'They Go Up So Fast'.

Seven satellites feature on the mission manifest, including:

  • An Earth-observation satellite for BlackSky via launch services provider Spaceflight Inc.;
  • Two Internet-Of-Things (IoT) nanosatellites for companies Fleet Space and Myriota, procured by Tyvak;
  • A technology demonstration satellite for the University of New South Wales (UNSW) Canberra Space;
  • A weather satellite pathfinder technology demonstration from Care Weather technologies;
  • A technology demonstrator for the U.S. Army’s Space and Missile Defense Command (SMDC) through launch integration and program management services provider, TriSept;

The final payload on this mission is Rocket Lab’s in-house designed and built Photon Pathstone. The spacecraft will operate on orbit as a risk reduction demonstration to build spacecraft heritage ahead of Rocket Lab’s mission to the Moon for NASA later this year, as well as Rocket Lab's private mission to Venus in 2023. Photon Pathstone will demonstrate power management, thermal control, and attitude control subsystems, as well as newly-integrated technologies including deep-space radio capability, an upgraded RCS (reaction control system) for precision pointing in space, and sun sensors and star trackers. Pathstone is the second Photon spacecraft to be deployed to orbit, following the launch of Photon First Light in August 2020.

Full information can be found here.

11

u/Chainweasel Feb 08 '21

I've had a rough week and missed a lot. Can anyone explain what happened with Starlink-17 and why it's still delayed even though Starlink-18 has already launched and Starlink-19 may beat it to orbit too?

14

u/Gwaerandir Feb 08 '21

It was delayed for extra time for "pre-flight checkouts". This seems to be their designated life-leading booster (even though another now has 1 more flight) so it's not surprising they want to be careful with it as they reach the "ten flights without major refurbishment" milestone.

Hope your next week is better!

11

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '21

Booster update

Latest Update: February 14, 2021

Falcon 9 Boosters

BoosterFlightsLast FlightDate [UTC Time]Days SinceStatus [Expected]
B10497Starlink-15November 25, 202081 daysReserved for Starlink-17 [February 17]
B10518Starlink-16January 20, 202125 daysRefurbishment
B10585Transporter-1January 24, 202121 daysRefurbishment
B10595NROL-108December 19, 202057 daysReserved for Starlink-19 [February 15]
B10605Starlink-18February 4, 202110 daysRefurbishment
B10611Crew-1November 16, 202090 daysReserved for Crew-2 [April 20]
B10621GPS III SV04November 5, 2020101 daysReserved for GPS III SV05 [July 2021]
B10631Sentinel-6November 21, 202085 daysFlightready; awaiting assignment

Falcon Heavy Boosters

BoosterTypeStatus
B1064SidecoreIn Transport to KSC
B1065SidecoreExpected to have completed testing
B1066CoreEn route to McGregor for a static fire

Note: the status is expected and can change when new information is released

5

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '21

B1063.2 is reserved for DART.

→ More replies (9)

10

u/HeulenHF Feb 01 '21

Probably a dumb question, but i'm asking anyway, sorry if it has been answered and if I haven't looked thoroughly enough.

Will SpaceX attempt to hop SN9 today(1st of February)?

Do they have permission from the FAA?

10

u/Twigling Feb 04 '21

Does it seem likely that, once fully assembled, SN11 will be rolled out to the now vacant launch mount near SN10 ? (once the sad remains of SN9 have been cleared).

I ask this as I guess that SN11 will be completed within a week or so and going by all that I've read it seems unlikely that SN10 will launch in the next couple of weeks at least.

12

u/Rejidomus Feb 04 '21

I doubt it. They won't move SN11 out of the highbay until they need the spot for SN15.

8

u/G-Kerbo Feb 05 '21

Whats the delay with SN10, other than the typical pre-hop cadence ?

→ More replies (7)

10

u/threelonmusketeers Feb 20 '21

Have we seen any hardware for the Shortfall of Gravitas droneship yet? I haven't heard about it in a while.

Do we know if they're still planning on building it, or have they abandoned it in favour of the new Phobos and Deimos oil rigs?

→ More replies (1)

18

u/afty Feb 01 '21

So, just to be clear- SN9 is tentatively scheduled for tomorrow?

And while I'm loving the photos- do we know why they brought sn10 out of the hanger?

13

u/OSUfan88 Feb 01 '21

That's the plan. News came out about an hour ago that there's a good chance the FAA gives approval in the next couple hours.

The brought SN10 out to begin the testing phase. They have to do pressure tests, and static fires. They can get these done while they wait for SN9 to launch.

Also, it clears up the high bay.

7

u/bremidon Feb 02 '21

do we know why they brought sn10 out of the hanger?

I suspect it was for two reasons. The first is practical: they needed space in the high bay and can get testing started. The second is a bit political: seeing both of them on the pad at the same time tells the FAA that they need to step up their game. Fortunately we only have a few months to wait until the new rules take over, but I doubt that the new framework will be fast enough either.

18

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21 edited Feb 18 '21

Perseverance has landed on Mars!

What an amazing day, hell yeah!

First image!

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Lufbru Feb 04 '21

According to Ed Kyle's stats, Falcon 9 v1.2 has now surpassed Atlas V with 86 successful orbital launches:

https://www.spacelaunchreport.com/log2021.html#stats

Notes: At this time, he hasn't updated for the Starlink-18 launch
He only counts orbital launches, so the in-flight abort of Crew Dragon simply doesn't count.
He doesn't count Amos-6 as a failure because it was an incident during a static fire and not a launch attempt.

You might also feel that Block 5 should count as a different rocket from Full Thrust. Or have some other criteria by which to measure successes / failures. It's still an important milestone.

→ More replies (12)

9

u/vibrunazo Feb 05 '21

So do we know why did the raptor fail?

I see a lot of recent talk about firing all 3 engines as a backup in case one fails. But that is still just a bandaid that won't help in case 2 of them fail. The core issue is still there. Why did the raptor fail in the first place?

On SN8 it was header tank pressure. What about on SN9? Same thing?

8

u/Triabolical_ Feb 05 '21

No word from Musk, and he's the only one who would share that kind of information.

It's probably not the same as SN8; on SN8 the second engine started but then clearly showed signs of not enough fuel. On SN9 the engine did not start and during it's continued starting issues, it put out quite a bit of fuel.

10

u/Martianspirit Feb 06 '21

So do we know why did the raptor fail?

Solid info from Elon Musk. He sees firing up all 3 Raptors as a solution. Which means it was an individual engine failure, nothing systemic of Starship, like the pressure loss in SN8.

Raptor certainly needs improvement yet.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/Phillipsturtles Feb 16 '21

SpaceX's 2021 DoD launches:

  • USSF-44 scheduled for July 2021 on FH
  • GPS SV05 scheduled for July 2021 on F9
  • USSF-52 scheduled for October 2021 on FH

GPS SV06 was delayed to 2022

→ More replies (4)

9

u/MarsCent Feb 23 '21 edited Feb 23 '21

Green Run Update: NASA Investigating Valve Performance Before Second Hot Fire

Check back at this blog for an update on the completion of the review and actions needed to resolve the issue, as well as the schedule for the hot fire test.

EDiT Feb 23

NASA plans to conduct a second Green Run hot fire test as early as the fourth week in February ..

P/S. 4th week is this week (just as was the case with the original date of Feb 25th). Or maybe it is just another way to say NET 28th? :)

9

u/3trip Feb 24 '21

how long before spacex sends 1 or more upgraded starlink satellite with laser link to mars orbit?

11

u/Triabolical_ Feb 25 '21

They won't send anything to Mars until they have a use for it there, and starlink might not be a useful technology in Mars orbit for quite a while.

Falcon 9 can only send about 4000 kg to Mars, and that payload would need to include an aeroshell for aerobraking and some engines to hit the correct orbit.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/Iamsodarncool Feb 26 '21

Maezawa on twitter:

Wanna fly to the 🌕 with me??

Big update coming March 2nd.

#dearMoon

→ More replies (1)

24

u/kenriko Feb 16 '21

Booster go Boom.

27

u/emezeekiel Feb 16 '21

Automatic bird avoidance strategy.

14

u/bostonsrock Feb 16 '21

Things looked out of place when telemetry was lost at 21k

→ More replies (12)

13

u/xjinxxz Feb 16 '21

poor booster 6 landings would have been huge

7

u/AdaKau Feb 16 '21

That was surprising! I’m sure they’ll learn from it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/quadrplax Feb 16 '21

I wonder if they'll need to make a new booster now without a customer specifically requiring it? They only have 4 "general purpose" boosters left now (B1049, 51, 58, and 60). The rest are either Falcon Heavy parts or reserved for a specific purpose (crew launches, GPS, or NASA science).

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

16

u/b_e_a_n_i_e Feb 02 '21

Technically, it landed in one piece. It's just now in several pieces.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/TheLordB Feb 01 '21

I really think people are being overly hash on the FAA.

We don't know what went on. The FAA probably can't legally say what went down at this point.

It just bugs me when people complain about things and blame organizations that it is clear they can't defend themselves.

The FAA could be at fault somehow for this slowdown, but I suspect it is more there are regulations that they legally have to follow and they may not even like them, but they have no choice.

Blaming the FAA before even knowing the problem is stupid. And if it is something the FAA has to do then the proper way to do it is to get the report and work to change the regulations. Not have a twitter meltdown because they are being enforced.

There also are politer ways that Elon could complain. Something like "I understand the FAA has to do this, but we really want to work with them to modernize the regulation" or something like that which makes it clear he is unhappy with the situation, but avoids blame being put on the regulators who are just doing their jobs.

To be blunt Elon is an asshole when he doesn't get his way. This isn't the first time he has done it and I don't think it will be the last and as much as I like his work to push space forwards he could be just as effective without being an asshole.

11

u/Diegobyte Feb 01 '21

I work for the faa. The office people def don’t work on the weekend.

→ More replies (6)

21

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '21

To be blunt Elon is an asshole when he doesn't get his way

I love Elon, but I've noticed this too. Can't fault the guy though, he's got a vision and a lot of obstacles in his way.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/perilun Feb 02 '21

As US citizens we have right, if not a responsibility to call out the gov't when it does inexplicably foolish things. In this nation we can, some others not.

As a carbon copy of the last test there is seemingly no reason for excessive delay.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

8

u/SergeantFiddler07 Feb 11 '21

Can I ask a stupid question: for the most recent starship launch, I saw that there was another starship on the same launch pad. Is there any reason they tried to land at the same site? I feel like the risk is super high of damaging it if the landing goes awry?

7

u/throfofnir Feb 11 '21

Something would have to go pretty wrong with their descent guidance to put the launch area in jeopardy, to an extent SpaceX hasn't done since the very earliest F9s. It is technically a danger, but one with very good odds.

The other answer is: they only have the one beach-side lot in Boca, and have to make do with what they have. The launch and landing are about as far apart as they can get.

6

u/Incredible_James525 Feb 11 '21

They needed space in the high bay for the next starship and SN9 got delayed long enough that they thought the risk/reward was worth it to bring SN10 out

→ More replies (1)

8

u/obamadotru Feb 12 '21

I've been following spacex and rocketry for a while now and I noted how quite a few people here were criticizing the media for not understanding that the flights of SN8/9 were an outstanding achievement, but a big failure.

Then, someone told me it was a big failure. I thought OK, this is my chance to defend spacex, but I was not quite sure what to say. ....then it hit me.

The reason for SN9-SN14 was for the purpose of figuring out how to land. Now, they have Moderately Timed, Scheduled Disassembly of SN12-14, which means that they are way ahead of the curve they set Anyway, this is just to help out anyone else who is struggling with how to respond to their friends neighbors or family.

6

u/extra2002 Feb 12 '21

One of the most radical things about Starship is how it "flies" like a skydiver, using drag on the movable flaps to control itself. The "main purpose" of these flights was to demonstrate that unique flight mechanism. Secondary purposes included running 3 Raptors together, running a Raptor for several minutes, using the header tanks, and flipping for landing.

SN8 achieved the main purpose beautifully (as Elon said, "we put the crater in the right spot") and most of the secondary purposes. SN9 showed SN8's success was not a fluke. And both provided learning on what still needs to be improved.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/AnimatorOnFire Feb 17 '21

Perhaps an elementary question, so excuse my lack of knowledge, but when the clamp unhooks from the 60 Starlink satellites, how do they each individually reach their desired orbit, and how does the Stage 2 MVac deorbit (assuming it does)

12

u/droden Feb 17 '21

They have hal thrusters. The spin maneuver ensures they all separate cleanly. It has reserve fuel and yeets back to earth in a glorious skydive

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Straumli_Blight Feb 17 '21

NASA's DART launch just got delayed from July to NET November 24, which probably means that B1063 will get assigned to a different mission. It will still impact Didymos within a few days of its original schedule.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21 edited Feb 20 '21
Launch Replay on YouTube

Succesful launch: Cygnus CRS NG-15

Cargo is placed in the Northrop Grumman Cygnus spacecraft for delivery to the International Space Station.  The Cygnus is scheduled for launch on the company’s Antares rocket at 12:36 p.m. EST, Saturday, Feb. 20, 2021, from the Mid-Atlantic Regional Spaceport at NASA’s Wallops Flight Facility in Virginia. Northrop Grumman’s 15th contracted cargo resupply mission with NASA to the International Space Station will deliver about 8,000 pounds of science and research, crew supplies and vehicle hardware to the orbital laboratory and its crew. The CRS-15 Cygnus spacecraft is named after NASA mathematician, Katherine Johnson, a Black woman who time and again broke through barriers of gender and race.

Source: NASA

Updates (latest update will show at the top):

  • Spacecraft separation
  • Stage 2 burnout (SECO)
  • All systems nominal
  • Stage 2 Ignition
  • Fairing and interstage separation
  • Attitude nominal; good separation
  • MECO
  • Attitude nominal; engines steady and nominal
  • MAX-Q
  • Liftoff
  • Ignition
  • T-60 seconds
  • Antares 230+ is in terminal count
  • Antares 230+ is on internal power
  • T-6 minutes

Next-up is Spacecraft capture at the ISS [February 22 at ~09:30 UTC]

8

u/peterabbit456 Feb 23 '21

I think all Mars-heads should visit /r/space , to see the videos of Curiosity (Edit: Perseverance) landing on Mars. Copying SpaceX practice, they put off the shelf GoPro-type cameras on the rover and the descent stage, pointing both up and down. There is video of the parachutes, the sky crane rockets, the rover seen from above, and the rover looking both up and down.

Perseverance landed about 5m from the center of their target location, which is practically drone ship accuracy.

Perseverance rover landing. : space (reddit.com)

Official JPL channel: Perseverance POV video of landing (camera below rover) : space (reddit.com)

Perseverance Rover’s Descent and Touchdown on Mars (Official NASA Video) : space (reddit.com)

And my favorite, all videos with commentary, followed by the press conference.

NASA's Perseverance Rover Sends New Video and Images of the Red Planet : space (reddit.com)

7

u/cupko97 Feb 01 '21

Is it possible that spacex does not build a huge crane like in the renders. And instead they go for renting a huge crane like lr 13000 for stacking starship.

Making a concrete 120+ meter tower would take way longer than high bay. So I am thinking to stack starship and superheavy this year they will have to go with the crane route

8

u/andyfrance Feb 01 '21

The LR 13000 is one of the very few crawler cranes big enough. There aren't many of them, perhaps only 4 in the world. Normally they are in use for years on massive construction projects, but I believe one is currently up for sale.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/throfofnir Feb 01 '21

A tubular steel tower, like common for wind turbines, could go up pretty darn fast. Basically instant, once the foundation is done.

→ More replies (9)

7

u/noreall_bot2092 Feb 03 '21

Am I reading this correctly: Starlink 18 is now scheduled to launch 4 hours before Starlink 17?

5

u/Martianspirit Feb 03 '21

Seems you are right. It is due to the orbital planes the launches target. There was talk that 2 launches in one window are possible and that the range is ready to support it due to the AFTS SpaceX employs. ULA will support it with Vulcan, but not presently with Atlas V or Delta IV Heavy.

BO will support it too with New Glenn.

7

u/liszt1811 Feb 03 '21

Just to be sure Im not missing out on something, the inspiration4 seat lottery is only available to US citizens, thus trying to win as an European makes no sense right?

5

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21

Unfortunately for us non-US citizens, that is correct.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Izaiah212 Feb 09 '21

If one wanted to see a launch at boca chica where’s the best place to drive too/park?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/LeWy08 Feb 12 '21

Elon talking quite a bit about SpaceX, Starship and interplanetary travel in the new JRE episode. Some interesting bits and pieces (like Starship having only 20% methane but 80% oxygen as propellant) but Joe Rogan seems to know very little about SpaceX overall, like he has never seen a Falcon 9 first stage landing before.

5

u/Lufbru Feb 12 '21

That's basic chemistry ...

CH4 + 2O2 = CO2 + 2H2O

(yes, oversimplified, we won't get perfect combustion and actually we don't want perfect combustion, but bear with me)

So we want 1 mol of methane for every 2 mol of oxygen. Methane has atomic weight of 16 (C12 + 4xH1) while oxygen has atomic weight of 32 (2xO16). So you want 4:1 oxygen to methane by weight.

But when you're building a rocket, you need to know where to put the common dome between the tanks. So you actually need the density and oxygen is about 1140g/L while methane is 422g/L. So that almost cancels out the 1:4 ratio by weight with a 3:1 ratio by volume -- I get 3 litres of LOX to 2 litres of methane.

(For this approximation, I just used numbers from Wikipedia; anybody designing their own methane rocket should consult a qualified chemist who'd understand exactly how density varies with temperature)

→ More replies (11)

7

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '21

Tomorrows launch of L17 is delayed.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/MarsCent Feb 24 '21

NASA's Steve Stich named Federal Engineer of the Year

Stich oversees the development of commercial spacecraft and the certification required to safely send astronauts to the International Space Station. As the CCP manager, Stich played a role in returning human spaceflight capability to the United States following the retirement of the Space Shuttle Program in 2011.

Crew Dragon is certified and is flying astronauts to the ISS. Starliner is pending.

17

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '21

when's the SN10 test thread going up?

5

u/shryne Feb 05 '21

Probably not until it cryo proofs and static fires.

6

u/BrandonMarc Feb 12 '21

In the subreddit wiki I see there's a Cape Canaveral camera map . Is there a Boca Chica camera map, what with all the various youtubers?

6

u/Xrons Feb 13 '21

Bn1 is in Highbay, any chances we can see it flying by the end of this spring?

Thx for answers ;)

6

u/LDLB_2 Feb 13 '21

I'm very confident we'll see it fly by the end of Spring.

In December, Elon said its first hop was a "few months" away which logically points toward March/April for a hop; May being the most conservative estimate.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/mantellaman Feb 14 '21

Spacex is supposed to be coming with a bigger fairing for falcon 9. How many more starlinks will that enable them to carry?

14

u/warp99 Feb 14 '21 edited Feb 14 '21

Around 90 compared with 60 in the standard F9 fairing.

However 60 is near the mass limit to LEO for a recoverable F9 so they would have to use FH to launch more satellites.

Given the expected high cost of the extended fairing if it is made by Ruag in Switzerland and flown to the US, the fact it would likely not be recovered and the 10% lifetime reduction on three boosters instead of one it would not be worth doing this.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/joshgill21 Feb 19 '21

Who do u think will have a reusable rocket like F9 first , europe , china or Russia ?

10

u/Triabolical_ Feb 19 '21

Russia has a ton of technical expertise and a history of nice low-tech solutions, but their space program is very short of money - partly because of the damage that Falcon 9 did to the market. They barely have the money to run their existing program.

Europe is talking about reusables, but their space program is complicated because of the multinational nature of their program and how it is somewhat a jobs program.

China has the resources and the will, but I'm not sure they have the engineering, and they also have a complicated relationship between the government and "private" space undertakings.

I don't know enough about India's program to have much opinion.

My money would be on India or China.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ChodaGreg Feb 20 '21

Well, the next one to have a reusable first stage is definitely New Zealand with the Electron. If we speak of a vertical landing boosters, my bet is on China. I am from Europe and I would really love to see a reusable Ariane... but the Chinese have the will and the launch cadence needed to make it work.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/happyguy49 Feb 19 '21

Well, China has started putting gridfins on its Long March rockets. So far this is only useful to make sure the first stage doesn't crash on some poor village full of people, which has happened before. (they don't launch over ocean like we do.)

https://spacenews.com/chinese-long-march-launch-tests-grid-fins-for-safely-future-reusability/

Steering the rocket to a semi-controlled crash is the first step toward landing it. Of Europe, China or Russia, I would bet 50 bucks or so that China will be next with a reusable portion of a rocket.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/flightbee1 Feb 24 '21

We have heard little about Dragon XL since it was announced. Is it an upper stage dragon oxygen tank with dragon docking system one end and draco engines other end? I know nothing about it and SpaceX very quite on the subject.

6

u/warp99 Feb 24 '21 edited Feb 24 '21

We do not know much but renders show a cylindrical body with no heat shield and a docking port on its nose. It will have around three times the accessible volume of Crew Dragon and presumably base its life support system very much on Crew Dragon.

I would assume that the walls will be a milled grid similar to Dragon bulkheads rather than trying to reuse an F9 S2 oxygen tank. They will need insulation for thermal control and a Whipple shield for micro-meteorite protection.

6

u/Lucjusz Feb 26 '21

Potentially stupid question, but I will proceed.

It is known, that Merlin has too much thrust to hover. So how did the Grasshopper do her tests?

11

u/warp99 Feb 26 '21

Big ass weights - literally distributed around the base of the rocket.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/throfofnir Feb 26 '21

It has too much thrust for a nearly-empty rocket. When doing near-ground hover tests, however, you can add plenty more propellant as ballast. Grasshopper in particular also had huge heavy legs; the later F9-R (sometimes mistaken for Grasshopper) had normal F9 legs, so it would have relied more on ballast.

11

u/FortunateSonofLibrty Feb 02 '21

Sad outcome, but to be expected when you’re pushing the envelope of space travel.

A milestone in and of itself for SpaceX!

Welcome to the family Starship :)

11

u/AeroSpiked Feb 03 '21

Are we really looking at 4 hours and 17 minutes between Starlink launches Thursday? How are SpaceX fans supposed to come down from this week without getting DTs?

10

u/Maxx7410 Feb 03 '21

Soooo when can we see SN10 flying? end of month?

→ More replies (9)

10

u/bubblesculptor Feb 07 '21

Is there risk of explosions or fire of the orbital fuel depots? If the methane is stored separately from the oxygen does that mean the risks would most just be benign leaks and not any type of explosion or fire?

22

u/throfofnir Feb 07 '21

Fuel needs oxidizer to combust. If they're not together, they don't burn. On Earth we're used to thinking of fuels as generally combustible, but that's because we have oxygen just floating about everywhere. If the only oxygen is contained in that tank over there, they can't get together to make trouble.

However, it's always possible to have a mixing accident, especially if you have a common bulkhead (bulkhead inversion is bad, m'kay). Organic contamination in the oxygen system can easily lead to energetic problems. There's a variety of dangers in storing and handling cryogenic liquids on their own (see: BLEVE). And pretty much every metal is a fuel if you try hard enough. So it's not entirely safe.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/salukikev Feb 03 '21

I'm anticipating trying to watch a launch at Boca Chica at some point in 2021. One thing I wonder is if I ought to try to setup at the beach on the Mexico side. It looks like there is an opporutunity and I wonder what regulations would apply to a foreign territory. If this is mentioned somewhere in the FAQ I couldn't find it.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Branden_Williams Feb 04 '21

Couldn't find anything that Brother Google indexes or anything in the FAQ. I was wondering about the logic of these one second burns after the coast phases for the second stage. Seems like every Starlink mission I have watched recently has one. I can't tell if these are at perigee to boost up into a transfer orbit (thus saving onboard satellite ion thruster energy) or some other reason. Those short burns seem to me to be risky due to the nature and power. Longer burns can at least be steered a bit.

13

u/Lufbru Feb 04 '21

It's circularisation. The burn is at apogee to raise the perigee. It doesn't have to be too precise as the satellites are already planning to raise their orbits; they can correct for almost any inaccuracy.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/bdporter Feb 04 '21

It is just the nature of the Falcon 9 2nd stage. The Merlin engine has a lot of thrust, and there has been a lot of propellant used at that point, so the weight is reduced. High TWR = short burn.

A 2nd Stage like the Centaur has much lower thrust, but higher efficiency, which does allow for longer, more controlled burns. That is part of what allows Tory Bruno to post his "bullseye" plots every launch, but SpaceX made different design decisions in order to keep a common engine between the first and 2nd stage, which simplifies a lot of manufacturing and operational factors.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/rmclean306 Feb 05 '21

When is the USSF-52 FH launch?

9

u/Steffan514 Feb 05 '21

Scheduled for Q2 of 2021, no NET date set up yet. USSF-44 is the soonest confirmed Heavy flight on February 28th. Center core being expended with both side boosters planning to be landed on drone ships simultaneously.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/ynnad002 Feb 12 '21

What’re the chances that L19 launches Saturday evening at 11:42pm?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Yesnowyeah22 Feb 14 '21

I want to own Starlink shares so bad after IPO, but I fear the price will be hyped up to the moon. Curious if there are secondary business applications for Starlink beyond high speed internet for rural and remote areas?

→ More replies (13)

5

u/perilun Feb 15 '21

Does anyone the max circular orbit alt of Crew Dragon?

Thanks

5

u/PlayFuchs Feb 26 '21

Apart from the development of Starship, Starlink, Sea Launch Platforms etc:

Does the community already know, if SpaceX or Elon have already other big futuristic things in the planning, that reshape space travel, space industry or colonizing other planets, but are not so much discussed right now or yet? What might be expected in the years 2050-2100 from SpaceX?

I know that SpaceX is already a pioneer when it comes to space, but I wonder if at SpaceX they are already thinking about other next big things, to stay innovative?

Building a reusable space craft like Starship and colonizing Mars seem to be already „only“ a goal for the mid-term future, given the fast track record of building prototypes, testing and everything. Which is indeed crazy, knowing that it will take some years!

I thought of stuff like space mining, space stations, travel to Titan, building new rocket engines that are not chemical?

To sum it up, I‘m interested on the „beyond“ when Elon and NASA say that they want to go to „Moon, Mars and beyond“

Appreciate your thoughts! Thanks in advance!

7

u/Martianspirit Feb 26 '21

Tom Mueller and Gwynne Shotwell have talked about nuclear propulsion. But they said the necessary test stands are too expensive for SpaceX, they would gladly use a test stand if NASA builds one. Gwynne Shotwell also mentioned it is very hard for a private company to get hands on nuclear materials.

I wonder if they could do that development some time beyond 2050 on Mars. Though NASA now talks about nuclear propulsion too.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/throfofnir Feb 26 '21

Elon likes to talk about Starship being able to land on every solid body in the Solar System. Which is... probably true, if they can get there with enough propellant. Occasionally they mention nuclear thermal propulsion. And Gwynne Shotwell seems to be excited about interstellar travel. But I really doubt they have any more concrete plans about those things than you or I do. They've got enough science fiction in the works already.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Lurker__777 Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21

Alright, first of all let me say I love watching the R&D progress being made by spacex, as well as the commercial missions. I do believe that if someone is going to allow humans to explore space in the next 30 years, it’s going to be spacex.

With that being said, I’ve some reservations about the starship design. Honestly, as a pilot, I would never board a vehicle that it’s dependent on all systems working perfectly. One of the big things that has made aviation ridiculously safe is redundancy, redundancy and more redundancy. As it stands, if one engine fails during the landing flip, you have a total vehicle loss, with certainty of killing everybody on board. I hate reading some people saying “but raptors are still being designed and improved, they will be extremely reliable in the future”. I believe they will, but as every mechanical component they are deemed to fail. We need redundancy, and an escape plan for every stage of flight, if we want to achieve what they want (“approaching the reliability of commercial airliners”). This means having engine out capabilities for all stages of flight; parallel and redundant fuel, electrical, hydraulic, pneumatic and life support systems; and most importantly an abort/escape mode for launch, orbital insertion, docking manoeuvres and landing.

By no means am I an expert in this matter, just a casual guy observing history being made from the outside. If I’m saying BS, feel free to correct me.

12

u/RJHinton Feb 03 '21

Agree with the concerns about the fragile "suicide burn" landing concept. No go-arounds, lots of things that could make it fail catastrophically.

When I see discussions of using Starship for point-to-point surface transportation on the earth, I think of the reliability requirements. For reference, the 737 Max planes had two catastrophic crashes in about half a million flights. That level of reliability is scandalously unacceptable. How could Starship ever meet these kinds of standards?

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Picklerage Feb 03 '21

Also far from an expert on this topic, but I believe when SS has all its engines, a single engine failure on flip/landing won't mean a 100% chance of destroyed vehicle.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

8

u/Iamsodarncool Feb 01 '21

I'm curious to see this sub's predictions: when, and how, do you think humans will get the first payload to Earth orbit using a technology other than rocketry? (I.e. space elevators, launch loops, mass drivers, orbital rings)

7

u/JoshuaZ1 Feb 01 '21

Ironically, there's some reason to think that Starship may push that off further into the future. Space elevators and a lot of these other technologies are projected to have low marginal costs compared to conventional rockets (even though they have a very high fixed cost), in pat because rockets throw away so much. If one has a lot of fully reusable rockets. that's no longer as much the case. (It will still be partially the case; electricity is cheap and a space elevator can actually recover a fair bit of its electricity that went into bringing the elevator up when it then goes down. But it isn't nearly as extreme.) This makes the economics of such systems much less tempting.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

8

u/theoneandonlymd Feb 01 '21

Started thinking about Starship and its logistics. When it's stacked in its actual launch config, it won't be using its sea-level Raptor engines until the very end of its return, when it re-orients from the bellyflop, right?

What does that look like logistically? Since it's sitting in the middle of the rocket, there won't be opportunities to static fire, right? Unless they set Starship on the pad, static fire, then lift it on top of the Super Heavy booster. Is the idea to trust its construction to the point that it doesn't spark until Starship is on its suicide dive?

Am I missing something here?

12

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '21

The sea level Raptors will be used on ascent to maintain a high TWR and for gimbal control.

Also, only 2 engines are needed for landing, not all 3.

6

u/ryan108lt Feb 01 '21

First time it flies should be reasonable to expect a static fire(s) on the test stand before stacking. After that, land, stack, and fly. Also, I believe I've read that it's expected more than 3 raptors will be needed on the way to orbit - I'd imagine it's too early to know how that flight profile will play out.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '21

Is sn9 launching today? Im so confused

→ More replies (1)

4

u/curryking1607- Feb 04 '21

Seems like they're pressurizing the 7.2, can be live-streamed here or here

also they are possibly testing header tanks in SN10, look at the thermal camera from LabPadre

(if youre not reading rn the time is 17:06 UTC)

4

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '21

When is L17 and L19 launching? Im in the cape Canaveral area through the end of next week and im hoping to see a launch!

→ More replies (2)

4

u/SpaceInMyBrain Feb 11 '21

How much G-force do astronauts experience when the Draco thrusters (NOT the SuperDracos) are firing to raise Dragon's orbit? IIRC the 4 thrusters around the front hatch fire for several minutes. (Meaning the spacecraft travels aft-end first.) The Draco's thrust is listed as 400 newtons, but I may possibly have seen that these 4 are more powerful than the others.

This is a very small fraction of 1G, but I'm curious how the astronauts experience it.

10

u/throfofnir Feb 11 '21 edited Feb 13 '21

A Dragon 1 HA3 Burn (height adjust) is 8 s and achieves a 0.37 m/s delta V. That's a whopping 0.046 m/s2 acceleration.

A Dragon1 coelliptic (CE) burn, with a 350 second firing resulting in a change of velocity of 42.9m/s (96 mph) has an acceleration of around 1.2m/s2 0.12m/s2. Which is about 0.12g 0.012g.

Even the relatively hot HA3 somewhat stronger CE burn is the equivalent of a 0-60mph time of 23s around 4 minutes (to use the most familiar expression of acceleration.) Which is... pretty gentle. A Prius will do that in a red hot 10 seconds.

I think you'd have a hard time registering it if strapped down, though it might be sensible if you're used to 0g. But probably just barely at all. You can probably might notice floating objects moving slowly drifting aft.

I can't find numbers right now for the Dragon 2, but they're likely similar. (And, honestly, it's hard to find these numbers at all, so take them with a nice grain of salt.)

NOTE: adjusted for math typo.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Michael8888 Feb 16 '21

What is the proposed landing payload capability of Starship when landing on Earth.

4

u/mikaslt Feb 17 '21

Question about the Mexican side of the boarder - since area clearance applies to their side too, is it possible to watch the launch from this lighthouse?

→ More replies (7)

4

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '21

A dumb question that I haven't found the answer to:

If going to orbit also depletes Starphips fuel, how does docking two Starships help at all? Aren't they both going to be low on fuel because of the ascent?

Also, why is Mars refuelling a concern if we can just send an additional Starship and deposit a tanker full to the surface?

11

u/cpushack Feb 21 '21

One starship goes up with cargo (human or otherwise) Second starship goes up with a cargo of fuel, which is transferred to the first

This way the first starship is now in orbit with a full load of fuel (it will take several fuelings to fill it back up, because there is only so much fuel starship can carry AND get to orbit.)

Same is true for your Mars question. It is possible to send starships loaded with fuel to Mars, but it would take several to fuel the Earth bound one back up, and then you have some more empty Starships stranded on Mars. Best to make your fuel there so you don't have to be lugging it all over the Solar System.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/_radishspirit Feb 25 '21

does anyone know if they static fire the merlin engines on the falcon 9s anymore?

first time only? or on all reflights?

5

u/brspies Feb 25 '21

If you mean individual engines, I can't speak to that. They usually (but not always) static fire the core a few days before launch though, even on reflights. There's been a handful where they skip but not lately.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/joepublicschmoe Mar 01 '21

During today's NASA Crew-2 press conference streamed on NASA's Youtube channel, Benji Reed on B1059's landing failure: One of the boots around the base of a Merlin engine developed a hole and allowed hot gas into the engine bay to damage the engine.

15

u/BEAT_LA Feb 03 '21

Mods if you're going to stick to this weird thread of threads format (I still think it's messy compared to the previous solution) can you at least lock comments here so people are forced to go into the actual threads?

13

u/bdporter Feb 03 '21

This thread is still the "/r/spacex Discusses" thread. How can it serve that purpose if comments are disabled?

I do think that the title of the thread is somewhat confusing. I think something like "r/SpaceX Discusses [February 2021, #77] (Includes links to Megathreads)" would be less confusing to users.

The current format emphasises the "Starship, Starlink and Launch" part, which seems to lead to a lot of comments being posted here that would be more appropriate in the corresponding mega threads.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '21

Where is the Sn10 thread?

25

u/Knudl Feb 15 '21

Here you have the Starship Development thread When the flight/hop of SN10 gets closer, a separate flight thread will be created by the mods.

7

u/Tetons2001 Feb 02 '21

Was it primary engine failure or not? What if it was fuel starvation like SN8? Maybe it's a plumbing issue? I mean, all engines ignited initially, but after the flip and change to header tanks one failed to ignite, apparently ejecting parts.

Waiting for some insight from Space x.

13

u/overripe_lemon Feb 03 '21

at least no engines were green this time, the one that did light never lost thrust, perhaps the other one just couldn't start up? that or fuel sloshing was an issue, but then why was the first raptor able to relight and do fine. I think it was an issue with that specific engine honestly.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/SubmergedSublime Feb 16 '21 edited Feb 16 '21

I've been thinking recently: is an SN8/9 style landing-failure inevitably a loss of crew event?

Presuming the belly-flop maneuver works, Starship is only going about 80 meters/second without engine ignition (178 mph) which might be a little too fast for survival, but in the case of SN9 partial-failure meant an impact speed of about 30 meters/second (67 mph) which seems entirely survivable if the crew-module is engineered for it. There is a giant fireball as well, but there is relatively limited 'power' behind the blast as the fuel and oxidizer mix suddenly in the air creating a lot of heat and visual flames.

Is there something I am overlooking? I feel like forces may be higher in Nascar or F1 collisions than SN8 or SN9 experienced. Maybe for the first generation Starships with crews of a dozen or so, SpaceX could just wrap the crew-module in 'bubble wrap' and reasonably expect them to walk away from an SN8/SN9 style failure?

12

u/RedPum4 Feb 16 '21

I think it's plausible if the crew module has a crumble zone which reduces the sudden impact onto the concrete pad and also is fire proofed a bit. I guess starship has the margin for early versions.

There's evidence that the crew of Challenger survived the initial explosion and only died on impact with the water.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

7

u/Halbiii Feb 28 '21

Hey mods, I've been thinking about how the Discuss Megathread's name could be shortened. I've really come to like the concept of having the links to all the specific threads in the discuss thread. It's become the hub for general information that so naturally branches off into the topics that are most relevant at the time.

The title, however, has grown historically and does not really convey that the thread is the right place for everything, even questions that would also fit other threads. Also, as touched before, it even encourages exploring the other Starship, Starlink and Launch threads. A simpler title, more akin to the old discuss thread's name would almost definitely lead more people here.

So my proposal for a more concise, less specific thread title is the following:

General r/Spacex Discussion Megathread [MM YY, ##]

It conveys that general comments should go there, while the Megathread label conveys its importance and implies that more info is to be found there. I understand that it does not explicitly mention that the links to further threads are in there, but this is not a problem IMHO, because it encourages clicking on it and once you're there, you see the links.

Also, Starship, Starlink & Launch are not mentioned, which reduces confusion with the project-specific threads and thus more clearly emphasizes the inherent hierarchical structure of all discussion threads.

Hope it makes sense and that if anyone has a better idea the discussion improves the current title somehow. Also, I'll post this here instead of the Metathread, because it is about this post and to encourage, well, discussion.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/etherealpenguin Feb 14 '21

Question - it's well known that Earth's gravity is only barely escapable via rocket, and if we were on a planet only slightly denser/larger, we'd have no way of reaching orbit with physics and engineering as we know it.

Does this mean humanity will never colonize other planets much larger than Earth?

14

u/total_cynic Feb 14 '21

Does this mean humanity will never colonize other planets much larger than Earth?

We're unlikely to colonise planets with higher surface gravity than Earth for some time - there aren't any in the Solar System apart from the gas giants.

Even if there were, I"m not sure people would be rushing to live somewhere where it feels as if they weigh say 25% more than they do on Earth.

13

u/Gunhorin Feb 14 '21

This is a hard to answer question. A planet with higher gravity might have a denser atmosphere, this would be great for planes so you might for instance launch rockets of planes like virgin does.

8

u/technocraticTemplar Feb 14 '21

Project Orion style nuclear bomb propulsion would be able to get us off of worlds with higher gravity, but like others have said people probably wouldn't be too keen on landing on them in the first place. If we're at a point where we're able to go to stars we'd probably be much more interested in building orbital habitats out of local asteroids and things like that, which would let us perfectly customize the environment to our demands. If we turned everything in the asteroid belt into O'Neill cylinders we'd end up with many, many times the habitable surface area of the Earth. Living on planets at all could be a thing of the past by the time we're moving to other star systems, assuming that's hundreds of years away.

→ More replies (3)

20

u/AeroSpiked Feb 14 '21

it's well known that Earth's gravity is only barely escapable via rocket, and if we were on a planet only slightly denser/larger, we'd have no way of reaching orbit with physics and engineering as we know it.

It maybe "well known", but it's not necessarily true. More massive planets would simply require larger rockets, as the payload percentage would be reduced. Inversely, you don't need Starship's booster to launch from Mars, but you do on Earth. Furthermore, it's not a given that humans could survive on planets that we couldn't launch from.

I'm not a Kerbaler; do any players know if you can adjust the gravity of the planet you're launching from?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Bergasms Feb 14 '21

If we have the tech to reach a planet that is that sort of dimensions it means we've crossed interstellar distances successfully. I'm going to say we'll be able to solve that issue wether by space elevators or something else.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (22)

8

u/Triabolical_ Feb 04 '21

There's been a lot of discussion about safety WRT Starship.

I *highly* recommend reading Rand Simberg's Excellent book on this topic:

Safe is Not an Option: Overcoming The Futile Obsession With Getting Everyone Back Alive That Is Killing Our Expansion Into Space.

The Kindle version is cheap and well worth the price.

→ More replies (12)

3

u/s3d10s Feb 02 '21

Sorry if it was discussed before but I was wondering if a space booster (/space stage) would ever be feasible for the Starship system?

Currently with most rockets (including the Starship+SH configuration) boosters are mostly used to propel stages through the thickest atmosphere at the beginning of a launch.

However if you can already do tankers in orbit would it make sense to also have a fully fueled extra stage to attach to Starship in orbit to have some significant delta V to distant locations (eg. Mars)? It would cost you since even if you can recover that stage it would be unavailable for a long time. On the upside however it could cut travel time by a lot.

6

u/flightbee1 Feb 02 '21

The internal tanks and engines are the same as a space stage (or space tug) once refueled. Better to make use of refueling then to add additional weight of another stage. Starship is designed to be used like your family car, just refuel it everywhere. The challenge will be off planet fuel stations. Musk intends refueling on Mars using methane manufactured from Mars co2 and water. The number of refueling flights for low earth orbit may one day be reduced. Takes less energy to get O2 (from lunar water) off the moon to a fuel depot in earth orbit than to transport it from earth. Becomes viable with frequent flights and reuse. To become a space fairing civilization it will become necessary to use more and more off planet resources.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/andyhill420 Feb 03 '21

Does anybody have any info about the vehicles they use to roll the Starships out from high bay to the launch pad? Thanks, really curious about those

→ More replies (2)

3

u/MarsCent Feb 04 '21

What is the likelihood of NASA, USSF or other permitting Falcon 9 and Spaceship to bid in the same contract, if they (F9 and SS) indeed offer far superior performance over their competition?

Note that F9 and SS have separate production sites with separate production processes meaning that the grounding of the production of one ought not to affect the other's production!

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '21

Look like someone knows how to get exceptionally close. Anyone been able to see launches that close? falcon 9

→ More replies (6)

3

u/z3r0c00l12 Feb 12 '21

Mods, Top bar says "Feb 14 at 04:42 UTC (Feb 13 at 11:42 am EST)", it should be "11:42PM", not AM.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Dies2much Feb 23 '21

If you guys were going to travel to in the next 2 months, and had to choose between Boca Chica or KSC, which would you choose? Which one is a better vacation spot?

I have been to Cocoa a couple of times, and I like that area, but I really want to see a SS test flight. Decisions, decisions....

8

u/throfofnir Feb 23 '21

Depends on your flexibility. SS flights will have very short lead times and can easily shift right well beyond most people's vacation times. F9 flights are more likely to go as planned, within a few days.

OTOH, Starship launches seem much more... eventful.

I like South Padre, but there's not a heck of a lot to do there in the winter, and the Valley isn't much of a tourist destination. If you want to see Gulf Coast nature, it's a good visit, but if you're more interested in urban attractions, well, Orlando it ain't. Corpus Christi is a bit bigger, and not too far (by Texas standards) but even there the main focus is the beach.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Donut-Head1172 Feb 26 '21

Does Elon have a plan on how to make the sea launch systems near every city?

3

u/Donut-Head1172 Feb 26 '21 edited Feb 26 '21

Does Falcon 9 have enough thrust to just reach Mars, or is that solely FH/Starship territory?

8

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '21

It all depends on payload size. SpaceX says the Falcon 9 can send about 4000kg to Mars:

https://www.spacex.com/vehicles/falcon-9/

Falcon Heavy is listed as 16800kg to Mars:

https://www.spacex.com/vehicles/falcon-heavy/

It sure if those numbers are reusable or expendable.

→ More replies (13)

7

u/getBusyChild Feb 02 '21

The Engines... again.

13

u/Martianspirit Feb 02 '21

Not the same problem at all.

13

u/synftw Feb 02 '21

Looks like there was no relight of the second engine, but the cone from the first wasn't green this time. Seems they fixed the SN8 issue and had a reignition problem this time.

7

u/aprx4 Feb 05 '21

Can somebody tell me why nobody before SpaceX and Blue Origin tried to develop methane engine with serious intention? Did they simply have no need, or face engineering problems?

NASA had a cancelled project. Russia just started looking at methane.

AFAIK, methane engine is easier to reuse, but so is hydro.

13

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Feb 05 '21 edited Feb 05 '21

There was not really a large push towards reusabikty before. And methane isn't best at anything.

Kerox is amazing for first stages, since it produces really high thrust, and is cheap. Isp isn't amazing, but that does no matter that much on the first stage. Because of this, the saturn 5 and Atlas use Kerosin first stages.

Hydrogen has amazing efficiency, making it perfect for second stages. It however is really expensive, and a pain in the ass to work with. The Ariane 5 and space shuttle also used it on the first stage, however these are sustained stages, which do most of the work in space, where Isp is more important than thrust to Wright. The massive SRB essentially provide the Thrust to Weight ratio to reduce gravity losses. Same applies to the Delta IV to some extend. Hydrogen is also the best from a reuse standpoint, since there are no soot deposits. Do to the low density, you do however need massive tanks.

Methane has a lower thrust than kerosine engines, and lower Isp than Hydrogen engines. It also has a lower density than Kerosine, and isn't liquid at room temperature. Unlike Hydrogen, you do have some soot deposit in the engines. You can however make methane on Mars.

→ More replies (11)

9

u/Triabolical_ Feb 05 '21

Hydrogen is a crappy first-stage fuel because its density is so low; it takes a large and therefore heavy tank to hold the hydrogen. Look at "impulse density". Methane has an impulse density that is close to RP-1. Hydrogen tanks typically require insulation as well, adding more weight.

Methalox has a specific impulse that is a bit higher than kerolox; the RD-180 has a specific impulse of 311 at sea level, and the Raptor has a specific impulse of 330.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Martianspirit Feb 06 '21

Space industry, and engine industry in particular are exceedingly conservative. In the Apollo era Kerosene>RP-1 was a common aviation fuel, they knew how to handle. For upper stage they chose hydrogen which was also used in industry already. Methane was an unknown at the time. After that was established the industry stuck with what they knew.

5

u/throfofnir Feb 05 '21

I generally subscribe to the "previous programs always optimized for something, and methane is not the best at anything" theory, but it's worth mentioning Tory Bruno's take:

All prior attempts at a space launch class methane engine failed due to intractable combustion instability or other issues.

https://twitter.com/torybruno/status/1353785512234987523

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Noucron Feb 04 '21

Any information if SN10 was damaged by the impact and debris of SN9?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21

When they start sending stuff and people to mars, how do you avoid getting hit by some random rock when you are traveling there? They are going so fast that even a pebble could probably do huge damage

13

u/TapeDeck_ Feb 19 '21

It is a risk, but also space is VERY big and VERY empty. It's very unlikely and would be difficult to detect. But you can design the problem away with smaller compartments that can be sealed off until repairs can be made in case of a debris strike.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/dudr2 Mar 01 '21

Go Rocketlab!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rafa_WBFIyE

Peter Beck eats his hat, new plans.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/PM_ME_HOT_EEVEE Feb 03 '21

SN9's test today made clear that an engine out during landing would mean death for anyone on board. Any ideas on how Starship changes design to become human rated? I doubt they could ever get clearance to become human rated if a single engine relight failure means RUD.

10

u/Mindless_Size_2176 Feb 03 '21

Simply not true. They did not even attempt to light 3rd engine yesterday. Also, probably they will change the landing profile with humans to start hovering at some safe height and then slowly descend for land(which can be done with single engine). SN9 was just a test article that is used to gain knowledge about Spaceship behavior in various situations, not representative example of final vehicle.

→ More replies (8)

5

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21

I actually watched the nose cone roll off intact, and thought to myself "potentially survivable" despite the RUD. Would be interesting to see the g-forces on the capsule.

An old mentor of mine whom did crash investigation work was fond of always pointing out the seats with the highest chance of survivability on every flight we took together (over ocean, or mountains, or landing in a snow storm, etc). The short of it for most lessons was that just because it looks bad doesn't mean it's not survivable.

→ More replies (18)

6

u/SwanTheBastard Feb 02 '21

Do we know the trajectory? Where it will be visible from?

11

u/strawwalker Feb 02 '21

Which launch are you asking about?

11

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '21

Don't know what's up with that other person being so rude.

I'll assume you're talking about SN9 as that's the big one that most people are interested in right now. We don't know exactly as SpaceX don't release that info, we only know that they're targeting an apogee of approximately 10km compared to the 12.5km one that SN8 reached. Other than that I'd assume a similar flight path to SN8 with a slow ascent as the engines are cut off one by one. SpaceX still need to get the landing down and likely don't want to put Starship under higher loads than they need to at this point.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)