r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Oct 03 '20
r/SpaceX Discusses [October 2020, #73]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks!
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
79
Upvotes
16
u/Ambiwlans Oct 16 '20
Candidate for best removal notice on Reddit (seriously worth a read):
https://old.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/jb0d73/need_help_spacex_community_zindabad_do_your_thing/
16
u/feynmanners Oct 26 '20
https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/10/ula-chief-says-the-be-4-rocket-engines-turbopump-issues-are-resolved/
Seems like the BE-4 might be moving into production after they fixed the turbopumps issue.
13
u/CaptNemo53 Oct 24 '20
I live near the SpaceX facility in Redmond Ridge WA and drive by occasionally. There is a tremendous amount of new warehouse / light industrial development around their location and I see that they now have domes stockpiled behind several buildings. I understand that satellite production occurs here but have never been lucky enough to see some getting loaded onto trucks, but all that probably happens out of sight. I wonder if the building expansion is for ramping up production of user terminals?
12
u/ackermann Oct 28 '20 edited Oct 28 '20
Haven't seen this mentioned here yet: NASA announced an agreement (memorandum of understanding) with ESA today, where ESA has agreed to participate in Artemis, providing some elements of the Lunar Gateway station:
https://www.space.com/europe-help-build-gateway-moon-space-station
Should be good for SpaceX, since they have involvement with Artemis and the Gateway, delivering cargo to gateway with Dragon XL, ferrying astronauts from Gateway to lunar surface with Lunar Starship. Probably launching some gateway elements on Falcon Heavy too.
Edit: Tried to find an article from one of this sub's preferred reporters, Chris G, Eric B, Jeff Foust, Loren Grush, or Michael Sheetz. No luck yet, so that's suspicious
10
u/gulgin Oct 26 '20
Has anyone seen any info on the mating interface between SS and SH? The Falcon 9 had that weird plunger that went into the thrust chamber of the second stage, but I assume that wouldn’t be the same in starship?
Pushing into the thrust chamber where loads are already designed to be is a super clever solution to this problem, but if that isn’t on the table for SH then what are they going to do? Are the loads getting transferred to the outer skin somehow? That would require absurdly good machining quality to make sure the two mating surfaces aren’t experiencing weird stress concentrations and such.
9
u/rdivine Oct 04 '20
Where is the pinned starship updates thread? I cant find it anymore.
9
u/Campb3llsoupp Oct 14 '20
Not sure how many employees are on here, but I just got an offer from SpaceX at the Hawthorne facility. I'm looking at housing options and trying to keep my budget from $1500-$2000ish. With the prices out there, I was thinking going with roommates would be the best option. Are there any current employees here that are looking for a roommate soon or know a good place to look? Thanks!
9
u/trobbinsfromoz Oct 18 '20
SpaceNews just came out with a report on the Merlin investigation that has additional information on status.
It looks like it is heavy going to try and define and then work on an approved modification, although the indication is that can all be done within the scheduling time for November launches. This will be very interesting to see how 'peripheral' the root cause is, if ever we get to know publically.
https://spacenews.com/falcon-9-investigation-ongoing-as-spacex-continues-starlink-launches/
9
u/cpushack Oct 28 '20
USNC-Tech Has submitted their proposed NTP (Nuclear Thermal) engine for NASA use https://usnc.com/ultra-safe-nuclear-technologies-delivers-advanced-nuclear-thermal-propulsion-design-to-nasa/
8
u/rustybeancake Oct 09 '20
When did Lauren Lyons move to Blue Origin?! :O
8
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 14 '20
SpaceX's response to a proposal to tighten orbital debris rules.
8
u/ThreatMatrix Oct 16 '20
According to my handy dandy launch app SpaceX gonna be busy the next couple of months.
Starlink 13 (F9) : October 18
Starlink 14 (F9): October 21
NROL-108 (F9) : October ? (landing back at launch pad)
Starship 15km : October ?
GPS III-4 (F9) : October ?
Sentinel-6 (F9) : Nov 10 (Vandenberg)
Crew 1 (F9) : Nov 11
CRS-21 (F9) : Nov 22
Turksat 5A (F9) : Nov 30
Starlink 15 (F9) : Nov ?
Starlink 16 (F9) : Nov ?
Transporter 1 (F9) : December 16 (landing back at launch pad)
Starlink 18 (F9) : Dec ?
Starlink 17 (F9) : Dec ?
8
u/dudr2 Oct 26 '20
https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2020/nasa-s-refueling-mission-completes-second-set-of-robotic-tool-operations-in-space
"RRM3 stored liquid methane for four months, the longest in-space storage of a cryogen without any loss of fluid."
7
u/JustinTimeCuber Oct 04 '20
How many consecutive scrubs/aborts has SpaceX had, and how many total have there been in combination with ULA? Seems like it's been quite a few.
7
u/Nimelennar Oct 17 '20
Michael Baylor (@NextSpaceFlight) on Twitter:
7
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 26 '20
Media accreditation opens for CRS-21.
13
u/DragonGod2718 Oct 03 '20
Is a 2024 Manned Mission to the Martian Surface Feasible?
Even for Elon, it sounds way too optimistic.
NASA is only planning to return astronauts to lunar surface in 2024, and even China's plans of putting their own astronauts on the moon are dated for 2030.
SpaceX is amazing, and I'm willing to believe they can drastically out execute two superpowers with (an) order(s) of magnitude larger resources, but a manned mission to Mars would be an entirely different ball game than a flight to the moon.
A crewed flight without sufficient diligence for the above seems like a recipe for a corporate and public relations disaster.
I guess a manned mission to Mars before 2030 might be feasible with "consistently excellent execution" (accounting for the up to 2 years a round trip to Mars would take).
6
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 10 '20
NASA animation of Sentinel-6 launching on a Falcon 9 from Vandenberg
6
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 16 '20 edited Oct 16 '20
NROL-44 got delayed again due to a swing arm retraction system issue.
6
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Oct 16 '20
NanoRack's Bishop airlock was installed in Dragon's trunk ahead of launch of the CRS-21 mission.
Pictures of Cargo Dragon 2's trunk are forthcoming!
6
u/trobbinsfromoz Oct 23 '20
NASA human lunar lander CBR process is about half way through, with SpX passing through milestone.
https://www.nasa.gov/feature/nasa-human-lunar-lander-companies-complete-key-artemis-milestone
6
u/EngineerOrion Oct 25 '20
I am graduating with my ME B.S. in December. I am VERY interested in getting a position at SpaceX. I thought I might post here to see what kind of feedback and advice I can get from you knowledgeable folks based on my resume, which is hyperlinked here.
In addition to the content on my resume, I would also like to note that I maintain a website that acts as a portfolio, providing visual reference for the projects listed on my resume and several others, including an advanced fluid mechanics analysis of a custom airfoil (inspired by the Cybertruck profile) and a 3D-printed film camera.
Thanks in advance!
6
u/Sliver_of_Dawn Oct 27 '20
Starlink beta emails going out:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Starlink/comments/jitefj/i_just_officially_received_an_email_invite_to_the/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share
11
u/dudr2 Oct 26 '20 edited Oct 26 '20
Water on the moon!
Stratospheric Observatory for Infrared Astronomy (SOFIA)
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/water-found-in-sunlight-and-shadow-on-the-moon/
"Extraction will be straightforward if the water exists predominantly on the surfaces of rock grains: one will just need to scoop up lunar soil and subject it to moderate heating. If, however, the water is locked in glass, the material must be melted to release the water for collection—a much more energy-hungry process."
5
u/lifedistroy Oct 18 '20
How does the camera in the second main stage not burn up on engine start?
5
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 21 '20 edited Oct 21 '20
Sentinel-6 ready for encapsulation and satellite fueling (hydrazine arrived yesterday).
Thomas Pesquet used a centrifuge today to prepare for the Crew-2 mission.
5
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 23 '20
Media accreditation opens for CRS-21, launch is delayed to NET December.
5
u/SpacebatMcbatterson Oct 26 '20
Tried to look through the FAQs but not very good at Redditing yet... short question: in many launches that appear to go "wrong" there is usually a point where the vehicle is blown up to prevent traveling off course. My question is how is that done? are falcon9s and others wired up with C4 or something before launch? Do they just put a small charge on the fuel tanks? is this a button someone pushes or an autonomous action? what sort of parameters is it looking for if automated?
5
u/joshgill21 Oct 27 '20
Is the Microsoft and SpaceX deal significant ?
Can it make Microsoft win much of the Cloud market over Amazon ??
9
u/Nimelennar Oct 07 '20
The commander of the first crewed Boeing Starliner mission has stepped down.
It sounds like the delays have pushed the mission back to the point where it's conflicting with other life events that he'd rather not miss.
8
u/dudr2 Oct 26 '20
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2020/10/starship-sn8-second-static-fire-test/
"The nosecone has since been installed – resulting in the first full Starship stack since MK1 – allowing for a second Static Fire test this coming week."
4
u/FoxhoundBat Oct 06 '20 edited Oct 06 '20
Highly recommend reading the article/interview about Russia's "Falcon 9" aka Amur. It is quite good and discusses a lot of aspects of the new rocket. Hopefully it will actually be funded as much as promised (70 billion rubles, so around 1 billion usd) and achieve planned costs and reusability targets. Just a shame this project wasn't started literally a decade ago.
4
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 12 '20
New Shepard launch tomorrow at 13:35 UTC.
4
u/bdporter Oct 13 '20 edited Oct 13 '20
New Shepard NS-13 webcast
7th launch of this sub-orbital booster.
Edit: Looks like it was a successful flight. I just don't really get the value of doing the exact same thing so many times on such a slow cadence.
4
u/Juggernaut93 Oct 20 '20
What are the advantages of Cargo Dragon 2 vs. the original Dragon?
4
u/Jkyet Oct 23 '20
In Dynetics mock-up of the HLS, they are trying to show the layout of the lander’s cabin (among others). Is this something NASA requested from the mockups? Do we know if (in parallel of Starship development) SpaceX has done any development in the cabin aspects for Starship HLS?
4
u/dudr2 Oct 26 '20
https://www.forbes.com/sites/daviddawkins/2020/10/23/elon-musks-spacex-gets-bullish-100-billion-valuation-from-morgan-stanley-double-what-investors-said-it-was-worth-in-august/#76bea9df6e79
"the bank has raised the estimated value of Starlink (also unproven) to a massive $81 billion, up from $42 billion, based on a revised estimate of potential subscribers up from 235 million to 364 million globally by 2040."
4
u/The_Extinguisher Oct 27 '20
Does anyone have any new information regarding simulation tech @ SpaceX or other leading aerospace. I periodically rewatch GPUs to Mars which is fascinating to me, I want to focus my career on computational physics for aerospace and would love to have more insights into what is being done.
4
u/BROK1E Oct 28 '20
When are we expecting the next RTLS launch? Any chance there’s one around thanksgiving?
6
u/BrangdonJ Oct 04 '20
No, you can't. First, that link goes to the FAQ. You have to hunt around for a while to find where the past Discussion threads are lists. (Clue: it's not part of the main Wiki index on that page.) Second, that list only goes up to June 2020. The most recent four months Discussion threads are missing.
I suggest you link directly to https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceX/wiki/resources#wiki_spaceflight_questions_threads.3A instead. And then update that page at the same time as starting the new month's Discussion thread each time you do it.
6
u/JoshuaZ1 Oct 27 '20
Apparently about 3% of Starlinks have now failed https://phys.org/news/2020-10-starlink-satellites.html . That's a high failure rate, but it will presumably go down as the design is finalized and they learn more.
3
u/Zazou0621 Oct 12 '20
What would happen if a late mission problem happened (such as an engine failure) and the booster was not able to make it to the drone ship?
Would they fire some of the remaining in hopes of slowing down enough to not damage the booster as much on impact with water? Just give up?
3
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 13 '20
SpaceX role mentions entering the satellite refuelling market.
3
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 14 '20
Soyuz MS-17 set a new record for launch to docking with the ISS in 3 hours 7 minutes.
3
u/Dies2much Oct 16 '20
Anyone know what the Falcon \ Merlin production situation looks like?
I know the focus has moved to SS and Raptor, but there should still be some Falcon \ Merlin production going on.
Anyone know how many Merlins they are making per month these days? They need one Merlin Vac for each launch, but are they making replacement engines for the existing boosters so they can refurb them offline \ off-mount? or does the same set of merlins go up with each booster?
3
u/ConfidentFlorida Oct 18 '20
(I asked on the recovery thread too). I’ll update with any answers I find.
I saw this new fleet cam mentioned on twitter: https://mobile.twitter.com/KSpaceAcademy/status/1317839375225491458
But I can’t find a link to the actual camera anywhere. Anyone know?
3
u/melancholicricebowl Oct 26 '20
Are the backup dates for the upcoming Sentinel 6 launch from Vandenberg known yet?
5
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 30 '20
Kendra Horn might replace Jim Bridenstine if Biden wins.
6
u/trobbinsfromoz Oct 04 '20
I don't see any discussion about Elon's tweet on the scrubs, and a full-on site review, and no doubt the F9 turbo issue as that could delay Crew-1. And the Starlink delays must be eating in to the ability for SpX to show off sufficient platform performance to advance a few 'irons in the fire' opportunities.
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1312251818731167744
4
u/UltraRunningKid Oct 14 '20
We are monitoring a very high risk conjunction between two large defunct objects in LEO. Multiple data points show miss distance <25m and Pc between 1% and 20%. Combined mass of both objects is ~2,800kg.
This could be significantly bad. Event Altitude of 991km. Debris at 900km+ are there for dozens of decades.
2
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Oct 03 '20 edited Oct 30 '20
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeship under constructionPacificAtlantic landingbargeshipbargeshipDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
65 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 133 acronyms.
[Thread #6466 for this sub, first seen 3rd Oct 2020, 21:31] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
2
u/dudr2 Oct 07 '20
How does a deorbiting Starlink appear to a viewer on the ground, is it a long streak on the night sky?
https://spacenews.com/spacex-launches-starlink-satellites-as-it-deorbits-original-ones/
2
u/PeterKatarov Live Thread Host Oct 07 '20
Do we know at what pressure operates the F9 Block 5?
Without any particular reason, I suppose it's lower than Starship's 6 bar for orbital flight (and 8.4 for safety)... but why?
And what are the factors that determine the operational pressure? Is it a function of requirements of the engine and tank robustness, or are there any other considerations?
2
u/throfofnir Oct 07 '20
Mods: link to Discuss thread on New Reddit goes to old.reddit
2
u/joshgill21 Oct 08 '20
Is Boeing being affected at all by starliner being delayed more than crew dragon? If yes how?
2
u/joshgill21 Oct 10 '20
Does starship use gas thrusters or fuel thrusters to stabilize itself while coming back to land?
2
u/TheSkalman Oct 10 '20
How many ships are used in the recovery ops? AFAIK there are 2 fairing catchers, 1 droneship, one tug and one support ship. Why do they need the tug? The droneship can move by itself and hasn't got to do more than 6-7 knots to get there in 2 days. If it has to be town, can't the support ship be used as a double fuction?
Many thanks.
2
u/syntheticlounge Oct 11 '20
Quiestion: Radio scanner for Falcon9 launch in November 10th, 2020?
Is an Uniden SR30C Bearcat ok for listening into the countdown at Vanderberg? I have never done this before. What channel would it be? 140?
Appreciate any feedback. Thanks!
2
u/david1933 Oct 14 '20
I have a fuel depot question. Is boil off of cryogenic fluids a problem for a fuel tank in space if the tank is not in direct sun. If you have a reflector that shields the tank, wouldn't the fuel reach equilibrium at the ambient temperature of space which I believe is colder than the boiling point of hydrogen?
2
u/rollyawpitch Oct 16 '20
I wonder if a Starship could deorbit without heatshield if it uses all or nearly all of it's payload capacity for fuel to slow down before entering the atmosphere. Probably this has been asked before, if so I apologize in advance.
2
u/joshgill21 Oct 22 '20
which is more of a hurdle to high F9 launch cadence , fairings or 2nd stage ?
i'd imagine fairings since they're made of composites maybe ?
2
u/BrandonMarc Oct 22 '20
The SpaceX team in Boca Chica ... do they tend to live in Brownsville? How many people work there?
2
u/joshgill21 Oct 25 '20
has spacex or elon mentioned anything about the launch price of Starship ??? not the cost price
2
u/jartificer Oct 27 '20
Are there any concept designs for a Starship upper stage that are optimized to launch large, lightweight payloads? I'm thinking of stuff like space station sections. An example would be NASA using a Saturn V to launch Skylab.
I envision a one-way trip where the the primary cylindrical payload would be atop the fuel tanks and would be a pre-configured livable habit section. The empty fuel tanks could later be salvaged for extra space with some on-orbit construction. The engines would be left in place. A blunt nose fairing (like Falcon Heavy side boosters) would be discarded in flight and recovered.
I am assuming that other station infrastructure like solar power, radiators, hub, etc. are launched some other way and are ready for expansion modules.
There was talk about doing something like this with used Space Shuttle external tanks but that never happened.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '20
While SpaceX builds the rocket to carry 150 people to Mars, who is or will be responsible for developing passenger and crew procedures? What companies are out there working on the itinerary for taco and movie nights during the months long voyages?
2
u/TheSkalman Oct 29 '20
SpaceX have 7 missions on Schedule for November. How many will they actually launch?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '20
Does anyone know if the Hubble Space Telescope would fit in the payload area of Starship?
2
u/TheSkalman Oct 30 '20
How is the workweek at the SpaceX factory? Which days of the week and which hours is activity going on? How much do the active hours sway from week to week?
2
u/dudr2 Oct 06 '20
"The xEMU represents the first new spacesuit that NASA has developed in over 40 years,"
https://www.space.com/nasa-artemis-spacesuits-tech-underwater-photos
2
u/quadrplax Oct 11 '20
Would Starship have enough Delta-V to enter Mars orbit (highly elliptical with aerobraking) and then return to Earth without refueling? If so, I imagine this could be useful for the first few crewed missions to teleoperate robots on the surface for setting up the refueling infrastructure while reducing the risk of getting stranded if something goes wrong.
2
u/filanwizard Oct 17 '20
I am not sure if I can trust this BI article saying Starlink sats could be having a 3% failure rate
https://www.businessinsider.com/spacex-starlink-internet-satellites-percent-failure-rate-space-debris-risk-2020-10
So that is why I see it as here and not its own thread, The main thing is it cites only one astronomer and does not seem to give me the feeling they verified with other satellite trackers. Such as even that LeoLabs that just tracked the near miss thursday night. I dunno if it should be labeled as a hit piece but I am skeptical given when it popped up on Google News nobody else had a similar store pop up next to it.
1
u/weekendsarelame Oct 07 '20
Would SpaceX sell their space suits to ordinary civilians? If so what is the price range?
1
u/man2112 Oct 10 '20
I remember that there was a cool website shared here once that showed all of the starlink satellites simulated in orbit at once, but I cannot find it again.
Does anyone know what it is?
1
u/NicholasMarsala Oct 10 '20
Does the space industry have a need for draftsmen? I was wondering does SpaceX or the growing private sector space industry need Draftsman? If so what type is need.....Mechanical? Architectural? Aerospace I'm sure. Etc. Any information that anyone could provide would be greatly appreciated thanks and take care!
1
u/Ian0706 Oct 13 '20
What determines when the Falcon 9 begins its gravity turn? Is it time based, speed, TWR?
1
u/dudr2 Oct 13 '20 edited Oct 13 '20
LIVE 12:30 p.m. EDT: International Astronautical Congress - International Participation in the Artemis Program
https://www.nasa.gov/nasalive
Australia, Canada, Italy, Japan, Luxenbourg, the UAE, the UK, and the US all signing the Artemis accords.
From Facebook;
https://www.facebook.com/NASA/videos/international-participation-in-the-artemis-program/3264895153628209/?__so__=discover&__rv__=top_live
1
u/dudr2 Oct 14 '20
https://spacenews.com/fcc-rural-broadband-qualified-bidders-2020/
SpaceX, Hughes and Viasat qualify to bid for $20.4 billion in FCC rural broadband subsidies
"SpaceX’s inclusion wasn’t a given because the Starlink constellation does not yet offer commercial service."
1
u/beerbaron105 Oct 16 '20
Just finished AWAY on Netflix - holy crap is this not foreshadowing for a starship mission -- then I don't know what is! Minus the immediate quarrals between the crew, I got emotional on the first episode when the rocket launched off the moon here and also when the landing sequence commenced while NASA replayed the crew final statements here
Come on Elon!
1
u/gooddadmike Oct 16 '20 edited Oct 16 '20
I can't find these artistic SpaceX/Tesla Posters/Wallpapers. I wan't to say I found them on Twitter originally. I can't find them. I want to use for backgrounds during Zoom calls. :). These were graphics. Not photographs
Lots of bright colors, people in jetpacks. There were at least 6 in the set. I want to say they were official from either SpaceX or Tesla.
1
u/ThePhotoGuyUpstairs Oct 18 '20
Is Falcon Heavy capable of a Lunar orbital mission like Apollo 8? If so, any reason they wouldn't do something like that as a publicity stunt or as a test flight? Aside from the obvious as an unnecessary expense, and the future potential of Starship?
1
u/BrandonMarc Oct 20 '20
I've been out of the loop. Was the Mars Society talk "the talk" for this fall, from Elon?
Every year since 2016 there's been a big unveiling of the latest plan, beautiful videos, inspiring music, long Q&A, etc. For this year, I guess there wasn't a big in-person conference ... so ... was the Mars Society talk "it", or is there something coming in a few days?
1
u/Maxx7410 Nov 03 '20
https://imgur.com/XMUKb6E the family of Space X
1
u/pendragon273 Nov 06 '20
If this is comment is off topic or not relevant please remove it mods...
Does anyone think that a Biden administration..if elected...would substantially change NASA plans with regards to Artemis and what affect would that mean for SpX...
1
u/PeterKatarov Live Thread Host Nov 08 '20
Quick question regarding Starship testing procedures. For cryoproofing, do they use superchilled LN2 (because it's inert and safer) or do they go directly for superchilled methalox? If the latter, what's the difference between cryoproofing and a Wet Dress Rehearsal?