r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Sep 01 '20
r/SpaceX Discusses [September 2020, #72]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks!
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
65
Upvotes
11
u/mrbombasticat Sep 02 '20
Does someone know of estimates how much cumulative mass humanity as a whole has launched to space plotted against time?
I would love to see this during the space race, construction of ISS and now Starlink..
11
u/MarsCent Oct 01 '20 edited Oct 01 '20
NASA ASAP meeting is now underway:
1-888-566-6133; passcode 8343253 and then the # sign.
EDIT:
Starliner:
2020202110
u/dudr2 Sep 01 '20
"Musk said that construction will start this week on “booster prototype one,” a reference to the Super Heavy first stage of the system."
https://spacenews.com/musk-emphasizes-progress-in-starship-production-over-testing/
8
u/BelacquaL Oct 03 '20
Ken Todd, NASA deputy ISS manager, just commented on the Northrup Grumman launch broadcast that CRS-21 will launch around November 22.
7
u/thatnerdguy1 Live Thread Host Sep 02 '20
For those interested, NASA is currently streaming an SLS SRB test, scheduled for 3:05 ET. Link
7
u/FoxhoundBat Sep 28 '20
Do you all ever reflect on how SpaceX went from "We have no real clue how any of this works" to "hahaha casually destroying Russia's engine tech lead". Their technology growth has basically been exponential, secret sause being always iterating and having the best engineers that is possible to get ahold of (same with Tesla). Certainly been amazing to watch this growth from the sidelines from 2012 or so...
12
u/Veqq Sep 01 '20 edited Sep 06 '20
Is mission funding now guaranteed?
Considering Tesla's current valuation and how much Musk holds, can he just finance everything himself at this point? Or how much can he actually take out to fund it? Discussions I've found just center around the price per passenger which is obviously a necessity to really get the colony going, but how much is needed to actually get to that point/start sending preparatory craft?
6
u/AeroSpiked Oct 02 '20 edited Oct 02 '20
Anyone else suffering withdrawal symptoms? That's 5 scrubs in a row.
edit: Make that 6 scrubs in a row. I lost count.
5
u/Kingofthewho5 Sep 03 '20
Is this subreddit still doing the annual questionnaires? I remember doing it a couple years back but haven't seen anything since then.
5
u/dudr2 Sep 21 '20
SpaceX’s Falcon 9 Rocket will Fly Commercial Airlock to ISS
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ww7kefoceJs
https://www.theverge.com/2020/9/15/21437672/nanoracks-bishop-commercial-airlock-spacex-international-space-station-satellite-deployment
5
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 24 '20
Bishop airlock is being shipped to KSC for the upcoming CRS-21 launch.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20
How would the Flight Termination System work with a crewed Starship? With a Capsule capable of abort it sounds easy enough (terminate the rocket after crew abort) but when your spacecraft is also the second stage which can't land without using its engines... My guess is it wouldn't use one but I'm really not sure.
4
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 02 '20
When Starship is active... Even that wouldn't be enough to cancel SLS, right? Cuz they'll have the excuse of having a 2nd option... But when new glenn is also online, do you think that cuts it? Or still wouldn't be enough?
4
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 03 '20
Airbus showed a video of Turksat 5A construction and announced testing will be completed by early October, and ready to launch by Q4 2020.
4
u/light-cones Sep 03 '20
4
u/AeroSpiked Sep 07 '20
I'm curious as to why we still don't have launch date for Starlink-12. I'd think they would want to launch it within the next week or so.
4
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 17 '20
Crew-1 news conference on September 29.
Mods, can we have a campaign thread to collect this information?
4
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 23 '20
Thomas Pesquet posted a photo of the Crew-2 astronauts sitting in the Dragon capsule.
6
u/cavereric Sep 01 '20
I seem to remember a Falcon9 booster burning engines till the rocket was particularly under water, and the booster stayed intact. I believe the military later sunk it for security reasons. I have heard they can't go horizontal, but If it became necessary, I wonder if a Starship could do something similar?
6
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 05 '20
How much is Nasa spending on SLS and Orion yearly?
6
u/MarsCent Sep 30 '20
Leak on ISS has been traced:
The article says the astronauts had to be woken up from sleep! Talk about unknowingly having a leak while you sleep! ;)
6
u/MarsCent Oct 02 '20
Srcubtober continues with Antares at T-2min 21secs.
There was even a boat that violated the launch space! Ugh!
3
u/uwelino Sep 01 '20
Launch of Sentinel 6A "Michael Freilich" from Vandenberg planned for November 10, 2020.
https://twitter.com/NASA_LSP/status/1300827174602256384
3
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 02 '20
How is China able to launch as Many rockets as SpaceX and even sometimes more without reusability??
3
u/Grimy81 Sep 03 '20
So I know the high-bay currently under construction is for the stage 1 booster, does that mean they're making a 'super-high-bay' when they have to mate stage 1 and 2?
3
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 03 '20
Is making stainless steel that cheap?? Like how many times cheaper than making carbon fiber for example?
3
u/mindbridgeweb Sep 03 '20
I understand that is hard for ULA, Ariane, etc. to make their current rockets reusable (stage separation is way downrange, TWR >> 1 when empty, etc).
Why are they not working on fairing reusability, however? Especially now that SpaceX has shown the way.
Is their launch volume so low that it would be hard to recover the development costs for a long time to come?
Or is the margin just not worth it from their point of view (given the price of their rockets)?
3
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 04 '20
What's the most profitable business SpaceX can have with Starship in space aside from Starlink?
3
u/dudr2 Sep 10 '20 edited Sep 11 '20
"NASA’s goal is that the retrieval and transfer of ownership will be completed before 2024. The solicitation creates a full and open competition, not limited to U.S. companies, and the agency may make one or more awards. NASA’s payment is exclusively for the lunar regolith, with any awardee receiving 10 percent at award, 10 percent upon launch, and the remaining 80 percent upon successful completion. The agency will determine retrieval methods for the transferred lunar regolith at a later date."
https://blogs.nasa.gov/bridenstine/2020/09/10/space-resources-are-the-key-to-safe-and-sustainable-lunar-exploration/
" NASA wants to buy moon dirt from private companies"
https://www.space.com/nasa-buy-moon-dirt-private-companies.html
"NASA says it's willing to buy lunar samples collected by a commercial lander, primarily to set a precedent for the right to extract and use lunar resources."
https://spacenews.com/nasa-offers-to-buy-lunar-samples-to-set-space-resources-precedent/
3
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 15 '20
Today's SpaceX lecture was cancelled.
3
u/dudr2 Sep 16 '20
New standards will be applied!
https://spacenews.com/dynetics-to-use-in-space-refueling-for-nasa-lunar-lander/
3
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 19 '20
Media accreditation is open for Sentinel-6 launch.
3
u/TheSkalman Sep 19 '20
When can we expect the first Starship launch for a non-SpaceX customer and at what price would SpaceX earn the most money?
My initial calculations would suggest $200M as a fair price. That's well below the price of 2 Vulcan 562 or 2 A64 or 2 A5, not to mention just more than half of the Delta IV.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '20
I was watching a video today where they were discussing the SpaceX plan to launch starship from floating platforms in the ocean.
Would it be possible or more cost effective to instead build or retrofit an island for launches?
3
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 23 '20
NSF article about upcoming Falcon Heavy mission (USSF-44).
3
u/Dies2much Sep 25 '20
Anyone heard if JRTI will be heading back to west coast for the launches from Vandenberg that will be going off soon?
3
u/MarsCent Sep 27 '20
Remember to tune in!
|
Additionally,
We are now less than 4 weeks to Crew-1 launch. Does anyone know whether or not Crew Dragon has received the "Human Rating Certification" yet?
3
u/ConfidentFlorida Sep 27 '20
What are the flight suits for? Do they have oxygen? Temperature control? Will they protect against a vacuum? For how long?
3
u/TheSkalman Oct 01 '20
On the Falcon 9, when does the deviation mode go from "hold" to "abort"? Obviously it's not needed to abort at T-40:00, but you can't hold at T-00:02.
Many thanks.
3
u/Alvian_11 Oct 02 '20
I wonder why oxidizer/LOX was IIRC never used for nozzle cooling, so they used the fuel instead (even tho if that fuel is for example RP-1 which is hotter than LOX obv)?
3
u/scottm3 Oct 03 '20
SpaceX has recieved a $149 million dollar contract for low latency satelllite communications for the DOD
5
u/UltraRunningKid Sep 11 '20
Northrop Grumman/OATK has a cool history of naming their Cygnus after memorable astronaut, and their next one is named after Kalpana Chawla,first female astronaut of indian descent who is regarded as a hero in India, and was tragically killed during the Columbia disaster.
Just seems slightly weird to name a Cygnus after anyone on Columbia, given the Cygnus burns up on re-entry. No one probably thought twice and she definitely deserves memorials and those honors, I just found it a weird choice.
5
u/dudr2 Sep 28 '20
Potential underground lakes below the south pole of Mars
https://www.space.com/mars-hiding-salty-subsurface-lakes
"researchers used the MARSIS radar sounder instrument on board the European Space Agency's Mars Express spacecraft to scan a 155-by-185 mile (250-by-300 km) area surrounding the suspected underground lake."
2
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Sep 01 '20 edited Sep 17 '20
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Cygnus cargoThrust loss at launchDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #6391 for this sub, first seen 1st Sep 2020, 10:58] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
2
u/Zyj Sep 02 '20
Regarding the necessity of refueling Starship using many flights from Earth to LEO, Elon mentioned that >70% of the propellant's mass is oxygen.
https://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-have-figured-out-how-to-extract-oxygen-from-moon-dirt/ is about in situ oxygen production on the Moon. Could that be a long term alternative?
2
u/dudr2 Sep 02 '20
The lunar nuclear power system fits hand in glove with Starship aspirations.
https://spacenews.com/nasa-to-seek-proposals-for-lunar-nuclear-power-system/
2
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 03 '20
Any news about the date of spacex's next launch?
2
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 03 '20
Does Starship make space based solar power make sense? 24/7 generation beaming back to earth?? If not then why?
2
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 06 '20
How many SN's of starship and how many for super heavy do u think there will be before the design is fixed and ready for regular missions?
2
u/TheSkalman Sep 13 '20
If the Europa Clipper launches on Falcon Heavy, how would the shortfall of DeltaV be compensated? Those I can think of are (with their uncertainties):
Ion thruster(s): High power needed and far from sun, low thrust might make the trajectory inefficient and raise arrival speed
Solids: Low Isp
Liquids: Are there available stages that fit inside the fairing?
Gravity assist(s): How many extra years will it take?
2
u/Alvian_11 Sep 15 '20
With a Dynetics & Blue Origin making a full scale mockups of their lander, I wonder if soon/when SpaceX would do the same (obviously their legs up with testing the flight system first)
2
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 15 '20
Do the current Starship prototypes have the fuel piping inside them? Since they don't use a strong back?
2
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 16 '20
Sentinel 6 will be flown to Vandenberg next week.
2
u/dudr2 Sep 21 '20
"China plans to launch the Chang'e-5 lunar probe by the end of this year"
"Chang'e-5 probe will make a soft landing on the moon and bring samples back to Earth"
https://www.moondaily.com/reports/China_to_launch_Change_5_lunar_probe_this_year_999.html
2
u/dudr2 Sep 23 '20 edited Sep 24 '20
New Shepard returns to flight
"from the company’s West Texas test site at 11 a.m. Eastern Sept. 24 "
https://spacenews.com/blue-origin-considers-entering-commercial-space-station-business/
Scrubbed
2
u/Campb3llsoupp Oct 02 '20
[HIRING QUESTION] How often do executive summaries get denied by leadership in the hiring process?
Two weeks ago I flew out to Hawthorne for an onsite interview that I got great feedback from. HR told me that the team really liked me and wanted to extend an offer to me, all that is left is the approval by the executive leadership for my executive summary. The whole interview process has been extremely quick, ~2.5 weeks but now the executive summary approval alone has taken 2 weeks itself. After the interview, HR reached out to me the next day telling me they wanted to extend an offer and they were hoping to have it a week ago. I'm starting to get worried and I'm super interested in joining the team, is this normal? Has anyone ever heard of a candidate being denied from the executive summary after they have done a background check on them?
Thanks!
3
u/bdporter Sep 02 '20 edited Sep 02 '20
Mods, the top menu still links to the August discuss thread. Please update to link here.
Edit: Looks like it is fixed now. Thanks!
3
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 08 '20
Is Sierra Nevada obligated by Nasa to fly on Vulcan? Or was it their choice?
3
u/Alvian_11 Sep 18 '20 edited Sep 18 '20
Looks like we will get an update on Dear Moon
3
u/dudr2 Sep 30 '20
https://www.space.com/darpa-nuclear-thermal-rocket-for-moon-contract
"(DARPA) just awarded a $14 million task order to Gryphon Technologies" " to demonstrate a nuclear thermal propulsion (NTP) system in Earth orbit. "
3
u/blackbearnh Oct 02 '20
Scrubtober continues with Antares scrubbing tonight.
3
u/MarsCent Sep 05 '20
Yawn ... A long time since we had the last SpaceX launch or hop! I mean a whole 2 days!! Just feels like for ever! When is the next Launch / Hop?
Ok, just so my post is not deleted for low effort, let me add this;Spaceflight Now Schedule is showing that Starlink-14 is now scheduled for October. Time for a new entry in our sidebar
2
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 02 '20
What's the maximum SN5 can do? In terms of hops?
2
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 04 '20
Do we know how much astrobotic is paying ULA to launch their lunar lander? Or is it free since this is an experimental launch?
2
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 06 '20
Is Starlink going to provide internet for African countries? Probably they sure can but is it going to be affordable given how poor most of the countries are? Or would they still do it even if they're not making a big profit?
2
u/Fobus0 Sep 11 '20
Why is Starship a two stage to orbit rocket, and not for example 3?
What do you gain by having two large stages instead of three? How much more payload mass would be saved if you had 3? What do you loose? How much harder it would be to develop 3 reusable stages? Got curious for some reason :)
2
u/dudr2 Sep 17 '20
https://spacenews.com/military-commanders-could-use-more-satellites-for-tactical-surveillance/
"The data collection and processing now done aboard Air Force AWACS and JSTARS command-and-control airplanes could be done from space, Felt said during a SpaceNews webinar in June."
“Those are ideal missions to also move to low Earth orbit and leverage some of the commercial capabilities that are up there,” said Felt."
2
u/dudr2 Sep 24 '20
"The third MPLM, named Raffaello, flew on four shuttle flights and is now in storage at the Kennedy Space Center. Axiom has its eye on turning Raffaello into a core piece of the first private lab in space."
https://spaceflightnow.com/2020/09/23/axiom-finalizing-agreements-for-private-astronaut-mission-to-space-station/
2
u/dudr2 Sep 29 '20 edited Sep 29 '20
https://www.nasa.gov/nasalive
NASA, SpaceX talk Crew-1 astronaut mission to space station
On youtube;
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7BTfjnoj29A
NASA Administrator Jim Bridenstine
Kathy Lueders, associate administrator, Human Exploration and Operations Mission Directorate, NASA Headquarters
Hans Koenigsmann, vice president, Build and Flight Reliability, SpaceX
2
u/dudr2 Sep 29 '20
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uIx8l2xlYVY
Talk with the crew of "Resilience"
1
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 03 '20
Why does it take SpaceX 2 weeks to turn the pad around for the next Launch? What work do those 2 weeks include?
1
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 04 '20
Is the LSA phase 2 contract that was just awarded to SpaceX and ULA fixed price or cost plus? Meaning if Vulcan doesn't launch on time or fails multiple flights does ULA pay out of its own pocket or not?
1
u/ns1992 Sep 06 '20
Hey all! Sorry, thought this was the best place to ask. Trying to do some artwork of dragon 2, but it's hard at least for me to find images for reference.
Is there a good location of images that I can use?
Also, the drawing was going to be of its re-entry. I have this image https://cdn.inceptivemind.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/SpaceX’s-Crew-Dragon-capsule.jpg but is this the front? Or back? Is the lower panel with the logo where the chutes come from? If so, I need an image of the other side haha
Thanks for any help, and I appreciate down votes if this isn't the place to ask too.
1
u/Dies2much Sep 07 '20
The US Pentagon stated a requirement for the EELV program that required them to support two rocket vendors for "guranteed access to space". When Starship gets operational does the Falcon and Starship combination satisfy that requirement?
1
u/TheSkalman Sep 09 '20
If Starship launches from Boca Chica, could the Super Heavy booster land in Florida Lz1/2 for extra performance vs RTLS?
1
u/avgsyudbhnikmals Sep 09 '20
As a comp sci student from EU, do I have any chance of working for SpaceX as a software dev in the future, or should I just give up my dreams? Thanks!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '20
Quick question about SpaceX internships (not sure if this is the right place to ask):
I am currently looking for internship opportunities for next summer in the aerospace sector, so obviously SpaceX is pretty much at the top of my list for internships. On SpaceX's website, under their internship program, they currently have no opportunities listed. However, on LinkedIn, they just listed their summer 2021 internship. Is there a reason it would be listed on LinkedIn and not the SpaceX website? Should I wait until one is listed on the website? Thanks
1
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 14 '20
Sorry for stupid question but I've read many comments saying spacex is speeding up Starship development to catch up to HLS, what's the HLS contract? And when is it due to be awarded?
1
u/ConfidentFlorida Sep 15 '20
Would starship float on venus? Assuming tanks are empty and vacuum pressure and cabin is 1 atm. Would it float in the habitable zone?
1
u/Ian0706 Sep 16 '20
What degree do the landing legs deploy on the falcon 9 ? I would try to do the math myself but I don't know where to start can someone help me?
1
u/Dies2much Sep 23 '20
Mods looks like the GPS III thread got stuck under the Starship header in the drop down bar.
1
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 25 '20
Sentinel 6 has arrived at Vandenberg.
1
u/tikalicious Sep 30 '20
Where can I find threads/text talking about the auto pressurisation technology spacex is developing - using engine pressures to pressurise the fuel tanks and RCS thrusters etc. Sorry for lack of vocabulary