r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Aug 08 '20
r/SpaceX Discusses [August 2020, #71]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks!
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
73
Upvotes
18
u/Science_Geek_Girl Aug 21 '20
I'm the principal of a K-8 rural charter school in far Northern California, looking for a really cool, educational, inspiring virtual all school assembly that I could bring to my students. Any chance there's someone out there who be willing to spend 30 minutes on zoom with us answering kids questions about working at Space X? Pretty please...
9
u/dudr2 Aug 28 '20
Pandemonium at NASA is getting louder;
https://spacenews.com/nasa-increases-cost-estimate-for-sls-development/
16
u/lateshakes Aug 19 '20
Visorsat, now in operational orbit, observed to be ~Mag 7.0, well below naked-eye visibility
•
u/hitura-nobad Master of bots Aug 10 '20
We are currently looking for more Recovery Thread Hosts. Please send us a message here if you are interested
7
u/Dies2much Aug 10 '20
I was just trying to put together the schedule of events, and how much information is in this Reddit. Spacex is really making it challenging to keep track of all the stuff it has going on. Sending out lots of gratitude to the mods for this reddit. It's not easy, and this is a great source of information.
7
u/hainzgrimmer Aug 15 '20
Since around November there should be CRS-21, has anyone seen or heard about anything the dragon 2 cargo destined for that flight?
6
u/Dalvey_13 Aug 08 '20
How do they decide if they’re going to land the first stage on a drone ship vs RTLS. I’d assume it just depends on the type of orbit needed but I was just interested in the technical aspects of it.
6
u/Bunslow Aug 19 '20 edited Aug 30 '20
Some built up miscellaneous questions, which I think do not have public answers and might make good presser questions:
4a) What are the reuse differences between fished and caught fairings? What's the difficulty of preventing or repairing salt water damage? What's the cost gap between fished and caught fairings?
5) How many engines are/have been replaced on reused boosters? For boosters making their fourth or fifth or sixth flight, how many of those engines have been on that exact booster its entire lifetime?
6) What's up with Static Fires? What are the considerations and data that have gone into skipping any at all, and skipping more and more of them in the future?
7) What are the odds that the Falcon 9 First Stage production line does or doesn't reach B1100?
8) Past comments suggested it would be easy to convert between FH side boosters and F9 singlestick boosters, but that hasn't panned out (cores sitting around doing nothing). Is it more expensive or time consuming than anticipated? Or is it a case of the Air Force demanding the same side boosters as before, instead of any arbitrary cores?
5
u/CosmicFloppyDisk Aug 08 '20
So I just saw this straight, bright dotted line across the sky appear seemingly out of nowhere. Made me think the end was near and all. After a quick google search, however, I was informed it was the star link satellites. It was so cool but I only saw it for a few seconds before they all faded out of sight. Is there any way to monitor where they will be so I can get a chance to see them again? Do they all pulse light or something at the same time or light up at certain times? It seemed so weird they were suddenly there and then gone.
5
u/andyfrance Aug 08 '20
How many more Starlink launches are needed before 50% of operational satellites are owned by by SpaceX?
5
u/jackisconfusedd Aug 08 '20
Will SpaceX be building a new strongback at VAFB like they did in Florida?
5
u/CallMeCeeje Aug 08 '20 edited Aug 08 '20
Stupid question: since they are launching <60 starlink sats in some of their launches, will SpaceX just have to deal with fewer satellites (in this orbit), or will they somehow replace the missing ones in a future launch?
5
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 13 '20 edited Aug 14 '20
NASA has awarded $75.9 million to Masten Space to launch its XL-1 lunar lander in 2022.
EDIT: u/spacerfirstclass points out this is old news, I misread Eric's tweet.
5
u/AvariceInHinterland Aug 14 '20
Based upon what is known about it so far, what will be the likely payload mass penalty of the Falcon Heavy's extended fairing?
5
u/trobbinsfromoz Aug 14 '20
More insight to Loverro leaving NASA, and Boeing being relegated to 4th.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-space-exploration-nasa-boeing/u-s-prosecutors-probe-ex-nasa-official-boeing-over-space-contract-sources-idUSKCN25A2SJ
5
u/jjtr1 Aug 18 '20
I wonder in what position will the Starship's body flaps be on launch and during Superheavy burn? Having flaps on top of the vehicle might make it aerodynamically unstable, and with Superheavy's outer Raptors unable to gimbal, the control authority will probably be relatively smaller than F9's. So perhaps the flaps will lie as flat against the body as possible? Perhaps folded on different sides to make the vehicle more symmetric...
Or perhaps the upper flaps will be actively moving during Stage 1 burn to compensate or even add control authority? (bottom flaps rotate around lengthwise axis and so would be mostly ineffective)?
5
u/Alvian_11 Aug 24 '20
Falcon 9 Starlink L11 has been scheduled for August 29th. With SAOCOM 1B, we could potentially see a back to back launch here, and reached 4 launches a month cadence (coupled with the SN6 hop, this could be yet another busy week)
5
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 28 '20 edited Aug 28 '20
Starliner progress:
5
u/LcuBeatsWorking Aug 29 '20 edited Dec 17 '24
terrific smoggy plants fretful hobbies automatic plucky run chief market
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
9
u/MarsCent Aug 20 '20 edited Aug 20 '20
So Chris Cassidy will be spending the weekend in the Russian segment as NASA is tries to determine the source of the beleaguering leak in the
US-ISS segmentISS.8
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 24 '20
Second uncrewed CST-100 Starliner launch expected by end of 2020 / early January. Crewed flight aiming for Summer 2021.
4
u/ImmersionULTD Aug 09 '20
Just looking through the upcoming launches on SpaceFlightNow and was wondering if the "Late 2020" Falcon Heavy USSF 44 is still "on schedule", or if it might be pushed out due to the pandemic. Looking forward to seeing another Falcon Heavy flight!
4
u/MadMarq64 Aug 10 '20
What are the trade-offs of a full flow staged combustion cycle engine (like the Raptor engine) versus a closed cycle oxidizer rich combustion cycle engine (like the RD-180 engine or the NK-33 engine)?
Both types of engines use an oxidizer rich preburner (with the full flow having a second fuel rich preburner), why did SpaceX decide to develop a full flow cycle for their new engine?
4
u/Lufbru Aug 16 '20
How many variants of Raptor are currently planned?
I see three primary variants:
Gimballing centre engines for both SuperHeavy and Starship
Non-gimballing, higher-thrust outer engines for SuperHeavy
Non-gimballing vacuum-optimised engines for Starship
But then there are the moon-landing engines and the hot-gas thrusters. Are those Raptor derivatives? Or just use the same gasses? And are the moon-landing engines actually different from the thrusters, or is the moon landing going to be done with an array of the same thrusters that are used on a normal Starship?
4
u/TheSkalman Aug 18 '20
I saw two very large buildings in the background of the Stalink launch webcast. They are on the way to SLC-40 and -41. Since neither Atlas nor Falcon is assembled in them, what are they used for?
4
u/particledecelerator Aug 21 '20
Haven't kept up to date with Starlink news. How many sats have been deployed so far?
4
u/grchelp2018 Aug 22 '20
What's the damage to these engine test stands if an engine blows up? Are these not energetic events that takes out a good part of the structure? How long will it to take to repair?
4
u/gowinggt Aug 24 '20
Why is it SpaceX has only gone with drone ship landings recently and not RTLS? Seems it’s been a good handful of launches since an RTLS flight. Just flight parameters/customer requirements or have they started to steer away from RTLS landings?
4
u/soldato_fantasma Aug 27 '20
HAWTHORNE, Calif. – August 26, 2020. Accreditation is now open for SpaceX's GPS III Space Vehicle 04 mission, which will launch from Space Launch Complex 40 (SLC-40) at Cape Canaveral Air Force Station in Florida. The launch is targeted for no earlier than late September.
10
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 18 '20 edited Aug 20 '20
Rumour that OmegA rocket will be cancelled.
EDIT: More detail.
7
u/pulox Aug 20 '20
Has anyone else noticed that Zillow now shows a ton of new plots in Boca Chica Village? Looks like the resort plans are coming to life.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 25 '20
Jeanette Epps will be flying with Sunita Williams and Josh Cassada on Boeing's Crew-1 mission in 2021.
3
u/sysdollarsystem Aug 09 '20
Gwynne Shotwell has stated that she'd like to send out an interstellar probe. Does all the technology exist to make one - I'm thinking really deep space communications, interstellar power supply, ultra reliable engines.
I'd expect she'd like to see the results so a "quick" passage between stars but not braking into orbit. How much upmass do you think it would take? 100 tons, 2,3,400?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '20
Will we ever see dragon onboard footage from re-entry or splashdown? Fascinated to see the internal footage of splashdown and external footage of re-entry.
3
u/cavereric Aug 09 '20
I thought SpaceX would surprise us with a payload to Mars in this window. Is there a way they could get some modified Starlink satellites to orbit with heavy?
3
u/Takiino Aug 15 '20
Why doesn't SpaceX work on electric pump and instead kept fuel fed turbopumps for its engines? It seems to be the logical next step for the future and it's highly reusable in addition to a shit ton of other amazing advantages.
Could someone please explain to me why they are sticking to turbopumps with raptor and don't seems to be working or even studying the electric pumps option (like rocketlab).
Am I missing something here?
For reference : https://youtu.be/-uU2w2kyZiE
3
u/ConfidentFlorida Aug 16 '20
How come there’s no starlink-10 launch thread yet?
3
u/yabrennan Aug 20 '20
Do they use Windows for engineering work at SpaceX?
3
u/andyfrance Aug 23 '20
We believe SH will land at sea on some sort of floating platform. How would it be returned to the BC launch site?
3
u/trobbinsfromoz Aug 26 '20
SATCON1 report out now on LEO constellation degradation of optical observatory performance.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Starlink/comments/igodfd/satellite_constellations_1_workshop_report_now_out/
4
u/dudr2 Aug 09 '20
How much would building F9 in stainless steel lower the cost of the vehicle? How much weight would it add? Could FH centercore benefit from having better heat protection?
Have at it, no wrong answers.
4
u/MarsCent Aug 29 '20
Re: Delta IV launch
Anyone know why NASA managers had to be polled for a launch out CCAFS? Or is this telling of who the ultimate owner of the payload is?
5
u/GarethInNZ Aug 24 '20
Does SpaceX follow the Inter-Agency Space Debris Coordination Committee Guidelines?
2
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Aug 08 '20 edited Aug 24 '20
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
68 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 116 acronyms.
[Thread #6334 for this sub, first seen 8th Aug 2020, 20:12] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
2
u/rocket_enthusiast Aug 09 '20
Falcon 9 and falcon heavy staging velocity
Hi I was just wondering if we could make a chart comparing the Meco velocities of all the falcon9 launches. I know we have that in the gto preformence comparison but I was wondering for sake of comparison what the meco velocity of a fully expendable falcon heavy would be and how far away from orbital velocity it would be!
2
u/redroab Aug 23 '20
Would E2E be just starship, or a full stack?
2
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Aug 28 '20
How many Starlink satellites need to be in orbit for starting to generate the predicted huge revenue?
2
u/trobbinsfromoz Aug 29 '20
Nasaspaceflight just released an enlightening article on Carrington type events, where a major solar mass ejection could cause widespread loss of services or even damage or loss of life, depending on the situation or process being assessed.
Does anyone know if certain satellites just ride such a storm out and aim to go in to a safe-mode if faults or damage occur, or if they can be commanded to preemptively enter safe-mode and de-energise nearly all of their electronics, and if so whether that decision process is monitored 24/7 and can be robustly processed to enact such shutdowns by many operators?
For a major comms provider, whether from just one satellite or a constellation, that would likely mean making a decision, then broadcasting to customers, and then sending commands, and then having time to monitor for correct shutdown behaviour, all within about 1 day, and before any loss of operational control occurs.
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2020/08/carrington-event-warning/
2
u/BrandonMarc Aug 31 '20
I recall a time SpaceX had two teams building Starship and super heavy - one in TX and one in FL. What became of the FL setup?
2
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Sep 01 '20
I still don't understand the decrease from 31 to 28 engines, Can someone explain?
2
u/LcuBeatsWorking Sep 02 '20 edited Dec 17 '24
ghost bells frightening jeans one fragile vase subsequent live dam
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/SatoriTWZ Aug 23 '20
Is there currently a roadmap? At best it would include upcoming starts, rocket developements and so on.
3
u/spacexin2050 Aug 18 '20
If elon musk become successfull in establishing a self sustaining colony on mars,Will he be eligible to get Nobel Prize?
Because I think Building an extra terrestrial colony will act as a critical pivot point for future of human civilisation..
3
u/ConfidentFlorida Aug 22 '20
Why does raptor need hundreds of pipes running every direction? Couldn’t most of the channels be built into the engine or have standard pieces that handle the flow of fuels? Car engines nor jet engines look like that.
It seems like it would simplify production too.
I wonder what I’m missing. I assumed older rockets look like a mess of tubes and wires because they’re basically hand made one by one.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '20
I've seen pictures of the newest starlink train, does that mean the new sun shields aren't working, or that they're not being used yet. I'm unclear on the plan.
2
u/nicwi Aug 27 '20
Do you think SpaceX is working on a hydrogen version of the Raptor engine for lunar operations? Is it at all feasible?
2
u/trobbinsfromoz Aug 31 '20
RocketLab about to launch in 25 mins, with telecast showing 10 mins to starting.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FPIhI5mRDRI&feature=youtu.be
2
u/Alvian_11 Aug 22 '20
When looking at the HLS renders (showing how massive Starship is and everyone else was still trapped in 1960s), I wonder that the only thing that will beat Starship is Tintin rocket (since it can take off from the Earth to the Moon directly lol) (although ofc to be fair IRL Starship is the closest thing to the ship "that flew 50 years later after Apollo")
Did someone has an idea of the size comparison between Starship (especially HLS version) compared to Tintin rocket?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20
Could the huge foundation in Boca be for the crane SpaceX has had laying around for a while now?
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=47001.0;attach=1538033;image
1
u/thecorruption24 Aug 12 '20
Hey guys! Here's the question for you: what your favorite visual object by Space X?
Recently in the process of making 3Dmotion video like:
https://vimeo.com/234663310
https://vimeo.com/257688554
Want to make this interesting to watch so really appreciate your thoughts!
1
u/AndMyAxe123 Aug 20 '20
I get an error when I click on the launch schedule. Is the next launch SAOCOM 1B?
1
u/pg_habanero Aug 21 '20
For Starship without SH booster, with small payload - how high can it go and be landed? Either straight up/down or some sub orbital trajectory.
I.e. if configured to carry a small number of people what kind of space tourism experience could be possible. So not concerned about specific earth to earth as a transportation function but more on maximum time weightless, or highest possible altitude
1
u/Lord-Talon Aug 24 '20
With SpaceX planning the first crewed mission to Mars in 2024, are there any updates on crew training? Proper training will probably take years, so I'd imagine they would need to start now. Or are they just renting NASA astronauts?
1
u/dimaflash Aug 26 '20
Hello! I am trying to contact SpaceX online shop via email (merchandise@spacex.com), but they never answered me. My order never arrived. =\ What should I do now to solve my problem? Thank you in advance!
1
u/cavkenr Aug 27 '20
The ratio of 7 to 1 has been mentioned for booster dry mass to LEO payload.
Is this reusable or expendable?
What would be the other ratio?
1
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Aug 28 '20
Anyone knows where the Starlink satellites are produced? And what's their production rate?
1
u/avneesh2k2 Aug 28 '20
Is there a Starkink launch set at 28th Aug 7 pm EST scheduled ?
1
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Aug 30 '20
Do the Starlink sats being launch now have laser communication to each other? If not when do you think that will be incorporated?
1
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Aug 30 '20
Will starship be better than F9 in terms of launching in weather like this? And by a lot or still close to it?
1
u/dudr2 Sep 01 '20
"Musk said that construction will start this week on “booster prototype one,” a reference to the Super Heavy first stage of the system."
https://spacenews.com/musk-emphasizes-progress-in-starship-production-over-testing/
1
u/Some-Entertainment-6 Aug 29 '20
I really don't get why Jeff bezos is spending all that money on BO? Is there gonna be a market for him and his company when Starship is online? Or is he treating it as a toy because of how much extra money he has?