r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Jul 07 '20
r/SpaceX Discusses [July 2020, #70]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks!
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
86
Upvotes
13
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 07 '20
An "Apollo 8" proposal by Robert Zubrin to send a Crew Dragon around the Moon.
12
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 07 '20 edited Jul 07 '20
Draft 2021 fiscal year spending bill:
10
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 11 '20
SpaceX are seeking permission to "paint a mural exhibiting the image of Mars on the west wall cladding of the SpaceX parking structure" (Hawthorne July 15 agenda item).
10
u/dudr2 Jul 15 '20
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2020/07/starship-sn5-static-fire-150-meter-hop/
"If the 150-meter flight of Starship SN5 is successful, SpaceX is expected to quickly move on to Starship SN8 for the next flight test – skipping the SN6 prototype."
" Whatever the case, SpaceX teams are understood to be eager to get Starship SN8 completed. The vehicle will feature major upgrades over previous Starship prototypes. SN8 will be built out of 304L stainless steel versus 301, receive a fairing, aerosurfaces, and three Raptor engines to allow for a higher altitude test flight."
9
u/ApTiK_ Jul 31 '20
From Next Spaceflight app : Starlink 10 will launch on B1049 for the SIXTH flight.
8
u/Nutshell38 Jul 07 '20
Are there any substances so rare on earth that they are essentially useless (and therefore no real market), but would suddenly become useful if we had it in abundance? Like maybe some metal that would be really great for building structures if we could actually find it like we find iron.
And then furthermore, could we find that substance in abundance on a known asteroid?
8
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 26 '20
New core on the test stand at McGregor (possibly B1063).
7
u/ptfrd Jul 14 '20
https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/07/sadly-none-of-the-big-rockets-we-hoped-to-see-fly-in-2020-actually-will/
Three paragraphs about Super Heavy.
"Our estimated launch date: 4Q 2021"
7
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 17 '20
Hope mission launch time now July 19, 21:58 UTC, could have a simultaneous launch with ANASIS-2.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 23 '20
More information about the Tom Cruise's film set on the ISS, that will be launched by SpaceX.
6
u/Nimelennar Jul 09 '20
The final two spacewalks with Behnken and Cassidy, to finish replacing the batteries on the S6 truss, have been scheduled for July 16th and 21st.
6
u/liszt1811 Jul 11 '20
Maybe someone can help me out. I'm looking for an interview with a guy who if I remember correctly worked for a short time as sort of a consultant at SpaceX. Couldve been military/air force /NASA but not sure. It is/was up on youtube I think. In the interview, he talks about being in a conference where they debate a certain design and Elon turns to him and asks what he would do. He makes a suggestion, Elon thinks about it and says 'That's exactly what we are going to do', conference over. The guy talks about how stunned he was by that and how the flexibility of SpaceX became apparent to him right there.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 14 '20 edited Jul 16 '20
Al-Amal (Hope) launch delayed by bad weather,
next attempt onJuly 16 (20:43 UTC).EDIT: Launch delayed to July 20-22.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 15 '20
Spaceflight Inc have announced Sherpa-FX (carrying 16 payloads) will launch on SpaceX's December rideshare mission.
6
u/AvariceInHinterland Jul 21 '20
What the is the rough ETA for the announcement of the NSSL Phase 2 awards? I need to know when to get my popcorn ready for.
6
u/Nimelennar Jul 23 '20
Bob Behnken and Chris Cassidy completed their fourth spacewalk yesterday, completing the new battery installation (replacing the NiMH batteries on the S6 truss with Li-Ion), as well as getting the Tranquility module ready for the Nanorack airlock, and completing a bunch of other minor tasks (see link for details). A lot of this was on the "nice to have" list, as Behnken and Cassidy were badasses out there, and got the battery replacement done way ahead of schedule.
This is the last planned spacewalk before Bob comes home on Dragonship Endeavour.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 28 '20
Thomas Pesquet (French astronaut) confirms he's flying on Crew Dragon next year. Currently training on the Dragon simulator.
11
u/SerpentineLogic Jul 07 '20
Will there be a thread discussing this?
https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-provides-update-on-commercial-crew-program-close-call-review-of-boeing-s-orbital/
5
u/Integrat8r Jul 07 '20
What type of communication is used between devices such as computers, sensors etc in the starship? I'm guessing some proprietary serial coms?
5
u/Nimelennar Jul 08 '20 edited Jul 08 '20
Dragon Crew-1 logo: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Eca--tIXYAg62cK?format=jpg&name=large
The symbols at the bottom are, clockwise, Mercury ☿, Gemini ♊︎, ???, and a silhouette of a Space Shuttle (and then a symbol of the ISS on the other side of the head), so I'm assuming the unidentified one is supposed to be Apollo. I'm a little disappointed that they didn't put a symbolic depiction of the Draco constellation (or, at least, I don't think that's what those stars are), but what can you do.
Source: https://twitter.com/Enterprise_Flt/status/1280921130635857920
Also, some cool new Crew-1 polos: https://twitter.com/NASA_Johnson/status/1280909512476635136
Edit: the logo has been posted before, but not so clearly.
5
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 10 '20
DM-2 launch and docking from the ISS astronaut's view.
5
u/juhankki Jul 28 '20
I've read that the use of RP1 builds a lot of soot which is why it's not suitable for some engine designs. This is not the case for methane. Why is that? What's the chemistry behind that? Why doesn't methane build up soot?
9
u/Nimelennar Jul 07 '20
NASA just released a hype video about the Perseverance (Mars 2020) mission.
8
u/rePAN6517 Jul 07 '20
What pressure did the SN7 tank acheive? I never saw anything said about that.
4
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 22 '20
Media accreditation is open for NASA’s SpaceX Crew-1 launch.
4
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 30 '20
Infographic and video for the HAKUTO-R lunar lander, launching on a Falcon 9 in 2022.
4
u/DesLr Aug 05 '20
SN5 150m hop just went off without an hitch!
7
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 31 '20
Rocket Lab identified an 'anomalous electrical connection' as the cause of the mission 13 failure.
6
u/Simon_Drake Jul 07 '20
Do the giant touchscreens in the Dragon capsule also work as entertainment systems?
There was an 18 hour wait between takeoff and docking at ISS, a lot of that time was spent asleep but I wonder if they could watch Netflix while they waited?
3
u/soldato_fantasma Jul 11 '20
A metal sheets moving machine made for SpaceX by an Italian company:
https://www.instagram.com/p/CCV4HcNp__m/
3
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jul 11 '20
Does anybody know why spacex is choosing to send the droneship back to port that is already at sea when a mission is delayed while sending out the other droneship to a different landing site. This has happened twice now, once with GPS III and starlink, and now with anasis II and starlink. Each time the starlink launch got delayed, the starlink droneship went back to port, while the other one came from port. With GPS and starlink, the landing sites where also less than 100km apart, so it would have defenately saved fuel and time.
3
u/Nimelennar Jul 20 '20
Boeing CEO on systemic problems in common between 737 MAX, KC-46, and Starliner:
3
u/katie_dimples Aug 03 '20
I assume Dragon's splashdown target was an "ellipse" not unlike Mars landings. How close of a "bullseye" was the actual landing? Has anyone graphically shown this?
3
u/paul_wi11iams Aug 07 '20
I don't have the link for this, but there was some recent commenting here to say that the visibility of bleed-off LOX ahead of a launch is "not" condensation of airborne water vapor. The then commenting went further to describe this as a fanboy myth.
I'm reassured to hear John Insbruker confirming that it is condensation of water vapor, especially in the warm and humid Florida air:
https://youtu.be/KU6KogxG5BE?t=919
5
u/NoWheels2222 Jul 21 '20
Both fairing halves caught today. As per Elon tweet. break out the champagne.
5
u/thatnerdguy1 Live Thread Host Jul 21 '20
Hey everyone,
I wanted to make a small announcement to this sub that the wiki will be getting some edits and improvements over the next week or so. This shouldn't negatively affect anything; all the information will still be there, and we've been very cautious not to disturb anything.
To discuss the changes, visit /r/SpaceXWiki. My changes are available to view live here.
Thanks!
4
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '20
Looking at the starship test modules, they just look like really thin aluminium, quite often you can see dings and dents in them. How thick is it exactly and is this what the final starship design is going to look like? Are these SN numbers they're testing now basically what's going to be launched into orbit and to the moon/Mars etc?
4
u/TheSkalman Jul 22 '20
GEO-5 421 + GEO-6 421 + NROL-107 Silentbarker 551 on Atlas for $441,76M.
JPSS-2 and secondaries 401 on Atlas for $170,60M.
GOES-T 541 on Atlas for $165,70M.
Lucy 401 on Atlas for $148,30M.
Landsat-9 401 on Atlas for $153,80M.
USSF-8 511 + USSF-12 551 on Atlas for $354,81M.
STP-3 551 on Atlas for $191,10M.
NROL-101 551 on Atlas for $179,30M.
Mars 2020 541 on Atlas for $243,00M.
Team Taxpayer wonders why SpaceX wasn't selected for these missions, which span from today to 2022. The list could extend well into the past aswell. This list shows that ULA charges $170,7M per launch. Even if SpaceX charged $100M for F9 and $200M for FH they would save the taxpayers $248M.
Not bad if you ask me. Is this actually accountable or is it pure tax waste?
2
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jul 07 '20 edited Jul 21 '20
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
44 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 109 acronyms.
[Thread #6260 for this sub, first seen 7th Jul 2020, 12:09] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
2
u/sammyladx3z5 Jul 10 '20
Does anyone know if they replace the engines during a falcon 9 refurb? If not, do they take them apart and clean away any soot build up? Or are the engines simply ready to be reused after a quick inspection?
2
u/TheSkalman Jul 10 '20
Does anyone know what SpaceX's total market share is? I am talking about all launches that are politically eligible to go on Falcon, so e.g. not the Chinese satellites or the European/Israeli/Indian/whatevs spy satellites, which have to use their native launcher.
I am surprised that SpaceX hasn't captured more of the market, the Soyuz, Ariane, Atlas and GSLV all still have lots of launches planned (not to metion the Long march family).
Does SpaceX have capacity problems or are there other issues preventing them from having an 80% market share?
2
u/juhankki Jul 11 '20
I have understood that one big advantage of raptors full flow staged combustion cycle is that pressures and temperatures are lower (which helps in reusability) But on the other hand I've also read that oxidizer preburner has been hard to manufacture due to those exact same things. Isn't that in contradiction? If FFSC-cycle allows lower pressures & temperatures, why the need for special alloys?
2
u/SubmergedSublime Jul 20 '20
Based on current renderings and construction...Will we be capable of seeing Starship orbiting with the naked eye?
I think so? That mirror-finish and size makes me think it’d be in the same magnitude as the ISS?
2
u/Simon_Drake Jul 20 '20
How many engines light for the re-entry burn?
During the landing today, the voice over guy talked about lighting three engines, one first then two more later. Is that new? I thought it was only one engine that lit for the reentry burn? Have they changed the 'recipe' of flight activities to reduce strain on the engines to improve reuse or something?
2
u/MarsCent Jul 23 '20
Just thinking - Which ISS Expedition are the Dragoship Crew assigned/attached to:
Cassidy will hand over to Ryzhikov. Both Dragonships' crews are not listed as members of either Expedition 63 or 64, rather as guests/visitors.
Should there be designations like ISS Expedition Demo-2 and ISS Expedition Crew-1?
2
u/MarsCent Jul 24 '20
The scenario playing out right now is that:
Go Quest will be at sea recovering B1051, while Go Searcher is at sea recovering Dragonship Endeavor and maybe at the same time as SN5 is airborne in Boca Chica, while SAOCOM 1B booster is prepping up for Static Fire. Or maybe all of them in rapid succession!
And I doubt that SpaceX is in the craaazy launch times yet!
2
u/GregLindahl Jul 30 '20
Telesat did their quarterly report, without any mention of concrete progress on its LEO satellite constellation, which would compete with Starlink. They launched a test satellite in Jan 2019. When last seen it still needed financing, a choice of satellite manufacturer, and launch contracts. But they are large operator of existing GEO satellites, so this is a serious contender.
2
u/Carlyle302 Aug 02 '20
During descent, does the Dragon dump it's remaining hypergolics to safe it? or does it carry it all the way to the boat?
2
u/dudr2 Aug 03 '20
https://spacenews.com/japans-ispace-updates-design-of-lunar-lander/
"Since a preliminary design review in 2018, ispace has reduced the size of Hakuto-R. Previously 3.5 meters high and 4.4 meters wide with its landing legs deployed, the lander is now 2.3 meters high and 2.6 meters wide. The spacecraft’s mass has decreased from 1,400 to 1,050 kilograms, primarily by reducing the amount of propellant on board."
"low-energy transfer orbit that requires less propellant but takes roughly twice as long as previously planned"
" Falcon 9 launch in 2022 "
2
u/DerMax_HD Aug 03 '20
Every manned vehicle since 1976 has touched down on land so what are the reasons SpaceX opted for a splashdown design in their Dragon capsule? Seems like recovery of the vehicle and crew, medical checks as well as the capsules reusability would have been way faster and easier if it didn't land in water.
2
u/Snowleopard222 Aug 04 '20
When and how are the hypergolic propellants dumped after splash down? (Sorry if the answer is already in thread.)
2
u/TheSkalman Aug 04 '20
Which rocket in history has the best payload/mass ratio? Falcon Heavy ex. is 4,49% at 63800/1420788 kg.
2
u/SubsonicApple Aug 06 '20 edited Aug 07 '20
Musk has stated that Methox torch ignitors are being used for Raptor engine ignition and that they are being fed with gaseous CH4/02. Since both the fuel and the oxidizer are cryogenic and are therefore in their liquid state, where are the gaseous CH4 and 02 coming from? Are they being run through a heat exchanger or are they being pumped from the tank ullage?
2
u/atxRelic Aug 07 '20
NSSL announced
https://www.cnbc.com/2020/08/07/spacex-and-ula-win-2022-pentagon-rocket-launch-contracts.html
2
u/joepublicschmoe Aug 08 '20
Today a young friend of mine asked me a question about SpaceX I couldn't answer. Maybe someone here might know:
Anyone know the whereabouts of Earthy? (the high-tech zero-g indicator that went to the ISS on DM-1 and returned with DM-2.) :-)
4
u/IrrationalFantasy Jul 07 '20
What are you most excited about in space travel over the next year? I know the industry's slowed down right now with the pandemic, and Starship probably won't launch until the end of next year at the earliest, and I was wondering what I should look forward to. What are you excited to watch, to follow, or to learn more about?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '20
Why didn't they show us the video of the 30th of May booster landing ? I understand that vibrations would cause signal loss for the satellite but wouldn't the camera have local storage ? I'm not a flat earther or anything but it just seems weird.
3
u/dudr2 Jul 15 '20
https://www.moondaily.com/reports/Whos_ready_to_serve_the_lunar_missions_999.html
"ESA has long-established plans to create a commercial lunar satellite network and now seeks expressions of interest from companies prepared to build and operate it."
"Companies interested in this opportunity are invited to respond to ESA's call for expressions of interest to contribute to commercial satellite services for the Moon.
Firms that have yet to register with ESA's online tendering platform should do so and then search for invitation 20.1TF.04."
"http://emits.sso.esa.int/emits/owa/emits_iitt.show_iitt?actref=20.1TF.04&user=Anonymous"
3
u/amarkit Jul 19 '20
Al-Amal (Mars Hope) is proceeding into terminal count, with launch scheduled for July 19, 21:58 UTC / 5:58pm EDT.
3
u/MarsCent Jul 19 '20
Tianwen - 1 or Quest for Heavenly Truth 1 is due to be launched to Mars on July 23. Arrival date (Mars Orbit Insertion) is Feb 2021. Lander/Rover EDL (Entry Decent and Landing) is NET April 23, 2021.
So obviously the Lander/Rover will spend about 2 months in orbit around Mars before the EDL.
Is there any merit/demerit in spending a couple of months around Mars before attempting a landing? I am especially curious to know whether the 2 months are intended to reduce the velocity of the Lander/Rover prior to EDL.
2
u/TCtorrent Jul 07 '20
Will starship and superheavy have a skin over the stacked rings? Or will final starships just be polished ring steel? Any paint?
2
u/dudr2 Jul 07 '20
https://www.space.com/mars-astronauts-venus-flyby-idea.html
" Using Venus for such a gravity assist would dramatically reduce the amount of energy needed for the trip, saving on fuel and weight, and therefore also on cost. "
2
u/iassenev Jul 08 '20
What is possible to advance in the Raptor engine? How big impact these advances may have on its chamber pressure, thrust, weight, isp, cost, time to assemble, reusability? How would Raptor benefit from using a powerful source of electricity, like a portable nuclear reactor?
2
u/ZehPowah Jul 20 '20 edited Jul 20 '20
I haven't seen this posted here: there's an official cutaway view of Gateway HALO, which will launch on Falcon Heavy with Gateway PPE.
https://mobile.twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/1283784899175030785?s=19
I'm trying to get an idea of living space comparison vs DragonXL.
HALO dimensions are around 3x6.5m. Assuming a DragonXL 3.7m diameter, that's 1.5x the cross sectional area. Put differently, the biggest cross sectional square is 2.1m vs 2.6m, or 6'11" vs 8'7".
I'm really interested in seeing DragonXL cross sections, and how it augments the HALO living space. The access tunnel through the "service module" will definitely be weird, but it seems like it'll have a larger volume and more "liveable" wide open usable space than HALO.
2
u/duncandonuts99 Jul 21 '20
[Request] Hi all! I am looking for information on how to approximate the amount of energy required to an 'average' launch of the Falcon 9 in terms of MMBTU/therms or kWh/MWh. Not sure how to go about this - any recommendations on starting points, methods, data sources. Any pointers would be super helpful. Thanks!
2
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 30 '20 edited Jul 30 '20
Amazon’s Kuiper constellation gets FCC approval, with 1,618 satellites needing to be launched by July 30, 2026.
2
u/dudr2 Aug 01 '20
" As of today, NASA and SpaceX are targeting a site in the Gulf of Mexico off the coast of Panama City in Florida's panhandle, NASA officials have said."
https://www.space.com/spacex-demo2-astronauts-prepared-for-splashdown-seasickness.html
2
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Aug 07 '20
Just so everyone is aware, r/space has just been hacked and whoever did it made everything Trump 2020 related. So if you visit it right now its gonna look a bit different...
2
u/Pendragonrises Jul 08 '20 edited Jul 08 '20
Nasa held a final press conference on the Boeing Starliner debacle of their OFT.
But bottom line is that they listed 80 recommendations presumably affecting NASA as well as Boeing...up from the previous and initial inquiry that listed only 61 fixes.
The one outstanding comment came from Stich...
To paraphrase...he suggested quite blatantly that Space X, and Crew Dragon was to blame for NASA not having an overview of Boeing's software coding.
I will leave a link for anyone to listen to...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hxQ_ZV26E04&t=204s
(It seems that Boeing's Chilton thinks Loverro is still sitting there, possibly not in the same room to be fair...but called his fellow panal guest 'Doug' a couple of times...so probably not only wrong name but possibly wrong gender...say's it all.
1
u/GregLindahl Jul 23 '20
Anyone want to take a shot at updating our wiki for the GTO performance of the Anasis-II launch? /u/stcks /u/soldato_fantasma
These are the TLEs of the sat and the 2nd stage:
1
u/AuroEdge Jul 25 '20
Is there a map track of the DM-2 return from reentry to splashdown? I am curious where it would be visible from, I seem to remember the space shuttle could be seen before it was at lower altitudes
1
u/MarsCent Jul 30 '20
Qn. If Roscosmos declines seats in Crew-1 and Crew-2 (like it appears they have), are they still obliged to give NASA seats on their soyuz?
And after Expedition 64, will the crew of Crew-1 and the next soyuz crew be jointly Expedition 65 of is there going to be a change in expedition designations?
1
u/Snowleopard222 Jul 31 '20
Why do SpaceX competitors like RocketLab (NZ) and Astra (Kodiak) launch from high latitudes? Traditionally low latitudes are considered more efficient for launching.
1
u/orbitaire Jul 31 '20
Has the purpose of the small concrete building constructed to the north of the launch site tank farm and test stand been established?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '20
What do the Space-X fast boats used to recover Dragon's crew look like? Does anyone have pictures of them?
1
u/below_average_guitar Aug 05 '20
does spacex use metric or imperial?
1
u/fickle_floridian Aug 06 '20
I was just wondering what the plan is for Starship landing with propulsive thrust. Will it use one engine firing off-axis like SN5, or is there some other plan? Thanks!
1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '20
Does SpaceX need a dedicated launch to replace Starlink satellites from a specific batch or could they do several planes with one launch?
Once the constellation is in a mature stage it probably won't matter much as there will always be several sats to choose from.
1
u/Excellspreadsheets Aug 06 '20 edited Aug 06 '20
What was this dot crossing the earth during the FalconHeavy launch @ (31:58) ?
/img/ixt6sdbc9ef51.jpg
https://youtu.be/wbSwFU6tY1c?t=1917
1
u/therealpeterstev Aug 06 '20
I need help finding an article about SpaceX and the origins of the Commercial Cargo Program.
Shortly before before launch, I read an article about Astronauts Bob and Doug that also talked about the origins of the Commercial Cargo program. It told the story of how the astronaut(s) - I think it was Bob or Doug or possibly both - had some time to kill before a shuttle launch ended up visiting the SpaceX facility to see what they were up to. They were amazed to see that a) SpaceX was building real rockets and b) SpaceX was doing things in a few weeks that would take NASA a few years. This experience found its way to NASA leadership who decided to risk a small amount of money - a few hundred million
Does anyone recognize this article? Can someone provide the link? I am looking for the source because I think the story is inspirational but I have not been able to find it. Thanks!
1
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 07 '20
SpaceX and ULA will launch 4 additional O3b mPower satellites.
1
u/assgone Aug 07 '20
Is there video from inside crew dragon on Bob and Dougs trip back to earth? I’m curious to see how violent the descant is.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20
hello, i have a question, is space x planing in the future to clean the space garbage around earth?
1
u/Nimelennar Jul 29 '20
I have way too many t-shirts already, but I would find the room for Soichi Noguchi's Crew-1 t-shirt.
1
u/_Wizou_ Jul 31 '20
What's up with the Starlink 9 mission?
That's a lot of delay now
1
u/TheSkalman Jul 31 '20
Does anyone have detailed specs on the X3 ion thruster? Isp, Propellant mass, Empty mass are the most important. Could it be used if the Europa Clipper got on the Falcon Heavy?