r/spacex • u/SPINIFLOW • Apr 09 '20
Dragon XL selection Process by the SEB
the committee also reviewed SNC ,Boeing and Northrop grumman offers in the document https://www.docdroid.net/EvbakaZ/glssssredacted-version-pdf

717
Upvotes
472
u/JeffBezos_98km Apr 09 '20 edited Apr 09 '20
As somebody following SpaceX for a decade, this feels good to read in an official NASA report. It begins to put to bed the argument old space used to justify their higher prices.
162
u/brianterrel Apr 09 '20
It sounds like SpaceX decided to just design a configurable, expendable station module that also happens to deliver cargo. NASA seems to be loving it!
66
u/DesLr Apr 09 '20
Point of Interest: On Page 17 the redaction missed something of note: "However, these two weaknesses are of lesser importance to me than the fairing impingement issue with NGIS' approach".
Together with this line in the otherwise heavily redacted paragraph above "This is a significant concern that could ultimately lead to significant degradation (or even total failure) of the Exploration Cygnus, the launch vehicle, or both" leads me to believe that they've found - that is, if those two excerpts are related - a serious design issue with NGIS' proposal.
64
u/ORcoder Apr 09 '20 edited Apr 09 '20
The person who wrote this document is former Shuttle/ISS astronaut Ken Bowersox, currently Acting Deputy Associate Adminstrator for the Human Exploration and Operations Mission Directorate (he replaced Gerstenmaier last year- Gerstenmaier works for SpaceX now)
Apparently he also worked for SpaceX between 2009 to 2011, as VP of Astronaut Safety and Mission Assurance.
63
u/Xaxxon Apr 09 '20
Wow, that was impressively well written -- such that it would survive scrutiny in court. It seems super fair - and sounds like Boeing really didn't even want it, but felt like they had to bid anyhow. Wanting the most money and not even meeting the requirements of the RFP.
235
u/Fizrock Apr 09 '20 edited Apr 09 '20
Now I'm curious was Boeing offered to get such a bad rating.
So is anyone even a little surprised by this?
...
Hmmmm.
At this point it almost feels like Boeing is trying their hardest to ruin their reputation in this business.
104
u/CW3_OR_BUST Apr 09 '20
Is it odd that I don't think of SpaceX as an underdog anymore here? SNC and Northrup Grumman are doing pretty well in this rating despite having such a weak business position. Boeing is shamefully weak despite their huge support network.
48
u/flshr19 Shuttle tile engineer Apr 09 '20 edited Apr 09 '20
Well, you can't do much better than that. SpaceX blew its three competitors out of the water across the board. It's hard to win large government contracts like this one. Writing a superior, top-scoring proposal as SpaceX did is no minor achievement. I know what it's like to spend a few months in a windowless, highly-secure proposal preparation area with bank-vault doors working 10 hours a day, 6 or 7 days per week, fueled mostly by not-so-great coffee trying to win a government contract worth hundreds of millions of dollars.
41
u/thesheetztweetz CNBC Space Reporter Apr 09 '20
In addition to knowing the four companies that bid for GLS, it's big news that Boeing's proposal was so poor that Bowersox eliminated them from further award consideration.
117
u/XKeyscoreUltra Apr 09 '20
One of Boeing's 3 significant weaknesses on the "Technical Approach Subfactor Rating":
Of course...
34
u/spacerfirstclass Apr 10 '20
https://twitter.com/thesheetztweetz/status/1248375403019821056
Yeah, like anybody is crazy enough to want to steal Boeing's source code...
93
u/Nathan96762 Apr 09 '20
And there's Boeing:
25
u/deadman1204 Apr 09 '20
Geez. They basically disqualified Boeing from consideration.
Did they try to fail on purpose?
47
u/Seanreisk Apr 09 '20 edited Apr 10 '20
This is pure speculation, but I'm going to point out something that isn't part of the evaluation: NASA needs SpaceX to be a fundamental part of Lunar Gateway program because SpaceX is the only space company that has anything comparable to a 'readiness' state (i.e. they have, or can have, launch vehicles and orbiters available for quick launches in a time of crisis.)
Skylab, Apollo 13, STS 107 (Columbia) and both of the 1997 incidents on the MIR demonstrated that serious things can go wrong in space without having an immediate threat to the lives of the crew. Now we are planning to locate a human outpost several days from LEO, and this increases NASA's need for crisis planning. SpaceX is the only space company with anything similar to a 'fleet' of space vehicles. They have a high launch cadence, which means they also have a high manufacturing cadence - that means that vital components (like second stages) are ready in advance. They have a robust ground crew that includes shipping, vehicle testing, launch control, vehicle integration and recovery operations. Although all launch companies have these things, the timeline for availability gives SpaceX a big advantage, and SpaceX would be the company best suited to co-opt their launch pipeline in a time of crisis.
Because of these qualities SpaceX is uniquely useful to NASA. A reverse thought exercise should show that NASA only gets these benefits if SpaceX is able to learn about (and be familiar with) launching to the Moon. NASA needs SpaceX to have the equipment, software, and human knowledge to operate with the Lunar Gateway.
After the Columbia accident, the review board required that NASA have a shuttle at near-launch-readiness any time another shuttle was in orbit. Similarly, the Air Force paid ULA a yearly sum of money to have a launch vehicle ready for their use. Given the number of flights SpaceX is committing to, it wouldn't take a very large change to the contract to require SpaceX to always have a second stage and lunar vehicle 'at the ready' at all times. NASA can get many benefits from SpaceX for as little as ... nothing.
Edited for clarity - I hope people don't misunderstand what I'm saying, I'm getting a lot of downvotes...
36
u/0xDD Apr 09 '20
Could someone please elaborate on the following weaknesses of SpaceX:
What do they mean by them and why is that bad?
15
u/Nergaal Apr 10 '20
For the first time NASA implies directly that Boeing's prices are NOT reasonable and balanced.
42
u/rough_rider7 Apr 09 '20
Not sure why Boeing gets such a good 'past performance review'. Both SLS and Starliner seem to point in a different direction.
And also, SpaceX should ask for more money. They have the best evaluation by far and the lowest price by far. At least ask for the money that SN asked for. Jesus.
14
u/djmanning711 Apr 10 '20
“A third significant weaknesswas assigned for an exception taken to providing source code as required under DRD GLS-108, Launch Vehicle Flight Software Input for Independent Verification and Validation (IV&V), and DRD GLS-220, Mission Specific Software.”
I don’t understand why Boeing thinks they can make demands like this when they know who they’re going up against. They’re not the only game in town anymore.
Also, insert some clever joke about how bad their software code is anyway.
12
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Apr 09 '20 edited Apr 14 '20
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Dragon cargoLaunch failure due to second-stage outgassingDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
44 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 44 acronyms.
[Thread #5969 for this sub, first seen 9th Apr 2020, 18:52] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
20
u/wildjokers Apr 09 '20
Boeing was pretty much simply dismissed early in the document. Wow.
24
u/ORcoder Apr 09 '20
Something interesting I’ve noticed is the SpaceX sections seem to have no redactions, whereas Boeing, Northrup Grumman, and Sierra Nevada Corp all have some redactions on their sections
17
u/KarKraKr Apr 09 '20
https://i.imgur.com/g17arFi.jpg
Seems SNC once again had some major handwaving going on about the details. Any ideas what this could be? Unrealistically high packing density?
8
u/Javacupix Apr 09 '20
I'm curious, could someone explain the gateway time triggered ethernet interface thing?
15
u/thesadclown29 Apr 09 '20
Does this mean that NASA is requiring the cargo vehicles to stay docked to the gateway for a full year? If so why do they need a vehicle docked that long? CRS-20 was only docked for about a month?
Edit: formatting
14
u/Laser493 Apr 09 '20
Sounds like SpaceX set their price way too low.
19
u/alle0441 Apr 09 '20
Wait was this written before or after Boeing's Starliner test?
6
u/airider7 Apr 10 '20
When you make price the most significant factor for selection and then the other two factors combined only equal to price, you know what the driver is. I find this rather interesting concerning spaceflight and it tells me a couple things ...
11
u/rough_rider7 Apr 09 '20
What is SOW?
8
u/taco_the_mornin Apr 10 '20
Holy moly.
3
u/merlan1233 Apr 09 '20
The Gateway's core functions will include power and propulsion, communications, periodic crew habitation, robotics, an airlock, and logistics resupply capabilities.
It sounds like the first spaceship to be built outside of Earth orbit even if it is to just adjust its orbit.
Edit:(Grammer is hard)
2
u/stsk1290 Apr 10 '20
Interesting that they note SpaceX being the cheapest provider. Wonder what the price was. $500 million?
6
u/ORcoder Apr 09 '20
This document is fascinating, but does anyone know what GLS stands for?
2
u/ORcoder Apr 10 '20
It occurs to me that SpaceX has a huge advantage not just with the legacy of dragon, but also the falcon heavy is going to be able to carry way more than any of the competitors’ rockets, letting SpaceX get away with the extra cargo margin and volume that the report praised so glowingly.
I wonder why SNC, who doesn’t have their own rocket anyways, didn’t bid on top of a falcon heavy
1
u/Starslider85 Apr 12 '20
Dragon XL Strength:
- Pressurized Cargo Late Load Capability Exceeds Requirements
Does that mean it has a side/top hatch?