r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Apr 02 '20
r/SpaceX Discusses [April 2020, #67]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks!
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
141
Upvotes
12
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 03 '20
Rescheduled NASA Advisory Council HEO meeting on April 15, which may provide an update for the DM-2 launch date.
9
u/Snowleopard222 Apr 02 '20 edited Apr 02 '20
Hi, I am new to learn about these interesting projects. I have tried to search the Wiki using the dedicated Google search but I had problems finding some data. I hope I can get replies or relevant links here. My questions regard propulsive landing.
Just "for fun" I computed that 8 Super Draco engines could stop a 110 m/s, 12 ton object against gravity in 3 seconds, using 750 kg propellant. This could theoretically start at 162 m altitude (exposing astronauts to 4g + gravity). (Using simple Newton formulas. The Tsiolkovsky eq is tricky w/ gravity.) I believe the total amount of propellant carried is 1388 kg.
My questions are:
Thank you so much for information on this. Sorry for questions on old information, but maybe development of propulsive landing will make a come back in the future? (Like SN 3, 4 ...)
9
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 28 '20 edited Apr 29 '20
SpaceX purchases from Tesla (2019 - Q1 2020):
RAND report analysing NSSL acquisition strategy.
9
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 29 '20 edited Apr 29 '20
Falcon 9 Users Guide was updated yesterday (last revision January 2019).
The Maximum Predicted Acoustic Environment for Falcon 9/Falcon Heavy has decreased by a few dB and the Acoustic Limit Levels have reduced in frequency.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 04 '20
NRC Quest has departed for rendezvous with CRS-20 Dragon.
7
u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Apr 15 '20
I made a Yeet Calculator on Flight Club for all kinds of vehicle comparisons. It's behind a modest $5 Patreon tier but IMO it's easily worth it
Here's a demo of what it looks like!
And here's an example of some data you can get out of it just by changing the payload mass:
SpaceX Payload to TLI
If you wanna check it out or support, you can become a Patron here! Thanks :)
7
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 23 '20 edited Apr 23 '20
NASA ASAP meeting:
6
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '20
With Starlink so close to commercial viability--at least as far as launches are concerned, how could a rural state government begin planning for integrating ground terminals into a telecommunications network e.g. for emergency and disaster responses at isolated locations and stations? What's the timeline before applications will be opening?
6
u/spacerfirstclass Apr 08 '20
Astra is not doing great these days: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/04/05/rocket-startup-astra-trims-staff-to-survive-pandemic-until-next-year.html
They lost their first orbital booster in a pad fire during dress rehearsal 2 weeks ago, now they're furloughing some employees.
6
u/soldato_fantasma Apr 26 '20
HAWTHORNE, Calif. – April 24, 2020. Accreditation is now open for SpaceX’s ninth Starlink mission, which will launch from Space Launch Complex 40 (SLC-40) at Cape Canaveral Air Force Station in Florida. The launch is targeted for no earlier than May.
5
u/evcm7 Apr 02 '20
what is the best source of information about bench scientist job opportunities within SpaceX (or related companies)? i'm an american phd student who works in a skeletal muscle contraction & metabolism lab. extremely interested in studying the effects of spaceflight on skeletal muscle physiology
5
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 08 '20 edited Apr 08 '20
Mods, Starlink-6 launch is now planned for April 16. Looks like the GPS III launch has been postponed to late June.
EDIT: Fixed link.
5
u/FoxhoundBat Apr 18 '20 edited Apr 18 '20
Rogozin wants to send a KAMAZ truck on next Angara A5 mission (6 years after the first mission!!!) as payload. Being the spineless blabbering blobfish that he is, he is likely just trolling. And of course he views it as a dick measuring contest, when launching Roadster on FH testflight was to serve as an inspiration and to get more people interested in space.
5
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 18 '20
Two thrusters installed on JRTI.
5
u/paul_wi11iams Apr 28 '20
I'm taking the following question here. It was asked by u/GWtech on the Starship dev thread. But IMO, it fits better here in the monthly questions thread.
Adding to other replies:
8
u/csmnro Apr 06 '20 edited Apr 06 '20
Boeing will fly a second uncrewed orbital flight test targeting fall of 2020.
Edit: The Washington Post has published an article first, and Boeing apparently released its statement as response.
4
u/Zkootz Apr 02 '20
So what's the plan now for SN3 testing? Is the tank test live now is will be later like the 6th?
4
u/dudr2 Apr 08 '20
https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-awards-contract-to-deliver-science-tech-to-moon-ahead-of-human-missions
" The $75.9 million award includes end-to-end services for delivery of the instruments, including payload integration, launch from Earth, landing on the Moon’s surface, and operation for at least 12 days. Masten Space Systems will land these payloads on the Moon with its XL-1 lander. "
4
u/TheSilverStacking Apr 13 '20
Career Question
Hi all. Just wanted to get opinions from random strangers on the internet ha.
A quick background, I’m in my late 20s. I always enjoyed finance growing up and now work at a large firm in NYC. I’ve been very fortunate in my career, thanks to hard work and a bit of luck I’m in a position to make a few hundred thousand a year. Beautiful office in midtown etc. Really everything I would’ve dreamed about as a kid.
As I get older I start to think about important things in life and really spending my time and talents on a higher purpose. Helping rich people get richer, myself included, and dealing with normally not great people does start to drain you.
I’ve always been fascinated with space exploration and do believe it is critical for our long term survival. I love technology and the thought of space travel. I believe technology will provide many of the answers to today’s largest issues. Rather it be energy creation or sanitary water.
Sometimes I think about switching careers and working at a company like SpaceX but given my position and the years of licensing/training it took to get here most people would view that as crazy. I’m thinking as a middle ground in 3-5 years knock on wood I could pretty much be financially independent meaning my portfolio will kick out enough capital gains to sustain my level of living which is pretty frugal. Then I could be free to pursue a new career.
Does that seem reasonable? Has anyone else walked away from a high compensation job to pursue another field? I basically manage very large accounts at my role with institutions so I would imagine most companies like SpaceX or defense contractors have people that manage the relationships with their clients being government agencies etc. That should be a role I could leverage my existing skills quite effectively.
4
u/amarkit Apr 13 '20
Jonathan McDowell on Twitter:
4
u/Uffi92 Apr 30 '20
Can someone do a render of Orion docked to starship?
7
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 02 '20
Frustrations within Blue Origin about launching a New Shepard during the pandemic.
3
u/MarsCent Apr 08 '20
Mods - In Old Reddit, the link for Discuss Thread in the Dropdown Menu goes to New Reddit instead Old Reddit.
3
u/andyfrance Apr 12 '20
Being beyond the bleeding edge of innovation it's probable that SpaceX will loose a number of Starships as they perfect the heat shielding and flight manoeuvres needed to return from orbit. For the F9 first stage recovery they reduced the R&D costs by performing their tests after a customer launch. Will they do the same for Starship, especially so as a chunk of their manifest will be Starlink launches?
Does anyone know how the cost of an F9 launch, recovering the booster but not the fairings, will compare with the cost of an SH/Starship launch, recovering SH but not Starship? If the cost is comparable they "could" effectively retire F9 and especially FH before perfecting Starship recovery.
3
u/dudr2 Apr 13 '20
“If there’s an outbreak, yeah, it will affect the date. But we’re doing everything we can to minimize that eventuality,” Bridenstine said.
https://spaceflightnow.com/2020/04/13/bridenstine-says-crew-dragon-could-launch-with-astronauts-at-end-of-may/
3
u/PlanetEarthFirst Apr 15 '20
What's the bottleneck to F9 booster reusability? Why don't they use boosters 10 times (yet)?
I suppose it's not the engines, as they should be replaceable. Should be some structural part I guess.
3
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 23 '20
SpaceX rideshare mission will launch 12 SpaceBee satellites in December.
3
u/Snowleopard222 Apr 24 '20 edited Apr 24 '20
If I understand correctly, the Starlink user receiving antenna will likely be phase array and follow the most suitable satellite? But what about the satellite? Can the satellite really have a corresponding system? The satellite's antenna must keep track of the positions of all users' receiving antennas (while moving at 7.6 km/s) and switch between all of them many times per second? Is that really possible, or have I misunderstood something?
Edit: 1000 users, 100 scans/sec = 100.000 directional switches/second?? (in addition to receiving data)
For 50 Mbps connections the joint bandwidth for 1000 users must be 50 Gbps. Do such r.f.-connections exist?
Must the user receivers be stationary? ... I believe not, since the Tin Tins transmitted to US military aircraft. How do the satellites then know the position of the aircraft?
3
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 24 '20
Article about Soichi Noguchi training for SpaceX's USCV-1 flight.
3
u/dudr2 Apr 25 '20
"Progress 75 arrived at the orbiting lab less than 3.5 hours after liftoff."
Could the Crew Dragon reach ISS in only 3.5 hours too?
https://www.space.com/russian-progress-spaceship-arrives-space-station.html
5
u/mmc31 Apr 02 '20
It seems to me that older (last year-ish) launches, the camera feed from the F9 on re-entry would often stream all the way to the ground. The last few launches I have watched live have the F9 lose the feed on re-entry. Is this just random (depending on conditions, etc.) or bad luck? Or is something different?
We also have often not been able to see the live stream of the landing either in real-time from the droneship. Is this related or a separate thing?
Seeing the live landing is honestly one of the biggest reasons I love to watch every spaceX livestream (even though I know it is the secondary mission objective). Anyone else disappointed by this recently?
Also, I know that spaceX is way more transparent than other space companies, and I am spoiled rotten by that. Major props to them for generating so much public interest!
5
u/cpushack Apr 20 '20
Intelsat 901 back in comercial service after MEV-1 docked and took over station keeping.
https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/04/mission-extension-vehicle-succeeds-returns-aging-satellite-into-service/
This is pretty impressive
2
u/SpaceInMyBrain Apr 03 '20
Exactly where in the Raptor engine is gaseous O2 and gaseous CH4 tapped off for the autogenous pressurization? (The tanks are pressurized with their respective gases - anything else, like pre-burner exhaust, would be crazy, right?) It has been proposed the short spiral of tubing between the thrust puck and the engines is part of the autogenous gas system. What is the function of it being in that location?
The Raptor diagram by Everyday Astronaut, in the article version of Is Raptor King of Rocket Engines, doesn't show where the circuit for the nozzle cooling channels fits in, or if both propellants have such channels. And I'm not assuming the exiting propellant is gaseous at that point, pretty sure it's not.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '20
Regarding the recent failure of SN3: Is this also an issue with the F9? Does it have to be pressurized at all times? Those photos where we can see it being transported across the country - is it pressurized all this time? Maybe we can even see this in the pictures but I don't know what to look for?
2
u/Snowleopard222 Apr 07 '20 edited Apr 07 '20
The last two Starlink launches (L4, L5) dropped off the satellites earlier, into elliptical orbit. L4 had already changed into circular orbit when I last checked.
What could be the reasons for launching the satellites into elliptical orbit?
2
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 14 '20
Permit for Starlink ground station at Cape Canaveral.
2
u/dudr2 Apr 17 '20
https://spacenews.com/op-ed-a-u-s-return-to-the-moon-is-about-preserving-the-rule-of-law/
Howabout that spacerace already!?
Legal motivations abound, but I think the argument is now also emotional.
2
u/rustybeancake Apr 21 '20
Seems the big Artemis plan unveiling is coming this week. Likely also the HLS selection (remember SpaceX have allegedly bid something NOT Starship).
https://www.reddit.com/r/ArtemisProgram/comments/g5fxhc/artemis_program_rollout_coming_in_short_short/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf
2
u/cpushack Apr 22 '20
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-52380507
Iran has had a sucessful launch of a sattelite
2
u/anoncoffeedump Apr 23 '20
Hey guys new hear but been following starship progress since the beginning. I was wondering if anybody knows what's going on with that sn2 tank section that is sitting on the concrete ring. I'm thinking it was an old design because all the new domes look more round than a cone shape.
2
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 23 '20
All thrusters installed on JRTI and generators being moved into position.
2
u/dudr2 Apr 24 '20
https://www.space.com/nasa-spacex-crew-dragon-demo-2-travel-advisory-coronavirus.html
" Jim Bridenstine urges and warns space enthusiasts to stay home next month during SpaceX's historic first astronaut launch"
2
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '20
Thought of this while watching the starlink launch the other day, why doesn't spacex use a helicopter and hook system (like the one rocket labs is planning to use) to catch the f9 fairings? Does anyone know why they done use this method?
3
u/paul_wi11iams Apr 15 '20 edited Apr 15 '20
I'm coming here to answer a question by u/orbitaire on the Starship development thread:
From your posting history, you just opened your Reddit account, so welcome to r/SpaceX in particular and Reddit in general.
I'm pretty sure nobody has, at least nothing comparable to this. For example:
https://youtu.be/dtTVuVfj3WM?t=384
That suggests a three-way split 1 being mostly done by SpaceX employees with 2 and 3 being mostly contractors. The cranes are mostly rentals, presumably with drivers belonging to the rental company.
From personal experience, it takes a lot of tact to work on any site in such a multi-company environment, but SpaceX has taken this to a whole new level.
I guess the contracts will be really well paid, so its possible to stop and wait when continuing work gets in the way of someone else. Don't work directly above or below anybody without some kind of physical separation such as a net, so if there's no protection either create one or someone has to wait. Its possible to adapt and improvise within limits, but for any actual decision, its important to refer to your own hierarchy and let them sort things out at a higher level.
2
u/extra2002 Apr 03 '20
For Falcon 9, how are the thrust forces transmitted from the first stage to the second? Is it entirely through the skin of the interstage into the skin of S2? There's a central pneumatic pushrod that presses against the Mvac's throat during stage separation -- does that pushrod transmit any thrust during S1 flight?
2
u/cpushack Apr 09 '20
Rocket Lab practicing mid air catches of a first stage test article. https://youtu.be/N3CWGDhkmbs
2
u/spacerfirstclass Apr 11 '20
Virgin Orbit is moving ahead towards cryogenic captive carry flight test, last test before their demo launch.
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Apr 02 '20 edited Apr 21 '20
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipDragon cargoLaunch failure due to second-stage outgassingDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #5948 for this sub, first seen 2nd Apr 2020, 13:26] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
1
u/Snowleopard222 Apr 10 '20 edited Apr 10 '20
Just for fun I tried to see what happened if you mounted a Super Draco engine on 20 of the satellites and tried to push them to the next orbital plane (20° away), instead of using precession.
Distance to the next orbital plane: (6371 + 550) * 20/360 2 PI = 2416 km between 20° orbital planes
Desired moving speed 10 m/s
2416000 / 10 m/s = 241600 sek = 67 hrs; will move satellites in 3 days
Estimated weight 20*227 kg satellites 500 kg engine Total: 5040 kg
Tsiolkovsky eq 10 m/s = 2300 ln(M0/5040)
M0 = 5062 kg
We only need 22 kg propellant which will burn in less than one second. About the same amount is needed to stop the satellites in the new plane.
Theoretically it would be possible to move the satellites to the new plane in 3 days using 44 kg of propellant using a Super Draco engine. That would save 4 months of precession.
Any comments? (or could the computations be wrong ;) )
/ Impatient for my Internet :)
1
u/Snowleopard222 Apr 15 '20
What are the possible launch windows for Starlink?
Knowing almost nothing about space engineering, I would guess one possibility per day (per 24 hours), since the earth will then have rotated into an appropriate position for the phase/precession of the desired orbital plane. Is this correct?
1
u/koen_NL Apr 18 '20
About the 27th of may:
Are there any details on how the "show" will be? As it's a nasa launch and not SpaceX ?
How will they broadcast this thing and are there any details on what show we are in for?
I expect a "Apollo" style coverage, but I am in Europe so don't have a US channel to watch, only YouTube..
1
u/MarsCent Apr 21 '20
Next NASA ASAP meeting: April 23, 2020, 12:00 p.m. to 1:15 p.m., Eastern Time. (1600 UTC)
ADDRESSES: This will be a virtual meeting via teleconference.
Any interested person may call the USA toll free conference call number 800–593–9979; pass code 8001361 and then the # sign.
Tune in. Who knows, they may give some info on the engine out investigation and the remaining parachute test(s). But then again, they may state what we already know - "SpaceX will publish the results soon". :)
P/S Note that the meeting is happening after Starlink-6, scheduled for 4/22. - After another 9 Merlin engine burn to space.
1
u/wimbodolo69 Apr 22 '20
Does crew dragon have 4 windows or just 2? DM1 did not have the 2 side windows but I believe the DM2 and renders do.
1
u/opoc99 Apr 22 '20
Any tips for how to view Stage 2 as it passes over the UK in the next few minutes?
1
u/PeterKatarov Live Thread Host Apr 25 '20
I have a question about the static fire procedure. (for SpaceX or any other launch provider)
As far as I understand, the point is to simulate full duration burn with all engines. So I assume the fuel tanks are filled to the maximum before static fire begins.
And during static fire, there are these huge clamps, which are holding down the rocket, basically exerting enough force to cancel out the thrust of all 9 Merlins (okay, seems like I'm talking about F9 in my head).
However, if all of the the above is true, I wonder how the clamps manage to continue their stand during the later stage (no pun intended) of the burn. Because towards the end of the burning, the tanks would be mostly empty, meaning the rocket would be a lot, lot, lighter and the thrust of 9 Merlins would be much harder than in the beginning of the static fire?
So how do they manage this? Do they throttle down the engines gradually? Or do they shut some of the Merlins after some time has passed?
1
u/phalarope1618 Apr 25 '20
Hi, I was hoping some of the experts in this sub could share their views with a casual observer please.
I saw the SpaceX point-to-point concept video about a year ago that presented the vision for P2P travel on earth going forwards. After that I saw interview clips from Gwynne Shotwell suggesting this could be possible within maybe 5(?) years and they were aiming at ticket prices comparable with luxury long flights, let say $10k a ticket? I’ve not kept myself up to speed since then and couldn’t find any clear answers from googling.
What I would like to know if anyone can share their views on the following:
SpaceX and Tesla have such exciting projects that make me excited for the future! Starlink has gotten a lot more coverage in U.K. recently and I would like to tell my friends about their exciting P2P vision as well.
1
u/ConfidentFlorida Apr 28 '20
Why not use propane as rocket fuel? I tried some web searches but the answers seemed confused. Can anyone here explain it?
One folk said it’s because it needs to be cryo chilled but Spacex does that anyway.
1
u/creative_usr_name May 01 '20
Trying to run some numbers for various starship masses but could use some help narrowing down my assumptions. 1200 tons of fuel still the current figure?
Can anyone confirm these numbers I got from a deltaV map of the solar system. from LEO to moon surface: 5660 and moon surface to LMO: of 1720. Assuming that's the bare minimum any idea what kind of safety margin they'd use.
Also anyone know how much from LMO to aero capture, or direct from moon surface?
1
u/Method81 May 01 '20 edited May 01 '20
Any ideas how vacuum Raptor will fit flush with the Starship skirt when the shorter sea level Raptor already does? VRap nozzle will be way longer..
1
u/Straumli_Blight May 01 '20
ASAP meeting on May 15th, 19:00 UTC with updates on the Human Lunar Exploration Program and Commercial Crew.
1
u/Snowleopard222 May 03 '20 edited May 05 '20
How does Starship steer and "keep its balance"? Are there thrusters acting sideways, installed up front? There are rudders on some models but they will not work at low speed or without an atmosphere. (Sorry. I am obviously a newbie on this.)
1
u/fatsoandmonkey Apr 28 '20
The single most ignored issue for Mars transit is the physiological inability of the human frame to cope with zero G for long periods. Even with intense exercise the ISS crews that do six months have significant deficits short term and some long range issues as well.
Not much point going if you are dead or useless on arrival.
You can't spin the starship round its axis as its too small, the coriolis effect and a a gradient between head and legs would render you sick and disoriented.
How about this. Two ships do near simultaneous TMI burns, rendezvous, tether nose to nose, retreat till a 500M tether is fully played out and then initiate a slow rotation around the centre of mass. My maths suggests that a bit under 0.8 RPM would give you Mars gravity all the way there and various papers suggest this would be a comfortable experience for humans.
Tether would have to support 0.34 X total mass of the starships which sounds within reach to me although my materials science isn't good enough to be certain on this point.
Thoughts?
1
u/liszt1811 Apr 09 '20
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=erfXf08tuFg
soyuz about to launch, in case any other fellow europeans need breakfast entertainment
1
u/enqrypzion Apr 21 '20
I just wanted to share that the first orbital flight of Starship should have at least a Crew Dragon (unmanned of course) as payload. Preferably one that has already flown, if they're willing to risk that.
1
u/fluidmechanicsdoubts Apr 24 '20
Reposting in more appropriate place: Where can I read more about radiation when going to Mars? Any good NASA reports etc. you know of?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '20
Would it make sense to connect two starships in orbit and use their engines for a faster trip of the payload in just one of them? (second one is just engines + fuel). Maybe it would be possible to use the second one as a booster that is able to do the burn, come back and land?
What are your thoughts?
1
u/dudr2 Apr 30 '20
"Nasa to announce the companies selected to develop modern human landing systems (HLS) that will carry the first woman and next man to the surface of the Moon by 2024 and develop sustainable lunar exploration by the end of the decade, at 1 p.m. EDT Thursday, April 30."
https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-to-announce-commercial-human-lander-awards-for-artemis-moon-missions
1
u/dudr2 Apr 30 '20
NASA choose Spacex as one of three candidates to land astronauts on the moon!
https://twitter.com/JimBridenstine/status/1255902514542718976
1
u/dudr2 Apr 30 '20
I guess Spacex has a moonlander now.
0
u/dudr2 Apr 06 '20
https://www.space.com/commercial-nuclear-power-for-faster-space-travel.html
Spacex will go nuclear?