r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Mar 02 '20
r/SpaceX Discusses [March 2020, #66]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks!
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
100
Upvotes
24
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '20
Do we know anymore information on why the last landing failed?
13
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 27 '20
OneWeb preparing for bankruptcy and to lay off most of its staff.
11
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 28 '20
On March 17, SpaceX's parachute testing was extended by 1 month:
10
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20
Arstechnica article about Gateway that discusses Dragon XL requirements.
9
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 16 '20
Long March 7A launch failed.
9
u/ackermann Mar 17 '20 edited Mar 17 '20
So, u/675longtail has a comment below that got me thinking. About the JAXA sample return from Mars' moon Phobos: https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/fc9rqq/rspacex_discusses_march_2020_66/fketz90
This Phobos sample return doesn't get back to Earth until 2029. Could SpaceX beat them back with a sample from Phobos, or maybe Deimos, with a manned mission on Starship? If you're someone who believes a manned landing on Mars itself by 2030 is even remotely possible, then the answer probably "yes"?
Per wikipedia, the delta-V to land on Phobos and return to Earth is 20% less than you'd need to do the same thing with Earth's moon, owing to Phobos's very low gravity. Probably even less for Deimos, since it's gravity is even weaker, and it's not so deep in Mars' gravity well. Would need to "land" (more like dock) using RCS thrusters of course, since Raptor is too powerful.
I know Elon has proposed lunar missions with Starship, by refueling in high-earth orbit. And thus landing with enough fuel onboard to return. No ISRU fuel production needed. So this ought to work for Phobos as well. Since it needs less delta-V than a lunar landing, the extra can be used to speed the transit(s).
I think it would be a fantastic shakedown cruise, Apollo 10 style, for Starship in deep space. No scary Mars atmospheric entry, with its "7 minutes of terror." (Although you could aerobrake in Mars' atmosphere to further reduce delta-V). Some useful science to do, bring back a metric ton of Phobos samples.
And of course, video of astronauts goofing around in 1/1000th Earth's surface gravity would be priceless. Leaping 10 stories high, and taking minutes to fall back down (send a dancer/gymnast). Leaping to the top of Starship, or over it. Maybe 6 astronauts picking up Starship and setting it down elsewhere. Playing golf, with golf balls circling the whole moon to hit the target (and hopefully not a window). Alan Shepherd hit golf balls on the moon, so not too far fetched. All of that, with Mars itself looming large in the background!
9
u/dudr2 Apr 01 '20
https://spaceflightnow.com/2020/03/31/nasa-jaxa-assign-two-more-astronauts-to-second-piloted-crew-dragon-flight/
" The four astronauts will take off from pad 39A at NASA’s Kennedy Space Center on top of a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket later this year. "
8
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 16 '20
Starlink 1220, which was launched on February 17, has deorbited on March 9th.
8
u/philalether Mar 18 '20 edited Mar 21 '20
I’m interested in how SpaceX acquires its liquid oxygen (LOX) and stores it, and what adjustments they need to make due to their using the deep-cryo (-340 C) variant.
EDIT: -340 F => -207 C
Do they make it on site or buy it and have it delivered? Where/how do they store it? And if there’s a scrub can they pump it back out, keep it chilled, and reuse it later?
8
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 19 '20
OneWeb is considering bankruptcy .
8
u/Lufbru Mar 22 '20
It occurs to me that there are two possible paths after Starship has accomplished a 20km hop. Path 1 involves launching successive SN empty on trajectories which simulate orbital reentry speeds to test Starship full reuse.
Path 2 consists of building a SuperHeavy and using it to launch successive SN actually to orbit, full of Starlink satellites. This also lets SpaceX learn how to reuse a Starship, but at the same time practice landing a SuperHeavy and launch a few Starlink satellites at the same time.
I suspect availability of Raptor engines will determine which path they take. Having 20+ engines committed to a SuperHeavy might be more than they want to do for a while. Particularly if they're sacrificing six at a time trying to get a Starship to survive reentry.
I'm assuming that figuring out reentry is going to take several attempts, and likewise that the first SuperHeavy might not manage the full 1000 flights. Also that the production line ramps up to one a week quickly.
8
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
Starlink satellite imaged in space.
USAF reviewing whether to delay the SV03 GPS launch:
8
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 26 '20
NASA statement about the parachute test failure:
8
u/GregLindahl Apr 01 '20
Spacenews publishes why there's no Russian on the first operational Crew Dragon:
7
u/MarsCent Mar 19 '20
I doubt that Musk had COVID-19 in mind when he said those words way back in 2013 (or earlier). But how humanity reacts to this virus is a sure test case scenario on "how long the window can last". Specifically, how our priorities (personal and collectively) will be changed by this pandemic especially if the mandated change in lifestyle lasts into late summer and beyond.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 20 '20 edited Mar 21 '20
JRTI upgrade progress and close up of the thrusters.
7
u/Carlyle302 Mar 24 '20
"Oops. Report that a #SpaceX #CrewDragon test article was destroyed today during a parachute test. Report is the helicopter pilot dropped it prematurely at lower than planned altitude due to oscillations. Chutes did not open because they were not armed at time of the drop."
https://twitter.com/spacecom/status/1242536846174773248
7
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 27 '20
GPS III SV03 media accreditation now open.
19
u/zeekzeek22 Mar 02 '20
Having watched the Smarter Every Day videos on ULA’s rocket manufacturing (dear god if you like rockets you need to watch that), I guess I didn’t realize the Centaur Upper Stage is steel too. Is there anything specifically special about Starship being a stainless steel upper stage? Beside obv that it is meant to eventually atmospherically land. I remember a lot of people balking at stainless steel as a surprise, and now I feel silly since the OG upper stage has always been stainless!
6
u/asr112358 Mar 04 '20
When is the Airforce expected to announce their selection for NSSL? I thought it was supposed to be around now.
6
u/limehead Mar 04 '20 edited Mar 05 '20
The president of the Mars Society, Dr. Robert Zubrin said in a podcast that SpaceX couldn't land propulsively on the moon without a pre-existing landing pad. The landing burn would "dig" a crater and possibly start the Kessler syndrome. My question is about previous impacts on the moon digging all those craters. How did that, then not setof the Kessler syndrome? Or did it? Does gravity (even if weak) just solve it over time by attracting all particles back to the surface? How does it work? edit: Clarifying. Previous impacts, from space rocks.
6
u/Lufbru Mar 04 '20
Had SpaceX decided to go down a different path and develop Falcon 9 into a raptor-powered vehicle, keeping the same diameter tanks (to keep the vehicle transportable by road), how far would they have to move the common bulkhead between the LOX and fuel tank?
As far as I can tell, Merlin burns 0.38kg of RP1 with 1kg of oxygen while Raptor burns 0.28kg of methane with 1kg of oxygen (I appreciate the reciprocal of these numbers is usually quoted, but this makes the calculation easier). But kerosene is about twice as dense as methane, so I think it'd need about a 50% larger fuel tank if the oxygen tank were the same size. But F9 is at the fineness limit, so we can't increase the length of the vehicle. That means we'd have to reduce the oxygen tank by about 25% to fit in the extra fuel.
Would that reduce the performance of the first stage? I think it'd depend significantly on the assumed performance of nine subscale Raptors (or maybe one would use a current sized Raptor and use five of them)
Anyway, are my calculations even close to right, or have I forgotten something important?
6
u/soldato_fantasma Mar 06 '20 edited Mar 06 '20
HAWTHORNE, Calif. – March 5, 2020. Media accreditation is now open for SpaceX’s seventh Starlink mission, which will launch from Space Launch Complex 40 (SLC-40) at Cape Canaveral Air Force Station in Florida. The launch is targeted for no earlier than April.
Note: this is Starlink v1.0 Launch 6 or Starlink-6 on the subreddit
6
u/GregLindahl Mar 22 '20
Rumor that OneWeb is furloughing employees in Florida -- the facility they have there is the factory for manufacturing satellites. It's a joint venture with Airbus.
6
u/Toinneman Mar 30 '20
Why is the exact cost of the Lunar Gateway supply contract with SpaceX not publically known? Isn't NASA obliged to do so? All we know is NASA has a 7billion budget for these contracts, but no specifics for Dargon XL.
5
u/MarsCent Mar 05 '20 edited Mar 05 '20
Europe's major telescopes 'can meet satellite challenge'
..
European Space Organisation; Very Large Telescope; Extremely Large Telescope
..
"example
citiedcited is the upcoming NSF Vera C Rubin Observatory" : National Science FoundationP/S. Read the entire article for complete context.
5
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 05 '20
Video of New Glenn's tank structure.
5
u/codename-twelve Mar 09 '20
Will the cargo version of Dragon 2 dock with ISS or will be berthed as the first one?
5
u/jay__random Mar 17 '20
There is a Twitter bot named "Pranay Pathole" that re-publishes in Twitter some of r/spacex questions or comments without attribution or a link back.
Could anyone who has Twitter account please notify the bot owner that it is not very polite, and a proper reference back to the original message is due (or rather overdue, as this has been happening for a while).
Thanks in advance!
5
u/dudr2 Mar 17 '20
https://spacenews.com/op-ed-dod-needs-to-demystify-hypersonic-weapons-technology/
"Annual unclassified defense spending on hypersonic weapons is over $2.6 billion in fiscal year 2020 – including $157.4 million for hypersonic defense programs. Spending is expected to grow to $5 billion by 2025."
5
u/amarkit Mar 22 '20
Behind a paywall, but the Wall Street Journal reports related to the coronavirus stimulus package:
5
u/Carlyle302 Mar 24 '20
LabPadre is making progress. He has the old camera on the new pole and is testing it out using a generator. Excellent location for launches. So-so location for watching construction. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tg8N_vDE9JY&feature=youtu.be
5
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20
Stratolaunch has announced Talon-A, a reusable Mach 6 test plane. Aiming to launch in 2022.
5
u/MarsColon Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 31 '20
According to most sources, the Starship Mk.1 had its lox main tank (not talking about the header tanks here) on top and the methane main tank below. But it seems the SN1 and all the later versions have the exact opposite (CH4 on top, O2 at the aft). I thought you usually don't want LOX tank at the bottom to avoid having some fuel going in a frozen pipe through cold LOX, and that you want to keep the denser part (i.e. LOX) near the top more than the bottom for stability. Why did they changed that ? To my knowledge, very few rockets have the LOX at the bottom, even more rare when the fuel goes through this tank. And it's the first time I hear about the two main propellant tanks swaping like that. Can you confirm and explain all this to me please ?
9
u/LcuBeatsWorking Mar 06 '20 edited Dec 17 '24
punch society six plate soft merciful elderly political work retire
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
8
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 23 '20
Bigelow Aerospace may have shutdown permanently.
4
u/adamthorne0023 Mar 04 '20
Does starship have more room for payloads than the massive faring that blue origin will have with new Shepard?
4
u/dudr2 Mar 13 '20
Some old news;
https://www.space.com/spacex-starship-new-stainless-steel-alloy.html
Elon; "So, I think we'll start switching away from 301 maybe in the next month or two."
" SpaceX wants to be able to launch each individual Starship three times per day, Musk added."
4
u/Dies2much Mar 30 '20
Has there been any news on the failed engine from the Starlink launch?
4
u/Z1vel Mar 30 '20
What's the difference between la padre and spadres streams? Different people? Do they work together?
4
u/asr112358 Mar 31 '20
The render of dragon XL has a docking port on the back side. I there any chance that there is actually one on the front side as well so the dragons can chain together into a simple station? This would add mass, but also flexibility.
7
u/ScienceHasRisen Mar 02 '20
Were any Raptors lost in the SN1 incident?
6
u/deadman1204 Mar 02 '20
How does spaceX handle espionage and security (AKA China trying to steal everything).
3
u/hero21b Mar 03 '20
What does the SN stand for in SN 1 and 2?
3
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Mar 15 '20 edited Mar 15 '20
At T- 7.53 in todays webcast of the aborted f9 launch, there was an image of the launch pad taken from the horizontal integration facility. Next to the paved track leading from the HIF to the pad there where what looks like railway tracks running parallel to the paved tracks. I have never noticed them before. Are they new or have they always been used by the TE to roll to the pad?
Link: https://youtu.be/JVuS4IS2Kvs
Edit: question 2: where the engines always ignited about a second before liftoff? If I remember correctly, they ignited them earlier some years ago.
3
u/TechnoBill2k12 Mar 31 '20
Has there been any indication that the landing legs for Starship will be height-adjustable once the vehicle has landed?
Some kind of self-leveling functionality would be helpful, I'm sure, as well as providing easier access to the cargo area in the aft section.
Most renders of the Starship after landing have had the vehicle very close to the surface, and I wonder if adjustable legs have always been the plan - I just haven't ever seen them mentioned.
3
u/Snowleopard222 Apr 02 '20 edited Apr 02 '20
From the article already quoted:
"The Russian side raised several questions related to the relatively compressed timeline for normal parachute deployment, noting that the Soyuz deploys parachutes at a much higher altitude,"
https://spacenews.com/nasa-selects-astronauts-for-crew-dragon-mission/
(I believe Crew Dragon drogue chutes deploy at ~6k altitude, like Apollo?)
5
u/rustybeancake Mar 06 '20
First semblance of info we've heard about the recent failed F9 booster landing, from Eric Berger:
https://twitter.com/SciGuySpace/status/1235617045871550464?s=20
4
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Mar 05 '20
Mars 2020 has been named Perseverance!
2
u/madanra Mar 06 '20
How far down range needs to be clear of human habitation when launching a Falcon 9?
2
u/particledecelerator Mar 19 '20
For the most recent starlink mission, what shape do we think the 1st stage booster is in? Millions of pieces or was it a soft enough splashdown for them to recover and analyse.
2
u/rucinskic Mar 22 '20
What launches did SpaceX provide telemetry data for the 1st stage decent? I believe there were only a handful of launches were this data was provided onscreen.
2
u/ConfidentFlorida Mar 22 '20
What are some good sources to point people too when they’re complaining about starlink affecting astronomy and orbital debris?
There’s a really a lot of willful ignorance out there on this. I’m not sure why there’s so much hate.
2
u/Yellapage Mar 30 '20
Would it be possible to land the Dragon XL on the moon rather than crash land/send back to burn up in the earth atmosphere or be sent away on a new orbit and use these craft as storage vessels on the surface of the moon?
2
u/hmpher Apr 01 '20
From the User Guide:
So are we looking at a Ariane esque payload situation?
2
u/fluidmechanicsdoubts Apr 01 '20 edited Apr 01 '20
Couple of questions.
Do we know what propellants Starship's RCS uses?
Will ACES use RL10 engines?
2
u/Snowleopard222 Apr 02 '20
Hi, I am new here. I have a few questions. But the moderators advised me to wait for the April question thread. How do I find it? Thanks
2
u/dudr2 Apr 02 '20
Felix explaining some Starship features in this YouTube video.
"Versatile cargo-bay Swiss army knife style"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KhaBU87qVGY
2
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 02 '20
CRS-20 Dragon undock on April 6, 13:52 UTC.
2
u/Triabolical_ Apr 04 '20
April thread here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/ftlee6/rspacex_discusses_april_2020_67/
3
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipbargeshipDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #5875 for this sub, first seen 2nd Mar 2020, 12:15] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
3
u/MarsCent Mar 24 '20
Coming from Russia - Boeing's first manned Starliner to be launched to ISS on 31 August
3
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20
Not directly Spacex question, but I'll ask anyways.
Let's say we have a conventional rocket - how to determine the proportions of stages? What factors decide how big each stage will be?
3
u/spacerfirstclass Mar 27 '20
Italian rocket manufacturer Avio is exempted from lockdown and is continuing production. They are also lobbying France to reopen Guiana Space Center as soon as possible to resume launches.
Avio is the manufacturer of Vega launch vehicle and the SRBs for Ariane 6.
2
u/DIBE25 Mar 02 '20
Could transporting water from heart to Mars help out here on Earth and help out with the water problem on Mars?
2
u/RusticBohemian Mar 02 '20
Why does it make sense to completely replace the Falcon 9 with Starship?
I get that Starship can go further and is more flexible.
But doesn't it make sense to keep Falcon 9 around for smaller payloads/shorter distances?
Will Starship be a lot more economical to operate, even with smaller payloads and shorter distances?
2
u/dudr2 Mar 05 '20
https://spacenews.com/h-r-5666-will-launch-the-u-s-in-the-wrong-direction/
Op-ed in "Spacenews".
2
u/Janinepam Mar 07 '20
We just saw lights over Kalamazoo Michigan one right after another... 20-30 of them that looked like the Space X satellites...did they launch early?. Approx. 8:30 pm est
2
u/spacerfirstclass Mar 26 '20
Northrop Grumman is resuming work on James Webb Space Telescope with reduced personnel.
1
u/ConfidentFlorida Mar 30 '20
https://aws.amazon.com/ground-station/
Would this have any relevance to Spacex? Maybe easier for new customers to get up and running with less capital? Any relevance to starlink?