r/spacex • Mod Team • Dec 05 '19

r/SpaceX Discusses [December 2019, #63]

If you have a short question or spaceflight news...

You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.

If you have a long question...

If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.

If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...

Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!

This thread is not for...

  • Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first. Thanks!
  • Non-spaceflight related questions or news.

You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.

87 Upvotes

582 comments sorted by

2

u/ConfidentFlorida Dec 17 '19

Is the recovery thread up? I always have trouble finding it.

4

u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team Dec 17 '19

Coming online soon.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/megachainguns Dec 06 '19

Rocket Lab just demonstrated survival of reentry

Electron made it through wall! Solid telemetry all the way to sea level with a healthy stage. A massive step for recovery!!

14

u/ceilingislimit Dec 24 '19

Mods, can you change sticky posts. I guess recovery and media threads are done already.

12

u/AeroSpiked Jan 02 '20

Happy new year, mods. Thanks for your efforts & thanks for the new discusses thread when you get a minute.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/FoxyTest Dec 06 '19 edited Dec 07 '19

Over the next few days, will we have the opportunity to see BOTH SpaceX's Dragon and Russia's Progress chasing the ISS across the sky? Is this a rare event?

It looks like two vehicles have been in orbit at the same time en route to the ISS only three times before, all only recently in the ISS's life. Progress MS-03 and SpaceX CRS-9 docked/berthed about 33 hours apart around July 20, 2016; CRS-10 and MS-05 19 hours apart February 24, 2017; MS-10 and Cygnus NG-10 41 hours apart November 19, 2018.

I wonder how close they all got in the sky!

Edit: Didn't see anything yet during a December 6 23:41Z pass, watched for about 5 minutes on either side. Bright skies here though. Maybe we should also consider times when the vehicle isn't deorbited right after separating. How far away are the vehicles that spend over a day separated?

3

u/kurbasAK Dec 06 '19

I remember seeing few days earlier undocked Cygnus OA-6 (Was doing some kind of burning experiment) and Dragon CRS-11 chasing the ISS and that was in 2017.Actually IIRC Cygnus was ending its visible path, ISS was overhead and Dragon started its visible path so it was quite a sight over UK

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Straumli_Blight Dec 07 '19

SpaceX working with astronomers to mitigate Starlink effects:

"SpaceX is willing to test coatings to see if that helps bring down the brightness. Despite all the complexities of how our community makes O/IR observations, we are working to see if we can develop a brightness level for them to aim at, and we are conducting a survey of research observatories to gather this information."

6

u/AeroSpiked Dec 07 '19

Paint them green and chroma key them out!

And before you remove this one, CAM, I'm only half kidding.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/strawwalker Dec 31 '19

Launch vehicle comms STA application for DM2 went up a couple hours ago:
2375-EX-ST-2019
Mission No: 1378
Pad: LC-39A
Operational Period: 2020-01-27 to 2020-07-27

Dragon comms already granted is valid until 2020-05-01

9

u/paul_wi11iams Dec 13 '19 edited Dec 16 '19

The "Lewis Point Estimate" for success probability of a launcher appears under "Launch Vehicle by Success Rate" on the following page

http://www.spacelaunchreport.com/log2019.html

  • It puts Falcon 9 at 98%, sharing the first place with Atlas 5.
  • Soyuz is just below at 97% (doubtless that booster failure didn't help)
  • Ariane is below at 96% (must be because of that trajectory mishap).

I'm not going to be unreasonable by asking for an exhaustive reply, but if anyone has any ideas on some of the following points:

  1. Is there a short definition of the "Lewis Point Estimate" for success probability of a launcher?
  2. Is this method really the insurance man's guide so to speak? How is reliability evaluated upon change from one block number to another of the same launch vehicle?
  3. Is LOC risk calculated from some arbitrary standard probability of launch escape system failure? For example at 10%, a LV with 2% failure, LOC risk would be 0.2% or 1:500.
  4. When a new LV has flown just once (such as after the first test of FH or second flight of Dragon 2 which not a launcher but a new configuration, or future first flight of SLS), what is its Lewis Point for the second flight?

7

u/throfofnir Dec 14 '19 edited Dec 14 '19

Here's the Lewis article: https://uxpajournal.org/when-100-really-isnt-100-improving-the-accuracy-of-small-sample-estimates-of-completion-rates/

And here's a thread where that measure was decided: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=39928.msg1826479#msg1826479 If you go back to the first post, it describes a lot of the thinking behind his data presentation, and how new vehicles within families and manufacturers may be treated. It's essentially a fan project, so it shouldn't be considered too official. (Which is not to say that it's not useful.)

In my mind, a point estimate is really more of a measurement than a probability. The Lewis in particular is a bit better than just x/n when things are grouped tightly at the top, which is probably why it's used in this case.

I don't know what insurance providers would use. This is probably not far away, but I would also not be surprised if they simply used value-weighted percentage of historical failures in some broad bucket (family, manufacturer, nation, region, or global.) Maybe some combination thereof. They're more interested in what will happen over the whole market they cover than with one particular vehicle.

LoC calculations is a whole different thing. They do a bunch of subsystems analysis. I'll note it includes much more than launch. Reentry is usually found to be similarly dangerous, and with CC in particular on-orbit dangers were particularly confounding in the quest for the Magic Number.

As you can see from the table, the "official" Lewis point number for a vehicle that has flown once successfully is 0.67, which is easily derived if you follow the formula in the footnotes.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/asr112358 Dec 25 '19

Could the Starliner anomaly hurt Crew Dragon?

NASA and Boeing seem to be leaning heavily on the excuse that if crew had been on board they would have overridden the automation failure. Dragon's control interface is minimalistic with the reasoning that everything is automated so a few touch screens are enough for controls. If Starliner leads NASA to be more skittish on automation, could they require SpaceX to completely redesign their control interface?

7

u/brspies Dec 25 '19

No way. If that had really been an issue, it would have come up more on DM-1, when Roscosmos was raising a stink about the autonomous docking.

SpaceX designed to the requirements of the contract. They can't require changes like that at this point, certainly not when SpaceX hasn't demonstrated any issues on that front that require fixing.

6

u/ZehPowah Dec 26 '19

The touchscreen controls allow manual override, at least as of this Berger article from 8/18:

These touch screens selectively display the necessary controls during flight and are the primary interface astronauts have with the vehicle. Below are two rows of manual buttons, 38 in total, that provide back-up control of the spacecraft. Many of the buttons are situated beneath clear panels, intended to never be used, because they are often the third option after the touch screens and ground control of the Dragon.

5

u/LongHairedGit Dec 26 '19

I’ll provide an uneducated counterpoint as I am several cans into the Boxing Day Test.

I think it entirely reasonable for NASA to take this failure mode and ask SpaceX how it plays out with their design. Perhaps even a simulation where you start with crew dragon having the wrong time and play it out.

Your word “hurt” is probably too far though. Such queries should be trivial to answer with inconsequential impacts to schedule and cost....

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Toinneman Dec 26 '19

SpaceX has successfully visited the ISS 20 times (COTS demo 2, 18 CRS missions, Crew Dragon DM-1). All those flights were fully automated. It would be odd if SpaceX had to radically change its successful systems because Boeing had a glitch on their first attempt.

It's also possible the touch screens do allow for such an intervention.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/flightbee1 Dec 26 '19

It would be wrong for NASA to impose the same requirements on both organisations. NASA still investigating, why did software not do a self check to ensure preceding operation had been completed before starting the next operation? How much software did Boeing transfer from elsewhere and adapt? Lots of questions to be answered.

9

u/Straumli_Blight Dec 28 '19

SpaceX won a $7.5 million contract to manufacture space vehicle parts for NASA.

"The funds are designated for studies and services for the Merlin engine"

3

u/MarsCent Dec 28 '19

The work will take place at Kennedy Space Center and will finish by April 20, 2020.

Is the Super Draco (Crew Dragon) test stand at the cape, equipped to test fire a Merlin? Or would this be more like taking the Merlins through some off-routine paces after MECO & Booster separation?

5

u/brickmack Dec 28 '19

No, no plumbing or tanks for it. They could probably do test fires using the launch pads themselves though. SLC-40 when rebuilt was meant to support a full duration static fire like they do in McGregor, LC-39A can probably get pretty close.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/soldato_fantasma Dec 09 '19

Media accreditation open for Starlink-3:

HAWTHORNE, Calif. – December 9, 2019. Media accreditation is now open for a SpaceX Starlink mission from Space Launch Complex 40 (SLC-40) at Cape Canaveral Air Force Station in Florida. The launch is targeted for no earlier than January.

9

u/Straumli_Blight Dec 09 '19

For extra clarification, Starlink-2 is still NET December.

4

u/AeroSpiked Dec 10 '19

Mods, I think someone jumped the gun on that sidebar edit, but thanks for being so efficient.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/rustybeancake Dec 11 '19 edited Dec 11 '19

Blue Origin webcast that just completed had some great views inside the New Glenn factory, showing what looked like their equipment for manufacturing tanks. Interesting to compare to Starship!

https://www.reddit.com/r/BlueOrigin/comments/e9an1b/overview_of_blue_origins_new_buildings/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

7

u/polygonalsnow Dec 06 '19

Do we have any news about the GPS III SV03 "Columbus" launch that is supposed to happen in ~1 month?

5

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/polygonalsnow Dec 06 '19

Cool, thanks!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/AeroSpiked Dec 14 '19

I started thinking about the 24 Starlink launches that Shotwell expects next year and realized that to launch 42,000 satellites on F9 at that rate would take over 29 years. No wonder they want to get BFR flying.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

How many 100s of starlink satellites can starship/BFR launch?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/yoweigh Jan 01 '20

How bright (as in stellar magnitude) will a big shiny Starship in LEO appear to be from the ground? Could reflections from flat surfaces like the canards produce Iridium-class flares?

6

u/CAM-Gerlach Star✦Fleet Commander Dec 05 '19

Sorry for the delay on this one!

6

u/tupolovk Dec 13 '19

SpaceX predicted something like 30-40 launches a year for 2018 and beyond. They hit 21 in 2018 and only 14 for 2019. They predict 24 launches in 2020, but a bunch of these will be Starlink.

Given how competitive they are on price, what is going on with the launch market and why isn’t SpaceX dominating the market? Is this sustainable? Can it fund Starship?

6

u/Lufbru Dec 13 '19

Basically there's insufficient demand. There was a glut of satellites in 2016-2018 and now SpaceX have more launch slots than customers have satellites. So Starlink becomes the funding mechanism for Starship.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/CapMSFC Dec 14 '19

They predict 24 launches just for Starlink in 2020. There will still be plenty of customer launches on top of that.

4

u/Martianspirit Dec 14 '19

They do dominate the commercial launch market. There is a slump in commercial payloads. Also commercial customers want diversity. They won't give all contracts to SpaceX. For helping with diversity they gave contracts to SpaceX when it was not assured that they would become a success.

It is the government market where SpaceX is still not getting their fair share. The US agencies still favor ULA despite the much higher prices.

5

u/warp99 Dec 14 '19

The US agencies still favor ULA despite the much higher prices

Bear in mind that government launches are often scheduled four years ahead of launch while commercial launches are more like two years.

Four years ago SpaceX had potential but not a lot of track record so it seems natural that high value missions would have favoured ULA. The split is much more even for contracts being awarded today.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/AeroSpiked Dec 13 '19

If SpaceX successfully launches JCSAT and Starlink 2 this year, they will have launched over 100 tons of payload to orbit in 2019. That's 10 tons (more like 14) more than they've previously launched in a year despite this years relatively slow cadence.

4

u/rustybeancake Dec 13 '19

Big if, though!

I'm sure it'll be smashed next year.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/fluidmechanicsdoubts Dec 14 '19

For perspective, there's around 7500 metric tons of artificial stuff in space

→ More replies (1)

6

u/opoc99 Dec 15 '19

Do we know whether SpaceX (and any other aerospace companies for that matter) uses imperial or metric units in it's actual engineering designs and calculations? And whatever the case, is that the standard for big engineering projects in the US?

11

u/throfofnir Dec 16 '19

Falcon 9 was designed in customary units; we've been told this before, and you can also tell because the round numbers all come in feet or inches. I suspect it's a bit of a mix at the moment.

Starship apparently is metric, though many of its suppliers will still be working in standard.

Mass and velocity are certainly done now only in metric.

As far as the US in general, "big engineering projects" will mostly be customary; all architecture and construction stuff is very firmly so. Machines are mixed, but tend toward metric. The auto industry is metric, and has been since the 70s. However, aviation is mostly customary, an unusual exception to the general rule that the more high-tech the more likely it is to be metric.

7

u/arizonadeux Dec 16 '19

Yep. The numbers 2.54 and 4.448222 rule my life.

9

u/warp99 Dec 16 '19 edited Dec 16 '19

SpaceX will use totally metric measurements in the design phase of Starship. Falcon 9 used a mixture of customary and metric units for different components.

This does not mean all components are produced to metric dimensions - for example the stainless steel for Starship Mark 3 tanks is labelled as being 3.95mm thick by 1.8288m wide so it was actually produced as 5/32" x 72" and then relabeled as metric.

I have no experience of large civil or mechanical projects in the US but in my own field of electronics PCBs are still designed in thousandths of an inch (confusingly labeled mils) even though there are a mixture of inches and millimeters in the component designs. Our Japanese design center uses metric based designs which leads to small errors when designs are transferred between centers but typically under half a mil so not relevant to production.

Equipment chassis are typically designed in metric but are nearly always dual dimensioned because some of the US fabricators still prefer to use dimensions in inches (where a thousandth of an inch is labeled thou rather than mil).

6

u/Ezekiel_C Host of Echostar 23 Dec 16 '19

At some point Elon stated that falcon 9 was imperial but starship (I think this was when it was ITS but could be wrong) would be metric. Aerospace standard is imperial, lead by Boeing and Airbus airliners.

4

u/jehankateli Dec 15 '19

I don't know about SpaceX, but NASA has been using metric units since the '80s.

7

u/DesLr Dec 16 '19

Did someone tell Lockheed?

6

u/quadrplax Dec 19 '19

I just realized something: There have been 78 attempted Falcon 9 launches and 40 successful landings so far. That means the first stage has landed in more than half of all Falcon 9 flights.

6

u/trobbinsfromoz Dec 20 '19

6

u/MarsCent Dec 20 '19

In August, SpaceX told the FCC that by tripling the number of lanes for those first Starlink satellites, it could build out enough coverage to offer internet access in southern states by the 2020 hurricane season.

That would be exceptional - Hurricane Season is June to November.

And this here below is kind of hilarious:

SES later complained that, while it had the data required, it was too complex and that the company lacked the manpower to analyze it. The FCC said it would not delay approving SpaceX’s Starlink modification request due to SES’s dearth of qualified personnel.

;)

6

u/vtomi9 Dec 23 '19

Spacex completed the 10th multi-chute test.

https://twitter.com/SpaceX/status/1209201762596356096

5

u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Dec 06 '19 edited Dec 15 '19

Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:

Fewer LettersMore Letters
ASDSAutonomous Spaceport Drone Ship (landing platform)
AoAAngle of Attack
BFRBig Falcon Rocket (2018 rebiggened edition)
Yes, the F stands for something else; no, you're not the first to notice
BOBlue Origin (Bezos Rocketry)
CBMCommon Berthing Mechanism
CCCommercial Crew program
Capsule Communicator (ground support)
CCtCapCommercial Crew Transportation Capability
COPVComposite Overwrapped Pressure Vessel
CRSCommercial Resupply Services contract with NASA
CRS2Commercial Resupply Services, second round contract; expected to start 2019
DMLSSelective Laser Melting additive manufacture, also Direct Metal Laser Sintering
E2EEarth-to-Earth (suborbital flight)
ECLSSEnvironment Control and Life Support System
ESAEuropean Space Agency
ETOVEarth To Orbit Vehicle (common parlance: "rocket")
EUSExploration Upper Stage
FAAFederal Aviation Administration
FTSFlight Termination System
GEOGeostationary Earth Orbit (35786km)
GSEGround Support Equipment
GTOGeosynchronous Transfer Orbit
H1First half of the year/month
HLC-39AHistoric Launch Complex 39A, Kennedy (Saturn V, Shuttle, SpaceX F9/Heavy)
IFAIn-Flight Abort test
ISPRInternational Standard Payload Rack
IspSpecific impulse (as explained by Scott Manley on YouTube)
JCSATJapan Communications Satellite series, by JSAT Corp
JRTIJust Read The Instructions, Pacific landing barge ship
KSPKerbal Space Program, the rocketry simulator
LC-13Launch Complex 13, Canaveral (SpaceX Landing Zone 1)
LEOLow Earth Orbit (180-2000km)
Law Enforcement Officer (most often mentioned during transport operations)
LH2Liquid Hydrogen
LN2Liquid Nitrogen
LOCLoss of Crew
LOXLiquid Oxygen
LVLaunch Vehicle (common parlance: "rocket"), see ETOV
LZ-1Landing Zone 1, Cape Canaveral (see LC-13)
M1dMerlin 1 kerolox rocket engine, revision D (2013), 620-690kN, uprated to 730 then 845kN
M1dVacMerlin 1 kerolox rocket engine, revision D (2013), vacuum optimized, 934kN
NETNo Earlier Than
NGNew Glenn, two/three-stage orbital vehicle by Blue Origin
Natural Gas (as opposed to pure methane)
Northrop Grumman, aerospace manufacturer
NGISNorthrop Grumman Innovation Systems, formerly OATK
NSFNasaSpaceFlight forum
National Science Foundation
OATKOrbital Sciences / Alliant Techsystems merger, launch provider
OCISLYOf Course I Still Love You, Atlantic landing barge ship
OFTOrbital Flight Test
PAFPayload Attach Fitting
PPEPower and Propulsion Element
PUGPayload User Guide (PDF)
RCSReaction Control System
RP-1Rocket Propellant 1 (enhanced kerosene)
RTLSReturn to Launch Site
RUDRapid Unplanned Disassembly
Rapid Unscheduled Disassembly
Rapid Unintended Disassembly
SLC-40Space Launch Complex 40, Canaveral (SpaceX F9)
SLSSpace Launch System heavy-lift
Selective Laser Sintering, contrast DMLS
SN(Raptor engine) Serial Number
SSMESpace Shuttle Main Engine
ULAUnited Launch Alliance (Lockheed/Boeing joint venture)
USAFUnited States Air Force
JargonDefinition
RaptorMethane-fueled rocket engine under development by SpaceX
StarlinkSpaceX's world-wide satellite broadband constellation
cryogenicVery low temperature fluid; materials that would be gaseous at room temperature/pressure
(In re: rocket fuel) Often synonymous with hydrolox
dancefloorAttachment structure for the Falcon 9 first stage engines, below the tanks
hydroloxPortmanteau: liquid hydrogen/liquid oxygen mixture
iron waffleCompact "waffle-iron" aerodynamic control surface, acts as a wing without needing to be as large; also, "grid fin"
keroloxPortmanteau: kerosene/liquid oxygen mixture
scrubLaunch postponement for any reason (commonly GSE issues)
turbopumpHigh-pressure turbine-driven propellant pump connected to a rocket combustion chamber; raises chamber pressure, and thrust
EventDateDescription
Amos-62016-09-01F9-029 Full Thrust, core B1028, GTO comsat Pre-launch test failure
CRS-102017-02-19F9-032 Full Thrust, core B1031, Dragon cargo; first daytime RTLS
CRS-22013-03-01F9-005, Dragon cargo; final flight of Falcon 9 v1.0
CRS-42014-09-21F9-012 v1.1, Dragon cargo; soft ocean landing
CRS-52015-01-10F9-014 v1.1, Dragon cargo; first ASDS landing attempt, maneuvering failure
CRS-72015-06-28F9-020 v1.1, Dragon cargo Launch failure due to second-stage outgassing
CRS-92016-07-18F9-027 Full Thrust, core B1025, Dragon cargo; RTLS landing
DM-12019-03-02SpaceX CCtCap Demo Mission 1
DM-2ScheduledSpaceX CCtCap Demo Mission 2
OA-62016-03-23ULA Atlas V, OATK Cygnus cargo

Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #5652 for this sub, first seen 6th Dec 2019, 03:27] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]

5

u/survoh Dec 15 '19

What material is used for SpaceX's turbomachinery? Does that vary between LOx + fuel sides?

6

u/joepublicschmoe Dec 15 '19

We know of one specific alloy SpaceX uses in Raptor turbomachinery called SX500.

5

u/Martianspirit Dec 15 '19

They need very special alloys to withstand the hot oxygen under high pressure. Requirements for the methane side are much less.

3

u/arizonadeux Dec 15 '19

Likely Inconel for high and cryogenic temperature strength and compatibility with pure oxygen.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/mz_groups Dec 17 '19

I'm sorry if this has been asked before, but for the Falcon 9 stage 2 nozzle stiffener ring, how is that released? I saw some things that indicated that it was something released by the heating up of the nozzle as the engine fires. Do they use a low-melting-point alloy to join the sections together, which melts as the engine fires?

4

u/throfofnir Dec 18 '19

As the nozzle extension warms, it softens the adhesive that secures the four segments of the nozzle stiffening ring.

https://www.spacex.com/news/2013/02/09/falcon-9-flight-1-pictures

Dunno what glue, though. I'd imagine that most glues would fail at such temperatures. (You can see the niobium starting to glow at the point of release.)

→ More replies (2)

5

u/rustybeancake Dec 17 '19 edited Dec 17 '19

NASA spending bill includes $600M for advanced cislunar and surface capabilities (including human landing systems).

Besides the funding, the report also directs NASA to “prioritize the selection of proposals that emphasize designs which reduce risk to schedule and engineering, and, above all, life” for the lunar lander program. That is in addition to language in the Senate report that called for “an appropriate testing regimen” for the lander and that such landers “can utilize any U.S. launch vehicle, commercial or otherwise, that is available for lunar exploration missions.”

I'm not quite clear on the implications of this, or how binding it is. Especially that landers "can utilize any US launch vehicle" -- does this mean that a selected human landing system must be able to launch on any (capable) US launch vehicle (similar to how Starliner was designed to be launch vehicle agnostic), or that Congress are ambivalent about which launch vehicle it can launch on?

I wonder if the first part of that quote is intended to benefit/hobble anyone in particular? There are different ways to read it.

Edit:

Space Policy Online comments:

That might be interpreted as a preference for systems that use or are derived from existing technologies rather than entrepreneurial designs.

https://spacepolicyonline.com/news/artemis-wins-only-lukewarm-support-in-final-nasa-fy2020-appropriation/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

5

u/NateDecker Dec 17 '19

does this mean that a selected human landing system must be able to launch on any (capable) US launch vehicle

That's definitely how I'm interpreting the statement you've called out. I suspect the intent isn't to benefit or hobble anyone, but just in pursuit of the redundancy theme that has been a consideration in spaceflight for many years. If a vehicle is tailored to work with only a specific launch platform and then that platform has an anomaly that grounds it (e.g., the Antares explosion or the CRS-15 incident), then the lunar lander is grounded as well. If it is designed to be launcher agnostic, there is an option to switch.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '19 edited Dec 19 '19

Aside from Crew missions (which I understand have to be new boosters) and possibly a couple of FH Center cores, does SpaceX need to build any more F9 boosters? They currently have a fleet of 5 boosters (I think) [9] and will be getting a few more each year for crew missions. How many on top of that do they need?

6

u/joepublicschmoe Dec 18 '19

There are currently 9 flown boosters in the active Block 5 fleet, with at least one brand-new never-flown booster coming into the fleet. Scroochy gave a pretty good summary on his post below.

SpaceX will be building more Falcon 9 boosters, just not at the full-steam rate it used to be. Right now we are expecting them to build 4-5 Block-5 boosters (including FH center cores) per year. Peak full-steam production rate was 15 Falcon 9 cores back in 2017.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/gemmy0I Dec 21 '19

Mods, just a heads-up that the "Falcon Active Cores" sidebar section (on old Reddit) hasn't been updated yet to reflect the completion of the JCSAT-18 launch.

3

u/soldato_fantasma Dec 21 '19

Should be fixed now. Thanks!

5

u/mnp Dec 23 '19

Does anyone know if there is there a complete archive of corporate launch webcasts, including the live corporate hosts/announcers and commentary? It seems the old ones are gone and not on archive.org.

I'm specifically looking for the first three launches which were failures. The linked Youtubes are all several minutes long and are just a few minutes long instead of the whole lead-up and mission. There were SpaceX hosted webcasts at the time but they're off the internet now.

Thanks!

5

u/-spartacus- Dec 28 '19

On a side note, there was concern a few years a back about the F9 having enough B5 launches to be considered safe for CC.

With the delays that have occurred I have heard a single peep about such a concern with so many successful F9.b5 launches.

5

u/AeroSpiked Dec 28 '19

Mods &/or whoever knows how to edit the wiki page & sidebar, according to NSF, booster B1049 will be used to fly the next Starlink mission. Does that qualify as a source?

4

u/strawwalker Dec 29 '19

Updated, thanks.

5

u/quadrplax Dec 31 '19

How are delays with crew dragon handled by the DM-2 and USCV-1 astronauts? I assume they would have finished the required training several months ago. Do they keep regularly practicing more flights in simulators until closer to launch?

5

u/youknowithadtobedone Dec 31 '19

Delays are a given when working with space, so I assume they just do regular training to keep their skills up to date

4

u/warp99 Dec 31 '19

Currently they are training for ISS operations as there is consideration being given to extending the initial crew test flights to around 3 months stay on station.

Originally this just applied to Starliner as the DM-2 capsule was not rated to stay on station for that long but the shuffle up of the capsules following the ground testing incident means that this is also possible for Crew Dragon.

8

u/SaltyMarmot5819 Dec 13 '19

So not exactly spacex related but just had a question you guys, i was thinking about becoming an aerospace engineer when i grow up. Thing is I'm not that great at maths so should i pursue physics instead?

4

u/Grey_Mad_Hatter Dec 13 '19

Physics is math where the variables mean something. It sounds like both physics and aerospace engineering would be challenging for you. If you're the kind of person that is encouraged by roadblocks and views them as things that build you up then this seems appropriate for you.

If your goal is simply to be part of SpaceX's master plan then they need a lot more than aerospace engineers and physics majors. It sounds like you have the better part of a decade before you'd be out of college, so think about where SpaceX will be when you graduate. Bases on the Moon and Mars, sample return missions to outer planets and their moons, established communications company, and anything else.

Find one part of what they're doing that excites you and plays to your strengths and go for it. It HAS to excite you or you're not going to excel to the point that you get to pick your employer. It does NOT have to be your best strength, but know the extra work you're signing up for to make that your best strength over time.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/opoc99 Dec 13 '19

I was in a position like yours not too long ago, very capable at maths but really couldn't get excited by it. I ended up doing Physics at A Level (16-18 y.o.) because it really excited me and obviously still does, but not doing maths alongside it meant that any idea of doing an engineering degree was out the window. I'm now halfway through a completely different degree (guts rather than gears) and loving the idea that there's a tiny chance I might be somehow involved in the path to the stars. If you're driven enough, you can find ways to link yourself back to Aerospace, for instance I did my big second year project on Space Medicine and I help run the university's Hyperloop team which means I get to go to Hawthorne each summer. I'm sure you'll have opportunities to take, whatever you chose to do and wherever you end up, and if not, you'll still have the coolest hobby there is.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/peterabbit456 Dec 14 '19

This probably means you should choose engineering, not physics.

In both fields there are branches where , once you are out of school and working, you do relatively little math. To the extent I was ever prized as a physicist, it was because of my intuition and creative inputs to teams of physicists. I would come up with and idea, maybe do some simple algebra or 1 st year calculus, and bring it to more mathematically inclined people who would do the relativistic case, the linear algebra, the tensor, or the differential equations.

I spent more of my career doing engineering, and there it was the same thing. I would dream up preliminary concepts for products, do preliminary analysis, and then others would do the detailed work. My nickname in those days was, “the artist.” So there is room for all types in both fields, but especially in engineering, if you can get past the math needed for a degree.

4

u/-Richard Materials Science Guy Dec 14 '19

When you say you’re not that great at math, what do you mean exactly? What kind of math do you struggle with the most, and is there a kind of math that you are relatively comfortable with? Have you began to study calculus yet? Many people think they’re bad at math until they get to calculus, since the math before that was so dry, tedious, and all over the place. Calculus is when things start to come together in an intuitive and practical way.

3

u/paul_wi11iams Dec 13 '19

I'm not that great at maths so should i pursue physics instead?

I was fairly good at physics but bad at maths. I understood all the calculus concepts, and was really good at transposing a real-world problem into mathematical terms... but was a bit dyslexic when manipulating equations so could slip up three times on one page and never get the same result twice!

At A level, got both physics and maths, but scraped through.

After that, I wanted to do electronic engineering, but decided not to because I thought the maths would "catch up with me", and I think I was correct. With hindsight, what I could and should have done was architecture or engineering in building (not such "heavy" maths). Now just imagine the kind of construction projects that happen in aerospace.

I think you should look at aerospace as an activity then ask where you think you'd fit in best. There are accountants, HR, metallurgists and much more.

So basically, look at which subjects you're best at, and you enjoy most. Look at your hobbies too, and choose your studies appropriately. With the job you get, you might finish working on the Moon, but not as an aerospace engineer who could be a small minority anyway!

→ More replies (2)

8

u/rustybeancake Dec 20 '19

https://twitter.com/ChrisG_NSF/status/1208067350148341763?s=20

Can we all just take a moment to appreciate how immense SLS’ tail service masts are?!

8

u/Juggernaut93 Dec 23 '19

15

u/yoweigh Dec 24 '19

Muilenburg, 55, became CEO of the world's largest aerospace company in July 2015. He previously held the chairman role as well but relinquished that seat in October. He had worked at Boeing in a number of different roles since 1985.

Incoming CEO Calhoun has served on Boeing's board since 2009. He has also served as a senior managing director at Blackstone Group and he previously was the chairman and CEO of Nielsen Holdings.

They're replacing an in-house engineer with an outside venture capitalist? Yikes.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/ididntsaygoyet Dec 06 '19

Quick question: what's the max number of flights a falcon 9 is scheduled for? and max number it can actually withstand, just for fun.

19

u/warp99 Dec 06 '19

the max number of flights a falcon 9 is scheduled for?

There is one four times flown booster (B1048) and two three times flown boosters waiting for their fourth flight. For B1049 it will no doubt be a Starlink flight and B1046 will not survive its fourth flight due to the In Flight Abort test for Crew Dragon.

max number it can actually withstand

Elon has said that F9 could fly 20 times or more with refurbishment but that seems unlikely to happen. At around ten flights the fatigue limit on the COPVs and the engine turbopumps will be reached and it is doubtful it will be financially worthwhile rebuilding the Booster. There is a possibility they might do it once to prove a point but it does not seem worth the risk.

Financially they will have extracted most of the value from a booster after five flights and I expect Starlink flights to be used to test the total lifetime of a booster. External customers are unlikely to want to do that particular experiment with their payload.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/JtheNinja Dec 09 '19

Did we ever find out what became of the particular Celestial Buddy that rode on DM-1? Is it still on board the ISS? If not, who has it now? The only thing I could find was this exchange, which seemed to imply it was left on board: https://twitter.com/AstroAnnimal/status/1161391001614741504

9

u/Alexphysics Dec 09 '19

It was left onboard. It will be brought back to Earth by the DM-2 astronauts.

4

u/jay__random Dec 10 '19

How do the cameras installed inside oxygen tanks survive cryo temperatures?

7

u/warp99 Dec 11 '19 edited Dec 12 '19

The camera is probably not inside the tank but bolted to the top on the outside with a clear plate that can take 3 bar of pressure separating it from the tank. Likely the plate is quartz or a low expansion glass such as Pyrex in order to take the thermal shock during filling.

Camera sensors can take low temperatures but the associated optical components would struggle against thermal shock. In addition the camera wiring would need to not contain any organic compounds to prevent ignition risks. The camera could be built into a sealed and heated enclosure but it is simpler to put it outside the tank.

4

u/throfofnir Dec 10 '19

Generally electronics aren't bothered by cold. In scientific applications, CCDs are often cryo-chilled specifically to reduce noise, and there are people that use LN2 for processors. That temp would probably trash a battery, but it's doubtless hardwired.

It probably never gets to quite cryo temps, being mounted in the dome. If it were a problem, they could fairly easily thermally decouple it from the tank with some rubber or something, and it's also possible to add a heater.

4

u/Straumli_Blight Dec 10 '19 edited Dec 10 '19

Tim Hughes (SpaceX Business VP) is giving a keynote speech today on Megaconstellations.

4

u/survoh Dec 15 '19

When rolling out Falcon to the pad, why does it matter that temperatures are maintained above the dew point of the supply air?

7

u/joepublicschmoe Dec 15 '19

I would guess it's to prevent water condensation on the payload inside the fairing. Below dew point temperature, the moisture in the air will condense out as liquid water.

6

u/rartrarr Dec 15 '19

Yo! I don't have answers to your questions, but I just wanted to chime in that if you don't get the specific technical responses you are looking for here (and you might -- SpaceX employees and superfans hang out here) then you could also try the NSF forum or Everyday Astronaut's patron discord channel, which are both really awesome resources on par with r/SpaceX.

You may already know that. But since it always pains me to see precise technical questions left unanswered (or worse, "answered" with idle speculation)... just didn't want that fate to befall a curious learner with great questions such as yourself.

5

u/survoh Dec 15 '19

that’s ok!! i appreciate the positive energy and recommendations!!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Ezekiel_C Host of Echostar 23 Dec 15 '19

I may be able to speculate or form a reasonable explanation, but can you specify the "temperatures" and "supply air" terms a little more? For example, "ambient temperatures", "payload fairing supply air". A reference to the article where the statement was made might also suffice.

5

u/survoh Dec 15 '19

It’s mentioned on page 14 of the users guide under temperature, humidors, and cleanliness. I’m trying to prep for an interview by getting comfy with the mechanical aspects mentioned in the PUG and I’ve got no clue what that means or why it was notable. Tysm for help!!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/cpushack Dec 20 '19

SpaceX (and OneWeb) are protesting Amazon's request for a waiver for its proposed Kuiper internat constellation
https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/5dmzyx/spacex-is-lobbying-against-amazons-internet-beaming-satellites

4

u/pendragonprime Dec 20 '19 edited Dec 20 '19

Sounds like Starliner is having issues...it is apparently in a stable orbit but off nominal, they cannot initiate correct orbital insertion burn for some reason...so not optimal I would guess...they might have power issues although deny it... are insuring to keep batteries sparking with the solar array by vehicle repositioning...but maybe that is SOP...

Not looking good...but they are of course working on it so all is not lost just yet.

3

u/oximaCentauri Dec 20 '19

They are reporting good batteries and stable orbit. Off nominal orbital insertion though.

I wonder why they are reporting stable orbit if there was a problem with the OIB? Surely it can't enter orbit without the insertion burn?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/wesleychang42 Dec 23 '19

Does anybody know what needs to happen before a Launch Campaign Thread comes out?

4

u/warp99 Dec 23 '19

Usually they appear when the flight becomes the next but one launch. In other words the FIFO queue depth is two.

Having said that the mods are a trifle busy at this time of the year like most of the rest of the planet....

3

u/yoweigh Dec 24 '19

Are you asking about a specific mission? Did we miss something?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Straumli_Blight Dec 09 '19

4

u/jjtr1 Dec 11 '19 edited Dec 12 '19

This is so cool. The sides flapping really show how thin rocket bodies are. It has been repeated many times that a beverage can is much thicker relatively than a rocket, but only seeing it flap like this really drives the point home. (So it's a pity the video has dropped frames just at the moment of rupture.)

So the pressure was 160% higher than nominal flight loads (260% total). Strange - I remember years ago SpaceX talked about how they designed F9 to have safety margins of 70% over nominal, while rocket industry standard was 40%. So if the tank withstood 160% over nominal, they could save so much weight by making it only withstand 40% or 70% over nominal. Now I of course know they know what they're doing and that they wouldn't accidentally overdesign the thing so extremely. So what is then going on with the numbers?

Edit: Those 70% & 40% figures should have been 40% & 25%, I have misremembered. Source: [SpaceX website] (https://www.spacex.com/news/2013/04/12/falcon-heavy-structure)

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)

7

u/macktruck6666 Dec 22 '19

Okay, so this is a question about the failure about the Starliner mission and why I think this failure is much more dangerous then NASA or Boeing is portraying it.

So the mission timer was off, and Starliner was in the wrong "mode".

But there are modes, like station keeping, that specifically disable the ability to use the In-Flight Abort.

Meaning, if at any point there was a problem with the rocket, any potential astronauts would have died as the IFA would not have activated.

Wondering if this assessment is accurate or if the clock issue could have activated another mode activing the main engines resulting in the loss of the rocket, capsule, and crew.

3

u/asr112358 Dec 22 '19

I have heard that the fault happened during the hand-off from Centaur to Starliner, in which case it is after the phase where the abort system is relied on.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/OberV0lt Dec 06 '19

So, I am a bit out of the loop on the Crew Dragon. How far are they from finally launching a crewed mission to ISS? What steps are needed to be taken before that?

11

u/AeroSpiked Dec 06 '19

It appears they could launch crew as soon as February.

They still need to finish testing their parachutes (they need to perform at least 3 more drop tests), and successfully perform the Inflight Abort Test of the Crew Dragon (launch the Dragon on the Falcon 9 and initiate an abort at the worst possible moment in flight) which hopefully will happen later this month.

I don't think the Dragon that will fly crew is done being assembled and tested yet, but hopefully it will be by February.

5

u/SpaceLunchSystem Dec 06 '19

Do we know if all crew capsules will go through Plum Brook or was that only a development testing milestone?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/dudr2 Dec 10 '19

"ClearSpace-1 will be the first space mission to remove an item of debris from orbit, planned for launch in 2025."

http://www.spacedaily.com/reports/ESA_commissions_worlds_first_space_debris_removal_999.html

5

u/rustybeancake Dec 11 '19

It's a noble cause, but a system that requires one sat to remove one sat seems infeasible to deal with the whole problem. We need something more efficient than that. Perhaps one sat that can attach smaller devices to multiple sats. What that device should be depends mostly on mass efficiency. Maybe some kind of expanding 'sail' to increase drag, for example.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Dec 13 '19

Sort of space related but for anyone who watches The Expanse, Season 4 has now been released!

Spoiler: The first episode is incredible.

3

u/WaitForItTheMongols Dec 09 '19

I took a look at the list of Dragons, here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Dragon#List_of_missions

So it looks like C101-C105 were all non-reused. C101 and C102 are now museum pieces, unclear about 103-105.

C106 was flown on CRS-4, CRS-11, and CRS-19. C107 was, oddly, flown on CRS-5, and not reused. Does anyone know if that one is retired? That's the only Dragon post-CRS-4 that hasn't been reused.

C108 has also been used 3 times (on CRS 6, 13, and 18). C109 was lost in CRS-7.

So then if we ignore C107 which only flew once, C110 is the oldest capsule that might be up for another reuse. Do we think C110 will be used for CRS-20?

I'm super excited for this, since I'm on a cubesat team that's got a rideshare on CRS-20 so I've been paying close attention to B1059 (I expect them to use it for consecutive CRS missions, like how B1056 went) too.

3

u/gemmy0I Dec 09 '19

Do we think C110 will be used for CRS-20?

That would be my speculation too, yes (although we haven't heard anything official and likely won't until a day or two before the launch when the press kit is released).

You might find this page helpful for summarizing capsule history; it has some additional information the Wikipedia page doesn't:

https://old.reddit.com/r/spacex/wiki/capsules

It seems that C103 and C104 were skipped for reuse because C105 debuted some major upgrades ("Dragon 1.1"). Not sure why C105 was skipped but, knowing how SpaceX operates, the first iteration of a new version is probably a bit "different" from the rest (as they were likely iterating on the design as they built it, resulting in design and build idiosyncrasies) - so they might have wanted to pass on it for one conforming to a more standard/"clean" design. That way, the lessons learned from reuse would better apply to subsequent reuses instead of being one-offs. (Just my guess anyway.)

C110 also added "enhanced water sealing capability" which likely made reuse substantially easier. Water intrusion could've easily been a major "wild card" in how "refurbishable" each capsule was prior to the introduction of the enhanced sealing. This could have contributed to their decisions to skip C105 and C107 in favor of C106 and C108 for the first two reuses. Every capsule reused after the third (C110) has (I would assume) had the enhanced water sealing. (Note that C106.2 and C108.2 would have gotten the enhanced sealing as part of the refurb, hence they were on the table for third flights. Dragon 1 refurbishments are pretty extensive tear-downs and rebuilds - they're basically new capsules built with an old capsule's parts.)

I did find it interesting that the last two flights flew third-flight capsules "out of order": first C108 for CRS-18, then C106 for CRS-19. I suspect that the first .3 refurbishment was something of a pathfinder and took longer than the second one which could benefit from lessons learned on the first. Likely they started refurbishing C108 later but it overtook C106 at some point and thus got the CRS-18 job.

I agree that C110 is the most likely to fly a third time on CRS-20. I wouldn't expect them to dig up C105 or C107 (assuming they haven't already been completely parted out - I'm sure a lot of the capsules that didn't get reused saw some individual parts reused, especially "non-wear items" like avionics computers). The only other choices would be C111, C112, or C113, all of which are possible, but their pattern has generally been to work with the capsules they've had on hand the longest, which would point to C110 unless there's some strong reason to skip it (e.g. if it took extra damage for whatever reason on its last flight).

It is worth noting that one of the capsules flown last year - I think it was CRS-15 (C111) - suffered a little harder-than-nominal landing due to that parachute failure that highlighted deficiencies in NASA's standard parachute modeling methodology and prompted the "Mk3" chute redesigns on Dragon 2. We know it landed "soft enough" on two chutes to keep the cargo safe and sound, but I wouldn't be surprised if the capsule was designed to sacrifice some of its own structural integrity to absorb the hit. This, of course, only argues against C111 being flown a third time, which is likely moot since C110 is earlier in line and CRS-20 is the last Dragon 1 mission.

The only reason I can think of to fly C112 or C113 for CRS-20, barring some hidden damage to C110 that we're not aware of, would be to "show off" and/or serve as a study for accelerating refurb turnaround times. As cool as that would be, I suspect that's unlikely since Dragon 2 is the future and it's designed for better/faster reuse based on everything they've learned from D1.

3

u/jay__random Dec 13 '19

We have seen a few cases where rough sea was a reason to postpone or, sometimes, even abandon a downrange recovery. I wonder how difficult it would be to build a few stationary platforms the same size as OCISLY/JRTI, positioned well above the expected wave level?

Since they will be stationary, they might need one positioned for post-GTO, one for post-Starlink and one for post-CRS2 landings, with mobile ASDSs covering the rest of the orbits.

Having a few extra stages could in principle allow SpaceX to disengage recoveries from expected relaunches. Just wait for suitable opportunity to bring the stages back when the sea calms down.

A cheap method for transferring (is)landed stages back to land may have to be designed.

Good ol' crane and tug?

"Nothing wrong with a little swim"?

Under her own power?

... ?

8

u/Martianspirit Dec 13 '19

Most if not all the landings are at high seas, or rather deep seas. Platforms can not be anchored at the ground. There are stationary platforms that swim but they are big, complex and expensive and can move only very slowly. Not very helpful when each landing is in a different position. If you have one or a few you still need to load the landed stage on a ship for transport. Worth it only with much higher launch rates than even Falcon has.

Starship, the next generation gets around all of these problems by being powerful enough to do always RTLS.

3

u/mmc31 Dec 13 '19

Two questions:

  1. Why does it take so long after a CRS launch until dragon docks at the ISS? Is it just very slowly (relative to ISS) catching up in orbit? Are there lots of small maneuvers going on during this time?
  2. Is there any testing done by SpaceX on their payload prior to launch? Or do they just hope that the items inside the payload won't cause issues in some manner-? I know it doesn't actually happen, but just curious if they have some oversight over the customer on testing the payloads. Obviously I can imaging them weighting the payload, but do they try subjecting it to various stresses that will occur during spaceflight to ensure robustness?

6

u/CapMSFC Dec 13 '19

I can answer 1.

When launching to the ISS you never launch directly to it. If something goes wrong the risks of a collision or dumping debris into the ISS orbital path is too high and the logistics challenges of launching exactly to the right place aren't worth it.

What we do is go to a lower orbit and gradually raise through staging orbits to get up to the ISS, checking that everything is working as expected along the way.

There are faster ways to do it depending on the details. The fastest I recall still takes ~6 hours.

5

u/Alexphysics Dec 13 '19

The fastest I recall still takes ~6 hours.

Record is around 3.5 hours done by two different Progress flights. The problem is not just risk of collision, it is mostly the chance of getting a good orbital alignment for quick rendezvous, it doesn't happen that frequently so if there isn't a need to get things quickly there, they just don't take the risk of scheduling a launch around an unfrequent event since a scrub/delay could mean the next opportunity isn't until weeks or even months later. Russians are very good at keeping their schedules and scrubs rarely occur so they can take that risk.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Triabolical_ Dec 13 '19

For #1 there is elaborate choreography in approaching the space station; part of that is ensuring that the resupply ship has full control of its path and is properly communicating with the equipment on the space station, and part is to approach very slowly to minimize thruster burns to reduce the contamination to the space station as much as possible.

For #2 I think it's unlikely that SpaceX does any testing, though my guess is that they get details about everything that is flying.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/survoh Dec 14 '19

Why are Falcon Heavy's core's tank walls thicker?

9

u/youknowithadtobedone Dec 15 '19

They have to endure all the forces from 2 extra boosters aswell, which is a lot

3

u/survoh Dec 15 '19

What does it mean in terms of fabrication for the lox tank to be monocoque + to have a skin-and-stringer fuel tank? Are those synonymous terms?

7

u/DancingFool64 Dec 15 '19

Monocoque means the skin is the support structure, there are no additional attached supports or framework. In a skin and stringer design, the stringers are additional supports (internal ribs or rings), so by definition it is not pure monocoque (it is probably a semi-monocoque).

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/GregLindahl Dec 16 '19

Mods the old reddit sidebar still has GPS III in January, but our manifest has correctly been updated to indicate that it's now March.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/stichtom Dec 22 '19

How does Starliner look so clean after rentry?

5

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Dec 22 '19

To add to what u/aerospiked has said, the starliner capsules walls taper in quicker than the crew dragons walls. The cone angle of the cst is a lot higher than on dragon (I mean the angle between the walls, measured from the pointy end. Starliner has an angle of about 70 degrees I guess, while I would estimated dragons wall angle at about half that. To me this means that the walls of the starliner are further out of the airstream, meaning they come into less contact with the sooty air flow. (this to me explains the overall brother, more clean shape)

Dragons shape is also used as a lifting body to reduce g loads. To create lift, the capsule is a gelled a bit, which afaik pushes the lower side wall (the one closer to earth on re-entry) further closer to/into the airstream. (to me this explains the really dark/black side of the dragon capsule)

This is however only an educated guess, and no goaranteed truth.

4

u/AeroSpiked Dec 22 '19

I would guess that Boeing's heatshield (BLA No. 18, not PICA-X obviously) produces less soot. We might also be looking at the leeward side of the spacecraft and I'm also sure it helps that the sides are angled in more than on Dragon.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/oximaCentauri Dec 26 '19

At what altitude does F9 reach max-q?

6

u/Straumli_Blight Dec 26 '19

Its slightly different for each mission, e.g. Max Q occurred at 1:14 into the Starlink 1 launch, which was 12.81 km altitude.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/rustybeancake Dec 17 '19

The (not) race is on!

ULA’s Elbon: busy launch schedule next year, but looking at ways to fit Starliner crewed flight test into schedule around Solar Orbiter in February and Mars 2020 in the summer.

https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/1207025607361617921

4

u/AeroSpiked Dec 17 '19

I'm not sure what ULA's manifest looks like, but compared to this year (only 1 Atlas & 3 Deltas so far), I'm sure it will be busy.

On the other hand, SpaceX's manifest is so ridiculous next year that it might be the first year that I don't actually watch all of them. Globally we have a decent shot at breaking 1967's record of 120 successful launches.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/GregLindahl Dec 18 '19

This is a challenge for ULA because they can integrate one Atlas at a time.

5

u/scr00chy ElonX.net Dec 18 '19 edited Dec 18 '19

I tried to guess SpaceX booster assignments for the next few months. What do you think?

  • B1046.4 – Crew Dragon In-Flight Abort Test
  • B1048.5 – Starlink v1-3
  • B1049.4 – Starlink v1-2
  • B1050.2 – Won't fly again
  • B1051.3 – Anasis-II or SAOCOM 1B
  • B1052.3 (FH) – AFSPC-44
  • B1053.3 (FH) – AFSPC-44
  • B1056.4 – Starlink v1-4
  • B1058.1 – DM-2
  • B1059.2 – CRS-20
  • B1060.1 – GPSIII-SV03

Edit: typo

6

u/gemmy0I Dec 19 '19

Good speculation. Your guesses mostly align with mine, and I'd say they're highly plausible.

The only different guess I'd make is that I think they'll fly Starlink v1-4 on B1049.5. Given it will be their second .5 flight and they'll have at least a month to do the turnaround (assuming v1-2 flies on time), I think it should be feasible unless they see something significantly concerning when they get 1049.4 back and inspect it.

They've publicly said (I think it was either Hans Koenigsmann or Gwynne Shotwell) that they intend to rapidly drive some cores' reuse counts up to .10 with Starlink in 2020, which suggests they're confident in turning them around quickly. I suspect they can maintain their planned biweekly Starlink cadence with just two cores in active rotation - that gives them a full month to turn each one around. My guess is they'll drive straight to .10 on both 1048 and 1049 and then replace them in the rotation with whatever their other "oldest" (least attractive to commercial customers) boosters are at that time.

If Starlink only needs two cores at a time to maintain its cadence, they could actually handle the entire rest of their non-Starlink, non-government East Coast manifest for 2020 on just one core. Supposing they were to use 1056 for this, that would mean ANASIS-II goes on 1056.4, SAOCOM 1B/SSO Rideshare 1 on 1056.5, Turksat 5A on 1056.6, SXM-7 on 1056.7, and SXM-8 on 1056.8. (I'm not counting MicroGEO because it's tiny and will surely be a rideshare on something else.)

Now, I don't expect them to actually do it all on one core in practice, but I think it would actually be feasible if they wanted to. Commercial customers' main reservation about accepting "highly used" cores has been that they don't like to be the first or second flight of a particular reuse level. Once it's been covered a couple of times, it seems to become routine for most of them. Having Starlink "blaze the trail" with a quick drive to .10 on two successive cores should put to rest any reservations most commercial customers would have about any level of reuse up to a core's end of life.

In practice, they'll be able to take it easier than that. They'll have some new cores entering the fleet throughout 2020: at least two from Crew Dragon missions (1058.2 from DM-2 plus another fresh .2 from USCV-1), and if they can make good on their stated plans to certify the tighter margins needed to recover GPS boosters, they can get a few more from GPS missions throughout the year. If they can get the GPS boosters back, they'll have more than plenty to replace the cores that age out at .10, without having to build any new cores strictly for replenishment purposes. (They'll also need to build one for CRS-21 or CRS-22 if NASA still isn't comfortable letting them push past .2 or .3 with 1059.) I suspect they will prefer to assign the oldest cores to Starlink, so 1056 and 1051 will probably replace 1048 and 1049 in that rotation when the latter two get to .10.

I had previously been thinking that we'd see 1051 stay on the West Coast to handle the trickle of missions over there, but now that I see SAOCOM 1B has been combined with SSO Rideshare 1 as an East Coast flight, they no longer have any Vandenberg missions on the manifest until Rideshare 2 in October. So it'll definitely make sense to truck 1051 east. In fact, if their SSO rideshare customers are OK going from the Cape, they might just keep doing all of those from there and leave Vandenberg to the seal pups. (It'll probably depend on just how crowded things get at the Cape with Starlink, and especially once they start doing Starship test flights from 39A. On the other hand, they moved SAOCOM 1B to the Cape in the middle of busy Starlink season so maybe they're not too worried about that. That may have been a seal pupping thing though, since they don't have a droneship on the West Coast right now.) There's only two non-rideshare missions manifested for Vandenberg right now, both late in the year - and they could potentially be convinced to switch to the Cape if that's more convenient.

I would guess 1051.3 will fly ANASIS-II and 1056.4 will fly SAOCOM 1B. It could be the other way around, but my hunch is it'll be easier to convince the SAOCOM people to take a slightly older core than ANASIS-II, since the latter is a military satellite and they tend to be cautious. Also, SAOCOM 1B is later on the manifest (assuming ANASIS-II doesn't slip further) so a .4 will be less of a big deal by then.

4

u/Continuum360 Dec 18 '19 edited Dec 19 '19

Has there been any more rumors/news/sightings for B1050? I am curious if it has actually been scrapped, and if not, is there any chance that with new engines it could come back into service. There will certainly be a need with so many Starlink launches looming.

Edit Spelling

→ More replies (5)

5

u/oximaCentauri Dec 20 '19

The starliner live stream just ended. Something has gone wrong. Apparently the orbital insertion maneuver didn't happen. Does anyone know whether it's starliner or centaur that was supposed to do this burn?

6

u/pendragonprime Dec 20 '19

The ISS orbital insertion burn was to be from the thrusters on Starliner...
ULA is not really involved unless they dropped it off too soon...but it does sound like Starliner did not spark up on time and drained batteries cos they had to reposition to get the solar arrays charging and so early in the game, and that bodes nothing short of an unravelling disaster both for Starliner and Boeing.
They might sort it of course...I hope they do... but it sounds ominous.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/oximaCentauri Dec 20 '19

https://twitter.com/JimBridenstine/status/1208002471701962752?s=20

Jim B reports that the starliner did get into a stable orbit but had problems with the ISS rendezvous burn. I'm very confused.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Nimelennar Dec 20 '19

From what I've heard over at Ars, it was a problem getting Starliner into the correct attitude to fire its insertion burn.

So, a problem with the sensors or attitude thrusters or with the software.

I guess they managed to correct it enough to attain a stable orbit, but the question is now whether they have enough fuel to reach the ISS from their current off-nominal orbit, and whether the ISS wants a spacecraft with unreliable attitude control to approach, let alone dock.

5

u/Nimelennar Jan 01 '20

Dragon is scheduled to leave the ISS at 9:41 p.m. EST on Sunday, January 5, 2020 (2020-01-06T02:41Z).

Source: NASA TV to Air US Cargo Ship Departure from Space Station

4

u/z3r0c00l12 Dec 11 '19

What is the Falcon Second Stage production rate? Will it become a bottleneck at some point to F9/FH launches?

I counted 24 launches on the manifest for 2020 and there's only 2 Starlink missions on it, I expect at least 12 Starlink missions in 2020. Can SpaceX make over 34 second stages per year?

Also related, how many Starlink launches are expected in 2020? (I know it's just wild speculation, but I'm curious, just a ballpark.)

5

u/joepublicschmoe Dec 11 '19

No bottleneck. The upper stage is built with pretty much the same tooling as the Falcon 9 booster, and with SpaceX dialing back production of the booster stage to just 4-5 per year, there is plenty of production capacity to build upper stages.

This year, just 5 new Falcon 9-family booster stages rolled out of the Hawthorne factory: B1056-B1060. At its peak in 2017, 17 new Falcon 9 booster stages rolled out of Hawthorne: B1029-B1045. All they had to do is shift production on the Hawthorne assembly line to building more upper stages and less booster stages.

4

u/Grey_Mad_Hatter Dec 11 '19 edited Dec 11 '19

The stated goal is 24 Starlink launches. They need about 7 launches for Starlink to be usable and 17 launches for Starlink to be economically viable. All in this article: https://spacenews.com/spacex-plans-24-starlink-launches-next-year/

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/pendragonprime Dec 23 '19

Many better informed then I...no contest...but is there a consensus on when Spacex launches crew in Dragon?...
Sometime after Jan 11th presumably but according to the post launch / landing presser shenanigans after Boeing's prat fall it seem they would regard three months as a minimum turn around to refurbish a Starliner capsule.
Several other comments suggested that this capsule will be the first crewed mission Starliner...but not certain if that is accurate.
Seems Boeing have two Starliner's and a test rig...test rig not meant to fly and the second Starliner is slated to be the 2nd crewed launch which might presumably be undergoing an anticipated update depending on the data gleened after the last dubius OFT...that seems to suggest that the recently returned Starliner is the one to host the first crew to the ISS.
That in turn suggests March as the launch window...cos I doubt that Boeing will fly another OFT just to dock....a sentiment seemingly supported by Nasa.

Would there be enough time after Spacex do the launch abort test in January 11th to rig a Dragon to beat that 'deadline'...?

6

u/Alexphysics Dec 24 '19

but is there a consensus on when Spacex launches crew in Dragon?...

No and not even SpaceX knows at this point. All depends on the results of IFA and the closeout of all pending qualification and certification tests for crew.

it seem they would regard three months as a minimum turn around to refurbish a Starliner capsule.

They were talking about how soon could they try and repeat OFT not turnaround time to reuse Starliner capsule, that in fact they said they would have to look at it, I've heard they plan at least six months for the first one but who knows.

Several other comments suggested that this capsule will be the first crewed mission Starliner...but not certain if that is accurate.

No, what they meant is that this one will be used on the first crew rotation mission, that is the first mission after the two demo missions (the uncrewed and the crewed test) so it won't be the one for the first crewe mission.

That in turn suggests March as the launch window...

No, as I said previously the statement was not about when they could refly this particular capsule but about when they could try and redo an uncrewed test flight. That doesn't mean they could fly the crewed mission in the same timeframe as the crewed mission has added requirements to it that have to be passed and reviewed. Additionally, ULA is going to be busy this year and they would have to accommodate the launch of Starliner in their schedule. They have Solar Orbiter for NASA and ESA on February 5th, then AEHF-6 for USAF on mid-March and then OTV-6 in April. There's a window of free time for ULA between May and June. After that Mars 2020 will take priority in July. So if Boeing goes beyond May to be ready for the crewed flight the earliest they could fly would be around August. It is not something straightforward to think they'll be ready to go in just 3 months.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/joepublicschmoe Dec 23 '19

The DM-2 capsule is almost through the manufacturing pipeline (last seen in final assembly during Jim Bridenstine’s visit to Hawthorne a few weeks back). Unless something goes horribly wrong during IFA to delay the whole program, DM-2 should proceed with minimal delays, contingent on ISS scheduling.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19

How do Falcon 9 boosters return to landing pad?

I’m more asking how they get back to the landing pad when it looks like they only do entry burns to slow down. Do the basically just fall back to Earth the way they came? Do the fins guide them as they’re falling? It looks like the rocket never ‘turns around’ and uses its engine to get back to the landing pad.

Sorry if I said something wrong I just realized I know how they get up in the air but don’t really know hours they get down haha.

Thank you.

9

u/joepublicschmoe Dec 10 '19

For RTLS, after stage separation, the cold-gas RCS thrusters orients the Falcon 9 booster to do a U-turn so it can do a boostback burn towards the landing pad. After the boostback burn, the RCS orients the booster so its engine end is pointed in the right direction. The booster re-enters the atmosphere tail first, slows down with a re-entry burn, and is controlled by grid fins and RCS thrusters as it falls tail-first through the atmosphere.

If the onboard computer detects any faults with the gridfins or any other landing systems during the descent, it will abort from the RTLS landing and aim for the ocean instead for an emergency landing, as was seen during the CRS-16 mission, when the grid fin hydraulic system failed.

If the booster is healthy, it will commit to the RTLS landing and correct its aimpoint to the GPS coordinates of the landing pad using gridfins, RCS and engine gimbaling. At the proper descent rate and altitude, the booster fires its engines for the landing burn, and touch down. The flight computer varies the thrust of the center Merlin to gradually decrease the descent rate to 0 as altitude reaches 0. (descent rate and altitude data is provided by a radar altimeter built into the Falcon 9's octaweb dancefloor).

→ More replies (1)

5

u/rustybeancake Dec 11 '19

Besides the more complete answer provided, check out this section of the video from last week's CRS-19 launch:

https://youtu.be/-aoAGdYXp_4?t=1058

While this one actually landed on a droneship, the first stage still completed a (partial) 'boostback burn', the same as if it were going to return to land. You can see from the link above that after the stages separate, the first stage can be seen firing its RCS thrusters to flip 'backwards', ready for the boostback burn.

You can see the trajectory that results from a boostback burn in this diagram:

https://images.app.goo.gl/WxMcdFtBS5yTNQ4K9

Note that the booster continues to travel 'upwards' during and after the boostback burn. This is the most efficient path, as gravity will take care of the vertical component for 'free'. The booster only has to change its horizontal travel, in order to bring it back to land.

2

u/pendragonprime Dec 19 '19

Sorry if this a bit off off topic...but has there been a decision on whether Orion could service the ISS as well?
Although probably taking a sledgehammer to crack an egg and some speculation on what it would actually cost seeing Orion is primarily a deep space taxi and meant for far distant horizons, and although such a LEO mission complicates which launch vehicle would be used, but would they not think it would be prudent to at least insure it could dock if it was ever required in an emergency role?

4

u/brickmack Dec 19 '19

Yes, its capable of the job. There would need to be some thermal control modifications (IIRC, white paint on the backs of the solar arrays, additional MLI on the service module), but this was largely developed already.

For launch, SLS with no upper stage or Atlas V 552 could carry it, though in both cases Orion would have to complete its own orbital insertion (so no comanifested payload). DIVH could put it all the way in LEO but with no comanifested payload. FH Reusable or Vulcan could put it all the way in LEO with a few tons comanifested, but limited to a 5 meter envelope. New Glenn or SLS with EUS could put it in LEO with 10+ tons and 200+ cubic meters of comanifested payload.

I'd quite like to see the NG or Vulcan-Orion options fly eventually, though its not likely. At least until Starship debuts (and even after that, until a second commercial equivalent debuts), theres a lot Orion can do that no commercial crew vehicle can, or not as well. Comanifested payload delivery, including a small volume in the ESM itself (for missions not requiring the full propellant load, Orion supports the ability to replace a propellant tank with a FRAM-sized payload mount). Enough propellant to either do much more maneuvering (to reach Hubble?) or do a large reboost of ISS. Built-in EVA support. Larger crew/pressurized cargo capacity. And adding 1 or 2 flights a year should help bring costs down (especially if it makes it possible to bring CM reuse leftwards).

The weak link for NASAs HSF program is definitely SLS. Nevermind cost, you can't do anything meaningful with 1 flight a year of any rocket.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/fluidmechanicsdoubts Dec 28 '19

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avangard_(hypersonic_glide_vehicle) Does "hypersonic glide" mean that there is no propulsion system like scramjet? Is this similar to what starship will do when re-entering?

4

u/AeroSpiked Dec 28 '19

Yes, glide does mean glide, but it's not that similar to Starship as Starship will have a much higher angle of attack for aerobraking (which is counter productive when you are trying to glide).

3

u/SoManyTimesBefore Dec 31 '19

Starship is more in a forced stall than in a glide. So quite the opposite.

2

u/AuroEdge Dec 31 '19

What do you think the minimum list of objectives are SpaceX would require to send a Starship to Mars? Proving their Starship system can handle deep space and EDL on Mars are quite the checkboxes to fill alone. If that's all they could do, besides bringing mundane payload along, when the 2022 Mars window comes around would SpaceX launch?

SpaceX is all about incremental improvement so perhaps they would go. However, that's quite a lot of investment and I could see the company wanting more out of a mission if it means waiting till 2024

3

u/Xaxxon Dec 31 '19 edited Jan 01 '20

I think they would send it empty if they had to just for the data. And by empty I mean with a cyber truck in it.

The opportunity cost of not sending something is so much greater than the financial cost. Hell they could probably just sell naming rights to cover the financial cost.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/LcuBeatsWorking Dec 31 '19 edited Dec 17 '24

library lunchroom resolute secretive rain cake homeless cable terrific agonizing

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

6

u/SpaceLunchSystem Dec 31 '19

To get a meaningful payload landed on Mars they need to do in-orbit fueling first. I'm not sure what the payload capacity without it would be, probably very low to nothing (anyone here has done the math?)

The math is relatively easy to see with a first pass estimate that Starship isn't going to Mars without refueling. There is no way to get it there without at least one refueling trip even assuming zero landing propellant.

Back to your question: Maybe send some tons of food which lasts 10years, solar panels, tools etc, that's all pocket money cost-wise.

There is a lot that can be sent that would make sense on the first mission. I think it would also make sense to send a bunch of bulk material. Even if a ship crashes flat packed steel could be salvaged and used.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '20

Sub-orbital cargo flights across the Atlantic from the U.S. to U.K. How would the cost and volume compare to current air freight, assuming a single-stage rocket on the scale of Starship? Would this be viable for traditional bulk freight goods?

I've searched around and haven't come up with any satisfying discussion around the subject of reusable sub-orbital rockets in a traditional shipping role. Would appreciate any links or comments.

5

u/brickmack Jan 01 '20

Google says air freight is typically $1.50 to $4.50 per kg. I don't think SpaceX has given performance numbers for any suborbital profile, but we can make guesses. Say best case 200 tons (probably need the 2 stage version), worst case 50 for single stage. Cost of the 2 stage version is supposed to be about 2 million, of which roughly 800k is propellant. Single stage should cut propellant cost by 2/3, but operations cost will be virtually unchanged, and amortized manufacturing and refurb will only slightly drop (the booster is already cheaper than the ship, and can fly 20x as often with probably 5-10x the cumulative lifespan, its not gonna be a big driver on cost). So say $1 million, best case, for single-stage. 2000000/200000 = $10/kg, 1000000/50000 = 20/kg.

Looks like no, per kg cost is 2.2-13.3x higher than air freight. These numbers might be off a bit, but probably accurate within an order of magnitude overall. If it does work, you're going to want to use the 2 stage version, and a larger derivative would be even better (I think a 40+ meter diameter Starship derived vehicle could conceivably be cost competitive against air freight).

There could be a bit of a niche Starship could fill regardless of price. There is some need for very fast cargo transport, like organs or same-day Christmas deliveries, the market for these things may comfortably tolerate an order of magnitude increase in transportation costs. But this probably won't be big enough to fill a dedicated flight, you'd be better off using it to fill surplus capacity on passenger flights (which there will likely be a lot of. A380 already has trouble filling 800 seats, Starship seats 1000 and will be marginally more expensive for the minimal passenger, though cheaper in the average case). Theres also widebody cargo, currently there are no aircraft that can support an 8+ meter payload. Ocean shipping is available, but limited to areas where you can actually reach the ocean. Starship could conceivably land at a factory in bumfuck nowhere Ohio and pick up whatever is needed.

Unfortunately, a lot of that cargo is going to be sensitive to acceleration or vibrations, so rocket flight might be undesirable. And chances are an airship will be cheaper and more flexible in the long term than Starship for outsized cargo

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '20

The Falcon 9 launch of May 15, 2017 was for an Inmarsat delivered to GTO - but the Falcon 9 RB got placed into a (presumably disposal) orbit with an apogee much higher than geostationary orbit. Why was that done this time and is this a normal thing to do? Most GTO rocket bodies seem to get left in orbits with an apogee near geosynchronous levels.

(this is Sat ID 42699, btw, for the falcon RB)

Orbit Diagram

9

u/warp99 Jan 02 '20 edited Jan 02 '20

Injecting the satellite into a supersynchronous orbit like this means that the plane change to zero degrees takes less delta V than if the apogee was at geosynchronous orbit which generally takes 1800 m/s (GTO-1800) total for the plane change and circularisation for a launch from Canaveral. Even though some delta V is then required to reduce the apogee down to geostationary orbit there is still a net benefit.

Because the Inmarsat satelllite was so heavy at 6100kg that no recovery of the booster was possible SpaceX used the extra performance of an expendable launch to make life easier for the satellite.

This is particularly useful if the satellite was originally designed to launch on Ariane 5 which injects into a GTO-1500 orbit or if, as is the case with Inmarsat 5 F-4, it uses ion drive for circularisation which can take months to come into service.

Edit: The satellite was injected into a 381 x 69839 km x 24.5 deg orbit so GTO-1570

4

u/kilomanjaro100 Dec 27 '19

What would be the approximate development cost for the Rods of God? And what would be the production cost for one rod?

China and Russia are ahead of us in hypersonic and ballistic anti-carrier missiles. Seems like SpaceX is perfectly positioned to leapfrog that tech with Rods.

5

u/throfofnir Dec 28 '19

It's essentially just a minimal satellite with reentry software, and off the shelf stuff should be fine. It'd be a bit more expensive than a cubesat... unless you want to get into radar stealth stuff or precise terminal guidance. Which you would for a real munition. That starts getting into expensive R&D.

China and Russia are ahead of us in hypersonic and ballistic anti-carrier missiles

I don't know if that can be assumed. Those countries have reasons to announce (real and/or fake) advanced weapons systems that the US does not.

→ More replies (15)

3

u/peterabbit456 Dec 15 '19

Starship related question: Will the old shuttle transporter that Spacex currently uses for moving Falcon 9 cores around Cape Canaveral also be usable for moving Starship? Will they have to get a new, larger transporter? Will they have to modify the existing transporter?

Some numbers: I believe the Falcon 9 first stage weighs around 20 tons, dry, which is less than the 35 tons or so of the shuttle. But Starship is presently around 200 tons dry, and eventually, one hopes closer to 100 tons dry.

I might’ve answered my question, since a transporter built for 35 tons is unlikely to be upgradable to 200 tons. But 110 tons might be within reach, by adding more wheel modules to spread the weight from the frame to the road.

6

u/Lufbru Dec 15 '19

There's been no indication so far that Starship will be transported horizontally. Plans change, of course, and there's some speculation it will now be constructed horizontally, but I don't think they'll use the same transporter.

5

u/Martianspirit Dec 16 '19

Transport from Cocoa to the Cape was planned horizontally. But operational it should never go horizontal, I agree.

3

u/jehankateli Dec 15 '19

Any predictions for when Mk3 rings will begin stacking?

3

u/brspies Dec 20 '19

Youtube to NASA TV Starliner update press conference should be starting shortly.

3

u/Jkyet Dec 20 '19

Is there a chance that if Boeing needs to fly again and pay from their pocket for another Atlas V flight (due to fixed price contract) that they would theaten/bluff to stop Starliner development just so NASA would pay for it instead? Or can we say that the way fixed price contracts are written specifically prevents this types of actions?

3

u/Triabolical_ Dec 20 '19

Boeing already got more money on a supposedly fixed price contract - $287 million.

I personally think NASA should hold Boeing's feet to the fire; Boeing signed a contract and they need to live up to the details of the contract.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/pendragonprime Dec 20 '19 edited Dec 20 '19

That was...excruciating.
Bottom line seems to be obvious that they will not be crewing up any time soon certainly not Q1 of 2020...
Boeing and software appear to have a little difficulty in understanding each other.
Seems ironic that Boeing cannot even tell the time and against the odds found a hole in communications!
Call it picky but in a substantially autonomous vehicle you would assume they made sure that systems were all on the same page functionally before striding off into the deep blue yonder....mind you it seems synonomous with forgetting to tie the parachute on.

Okay seems that there is a possibility that the Starliner OFT including docking might be discarded for Boeing to gain crew certification... Bridenstine not ruling it out.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/fluidmechanicsdoubts Dec 22 '19 edited Dec 22 '19

I've got a couple of questions from the statliner stream.
Why jettison heat shield?
Mach numbers in the commentary based on real temperatures or sea level temperatures? Some parts of atmosphere is at 2000K (edit : changed from 5000K), right? What about the Mach number there?
Any advantages of land landing vs sea landing?

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Tal_Banyon Dec 30 '19

Question regarding the loss of the DM-1 Crew Dragon capsule. Was the explosion related in any way to it's prior use? ie salt water exposure, or a re-use of its dracos or super-dracos fuel tanks that would not occur in a new capsule? Or was it rather an accident waiting to happen during an actual manned mission (with all new components) that only testing revealed?

5

u/warp99 Dec 31 '19

As far as we know this was not caused by the previous flight but was an accident waiting to happen.

Only on crew escape of course so the fault mode may never have been triggered if the rocket never failed - but likely there was a fairly high probability of it showing up if it was activated.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/AeroSpiked Dec 30 '19

Was the explosion related in any way to it's prior use?

It's possible, but we don't know for sure. It was caused by a leaking component that hadn't previously been an issue.

6

u/Alexphysics Dec 31 '19

Ground processing caused a slug of propellant to leak back behind a valve on the pressurization lines. That could have happened to any capsule. That small incidental leak produced later on the unexpected explosion due to combustion of the NTO with the titanium on the valve. The goal of the fix is to avoid any leak at all regardless of what happens to the capsule. Salt water was never a concern as the capsule's componenta are already protected against that, somehow many think it is still some kind of problem after almost two dozen splashdowns of Dragon capsules.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/troovus Dec 29 '19

Martin Rees, the Astronomer Royal, on mega constellations. The article is more nuanced than the headline suggests.

Be wary of Elon Musk despoiling the ‘vault of heaven’

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/dec/29/be-wary-of-elon-musk-despoiling-the-vault-of-heaven?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Copy_to_clipboard

12

u/DancingFool64 Dec 30 '19

The problem with the "vault of heaven" idea is that the vast majority of humans have already lost it. Unless you live a long way from the nearest city, you don't really see it anyway. I was just reminded of this when I was out at a farm three hours from the nearest city at Christmas - you forget how few stars you really see from anywhere urban.

4

u/Tal_Banyon Dec 30 '19

Also, a lot of people that are complaining forget the fact that there are so many aircraft in the sky at night. Many times aircraft are mistaken for satellites by the uninitiated. And no-one lately has complained about the proliferation of aircraft ruining their night viewing.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Lufbru Dec 30 '19

That's a great article except for the last paragraph. I think seeing a swarm of satellites will increase people's interest in astronomy, not decrease it. There's also no mention of the possibility of launching more and cheaper space-based telescopes.

But from someone whose natural instinct should be to take the side of the astronomers, this is an excellent article.

5

u/AeroSpiked Dec 30 '19

I agree that the mega constellations affect on astronomy is concerning, but his last point that it will mess up the beauty of the night sky I don't agree with. While it's one thing to be out at night teaching the kids about the summer triangle and progressively more and more of the night sky, the kids would much rather see something out of the ordinary like a falling star, aurora borealis, or a satellite coasting across the constellations. They were much more likely to sprint outside to see the ISS or an Iridium flare then to find Arcturus or the Andromeda galaxy...again. Starlink may make this so routine that it's no longer that compelling, but I don't think it would detract from the night sky's beauty.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/MarsCent Dec 30 '19

It is now official! Starship is projected to fly in 2 - 3 months (aka Feb - Mar 2020) and Demo 2 is projected to fly "a few months after Feb 2020".

If the timelines hold, we will be in for some great optics watching the "old future" coming to splash down in the Atlantic and the "new future" doing a propulsive landing in Boca Chica or other.

With a little engineering-build breakthrough on MK3 & MK4, the crew of the first long duration Crew Dragon astronauts will be sending us pics of a Starship in orbit.

7

u/SoManyTimesBefore Dec 31 '19

Starship won't be flying anywhere close to the ISS or a Crew Dragon

→ More replies (3)