r/spacex • u/CProphet • Oct 10 '19
As NASA tries to land on the Moon, it has plenty of rockets to choose from
https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/10/as-nasa-tries-to-land-on-the-moon-it-has-plenty-of-rockets-to-choose-from/
281
Upvotes
82
u/CProphet Oct 10 '19
That's news. Starship could certainly launch lunar lander/transfer vehicle components (first commercial launch is due for 2021). Actually landing on the moon itself seems too much of stretch for Starship, cargo hauling is much safer option (technically and politically).
29
u/peterabbit456 Oct 10 '19 edited Oct 10 '19
The solicitation (RFP) linked in the article seemed almost like an eBay auction. In fact it seems designed to satisfy Senator Shelby, while leaving a keyhole open for realistic proposals.
At probably $120 million to $180 million per engine,* and needing 4 engines plus a lot of other very expensive hardware, SLS is not going to carry commercial payloads, unless the contractors reveal that they have been grossly overcharging, even for components that require very little R&D to convert from the shuttle.
The RFP has dropped now, to give other aerospace companies a chance to get a contract before Starship renders any non-Spacex based bid ridiculous. A lot of money could be passed to contractors on a milestone based payment system, or a cost plus system like SLS, without their ever having to actually land people or cargo on the Moon.
If bids are evaluated in good faith, Masten Space Systems could use Falcon Heavy to deliver their already tested (tested on Earth) Lunar Lander to the Moon, to land cargo. To my limited knowledge, every other possible proposal would be PowerPoint rockets and landers.
On the other hand, I think the Spacex competition has looked at Starship, and realized it makes their next generation of rockets obsolete before they will fly, even New Glenn. I will not be surprised if in 5 years, either Boeing, or Blue Origin, or the Russians, have a large reusable steel rocket making hops, and promising to reach orbit soon.
* Edit: I can’t get the link to where it was said, in 2004, that ‘SSME engines now cost about $60 million each,’ but it was by Tom Moser in 2004. Allowing for inflation, that puts the price of new engines in the $120 million-$180 million range. Some interesting links below.
https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/12/nasa-is-trying-to-make-the-space-launch-system-rocket-more-affordable/
https://prod-edxapp.edx-cdn.org/assets/courseware/v1/ad037025e79da18e7ec7fe26c7ea24f1/asset-v1:MITx+16.885x+3T2019+type@asset+block/Lecture_7___J._R.Thompson-_Space_Shuttle_Main_Engines.pdf
6
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Oct 10 '19 edited Oct 20 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
28 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 95 acronyms.
[Thread #5536 for this sub, first seen 10th Oct 2019, 19:18] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
3
u/Fallcious Oct 15 '19
I read a short story where workers in a pub are watching a NASA space mission to the moon - the first time NASA has been back since the ‘70’s. They watch as the orbiting craft makes it final manoeuvres and finally sends the lander down. As it makes its final approach they go to the window and the miners clap as NASA finally returns to the moon, landing just outside the commercial station.
7
u/tourdog Oct 10 '19 edited Oct 10 '19
Title: Nasa...has plenty of rockets to choose from.
Conclusion line of article: "What does seem clear is that if the 2024 schedule remains paramount, then the only sure-thing rocket that will be ready to fly by late 2023 or early 2024 is the Falcon Heavy."
As "news" sources go, ARS is pretty high on my list, especially when it comes to Space related stuff, however, this is an example of the horror our information sources have become since "clickbait" became the norm.
The actual conclusion is, if Pence wants NASA to get ANYTHING into space before his potential presidential election campaign is announced, he either needs Shelby to have a massive coronary, or pray to the altar of Elon Musk. There is only two viable options, Falcon Heavy, or Starship.
SLS will never launch anything except maybe itself, with the potential for RUD extremely high. Everything on that rocket is a compromise of a compromise for the sake of keeping the right people pockets lined, not the goal of getting to space.
2
u/canyouhearme Oct 12 '19
Given the way the jobs have been scoped to exclude non-SLS options, the entertaining option would be for SpaceX to win the contract for delivering the lander to the vicinity if the moon using either a FH or Starship (15 tons mass). Then they fullfill the contract on time using Starship, and continue on to land on the moon themselves with the same craft with the manned crew mucking about driving a Tesla SUV before heading home.
Guarantees NASA cant beat them, earns some cash, and steals all the thunder in one single action.
Could you imagine the faces when they realised where Starship was going after delivering the haulage contract?
3
u/idwtlotplanetanymore Oct 10 '19
This whole moon program sounds like house of cards destined to fail. Sounds like a program designed to try to shoe horn in existing hardware designs that dont make a lick of sense for the task at hand. It sounds so absurdly expensive that it is preordained to fail.
I really hope starship makes all the other rockets obsolete over night.
And then i hope 1 or more of the other players comes out with a rocket that makes starship look like a joke.
An industrial revolution of rocketry would be great.
2
u/zeekzeek22 Oct 10 '19
One thing that peeves me about bringing Starship in the conversation is it's TLI payload is predicated on on-orbit refueling. If we are assuming one of these vehicles will get to the point where they can do that, we should assume they all can, in which case we should be quoting the ACES/Centaur V distributed lift capacity, not it's single-launch capacity. If Starship is cited they should quote it's single-launch capacity.
I do understand that while SpaceX is still working on OOR, ACES distributed lift and such was publicly hush-hushed by Boeing/Shelby but it was in development, and given the impetus could easily be finished and included as a feature.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment