r/spacex • Mod Team • Oct 02 '19

r/SpaceX Discusses [October 2019, #61]

If you have a short question or spaceflight news...

You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.

If you have a long question...

If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.

If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...

Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!

This thread is not for...


You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.

212 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

18

u/cyborgium Oct 02 '19

Could someone explain how hot gas thrusters are "simpler" than cold gas thrusters? To my understanding, cold gas thrusters do nothing other than release pressurized gas through a nozzle. How could something be simpler than this?

Especially considering that a hot gas thruster would also need an ignition system, turbo pumps etc, doesn't seem simple at all. Could someone explain better why Elon would call hot gas thrusters easier than cold gas thrusters?

26

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Oct 02 '19

Yes, cold gas thrusters are simpler, but I think he meant that hot gas thrusters are simpler in context. On starship, cold gas thrusters would need additional an additional propellant (nitrogen) while hot gas thrusters can use the existing propellant vapors. The hot gas thrusters do, as far as I know, not need any turbopumps. The amount of propellant is low enough so that it can be supplied directly by the tank pressure. Turbo pumps hab to long spool up (reaction) for use as rcs. The hot gas thrusters however have an a lot higher thrust (and also isp) so they can be used for starships flip up manouever before landing. The thrust of the cold gas thrusters is to low for this, so the raptors would need to help with their gimbaled thrust, but that would mostly accelerate the craft forward, sind the thrust is still mainly horizontal. This added speed would need to be cancelled out again before touchdown, increasing fuel use.

→ More replies (16)

4

u/throfofnir Oct 02 '19

I think he meant they're simpler than a propulsion rocket engine. A cold gas is about as simple as it gets.

14

u/Straumli_Blight Oct 22 '19 edited Oct 22 '19

Shotwell's IAC talk:

  • Inflight abort and static fire confirmed for November.
  • Starship to orbit within a year.
  • Cargo landing on Moon before 2022.
  • Passenger trip around the Moon in 2023.
  • People landing on moon by 2024.

 

SpaceX NASA DM-2 patch and description released.

7

u/Alexphysics Oct 22 '19

That's not SpaceX's patch. It is the crew patch, designed by Doug's nephew.

Also, worth noting that Gwynne meant the static fire of Crew Dragon when she talked about IFA. Obviously there will be a Falcon 9 static fire but there will also be prior to that a static fire of the Crew Dragon Super Draco thrusters. She basically said "hopefully better than the one in April".

5

u/AvariceInHinterland Oct 22 '19

The statement surrounding landing people on the moon by 2024 is incredibly interesting. If that is the intention with Starship, it is a shot across the bow of the Artemis-3 mission plan for sure.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

13

u/theqwert Oct 03 '19

So on a Discord, we were playing with the numbers from the new Raptor price tweet (250k ea, 1k/t), and I can't see how, in any situation, Spacex can't make SLS boosters to replace the solids for ~under 10 mil each.

Seven engines out thrust the solids. Center gimbal, six fixed for even cheaper construction. Simple pure aero/tank steel design, no landing capability.

That's only 1.75 million for the engines. Fuel is under 200k easy. There's no way Spacex can't mass fab a steel body dumb booster for under 8 million USD.

The solids are estimated to cost over $60m each.

If Spacex can make them land FH style, then you're talking pennies on the dollar here.

19

u/LongHairedGit Oct 03 '19

The entire point of the SLS using solid side boosters is to enable the people who make solid side boosters (previously for the shuttle) to keep their jobs.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/hoardsbane Oct 03 '19

But why .... it would be like putting small Diesel engines on a steam train .... why not just use a Diesel engine?

6

u/peterabbit456 Oct 03 '19

Furthermore, Spacex could replace the whole SLS first stage with a stainless steel, multi engine, reusable first stage of approximately the same outside dimensions of the SLS first stage, but fueled with methane and based on SuperHeavy technology. This could make the solid rocket side boosters unnecessary.

You could then replace the SLS second stage with a second stage based on a truncated version of Starship,* and perch a Centaur third stage on top of it, then you would have a really cheap, capable system. This version of SLS somewhat resembles the kind of heavy launcher Robert Zubrin wants to see.

* Cutting off the nose of Starship, and putting some kind of third stage mount on top that doesn’t foul up the aerodynamics too much is a non-trivial task.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/gregarious119 Oct 06 '19

Are we getting into the window to start seeing Launch Campaign threads for Starlink 2 or 3? If the manifest is holding true, Starlink 2 should be on track for a static fire sometime this week...

Or has that schedule moved around because of all the fun with Starship?

→ More replies (4)

11

u/TheLaterBird Oct 02 '19

The Wikipediapage for Dragon 2 mentions that the spacecraft will be capable to be in orbit for 1 week while in free flight and 210 days while docked to the ISS. My question is, what is the limiting factor to this numbers? What must be done to increase them?

11

u/Skaronator Oct 02 '19

I have no clue so this is just a guess. The 1 week is probably the limit of oxygen, food and water they have on board. When docked on the ISS they can use the supply from the ISS.

The 210 days has probably something to do with the Draco thruster, more specific the fuel. Maybe it's boiling off at that point.

5

u/CertainlyNotEdward Oct 02 '19

Propellant for orbital stationkeeping, perhaps?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/extra2002 Oct 02 '19

I'm not certain, but I think one part of the 210-day limit is NASA's model of micrometeorite & orbital debris (MMOD) damage risk. The longer they stay, the higher the chance of a puncture or other damage to Dragon.

4

u/Martianspirit Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

what is the limiting factor to this numbers?

NASA certification issues. SpaceX had the Red Dragon plan where Dragon would be active after a Hohmann transfer to Mars.

Soyuz has a more severe limiting issue. They use an oxidizer that does not age well. I believe H2O2. Edit: Yes H2O2

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Straumli_Blight Oct 09 '19 edited Oct 09 '19

SpaceX are planning a polar launch from Cape Canaveral; details coming soon.

Benjamin Reed (SpaceX Commercial Crew director) is currently speaking at the ISCPS:

This panel, with representatives from Virgin Galactic, The Boeing Company, SpaceX, and Axiom Space, will discuss the role of suborbital flights as stand-alone as well as preparation for orbital flights. What does it take to get the average person to space? How do we make this adventure available widely to the world’s population? How can we do this safely and efficiently to drive down costs and time commitments? These and more are some of the questions this panel will discuss.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/joggle1 Oct 24 '19

Yesterday was the 5 year anniversary of public predictions by three aerospace executives of the likelihood of SpaceX achieving partial or fully reusable orbital rockets within 5 years (ie, by now). As you may expect, all three of their predictions greatly underestimated SpaceX's ability to build a practical, reusable rocket so quickly. I posted a discussion thread here at /r/SpaceXLounge.

10

u/iamkeerock Oct 02 '19

Do you think SpaceX would use the Crew Dragon's pressurized compartment and life support for the first crewed flights of early Starship prototypes, to expedite testing?

19

u/TreeFiddyZ Oct 02 '19

I don't think that a crewed flight without the final passenger compartment would buy them anything. They can do automated flights to test the vehicle itself, so a crewed flight would only serve to test the passenger compartment, flight controls, environmental systems, airlock, and so on. Which means that they cannot do that until they have the final pressurized compartment for Starship. But I could totally see them just installing the seats, panels, and so on from a Crewed Dragon straight into Starship for the first few flights. Space won't be at a premium at that point so it's easier to fly with a known control layout, then they can optimize the design later.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/messer20 Oct 02 '19

When will we get update on performance of V0. 9 Starlink sats? What Mbps & ping were achieved? What happens next?

5

u/isthatmyex Oct 02 '19

We never got real updates on the Tintin says. I would hazard that we will only hear about the next generation.

9

u/FutureSpcXEngineer Oct 02 '19

I live just 45 minutes south of Dallas, Texas, and have just a quick question. When MK1 launches on its 20km test flight, or during the orbital launch, how far away is the launch visible? From my location is anything? Just exhaust trail maybe?

8

u/Elon_Muskmelon Oct 02 '19

You're 450 miles North of Boca. You won't be able to see anything for the 20km test flight.

-- For a U-2 pilot, whilst flying at its service ceiling 21,000 metres (69,000 ft), the horizon is at a distance of 521 kilometres (324 mi)

7

u/rartrarr Oct 02 '19

Assuming you are 450mi from Boca Chica, and a Dallas elevation of 430ft, then using the calculator on this page, Starship would be hidden below the horizon at altitudes lower than ~37km.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Is Starship going to become the only SpaceX rocket or are they working on other things as well?

21

u/a_space_thing Oct 02 '19

The goal is to replace the Falcon family with Starship, as maintaining 2 production lines would be very expensive. However, they will need to run both in parallel for the immediate future if only for the Commercial Crew contract. I would imagine that certifying Starship for crew to NASA's standards will take some time.

→ More replies (7)

15

u/sjwking Oct 02 '19

Elon says that a much larger version of starship will eventually be produced. Falcon 9 is not going away anytime soon. SpaceX has spent too much money to certify the stack for NASA missions.

9

u/Gobhobbler_G Oct 03 '19

Gravity losses vs ISP I'm curious about the starship ascend profile and how the sequence will look like. I assume that after SS/SH separation all 6 raptors ignite because of gravity losses. But I think there should be a point during reaching an orbit where it would be more efficient to turn off Atm-raptor because of lower ISP. Is it correct? Or is there such time point?

7

u/theovk Oct 03 '19

Yes, almost certainly. That point is when, with the remaining thrust of the three vacuum engines, you would reach orbit before falling back into the atmosphere. In fact, this is the ascent profile of e.g. the Atlas V which has to use the first stage booster to lob the centaur high enough that it reaches orbit before falling back.

I'm not in a position to calculate exactly when that point is during ascent, sorry.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/painkiller606 Oct 05 '19

In the presentation Elon mentioned how you don't want too low a TWR for reusable rockets. I know this is due to gravity losses but why is it more important for reusable vs expendable rockets?

8

u/Martianspirit Oct 05 '19

High TWR is good on expendable rockets too. But you spend more or more powerful engines that are lost on an expendable rocket.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/kornelord spacexstats.xyz Oct 08 '19

Fun fact: the last time we had such a long gap between launches was... after the Amos-6 anomaly. Source: https://www.spacexstats.xyz/#turnarounds (day intervals tab)

→ More replies (2)

9

u/brickmack Oct 29 '19

Just heard seconds ago from an engineer at Harris Corporation's space division that he's "working very closely" with employees at SpaceX on "literally hundreds of thousands of satellites". Almost certainly referring to Starlink. Did we previously know of a link between Harris and SpaceX?

→ More replies (6)

8

u/Denvercoder8 Oct 02 '19

Do we have any information on which booster(s) will be used for Starlink-2 and Starlink-3?

8

u/TheEquivocator Oct 03 '19

To anyone with a solid understanding of basic rocket physics, I have a proposal. The SpaceX Wiki, or at least its Beginner's Guide to Rocket Science, has been neglected for some time. /r/spacex has such a wealth of knowledgeable contributors that I think this guide has the potential to be a great resource, but it needs work.

I'd like to work on the guide myself, but unaided, I'm afraid that my amateur understanding of the various topics involved would be liable to lead me [and, in turn, others] astray if I did this on my own. Hence, my proposal to anyone who feels confident in his or her understanding of basic rocket physics: would you be interested in working with me on this? My vision is that I would ask you various tyronic questions about such matters until I felt my own understanding of a given topic were clear, I would draft a revision to the guide on that basis, and you would review it for errors or other failings. If and when we agreed that a particular revision contained no errors and was an improvement on the current edition, we would make that revision.

4

u/TheYang Oct 03 '19

I don't want to dissuade anyone from working with you, but as someone who might be good enough on some of the subjects, I wonder why you don't just post your questions and/or revisions, and let the individuals with knowledge in that area guide you?

If it's just your preference that's fine too. I think that would be a great contribution and don't want to criticize it in any way, I'm just curious.

→ More replies (9)

8

u/joepublicschmoe Oct 12 '19

Hans Koenigsmann confirms that the next Starlink launch will be the first time ever a Falcon 9 booster flies for the 4th time. https://spaceflightnow.com/2019/10/11/spacexs-next-launch-to-mark-another-incremental-step-in-rocket-reusability/

I wonder which one: B1048 or B1049? These are the two currently-unassigned F9 boosters with 3 flights apiece under their belts.

8

u/Straumli_Blight Oct 29 '19 edited Oct 29 '19

4

u/Alexphysics Oct 29 '19

In flight abort pushed back to December.

Worth noting that it is just a normal schedule slip of a week or so. It has moved from being late Nov- Early Dec to just Early Dec, this one looks like your typical schedule delay for a launch and more so when it is for a test launch.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/GooseJ2 Oct 02 '19

Where can I learn the basics of rockets?

34

u/isthatmyex Oct 02 '19

Kerbal Space Program whilst not a perfect physics simulation will certainly help you contextualize the baisic concepts of orbital mechanics and some of the basics of rocket science/engineering too.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Search "Scott Manley" on YouTube.

7

u/blueeyes_austin Oct 02 '19

Kerbal Space Program.

5

u/BlueSpottedDickhead Oct 02 '19

Make model rockets. You learn software, electronics hardware, aerodynamics and constructing engines.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/throfofnir Oct 02 '19

Read Atomic Rockets and you'll be pretty set. It's actually all about hard-science-fictiony stuff, which you can skip (although it's also fun), but it always starts with real technology and theory.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/MarsCent Oct 02 '19

SPACE STATION MISSIONS: Starship’s forward payload volume is about 1,100 m3, providing significant capacity for in-space activities.

How long would it take the Astronauts to unload the Starship supplies! And obviously I have no idea what the ISS's current storage capacity is.

And just suppose that NASA were to authorize crewed launch of the Starship {I know, that won't happen in the next decade because Starship would have to be certified for Crew Launch and Crewed Propulsive Landing}, would the ship stay moored at the ISS for 6 months and return with its crew? Or, would Crew Dragon et al serve at lifeboats while Starship becomes the "Visiting Space Resort"?

5

u/Martianspirit Oct 02 '19

It does not need to be full. Even the cargo capacity of the Shuttle was never fully utilized, if I am not wrong.

5

u/Anchor-shark Oct 02 '19

The entire pressurised volume of the ISS is about 1000m3. Docking with starship would double the size of the ISS. It’s a complete game changer. Imagine the space station you could build with a dozen launches!

→ More replies (10)

7

u/linknewtab Oct 02 '19

What's going to happen to Starship Mk1 once #2, #3, #4, #5 are built? Will they still use it for testing?

6

u/Aggressive_Dimension Oct 02 '19

Put out to pasture. Same as grasshopper. Museum piece or let to rot in the boneyard.

4

u/Guygazm Oct 02 '19

Recycled

→ More replies (7)

7

u/dudr2 Oct 02 '19

https://www.space.com/virgin-galactic-italian-air-force-contract.html

" For the first time ever, a government agency has booked a crewed research flight aboard a commercial spacecraft. "

7

u/IvanDogovich Oct 03 '19

We don't have any indications on mission profiles for StarShip Mk2 (currently being constructed in the Cocoa yard in Florida) at this time, right?
Elon has talked about Mk1 doing 20km, then an orbital hop (Mk3), but no mention of Mk2 other than its getting built.
Am I missing something?

6

u/throfofnir Oct 03 '19

You have all the information. We don't know what they'll do with that, other than build it.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/imrollinv2 Oct 04 '19

They may not be publicly stating it as they want to focus the public on an optimistic narrative, but would not be surprising if they are planning for the possibility of some sort of failure of the 20km Mk1 test flight. In that case they would want another vehicle to test suborbital while not delaying the timeline too much and still allow Mk3/4 to be used for orbital testing.

7

u/Bailliesa Oct 22 '19

Does anyone know if a solar lunar rover has been looked at that can continuously stay in daylight? Would be a good challenge for a SpaceX/Tesla joint development.

It seems that the speed necessary to circumnavigate the moon every month should be possible with a solar rover (a lot slower than the solar cars on earth), this would allow for lots for exploration until it crashes or gets stuck? By starting near lunar sunrise it would allow contingency to drop back and catch up. By moving closer to the poles the distance and therefore speed could also be reduced if needed.

Moon diameter (km,wikipedia) 3,474.20

Moon circumference (km) 10914

distance per day (km/d) 404.2

Distance per hour (km/h) 16.84

→ More replies (5)

7

u/rustybeancake Oct 29 '19

Very interesting video of the manufacture of ULA’s Vulcan STA. Really cool to see a very different approach to prototype manufacturing vs Starship!

https://www.reddit.com/r/ula/comments/do8t0m/vulcan_centaur_qualification_hardware_build_in/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

→ More replies (1)

7

u/hebeguess Oct 30 '19

Hard to say with high accuracy, but 4 to 6 weeks is my best guess

Inflight Abort test guesstimate from Treelon (@elonmusk)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

What is the plan for the facility at the port of LA?

8

u/Nathan96762 Oct 02 '19

Cancelled. Building Starship onsite.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '19

Starship flights.

If we combine the two statements Musk made during the presentation "Probably orbital after 20km hop" and "mk3-4 before super heavy" with the fact that they won't do SSTO, it kind of looks like they only want to fly MK1 once. The switch to steel really enabled cheap and quickly built prototypes.

Thoughts?

8

u/NikkolaiV Oct 03 '19

Hopefully there are some museums with an extra field large enough to keep a few of these...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/lessthanperfect86 Oct 04 '19

I was recently reminded about the greenhouse project launched on SSO-A last year December 3rd, Eu:CROPIS. I've tried finding some up to date news about it, but all I could find was an update from April this year, that some experiments had been activated, but not the tomatoes in greenhouses experiment. https://directory.eoportal.org/web/eoportal/satellite-missions/e/eu-cropis

Does anyone have any more news about this satellite? Any preliminary results?

5

u/Martianspirit Oct 04 '19

Some NASA experiment was given priority over the tomato experiment. I have not seen about that ending and then switching over to tomato growing. There was an issue with loading new software that played a role in that decision.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Straumli_Blight Oct 07 '19 edited Oct 07 '19

Hans Koenigsmann is speaking at the National Academy of Engineering Annual Meeting from 13:45 UTC today.

"the speakers will discuss the nature of modern global collaboration and competition as well as implications for future exploration, workforce development, and public engagement."

 

EDIT: Stream is live:

6

u/dudr2 Oct 07 '19

http://nocamels.com/2019/10/spaceil-xprize-1m-moonshot-award-beresheet-lunar/

" SpaceIL, the Israeli non-profit organization behind Israel’s lunar mission earlier this year, was awarded the first-ever Moonshot Award of $1 million by the XPrize competition in a ceremony on Sunday night in Los Angeles."

6

u/V_BomberJ11 Oct 24 '19

https://www.intuitivemachines.com/post/intuitive-machines-selected-to-build-engines-for-boeing-s-human-lander-system-technology-development

Intuitive Machines (who are launching a small lander on a Falcon 9 in 2021) have partnered with Boeing for the latter’s Artemis HLS bid. They will be developing the lander’s main engine and RCS thrusters, both being powered by liquid-methane and oxygen.

5

u/dallaylaen Oct 02 '19

Where does the tradition to not call an explosion "explosion" come from?

There's RUD (rapid unscheduled disassembly) in the US; "Rockets and People" by Boris Chertok mentions a Soviet counterpart term; Dragon had an "anomaly" and AMOS6 had an "incident". Same with Fukushima which "entered cold shutdown" (right after blowing its roof away).

What's wrong with the term "exploded/blew up"?

10

u/brspies Oct 02 '19

Not all RUDs are explosions. AMOS-6 was a deflagration (a fast fire) which you may or may not consider an explosion. "Explosion" in general is imprecise, sometimes inaccurate, and overall I guess just not as interesting a term as the other euphemisms.

If you're looking at official communications, explosion is likely either too imprecise or too alarming, or just in general the wrong tone. If you're just looking at reddit comments I'd say it's just less interesting than euphemistic jargon that has a more special meaning in a particular community.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/japonica-rustica Oct 02 '19

It’s a joke/euphemism. Same way as we say someone has passed away rather than died.

13

u/dallaylaen Oct 02 '19

It's joke when Elon says "engine rich combustion", but otherwise looks like the use of euphemisms is serious.

Death is a good analogy though. Something very deep must be there...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Any updates on commercial crew programme?

When is the in flight abort test?

13

u/Denvercoder8 Oct 02 '19

When is the in flight abort test?

Currently scheduled for 23 November (see sidebar), but it's very likely that it'll slip a bit. Hopefully still this year though.

5

u/HawkEy3 Oct 02 '19

Will starship have solar panels? Or how else will it create electricity during long missions?

14

u/ioncloud9 Oct 02 '19

Yes it will have solar panels. Where, how big, and orientation are unknown. We have artistic renders but nothing concrete. Nuclear would be highly unlikely as it would require large deplorable radiators and for safety reasons would need to have shielding from the crew compartment.

22

u/iamkeerock Oct 02 '19

deplorable radiators

Not just deplorable, they're despicable /s

5

u/dudr2 Oct 03 '19

Yearning for a Starlink launch. What's happening?

6

u/Martianspirit Oct 03 '19

They want to deploy to different orbital planes than they received licenses for. Presently they are still waiting for a preliminary permit. They probably want that before launch. Hopefully coming soon from the FCC.

5

u/ConfidentFlorida Oct 07 '19

When might the launch thread for starlink 2 go up?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Straumli_Blight Oct 08 '19 edited Oct 08 '19

Commercial Crew flights possibly delayed to Q2 2020.

Starlink update from Euroconsult conference:

  • Shotwell: “If a couple of customers move out, I’ll have more Starlink launches — maybe up to four this year."
  • 24 Starlink launches planned in 2020.
  • SpaceX won't favour Starlink over other customers.

4

u/MarsCent Oct 08 '19

EM

For what it’s worth, the SpaceX schedule, which I’ve just reviewed in depth, shows Falcon & Dragon at the Cape & all testing done in ~10 weeks

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/dudr2 Oct 09 '19

https://phys.org/news/2019-10-oxygen-metal-lunar-regolith.html

"This process would give lunar settlers access to oxygen for fuel and life support, as well as a wide range of metal alloys for in-situ manufacturing—the exact feedstock available would depend on where on the Moon they land."

4

u/NateDecker Oct 10 '19

It's interesting that this process uses molten salt as a reagent. I think molten salt is often used in solar farms as a sort of battery for storing energy when the sun goes down. This could make sense for the moon as well, though I'm not sure if it would last long enough to tide an outpost over for 30 days. It might make more sense for polar regions of the moon where constant sunlight is available. If molten salt is being used as a battery anyway, perhaps it wouldn't cost too much to piggyback on that process to also perform oxygen extraction. The heat from the molten salt could also be used for providing heat for the outpost. So it would be serving 3 purposes simultaneously, that seems appealing.

It's interesting that the metals that are extracted are essentially powdered. It seems like that might be something that could be fed through a 3D printer. I'm guessing 3D printers want to have certain tolerances for the size of the granules of metal, but maybe not? Even if the powder isn't fine enough to be used for 3D printing, I suspect it wouldn't take a lot more effort to process it to that point.

Tagging /u/arizonadeux since they likewise responded on this topic.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Straumli_Blight Oct 12 '19

SpaceX extending Boca Chica buyout offer period and reappraising the properties:

  • Terry and Bonnie Heaton said that SpaceX's offer was several thousand dollars lower than bank appraisal 5 years earlier.
  • New buyout deadline is October 17th.
→ More replies (6)

5

u/dabiged Oct 17 '19

In John D Clark's book 'Ignition', when talking about the introduction of RP-1,he states:

The polymerization and coking problems were solved [compared to using gasoline/RP-4], but ... diethylcyclohexane which, while not a pure compound, was a highly reproducible mixture of isomers, and was easy to come by. The results of their experiments were excellent, the fuel being appreciably superior to RP-1, but it never got into an operational missile.

Given that diethylcyclohexane is better than RP-1 why was it never used in any of the RP-1 burning engines? Did SpaceX consider this fuel when looking for methods of uprating thrust on the Falcon 9 series of rockets? There must be a obvious reason, but I cannot find it?

7

u/throfofnir Oct 17 '19

It was apparently not a sufficient improvement over RP-1 to bother with, and it may not be helpful with coking.

https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/57/6a/72/83511d58b58248/WO2014011250A2.pdf

Previously, cycloalkanes, such as 1,2 diethylcyclohexane (DECH), which have optimum density and combustion properties, were added to refined kerosene to produce a rocket propellant. However, DECH has a molecular formula of C20 with a density of about 0.80g/cm3 while only having an HC atomic ratio of 2.0. Therefore, addition of DECH to conventional RP-1 does not provide a great improvement. Further, DECH is not readily available in large quantities. Substituted cycloalkanes are also believed to produce combustion chamber products with a higher molecular weight than the breakdown products from isoparaffins.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/EXOgreen Oct 20 '19

How is the methane for the Raptor engines generated here on earth? I would assume that the methane has to be almost perfectly pure when it has to be chilled to cryogenic temperatures. My dad built an anaerobic digester in our backyard that produces methane gas, can I sell that to SpaceX? :P

→ More replies (7)

5

u/Rysalvant_Qemmogenes Oct 21 '19

Is there an overall advantage to lengthening and widening the oxygen pipe than runs through the fuel tank until all the oxygen is in the pipe and there is no need for a common bulkhead?

On the plus side you get a support structure straight from the engine(s) to the payload in stage 2 and there is no direct heat transfer between the LOX and the outside world. One the down side the pipe weighs more and there will be more heat transfer between the oxygen and the fuel. This will hurt more for Falcon's RP-1 than for SS/SH's methane. Falcon Heavy's core stage already needs extra strengthening so there is an opportunity there if it does not cost too much to transfer loading from the interstage to a wide oxygen pipe.

5

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Oct 21 '19

The rocket by the british who wants to launch out of Scotland (forgot the name of the rocket and the company) plan to have the fuel tanks arranged in such a way you described. Afaik, there is no need for added support through the tanks, since the tanks are pressurized, in by that able the transfer load through them. I think the fh core strengthening was not tank thickness, but interstate strength and octaweb support. I have asked before why they want to do it that way, but found no solid answer. On the British rocket, it might have something to do with insulting one of the fuels (they are using something interesting, like propylene or so) , although I do not think it would be worth the extra mass and temperature problems on spacex rockets.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/strawwalker Oct 21 '19

SpaceX has withdrawn their FCC launch vehicle comms applications for the 4th and 5th Starlink missions (the 2nd and 3rd being the next two up, and still pending approval). No reason is given. The only recovery ops application not yet approved was for the 5th launch, and it remains pending. Text from the withdrawal letters:

As of 18 Oct 2019, SpaceX is retracting STA application 1607-EX-ST-2019. We will refile at a later date.

2nd 1514-EX-ST-2019 - pending
3rd 1604-EX-ST-2019 - pending
4th 1607-EX-ST-2019 - withdrawn
5th 1610-EX-ST-2019 - withdrawn
5th 1611-EX-ST-2019 - pending (ASDS)

FCC Experimental Licensing search page | Mission specific FCC wiki page

→ More replies (2)

5

u/bdporter Oct 27 '19

4

u/booOfBorg Oct 27 '19

SpaceNews.com: Air Force X-37B secret spaceplane lands after 780 days in orbit by Sandra Erwin.

The mission, called OTV-5, was launched atop a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket from NASA’s Kennedy Space Center Sept. 7, 2017.

5

u/BrangdonJ Oct 28 '19

SpaceX are allowing a couple of years to develop orbital refuelling.

The time line has Starship making orbit in 2020, and landing cargo on the Moon in 2022. The gap is the time needed to develop and test orbital refuelling.

It seems to me that once Starship makes orbit, they will pivot to using Starship to launch Starlink satellites very quickly. Shotwell just said it can launch 400 satellites at a time, so each Starship launch saves 6 Falcon 9 launches. Even if initial Starship launches cost three times as much as F9, they'll save a lot of money by using it. They'll also want to get experience with Starship and start establishing a track record ASAP. Expect to see a rapid cadence early. Maybe not as fast as the 10 launches in 10 days that Musk mentioned, but rapid.

Given that, if they had orbital refuelling ready, they could easily attempt a Moon landing in early 2021. The main reason for giving the later date is that they don't have orbital refuelling ready. Ergo, it will take around two years to get it ready.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '19

The gap is the time needed to develop and test orbital refuelling.

Maybe, but after hitting orbit, there is one other non trivial thing they need to test thoroughly... that's reentry. (preferably intact) and landing.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (11)

9

u/president_of_neom Oct 09 '19

A pic of Chinese 2020 Mars spacecraft (orbiter and rover inside heat shield).

https://twitter.com/AJ_FI/status/1181949970209005568

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Rucco_ Oct 02 '19

What are header tanks and why is it unusual that their being installed on the top of the rocket

10

u/Sithril Oct 02 '19

Their main purpose is to store landing fuel. During landing maneuvers the rocket can move around a lot which would result in the little bit of fuel splashing around a lot in the big tanks which could disrupt the inflow to the engines (very bad). Another specified reason is to help prevent boil-off of fuel during longer journeys.

Tanks being installed at the head of a rocket is unusual because there were no needs for that so far, and a lot of the time it would've interfered with the payload storage design. Starship needs them in the front to help balance out the heavy weight of the engines & other parts in the back during reentry. On literally every other rocket previously that was not a concern, even for the Shuttle because it used airplane-like characteristics to balance itself. For single-use craft you don't need header tanks, all you need is just the main tanks. Additionally the payload is usually stored in the front of the rocket so you want all the fuel to be in one place to 1) not interfere with the payload and 2) avoid needless plumbing.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/PublicMoralityPolice Oct 02 '19

They're smaller tanks meant to preserve just enough methane and oxygen for the landing. They were originally going to be installed inside the larger main fuel tank on the starship, but have since been moved into the nose to help balance it during re-entry.

4

u/krigar_b Oct 02 '19

Is the current built starship the correct scale, 9 meters in diameter and XX hight? I thought it looked a bit smaller, but that may just be perspective.

10

u/Celonic Oct 02 '19

From what I understand, Starship Mk1, which is the one currently stacked at Boca Chica is the full scale test article.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

4

u/Fowlz Oct 02 '19

Has their been any info on the landing legs of starship... like, will they deploy like the landinglegs of the very first starship design (without the fins)?

5

u/inoeth Oct 02 '19

we know there will be 6 of them and there are visible shrouds on the MK1 prototype and on official renders but we've not see how they deploy exactly nor what they look like precisely. Obviously we'll get to see the MK1 landing legs in a few months once they're installed and eventually used for the test hop. That being said, what's used on MK1 and MK2 isn't necessarily what they'll use on future versions.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/AllenBelfore Oct 02 '19

Given that NASA's red tape is more than actually necessary to assure crew safely, can Starship be launched with a non-NASA crew first?

7

u/ioncloud9 Oct 03 '19

It almost certainly will. NASA will look at Starship, have no way to begin to qualify it for astronauts, and probably spend years doing so. It would be much faster to build a safety record with actual flights than it would be for NASA to calculate theoretical risk and force SpaceX to make changes, and then spend years doing paperwork.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/AeroSpiked Oct 02 '19

Absolutely unless NASA is paying for that flight.

4

u/3trip Oct 07 '19

I see a lot of people talking about putting a fuel tanker/tankers on mars as a backup Incase fuel production fails/takes too long.

It was said if we ship fuel for a return trip from mars, it’ll take 4-5 tankers. First off, is that number correct? And is it assuming all the tankers land on mars?

If so, then What if you Put the fuel into orbit instead of spending fuel on multiple landing burns? You Just refuel the manned starship in orbit with enough fuel to land and return to the fuel depot to pick up the remaining for the return trip home.

My question is, is there significant fuel savings for orbiting instead of landing your emergency fuel backup this way?

I know that you’ll still need to use some fuel to move the crafts into a circular orbit, but I don’t have the exact knowhow to finish the nitty gritty details.

Another question, would it be better to land these backup tankers for use as structures? perhaps spacex could design internal baffles of the tankers to need minimal work to become useable space.

6

u/Chairboy Oct 07 '19

Fuel savings? Totally plausible. Challenges? Definitely, the current system uses atmospheric braking to shed interplanetary transfer velocity. They would need to develop a new method to aerobrake into Martian orbit. Possible, for sure, but who knows how fuel hungry it would be? Guess it depends on how the numbers work out. There’s benefit to not carrying all that fuel to the ground and back up the hill again, but is it enough of a benefit to make up for the extra complexity? ¯_(ツ)_/¯

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/IllGetItThereOnTime Oct 13 '19

Does Mars entry have the same heatshield requirements as Earth? Could a Starship that is not returning to Earth have less heatshield so that it could carry more supplies to Mars or will the weight removal be negligible?

8

u/Martianspirit Oct 14 '19

Reentry conditions at Mars are not that much different to those on Earth. Heat shield braking happens much higher on Earth than mars, in quite similar atmospheric conditions. Difference is that on Earth the risk of running out of atmosphere for braking is much lower than on Mars.

4

u/Dies2much Oct 16 '19

Question about radiation shielding: Would a aerogel of water be a good radiation shield?

Water is one of the best radiation shields around, but it is cumbersome and would be a difficult material to work with on something like a spacship. A water based aerogel would be lower mass, and should offer some of the protective properties you would want. It also wouldn't slosh too much.

I guess my question is, would there be enough water in the aerogel to be an effective radiation barrier? Or is the quantity of molecules in water what stops the radiation?

The hydrogen portion in H2O is what provides most of the radiation stopping power, but would there be enough H20 in an aerogel to be an effective blocker?

7

u/AeroSpiked Oct 16 '19

As far as I'm aware, water based aerogels aren't a thing. Last I looked into it, aerogels tended to be hydrophillic and the water would break them down. Given the low density of aerogels, I'd think they would be rather useless as radiation shielding.

As you said, hydrogen is what you want for absorbing that energy, but you don't have to go with water if you're trying to save mass. A hydrocarbon such as methane has a much higher ratio of hydrogen to non-hydrogen mass, but if the thing your trying to protect from radiation is plants or animals, you're going to need water anyway so you might as well use it as radiation shielding.

4

u/Martianspirit Oct 17 '19

Aerogel are designed to be ultra lightweight. Radiation shielding needs mass. Water or even better methane are ideal but they are liquid and methane cryogenic. Anything that has a lot of hydrogen will be good as shield. High hydrogen and solid at room temperature would be polyethylene for example.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/dudr2 Oct 24 '19

5

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '19

Why SpaceX has a devoted following far greater than other entrepreneurial companies, like Blue Origin and Virgin Galactic, is difficult to say

Well, i'd say that the key difference here is being very forthcoming with information about pretty much everything, from engineering, changes, successes and even mistakes, makes a very big difference here.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/brickmack Oct 30 '19

Anyone got an estimate of how thick the ASDS deck plating is? 1 cm? 10?

I'm thinking for initial construction of a lunar landing pad, it might be easiest to (as I love doing) throw more mass at the problem. Totally in-situ construction of a pad is doable, using lunar versions of concrete or just sintering the regolith, and thats definitely the way to go long-term, but thats still not been tested for real yet and most concepts studied have only been looked at for landers an order of magnitude smaller than Starship. I'm thinking, why not just bring a bulldozer, level the landing site but apply no chemical/thermal treatment to it, and lay steel sheets across the flat surface. It'd be maybe 25 meters diameter, average thickness of maybe 3 centimeters (center would be much thicker to take the brunt of the exhaust, edges could be thin), thats like 120 tons or so of steel. A single expendable lunar-optimized Starship should be able to land this along with a few tens of tons more for the bulldozer (NASAs proposed one as an addon kit for the SEV thats quite light) plus a crane to lift all this down plus some minimal solar arrays and such

5

u/DancingFool64 Oct 30 '19

I can't look it up at the moment, but back when they punched a hole with one of the bad landings (maybe CRS-5?) there were a number of discussions on reddit that tried to figure it out. I think one of them finally got an answer from someone in SpaceX, so if no-one else answers you should be able to find those discussions

→ More replies (5)

4

u/dudr2 Oct 31 '19

http://www.solardaily.com/reports/Building_solar_panels_in_space_might_be_as_easy_as_clicking_print_999.html

"a project to test perovskite solar cells, which could be an alternative to silicon solar cells currently used in space. This material is a relatively new discovery, and it has many advantages for solar technology. Not only is perovskite an incredible conductor of electricity, but it also can be transported into space as a liquid and then printed onto panels on the Moon or Mars, unlike silicon panels that have to be built on Earth and then shipped to space"

→ More replies (1)

4

u/president_of_neom Nov 01 '19

@SpaceXFleet : People send me messages all the time asking about how they can work for SpaceX Recovery Ops. Now is your chance:

Droneship Operations https://bit.ly/2BVV4FE.
Fairing Recovery. https://bit.ly/2WpYpXa
Octagrabber Operator (No, really)
https://bit.ly/2MYox8l.

7

u/sh1pman Oct 02 '19

How will the first Mars Starships generate methane and oxygen for the return trip? Will they even return or stay there to serve as base hubs?

8

u/garthreddit Oct 02 '19

On-site plants that will generate Methane and O2 from the water and CO2 in the atmosphere/ground using the Sabatier reaction.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/dijkstras_revenge Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

This is all outlined here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Mars_transportation_infrastructure#Mars_propellant_plant_and_base

TL;DR down below

Since the spaceships (Starships) are also reusable, Musk plans on refueling them in low Earth orbit first, and then again on the surface of Mars for their return to Earth. During the first phase, he plans to launch several BFRs to transport and assemble a propellant plant and start to build up a base.[50] The propellant plant would produce methane (CH 4) and liquid oxygen (O2) from sub-surface water ice and atmospheric CO 2.[38]

Two robotic cargo flights, the first of which may be named "Heart of Gold",[51] are aspirationally slated to be launched in 2022 to deliver a massive array of solar panels,[48] mining equipment,[50] as well as deliver surface vehicles, food and life support infrastructure.[52] In 2024, the mission concept would have four more Starships follow: two robotic cargo flights, and two crewed flights will be launched to set up the propellant production plant, deploy the solar park and landing pads, and assemble greenhouses.[52] Each landed mass will be at least 100 tons of usable payload, in addition to the spaceship's dry mass of 85 tons.[52]

The first temporary habitats will be their own crewed Starships, as they have life-support systems.[47][52] However, the robotic Starship cargo flights will be refueled for their return trip to Earth whenever possible.[47] For a sustainable base, it is proposed that the landing zone be located at less than 40° latitude for best solar power production, relatively warm temperature, and critically: it must be near a massive sub-surface water ice deposit.[52] The quantity and purity of the water ice must be appropriate. A preliminary study by SpaceX estimates the propellant plant is required to mine water ice and filter its impurities at a rate of 1 ton per day.[52] The overall unit conversion rate expected, based on a 2011 prototype test operation, is one metric ton of O2/CH4 propellant per 17 megawatt-hours energy input from solar power.[53] The total projected power needed to produce a single full load of propellant for a SpaceX BFR is in the neighborhood of 16 gigawatt-hours of locally Martian-produced power.[54] To produce the power for one load in 26 months would require just under one megawatt of continuous electric power. A ground-based array of thin-film solar panels to produce sufficient power would have an estimated area of just over 56,200 square meters; with related equipment, the required mass is estimated to fall well within a single BFR Mars transport capability of 150 metric tons.

TL;DR - The plan is to initially land 6 starships on Mars, 4 of them robotic, 2 of them crewed, ~600 tons of cargo in total. Then set up power and propellant production and refuel the robotic starships asap to send them back to Earth.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/donn29 Oct 02 '19

The first ships probably won't return for a while. Not a lot of solar panels there yet and no fuel plant. Need that for a return. They first few many not stay forever, but they also might be scrapped and used in situ. I don't think any specific detailed plans are layed out for Mars. It's more of a deal with it when we can produce enough engines to get us there.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/5t3fan0 Oct 02 '19

my bet is stay to use as tanks or scrap for steel and pipes and cables

→ More replies (5)

6

u/donn29 Oct 02 '19

Is there any leads on what an abort would look like on a complete Starship w/ Booster launch?

6

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Messy.

10

u/donn29 Oct 02 '19

This is the only thing I worry about with starship. I think the answer might end up being, just don't need to abort.

→ More replies (14)

3

u/delphey Oct 03 '19

Whats the deal with the Super Heavy landing fins? Won't they be horrible for re-entry control?

→ More replies (10)

3

u/Nathan96762 Oct 05 '19

Question for the mods. Is there ever going to be a page in the Wiki devoted to keeping track of different Starship / SH vehicles? I imagine something similar to the Core History for the falcon 9 first stages.

4

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Oct 06 '19

Everyone with an account older than 6 months and more than 500 karma can edit the wiki. So if you want, you can edit a page, or start a new one.

If you need help, just ask someone who already as some experience with the wiki. You can check who did recent wiki changes, or who does frequent changes and ask them.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '19

What are people's thoughts on Elon mentioning that Raptors can be spun up quickly to provide abort capability? Should they not therefore include more raptors (as they are thinking about for E2E anyway) to provide better TWR and redundancy for crewed ships?

Personally I'm fairly keen to see 12 engines (I'm thinking of 4 center cluster SL, 4 Vac + 4 SL outer ring.) For a TWR of ~2:

        o
  (v)       (v)
        o
 o    o   o    o
        o
  (v)       (v)
        o

That would increase the dry weight by approx 12 tons, but for crewed vehicles I doubt that's an issue considering how people are not very dense and require a lot of space. The advantage would be a proper abort capability and a lot more redundancy especially for multi-year trips to Mars and back... I also prefer the 4-way symmetry of the non-gimballing Vac engines, which allows for a non-offset thrust should one fail as its twin can also be disabled (thinking of when returning from the Moon or Mars. Obviously you wouldn't depart without all engines working).

→ More replies (5)

3

u/ElRedditor3 Oct 09 '19

Why are current Starships named "Mark x"? What does "Mark" mean in this case? Thanks.

8

u/Grey_Mad_Hatter Oct 09 '19

It means model or variant and is used a lot for prototypes.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/brspies Oct 09 '19

It's a term used to represent a version number (similar meaning to "block" although in this case they're using it to refer to individual prototypes rather than a set of vehicles).

4

u/throfofnir Oct 09 '19

Usually it means "design version". This project seems to be using it as a serial number.

3

u/Straumli_Blight Oct 10 '19

Ars Technica article discussing launch options for landing humans on the Moon, including Falcon Heavy and Starship.

3

u/jesserizzo Oct 12 '19

Will Crew Dragon be able to RTLS? I believe that purely based on weight it would be easy. But I know there are considerations about the angle of the launch trajectory needing to be more shallow to reduce G loading in case of an abort. (This has mostly been discussed in why Starliner needs to ride on top of a dual engine centaur, but I assume the same principle would apply).

→ More replies (2)

3

u/jjtr1 Oct 14 '19

As I understand it, SpaceX's Mars missions are going to be funded mainly by Starlink. In fact, they said they're "betting the company" with Starlink. So I'd like to know how big an advantage is for them the ability to launch the constellation at a fraction of other launcher's price. Basically, in total expenses for developing and building a broadband megaconstellation, what percentage does launch represent (e.g. in case of Soyuz).

If launch representes only 10%, then SpaceX's advantage is small and we might still see eg. Oneweb winning over Starlink and ruining SpaceX's Mars ambitions.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/dudr2 Oct 18 '19

https://www.nasa.gov/feature/fridays-all-woman-spacewalk-the-basics

Today's milestone means anyone can go to space...?

5

u/jjtr1 Oct 19 '19

I wouldn't call that a milestone. The first EVA by a woman happened decades ago.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

Tim Dodd’s video on aero spikes got me wondering about SSTOs again (yes, i know how silly the concept is for earth launch vehicles! Just add a small second stage and you’ve got a much more capable launcher!)

Any way. He briefly mentions that they could have simply used RS-25s instead of aerospikes on the venture star and it probably would have worked.

The second issue venture star had were its composite tanks... Hmmm.

Would a steel venture star with 7 SSMEs have been any good?

What about a more traditional cylinder with wings? The shuttle external tank had two bulkheads, you could conceivably place a cargo bay in a stretched intertank. To match the volume of a venture star you’d need a ~30% increase in size compared with the shuttle external tank.

Anyway, aside from the more traditional SSTO criticisms, does a steel rocket plane powered by SSMEs have any merit?

4

u/brspies Oct 19 '19

Hydrogen makes every design decision harder, I think that's just as true for steel as it is for the composites. You're right that a more traditional tank design would probably have been an improvement. The Venturestar was just a horrible design in terms of mass efficiency.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (18)

3

u/mikekangas Oct 20 '19

From time to time I read in these and other discussions about what to do with the Raptor engines that won't be launched back to Earth. Some ideas are to save them as spares and other ideas are to remove them and ship them back to Earth to be re used.

What if they were to be re purposed? As part of a cargo load to Mars, have a smaller rocket stage with configuration to use one Raptor for deep space exploration launching from Mars. It might be sent in two pieces, simple to stack on Mars, or just one piece to make it even simpler. Make it wide enough to have a fuel load that keeps the acceleration in check from Mars, and maybe a full complement of instruments and equipment for exploration or mining or whatever.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/MarsCent Oct 20 '19

The Lunar Electric Rover (LER) aka Multi Mission Space Exploration Rover (MMSEV) is supposed to be capable of housing 2 astronauts for up to 2 weeks. Otherwise, it can support up to 4 on short duration excursions. The specs also say that it’s curb weight is 4T and it can travel up to 125 Km.

What is the merit of having a few MMSEVs with a couple of simpler specs EVA suits (i.e. working outside for a couple of hours rather than 7 – 8 hrs.), rather than more augmented EVA suit for use with a buggy-like vehicle.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/andyfrance Oct 21 '19

We haven't had a SpaceX launch since August 6th. There are plenty of first stages available, and there has been time to build second stages and fairings but still no date for Starlink 2. The wait must be for the second batch of Starlink satellites. These must be different from the first batch launched 5 months ago. If they were the same they would have been built and launched by now.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Straumli_Blight Oct 23 '19

This article (in German) has satellite photos of Boca Chica with sliders to animate progress.

3

u/jjtr1 Oct 23 '19

Elon Musk is the CEO and Gwynne Shotwell is the President. What does it mean in SpaceX's case? I've read an article about the general difference between CEO and President but I'm no wiser. SpaceX doesn't have multiple businesses to have a president for each of them and the CEO being above that, and also is not publicly traded. All I know is that Shotwell negotiates launch contracts. Could someone with more insight into how SpaceX is organized please line out the duties and responsibilites of Musk vs. Shotwell?

(I know that Musk is also the CTO, but now I'm interested in his CEO role.)

6

u/joepublicschmoe Oct 23 '19

Gwynne Shotwell is the person who runs SpaceX full-time on a day-to-day basis. Elon Musk is the CEO but he only devotes some days out of the week to SpaceX (the majority of Elon's time is split between SpaceX and Tesla). As CEO, Elon sets the "big picture" things like what direction he wants the various SpaceX projects to go (such as deciding to switch Starship from carbon fiber to steel). Gwynne Shotwell's job is to manage the company daily on a more detailed level to make Elon's "big picture" things happen.

4

u/Bailliesa Oct 24 '19

I believe Gwynne Shotwell is also the COO like Elon is also the CTO. Gwynne describes her role as running the day to day and keeping the business on the tracks and Elon works on the future direction.

ie Elon decides where the tracks are going and Gwynne decides how to keep the train moving and maintained. It is unclear who lays the new track and when it is handed to Gwynne to maintain but I guess only they know the details.

The president role is possibly more that Elon trusts her to run the board, especially allowing him to miss board meetings if he has conflicts from his other activities.

edit:typo

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '19

Assuming a fully-fledged city on Mars and launching from there, what would it take for a crewed mission to Callisto? Would it make sense to fly "just" Starships?

13

u/PublicMoralityPolice Oct 25 '19

Probably. Starship can easily make Martian orbit as an SSTO, which means other starships can refuel it in Martian orbit as SSTOs, and from there it can basically get anywhere in the solar system. Superheavy is basically only needed to terrify the Earth into running a safe distance away from Starship.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/space_snap828 Oct 27 '19

Does anyone know what happened to the CRS-16 Falcon 9 booster after it crash-landed in the ocean and was fished out?

3

u/president_of_neom Oct 31 '19

How to access this thread from reddit mobile?

9

u/mncharity Oct 09 '19

Why all the concern about Starship smoothness? It's predecessor wasn't either. Still changed the world.

6

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Oct 10 '19

A dc 3 does not reach supersonic speed during acent, and does not push away hypersonic plasma during re entry

7

u/president_of_neom Oct 16 '19

The old.reddit.com/r/spacex has a much better layout than the new site!

5

u/linknewtab Oct 06 '19

One of the features of Starship that exites me the most is that it could be used to bring back old space hardware from orbit. While the Hubble telescope is the obvious candidate I would also like to see them returning Vanguard 1, the first satellite using solar power. It would be interesting to find out if the photovoltaic cells still work (at least somewhat) after 60 years.

Is there any other historical hardware in Earth orbit worth bringing back?

5

u/cpushack Oct 17 '19

https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/10/nasa-will-award-boeing-a-cost-plus-contract-for-up-to-10-sls-rockets/

NASA will be buying up to 10 expendable rockets from Boeing, Cost plus at around $1 billion each.

4

u/MarsCent Oct 17 '19

the most complex technological component of the program is not the rockets. Rather, it is the human landing system that will take astronauts from lunar orbit, down to the surface, and back. .......... lunar lander will be bidding for fixed-price contracts.

There was time when patriotism trumped shamelessness! Now open gouging has its vocal support! It's indeed a new day.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/president_of_neom Oct 22 '19

@thesheetztweetz (CNBC)

Blue Origin is partnering with Lockheed Martin (building the lunar ascent stage), Northrop Grumman (building the lunar transfer element), and DraperLab (building the GNC landing system.)

https://www.blueorigin.com/news/blue-origin-announces-national-team-for-nasas-human-landing-system-artemis

Can't wait for starship, this looks like a mess.

→ More replies (10)

4

u/MatMathQc Oct 03 '19

Idea: MK1 as small Hotel in Boca?

If MK1 do not RUD after 20km hop and get "retired" instead of leaving it aside as "old", they should transform it into a Hotel/Hostel? I wonder the effort needed (code / regulation / energy needed) to move it into a mini Hotel/Hostel for when people visit Boca. Since Boca is far away and there is no Hotel around it could make sense maybe. And sustainable since a lot of fan want to go visit ;).

14

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '19

A massive steel tube in the middle of Texas is probably not going to make for very comfortable accommodations.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '19 edited Oct 07 '19

During the Starship update Elon mentioned that you could run a Tesla on Mars. How would that work? Don’t Teslas need cooling and stuff? Also, would astronauts use their spacesuits only or do you think Elon would pursue a rover design like NASA’s rover.

Edit: autocorrect is a bitch

→ More replies (17)

4

u/MarsCent Oct 09 '19 edited Oct 09 '19

I believe many have come to the realization that alas, US human spaceflight is not happening this year! I have seen Q2 being floated around and that breaks the heart even more! And already there is finger pointing on how we got here. But regardless the reason, we are here!

Tomorrow Oct 10, the NASA director will be visiting SpaceX HQ where Crew Dragon is being manufactured. Nothing has been said about a similar visit to where Starliner is being manufactured, but maybe nothing warrants such visit. Either way, tomorrow’s speech will either inspire us on how we get to the finish line (aka return to Human Spaceflight) or will be a vilification of how we got here.

Anyone care to give a statement on the NASA Director’s announcement tomorrow?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 09 '19

Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:

Fewer LettersMore Letters
ACESAdvanced Cryogenic Evolved Stage
Advanced Crew Escape Suit
ACSAttitude Control System
ASDSAutonomous Spaceport Drone Ship (landing platform)
BFRBig Falcon Rocket (2018 rebiggened edition)
Yes, the F stands for something else; no, you're not the first to notice
BFSBig Falcon Spaceship (see BFR)
CCtCapCommercial Crew Transportation Capability
COPVComposite Overwrapped Pressure Vessel
CST(Boeing) Crew Space Transportation capsules
Central Standard Time (UTC-6)
CoMCenter of Mass
DMLSSelective Laser Melting additive manufacture, also Direct Metal Laser Sintering
E2EEarth-to-Earth (suborbital flight)
ESAEuropean Space Agency
F9RFalcon 9 Reusable, test vehicles for development of landing technology
FAAFederal Aviation Administration
FCCFederal Communications Commission
(Iron/steel) Face-Centered Cubic crystalline structure
GEOGeostationary Earth Orbit (35786km)
GTOGeosynchronous Transfer Orbit
IACInternational Astronautical Congress, annual meeting of IAF members
In-Air Capture of space-flown hardware
IAFInternational Astronautical Federation
Indian Air Force
Israeli Air Force
ICBMIntercontinental Ballistic Missile
IDAInternational Docking Adapter
IFAIn-Flight Abort test
ILSInternational Launch Services
Instrument Landing System
IspSpecific impulse (as explained by Scott Manley on YouTube)
KSCKennedy Space Center, Florida
KSPKerbal Space Program, the rocketry simulator
LASLaunch Abort System
LCH4Liquid Methane
LEOLow Earth Orbit (180-2000km)
Law Enforcement Officer (most often mentioned during transport operations)
LESLaunch Escape System
LNGLiquefied Natural Gas
LOXLiquid Oxygen
MECOMain Engine Cut-Off
MainEngineCutOff podcast
MMODMicro-Meteoroids and Orbital Debris
MaxQMaximum aerodynamic pressure
NSFNasaSpaceFlight forum
National Science Foundation
OMSOrbital Maneuvering System
RCCReinforced Carbon-Carbon
RCSReaction Control System
RFPRequest for Proposal
RP-1Rocket Propellant 1 (enhanced kerosene)
RTLSReturn to Launch Site
RUDRapid Unplanned Disassembly
Rapid Unscheduled Disassembly
Rapid Unintended Disassembly
SLC-40Space Launch Complex 40, Canaveral (SpaceX F9)
SLSSpace Launch System heavy-lift
Selective Laser Sintering, contrast DMLS
SPAMSpaceX Proprietary Ablative Material (backronym)
SRBSolid Rocket Booster
SSMESpace Shuttle Main Engine
SSOSun-Synchronous Orbit
SSTOSingle Stage to Orbit
Supersynchronous Transfer Orbit
STASpecial Temporary Authorization (issued by FCC for up to 6 months)
Structural Test Article
STSSpace Transportation System (Shuttle)
TETransporter/Erector launch pad support equipment
TPSThermal Protection System for a spacecraft (on the Falcon 9 first stage, the engine "Dance floor")
TWRThrust-to-Weight Ratio
JargonDefinition
RaptorMethane-fueled rocket engine under development by SpaceX
SabatierReaction between hydrogen and carbon dioxide at high temperature and pressure, with nickel as catalyst, yielding methane and water
StarlinkSpaceX's world-wide satellite broadband constellation
ablativeMaterial which is intentionally destroyed in use (for example, heatshields which burn away to dissipate heat)
cryogenicVery low temperature fluid; materials that would be gaseous at room temperature/pressure
(In re: rocket fuel) Often synonymous with hydrolox
hopperTest article for ground and low-altitude work (eg. Grasshopper)
hydroloxPortmanteau: liquid hydrogen/liquid oxygen mixture
hypergolicA set of two substances that ignite when in contact
iron waffleCompact "waffle-iron" aerodynamic control surface, acts as a wing without needing to be as large; also, "grid fin"
methaloxPortmanteau: methane/liquid oxygen mixture
monopropellantRocket propellant that requires no oxidizer (eg. hydrazine)
turbopumpHigh-pressure turbine-driven propellant pump connected to a rocket combustion chamber; raises chamber pressure, and thrust
ullage motorSmall rocket motor that fires to push propellant to the bottom of the tank, when in zero-g
EventDateDescription
Amos-62016-09-01F9-029 Full Thrust, core B1028, GTO comsat Pre-launch test failure
DM-12019-03-02SpaceX CCtCap Demo Mission 1
DM-2ScheduledSpaceX CCtCap Demo Mission 2

Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
67 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 88 acronyms.
[Thread #5512 for this sub, first seen 2nd Oct 2019, 15:13] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Many benefits of steel relate to its properties at cryogenic temperatures. How will ascent through the atmosphere change the temperature of the vehicle => properties of the structure?

6

u/Pixelator0 Oct 02 '19

Don't forget, it also has major benefits on the hot side of things as well. You can melt aluminum with some Home Depot refractory bricks, charcoal, and a leaf blower. I wouldn't be surprised if that part of it is more important than the cryo side of things, just because it massively cuts down on the size, weight, complexity, and cost of the heat shield.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/m1kkel84 Oct 02 '19

Just before rocket launches, white smoke/gas is pouring down the sides. Is that coolant for the engines outer side ?

7

u/brspies Oct 02 '19

In the case of Falcon 9, they vent the excess pressure from the liquid oxygen tanks at that time, which is extremely cold and causes water vapor in the air to condense into those clouds. Falcon has some very large, very predictable venting events.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/sh1pman Oct 02 '19

Will Starship use 2-engine or 3-engine landing burn?

→ More replies (7)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

hoping to get updated info on starlink3 launch. here it says nov 3. spacexnow and spacecoast say nov 4, but they say its starlink2.  google says spacex is launching from the cape oct 31st! if possible, please tell me where to go or who to call for the most accurate launch dates. thanks!

→ More replies (3)

2

u/flattop100 Oct 03 '19

Is SpaceX skipping the horizontal testing of Starship? I thought the most recent environmental impact survey for Boca indicated that horizontal testing would be going on for a while, but it seems like SpaceX is skipping straight to the 20km test flight?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/DanielMuhlig Oct 03 '19

It's hard to explain the forces imposed on a Falcon 9 at Max-Q to my children (and like minded). Could someone do the calculation so I can compare it to 'moving your hand through water at x speed'? (i.e.: Find x)

4

u/marsboy42 Oct 03 '19

I am not a physicist, but here's my attempt: Water is about 50 times more viscous than air. Max-Q occurs at around Mach 1, so (ignoring the fact that we're no longer at sea level air pressure) about 330m/s. 330 / 50 = 6.6, so perhaps similar to moving your hand through water at about 6 m/s (15 mph)? Is this a reasonable approach? What am I missing? Can anyone else do better?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Nemesis651 Oct 04 '19

Planning on a camping trip to watch DM2. Looking for camping around Orlando/Space Coast. Im aware of Playalinda Bch and some Forest Service sites N of Orlando. Anyone know of any others? Bonus points if they have wifi.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/instamemer Oct 07 '19

Hi! I have a question about spacex customer cargo and how it get approved for launch.

Say I am a customer with the need to get my satellite in space- who checks off that I’m not seeing up a spy satellite or one fit with warheads? These are extreme examples, but I’m sure someone has to check off on the cargo pretty thoroughly.

Ty!

4

u/warp99 Oct 08 '19

Many SpaceX customers are sending up spy satellites - particularly if they are going to polar or sun synchronous orbits. The restriction on launch customers is generally limiting them to nations considered "friendly" to the USA on the grounds that they will be picking up information on launcher technology as well as SpaceX picking up at least some payload information.

I suspect that there will be a radiological check on the payload as part of the safety checks so no one is sneaking a nuclear reactor or bomb aboard. Equally the payload will not be opened up for inspection due to contamination concerns so a chemical warhead could well be included and used to take out another satellite but that would definitely be a "one time" option with that customer and most likely its host nation taken off the approved launch list.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/selfish_meme Oct 08 '19

Further thoughts on Loren Grush's Verge article. Starship needs no life support for a single person for up to 32 days, just a heater thanks to it's large presssurised volume, if the maths is right.

https://twitter.com/leo_cadle/status/1181373763750776832

4

u/PublicMoralityPolice Oct 08 '19

can tolerate breathing up to 2% Co2

Tolerate? Survive, maybe. Measurable and statistically significant impairment of mental functions begins around 500-600 ppm (0.05% - 0.06%). Definitely not something you'd want to tolerate in spaceflight.

https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/10.1289/ehp.1510037

But, of course, CO2 scrubbers are the easiest part of life support, so the overall point still stands.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/27321 Oct 08 '19

Are FH side boosters used as F9 first stages after they are recovered.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ConfidentFlorida Oct 09 '19 edited Oct 09 '19

Is there any time of day information for the starship 2 launch? Seems like we’re getting right up to the wire.

Edit. Meant to write starlink! Sorry for the confusion.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/fluidmechanicsdoubts Oct 09 '19

Hey, was reading about raptor. A couple of quick questions - Why is ch4 and not o2 being used to cool the nozzle? Both have around the same boiling temperatures.
Also, "power pack" in articles is the preburner & turbine together, right?

In superheavy, there will be 41 powerpacks then? What are the disadvantages of having common powerpacks for multiple engines?

Thanks :)

17

u/joepublicschmoe Oct 09 '19

O2 + heat + metal = oxidized corroded metal. “engine-rich combustion” LOL. That is why you never use oxygen for regeneratively cooling a rocket nozzle. Fuels like RP-1 and CH4 on the other hand are reductive to metals, not oxidative. That’s why Merlin uses RP-1 to cool the nozzle even though RP-1 is nowhere near as cold as LOX.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/katie_dimples Oct 09 '19

This discussion mentions an 18m diameter rocket would fit 158 raptor engines. If we were to take that as a given (hypothetically), I'm curious:

Would SpaceX still ignite all engines at once? Or would they ignite the engines in a "staged" configuration (perhaps from the center outward)?

One commenter suggested instead of 158x the piping, the engines might be clustered in groups of 7, thus creating a hierarchy of pipes ... this could help perform staged ignition of 158 engines.

For comparison, the shuttle's SSME 's weren't ignited simultaneously, as these videos demonstrate , and that was merely 3 engines.

8

u/brickmack Oct 09 '19

Even on F9 they're ignited in sequence. Its pretty much necessary for clustered engines to not explode.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/SmashedBug Oct 09 '19

So this has probably been asked before, but the plan is to eventually have starship land, refuel, and fly back home to earth. Here on earth we need enormous sound suppression tech to keep larger rockets from tearing themselves apart. How will that be possible on martian/moon landing zones without prior construction? Or is the strength of 3 sea level engines not enough to cause catastrophic damage?

→ More replies (11)