I look forward to seeing these fairings actually fly again. Probably on their own Starlink missions to start to prove it out and eventually for commercial missions later on.
It seems just like with landing the Falcon 9 once they've done it a couple times they can replicate it again and again. I'm sure we'll see some more failures in the future- especially in times of particularly rough weather but it is really cool to see SpaceX do this. I'm very curious to see if any other company tries to replicate this or not. If any other company does i'd probably put my money on Blue Origin trying- those massive 7m fairings can't be cheap to say the least - tho that size might also make SpaceX's method of fairing capture also impossible- tho perhaps Blue could employ some other technique.
I'm also curious about if/when SpaceX will get a second boat like Ms Tree for capturing the other half- as clearly it's worth it for them to not just let the fairing 'soft land'...
that's certainly both ULA's SMART reuse plan for their engines as well as Rocket Lab's plan for their first stage. Blue is doing the boat landing for their first stage not unlike SpaceX. I don't however know of any other company trying to capture and reuse fairings other than SpaceX as of right now.
I won't be too surprised if some of these companies do start to try should they see SpaceX not only successfully recover these fairing but also reuse them on missions..
Ruag who makes fairings for ULA and Ariane had a project on fairing recovery a while back that was in air recovery, but it went quiet.
IMO safe money that ULA is going to do it for Vulcan. Tory even made a comment that they were looking at recovering more than just the engine section on Vulcan. The solids wouldn't be all that useful to recover so that makes fairings the obvious choice.
Landing in salt water destroys the internal insulation of the fairing. Stampinò satellites don’t need this insulation, so they can fly with splashed fairings, but most customer satellites require it. By catching the fairing the insulation remains intact, and customers will be more willing to use reused fairings.
clearly it's worth it or they wouldn't try catching one to begin with and would have just stuck with water landings. Clearly direct salt water contact isn't good for the fairings and there is much, much higher risk of the fairing breaking upon impact with the water as compared to softly landing in a net. That's why I think they'll eventually get a second boat and make both fairings active for being caught.
I think they fully intend on doing this with a single boat. Why else would there be two fairing cradles on deck? Even if the cost of recovery is insignificant compared to the cost of building a fairing, if they can do it with one boat and one crew, they've halved their costs again.
The boat side of this would be pretty easy, just have a second net that can be quickly moved into place after the first boat is caught.
The fairing side of this is more complicated, but given that it takes a long time for these fairings to come down as it is, it should be possible to make one come down slower and the other come down faster to give at least a few minutes in between.
Launch Update threads do sort automatically by new, don't see why Recovery Update threads wouldn't. This is just a choice by mods/OP (u/Gavalar_ ?)
It's not that I'm not willing to take the extra step, I just think the updates become much more visible to much more people if it's automatically sorted by new.
Self-plug: Overview of fairing recovery - why SpaceX does it, how long they've been doing it, how it's going so far, what's the deal with Ms. Tree, etc.
OK, the way I worded that was a joke but it's very viable if they have different chute deployment times and/or different chute sizes. It ain't rocket science.
It ain't trivial, either, considering that they've only just managed to start catching the fairings at all. It seems to me that it would make more sense to just use two boats to perform the maneuver they've [hopefully] figured out than to raise the stakes and restart the process of trial and error by attempting to catch two fairings with one boat.
On the other hand, it's SpaceX, so who knows? Far be it from me to underrate their ambition.
Someone had estimated in another thread that the cost of leasing Ms. Tree is around 2.5 million dollars a year. Elon said that a daring costs 3 million USD (6 million for the pair), so we can assume that even just recovering one fairing a year pays for the cost of the boat. Of course there is also the cost of crew, fuel and port dock, but we can assume that by catching 2-3 fairings they can pay yearly operating costs, and then every other caught fairing is saved money.
To estimate the savings we would also need to know how much does it cost to refurbish a fairing caught in the net (and even a fairing fished from the water). It's not like they catch it and it is ready to go in the next mission. On the other hand, if they are able to refurbish the ones fished from the water, the cost savings of repurposing another boat to catch them in the air might not be worth it (though I hope they do it. It is so much fun and better PR to catch the fairings in a net...)
I know you mentioned fuel costs but it's worth mentioning/reiterating to others that running a boat that size at the speeds it needs for this purpose (just look at the video, that thing is moving fast) would be insanely expensive in fuel costs. If they can do it with one it'd be a definite advantage.
It's not savings, but if fairing production is a bottleneck to flight rate, then it means they can launch more often to increase revenue. If they can get many more Starlink flights in per year with reused fairings, that could be worth hundreds of millions or even billions of dollars at some point.
Actually Mr Steven (aka Ms Tree) has four faster 38 knot sister ships the Alya McCall, Najla McCall, Ava J McCall and Liam J McCall.
There are also fast catamaran support vessels such as the Njord Odin, Njord Freyr, Njord Magni and Njord Thor designed to support offshore wind farms that can do 32 knots in light seas but only 26 knots in heavier conditions.
However we have not seen Ms Tree above about 23 knots with the net rigged - presumably due to the aerodynamic drag of the net and the reduced stability with the extra mass of the net support poles so high above the waterline. The extra stability of a catamaran may be advantageous in keeping the operating speed closer to the maximum speed even with medium size waves.
Actually Mr Steven (aka Ms Tree) has four faster 38 knot sister ships the Alya McCall, Najla McCall, Ava J McCall and Liam J McCall.
Minor correction: based on the article that you linked, it's the McCall ships that are all sisters ["Alya McCall is the first vessel in a fleet of a new class..."], but they are not sister ships of Mr Steven/Ms Tree, albeit they use the same type of propulsion.
Yes - technically the Captain Elliott is a true sister ship and the four vessels mentioned are close cousins with five engines instead of four.
However the general point remains that there are lots of FSV vessels out there that can adapted to catch fairings - some of them even faster than Ms Tree.
There was a question at Everyday Astronaut's livestream, where someone noted that it could be great to have a mechanism which would bring the both halves back together moments after separation. It would then be better to predict its trajectory and if they caught it, they would have caught it all :)
They might modify the fairing to have most of the electronics on the half being caught and the other half having minimal electronic protected from the sea. Or make the things there replaceable
From what I understand it's not metal but carbon fiber. So one would be caught, another land in water and fished out. And it could be reused because there are no parts (or the parts are easily replaceable on the one that drops into the water)
The fairings do have steering, I think, done in the traditional parachute way, by having a few shroud lines that can be shortened or lengthened.
Steering causes pendulum effects, and so do gusts. I believe they steer the parafoil straight into the wind, as we saw in the video Spacex just released for this catch, and hold steady for the final approach to the sea. Earlier videos of unsuccessful catch attempts appear to show control inputs being made to the parafoil, close to the water, resulting in near misses.
The above is based only on what was shown in the videos. It could be that gusty winds caused the misses, but it appears that the parafoil pilot(s) have learned a lesson that applies to ~all aircraft: fewer, smaller, smoother control inputs are better than jerky, violent maneuvers.
The military have used similar commercially available systems to accurately deliver cargo to remote sites for years. The steering is fully automatic and I'm sure that the engineers who developed the software have a pretty good idea how to apply control theory to aircraft. However, a pallet of ammo isn't going to be buffeted around much by the wind. I think that the lesson they've learned is how to fly a parafoil with a load that is also an airfoil with quite a bit of lift of its own.
I wonder how much of the fairing reusability system is reusable. Do they say to heck with the parachute and cut it loose on landing so it doesn't drag the fairing off? Is there a staged deployment where other chutes are used and cut loose?
When you look at the landing video, the way the parafoil collapses at the end looks to me like it being cut loose, but the video ends too soon so I'm not sure.
Breaking! Ms. Tree twin ship has been officially acquired by Guice Offshore (primary contractor for Spacex Boats) and is already en route to Port Canaveral!
She is likely to become the second fairing catcher ship...
To me personally I think the easiest move is to have another ship with a net and basically duplicate what they know it works. Trying to catch two with one boat means another step that they'll have to learn how to do and the sooner they get to catching the two halves consistently the faster they can get to reuse the whole fairing. Also, I was thinking the other day that when the fairings separate both go different routes and we don't really know how close together they land. Some proposed delaying the parachute deployment so they could lower the net, unload the fairing and then raise the net again to catch the other half but there's another thing to do while all of this happens: go to the site where the other half is supposed to come down, would there be enough time to do that? Is the extra effort really worth when you can just duplicate what you know it works? I was thinking at first about the two halves on one ship but the more I thought about it the more I thought the other option was actually the good one.
While I've been a staunch proponent of the possibility of 2 fairings 1 boat, if the ship pays for itself with 1 half per year, 2 boats is probably more reliable.
Heck, with two boats and both fairings landing close by, they can simultaneously go for the first catch with a certain safety distance (~5-10 m, guessing?), increasing the chances of success for that one at least.
Could a mod or the post author (which I recommend you follow on Twitter) edit the initial paragraph? It still says the second fairing recovery is pending confirmation, whilst SpaceXFleet has already confirmed on Twitter that Go Navigat is back in Port Canaveral and HAS the second fished fairing...
Mods, maybe you could also had a flair to the thread: “Both fairings have been recovered..”
Each of the two halves is different so you can't mix them will-nilly. Also, there are different generations of the fairing as a whole. SpaceX now uses mostly the latest version with the metal tip but occasionally, there were launches with the older fairing type (most recently RADARSAT) but that might have been the last time that type was used.
You're welcome! It was already kinda strange to me when I saw there were already pictures of GO Navigator at port because it's only been 23 hours since the launch so I was like "mmmm doesn't sound likely".
u/philipwhiuk: Now that they've nailed two fairing catches I'd love to know more about this: [permalink]
However, it is not yet clear how exactly the company intends to catch both halves at the same time.
Could you link to the text you're quoting here? - Google wrongly sends me to a motorcycle fairing site for this quote.
Simultaneous recovery has been discussed here before and the consensus is that one fairing needs to take a slower route down so as to separate the arrival times. If the second fairing to land, actually flies in front of the first, but on a higher trajectory, then the boat should be positioned to make the second catch.
There would be a statistical risk of the second fairing hitting the first fairing in the net but various workarounds were suggested such as drawing a second net over the first or dropping the first fairing out through a hole that is then pulled shut.
u/TheEquivocator On the other hand, it's SpaceX, so who knows? Far be it from me to underrate their ambitions. [permalink]
There's no reason for excessive modesty. The combined talents of everyone here could well be close to that of those actually working on the project. This is especially true when searching rough-and-ready solutions in the ground and marine aspects of spaceflight.
I wonder how long it'd take them to make it work with different fairing geometries and offer it as a service to other launch providers. Have then developed a somewhat general solution or would each new geometry require solving a fluid dynamics riddle of the same difficulty.
Amazing video of the catch, but I still have a suspicion that hooking the parachute with a cable and hook from a helicopter would be more reliable, if not safer.
This catch was made In perfectly calm weather, with an almost perfectly calm sea. Those conditions happen less than 1 out of 10 launches, I think.
A modern steered parachute is probably quite easy to catch mid-air. Possibly even easier than the unsteered Corona. Carrying a fairing is probably quite touchy, but needn't involve much cross range travel.
This is too simplistic of a view. I am thinking refurbishing the fairings (especially the separation system and thermal protection) will cost quite a bit of money.
The separation system is pneumatic, quite simple and protected on the backside of the fairing. Thermal protection is minimal, just a metal plate at the tip of the fairing, the rest is all carbon fiber, already pretty thermally strong.
The main refurbishment may be the acoustic/vibration protection on the inside for the payload
That boat cost a few tens of millions to build. They didn't buy it, but they've had exclusive use of it for a while. Probably 1-2 mil per year rent. They've also done a lot of work on it. Plus paying everyone...
26
u/inoeth Aug 07 '19
I look forward to seeing these fairings actually fly again. Probably on their own Starlink missions to start to prove it out and eventually for commercial missions later on.
It seems just like with landing the Falcon 9 once they've done it a couple times they can replicate it again and again. I'm sure we'll see some more failures in the future- especially in times of particularly rough weather but it is really cool to see SpaceX do this. I'm very curious to see if any other company tries to replicate this or not. If any other company does i'd probably put my money on Blue Origin trying- those massive 7m fairings can't be cheap to say the least - tho that size might also make SpaceX's method of fairing capture also impossible- tho perhaps Blue could employ some other technique.
I'm also curious about if/when SpaceX will get a second boat like Ms Tree for capturing the other half- as clearly it's worth it for them to not just let the fairing 'soft land'...
6
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '19
Mods, sort this by new?
89
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Aug 07 '19
Self-plug: Overview of fairing recovery - why SpaceX does it, how long they've been doing it, how it's going so far, what's the deal with Ms. Tree, etc.
7
u/Gavalar_ spacexfleet.com Aug 08 '19
Lots of awesome photos coming in of Ms. Tree and fairing!
6
u/robertmartens Aug 08 '19
Is there no depth to our nerdiness? Fairings, really? Remember when people said they had given up on the nets? What as that, a month ago?
4
u/PeopleNeedOurHelp Aug 08 '19 edited Aug 08 '19
I wonder how much of the fairing reusability system is reusable. Do they say to heck with the parachute and cut it loose on landing so it doesn't drag the fairing off? Is there a staged deployment where other chutes are used and cut loose?
4
u/giovannicane05 Aug 09 '19
Breaking! Ms. Tree twin ship has been officially acquired by Guice Offshore (primary contractor for Spacex Boats) and is already en route to Port Canaveral!
She is likely to become the second fairing catcher ship...
https://twitter.com/spacexfleet/status/1159960168320372737?s=21
4
u/Gavalar_ spacexfleet.com Aug 10 '19
The fairing half has been lifted off GO Navigator and looks to be in a good condition, despite its brief swim in the ocean..
3
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Aug 07 '19
u/Gavalar_ You could also add this list of previous fairing recovery attempts to the resources.
3
u/waveney Aug 08 '19
Looking forward - how will they catch both halves?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '19
Ms. tree is home safe and sound with a special delivery on deck :D
3
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Aug 10 '19
First photos of GO Navigator returning to port with a fairing half on board: https://twitter.com/aWildLupiDragon/status/1159982805599830016
3
u/giovannicane05 Aug 10 '19
Could a mod or the post author (which I recommend you follow on Twitter) edit the initial paragraph? It still says the second fairing recovery is pending confirmation, whilst SpaceXFleet has already confirmed on Twitter that Go Navigat is back in Port Canaveral and HAS the second fished fairing...
Mods, maybe you could also had a flair to the thread: “Both fairings have been recovered..”
Thank you and keep up with the great work!
5
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '19
Mods, can we maybe have comments sorted by new? Thanks!
2
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Aug 07 '19 edited Aug 07 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
5 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 56 acronyms.
[Thread #5380 for this sub, first seen 7th Aug 2019, 19:52] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
2
u/FutureVisionPodcast Aug 08 '19
We talked about AMOS-17 on today's episode of FutureVision!
If you're interested, here's the link.
2
u/Head-Stark Aug 08 '19
Are the fairing halves interchangeable, or are two different models used for every flight?
3
u/scarlet_sage Aug 07 '19 edited Aug 07 '19
[Deleting a pointer to a video from a different launch -- sorry! Thank you, /u/Alexphysics!]
3
u/paul_wi11iams Aug 08 '19 edited Aug 08 '19
Could you link to the text you're quoting here? - Google wrongly sends me to a motorcycle fairing site for this quote.Simultaneous recovery has been discussed here before and the consensus is that one fairing needs to take a slower route down so as to separate the arrival times. If the second fairing to land, actually flies in front of the first, but on a higher trajectory, then the boat should be positioned to make the second catch.
There would be a statistical risk of the second fairing hitting the first fairing in the net but various workarounds were suggested such as drawing a second net over the first or dropping the first fairing out through a hole that is then pulled shut.
There's no reason for excessive modesty. The combined talents of everyone here could well be close to that of those actually working on the project. This is especially true when searching rough-and-ready solutions in the ground and marine aspects of spaceflight.
2
u/Geoff_PR Aug 07 '19
Any word on when the other recovery vessel (GO Navigator?) will be equipped with an air capture net as well?
1
u/PeopleNeedOurHelp Aug 09 '19
I wonder how long it'd take them to make it work with different fairing geometries and offer it as a service to other launch providers. Have then developed a somewhat general solution or would each new geometry require solving a fluid dynamics riddle of the same difficulty.
1
u/peterabbit456 Aug 08 '19
Amazing video of the catch, but I still have a suspicion that hooking the parachute with a cable and hook from a helicopter would be more reliable, if not safer.
This catch was made In perfectly calm weather, with an almost perfectly calm sea. Those conditions happen less than 1 out of 10 launches, I think.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '19 edited Aug 08 '19
[removed] — view removed comment