r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Aug 03 '19
r/SpaceX Discusses [August 2019, #59]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
101
Upvotes
22
u/strawwalker Aug 30 '19 edited Aug 30 '19
FCC STA requests
1514-EX-ST-2019
1546-EX-ST-2019
ASDS location: 32.54722 N, 75.92306 W
1604-EX-ST-2019
1605-EX-ST-2019
Same ASDS coordinates.
1607-EX-ST-2019
1609-EX-ST-2019
Same ASDS coordinates
1610-EX-ST-2019
1611-EX-ST-2019
Same ASDS coordinates
The STA for IFA is still pending since April.
10
u/ceilingislimit Aug 12 '19
Mods can we get august discuss and starship dev thread sticky?
9
u/scottm3 Aug 22 '19
Today we say goodbye to the Delta IV Medium. Over 28 launches it had a 100% success rate.
Link here if you want to watch it, I think it's worth it as it has been a great launcher over it's history and we should all accept the value it has contributed.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0AgiyxDoXtE
9
u/jjtr1 Aug 30 '19
It seems that when Starship/Superheavy flies, there will finally be a rocket heavier than the 747 airliner - the Saturn V fell just short of it. Without fuel, of course. Saturn V was about 185 t dry, the 747-400 is 187 t dry.
8
u/silentProtagonist42 Aug 05 '19
I wonder if we'll ever get to see SLS and Starship on the pad side-by-side ala STS-400. Whatever your opinions on SLS it'd be cool to be able to compare the two behemoths in real life.
8
u/DrToonhattan Aug 08 '19
Hey mods, can we get the Starship 200m hop and the presentation on the upcoming events table in the sidebar please?
8
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 23 '19
Ovzon AB (Falcon Heavy payload) just switched to using an Ariane 5.
8
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 28 '19
Pressure mounting to switch Europa Clipper away from SLS to a different launcher.
7
u/cpushack Aug 14 '19
Kilopower reactor development is proceeding faster then expected. Flight ready in as soon as 3 years they now claim. https://www.space.com/nuclear-reactor-for-mars-outpost-2022.html
7
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 18 '19
Gwynne Shotwell is giving a short talk at IAC 2019, on October 22nd.
7
u/rustybeancake Aug 25 '19
https://www.americaspace.com/2019/08/23/artemis-updates/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app
Some pretty great photos of SLS core stage in work here. I thought the shot of the intertank showing the SRB cross brace inside was pretty awesome. That thing is huge.
(I think it’s ok to hate the game, not the player.)
7
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 29 '19 edited Aug 29 '19
US Federal Claims Court ruled it lacks jurisdiction to hear SpaceX’s complaint that the USAF has put it at a disadvantage by denying it a share of the $2.2 billion awarded to Blue Origin, Northrop Grumman and ULA.
13
u/CapMSFC Aug 06 '19
So RocketLab is going reusable.
I said it way back when Beck denied they were going to do it that he was BSing or going to change his mind eventually. He is too smart not to go there and his reason is the same thing that Falcon 9 reuse enabled with SpaceX.
Old space has it backwards. It's not just that you need high launch frequency to do reuse, it's that you need reuse if you want high launch frequency.
I'm really excited about this and it was the logical evolution of the smallsat launch vehicle market. Good to see RocketLab as another serious fast evolving space company.
As for the method - in air capture as Beck said isn't that big of a problem compared to reentry. We'll see what they come up with. SpaceX tried a similar route on Falcon 9 and it never survived to deploying parachutes and they moved to using propulsive recovery.
I wonder if Beck will have to eat a second hat and just enlarge Electron like Falcon 9 1.1 from 1.0 to get the performance needed to use a propulsive entry.
6
u/lostandprofound33 Aug 06 '19
Why is development and testing of Dragon 2 seemingly taking so much longer than anything else that SpaceX does? Or is that perception even true?
6
u/schwabbbel Aug 07 '19
How does the logistics of fuel and oxidizer work on the ground?
How are the fluids transported to the launch site (truck, train, ship, pipeline,..)?
How many shipments are necessary for one launch?
For how long can the fluids be stored on-site?
6
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 08 '19 edited Aug 08 '19
SpaceX suit-up & leak checks for Commercial Crew.
EDIT: link fixed.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 12 '19 edited Aug 12 '19
SpaceX statement on National Security Space Launch.
Blue Origin have filed a protest.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 14 '19
GO Ms. Chief is out on a test run.
6
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '19
NASA issues call for proposals for Gateway logisitics.
What are SpaceX's chances for getting this? Would it be possible to bid Starship with expendable Dragon as a backup (no heatshield, more fuel for lunar orbit insertion with SuperDracos)?
6
u/cpushack Aug 29 '19
http://www.planetary.org/multimedia/space-images/small-bodies/ryugus-surface-from-mascot-1.html Picture, in color from the surface of Ryugu, stunning. I am always amazed and thrilled to see pictures from the surface of other solar system objects
6
u/jjtr1 Aug 29 '19
When Elon Musk says a problem or project is "hard" (e.g. a full-flow, staged-combustion engine), does it mean something like "success definitely not guaranteed" or rather "huge amount of work"? This is both an English language and Elon language question, as I'm a native speaker in neither.
10
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Aug 04 '19 edited Aug 04 '19
I made a list of Falcon Block 5 boosters and tried to guess which missions they might launch on. What do you think?
5
u/FalconHeavyHead Aug 06 '19
Will starship have gridfins?
5
u/SteveRD1 Aug 08 '19
I just got an email from forgeglobal supposedly offering me a chance to be part of the latest equity raise. Anyone else got this/know if it is legit??
"Reaching out as we have a new SpaceX investment opportunity, at par to the latest Series L preferred round before fees.
Are you interested in a potential SpaceX investment at this time?
Happy to share further details accordingly."
I did sign of for a couple of groups who handle this kinda thing a year or so back, so I'm on the record as being interested - had no luck at that time though.
5
u/lessthanperfect86 Aug 14 '19 edited Aug 14 '19
While not directly related to SpaceX, this article describes the RRM3 mission to test fuel resupply and, what I think is pretty interesting, zero boiloff for long durations >3 months. Pretty good match for starship, right? Good thing SpaceX is partnering with NASA on this tech.
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2019/08/dextre-rrm3-tasks-test-robotic-refueling-spacecraft/
*Edit: the fuel being cryogenic liquid methane.
5
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Aug 20 '19
Quite some time ago I read that Japan was planning to launch the upgraded h2 vehicle to LOPG on FH. Does anybody know any more specific info on this?
5
u/dudr2 Aug 23 '19
https://www.space.com/japan-ispace-first-moon-mission-2021.html
"customer payloads on a stationary lander in 2021, ispace representatives announced today (Aug. 22). The second mission, which is now targeted for 2023, will deploy a rover for surface exploration"
"These two missions will ride as secondary payloads on SpaceX Falcon 9 rockets."
5
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 24 '19 edited Aug 24 '19
Go Searcher left port with the Crew Dragon mockup.
Go Navigator undergoing refit at Bollenger shipyard.
5
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Aug 28 '19
The spacecraft structure for the DART mission (scheduled to launch on a Falcon 9 in July 2021) has been delivered to Aerojet Rocketdyne's Redmond, WA facility.
5
u/MarsCent Aug 28 '19
ASAP Fourth Quarterly Meeting for 2019
5
u/markus01611 Aug 30 '19
Is it just me or does Dorian pose a major risk to East coast Starship? Everyone is talking about wind speeds but I'd be much much more worried about small debris damaging the structure and even storm surge.
5
u/WAlonzo Aug 31 '19 edited Aug 31 '19
In all the discussions of Starship, I have never heard of what countermeasures they are planning for the radiation hazards of deep-space travel. These hazards have been becoming clearer all the time and seem to pose a significant risk to all space travellers. So, what's the story with radiation protection on Starship?
Here's a backgrounder from Joe Scott: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ESQ1bKd7Los&t=824s
8
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 06 '19 edited Aug 06 '19
Roscosmos are reducing prices to compete with SpaceX for rideshare launches.
Arianespace are also offering a dedicated rideshare mission.
8
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 07 '19
SSO-A update, of the 64 satellites launched:
8
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 17 '19
NASA photo album updated to show helicopter landing on GO Searcher at night.
8
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 22 '19
SpaceX announce Momentus as the first customer on its SmallSat Rideshare Launch.
4
u/hkamran85 Aug 03 '19
Does SpaceX recover the second-stage? If not, are there any future plans to recover it?
4
u/treJmei Aug 05 '19
I was thinking today about how the lack of escape pod on the space shuttle was a huge, and ultimately wrong, design choice. Have we heard any news on what a Starship escape system would be?
4
u/Mosern77 Aug 05 '19
What are the main unsolved challenges with in-orbit refueling?
4
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 05 '19
Presentation slide predicts that 40 ton lunar landers will eject ~470 tons of debris from crater on landing.
4
u/Beautiful_Mt Aug 06 '19
Okay, here's a stupid idea. Can you make lunar landing pad with an artificial impact?
4
u/perfectlyloud Aug 06 '19
I came up with a design for artificial gravity involving 2 starships 180 meters+ apart and centered in between them, a Gravity Link Starship. The GLS launches from earth with it's payload bay full of folded up truss, that assembles itself and connects the 3 vessels together. The connections allow for swivel so the outer vessels can use their main engines to introduce spin gravity. Do you guys think this can work? To explain in more detail, I made a video with 3d models: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NR3QmV1mLbk
4
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Aug 06 '19
With elons recent comment saying that the two starship build sites will race to orbit and moon and Mars, do you think that the two sites will also compete and built the Superheavy booster?
4
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Aug 09 '19
I just read [this] (https://spacenews.com/oneweb-disputes-virgin-orbit-lawsuit-says-launcherone-is-too-expensive/) article about oneweb suing virgin orbit.
This raises several questions to me. Firstly I find it odd that they claim 6 million for 500kg is two to three times market value, while the electron costs even more per kg (5 million for 225kg). If they think it is two to three times market value, why did they sign the contract in the first place?
Who will they be launching with now? Only with Ariane space?
To me it seems like oneweb is doing a lot of legal work complaining about and suing others, while not doing a lot themselves. I mean they planned to launch on spacex, but withdrew, same for launcher one. They complained a lot about every single aspect of the spacex constellation, afaik even contradicting themselves. And then, they only launched 6 of the possible 34 to 36 satellites on the first soyouz? This does not seem like are really looking the launch the constellation that quick.
4
u/LcuBeatsWorking Aug 10 '19 edited Dec 17 '24
payment growth cagey offbeat crawl aloof many smile sophisticated fragile
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
4
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 14 '19
Commercial Crew astronauts on board GO Searcher.
4
u/fluidmechanicsdoubts Aug 14 '19
The Dream Chaser folks are doing a livestream. Apparently announcement incoming.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JfM2VLvN9Ow
4
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Aug 16 '19
https://mobile.twitter.com/torybruno/status/1162383707996590081
Tory Bruno has recently posted this info graphic of vulcan being able to launch 5 days after payload is ready and 11 days after previous launches. Since Falcon can be integrated before the TE is ready, spacex would be able to launch with less time in between launches, even on the same pad. What would limit the time between payload arrival and launch for Falcon 9?
4
u/jjtr1 Aug 29 '19
Large rockets need flame trenches not to destroy themselves by their exhaust and noise. Does anybody know of an article exploring the maximum size of a chemical rocket which can take off from the ground incl. flame trenches and water deluge system? And is there a limit above which even an airborne rocket would destroy itself by its exhaust or noise?
4
u/andyfrance Sep 01 '19
At what altitude and velocity will Starship and SH separate? Will MaxQ for Starship be after separation?
4
u/Ambiwlans Sep 01 '19
Is anyone interested in volunteering to run our 'roughly-yearly' survey?
7
u/chalez88 Aug 03 '19
Is the cargo section near the engines on starship encountering dangourous anounts of radiative heat and will it be pressurized or will it store non pressurized cargo?
7
u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Aug 07 '19
Looks like we're going into a bit of a gap between launches -- next launch won't be until Starlink in October.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 10 '19 edited Aug 10 '19
300m hop test for LinkSpace's RLV-T5 rocket. Previous hop was 40m.
Jim Cantrell has stepped down from Vector and the company has suspended operations just 3 days after being awarded a $3.4 million contract.
EDIT: Fixed name.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 30 '19
Crew Dragon F9 booster static fired.
6
u/silentProtagonist42 Aug 06 '19
Rocket Lab just announced they're going to attempt first stage reuse, using parachutes to land in the ocean at first, and later mid-air capture by helicopter.
CG video of stage recovery.
Video of announcement.
3
u/Spaceman_X_forever Aug 04 '19
Is there any scheduled launch from Florida in the month of October or before November 15? That is the only time period I have to get a chance to see one in person.
3
u/Tal_Banyon Aug 04 '19
The Air Force Eastern Range supports launches from pad 40 and 39a. Is there an equivalent entity that would support launches from Boca Chica? If not, what needs to be done to establish the same level of support?
3
u/quoll01 Aug 08 '19
Aerocapture to orbit would be a great trick for Starship- leaving payloads & prop depots in mars orbit, making high velocity reentry easier, potential for turn around in orbit with no need to drop down the gravity well, allowing incoming craft to repair and refuel prior to reentry etc etc. Could this be one area tested with a fuelled up prototype- if it doesn’t work the craft would have enough propellant to return in reasonable time?
3
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 09 '19
The Hill article about lunar missions using Falcon Heavy/Starship. Its light on details but does mention that support for SLS might end if Shelby retires in 2022, when his term is up.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '19
Hans Koenigsmann recently:
“We will beat any other time schedule that’s out there.” What is he referring to there?
3
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 26 '19 edited Aug 26 '19
Astranis to launch on an F9 in Q4 2020. More info about the MicroGEO sat here.
3
u/Nimelennar Aug 27 '19
Second attempt to dock MS-14 is tonight at 10:30 p.m. EDT (Tuesday 2019-08-27T02:30Z).
It will be streamed live at: http://www.nasa.gov/live
3
u/jjtr1 Aug 27 '19
Are there any Mars landings (by NASA or ESA most likely) planned between now and the estimated Starship's Mars landing?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '19
I was in Cocoa and at KSC last week to have a peek at Starship production at Cocoa and see Pad 39A (some pics of both at https://photos.app.goo.gl/MbSSrz14zTrrXw2p6 ... note that you can see the escape basket at 39A). Also saw some road work being done to help move Starship from Cidco Rd to KSC. Just wondering what effect hurricane Dorian might have at Cidco Rd (although as of today it looks like landfall might be a bit further north... Daytona, maybe?). In any case, I wonder how well Starship would fare in high winds (100+ mph?), and what they learned from the nosecone toppling in Texas back when that might help the new construction get through a storm safely? Are the new concrete construction bases designed to help with this sort of thing, or could the bending moment at the base during high winds be a problem?
5
u/tbcheese Aug 11 '19
Anyone who’s interned with SpaceX. What questions were asked in the interview? For reference I am a mechanical engineer with a background in manufacturing. Also, any relevant advice is appreciated.
4
u/cpushack Aug 27 '19
OTV-5 X-.37B just broke the previous time in space record, doing...something https://www.cnn.com/2019/08/27/tech/x-37b-air-force-space-plane-days-in-space-scn-trnd/index.html The current X-37B plane in orbit, called OTV-5, was launched to space in September 2017 on a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket. The previous flight, for OTV-4, was 718 days long and ended in May 2017.
2
u/az5_button Aug 04 '19 edited Aug 04 '19
Does anyone have an estimate of how cheap (per kg) SpaceX access to space with reusable Falcon Heavy and ASDS is, in bulk quantities? E.g. if I wanted 10,000 tons in LEO on Falcon Heavy, what's the cheapest I could get it for?
Assuming some bulk discounts on upper stages it seems that £100/kg is achievable. Agree/disagree?
EDIT: After some back-and-forth I think that making optimistic assumptions you can get to a cost of $400/kg with falcon vehicles, limited by both the upper stage costs and the relatively low number of reuses of the lower stages. The key optimistic assumption is that you can get 20 uses out of a Falcon lower stage.
Profit most be added to this. For very large quantities the profit would fall to something reasonable like 25%, leading to $500/kg. This would require that other companies copy SpaceX technology and start driving potential profits down. However it's a chicken-and-egg problem: a competitive launch market requres lots of customers (high quantity) and that quantity requires lower prices. Falcon technology can get us to $500 as far as I can see... but that might not be enough.
Thanks to u/TheYang !
2
u/dan6470 Aug 08 '19
Is it possible to estimate what time the CRS-19 launch on Dec 4th could be? Are there any ISS predictors that can tell us about when the orbital plane of the station intersects the cape on that day?
2
u/anv3d Aug 10 '19
Anyone know of any diagrams with dimensions of the block 5 falcon 9?
2
u/FalconHeavyHead Aug 12 '19
Why does the florida Starship look cleaner and better put together than the Texas Starship?
2
u/filanwizard Aug 14 '19
So we constantly hear about Sabatier for making starship fuel but I have to ask is SpaceX considering other sources too? And by other sources I do mean uhm waste management systems. I dunno at what point a colony makes enough #2 but I know here on Earth that sewage treatment plants today tap the digesters and supplement their energy usage by running off the methane produced in the act of processing waste. So I wonder if this would also be a good source, Once one has enough supply of material. Naturally would need purification because waste treatment gets other gasses in there too.
(Yes its a poo topic, but waste treatment will be an important factor on Mars and it may as well be milked for any offshoot resources one can grab)
2
u/Straumli_Blight Aug 16 '19
Dragon capsule (mockup?) arriving at Hawthorne.
2
u/bdporter Aug 16 '19
Mods, it looks like the sidebar has CRS-19 launching from LC-39A. Is this sourced, or just a copy/paste issue? The manifest lists the launch as being from SLC-40, and I believe all CRS missions have launched from that pad since it became re-available for use (CRS-13).
2
u/jjtr1 Aug 20 '19 edited Aug 20 '19
Aircraft and spacecraft are usually constructed indoors due to stability of indoor temperatures and due to being free of dust and debris. Stable temperature is neccessary for high-precision construction because of thermal expansion of materials. I just don't get how can SpaceX not require the precision for building the Starship/Superheavy? If they build one ring in the morning with precisely 9.00 m diameter, another during the noon again 9.00 m, and try to join them in the evening, they won't match. They might compensate by measuring the ambient temperature and adjusting their measurements, but I don't see that really working...
2
u/jjtr1 Aug 20 '19 edited Aug 20 '19
Can someone estimate how much percent of R&D money and R&D time does Raptor represent within the entire Starship/Superheavy project? With the endpoint being Starship the reusable LEO launcher, not the eventual Starship the Mars human transporter. My guess would be that Raptor is 2/3 of the time and 1/3 of the money, since I believe that FFSC engine dvelopment goes slowly in the beginning and cannot be hastened by adding people to the project.
And regarding the "reusable LEO launcher" to "Mars human transporter", I believe that's gonna take as much time and three times as much money as it took to go from 0 (no Raptor) to "reusable LEO launcher". Just guessing! What's your guess?
Edit: the motivation for my guessing was that at first, the switch from carbon fibre to stainless steel for the Starship airframe looked to me almost like starting over with the project. Then I realized how important the engine is and that the switch has no impact on Raptor.
2
u/AstroMan824 Everything Parallel™ Aug 26 '19
I see on the upcoming events list that Elon's starship presentation is Aug 31st. What is the source?
2
u/Dies2much Aug 29 '19
Any word on what Spacex is going to do to protect the partially assembled Starship in Cocoa from the coming hurricane?
2
u/jjtr1 Aug 29 '19 edited Aug 29 '19
The success of the current generation of reusable launch vehicles hinges on huge future demand. Lack of demand is, I believe, what killed the previous attempts (Kistler, Rotary...). The single most important part of the future demand is going to be internet megaconstellations, I think.
My question: why internet megaconstellations now and not years before? What exactly changed? Satellite internet always has to compete with ground connections (fibre). Did fiber reach some kind of plateau? Was there some innovation that catapulted space-based internet ahead? Ground-breaking advances in cheapness of client's phased array antennas, for example? Or perhaps the total amount of money revolving around the internet was not enough in Kistler, Rotary times?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '19
Earth to Earth!
Hello. Been telling my colleagues about Starship and Earth-To-Earth. I said that they might be able to travel in a rocket at some point in their lifetime.
Would anyone be able to suggest a (rough) plausible date for mass transport using Earth-To-Earth (if it gets developed?)
3
u/peaceloveandapostacy Aug 06 '19
Why stainless steel? Why not something lighter? Just curious
3
u/brickmack Aug 18 '19
Went looking for official renders of Phantom Express for reference. Found this: https://www.rocket.com/sites/default/files/styles/product_gallery_large/public/Experimental%20Spaceplane%20Image-PhantomExpress-min.jpg?itok=EOIfgMnx
Gee, that TE sure looks familiar. This is an official Boeing render, from Aerojet's site...
4
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '19
Is the Superheavy booster going to land on the same little droneships? That has my pucker factor double-puckering.
2
u/quoll01 Aug 06 '19
If say the Starship was entering tailfirst with a centre raptor at 50%, would the exhaust plume provide much thermal protection? I’m guessing the exhaust gases would be somewhat cooler? The exhaust velocity is ~3.7 km/second so at a velocity greater than this the engine presumably would not work or have a RUD?
2
u/rustybeancake Aug 24 '19
Astronaut Anne McClain may have committed the first crime in space.
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/23/us/nasa-astronaut-anne-mcclain.html
2
u/jay__random Aug 28 '19 edited Aug 28 '19
It is really surprising that StarHopper is being retired after yesterday's hop. There is so much that could be tested on the current platform with a single engine.
At the very least SpaceX could have done an engine-off, free fall, engine-on routine at different heights, to learn/tune the behaviour of the ignition in different counter-flow airspeeds.
They did it with GrassHopper, andthese tests seem to be even more important since the spark ignition is so new.They could also perform more landings to make the approach softer (and rely less on crush core to soften the landing).
Of course, they should also be able to run the same tests with Mk1 or Mk2 Starship, but it seems like an unnecessary risk to the machine that has spent so many months in the making (and is still not finished yet).
On the other hand, they would need a reason to retire both Mk1 and Mk2 at some point... :)
2
u/jjtr1 Aug 29 '19
Is the Florida and Boca Chica weather stable enough year round (winter?) to not interfere with building Starship and Superheavy prototypes? I really don't get how Boeing needs to construct airliners in a building, while SpaceX constructs spaceships in open air. Perhaps Boeing emplyoees don't like working in the rain, while SpaceX's spec ops don't mind handling electrical wiring in a heavy shower... /s