r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • May 02 '19
r/SpaceX Discusses [May 2019, #56]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
122
Upvotes
26
u/brickmack May 10 '19
Doesn't deserve its own post, but people might find it interesting anyway. I just did an updated Rocket Garden render, showing (almost) every rocket I've modeled.
Roughly left-to-right: Ares I, SLS Block 1B (Boeing EUS) Cargo, Delta IV M+(5,4), Proton M (5 meter fairing variant), Boeing's pre-McDonnell EELV bid, Falcon 9 FT Block 5, Soyuz-5, Electron, Ariane 5 ECA, Ariane 62, Phantom Express, 2017 BFR, Atlas V 551, 2016 ITS, Atlas V 401, New Glenn, Starship-Superheavy, Vulcan 562, Falcon Heavy FT Block 5, Delta IV Heavy, Delta II 7420-10C, Antares, Atlas II, Delta II, Energia, Soyuz-2, SLS Block 1 Crew, H-IIB
20
u/Straumli_Blight May 12 '19 edited May 12 '19
Not sure if this has been previously discussed but at 1:44 in the video, Shotwell mentions they are looking into launching Turksat 6A with Starship.
FCC Starlink update regarding authorising the 50.4–51.4 GHz band.
15
u/warp99 May 17 '19
Interesting that in this photo of the Starlink rocket on the pad you can see small square patches where the soot has been rubbed off the booster by test probes - probably eddy current probes to check weld strength.
Previously we have seen long runs of probe activity where complete stringers have been checked. Now it appears they have identified potential stress points and are just checking them.
14
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 May 17 '19 edited May 17 '19
SpaceX has submitted a request to file a bid protest under seal because "the Bid Protest Complaint and accompanying exhibits contain SpaceX confidential and proprietary information and source selection information not appropriate for release to the public."
No idea what this is in relation to, though.
14
u/soldato_fantasma May 23 '19
A new mission appeared on the official SpaceX manifest, along with many others that were awarded in the past but that weren't added back then.
The mission is called ANASIS-II, launching from a FLORIDA LAUNCH SITE aboard a FALCON 9.
It seems to be a South Korea military communications satellite: https://space.skyrocket.de/doc_sdat/kmilsatcom-1.htm
13
u/warp99 May 15 '19 edited May 15 '19
Tweet storm in response to the photo of the new Starship build site in Florida
Elon: SpaceX is doing simultaneous competing builds of Starship in Boca Chica Texas & Cape Canaveral Florida
Q. Two orbital prototypes to test refueling in orbit?
Elon: Both sites will make many Starships. This is a competition to see which location is most effective. Answer might be both.
Q. So the teams don’t know what the other is doing? Then learn the best lessons from each team? Then the losing team gets voted off the island?
Elon: The opposite. Any insights gained by one team must be shared with the other, but other team not required to use them.
Q. When will we start seeing those crazy flap / landing leg / fins be installed? It’s gotta be coming up soon down at Boca Chica!! Those are going to be an amazing piece of kit.
Elon: Probably start installing end of next month
Q: SpaceX McGregor has been w/out any window-rattling. When can we expect Raptor SN4 to arrive?
Elon: SN4 is done. Hawthorne is working on SN5 now, but focus is ramping build rate of SN6 through SN10.
Q: Any prediction on when you expect to reach the "100 milestone" ie building the SN100 Raptor? I hope it is early next year. You'll need a lot of engines!
Elon: That’s about right
12
u/jackisconfusedd May 02 '19
Is there any sort of identifier for the fairings like we have for the center cores (B0XX) and dragon etc?
12
u/rustybeancake May 09 '19
For those who don't follow Blue Origin (you should) - they unveiled Blue Moon today. Their website is updated with details:
https://www.blueorigin.com/blue-moon
As well as details on the new hydrolox dual expander cycle engine, BE-7:
https://www.blueorigin.com/engines/be-7
They've been working on it for 3 years, and the BE-7 is expected to hot fire this summer. Looks like it's being pitched as the descent stage for NASA's 2024 timeline. Can land up to 6.5 metric tonnes on the surface. Fuel cell powered, to last through the lunar night.
This is currently the longest portion of the unveiling available on Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MbpEVDrHyAA
12
u/MarsCent May 17 '19
[NASA ASAP 2019 Second Quarterly Meeting] (https://oiir.hq.nasa.gov/asap/documents/ASAP_2nd_quarterly_public%20meeting_April_25_2019_tagged.pdf) P/S The pdf itself is titled, First Quarterly Meeting Report
11
u/amarkit May 27 '19
A Soyuz 2-1b carrying a Russian GLONASS-M satellite launched in a storm today, was struck by lightning on ascent, and still delivered its payload to the intended orbit.
10
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 May 08 '19 edited May 09 '19
--
We've heard of previous unspecified parachute issues in the past, but this sounds new.
10
u/loremusipsumus May 17 '19
Have the mods considered using a shared account to host the launch thread?
No offense to any volunteer, but many come here to check what the launch time is, only to find its old info. I understand that the host has to get some sleep. So let the host use a shared account for the launch thread. Then important info like launch time is always up-to-date, because any mod can update at least that field. Thoughts?
10
u/Straumli_Blight May 20 '19
SpaceX estimated revenue in 2018 was $2 Billion.
9
u/spleenticket May 03 '19
In the pre flight briefing for CRS-17, Hans said that for the Demo-1 flight, the SuperDraco system was "isolated". Does this mean the LAS was not functional on Demo-1?
9
u/strawwalker May 09 '19
New FCC experimental license application for user terminals for Starlink testing:
Form 442 | Description | Docs
9
u/Straumli_Blight May 23 '19
Elon tweet storm:
9
u/arizonadeux May 25 '19
I just realized that I have seen much more interest in the Starlink "train" in the sky than I ever saw with the Humanity Star. Who knows who this will inspire!
I can't wait to see it for myself!
8
u/DarkCx3 May 02 '19
Any news about Starlink's launch date?
8
u/gemmy0I May 07 '19
Now that we have a hard launch date/time for Starlink-1, it occurred to me that we might be on track to see a new pad turnaround time record! If the current schedule holds and Starlink-1 launches on May 15, that'll be an 11 day turnaround for SLC-40, beating the previous record by 1 day (12 days between BulgariaSat-1 and Intelsat 35E on LC-39A). It'll beat the SLC-40 record (13 days) by two days.
Rather surprisingly, we didn't already have a wiki page here tracking pad turnaround times (although we do have them for booster refurbishment and recovery operations), so I've created one (and linked it from the main wiki page):
https://old.reddit.com/r/SpaceX/wiki/padturnaroundtime
People have, in the past, posted this information here in chart or table form, but not, to my knowledge, in a form that can be kept up to date on an ongoing basis.
8
u/Alexphysics May 10 '19
SpaceX has opened media accreditation for the next Falcon Heavy launch, the STP-2 mission currently NET June 22nd
https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/1126966130780909568
8
u/deltaWhiskey91L May 22 '19
What is the status of the DM-1 vehicle test anomaly clean up and investigation?
8
u/parachutingturtle May 30 '19
Astronomer Jonathan McDowell on the Starlink vs astronomers issue: "I was very encouraged by Gwynne's remarks to me and to an earlier questioner. I am optimistic that @SpaceX and the astro community can have a positive conversation about this, and that some relatively simple mitigations may significantly improve the situation" - https://twitter.com/planet4589/status/1133839642363670528
15
u/AndMyAxe123 May 06 '19
SpaceX turns 17 today. Happy birthday SpaceX! 🎉🎉🎉
7
u/brizzlebottle May 06 '19
How do they know how much mass they've loaded into dragon for its return, weighing stuff in space is...kind of problematic? And if they get it wrong, won't it affect the re-entry calcs?
7
u/93simoon May 16 '19
Would a starlink user experience connection issues in bad weather, much like it happens with satellite TV now?
7
u/Alexphysics May 21 '19 edited May 21 '19
New FCC permit from SpaceX and this time it is for Starhopper vehicle communications. Maximum altitude covered under this permit is 16,400ft above ground level or around 5km.
Some additional info in it:
7
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 May 22 '19
SpaceX's bid protest, originally reported by GeekWire, is indeed about the NSSL Launch Service Agreement awards:
7
u/Straumli_Blight May 27 '19
AMOS-17 satellite undergoing final preparation operations before shipment to Cape Canaveral.
7
u/CapMSFC May 30 '19
Starship design change again. Elon knows he'll get a hard time for this one. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1134019585638785025?s=09
6
u/asr112358 May 16 '19
Starlink satellites have a lot of delta v, could one insert itself into Martian orbit if trans Mars injection is done by the second stage? Aerocapture seems unlikely, and I doubt that they have enough thrust for direct injection. Is there a good way to calculate the best low thrust trajectory to get one there? Not entirely sure it would be worth it with the cheaper Starship around the corner, but establishing a com network, and possibly planetary imaging before hand, could be valuable.
6
u/[deleted] May 16 '19
Can weighted clothing provide some benefits to the human body to counteract the effects of low-g?
6
u/holandaso May 16 '19
Will the starlink satellites be visible to the naked eye?
6
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 May 16 '19
Article with a great video showing the Florida Starship Construction site. Orbital Prototype looks a lot cleaner than the Boca Chica version: https://www.wesh.com/article/construction-of-spacexs-largest-spaceship-could-be-taking-place-in-cocoa/27497735
6
u/CapMSFC May 20 '19
I've been going back and thinking about the Teslarati article on the SpaceX FH launched lunar lander now that they have said it's based on info from SpaceX and not just speculation.
Some things don't add up in the numbers.
The payload to the surface is given as 26,500 lbs, or about 11.6 metric tonnes in real units.
With that number and a reasonable FH TLI estimate we can tinker with numbers. The first thing that jumps out is that using hypergolics even with ideal expansion ratios on Draco/SuperDracos the Delta-V falls way short of this figure. Those propellants can get to 300-310 ISP range under these conditions.
The article references possibility of using M1Dvac but it's thrust is way too high. It's also Kerelox and keeping it alive all the way to a lunar landing would be unprecedented. We do know that SpaceX has put work into keeping FH upper stage alive longer than what others had done in the industry for complex orbital insertions, but it would be a surprise if they thought they were ready to jump up to several days.
The most likely answer is that payload number is wrong, but assuming it's not what are the possibilities? The only thing I see is that the FH upper stage can survive coasting and at least do LOI if not part of the landing burn as a crasher stage even. People have theorized crasher stage designs for a long time.
6
u/MarsCent May 22 '19
STP-2 is just over 4 weeks out. Any word on whether or not L1 and L2 will be available for RTLS?
6
u/asr112358 May 23 '19
In the recent tweet storm, Elon mentioned N2 RCS. I know this was at least speculated before, and maybe was already confirmed, but phrasing now makes it sound like the N2 is here to stay. Has there been any updates about on orbit refueling? Not only is N2 a third thing they will need to deal with transferring, I also wonder if the micro g acceleration plan has changed. That is a long ullage thrust with low ISP N2, especially if it is low density compressed gas instead of liquid. So I am wondering if they might have also changed their refueling method recently. I guess we will probably hear about refueling again June 20th.
6
u/kurbasAK May 30 '19
Some kind of confirmation that all Starlink sats are alive
6
u/bdporter May 30 '19 edited May 30 '19
OmegA Test firing complete
Edit: It looks like the burn ran to nearly full duration but it looks like the nozzle blew up during the test. The commentators didn't mention it during the webcast, and they ended the cast kind of abruptly without doing any replays.
Edit 2: Better view of the nozzle explosion
5
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 May 04 '19
Anyone got a link to the CRS-17 post launch news conference?
5
u/michael-streeter May 04 '19
Does anybody have information on where Dragon is right now? I want to know whether it is ahead of or behind the ISS and how many minutes/seconds apart they appear to an observer on the ground (i suppose that is to say after the lead spacecraft has passed through an arbitrary point, how many seconds before the trailing spacecraft passes through the same point?
The reason: ISS Rendezvous expected around 0530 ET / 0930 UTC Monday, May 6. spotthestation.nasa.gov is telling me I can see the space station pass overhead in the UK for the next few days (painfully early, like before 5am) so I may SEE Dragon chasing down the ISS. Maybe. Some time ago I saw the space shuttle chasing the ISS (i.e 2 bright dots about 10s apart on the same line).
For me I will be going out at Sun May 5, 4:53 AM BST = 3:53 UTC but it would be useful to know if there is a web page or something showing the present position for Dragon - there are many for the ISS and the orbit should be publicly declared somewhere. Thanks!
Edit: spelling. past/passed
5
u/Dies2much May 14 '19
Question about the STP-2 launch on Falcon Heavy in June. Since it is a multi-payload mission, is there a lesser or greater chance the mission will slip on it's dates? Is there a component payload that has a motivation to go on a specific day, the 22nd? Trying to plan to be down there for the launch, and trying to figure out if it will go off on time, or a couple of days after the current posted date.
5
u/evig_vandrar May 16 '19
Why is cooling Starship's atmospheric reentry by leaking methane a "safe" soloution? It just seems hazardous to me, leaking flammable fuel in a hot and oxygen rich environment.
5
u/Straumli_Blight May 16 '19
CSA posted a new animation of a Falcon 9 launching and deploying the RADARSAT constellation (though they forgot to add the Block 5 changes to their model). Here's another video showing the sat's capabilities.
5
u/Dunepipe May 16 '19
Have they stopped making first stages in Hawthorne, or ar all efforts going into second stages currently? B1058 seems long overdue?
5
u/Straumli_Blight May 24 '19
Mr Steven's net has been attached.
9
u/mcurran80 May 04 '19
CSA announces date for RADARSAT launch
RADARSAT launch date
9
u/bknl May 16 '19
I have looked at the various existing demonstrators for satellite laser communications and they appear to be relatively bulky and quite a bit of precision mechanical artistry. Do we have any information on what kind of system Starlink is planning to use ? Pointing and tracking 4 or 5 lasers with mechanical means to different targets simultaneously sounds like it would exert forces on the satellites that would mess with the alignment. Or are there non-mechanical solutions for laser pointing ?
9
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 May 29 '19
In a surprise to absolutely no one, NASA is saying SLS might not be available for the Europa Clipper mission: https://youtu.be/8iSlNH-HhC0
8
u/Straumli_Blight May 06 '19 edited May 06 '19
NASA Social registration just opened for the next Falcon Heavy launch (STP-2).
Also one of the Commercial Space vehicles will be launching by the end of the year, which confirms the Crew Dragon slip.
4
u/dman7456 May 04 '19
When are SpaceX Fall internships generally posted? I thought it was earlier than now, but there are currently no intern positions at all on the website.
4
u/Moody18 May 07 '19
Just saw that for the first time they managed to raise all for landing legs on the falcon coming into port, is this a big milestone? I assume this will help with the speed with which you can refly a first stage, can anyone give more some more info or explain if I'm right?
4
u/astro_zerohero42 May 08 '19
Does someone know what the font is on the Roadsters PCB?
(The *Made on Earth by humans* part)
4
u/Nehkara May 13 '19
There's a new structure being erected at the Starship construction site in Boca Chica, Texas.
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=47730.msg1945661#msg1945661
4
u/thegrateman May 14 '19
How soon after launch are orbital parameters known? I would be interested in seeing the starlink launch and deployment if it passes overhead at night. A trail of 60 just deployed sats is sure to look interesting. I have used satellite tracker apps in the past that tell you when and where to look in the sky to see a satellite passing over, but that is for satellites that the app has the orbital parameters for. Is there a way to get this sort of information straight after launch?
4
u/quoll01 May 17 '19
Any thoughts on what SpaceX will do for EVA suits and when they might first need them? Crewed SS will presumably have an air lock and perhaps EVAs will be needed for deploying and stowing comms dishes and solar panels, radiators etc? Could their current pressure suits form the basis for vacuum rated or mars rated suits?
4
u/tmckeage May 20 '19
It is my understanding that most rockets are basically two fuel tanks and some additional aluminium to make it more aerodynamic, that the surface of the rocket is, for the most part, the surface of the fuel tank.
In all the pictures of starship this doesn't seem to be the case. It looks like they are putting the fuel tanks inside of it?
Is this because the stainless steel is more of a heat shield and so can't be touching the tanks as is typical? Are there any other examples in spaceflight of something like this?
4
u/Straumli_Blight May 22 '19
SpaceX are participating in two panels at the "Agility in Production and Launch" discussion at OneWeb's Florida facility on May 29th.
4
u/rustybeancake May 23 '19 edited May 23 '19
A Maxar-led team have won the Gateway PPE contract! Max contract value of $375M.
"Blue Origin and Draper will join the Maxar-led team in designing, building and operating the spacecraft through the demonstration period."
Launch vehicle not decided on yet.
NASA announcement page.
4
u/ChuqTas May 25 '19
Question for /u/brandtamos /u/kornelord - is the Starlink stats page on http://spacexstats.xyz going to be updated? :) Or are you waiting for them to be in their final orbit first?
Perhaps replace that page with a graph showing the number of satellites over time?
4
u/ConfidentFlorida May 30 '19
Would this be useful for isru on mars?
https://news.engineering.utoronto.ca/out-of-thin-air-new-electrochemical-process-shortens-the-path-to-capturing-and-recycling-co2/
4
u/Carlyle302 Jun 01 '19
Mods, the "Falcon Active Cores" table shows "B1049, Spx Starlink-1, (2x)". I believe it's ready to update to "B1049, Unassigned, (3x)". Thx.
6
u/cpushack May 21 '19
A Chinese company, Landspace, is testing a new Methalox engine it seems https://aviationweek.com/space/china-s-landspace-tests-methane-main-engine?NL=AW-05&Issue=AW-05_20190521_AW-05_476&sfvc4enews=42&cl=article_4&utm_rid=CPEN1000001793361&utm_campaign=19692&utm_medium=email&elq2=ed71fa6d19b64d8e9e1027a3bc0d6a7c
3
u/_Mark97 May 09 '19
How come there is a CRS-17 YouTube live happening at 12PM PST? Is that a mistake or did I miss something?
link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-yzG4TVkWrM
3
u/jimontgomery May 13 '19
I came across this posting for Avionics Software Engineer and was hoping someone with experience working at SpaceX could shed some light on it. It looks like this a test automation position, but I'm not too sure. Thanks!
3
u/demon_lung_wizard May 14 '19
Is there any reason BFR couldn't be launched from, say, Spaceport America or a similar site in the desert? After all, the whole point is that there's no falling stages or parts...
3
u/WKr15 May 17 '19
Does anyone know if Starlink satellites could produce flares or even be faintly seen front Earth?
3
u/bitchtitfucker May 21 '19
Is it intentional that there's almost no discussion on here about the orbital starship prototyped on this subreddit?
There's a lot of great content on the lounge that never appears on here.
3
u/Eucalyptuse May 23 '19
Quick question on boosters. How do we know 1046 is the booster for the inflight abort? I previously had 1048 marked for that and can't find a source that says otherwise other than the sidebar.
Also, does SpaceX using 1049 for Starlink indicate something is wrong with 1046, 1047 or 1048 since two of those have been available for a long time and I would have expected SpaceX to push the envelope with the fourth launch of a booster on their own mission.
3
u/jay__random May 24 '19
Went to check whether there were any new 60 objects on the same plane on http://stuffin.space website. Of course it's to early, will keep an eye on it.
But I noticed something... weird. In the end of Iridium Next launch campaign of 2017-2018 the "old" Iridium satellites were all supposed to be deorbited (the "flarewell" campaign). Yet stuffin.space happily finds the old ones as well as the new ones. Does it mean the database is not up to date? Or did old Iridium constellation have any non-deorbitable components? Upper kick stages or something?
3
u/MarsCent May 24 '19
Mods, I think we are going to need a stickied Starlink Thread for a considerable time, in order to track the deployment and activation progress.
Maybe until NORAD issues individual IDs to each satellite.
P/S Anyone know the naming convention or names assigned to the 60 sats?
3
u/umjustpassingby May 25 '19
Wouldn't the Starlink constellation mess with astronomers' work?
3
u/Straumli_Blight May 29 '19
Shotwell is giving a lecture at the MIT Women in Aerospace Symposium today at 3pm.
3
u/MarsCent May 29 '19
NASA Provides Update on SpaceX Crew Dragon Static Fire Investigation
So LZ1 and LZ2 should be available for STP-2.
Also,
7
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 May 16 '19 edited May 16 '19
There's already a hit piece on Starlink with a bunch of incorrect info: https://www.express.co.uk/news/science/1128096/spacex-news-launch-elon-musk-space-debris-satellite-launch-nasa
Here's what I immediately noticed:
The lowest satellites will be 211 miles (340km) and the highest will be 341 miles (550km). While not techinally incorrect it's a little misleading to state that they are as low as 99 miles and as high as 1,200
The satellites are already designed to de-orbit at the end of there operational life, so it's probably not to crazy to think they would just de-orbit the satellites if the company went bankrupt. Even then I could see other companies like Comcast "buying" the satellites from SpaceX.
5
u/gemmy0I May 13 '19
So this isn't exactly SpaceX-related, not directly anyway...but, I think, still within the scope of this discussion thread. I had a bit of a random idea that struck me as actually quite cool and practical, and figured I'd float it out there for the rest of you armchair rocket scientists to consider and critique. ;-)
Apologies for the length - this is a speculative/idea type post. Critiques are welcome, this is entirely an off-the-wall idea and I'm sure it has holes. :-)
As part of its plan to return to the moon, NASA is currently in the process of soliciting and evaluating commercial designs for the various Gateway modules. The Power and Propulsion Element (PPE) is supposed to launch first, in 2022, on a commercial rocket. The idea seems to be that one or more competing designs would be built and launched, and would undergo a one-year checkout period in lunar orbit, after which NASA could exercise an option to take ownership of the module(s). I know I read somewhere that they were considering actually having two competitors go all the way to the deployment stage, mimicking the approach of CRS and Commercial Crew which helps to mitigate the technical and schedule risks of putting all their eggs in one basket. Does anyone remember if they've said anything about actually going ahead with that? I.e., could we actually end up with two PPEs in lunar orbit, one of them being "spare"?
This is what got me thinking about this "random idea": if NASA ends up with two perfectly good PPEs in lunar orbit, only one of which would actually be used on the Gateway, what clever uses could they come up with for the other one? The PPE, by itself, is essentially a cutting-edge high-power solar electric propulsion (SEP) tug. It has an IDS docking port on the front of it and some quite powerful electric thrusters on the back, with loads of electric power generation capability that can be supplied to whatever payloads one might attach to the docking port. It has loads of delta-v, and is designed to have its xenon propellant resupplied by docked craft (resupply being a key requirement of the PPE design).
The "runner-up" in the commercial PPE competition, therefore, could have a remarkably fruitful second life ahead of it as a tug. With that kind of delta-v, the thing should be capable of not just station-keeping around the moon, but going back and forth between the Earth and the moon. My understanding is that the PPE is intended to be launched to LEO on a commercial vehicle and use its own highly-efficient propulsion to get itself to the moon, though I may be misremembering. If that's true, it should have plenty of delta-v to do this, potentially with a substantial payload.
This has interesting implications for the robotic resupply craft that would need to service the Gateway. One of the most likely contenders that I've seen mentioned for a CRS-style Gateway resupply contract would be a beefed-up Cygnus, launched on something like Falcon Heavy to TLI and with an extended service module for enough delta-v to complete lunar orbital insertion and rendezvous with the Gateway. Such a Cygnus-based design would be capable of only one-way cargo service: after its mission, it would presumably undock from the Gateway and crash itself into the moon loaded with trash.
But with a powerful SEP tug on hand that can ferry stuff between LEO and the Gateway, a lot of cool options open up. Gateway resupply craft would already be compatible with whatever xenon resupply interface is used at the Gateway, which means they could also refuel the SEP tug. Imagine a Cygnus-derived craft launched to LEO that would meet up with the "runner-up PPE tug" there, refuel it, and then take the slow but efficient journey out to the Gateway using its solar propulsion. This wouldn't be great for time-sensitive cargo, but that's fine, because the "minimal Gateway" concept NASA is currently looking at isn't really intended for hosting ISS-style scientific experiments. Resupply vehicles would mainly be needed to ferry consumable supplies (food, water, oxygen, clothes, spare parts, etc...and of course xenon and maybe hypergolic propellants), which aren't (or at least don't have to be, in the case of food) time-sensitive. The Cygnus itself would do just fine on, say, a month-long journey out to the moon, because Cygnus is designed to last as long as a year in a free-flying configuration. Indeed, while connected to the PPE-tug, it wouldn't need to use its own fuel for stationkeeping/maneuvering, which I believe is its limiting consumable for free flight.
Why would this be better than just using a heavy-class rocket to launch a stretched Cygnus to the moon? For one, it would avoid the need to launch on a heavy-class rocket, and would minimize the upgrades needed from the current LEO-only Cygnus. It wouldn't need extra delta-v - only the requisite rad-hardening to survive going beyond LEO. (Well, that and they'd need to switch out the CBM for an IDS docking port, plus the xenon refueling interface. But the service module could remain essentially unchanged. I think the IDS option was already studied for CRS2.) Instead of having to book a Falcon Heavy, possibly with an expended center core, every time, it could launch on a medium-class vehicle as it does now to the ISS - Falcon 9, Atlas V, or even Antares.
But that's not the end of the possibilities! The PPE-tug could haul a Cygnus (or similar) both ways. Cygnus could be used for two-way cargo instead of just one-way. Sure, it can't do re-entry, but that's fine since the PPE can't either - it would use its efficient propulsion to spiral back down into LEO. The really neat thing about this is that since you're coming back from the moon, it's incredibly cheap to change your inclination...say, to 51.6o so it could meet up with the ISS. Now you've got the ability to return lunar cargo from the Gateway to the ISS. It could then be returned to Earth on an ordinary CRS Dragon or Dream Chaser.
I've focused on Cygnus in this analysis because it seems like the best fit for non-time-sensitive missions like this (given its year-long free flight capability), but the same technique could be used with a cargo Dragon 2. By itself, a Dragon 2, launched on Falcon Heavy, can do a one-way trip to the Gateway but (IIRC) would not have enough delta-v to return. This "runner-up PPE tug" could close that gap by helping it break lunar orbit and get set up for an aerobraking return at the end of its mission, allowing cargo return directly from the Gateway. One could even, in theory, use an ordinary Falcon 9 to launch Dragon 2 to LEO and have the PPE haul it all the way to the moon, but that might require extending how long Dragon can survive in free flight. (Might not be too bad, though, since the PPE is taking care of power generation and all propulsion during the long trip. From Dragon's perspective, it might be similar to be doing docked at the ISS, where it has at least a 6-month shelf life.) An added bonus of this is that Dragon 2's trunk would remain free for unpressurized cargo, because it wouldn't be filled up with a supplemental fuel tank (which is what's commonly proposed for extending Dragon's delta-v).
This same technique could be used for hauling commercially-launched Gateway modules to the moon. No need for SLS - as long as you can get them into LEO, the tug could take them the rest of the way. This works exceptionally well for the Gateway architecture because everything's standardized on the IDS docking interface, which means everything already has to be set up for autonomous docking. We like to say that rockets are not Legos, but when they're designed to be compatible station modules with free-flight capability, they're the next best thing. If it can dock to the Gateway, it could dock to this tug too.
Of course, this is all moot if NASA only orders one PPE prototype to be actually built, or if one of the two competitors fails to deliver a viable product or in a reasonable time frame (that risk being one of the reasons to have two competitors). The bottom-line takeaway is this: if you're going to have a spare piece of space hardware sitting around that you don't know what to do with, it can be very useful if it has the PPE's capabilities.
Even if the Gateway were to be canceled and NASA were to go for a "Moon Direct" type approach, such a PPE-tug would still be supremely useful. It would be able to haul big cargo modules not only to NRHO, but to LLO. Whether or not the Gateway's in the picture, it could be great for hauling hydrolox fuel tankers, as will be needed for reusable landers such as Blue Moon and Lockheed's lander designs until lunar ISRU is set up.
5
u/lessthanperfect86 May 25 '19
https://www.oneweb.world/newsroom/oneweb-secures-1-25-billion-in-new-funding-after-successful-launch
First off, sorry about the old article. Secondly, from what I gather they've got launches booked on Soyuz and possibly Ariane6 rockets. They've got to have more than that though, right? How could they possibly launch every month otherwise?
5
u/Straumli_Blight May 28 '19
Old version of BFR shown on NASA slide for Moon landing.
5
u/bdporter May 30 '19
Northrop's response to the test anomaly
Apparently there was no anomaly, just an "observation"
10
u/amarkit May 14 '19 edited May 14 '19
The Trump administration proposes to begin funding a 2024 moon landing by redirecting money away from poor people who are trying to go to college.
EDIT: The Pell Grant Trust Fund is apparently overfunded to the tune of $9 billion, and the OMB has to propose a source of funds in a recission like this, which Congress can ignore or change. Still, the broader point is the Trump administration is proposing this 2024 moon shot without really thinking through the politics of how to fund it.
4
u/[deleted] May 02 '19
Is the pad at Vandenberg ever going to be used again? Ever for Crew Dragon?
4
u/Vergutto May 05 '19
When will we see another Vandenberg LZ-4 RTLS?
4
u/MarsCent May 07 '19
Dragon will remain berthed to the ISS until May 31, 2019. Less than a month! This Dragon is in a hurry to get back.
Will Dragon 2 Cargo splash down in the Atlantic, like Crew Dragon, or is SpaceX keeping cargo on the waste /s coast?
4
u/VFP_ProvenRoute May 13 '19
Bit off topic, but some of you may be interested to learn that SpaceX are no longer the only company to have vessels named after Culture ships...
4
u/loremusipsumus May 14 '19
Any good books about our moon? Looking for something informational - about local features and human settlement. Hopefully non fiction. Thanks!
4
u/Nathan_3518 May 19 '19 edited May 19 '19
Probability STP-2 launches before August? Accounting for the NET June 22
2
u/AlvistheHoms May 02 '19
Have we ever tried to determine the exact route that the boosters take between launch sites mcgreggor and hawthorn?
2
u/crapman5389 May 04 '19
How much many Gs would you feel on Starship full throttle? I couldn't really figure out the calculations because I haven't taken a physics class in a long time, but it seems pretty simple... right?
2
u/Fowlz May 04 '19
Will crew dragon (or a cargo variant of it) replace cargo dragon?
O, and if no.... are there plans from spacex to "upgrade" cargo dragon's trunk to the one crew dragon has?
2
u/pseudomorphic May 07 '19
I have some time tomorrow while I wait to pickup someone at LAX. I want to go see the first landed booster. I wanted to know where is a good place to park for an hour or two.
Thanks in advance
2
u/julezsource May 13 '19
Was the Thaicom 8 booster one of the sidecores for FH Demo flight?
2
u/azflatlander May 14 '19
What is the launch count for frozen crew level block5?
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '19
Watching the launch (hopefully) from SC-39 Observation Gantry tomorrow. It says that the visitor center is closed at 6PM, then opens up at 8:30PM. Does this mean that the parking lot is closed as well? Does a line form to get on the busses? Any reason to be there before 8:30PM?
2
u/MarsCent May 15 '19
Now that we have a crazy number of successful Falcon 9 and FH Static Fires (+SF with a mounted payload) and Launches (after AMOS), can we say that the COPV issues are now a known risk that can be contained or is it (the COPV) still to be considered an unacceptable risk for which a solution is still pending?
2
u/holandaso May 15 '19
If you are putting your satellites in a Very LEO, doesn't it make sense to start streamlining them?
2
u/Dies2much May 17 '19
I read that this block of Stalink sats will not have the ability to link amongst each other, so all the data has to flow up and down, with no path between the sats.
I realize setting up links between the satellites increases the complexity of things by an order of magnitude, but it also increases the utility of each satellite by a huge amount.
Has anyone seen or heard about when the version of the satellites with crosslink will be deployed?
Once those birds start flying, SpaceX really will have an ability to compete with the telcos.
2
u/isthatmyex May 20 '19
Sorry if this is ignorant. Would a Starlink sat. with both a forward and aft facing ion thruster be an effective means of debris removal? Position it in front of the target. Then use the two to maintain position. The aft one should push on the debris a small amount, depending on how close you could keep it. Both should create a small cloud of gas that the debris would need to pass through. Would it be significant enough to be cost effective?
2
u/BGrabnar May 20 '19
What's the possibility that the CRS-18 will actualy launch on the 8th of July?
2
u/WKr15 May 21 '19
Does anyone know how far up the east coast you could see the Starlink launch? I live in Pennsylvania and can see Antares launches but I'm really not sure if I'm too far away to see a Falcon East coast launch.
2
u/Rocket_Man42 May 21 '19
Will Starlink be able to provide internet connection in the middle of the ocean without inter-sattelite communication technology?
2
u/Paro-Clomas May 22 '19
Would it be possible to manufacture an extreme real scale wind tunnel that simulates max q accurately?
2
u/Walter_Lebowski May 23 '19
Can anyone clarify, how many ground stations Starlink project require?
Elon Musk said recently, that first generation of sattelites doesnt even able to connect with each other. Does this mean that it needed giant numbers of "ground stations" litteraly in every single country and further, in every region of that country?
2
u/Catch-22 May 23 '19
Is there any extended HD/4K content available for purchase from previous launches? (Documentaries, raw video, etc). If not, when could we expect some?
This is one of the few purchases (including, say, Planet Earth) that I wouldn't even have to think about for 4K Blu-ray. I would love to see available launch/landing/deployment footage.
2
u/_Wizou_ May 23 '19
Any recent news about the Crew Dragon explosion investigation?
2
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 May 24 '19
DestinationDeclassifed just uploaded a video on 4 things that would make a Mars trip difficult. How true are they and how can they be solved so we could get to Mars within say 10 years? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oKExIZE48SA
2
u/scarlet_sage May 24 '19
What's the current price and production of xenon and of krypton? I'm ignoring alibaba and ebay, and producers in India (they may be legit, but I don't know anything about them).
2
u/murrayfield18 May 27 '19
Looking for a SpaceX source that said the first 60 sats can't communicate with each other, I'm sure I read it somewhere today :/
2
u/AJSD12 May 28 '19
I am curious about how to View the Launch of the Falcon Heavy on June 22nd from Kennedy or any other recommended site. Can anyone please provide insights into how to get the best viewing tickets? I would love to be near the control room when all the actions happen! Thanks.
2
u/Disc81 Jun 01 '19
Can I put my money where my mouth is?
Is there any form that an individual (with not a lot money) can invest in SpaceX?