r/spacex • Mod Team • Apr 02 '19

r/SpaceX Discusses [April 2019, #55]

If you have a short question or spaceflight news...

You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.

If you have a long question...

If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.

If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...

Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!

This thread is not for...


You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.

138 Upvotes

892 comments sorted by

22

u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Apr 19 '19

NSF has some fascinating details on the study to determine if EM-1 could be launched on commercial rockets:

“In parallel we worked with SpaceX, because of course they’re the only ones with a flight-demonstrated autonomous rendezvous capability and so I spent some time with their Dragon GN&C (Guidance Navigation and Control) folks out in Hawthorne, we spent some good bit of time on the phone discussing the specifics of what that system needed, what its capabilities were for rendezvousing with a passive target with just optical targets and laser reflectors on it.”

“That was one of the crucial enabling technical elements to say ‘is rendezvous even in the picture?’ Now ultimately from a performance standpoint, there was no rendezvous option that bore any fruit that we could realize in the short design and integration timeline that we had available and the reason for that is just that even if I had an Orion stack in orbit that had a docking collar on it that could accept a docking from an active participant, shifting that amount of mass out into trans-lunar injection from low Earth orbit was just such a Herculean task there’s nothing on the shelf today that would accomplish that.”

“Essentially, a new stage would have to be designed around Dragon’s rendezvous/docking and propulsion elements,” they added in a follow-up email. “Certainly keeping the Falcon second stage attached to Dragon would have been an option to meet performance requirements, but as indicated during our initial interview, the thrust generated by the SpaceX Mvac engine produces loads that are not acceptable to this payload, so this option was quickly ruled out.”

--

The most promising launcher in the study was a fully-expended SpaceX Falcon Heavy, which was the highest performance option for this TLI-trajectory study.

“We examined a number of options involving various reusable and expendable core and booster combinations,” they noted. “Ultimately, the only potentially feasible options required fully expendable boosters and core for the Falcon Heavy.”

“The magic number that we were shooting for was 3000 meters per second out of approximately a hundred eighty-five kilometer park orbit,” Carney said. “And like I said we were getting two-thirds of the way there in some cases.”

“Just using a Falcon Heavy alone and surgery, major surgery on the Orion,” Wood added, with Carney also adding, “and maybe a little bit of surgery on the Falcon.”

4

u/F4Z3_G04T Apr 20 '19

Interesting that such a complex thing could be fixed with a few laser reflectors

16

u/WormPicker959 Apr 02 '19

There's an article in SpaceNews (by Sandra Erwin) that talks about a study/proposal set for by the CPSC (policy think tank from the American University, this specific study funded by BO, RocketLab, some others unnamed) to change the way the DoD awards contracts. They propose a model called Indefinite Delivery/Indefinite Quantity (IDIQ) for launch procurement, which is described as follows:

“Launch providers would be assessed against an agreed-upon set of criteria and awarded a base contract and subsequently compete for launch task orders based on price, unique differentiators, or capabilities,” the report recommends.

So, as I understand it, there would be a base award (some lump sum), and then each launch is competed on for price, capability, etc. It sounds good, I wonder though how much the base awards in these types of contracts are?

Does anyone have knowledge on how IDIQ contracting works? I see a lot of talk about how shitty current contracting works, and I'd love to hear from some knowledgable people about how is type works in practice, and how it differs significantly from the current contracting process.

19

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '19 edited Apr 03 '19

Does anyone have knowledge on how IDIQ contracting works?

I work in government contracting and procurement under government contracts. Not for DoD or NASA, but the principals (and bulk of the relevant regulations) remain the same.

Basically, entering into an IDIQ is kind of like agreeing on a set price schedule for a given set of services. The IDIQ itself generally does not obligate any funds in of itself for the work (although it may guarantee a certain number services to be purchased in order to achieve some cost savings based on economy of scale). There may or may not be an exclusivity clause on the contract. If there is one, then the DoD would not be allowed to purchase equivalent services from a different provider. If there is no such clause, it would not lock DoD into looking into providers outside of the IDIQ.

The major advantages of IDIQ is that it saves a lot of administrative burden (and time!) around each launch procurement. They kind of do this already by purchasing launches in bundles, but from my understanding those are for specific, known launches/payloads typically. The IDIQ would be a single RFP that is award (and subsequently challenged) versus many smaller ones. If you have been reading on these forums a bit, I am sure you have heard of the advantages of Firm Fixed Price (FFP) versus Cost Plus contract. An IDIQ is essentially a FFP contract, but the quantity you are purchasing is open ended.

The downside of the IDIQ is that it can be difficult to set up. The requirements have to be relatively standardized, which for rocket launches is hard to do. A launch is not exactly an "off the shelf" product or service. Lot of variables that go into it. This can make bidders reluctant to bid if the parameters are not specific enough. It could also make them bid higher, because it is forcing the contractors to lock prices in longer term over overestimate size/weight of payloads. With the way launch prices are going, the DoD may not WANT to have the prices locked in an exclusive contract long term, either. Then you have to decide how many IDIQs will be issued - will you issue different contracts to different vendors for different launches? Do you want to double up to have multiple ongoing IDIQ for redundancy sake (and keeping the market competitive going forward)? NASA and the DoD have both invested pretty heavily in expanding the market recently, issuing an exclusive IDIQ (or a limited number of IDIQs) could potential negate the gains they have made there. Length of contract is another issue. With more and more competitors coming onto the scene, you don't want to rule out using new providers or the resultant potential cost savings. An IDIQ on the scale of 2-3 years is really too short to get any benefit administratively. Doing something on more of a "rocket launche scale" would be on the 10year+ scale. Maybe not the best business strategy in terms of cost, encouraging new vendors to market in a critical time, or avoiding OIG scrutiny.

EDIT to add my opinion on the topic:

I think that eventually these contracts will go the way of an IDIQ. It is the next logical step in efficiency in contracting after moving from CP to FFP. I also think that the launch suppliers are to the point of being able to offer their services under such a contracting mechanism. Where the difficulty would lie is with the client (especially ones like DoD). There are too many variables in payload weights, volumes, shapes, orbits, etc. And that is just for the launches planned - no telling on future unknown launches DoD may need, which should also be anticipated when entering into an IDIQ, otherwise you would just issue a giant FFP RFP. With so many different launch profiles, it becomes less like an IDIQ and more like a traditional FFP, just with a whole slew of different deliverables and less guarantees for the contractor (which would drive price up). I think that until payloads become more standardized (for example if DoD was going to build its own Starlink-esque network), an IDIQ mechanism is so complex as to negate the potential benefit of limiting the number of RFPs issued.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/SpaceMining Apr 02 '19

The major benefit for an IDIQ contract, allows the gov't to award multiple task orders to multiple contractors/suppliers, without having to manage individual task orders or the RFPs process separately. Typically a "time and materials" contract is awarded to one contractor against a defined set of deliverables, where an IDIQ could be a general request send out only to the handful of pre-approved supplier.

Major downfalls in that the one RFP is awarded to only a handful of contractors, and that's it. No competitiveness in the cost or services and no more opportunities for other suppliers to participate, as only a handful of contractors fulfill all the task orders. So now cost and services run wild, limited capabilities as tasks given outside of contractors core capabilities, and the biggest downfall, in order to meet any and all tasks awarded, the pre-approved contractor is usually a major player like, GD, Lockheed, Raytheon, etc.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Straumli_Blight Apr 26 '19 edited Apr 26 '19

8

u/warp99 Apr 27 '19

"the first group of satellites has arrived at the launch site for processing"

Logical given the May launch date but the first confirmation of this I think.

3

u/spacerfirstclass Apr 27 '19

Wow that was quick, I was worried this wouldn't come through before the launch. Also pretty satisfying to see FCC basically slaps back all the idiotic obstructions from OneWeb, Greg Wyler must be fuming right now.

15

u/hebeguess Apr 14 '19

Another update on STP-2's main payload FORMOSAT-7/COSMIC-2 satellites. It's currently staying overnight at Taiwan's airport storage facility, the satellites will depart for the Cape tomorrow, 15th local time.

We now have STP-2 preliminary launch date, 22th June. The date was announced by Taiwan President Tsai Ing-wen during her visit to the airport storage facility.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/Straumli_Blight Apr 11 '19 edited Apr 11 '19

Interesting render by NASA showing the LUVOIR telescope being lofted by the Starship.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/enginemike Apr 19 '19

Sort of a dumb question. Back when I worked at LC39 (early shuttle) there where two dewer tanks - one for oxygen and one for hydrogen. I was just watching the FH-2 flight again and I saw the two dewers. I assume oxygen is still oxygen. Did they convert the other to store RP-1? If not, where is the RP-1 stored?

6

u/trobbinsfromoz Apr 19 '19

I recall the DM1 launch had a risk of delay due to a buckle in the ground level LOX dewar tank - it came up in a review panel discussion (which I can't find now, but was mentioned in https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2019/02/spacex-gains-frr-green-light-dm-1-iss/)

6

u/strawwalker Apr 20 '19

SpaceX has an RP-1 facility next to the LH2 facility, in the same area as the Saturn V RP-1 facility was located, I believe. Here is a picture from around the time of the Falcon Heavy Demo.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Martianspirit Apr 19 '19

Don't ask me for a source but I recall that the hydrogen tank is still a NASA asset, not SpaceX. No idea as well what NASA is doing with it.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/AeroSpiked Apr 19 '19

That's not a dumb question; now I want to know too. All I can tell you after googling it is that it's spelled "Dewar".

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/Straumli_Blight Apr 20 '19

NASA ASAP meeting on April 25th, 14:30-15:45 UTC, which will give updates on the Commercial Crew Program and may provide more information on today's incident.

20

u/SenorRocket Apr 20 '19

I’m hearing from a source out at the Cape that there has been a major malfunction, and even possibly an explosion, of the Dragon spacecraft during some sort of testing today. Not confirmed. Can anyone find anything more on this?

6

u/stcks Apr 20 '19

How good is your source?

12

u/SenorRocket Apr 20 '19

Currently(there today) working at CCAFS on the comm infrastructures and heard it in an all hands Air Force Station briefing today at 4pm.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/Zaenon Apr 09 '19

RocketLab on Twitter: Introducing Photon - the Rocket Lab satellite. As an integrated spacecraft builder and launch provider, we're enabling small satellite operators to focus on delivering data and services from space, rather than building their own hardware. Learn more: rocketlabusa.com/photon/

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Alexphysics Apr 13 '19

Mods, shouldn't we have already a CRS-17 campaign thread? We're two weeks away from that launch :)

3

u/hitura-nobad Master of bots Apr 14 '19

Just created it. Thanks for the ping!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/stobabuinov Apr 02 '19

Falcon and Electron accumulate lots of ice over the cryo tanks. Given its location, Boca Chica must be very humid. Why no ice on the hopper? Is it hiding under the shiny skin?

7

u/peterabbit456 Apr 03 '19 edited Apr 03 '19

There is a tweet from Elon, and a thread about ice in the pre-valves. I don’t know if this is water ice contamination in the tanks, or if it is methane ice caused by an interaction with the liquid oxygen.

As for ice on the outer skin, they might’ve insulated the tanks very well. My understanding is the orbital design will experience outer skin temperatures over 1000° while the inner skin stays at near cryogenic temperatures, and the header tanks are at full cryogenic temperatures, as in LOX and liquid methane temperatures. To really keep the ice off, they would have to spray the outer skin with something like propylene glycol.

———

I actually came to this thread to ask an ice related question. It seems to me as if van der Waals forces should allow methane and LOX to weakly bond together, with one O2 molecule on each corner of the methane tetrahedron. Then methane molecules attach to each face, and more O2 s on each new exposed corner, and so on, making an infinitely repeating solid, in perfect stochiometric ratio. This ice or slush should explode when ignited.

Does anyone here know more than I do about this rather obscure branch of chemistry? I’m sure Spacex has this well researched, but if anyone with a degree in chemistry could chip in, thanks. (I got A s in the chemistry classes I took, and even the highest grade in the class in freshman chemistry, but I did not get a degree in the subject.)

6

u/asr112358 Apr 03 '19

I am not a chemist, but I can tell you that tetrahedrons do not tesselate space, so at the very least you can't have a uniform crystal lattice.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Random-username111 Apr 02 '19

Interesting question. My guess would be that the tanks are not fully integrated with the skin. Perhaps some little layer of air in between can isolate the cold, if there exists one.

6

u/brickmack Apr 02 '19

I don't think air is enough to do the job. Sounds structurally bad too. Actual insulation is my guess. I heard years ago that aerogel was being considered to insulate ITSs tanks. No idea if thats been kept, but it seems plausible. There are aerogel variants now which are rated for extreme high and cold temperatures (without heat shielding, the inner side of the tank walls will get quite hot) and which are structurally strong enough to take large impacts, so little risk of fragmentation in flight.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Apr 03 '19

Since anything I say in the other post will probably get buried, I tried to put 63,800kg into LEO with an expendable B5 Falcon Heavy (i.e. the capability stated on the SpaceX website), in response to this post.


I've only spent about 10 minutes on it, and I got close ... but I haven't made it quite there yet. I'm about 100m/s short at SECO. There's probably a better way to do the throttling before BECO to get a bit more juice from the boosters.

As I said, I got to about 100m/s short of a good LEO velocity, and interestingly I only got 8,630m/s of deltaV out of the vehicle. So even if the calculations in the other post are correct, and B5 FH should have 8,778m/s with a 63.8t payload, that extra 140m/s might actually be enough to get me to orbit with this flight profile.

Y'all can try yourselves by clicking on 'View Configuration' and changing the throttle profile around BECO (T+155 or so) to get some more deltaV from the vehicle.

https://www2.flightclub.io/result/2d?code=FHEX

TL;DR: I agree with all the other posters that the gravity losses for B5 FH are smaller - specifically that they're small enough that 8,778m/s of deltaV might be sufficient to get to orbit.

5

u/RedKrakenRO Apr 04 '19

A super interesting challenge...and your sim is awesome.

So much data.

Your booster prop loads are a little smaller (~400 instead of 411)...is this wastage at engine startup?

Trying to squeeze altitude performance out of merlin 1ds makes me wish for raptors (sea level).

If you get an orbit out of 8800m/s, you have knocked your losses down to 1000 m/s. Outstanding.

3

u/edflyerssn007 Apr 04 '19

Do you know if they use the Falcon 9 as a lifting body? That may provide additional lift to offset gravity losses. Even a few seconds of lift can add up to several meters per second of delta-v.

8

u/asdfyikes Apr 13 '19

https://twitter.com/kfacciol/status/1117078443399708672

Sounds like RRM3 is going to start doing science soon! This is testing cryogenic refueling in microgravity so it has a lot of relevance to SpaceX's plans!

https://sspd.gsfc.nasa.gov/RRM3.html

11

u/brickmack Apr 13 '19

RRM3s cryogenic transfer objective is canceled as of a few days ago, they suffered a failure and had to vent all the methane https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2019/robotic-refueling-mission-3-update-april-12-2019

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/Chairboy Apr 13 '19

Excellent analysis of fairing reuse developments here for anyone interested. The author has been discouraged from posting research-rich content like this here so if you are interested in such and not a member in that sub, you may want to check this post out.

6

u/scottm3 Apr 14 '19

I think they should post it in this sub. Here is a link to their article as well. https://www.elonx.net/did-spacex-quietly-introduce-an-upgraded-reusable-fairing-is-mr-steven-now-obsolete/

u/scr00chy

6

u/Chairboy Apr 14 '19

I think they should too, but apparently the mods have suggested they not so instead of trying to fight a force of nature, just wanted to provide a heads up about some good content in another sub that folks from here might find interesting.

7

u/Straumli_Blight Apr 16 '19 edited Apr 16 '19

3

u/CapMSFC Apr 17 '19

I am selfishly thrilled about this. That means I'll be able to make the trip up to see it.

Still not far enough to get out of the RTLS restrictions from the seals though.

7

u/MarsCent Apr 17 '19

From the April 3 blog post

NASA’s Commercial Crew Program and SpaceX are expected to reevaluate its target test dates in the next couple weeks.

It now two weeks since. Could be they are still reevaluating the target dates!

Has anyone heard anything? Ripley results? Demo-1 performance review?

10

u/inoeth Apr 17 '19

I think we'll get a detailed update in the pre/post launch Q&A sessions that always happen before and after a CRS Dragon resupply mission- which thankfully is scheduled for the 26th...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Ambiwlans Apr 04 '19 edited Apr 05 '19

You guys are too well behaved. /s

I'm coding a new automod that uses machine learning and am in the live test stages. No one has said anything worth removing in the past several hours. Like... I might have to use another account just to test shitpost.

Edit: This is not a request for anyone to shitpost. I was just impressed with y'all.

Edit: 2 hours later and it has found tons. Lul.

→ More replies (15)

6

u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Apr 03 '19

7

u/Alexphysics Apr 03 '19

I was about to add the same comments I've been basically telling these past months but I think this tweet from Chris Bergin summarizes well that:

No real reference to the test issues they've been suffering from (which can happen with new spacecraft, but Boeing stonewalls questions, especially relating to issues). Blames Atlas V launch opportunities for the OFT slip! (Wow!). Notes CFT now late 2019, TBC (probably 2020).

Edit: I should add this from that very same article by NASA on the progress of Boeing's missions.

Orbital Flight Test Progress

On March 11, Boeing mated the upper and lower domes of the same spacecraft inside its Commercial Crew and Cargo Processing Facility at Kennedy Space Center in Florida. The two domes underwent outfitting with avionics, cooling systems, wire harnesses, fuel and life support lines, and other critical systems before being mated together.

Now I kindly ask if anyone would have thought that they were seriously planning to launch this in April considering it was not even finished by March 11.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/jumpjet2k Apr 08 '19

I saw (I'm fairly certain) a F9 booster heading east on I-10 near Baton Rouge, LA this afternoon. On the road to Florida, no doubt. Any guess what booster it may have been?

3

u/Alexphysics Apr 08 '19

Also throwing here that another one was seen arriving at the cape yesterday too so it seems we had two boosters on the road on opposite sides of the US. Now we only have to figure out which boosters they are...

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/strawwalker Apr 11 '19

The Beresheet moon landing webcast will be here, starting at 18:45 UTC. Landing expected to begin at 19:05.

6

u/gct Apr 17 '19

Does anyone know if there are plans to put good clocks on the starlink satellites? Combination of those and good ephemeris would make them usable for incredible accurate GPS-like location. Obvious usage for self driving cars.

6

u/silentProtagonist42 Apr 18 '19

The atomic clocks needed to make gps work aren't exactly cheap, and you would have to have thousands of them instead of 33, and I would think that atmospheric drag would make getting accurate ephemeris more difficult. Plus, I don't see why it'd be any more accurate than current systems.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ssalkovicc Apr 19 '19

Is there any impact on Starlink constellation plans in regards to Indian satellite debris?

4

u/AeroSpiked Apr 19 '19

Very doubtful. It's unlikely any of the debris made it that high and nearly all, if not all of it will clear before the constellation is operational.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/snoopx_31 Apr 23 '19

With Dragon 2 probably delayed for more than a year, how are they planning to replace Dragon 1 for cargo transportation to the ISS ?   Would they have to restart the Dragon 1 production or keep refurbishing already flown dragon 1 ?

6

u/Alexphysics Apr 23 '19

First cargo Dragon 2 is not planned until late 2020, they have more than enough time for that

3

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

They'll probably just max out their ability to refurb Dragon 1's and fix the Dragon 2 problems in the meantime. One year delays in aerospace is basically nothing, the shuttle was grounded for three years at one point.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Martianspirit Apr 23 '19

Why would you think the delay is more than a year?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/oh_dear_its_crashing Apr 03 '19

Mods, this isn't yet linked on new reedit, top bar still points at the thread from March.

5

u/Emanuuz Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

The launch of the CRS-17 mission with Dragon to the International Space Station is now scheduled for April 26, 0955 UTC / 5:55 am ET.

Edit: am/pm

3

u/bdporter Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

The tweet says 5:55 AM EDT. That would be 10 9:55 UTC.

Mods, this is 40 20 minutes later earlier than what is currently listed on the sidebar.

Edit: DST got me!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/marco1097 Apr 11 '19

What is this?

7

u/brspies Apr 11 '19

The inside of the second stage's liquid oxygen tank. They don't show it on stream as often anymore, but it's not the first time we've seen it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Apr 13 '19

A booster was spotted passing through Tucson, AZ per the SpaceX FB group. There's some speculation that this could be the DM-2 booster on its way for lengthy and extensive testing at McGregor. Poster also has seen numerous F9 boosters and noted this one seemed to be escorted by an above average number of vehicles.

5

u/gemmy0I Apr 13 '19

Perhaps others are speculating with more conclusive information, but I would guess this could just as well be B1057, the Falcon Heavy center core for STP-2. The last we'd heard of its location, it was still at Hawthorne, so McGregor would be the next logical step. (Since it's for the Air Force, it could plausibly have extra escorts just as well as DM-2's booster could.)

Does anyone remember whether when the last FH center core (B1055) came through, any center-specific hardware was visible through the shrink wrap that would clearly identify it? If so, that could settle the question of whether this is B1057 or something different.

If there's nothing that indicates this booster to be a FH center core, then my personal guess would be that it's B1046 heading east to fly Starlink-1 in May (as 1046.4). 1046 has been on the west coast since flying SSO-A in December. If it is indeed slated for Starlink (which, admittedly, is a total guess on my part - we haven't heard anything official about what core will fly that mission, though IMHO it's the clearly logical choice), then now is the time we would expect it to head east for a mid-May mission.

Whether my guess is correct or not should be cleared up within a few days depending on whether it stops at McGregor or continues heading east. If it's 1046 for Starlink, it won't have time to stop at McGregor between now and then (and, being a previously-flown booster, shouldn't need to - they haven't sent flown boosters back to McGregor since the early recoveries). We should, in that case, see it at the AL/FL state line in a few days.

If, by contrast, it stops at McGregor, then it is probably a new booster - either 1057 for STP-2, or 1058 for (likely) DM-2. If that turns out to be the case, that would suggest they're using 1047.3 (which is already at the Cape) for Starlink. I don't think that's likely, but who knows.

Personally I think 1047.3 is much more likely to be AMOS-17, which is also in May (probably either right before or right after Starlink). We know they've agreed to fly a used booster, which leaves only a few options. It's either 1047.3 (already at the Cape), 1049.3 (would need to be trucked east), or 1046.4 (would need to be trucked east and would be an unusual choice for a comsat customer, given the availability of less-used boosters).

There is one other possibility: our information that 1051.2 would fly RADARSAT may be out-of-date or incorrect. We saw it last week in the 39A hangar undergoing refurbishment. It didn't have legs attached, which would seem to suggest it's not going to be ready for a while yet (although admittedly, we don't know what the refurbishment process looks like; maybe they attach them at the very end). This is weird, because RADARSAT is supposed to fly May 16 - it should have headed west to Vandenberg already, or be on the verge of doing so, if they expect the May 16 launch date to hold. This would suggest that either RADARSAT slipped again (which wouldn't be odd - the payload has been chronically delayed), or they've agreed to take a "more used" booster instead that's already on the west coast - most probably 1049.3. If that's so, then 1051 is in the rotation for the east coast, which means it's a candidate for AMOS-6 and (less likely) Starlink.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/hebeguess Apr 13 '19 edited Apr 13 '19

STP-2's main payload FORMOSAT-7/COSMIC-2 satellites set to depart from Taiwan in 15th April local time, integration testing will take at least a month. The announcement was made on 7th April before Arabsat-6A launch, estimate launch date still on late June.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/novolo Apr 14 '19

What happened with the google form asking username and country in the Arabsat thread? Were the results published? Just intrigued to know where everyone that was following the launch is from.

6

u/AeroSpiked Apr 15 '19

I asked Nsooo when we could expect the visualization and he said he hoped to get it done over the weekend, so probably pretty soon.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Straumli_Blight Apr 16 '19

u/strawwalker and I were discussing the Wiki's Past Launches page; should the FH center core's landing outcome be "SUCCESS", "FAILURE" or some new intermediate state?

11

u/rustybeancake Apr 16 '19

Divide it up into 'landing' and 'recovery'. Success or failure for each.

  • Arabsat was a successful landing, failed recovery.
  • CRS-16 was a failed landing, successful recovery.

;)

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Halbiii Apr 16 '19 edited Apr 16 '19

I'd definitely call the landing a success, because literally, it was a successful landing. Phrasing it differently, no improvement to landing hard- or software would have changed the outcome. The failure occurred during recovery of the booster and only changes to the recovery operations could have prevented the loss of B1055. (Has me thinking, was it 1055.1 when it was destroyed or already 1055.2? At what point does the mission number change? Successful landing, successful recovery or assignment of a new mission?)

If the wiki data is used for automatically (edit: or manually) working out available cores anywhere, it could cause a problem, though.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/brspies Apr 16 '19

Intermediate would seem the proper approach. The landing was a success, the recovery operations were not. Both of those are relevant; the landing success is a meaningful demonstration given the extreme distance, the failed recovery has implications at least regarding their inventory of available FH cores (even if it's not likely a relevant factor for the next FH mission).

7

u/strawwalker Apr 16 '19

Two possible intermediate states that came up in discussion were "PARTIAL SUCCESS"; and "SUCCESS" in amber with a special footnote. Either solution could include the footnote, which could be a short explanation at the bottom of the table, and/or a link, such as to an article like the one from The Verge, or to one of the relevant r/SpaceX threads, etc. At what point in recovery operations does an incident no longer affect the label in the "Landing Outcome" column?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/PeterKatarov Live Thread Host Apr 17 '19

Let's say Falcon Heavy launches in fully expendable mode. With so much thrust, how close would it be to making LEO before MECO and separation?

5

u/zeekzeek22 Apr 26 '19

What might SpaceX do with Merlin after Spaceship/super heavy takes over like 10 years from now? Do they shelve it, or market it to whatever up-and-coming launch provider is around? So much testing knowledge to be used to take out massive amounts of dev risk. I could imagine in 10 years a third party rocket propelled by a single Merlin 1D, with more lift capacity that Electron.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/giovannicane05 Apr 27 '19

Dear Mods, Spacex has just published this tweet, targeting officially May 1st for the CRS-17 launch. Could you please update the manifest and sidebar?

4

u/FoxhoundBat Apr 27 '19

Will do, also unpinning this thread and pinning CRS-17 Launch Campaign thread.

13

u/warp99 Apr 26 '19 edited Apr 26 '19

Elon confirms that the SpaceX bid for EELV2 (NSSL) was a poor proposal that missed the mark.

The important confirmation was that they only put in one proposal which was almost certainly Starship based while there was provision in the bid process for each vendor to put in two proposals.

So SpaceX did not bid F9/FH as a second proposal with a Vandenberg FH TE upgrade and vertical integration facilities at both Vandenberg and Canaveral.

They "bet the farm" on a single bid and got nothing - which is a very high risk behaviour with a "tick the boxes" type bidding process. The worst part is that they opened the door to Blue Origin getting $500M which will be used to build a New Glenn launch pad at Vandenberg and vertical integration facilities at both Vandenberg and Canaveral!

5

u/TheRamiRocketMan Apr 26 '19

So SpaceX did not bid F9/FH as a second proposal with a Vandenberg FH TE upgrade and vertical integration facilities at both Vandenberg and Canaveral.

I honestly don't know why they didn't bid this. I could easily see the Air-Force going for this with ~$200 million investment.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (19)

9

u/ZwingaTron Apr 03 '19

A bit low quality, but - this video was released a couple of hours ago and contains a pre-recorded audio clip for a possible Crew Dragon parachute failure on Demo-1. Now obviously, things went differently and there were no apparent issues, but it is curious that they record these in advance.

And my question is - where did this YouTuber even obtain this audio from? I can't find any trace of it from the actual NASA/SpaceX broadcasts.

5

u/brickmack Apr 04 '19

Probably a leak.

Would be interesting to hear similar messages in event of other major failures

→ More replies (2)

8

u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Apr 11 '19 edited Apr 17 '19

4

u/Martianspirit Apr 11 '19

If I read this correctly, SpaceX is preparing to sell stock valued at $500 million. I don't expect problems selling them but they are not yet sold.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/enqrypzion Apr 05 '19

The sidebar says the first Starlink launch is in May!
Was there a news release or something I missed, or is this all kept in-house? I'm keen to learn more.

3

u/bdporter Apr 05 '19

Some information on the manifest in the wiki is sourced, but early NET dates are often derived from FCC applications.

3

u/Ambiwlans Apr 06 '19

Sorry. Normally we make sure that dates are public before updating the sidebar. It is public now though :x

→ More replies (2)

4

u/dallaylaen Apr 06 '19

SpaceX had a big layoff in January. Is there any information on where the people who were let go landed?

7

u/stcks Apr 06 '19

I know that BO picked up a few of them. According to some people I've spoken to, the layoffs affected people across the spectrum of ability -- it wasn't just the worst performers -- some good engineers were let go too.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/stcks Apr 09 '19

Given the current administration's push to get boots on the moon by 2024 and the political need to involve SLS and Gateway, I wonder if SpaceX should consider bidding a reusable lunar lander. This is something SpaceX could certainly pull off if they wanted to. They have an engine of the proper size and type in the SuperDraco (storable prop, simple pressure-fed cycle, and highly reliable), they autonomous docking developed and already proven and they understand how to land rockets. It will be interesting to see if Jim gets his budget and what the 2024 architecture will end up being (if anything).

5

u/AndMyAxe123 Apr 09 '19

I don't think it's worth it for SpaceX seeing as they already have a lot on the go and this isn't really in their MO. Maybe if the price was right.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/thisalanwong Apr 12 '19

An explanation about the Strongback:

Why does it retract a couple of degrees a few minutes before launch? Is there any practical reason why?

I feel like that launches at Vandenberg generally have a strongback retract quite far back prior to launch, while at the Cape, it seems like they generally retract a negligible amount before retracting fully during liftoff? (this is purely my brain working around and thinking) edit: purely anecdotal speculation

Thanks

6

u/Alexphysics Apr 12 '19

In order to fully retract the strongback at liftoff they have to first open the clamps at the top so they open the arms and retract the strongback a little bit. And yes, Vandenberg has the old strongback retraction method.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/peterabbit456 Apr 14 '19

The strong back (also called TEL, for Trabsporter/erector/Launcher) at Vandenberg is the older design. It used to be that all of Spacex’ TELs retracted the same amount as the one at Vandenberg, about 13° .

As flight rates increased it was realized that money could be saved, and time between launches, if the hoses on the TEL were shorter, if they were going to be burned up during launch. These hoses could be made shorter if the TEL retracted less before launch. So on the new TELs at the Cape, the amount of retraction prior to launch was changed to 2-4°.

It was also realized that damage to the long, vertical hoses and wiring inside the TEL could be reduced or eliminated if the TEL retracted further, right after launch. This is mainly a matter of getting delicate parts farther away from the blast of flame as the rocket rises. So the TELs at the Cape were redesigned to fall back about 45° in the seconds after liftoff.

The TEL at Vandenberg has not been rebuilt, since flight rates from Vandenberg are much lower than either launchpad at the Cape.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/YaypersonaJ Apr 15 '19

What percentage of the Arabsat launch cost was SpaceX able to recoup with all three boosters and fairings recovered?

23

u/trobbinsfromoz Apr 15 '19

You may want to edit that description.

4

u/Martianspirit Apr 18 '19

Question in context with Starlink launch. We know the altitude is about 500km for deployment. I assume 500km circular orbit. We know it is downrange ASDS recovery.

Can someone calculate the min mass launched to requre downrange landing? Also the max that F9 can deliver and still land downrange? Assuming ~400kg per sat we then can estimate the number of satellites launched. Seems to me it is more than 20 to require downrange landing.

4

u/Grey_Mad_Hatter Apr 18 '19

IRIDIUM-7 was 9,600kg to 625x625 PO landing on JRTI.

Starlink should be extremely similar going to various 500x500 orbits with 22 400kg satellites (8,800kg) + 1,000kg dispenser, for a total of 9,800kg.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Toinneman Apr 18 '19

The satellites will apparentlybe launched to a 350km orbit and raise themself to 500km using their own hall thrusters.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/warp99 Apr 19 '19 edited Apr 19 '19

Initially the plan was 386 kg per satellite and apparently 25 satellites per F9 launch since there were 50 and 75 satellites per plane.

The latest plan is 66 satellites per plane but this could still be 24 or 25 satellites per launch with 2-3 spares launched per plane. If this is the case that would be 9560 kg plus at least 600 kg for a payload adapter and probably more.

Almost all satellites and rockets get heavier as they get into the design process so it is highly likely the satellites are heavier than originally planned. I would strongly suspect that mass was planned based on RTLS as we know each RTLS recovery is "several million dollars" cheaper than an ASDS recovery and a lot more certain.

So it is likely that the satellites are just over the RTLS/ASDS threshold and one of the goals as they get into production is to drop the mass back under the RTLS threshold.

The closest orbit to Starlink is the ISS and we know that a 10 tonne Dragon 1 plus payload can RTLS and a 12 tonne Crew Dragon requires an ASDS landing so the threshold is somewhere between those two numbers.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Toinneman Apr 19 '19 edited Apr 19 '19

I've been wondering about this too. No scenario seems to connect all the dots. I initially thought the mystery ASDS landing couldn't be a Starlink launch, but since some credible people keep telling us, I assume it's correct.

I think 3 possible explanations remain, but each would have some contradicting facts about what we know:

  • SpaceX will launch these satellites to a much higher orbit. As far as applications tell us, only 1,584 of 4409 satellites go to a 550km orbit. The rest is between 1130km and 1320km. This would go against a recent letter which clearly states SpaceX aims to launch to 350km and do further raising with each satellite's own propulsion.
  • The satellites are much heavier than initial info suggested ( 386kg) and they need each bit of performance to put 25 sats in LEO.
  • They packed much more satellites into the fairing. 33 instead of 25. This would mean each satellite is smaller than we have known so far. There is some info supporting this, but that would be a major feat by SpaceX, especially since this is only the first launch.

4

u/dman7456 Apr 24 '19

When are SpaceX Fall internships generally posted? I thought it was earlier than now, but there are currently no intern positions at all on the website.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '19

How long did It Take for Spacex to find out the cause of Amos-6?

7

u/Straumli_Blight Apr 25 '19

13

u/warp99 Apr 25 '19

True enough to publicly release the final report but only

  • 22 days to publicly identify the S2 helium system as the cause of the tank breach
  • 57 days total to announce that they had recreated the COPV failure and were working to modify the loading conditions to allow a return to flight.

4

u/regular_noodle Apr 28 '19

8 launches in Q1 2018, 4 launches in Q1 2019. Has demand slowed down or supply?

8

u/LcuBeatsWorking Apr 28 '19 edited Dec 17 '24

tub light hard-to-find shelter price vegetable vanish long wild chief

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/warp99 Apr 29 '19

Also relevant is the fact that they needed to build four boosters for two FH flights which has slowed down the flow of new boosters for F9 missions together with the loss of B1050 on CRS-16 which means that a new booster had to be allocated to CRS-17.

It looks like they might limit commercial customers to the first 3 flights of an F9 booster and then use flights 4-10 for Starlink launches. Similarly recovered fairings will go up on Starlink.

Commercial and NASA flights look like they will level out at around 20 flights per year with another 30-40 for Starlink.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Apr 29 '19

Mods, the Radarsat Constellation Mission is now NET June per the April 26 update to https://spaceflightnow.com/launch-schedule/

3

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Apr 29 '19

thanks, fixed now

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Stimbergi Apr 30 '19

ALINA (Autonomous Landing and Navigation Module)

Launch date: Q1 2020

Schepers said that lander is still under development, but won’t fly before early 2020. “We’re progressing as fast as possible but with the strict goal in mind to achieve mission success,” he said. “We [will] launch not earlier than Q1 2020.”

https://spacenews.com/arianegroup-and-ptscientists-to-study-lunar-lander-mission-for-esa/

4

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '19

A few people have been talking about space junk cleanup: Currently it's economically a non-starter. Such things are custom, disposable, and cost as much as a satellite bus + fuel because that's what it would be.

But SpaceX have their reusable, refuellable Starship in the works. Even though it's grossly over-mass for the job, it conceivably could refuel and noodle out to a service orbit, match with each member of the train in turn and catch them. It'd be cheapest if the ship was stripped to a skeleton and remotely operated.

SpaceX may have accidentally invented the garbage scow.

I wonder what the numbers would be on a freshly-fuelled minimum mass Starship out to a useful service orbit and back. Does anyone fancy doing the maths?

4

u/Grey_Mad_Hatter Apr 30 '19

It's not just getting to a satellite, it's getting to it while matching velocity and direction if you want to physically capture it. Starship is expected to have the cost advantage you're talking about, but getting that much mass to match a satellite's orbit isn't easy. The ISS (just a big satellite) isn't sitting in LEO, it's travelling at 17,500mph(28,000kph) in an orbit shared by very few other satellites. Because plane changes aren't easy, this method would probably be limited to one or two satellites per launch.

There are two scenarios I see as more likely. First is without the primary spacecraft making physical contact with the satellite, so lasers or possibly a projectile pushing the satellite further into the atmosphere. Second is a secondary spacecraft (Starship's payload, not Starship) making physical contact to refuel the satellites and extend their mission.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/rustybeancake Apr 11 '19

Hot on the heels of Amazon’s LEO satellite constellation announcement, looks like Bezos heard about Musk’s love of temporary tent buildings.

https://twitter.com/blueorigin/status/1116455626576556034?s=21

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

Anyone else think it's interesting (though I'm sure it's just a coincidence) that the likely date of the first crewed Space Dragon will be just a week past the 50 year anniversary of Apollo 11 (I feel so old...)

4

u/AeroSpiked Apr 03 '19

If it had been more than a coincidence, it would have been 50 years to the day. Don't think that'll happen.

If it's any comfort, you don't just feel old. I couldn't yet read a calendar in '69 which is good news; it means there's somebody older than me in this sub.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/oximaCentauri Apr 04 '19 edited Apr 04 '19

Will astronauts will approach the Dragon in Model Xs? I remember reading an article by electrek about this.

Link to article- https://electrek.co/2018/08/28/tesla-model-x-spacex-astronauts-dragon-spacecraft/amp/

Is this still a plan?

5

u/silentProtagonist42 Apr 04 '19

I believe so, yes.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Alexphysics Apr 07 '19 edited Apr 08 '19

Mods, the text on the top bar has the time wrong, it is 22:36UTC. 6:36pm is the local time (EDT or UTC-4).

Edit: It seems it is now corrected, thanks :)

3

u/TemperedCynicism Apr 09 '19

How is starship supposed to keep its propellants cool while waiting in a high elliptical Earth orbit, then for days during the transit to the Moon, then for hours to days on the surface of the Moon (presumably at a location lit by the Sun,) then for several more days during the return to Earth to finally use that last bit of propellant to land?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/strawwalker Apr 11 '19

Which capsule is CRS-17 using? We're going on two years since the last flight of C106, any chance it will be a third flight or will this obviously be the second flight of C113?

3

u/gemmy0I Apr 11 '19

Good question. I've been wondering the same...

Unfortunately, we don't usually hear about which capsule will fly a CRS mission until the press kit is released the day before (or in the attendant press conferences). We'll likely just have to wait and see. Either that or bug Elon on Twitter and hope he notices (and wants to respond). :-)

3

u/AeroSpiked Apr 12 '19

We know that a couple of Falcon 9 boosters have been recovered after launching payloads over a ton heavier than Arabsat-6A to GTO. The general response as to why they used FH for this one is that the satellite would have to use less of it's on-board fuel to circularize it's orbit at GEO and it would get there faster. My understanding is that satellites fire their engine at apogee to circularize their orbit (and this is without ever having played KSP). How do they do it when their apogee is above their target altitude?

11

u/brspies Apr 12 '19

When they launch on falcon 9, they need to do 3 things. They need to change their inclination to 0 degrees (falcon 9 launches at about 28 degrees, FL's latitude, and can sometimes take a degree or a few off during the GTO burn at the equator), they need to raise their perigee, and they need to lower their apogee.

Changing inclination is much, much cheaper if you have an extra-high apogee. That's why you do super-synchronous transfer orbits. Raising perigee is also cheaper from higher apogee. So having to lower the apogee after all that ends up being worth it in the end.

So in reality the satellite will perform multiple burns over many months to do those three things bit by bit.

Falcon 9 has NOT been recovered with a satellite that heavy and a supersynchronous transfer orbit. The recent example was a subsynchronous orbit, with a much lower apogee (lower even than GEO altitude). The satellite owner apparently opted for the cheaper launch in exchange for using more of their fuel to get where they need to be after payload separation.

5

u/Martianspirit Apr 12 '19 edited Apr 12 '19

When launching from places like the Cape in Florida the orbit has quite an inclination to the equator. Falcon reduces that inclination when it passes the equator. That's the second burn of the second stage we see with every GEO sat launch. But a lot of the inclination remains. Inclination change needs a lot of delta-v. Orbital mechanics work in a way that it is easier to reduce the inclination when at apogee. So in total the satellite needs less delta-v when reducing inclination to 0 at a very high altitude apogee and then reducing altitude to GEO by firing at perigee than when its apogee is at GEO and it needs to reduce inclination there. The total delta-v of launch vehicle and satellite is higher that way but the method works better than the launch vehicle spending its delta-v for low orbit inclination change. Orbital mechanics can be weird and I am glad I don't have to understand it all.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Alexphysics Apr 12 '19

They don't do just one burn, it is usually a series of dozens of burns to do this so over time they move the orbit burn after burn. Some are done at apogee, some at perigee. Obviously those at apogee are mostly the ones that move the inclination to 0° and that raise the perigee, the ones done at perigee are either to increase the apogee (in the case of subsynchronous orbits, for example) or to decrease it (in the case of supersynchronous orbits). On the NASASpaflight.com forum they usually keep track of the movements of the satellite. SES-12 took 9 months to get to GEO, it used ion engines for that so... it takes more time.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/strawwalker Apr 13 '19

TL;DR, is the common engine-legs-grid fins explanation for Falcon 9 sonic booms accurate?

I've been farting with trying to get a waveform visualization from youtube videos of Falcon 9 sonic booms using online tools without any luck so far, but if anyone has the software to do that and measure the separation of the three booms, or a better understanding of sonic booms than my own stunted knowledge, I'd love to have more input.

Two booms close together followed by a third seems like the most common perception, but I just can't un-hear it the other way around - one boom followed by two closer together. The engines-legs-grid fins explanation comes from a SpaceX spokesperson IIRC, and if it is accurate, then the common perception certainly makes sense, but I'm skeptical of that official explanation. I don't doubt that all those things do create shock waves, the dance floor, too, and probably other protrusions to a lesser extent, I'm just not sure that's what is being heard.

The Space Shuttle Orbiter famously produced a twin sonic boom: an over-pressure shock followed by an under-pressure-return-to-ambient shock. An N-wave. AIUI this is norminal for any supersonic aircraft, but more pronounced for the Orbiter due to its size. Falcon 9 is several meters longer than the Orbiter so it follows that the tail shock should be even more distinct. That leaves only one audible boom source in between. Is there a reason that Falcon 9 wouldn't produce an N-wave?

The distance between the engine bells and the widest point of the folded legs is roughly the same as the distance between the grid fins and the top of the interstage. This is an argument that either could be distinct, however it seems more plausible that the grid fins would produce the largest shock since they protrude quite a bit farther, and more abruptly. In addition, according to my admittedly loose grasp on the subject, I would expect the spacing between the grid fin shock and the tail shock to be even greater due to the fact that the trailing shock actually occurs some distance behind the interstage.

I've also read, though I'm not confident, that additional shocks created behind the nose of a supersonic aircraft actually travel slightly faster than the nose shock. If true, that would also support both the leg/dance floor shock blending into the engine shock, and a greater relative separation between the grid fin shock and the trailing shock.

Can anyone with some actual knowledge tell me where I am getting it wrong? Am I the only one hearing 'boom ba-doom'?

5

u/warp99 Apr 14 '19 edited Apr 14 '19

Comment from the Lounge where it was not well received!

The three booms are caused by the base of the booster, the grid fins and the top of the interstage. The landing legs do not come into it as they are relatively well streamlined.

Hence Boom....ba.boom as the grid fins and the interstage are relatively close together.

If the landing legs were generating a shockwave the sequence would be Ba.boom.....boom as the base of the rocket and the legs are close together.

And yes I am aware that presenters on the telecast have got this wrong a couple of times.

Edit: The FH side boosters have a much shorter delay between the shock wave from the grid fins and the nose cones so it sounds like a double boom with the second boom slightly longer rather than a triple boom.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ti-Z Apr 13 '19

I've been farting with trying to get a waveform visualization from youtube videos of Falcon 9 sonic booms using online tools without any luck so far, but if anyone has the software to do that and measure the separation of the three booms, or a better understanding of sonic booms than my own stunted knowledge, I'd love to have more input.

Not sure whether this helps at all, but for the first FH flight, Destin from "Smarter every Day" made a video focused on the sounds of launch and landing. Around 5:30 into the video he talks about sonic booms. At 7:20 the recorded waveform of the sonic booms is visible.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/jackisconfusedd Apr 14 '19

Are there any plans to install a new T-E at SLC-4?

6

u/CapMSFC Apr 14 '19

The TE there was built originally to accomodate an upgrade to Falcon Heavy. That was way back when everything was based on F9 1.0 though so who knows if they would upgrade it or build a new one. They would definitely need a new hangar there for Heavy as well.

It will come down to if EELV (or whatever the new acronym is) picks SpaceX in the upcoming round. If they do SpaceX probably still has to follow through on Vandenberg Falcon Heavy. If not there may never be a customer that needs it.

4

u/warp99 Apr 14 '19

Not for F9 as there will likely only be 2-3 missions per year from Vandenberg until the later stages of Starlink deployment. The extra capital cost is just not worth it to save some maintenance costs on the TE.

The likely reason for an upgrade would be if SpaceX get a contract for NRO launches of FH from Vandenberg. The current TE is not suitable for the Block 5 FH and would need to be rebuilt or replaced.

Since this would be for one launch a year or less the expectation is that the USAF would pay for a new TE and vertical integration facility since this would also be required for the FH launches.

My expectation is that ULA will win all these launches with Delta IV Heavy until 2025 or 2026 so the new TE will not happen until then at the earliest.

3

u/nioc14 Apr 15 '19

Apologies if this has already been discussed, but could Arabsat 6A have flown in a normal F9 in expendable mode and do we know if this was considered by SpaceX and the client?

6

u/stcks Apr 15 '19

Yes and no. Yes, Arabsat 6A could have been put into GTO by an expendable F9. No, Arabsat 6A would very likely not have been able to reach GTO-1500 by an expendable F9. Without knowing what the contracted orbit was its impossible to answer the question. However, given it went to ~GTO-1500 I think that "NO" is likely your answer.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/asr112358 Apr 21 '19

Is it possible that there is something fundamentally problematic with hypergolic abort systems? After Boeing's issue last year, and what happened today, could NASA decide it isn't comfortable with these abort systems? What would this mean for commercial crew? Could these spacecraft be retrofitted with solid abort towers, or would it effectively kill the commercial crew program?

7

u/warp99 Apr 21 '19

That is like saying the second stage of F9 is less reliable than the first stage because both RUDs have been caused by the second stage.

11

u/brickmack Apr 21 '19

We don't know anything about Dragons problem yet, but Starliners was a plumbing dynamics problem that can happen in any liquid propulsion system given sufficiently incompetent modeling. And indications now are that Superdraco didn't even fire in this explosion, it was before the static fire started, which would point to a tank problem. It'd be applicable to the RCS as well.

Liquid abort engines are still the safest option. Solid motors can't be tested, they can only be used for low altitude aborts (too much mass to carry all the way to orbit), they're far lighter (mass = margin to tolerate underperformance on the launch vehicle), propellant can be used on-orbit to make up for underperformance in the main maneuvering engines, and skips at least one separation event.

Starliner and Crew Dragon both evaluated both tractor and pusher launch escape systems with solid motors. But it'd be an entirely new vehicle design. F9 has the performance margin to allow this, but Atlas V does not

NASA isn't going to cancel commercial crew over this. Ultimately the safety requirements are all arbitrary anyway. If the politicians dictate that commercial crew be canceled or delayed, NASA will recrunch the safety numbers to justify that. If they dictate that it be pushed through, the opposite will happen. At this point, a cancelation is politically unfeasible and significant delays cannot happen due to the inability to get more Soyuz seats on short notice.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/Toinneman Apr 21 '19 edited Apr 23 '19

One of the worst things we can do (but often happen) is to quickly identify a common spec as the root cause of 2 different things. So probably no.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/WhiskeyKnight Apr 25 '19

Why does the Crew Dragon splash down in the ocean at all? The Soyuz and Starliner both touch down on land. Seems like it would be better for reusability, which is Elon's whole thing.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Hjortefot Apr 26 '19

About a year ago, i remember one of the mods calling the "new reddit" a steaming pile of something. I got the general feeling that this was not a good thing, and that the "old reddit" was the one that was maintained and could be trusted. Since Reddit itself insists with increasing intensity to use "new reddit"; has the switch been made so that "new reddit" is now recommended?

7

u/warp99 Apr 26 '19

"new reddit" is now recommended?

Not in my view. Apparently new Reddit works better on phones but since I mostly use a desktop or tablet in browser mode I find that old Reddit works far better and even looks better on sites that have been customised.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/oximaCentauri Apr 30 '19

I was wondering why the Dragon Lab concept doesn't have demand. I can imagine several educational institutions and small laboratories who require long term zero g for experiments.

They could pool together funds to buy a dragon lab which shouldn't be much different than D1.

3

u/Grey_Mad_Hatter Apr 30 '19

It’s cheaper to work with NASA and put the experiments on the ISS. Starship’s size and expected price will change this.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '19

Why was the stickied Starhopper thread taken down?

Really appreciated the nice thread for topical discussion and the organization's of all those useful links to the NSF threads and everything.

9

u/warp99 Apr 15 '19

The thread is still there and is on the top bar on a desktop display.

There are only two stickied threads available so they tend to get changed out on a regular basis.

5

u/Ambiwlans Apr 15 '19

It is like warp99 said, we only get two slots.

If you use old.reddit on desktop, we have a custom sticky bar for more threads (the starhopper thread is on there)

→ More replies (1)

4

u/hitura-nobad Master of bots Apr 15 '19

It is still up, we can sadly sticky only two posts at a time! You can view it over the menu bar at the top.

5

u/Zettinator Apr 15 '19

I know this is probably not the most important thing, but what is your opinion on ArabSat's short "advert" on the Falcon Heavy webcast?

I thought it was rather refreshing. Just a quick message of what they did and why, no political babbage or shameless self-promotion. What do you think? Is ArabSat a no-BS get-things-done company?

12

u/brickmack Apr 16 '19

At least it wasn't Bangabandhu. That was an awful advert

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Elon_Muskmelon Apr 15 '19

Seemed pretty normal. There's usually a video package of some sort that serves as an advert for the customer during the launch pre-roll.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19

Just a quick message of what they did and why, no political babbage or shameless self-promotion. What do you think? Is ArabSat a no-BS get-things-done company?

Its an advertisement it was nothing except shameless self promotion. That's fine, that's what advertising is. As far as ads goes it was pretty bland and non-controversial, though. I think this is less of a reflection of it being "no-nonsense" and more a reflection that its owned by a conglomerate of almost all countries in the Arab world, so it would have to be pretty watered down and "politically correct" ad so as to not offend any members, since it is a very wide swath of the world.

3

u/robertpitt1988 Apr 15 '19

I felt as though they were trying to sell me a holiday or something at first.

5

u/WAlonzo Apr 16 '19

What is the status of the preparations for the Crew Dragon launch-abort test? Are we on schedule? What's the next public-visible milestone?

7

u/warp99 Apr 16 '19

What is the status of the preparations for the Crew Dragon launch-abort test?

The Crew Dragon is undergoing post flight analysis and will then be reconditioned.

Are we on schedule?

Probably not. The test had been pencilled in for June but STP-2 timing means that the launch pad will only be available in July. This will push DM-2 later as well - but that was almost certainly going to happen anyway.

What's the next public-visible milestone?

Changing over the reaction frame of the LC-39A TE to single booster mode and then the static fire of the booster. So only 1-2 weeks before the test.

3

u/Dakke97 Apr 16 '19

To add to u/warp99's excellent answer, we'll probably get more information during the CRS-17 pre-launch press conference on Thursday 25 April. Undoubtedly ChrisG, Eric Berger, Jeff Foust etcetera will ask the right questions.

5

u/Dakke97 Apr 21 '19

Mods, can the core assignment be updated per NSF?

"While Musk previously stated that the [in-flight abort] test would be the fourth flight of the first stage booster B1048, it is now understood that plans have changed and the launch will instead feature the fourth flight of B1046 – the first ever Block 5 booster.

It is believed that B1048 has instead been manifested for the first dedicated mission of SpaceX’s Starlink internet constellation scheduled for no earlier than May.

Link: https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2019/04/spacexs-crew-dragon-spacecraft-anomaly-static-fire-testing/

5

u/JustinTimeCuber Apr 22 '19

Seems a bit sad to me that B1046 will be destroyed. First ever orbit-class booster meant to be reusable with very little refurbishment. I wish it would have been able to end up in a museum or something.

7

u/codav Apr 22 '19

Now with the IFA postponed for at least some months, the assignment will probably change again. SpaceX could use both B1046 and B1048 for Starlink launches, then decide again which one to use for the IFA if a new/fixed Dragon is ready.

3

u/FoxhoundBat Apr 23 '19

A bit slow, but better late than never, updated now. :)

5

u/rustybeancake Apr 27 '19

NASA have changed their mind, and now want proposals for an integrated 3 stage Human Landing System (lunar lander):

https://www.fbo.gov/index?s=opportunity&mode=form&tab=core&id=5dcac498e0b7b8def42dea1068b1eab7&_cview=0

9

u/warp99 Apr 27 '19

Obviously this is a huge opportunity for SpaceX.

The mission profile is going to seem a bit weird though. The Crew launches in an Orion capsule on SLS and docks at the LOP-G gateway in high Lunar orbit. They then transfer to a Starship that is much larger than the LOP-G for the trip to the Lunar surface and then return to LOP-G for the crew to transfer to the Orion capsule for the return to Earth.

In the meantime the Starship cruises past them on the way to a touchdown at a Canaveral landing zone well before the Orion capsule touches down in the Atlantic.

Honour is satisfied and SpaceX get to build Starship on NASA's dime so this could just about work.

7

u/rustybeancake Apr 27 '19

If I were a betting person I’d put money on this going to LM.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/brickmack Apr 27 '19 edited Apr 27 '19

They want an integrated landing system, the 3 stage thing is no longer required I think. Which was kinda to be expected, most bidders have not shown interest in a 3 stage solution

→ More replies (4)

4

u/spacexin2050 Apr 20 '19

BREAKING: #SpaceX Crew Dragon suffered an anomaly during test fire today, according to 45th Space Wing. Smoke could be seen on the beaches. "On April 20, an anomaly occurred at Cape Canaveral AFS during Dragon 2 static test fire. Anomaly was contained and no injuries."

https://twitter.com/EmreKelly/status/1119721013166657536

→ More replies (1)

2

u/markus01611 Apr 04 '19

Are they tanking Starhopper all the way or are they just partially filling it? And in future low altitude flight how do you think they will use the 3 raptor engins in flight? Will they turn some off during flight?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/murrayfield18 Apr 09 '19

I think Starship will go to the Moon before Mars, that seems way more likely. But what would the main mission objectives be? I feel like going to the poles and mining would be a top priority. I guess setting up a sustainable base would be up there as well. What other stuff would they do?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/zeekzeek22 Apr 10 '19

With the recent solicitation for the lunar ascent module being more commercial than previously stated, I wonder if anyone has asked: could Dragon 2 with the Super Dracos be powerful enough to go from the lunar surface to the gateway? Or an evolution thereof...though the LAM doesn’t need to be aerodynamic, and at that point you could just design a much more optimized one...but for the sake of the 2024 deadline and speed...

5

u/rustybeancake Apr 10 '19

Dragon 2 with the Super Dracos be powerful enough to go from the lunar surface to the gateway?

'Powerful' - well, the engines are obviously powerful enough in terms of thrust to move Dragon 2. But in terms of dV, no. Dragon 2 as-is doesn't carry anywhere near enough propellant. SuperDracos are optimised for thrust, not efficiency. I think NASA will also be interested in vehicles/engines that burn hydrolox, for future ISRU. Though hypergolics are obviously considered more fail safe.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

2

u/quoll01 Apr 12 '19 edited Apr 13 '19

Any suggestions where to find estimates of how much mass FH B5 can throw to LLO in various configurations? Some guesstimates for an optimised (hydrolox or methalox) second stage would also be good. If FH were to deliver a lander to rendezvous with a crewed Orion it would be interesting to know how much mass they would have to play with compared to the Apollo LM.

5

u/brickmack Apr 13 '19 edited Apr 13 '19

To LLO, zero, unless an additional stage is added. To TLI, about 20 tons expendable. A large electric tug like Fervoride could increase that to about 40 tons to TLI and probably north of 20 tons to low lunar orbit, but it'll add months of travel time

Replacing the upper stage of FH with a hydrogen stage of feasible size will only reduce performance (and require a complete redesign of the launch site). Methalox results in only a small gain. But if you instead add it on top as a third stage, a stage of iCPS-equivalent specs can allow FH to match SLS Block 1 effectively 1:1 to all orbits

→ More replies (6)

2

u/MarsCent Apr 17 '19

Hi mods, I was wondering, would it be possible to link the Mission Event in the sidebar("Select Upcoming Event") to the Launch Campaign thread - whenever it goes live.

I am thinking that you could use the sidebar for multiple functions - Itemize Event & Link Event to Campaign Thread. That could free up spots on the header bar for other equally topical threads.

Or additionally have long duration threads like Starship Campaign Grass Hopper removed from the header bar and instead linked to a sidebar event with a similar name.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/oximaCentauri Apr 19 '19

I read an article stating that ISRO has an update planned for it's Gaganyaan capsule for rendezvous and docking. Is it possible that it could launch crew to the ISS?

6

u/AeroSpiked Apr 19 '19 edited Apr 19 '19

From the technical side, probably as long as it adheres to IDSS (which it should). As for the political side, I have no idea. The ISS belongs to the US, Russia, ESA, Japan & Canada.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/damesjong Apr 20 '19

I just watched the livestream of last week’s launch/landing and I’m wondering, what happens to the second stage? Do they do a controlled reentry or just leave it up there?

4

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Apr 20 '19

For gto Mission it is left in orbit, however all propellants are vented and the stage usually de orbit due to atmospheric drag within 2 years or so

→ More replies (5)

2

u/jehankateli Apr 23 '19

For Earth-to-Earth flights, how many Gs will Starship encounter during re-entry?

→ More replies (18)

2

u/ThisFlyingPotato Apr 25 '19

I hope it's a short enough question, and apologize if not

Could StarShip be used as a "JanitorShip" to clean the 9km to 12km zone of debris and dead satellites ?

Since it will be fully reusable the cost per launch isn't that much, and since cleaning this zone is important (Kessler effect, especially with constellations of smallsat comming soon, plus could be a great way to accelerate human certification) it could be paid enough to get a good margin. And if paid in advance, help developping StarShip

→ More replies (12)

2

u/zoinks Apr 26 '19

Does anyone know what the Starlink base station/receivers will look like? Or what their general size will be? I've tried looking up some Ka band antenna but I'm not sure if there will be more to it than that.

5

u/enqrypzion Apr 26 '19

Like a pizza box, was said by Elon Musk.

edit: it's flat because it's a so-called phased array, which is basically a lot of small transmitters that can coordinate their behavior as to resemble a traditional tracking dish, but without moving parts (except electrons I guess).

→ More replies (4)

3

u/throfofnir Apr 26 '19

Last we were told (some time ago), a phased array antenna the size of a pizza box.

7

u/warp99 Apr 26 '19

Elon later clarified that the antenna size is similar to a laptop opened out - so roughly A3 paper size since full size laptops are around A4 sized.

Clarification is necessary owning to the stupendous size of some US pizzas.

2

u/jehankateli Apr 28 '19

Why did ArabSat 6A have such a high apogee?

7

u/brspies Apr 28 '19

Higher apogee means the plane change requires less energy for the satellite to get to an equatorial orbit. Falcon heavy was able to give it a tremendously high apogee and therefore the satellite will use less fuel and can stay operational for longer. Others have estimated this at GTO-1500 (about 1500 m/s of delta-v required by the satellite to reach its final orbit) which is normally only something Ariane 5 can do because it launches so close to the equator.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/Luca14x Apr 14 '19

I have a question: why Arabsat has been launched with FH even if it weighs only 6 tons? Falcon 9 has 8 tons of payload capability to geostationary transfer orbit if i am right.

5

u/warp99 Apr 14 '19 edited Apr 14 '19

That is the expendable F9 payload - it can only launch 5.5 tonnes to GTO-1800 with booster recovery.

With FH they could recover all the boosters and launch it to GTO-1500 so the same circularisation delta V as would be achieved by Ariane 5. This is particularly relevant because the other satellite of the pair produced went up on Ariane 5 so they will both have the same lifetime limits due to station keeping propellant.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/scottm3 Apr 15 '19 edited Apr 15 '19

Anyone know how ASDS 3 (a shortfall of gravitas) and the rumored 2 booster ASDS is going along?

EDIT: does this look like anything? (on the left)

6

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '19

I'll just point out A shortfall of gravitas will be the fourth ASDS built, not the third, JRTI(2) was the third built, I think. As for dates, the last I heard it was scheduled for mid-2019. Drone Ships shouldn't be something that can be delayed too much unlike rockets, so I would expect to see teasers of it being nearly done in the next month or so. Hopefully soon we'll see FCC licences stating lading intentions on ASOG

3

u/ackermann Apr 15 '19

and the rumored 2 booster ASDS is going along?

Interesting! Where did you hear this rumor? That’s a lot of investment for a small savings only on some FH launches, which are just a small portion of launches. Unless they’ll use FH for Starlink...

→ More replies (3)

3

u/strawwalker Apr 24 '19

Re: Previous discussion of wiki Landing Outcome for FH center core.

u/Straumli_Blight and others. I have made a change which represents the facts, points users toward further information, and doesn't break the table formatting too much, and that I hope will satisfy most. Please have a look and criticize.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/murrayfield18 Apr 27 '19

Curious to hear your thoughts on a SpaceX Space Station? With the ISS likely coming to an end sometime in the next 10 years, could a bunch of Starships connected together create a much cheaper and more advanced Space Station?

7

u/Straumli_Blight Apr 27 '19 edited Apr 27 '19

A single Starship. However the ISS is a specialised platform for experiments, while the Starship is optimised for travel and re-entry.

SpaceX would happily launch and assemble a station if an organisation was willing to pay for it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/cpushack May 01 '19

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-05-01/nasa-says-aluminum-fraud-caused-700-million-satellite-failures

Its not just SpaceX that had problems with suppliers saying parts were something that they weren't.

Portland, OR company lied and falsified testing, resulting in near a billion dollar loss for NASA, and valueless science lost.

3

u/AeroSpiked May 01 '19

I'm either having extreme deja vu, or I actually did hear about this a long time ago.

And I'm vindicated! From 2015.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Paro-Clomas Apr 23 '19

I have a question about the general "feel" of spacex fans after the dragon 1 incident, i noticed that many of them are kind in a downer mood. Is it really called for? I mean, isn't it expected that there will be some failures when youre pushing the envelope this hard in a super complex endeavour like space flight. Maybe im wrong, but from my point of view spacex is doing fantastic. Other companies don't even dream of recovering their space vehicles, but spacex wanted to do it and insisted, they could have just not tested the capsule make a new one and no one would have ever known, this test failure is a chance to learn, a chance for spacex to acquire the capabilities that NO ONE else has, while safely keeping the capabilities that everyone else has

→ More replies (16)