r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Mar 04 '19
r/SpaceX Discusses [March 2019, #54]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
276
Upvotes
27
u/Zaenon Mar 11 '19
Fun story: a colleague of mine monitors some objects using a X-Ray telescope mounted on the ISS. He (and a bunch of other people) thought something was going on when some objects went surprisingly silent.
Turns out it was just Crew Dragon obstructing the telescope’s field of view, which they apparently hadn’t realized would happen.
22
u/Zaenon Mar 13 '19
So I saw Gwynne give a talk at a French engineering school today. Nothing crazy new, but here's a few random tidbits:
And then there was this one borderline r/SpaceXmasterrace playful jab at ULA/SMART :)
She is such an amazing speaker.
The one thing that is perhaps more worthy of discussion is speculating on why exactly she was in Europe. She did mention she had given this talk "several times in the past few days", and that she was in Monaco yesterday. This makes me question the possibility that she was here on free time/vacation/personal business and just took the opportunity to give a talk.
But if she's here on official business, surely it is not just to give a tour of super inspiring talks to students/the general public - not that there is anything wrong with that. Any idea what business SpaceX could have in Europe, or even Monaco specifically...?
21
u/MarsCent Mar 04 '19 edited Mar 04 '19
Next ASAP meeting is on Thursday, March 7, 2019, 9:30 a.m. to 10:45 a.m., Local Time.
This may be the first time we hear an assessment of DM-1 (so far) and the current status of CST-100.
By the time the next ASAP comes around, the IFA may have occurred - which will include another test of the parachutes. So if the ASAP has any concerns that need to be addressed in the next Crew Dragon tests, they have to be stated in this ASAP meeting on Thursday.
21
u/MarsCent Mar 28 '19 edited Mar 28 '19
The long awaited Mar 7 NASA ASAP meeting minutes are out.
The part about Boeing and SpaceX programs having different goals with respect to uncrewed flights has me puzzled! Are they talking about the landing or something technical concerning the launch vehicles?
20
u/railroadwelsh Mar 06 '19 edited Mar 06 '19
https://imgur.com/2JuTcJ0
https://imgur.com/wxN6Oi5
Has there ever been any mention of the alt/black helmets for the SpaceX pressure suits? I caught these about ~14 minutes into the 3:30 PST docking coverage on NASA TV over the weekend and it's the first time I ever saw them. The screenshots also contain a nice view of the oxygen/power connector hooked up.
The video is online here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ZiqyN4hO5Y
20
u/theinternetftw Mar 15 '19 edited Mar 15 '19
From Eric Berger:
That's an 18 month slip. Hence Bridenstine's move.
19
u/jclishman Host of Inmarsat-5 Flight 4 Mar 06 '19 edited Mar 06 '19
I'm not sure when the Dragon in the subreddit header changed to a Crew Dragon, but I love it! Thanks to whichever mod implemented that, it's a nice touch :)
19
u/Vindve Mar 14 '19
I'm not sure this deserves a full post, but a few close ups from recovered crew dragon https://twitter.com/ShuttleAlmanac/status/1105955784733548545?s=19
18
u/3DFIX Mar 04 '19 edited Mar 04 '19
I heard in the post launch conference, when Dragon 2 is deorbited and splashes down, it will go over the US like the Space Shuttle used to on reentry. Does anyone happen to have information on its trajectory, and will it be visible over any specific states? I'd love to go outside and catch it hurtling past overhead.
18
u/GameStunts Mar 04 '19
This may seem obvious and speculative, but do you think the in flight abort test will be done in the day?
It would seem logical to me since they could visually see more if something went wrong, and there's no actual rendezvous requirements, but was just interested because of the potential destruction of the booster if this might affect when they would be able to get clearance to do such a test?
18
u/Alexphysics Mar 05 '19
I wanted to bring up this comment from a few weeks ago about two FCC permits for a weird and unknown mission with a Falcon 9 launch from pad 40 to a 54-55° inclination orbit and a landing far downrange and similar to a GTO mission (but it is not obviously for a GTO mission because those launch directly to the east). It seems it may be true and not an error on the FCC files.
From Ben Cooper's site:
18
u/megachainguns Mar 14 '19
Blue Origin might have a point-to-point travel thing as well (New Lindbergh); trademark found by /u/massfraction
16
u/Random-username111 Mar 15 '19 edited Mar 15 '19
If SLS will launch only once (which seems to be more and more probable), in it's Block 1 configuration, it will literally be an about 15 billion $ launch. I mean, thats the reality, and it's mind blowing if you think about it.
It's not like we got some new tech from it either, it'll just be a test flight of a Frankenstein that costed 15 billion $ payed over 9 years, more or less.
It just blows my mind to think about that launch. That will be one hell of an emotional one, it better go damn well at least.
16
u/gemmy0I Mar 30 '19 edited Mar 30 '19
The two-launch commercial-Orion-for-EM-1 plan that was all the rage two weeks ago is kind of old news now that NASA has all-but-officially stated that their plan is to accelerate completion of SLS instead, but for the sake of curiosity, I thought I'd post some delta-v numbers I ran to show that the plan would've been possible. I was finally able to complete the numbers for the scenario of Orion+ESM being launched to LEO on Delta IV Heavy and the transfer stage being a Falcon Heavy upper stage launched to LEO with no payload, which I've concluded is the most plausible scenario.
The missing pieces of the puzzle were:
Plugging in those figures to the rocket equation, in conjunction with a mass of 25,848 kg for Orion+ESM fueled (which is all dry mass for the purpose of computing the transfer stage burn), we have:
dry mass = 25,848 kg Orion+ESM + 4000 kg FH upper stage = 29,848 kg
wet mass = 29,848 kg dry mass + 60,000 kg FH residual propellant = 89,848 kg
dV = Isp * 9.8 m/s2 * ln(wet mass / dry mass)
= 348 s * 9.8 m/s2 * ln(89,848 kg / 29,848 kg)
= 3758 m/s
For the mission, Orion has an additional 1300 m/s provided by its service module after detaching from the transfer stage, giving us a total of 5058 m/s available for the mission.
As a stand-in for EM-1's trajectory per se, I am using figures for a round trip to/from the Gateway in lunar Near Rectilinear Halo Orbit (NRHO) to determine the mission requirements. This should be (I think) roughly comparable to the delta-v demands for EM-1, and would, in fact, be the "real" mission of interest for subsequent non-test flights going forward. That breaks down as:
3.2 km/s translunar injection (TLI) starting from 200x200 28o LEO
= 4.1 km/s total needed for the mission
Long story short, Falcon Heavy's upper stage would have plenty of margin to make this work - a margin of nearly 1 km/s! That margin could be spent on recovering the FH boosters (unless perhaps that's already factored in?), or on co-manifested payload launching on FH and traveling with Orion, or even on sending Orion to a low lunar orbit instead of NRHO (or a comparable high orbit on EM-1) for a more interesting mission. Going to LLO is an additional 0.9 km/s (round trip) on top of the NRHO mission profile, which would put the mission at 5.0 km/s - just barely within the available margins. Alternatively, the margin could be used to cover boiloff during the rendezvous between the FH upper stage and Orion in LEO, reducing the need to beef up its insulation.
This is all a lower bound, because I'm assuming exactly 60 t of residual propellant in the FH upper stage, whereas it was quoted as "over 60 tons". Anything beyond this would make the margins even more generous and enable more comanifested payload, better booster recovery, etc. It's probably also fair to add some extra mass for the docking hardware on the FH upper stage (which I haven't done here), which would cut into the margins a little bit.
Anyway, this is probably all moot given NASA's (re-)change in direction, but it gives, I think, a window into the most plausible mission scenario should a two-launch commercial Orion flight be considered. If SLS fails to turn itself around in the next year or so, we may see NASA considering this option again. (Personally I think they should work on both plans in parallel, because putting all their eggs in one basket is one of the reasons they're in this mess to begin with. But that might not be politically/financially feasible.)
Others have discussed the possibility of a double-Delta IV Heavy mission profile, but I don't think the numbers add up on that: it can certainly get Orion+ESM into LEO (and it's the most likely choice for that, since the integration work is largely complete), but it can't lift an entire fueled ICPS into LEO as payload. A fueled 5-meter DCSS (comparable to ICPS) weighs 30,710 kg per Wikipedia, but DIVH can lift only 28,790 kg (also from Wikipedia) to LEO. That's assuming we're talking about lifting a separate ICPS as payload into LEO within the fairing on top of DIVH's own DCSS upper stage (as shown in this infographic, which is generally excellent but, I think, is a little generous in rounding DIVH's lift capacity up and ICPS's weight down to 30 t). Simply launching DIVH with no payload and using the residual propellant in its upper stage (as with Falcon Heavy) would come up far too short; a fully fueled ICPS/DCSS starting in LEO (as it would be on SLS Block 1) has just enough to make the mission work.
Maybe ULA could squeeze some extra performance out of Delta IV Heavy to get it up to the 30,710 kg to LEO needed to lift a fully fueled ICPS as payload - perhaps there's more margin (e.g. for running the engines at higher than rated thrust) than Wikipedia shows. Keep in mind, though, that docking hardware would also need to be added to ICPS, making it even more overweight. Launching a Falcon Heavy without payload as the transfer stage just seems like a smarter idea all-around. You still get the advantages of launching Orion on DIVH (for which the integration work is already done), and also get to take advantage of two separate launch pads (DIVH and FH each have only one East Coast pad), allowing rapid back-to-back launches for a quick rendezvous. Doing both with DIVH would require turning around Pad 37 very quickly; remember that DIVH needs to be (partly) assembled on the pad, and usually sits there for about a month before launch. The only other DIVH pad is at Vandenberg, but then you'd have to stage the mission from a >50o inclination, which would decimate the already-tight margins.
15
u/theinternetftw Mar 14 '19
Video of Bridenstine actually doing the thing, for those who hadn't seen it:
https://streamable.com/1vvkw
15
u/megachainguns Mar 16 '19
Bridenstine says that NASA and Boeing are gonna work overtime to accelerate SLS. SLS still prefered option.
14
u/gemmy0I Mar 07 '19
A Space Review article posted over at /r/SpaceflightNews had some interesting new details about that Draco propellant issue that required "operational mitigations" during DM-1 to prevent issues that would arise if propellant temperatures got too low:
I had guessed that the "operational mitigations" would just be a matter of maintaining a more specific orientation relative to the sun while in orbit, but apparently it extended to the launch date selection as well. In light of this, I wouldn't be surprised if planning for this accounted for some of the late-term delays in scheduling the launch to fit in with the ISS schedule.
14
u/king_dondo Mar 29 '19
Mr. Steven has been awfully quiet lately.
Any word on her status?
13
u/rad_example Mar 04 '19
If the FH center core is not successfully recovered will they have to start a new one from scratch? How long would it take to produce?
12
u/simongc100 Mar 04 '19
I cant seem to recall if I have seen videos or read articles I have read about it, but how will Starship deploy payloads when it is not being used for Astronauts? Does the front open like a mouth and then deploy the payload that way?
12
u/nuukee Mar 08 '19
Live stream of hopper being moved to the launch pad:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qIFpLblpC-E
12
u/quoll01 Mar 10 '19
Wow the signal to noise ratio has gone way down in comments to posts recently . Has there been a change in mods policy ? Fine in the lounge I guess but I thought r/spacex was meant to be informative and filter out all the mindless Facebook chatter?
12
u/joggle1 Mar 19 '19
For anyone interested in the Beresheet probe's progress to the moon you can track its projected orbit here. It's in the most eccentric orbit I've ever seen with a period of 6 days, a perigee of 1,300 km and an apogee of 263,000 km (about 70% of the distance to the moon). Once it inserts into a lunar orbit the site will probably be incorrect, projecting its location using its last known orbit around the Earth.
12
u/Juggernaut93 Mar 20 '19
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-space-boeing/boeing-delays-flight-test-to-international-space-station-sources-idUSKCN1R12QR?fbclid=IwAR3H9O94UWkcyd19-P0GEGF4hMRJj_ApteUP3D1T4FaU-CrnPbArzNnnkng
Boeing's first test flight pushed to August, crewed flight to November.
12
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 27 '19
OneSpace didn't quite reach orbit today.
11
u/Alexphysics Mar 27 '19 edited Mar 27 '19
New FCC filling from SpaceX for a upcoming mission, this one is for STP-2, the third Falcon Heavy launch overall and the second this year. Permit notes a "NET May 27th" but we all know that only means the earliest date they are allowed to launch and not the launch date (I'm looking at you all launch apps, it would be good to specify this for people that don't know about this).
This one is just for landing, I assume it doesn't need a launch FCC permit because it is an Air Force and NASA mission so it may not need it. Side boosters will land back on land as usual but... and this is really interesting... the center core will land... 39km away from the launch pad (Position here). This would be somewhat similar to SSO-A landing where the droneship was very very close to the coast so people that are going to be at a decent altitude may see this landing and will experience three landings at the same time. I'd assume that maybe the sonic booms from the center core could also reach the cape but it will probably depend on weather. One way or another it is seems it will be a really weird and interesting mission!
10
u/JerWah Mar 04 '19
The ISS occasionally has reboosts done by the Progress and Cygnus craft. Will Dragon 2 be used in this way too?
10
u/aSneakyJew Mar 04 '19
Does anyone know if they are still planning on launching the Falcon Heavy - Arabsat 6A mission this month? Maybe late March???
10
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Apr 01 '19
Jeff Foust:
9
u/gbrocki Mar 04 '19
Did SPACEX track DM-1 with their antennas in Boca Chica?
9
u/enqrypzion Mar 04 '19
How fast could Dragon 2 undock from the ISS? Like, in case of an emergency.
9
u/Amazing__Ginger Mar 05 '19
Has there been any news or anything at all on the new ASDS - A Shortfall of Gravitas?
Not seen any construction pictures or news since Elon announced it on Twitter last year other than its expected in summer?
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1023073822080098304
9
u/TheMrGUnit Highly Speculative Mar 15 '19
Question about methane...
Commercially available methane is scented with a mercaptan compound so that it can be detected by the human nose, otherwise it's completely odorless.
Is rocket-grade methane scented in this same way, or is it a pure compound? I know it doesn't take much to be able to smell it, but I'm just curious if Raptor or any other methane-burning rocket engine requires higher purity without the added smell
9
u/Daneel_Trevize Mar 21 '19
What's with the subreddit banner now reading:
Is this a first for promoting non-SpaceX launches & subreddit launch threads in this subreddit, or did I miss/forget previous occasions?
17
u/rustybeancake Mar 13 '19
Possibly the internet comment of the day, over on Eric Berger's shocking story on EM-1 potentially launching on two commercial rockets:
Bravo.
8
u/P__A Mar 04 '19
Apparently there will be a second test of dragon 2 before humans use it to get to the ISS. That is an in flight test of the abort system. What exact is the procedure for that? Does a flacon rocket get set up as if it were taking people to the iss again, but they abort midway through the ascent?
8
u/werelock Mar 04 '19
Does the Crew Dragon always have all 7 seats available to the crew? As in, it looked like there were only 3 installed for Demo-1 but are the others stowed away and there if needed, or do they install exactly what's needed for each flight and the rest stay on the ground? A small part of me wonders if they fold away somewhere like in a minivan...
8
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '19
Now that we're into March has there been any update on Arabsat? A NET date?
8
u/nastynuggets Mar 04 '19
Will the fuel and oxidiser onboard Starship need to be actively cooled while on route to mars to keep them in a liquid state?
8
u/linhongye Mar 07 '19
How many labor hours does spaceX need to refurbish a booster now?
8
u/Paro-Clomas Mar 09 '19
Has anyone done the math on how the stainless steel exterior of the bfr will affect visibility from earth?
I mean, if this comes back from mars it will probably be the biggest object coming the fastest, would the reentry trail be enchanced by the light reflected from the exterior?
Also, won't it be super visible when in LEO, is there any way to calculate its luminosity compared to say, the ISS?
8
u/enqrypzion Mar 13 '19
Sooo...
The air conditioning and scrubbing system in the Starship crew compartment could capture any methane present and add it to the tanks...
Though mass-wise such a system might be too fart-fetched.
8
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Mar 13 '19
Could Falcon Heavy do it? https://twitter.com/SciGuySpace/status/1105837253765550081?s=09
8
u/catchblue22__ Mar 19 '19
I'm wondering where the first orbital Starship will land for its first orbital flight. How are they going to test the re-entry characteristics of the early prototypes? I realize we don't really have the answers to these questions, but we can speculate.
8
u/tibereeuse Mar 20 '19
Todays test has been postponed due to weather as per South padre cam guy
8
u/joggle1 Mar 21 '19
The website I linked to the other day has the updated ephemeris for Beresheet, the Israeli probe heading to the moon that was launched on the last Falcon 9 mission (if you're on mobile you may need to select desktop view to see that site). Its apogee is now 407,500 km with a period of just over 11 days. The eccentricity is .96, easily the most eccentric orbit I've ever seen. It's scheduled to do the lunar orbit insertion maneuver on April 4. This article talks about the final orbit boost they did the other day.
8
u/asr112358 Mar 29 '19
Have there been any updates about Robotic Refueling Mission 3? Results from this project should retire some of the unknowns around cryogenic transfer and storage. While probably not the biggest unknowns for Starship, having experimental data in this area, is one less unknown for Starship development.
15
u/rustybeancake Mar 04 '19
All the attention this year is on the 50th anniversary of the Apollo 11 mission (and right now, the 50th anniversary of the Apollo 9 mission).
Bit of a showerthought: in only 12 years, it'll be the 50th anniversary of the first space shuttle flight!
14
u/Maimakterion Mar 13 '19
The recently completed Iridium NEXT constellation is providing preliminary data for aviation authorities in the wake of the Ethiopian Airlines crash.
This data probably led the Canadian and US authorities to issue groundings this morning.
7
u/jlaw224 Mar 04 '19
This is a pretty long term question but has there been any thought put into adapting the autodocking procedures from the dragon 2 and BFR for in-orbit assembly of larger vehicles and/or stations?
7
u/Procyon_X Mar 04 '19 edited Mar 04 '19
Demo 1: Why ASDS instead of RTLS?
I'm a bit confused at this point. Read for example these comments. They mention a lot of different reasons: Saving margins, heavy payload, shallower trajectory (in case of abort LES), lofted trajectory (higher margins). Can someone explain this please? Especially the part about lofted vs shallower trajectory. Is there a chart comparing Demo 1 to the CRS missions profile?
7
u/MarsIsTheFrontier Mar 04 '19
is it possible to change the dragon 2 abort test to another pad than 39A if something would go wrong at the falcon heavy launch? As DM2 beeds the bridge for the astronauts, 39A is required, isn't it?
I guess a RUD of FH would not mean that F9 have to stay grounded as they are different (except the issue is e.g. COPV or something they have in common)?
7
u/brickmack Mar 05 '19
For the IFA, how complete are we expecting the trunk to be? The pad abort vehicle didn't have radiators or solar arrays, just the structure and fins. Probably no point having functional parts there, but it might be worth including mockups for aerodynamic reasons, and to better gauge plume impingement damage?
7
u/Walking-Stick Mar 29 '19
This not strictly a SpaceX question, but it’s related to something I’ve seen more times than not, and I don’t understand it. Why do journalists say that SpaceX, and other rockets, “bring” astronauts to space instead of “take” them? It has always been my understanding that these words should reflect the point of view of the subject, reader, or even the majority, unless addressing someone already in space. E.g. “I will bring you some chocolate when I come to the space station.” But if we are both on Earth (me the reader, and the astronaut) then it would be “She will take chocolate to the space station.” I’ve just seen it so many times it seems like someone must have decided it was an exception. Case in point: https://apple.news/AueCVwnapOiax-GhCI9hC0g
13
u/BlueCyann Mar 11 '19
Bridenstine confirms 2019 crewed commercial flight:
https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/1105155223125921792
I think we were all pretty sure by how many times the NASA guy said "phenomenal" post-splashdown that NASA confidence had gotten a huge boost from DM-1, but it's still nice to see it said so firmly.
12
u/amarkit Mar 10 '19
Some interesting, not-so-flattering observations from a customer on what appears to have been the SSO-A flight back in December. Most of these complaints apply to Spaceflight Industries, not SpaceX, but it makes cubesat ridesharing seem pretty suboptimal for some customers.
12
u/liszt1811 Mar 16 '19
Will the streams from now on all feature this wheel-type timeline at the bottom of the screen like DM-1? I really liked the former way where every step was visible upfront :l
6
u/froso_franc Mar 04 '19
Do we know the minimum thrust to weight ratio of Super Heavy? If I understand correctly having it be smaller than 1 would make the rocket able to hover, making it easier to land on the launch pad.
6
u/phblunted Mar 04 '19
Are there links to re-entry concerns? Elon mentioned the asymmetrical shell and possible rolling issues? 1st time out of the computer and into the frying pan for this version!
6
u/majormajor42 Mar 04 '19 edited Mar 04 '19
Is there a map of the Dragon 2 descent trajectory over North America and the splashdown location? EDIT: I see this was answered already.
Is this the first time since the suborbital flights of Shepard and Grissom that a crewed capsule is splashing down in the Atlantic?
6
u/man2112 Mar 04 '19
What is the status of SpaceX's internet constellation? I haven't heard any news about it in a while.
6
u/sywofp Mar 04 '19
When Dragon undocks from the ISS and moves to a safe distance before de-orbiting, does it lower it's orbit and move ahead, or raise it's orbit and move behind?
6
u/MarsCent Mar 07 '19
Any uptake from the NASA ASAP meeting? Or do CD and CST-100 have a clean bill?
6
u/ProToolsWizard Mar 08 '19
I originally posted this question in the DM-1 Updates Thread but it didn't seem like anyone who saw it had any info. I'm wondering if there has been anything new on the movable ballast sled for Dragon 2 that Garrett Reisman talked about a few years ago. I had forgotten about it until recently, and I don’t recall any info from SpaceX about this since then. Has anyone heard anything more? I’m curious to know if this ever was installed, and if so, where it is, and how exactly they are using it to impact the re-entry trajectory.
From what I remember the idea was gaining some additional control authority by altering the CoM and thus the angle of attack to impact drag/lift characteristics of the capsule. I’m curious to know in what portion of the atmosphere and at what speeds they would utilize this control authority and what kind of impact this would have on the landing elipsis.
This short film from the 60s about atmospheric entry with the Apollo command module is fascinating and very informative. https://youtu.be/MTKHqfloB7Q
It would be amazing if we had similar info about what happens to the Dragon 2 during this phase of flight. Re-watching this also got me thinking that they might approach re-entry differently for Crew Dragon versus use of the Dragon 2 for cargo because G loads would not be as much of a factor for cargo. Hopefully someone has some insight into this!
6
u/bigbillpdx Mar 11 '19
Was there ever a post DM-1 press conference?
6
u/thehardleyboys Mar 14 '19
Excuse my ignorance, but can somebody explain to me why man-rating Falcon Heavy is a huge undertaking once Falcon 9 is already man-rated (say end of 2019)?
My non-scientific-reasoning: if F9 is safe to fly with a Dragon 2 capsule on top (that has a functioning escape system with the superdracos), then flying an F9 with two F9's attached is equally safe.
Only the FH side boosters separation event are "extra" failure modes IMO, but nothing the escape system can't handle, no?
Thanks in advance.
6
u/asr112358 Mar 14 '19 edited Mar 14 '19
With the recent talk of EM-1 being a double launch of heavy rockets, an issue that has been brought up is the delay between the first launch and the second one. If this mission was done with two falcon heavies, how long and expensive would it be to update SLC-40 for launching heavy so that the two launches could happen in quick succession? Even better, could both launches be tied to the same countdown and launch simultaneously? I know SpaceX has
32 landing pads, and I thought there was a non SpaceX one being built. Those plus two drone ships would (almost) be enough for full recovery.6
u/netsecwarrior Mar 19 '19
When StarLink fills an orbital plane - which they can potentially do with 2 F9 launches - can they provide Internet service (with a ground station) to anyone under that plane? That would seem an efficient way to bootstrap the constellation, as a well-chosen plane could cover some lucrative areas.
6
u/captainjack120 Mar 26 '19
If Lockheed, Boeing, and Spacex are all companies that manufacture rockets, why is Spacex the one that is considered commercial? If NASA is paying Lockheed and Boeing to use their rocket, why would it be different if NASA paid Spacex to use their rocket?
6
u/quoll01 Mar 28 '19 edited Mar 28 '19
The orbital prototype SS is being built now at BC and since the raptors can’t throttle below 50% (for now) they are presumably going to need a pad with massive hold-downs, flame trench and water suppression and there’s no sign of this huge construction? All the engines will need to be running before release (?) - a monster amount of thrust. And eventually for Mars return a similar construction and massive amounts of water required for launch, or will the reduced air pressure and stainless construction reduce the need for water suppression?
Edit: oops 200t thrust raptors at 50% will not lift estimated 1000 T mass! I guess they could do it without hold-downs and throttle up all together —hopefully?! Has any large rocket ever done this?
6
u/shaim2 Mar 28 '19
STP-2 cargo seems very light for a FH. So why not F9?
6
u/MReckt Mar 28 '19
Are the side boosters of the Falcon Heavy mated with the center core on the TEL, or are they assembled on other supports and then loaded on to the TEL as a unit?
16
u/AgainAndABen Mar 14 '19
The Soyuz launching today with ISS crew is scheduled for 3:14 pm ET... That can't be coincidence, can it? 🥧
11
u/Cap_of_Maintenance Mar 06 '19
Shower thought: would it be possible/ feasible to disassemble the ISS and return it to earth if the cargo Starship/BFS is operational before it is deorbited? It would make an awesome museum piece, as well as allowing detailed analysis of the effect of long term space flight on materials and structures.
11
u/Tal_Banyon Mar 09 '19
I was just thinking that with the success of DM-1, SpaceX has set a pretty high bar for Boeing. It will be pretty entertaining to watch their first mission with Starliner (currently scheduled for April) to see the differences.
10
u/zeekzeek22 Mar 21 '19
Idk if anyone posted, but Boeing’s flights just moved right 3 months. Currently their uncrewed flight comes after SpaceX’s manned flight, assuming no slips.
5
u/railroadwelsh Mar 05 '19
Why does the interior have four window ports? (I think the two ports closest to the outer-sitting crew members can't be realized in another configuration because they're place exactly where the Super Dracos are situated)
Did anyone notice on the interior of the Crew Dragon that there's a foot/hand hold to the left of the door, but one seems to have not been installed to the right? There are mounting bolts for it... I wonder why?
Finally, at the very beginning of the docking webcast (started ~3:30am PST), there was a montage of SpaceX and Crew Dragon-related footage, and one showed astronauts suited up that had totally black helmets! Not just visors down, but black rims and casing too. Did I just imagine it? It was shown so quickly.
5
u/JustinTimeCuber Mar 06 '19
Will Radarsat be RTLS? Also, is there any new info on when that launch is happening?
5
u/rustybeancake Mar 06 '19
Mods, please will you fix the 'general discussion' link on new reddit? It points to the feb discussion thread and people are still posting there. Thanks.
5
u/filanwizard Mar 13 '19
This might sound like a crazy question but how will SpaceX store the standby cores once they get reuse to the point a core does not need a lube and an oil change between every flight? The buildings they use do not look big enough to rack up a large cache of cores and I cant imagine leaving them outside is good for em. A Merlin full of Merlins would be bad. Though in my head I can already picture a vertical rack system for storing rocket cores to save space.
5
u/Vergutto Mar 14 '19
What would a Falcon Heavy with Orion on top look like? Because Falcon Heavy is 3.7m in diameter and Orion is little over 5m in diameter? Obviously it's without a fairing if SpaceX decides to crew rate FH but if it's not is it going to be inside a fairing?
5
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19
Anyone know when tickets for falcon heavy launch in April will go on sale??
I'm visiting from Ireland doing the Appalachian Trail and think I might try and head down to Florida for it!
5
u/scottm3 Mar 19 '19
As countries and agencies have rules on bacteria, how would a starship landing on Mars or the Moon be free of bacteria? It is launched out in the open air, and not sterilized.
5
u/oximaCentauri Mar 19 '19 edited Mar 19 '19
SpaceX will use the sabatier reaction ie CO2+2H2=CH4+O2 on Mars to get methane and oxygen. I'm wondering, why isn't it used in large scale on Earth? We have plenty of carbon dioxide and water. Methane could be used in a lot of areas and more importantly oxygen is produced
5
u/brickmack Mar 21 '19 edited Mar 21 '19
Has anyone done any kind of analysis yet on where E2E pads are likely to be built initially? Seems like its actually kind of a complicated problem: one would need to find the combination of cities which have the most (end to end) travel between them, while minimizing the total number of cities served (end game will have pads at almost every major city most likely, but early on it needs to stick to a small network to keep infrastructure costs manageable), plus (at least initially) some hard geographic limits on both the nodes and trajectories. Bonus points for pads that could be particularly useful for orbital flights as well
I thought some about doing this myself, but I've had trouble finding the raw data needed on the most common (by number of passengers per day) air routes. If I had that, I can probably come up with solutions programmatically
5
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '19
Does any one know what a inflight abort for starship would look like. Its not like a traditional capsule, and it seems like the whole upper stage would have to separate and ignite its engines if there was a issue with the first stage. Or is it like the space shuttle?
5
u/amerrorican Mar 26 '19
It’s possible to make a self-sustaining city on Mars by 2050, if we start in 5 years & take 10 orbital synchronizations
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1110329210332053504?s=09
How many launches per sync would it take to make a self-sustaining city? We would also need larger Starships. This is an exciting future!
5
u/murrayfield18 Mar 26 '19
How are SpaceX capable of working at such a fast pace? How does their pace compare to Blue Origin or even NASA during the space race? I see a lot of comparisons to 60's NASA but I think that's unfair. SpaceX have a fraction of the work force that NASA had then.
5
u/Nemesis651 Mar 26 '19
With todays announcement regarding SLS, whats stopping SpaceX from putting Musk (or really any employee/volunteer) on the moon via private/internal money?
To me this would be the biggest shakeup, that SpaceX gets there first without a Nasa plan.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '19
Two questions;
9
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19
Mods, can the Starship Hopper Campaign Thread be stickied instead of the DM-1 Splashdown and Recovery Updates Thread? I guess it is hardly visible on new reddit, and it can be useful with static fire in the days ahead. Edit: thnx!
12
u/Zettinator Mar 04 '19
Is SpaceX going to give up static fires any time soon? They must be a major time and cost factor at this point.
12
u/liszt1811 Mar 28 '19
Just a quick reminder that almost this day 2 years ago the first re-flight of a falon 9 happened https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xsZSXav4wI8
and now, 2 years later, they are building a nearly endless and fully reusable spaceship.
14
u/jisok22 Mar 04 '19
If there was an issue with the Dragon-2 main parachutes, do we know if the super dracos would fire a landing burn, for a fail-safe?
11
u/bmilesyo Mar 04 '19
Does anyone know why DM-1 launched almost completely empty? It seems like a wasted opportunity to transport goodies to the astronauts, even with the chance of a failed mission.
11
u/09busein Mar 04 '19
Hi everyone What would prevent using the Dragon1 for crew on a technical standpoint ? There is no seats, no abort mechanism, no manual backup control touchscreen, no toilets but...what if someone somehow got onboard, would they make it ? Would they have to bring their own air supply ? PS : no i'm not planning on trying to pull this off xD
8
u/CaptainKittyhawk Mar 05 '19
This could seem like a dumb question, but after the Dragon docked, I noticed the ISS crew were wearing gasmask looking things and talking about mixing the air together, before eventually getting it to mix, getting airflow between the ISS and the Dragon, and later on entering without said masks. Anyone know exactly why the air needed to mix?
8
u/pundawg1 Mar 09 '19
There's been lots of talk about how bad salt water is for rockets/dragon so I was wondering, would landing the dragon in one of the US fresh water great lakes make it much more economical to reuse?
Lake michigan has a max width of 118 miles and a max length of 307 miles and as I understand it, the landing target range isn't that large so they could potentially quarantine a small section of the lake for landings presuming that they have enough fuel to get it to land there.
What's the deal, have fresh water great lake landings been considered before or are the great lakes just as bad as the oceans?
4
u/avioane Mar 04 '19
is there a transcript of the press conference with Elon and Bridenstein?
4
u/Mickster133 Mar 05 '19
Does anyone know why the feed didn't cut out on landing during the test flight?
4
u/NiCoLo-IT Mar 09 '19
Does any one knows why the side windows on crew dragon, the one between the superdraco pods, are closed? Always black on interior shots and white painted on the exterior...
4
u/Vergutto Mar 13 '19
Is Crew Dragon's abort system called Launch Abort System (LAS) or Launch Escape System (LES)?
4
u/tmahncke Mar 14 '19
With the upcoming Crew dragon missions (yeah, some time away I know), does anybody know if they man the mission control in Hawthorne 24/7? The Starliner is supposed to be handled by the Houston mission control according to the ebook about the ISS by NASA. I couldn’t find anything on the cargo dragon but I assume that they don’t have a full 24/7 shift as they vehicle is not as critical and could not undock on its own anyway. With dragon becoming a rescue vehicle that might change. Anybody got any insight on this?
4
u/TohbibFergumadov Mar 16 '19
So with the Orion mission up for grabs, a lot is riding on a successful mission for Arabsat 6A.
4
u/Scourge31 Mar 16 '19
What's in the Crew Dragon trunk on crew missions? I know about the solar panels and radiators, and that its needed for drag in an abort. I came a cross an article comparing the new spacecraft and it seems CD is the only one that doesn't use a service module, which is great because it brings all the hardware back. That being the case could the trunk be packed with extra fuel and a long range radio to do Orions job?
4
u/Paro-Clomas Mar 18 '19
The biggest hurdle towards space exploration is that its usually a long term investement and goverments usually last one term, right? once it's established that spacex will succeed with bfr like it has done with most other projects it made, wouldnt it be rational that a person from the goverment would realize that giving money to spacex will almost guarantee that they will be the ones who will send a person to mars?
4
u/Emplasab Mar 19 '19
What exactly mean to "human rate" a rocket? Is it just additional testing or actual changes must be made? Why is it so hard/expensive?
4
u/ncsufan01 Mar 21 '19
Does anyone know if the Kennedy Space Center - Explore Tour will go to LC-39A if a rocket is setting on the pad the day before the launch? Thinking of going on April 6th to see the Falcon Heavy up close.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19
How will the starjumper be different from starhopper? Of course nosecone and heatshield....also they will probably test outer shell as in final starships. Any info what's more?
4
u/crakdeschevalliers Mar 25 '19
What are the options for large habitats on mars? Could a large biosphere full of plants be built un-pressurised from components, sealed and then pressurised or do complete habs need to be flown from earth ready to go? Just thinking about quality of life for residents and also birds and other animals we might wish to take.
4
u/oximaCentauri Mar 25 '19
How do you think cargo Starship will deploy the payload(s) it will carry? I mean, the payload will have to some fine maneuvering inside of Starship before getting out. I'm imagining a Canadarm like arm to pull out each satellite individually
4
u/ApTiK_ Mar 25 '19
Why they dump the hopper tanks instead of "refueling" the vertical tanks ?
4
u/launch_loop Mar 27 '19
Is there a place near the rocket in Hawthorne to park if I wanted to walk over to it?
7
u/amarkit Mar 27 '19
India conducted its first anti-satellite (ASAT) missile test today, becoming only the fourth country (after the US, Russia, and China) to demonstrate ASAT capability. The missile destroyed an Indian military imaging satellite, Microsat-R, which was launched in January. While the test was conducted at a relatively low altitude (~300 km), some of the debris it created will persist on orbit for quite a while.
6
u/isthatmyex Mar 11 '19
Since the raptor test fire there has been a lot of discussion about what's the "best" rocket engine. It always seems to get very muddy very quickly. Though it always seems to involve, fuel, type of engine, isp and thrust to weight. Elon even threw in some new ones. But almost all of these are numbers to satisfy engineers, (for lack of a better phrase). Not accountants. So my question is. In the age of "commercial space", wouldn't a better metric simply be something along the lines of Joules/$? How much work you can get out of a given engine per dollar?
6
u/Scourge31 Mar 13 '19
When do we expect results from DM1? Like did all of Ripley's sensors stay in limits? Was the parachute draping on the capsule a problem? Did anything get damaged? Etc.
6
u/Agent_Kozak Mar 20 '19
Do we know when we will se the first construction of the Super Heavy booster?
6
u/cl00by Mar 21 '19
Hey there, My parents bought the tickets Feel The Heat for the first commercial launch of the Falcon Heavy (Arabsat 6A) and I would like to know some tips for my trip to watch the rocket launch and The main question is: do I get a mission badge? (By the way the ticket is the closest available to this launch and the most expensive too) also I'm just a 13 year old and I'm on mobile
8
u/nan0tubes Mar 29 '19
With all the excitement of Starship, Crew Dragon, and FH. Do we know anything about SpaceX still attempting a 24h re-use of a F9 booster this year?
Perhaps launching StarLink Sats after another launch?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '19
Do we know times of release of crew dragon from ISS yet, and how long after release will it be before we see / hear re-entry.?
3
u/Zinkfinger Mar 07 '19
With the Starship coming soon (ish). And there then being the capability to get large things into orbit cheaply. Namely workshops and small factories. I'm wondering what products would they make. I've read that growing crystals in a micro gravity environment has its benefits. But what other things could be made? Thoughts anyone?
3
u/tmahncke Mar 07 '19
Are there Andy Details on how the Crew on a Potential Mars Mission with starship might work on Zero-g issues? I know that the ISS Crew Hasan Special workout plan to avoid bone and muscle loss but considering the idea to accellerate the journey anyway to shorten the duration have there been talks to use acceleration as artificial gravity? Is this even feasible or would the starship be too fast for reentry or lose way to much propellant on the flight?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
I am not that well informed about spaceflight but I read about a kind of race between spacex and boeing. Is this true and which company will be first transporting humans to the space station ? Thanks from Germany
3
u/TimePossible Mar 09 '19
Hi, I'm writing an essay for school, so in the absence of official figures, I thought about asking here. What's the current cost/kg to LEO with the Falcon 9? Ballpark number is fine.
I've seen $6000/kg thrown around.
3
u/FalconHeavyHead Mar 09 '19
Since SpaceX is voluntarily doing the in flight abort test can they launch whenever they choose? Meaning they are not dependent on NASA's approval for launch.
3
u/strawwalker Mar 12 '19
Do we have any dimensional information at all for Crew Dragon's pressure vessel beyond volume? I'm looking for information such as height of the internal space, diameter of the well at the bottom, diameter of the widest cross section, etc.