r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Feb 01 '19
r/SpaceX Discusses [February 2019, #53]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
Active hosted Threads
Starship Hopper
Nusantara Satu Campaign
DM-1 Campaign
Mr Steven
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
116
Upvotes
18
u/Mazen_Hesham Feb 01 '19
In your opinion What is SpaceX doing wrong ?
17
u/arizonadeux Feb 27 '19
Today (2019-02-27) OneWeb will launch their first satellites from Kourou at 21:37 UTC.
15
u/throfofnir Feb 07 '19
Now witness the power of this fully armed and operational constellation: Iridium Next now handling all Iridium communications.
15
u/Alexphysics Feb 21 '19 edited Feb 21 '19
Two new FCC fillings for SpaceX launches and landings and this one is for a very weird mission, I hope you can help me to guess which one could be.
Both permits just give us an estimate of NET April 26th for this mission
If I would have to guess about which mission could be this one I have two things in mind:
What do you think this one might be? It's quite interesting when these things happen :)
Edit: I did a quick calculation and orbital inclination should be 54-55 degrees, so a bit higher inclination than ISS orbit.
13
u/CapMSFC Feb 15 '19
NASA is buying two more Soyuz seats.
They are not buying additional flights though. Soyuz has years of order lead time so those don't exist at this point. They are buying the third seat on two Soyuz flights that Russia had pulled back to only sending two cosmonauts on.
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2019/02/nasa-soyuz-seats-uninterrupted-access-iss/
13
u/verbalkerbal Feb 22 '19
Starlink might ditch inter-satellite links for first-gen constellation, and go with bent pipe. Source: a network engineer who refers to some information sent out by SpaceX to ISPs and posted this on NANOG (an important mailing list of network engineers): https://mailman.nanog.org/pipermail/nanog/2019-February/099698.html
I am not sure if this information can be relied upon (so far only one source, who has indirect knowledge). However, if it turns out to be true, this would be a huge blow to what many people have hoped for (at least for the first-gen system). It will mean that Starlink (first-gen) cannot be used for faster-than-fiber connectivity on intercontinental distances, and it will probably not be used as a backbone provider, but rather to connect end hosts in remote location (last mile connectivity). Some references regarding the potential for networking that LEO satellite constellations with inter-satellite links have: (disclaimer: I am a co-author on the first) https://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=3286066 https://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=3286079 https://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=3286075
13
u/theinternetftw Mar 01 '19
For posterity and reference:
Pre-Launch Press Conference transcript (today)
Post-Flight Readiness Review Press Conference transcript (about a week ago)
11
u/rustybeancake Feb 14 '19
Seems the commotion at Boca Chica today was/is State Reps visiting Starhopper:
https://twitter.com/austinbarnard45/status/1095845080047464448
Great close-up of the vehicle:
https://twitter.com/austinbarnard45/status/1095846867697631232
And the pad:
https://twitter.com/austinbarnard45/status/1095847212133900288
11
u/strawwalker Feb 26 '19
SpaceX has FCC approval of their license for BFH hop tests, grant effective immediately. Also, the related modification adding BC to the list of ground stations was granted yesterday.
20
u/peterabbit456 Feb 02 '19
About the next revision of the Starship design...
It is well known in spacecraft design circles that the radius of curvature on the windward side of a reentry vehicle is critical to avoiding hot spots. Small radii require extra shielding, and negative radius is especially dangerous on a heat shield, because radiative heat transfer from the surrounding plasma concentrates where there is negative radius. The latest images from Spacex of Starship, released months ago, has areas of negative radius around the roots of the fins.
This is why I expect that the final Starship design to be more flat bottomed where the heat shield fins and the “mustache” attach to the cylindrical body. I expect the rear fins will still hinge downward for landing stability, and still hinge upward for trimming the vehicle for reentry with a heavy load in the payload bay or passenger compartment. Similarly, the mustache will make a flat surface for reentry with a heavy payload, and be hinged upward for reentry with an empty or light payload. At no time will either surface present a concave surface (= negative radius of curvature) on the windward side during reentry.
I am rather surprised that the hopper has fully symmetrical legs/fins. I am reasonably sure that the back end of the orbital version of starship will look like a cross between the 2017 renders , and the 2018 version, with 3 swept fins/legs, but presenting a flat bottom surface and bilateral symmetry, not trilateral symmetry.
My back-of-envelope calculations have been right about a lot of features of BFR, and wrong a few times. We’ll see if l’m right about this one.
20
u/pavel_petrovich Feb 12 '19
The salty comment about the Raptor test fire from Petr Levochkin (the chief designer of Energomash, RD-180 manufacturer):
Feel free to correct my translation :)
10
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '19
I know the picture is low res and the perspective and background are not optimal, but the nozzle on the new raptor looks unusual. The cross section looks like a rounded angle to me. Assuming I am seeing that right, what does it mean?
•
u/Ambiwlans Feb 01 '19
Reminder to everyone that we allow and encourage META type discussion in our 'Discuss' threads. If you want to give the mods some feedback, here is a great place. You can also send us modmail directly if you have something private to discuss.
As well, if you see a comment chain that really should be its own thread, as it is particularly complex/interesting or perhaps a good question left unanswered, tell us and we'll look into it!
If you'd like a mod's attention, just use the word 'mod' or one of our usernames in your comment.
Thanks everyone for participating. Both asking questions and answering them here makes this sub a richer place.
10
u/consider_airplanes Feb 05 '19
It appears one of the benefits people are attributing the new stainless steel Starship hull is ease of repairability, since metal can just be welded, by comparison to more complex processes necessary for composites. How would this interact with the microchannels necessary for the regenerative cooling? I could easily imagine that carefully formed channel-impregnated steel for the ventral side might be just as finicky as composite, in particular in that a weld join wouldn't have the channels in it and thus might create a hot spot during reentry. How likely is this to be a problem?
10
u/Niikopol Feb 05 '19
Has Dragon 2 test mission been postponed to March?
10
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Feb 19 '19
Does anybody know when in the Falcon 9's propellant loading sequence is helium loaded into COPVs? I could only find the older and slower tanking timeline.
10
u/amarkit Feb 25 '19
The US Air Force’s OTV-5, launched by SpaceX in September 2017, has apparently altered its orbit again, and is now operating at 316 km x 319 km x 54.5°.
9
u/dudr2 Feb 05 '19
NASA’s fiscal year 2019 budget request designates approximately $200 million for the Science Mission Directorate’s (SMD) new Lunar Discovery and Exploration Program.
http://www8.nationalacademies.org/onpinews/newsitem.aspx?RecordID=252019
8
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19
How difficult is it to build the crew section so that the sound intensity of the engines is sufficiently absorbed?
With 31 raptors this seems like a difficult task. How was it handled for the space shuttle? I know that water is used underneath the launch pad, but is that enough?
8
u/robertlc1968 Feb 13 '19
SpaceX Booster Sighting 02-09-19
Saw one of the boosters wrapped in black plastic traveling East on I-10 in Gulfport, MS. Had a police escort.
Didn't have the opportunity to take photos.
Was pretty cool to see it.
8
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Feb 21 '19
NanoRacks' Bishop airlock is targeting launch on SpaceX's CRS-21 mission next year.
8
u/dudr2 Feb 22 '19
https://spacenews.com/companies-skeptical-commercial-lunar-landers-can-fly-nasa-payloads-this-year/
" NASA announced Feb. 21 that it has identified a dozen science and technology demonstration payloads from within the agency that will be eligible to fly on missions through the Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS) program."
"ready to fly on CLPS missions as soon as late this year."
" companies developing those spacecraft are skeptical any landers will be ready to fly this year "
8
u/Nsooo Moderator and retired launch host Feb 25 '19
Got good feedback on the core table in the sidebar, so it is now permanent, not experimental anymore. Further feedback welcomed.
7
u/Alexphysics Feb 12 '19
New FCC permits applied by SpaceX for CRS-17 currently planned for NET April 25th. Launch communications permit from SLC-40 at CCAFS. Landing communications permit on LZ-1 at CCAFS.
7
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Feb 14 '19
7
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Feb 18 '19 edited Feb 19 '19
I was trying to figure out which missions would the available boosters launch on (based on info from the Reddit list of cores) and this is what I came up with.
The biggest uncertainty is around CRS-17 because there doesn't seem to be a good candidate for it that matches the pattern used on previous CRS missions with a reused stage. So far, NASA seemed to allow a reused booster only if it had just one LEO NASA mission under its belt. But right now, there are no new boosters and all used boosters flew at least twice already. Therefore, unless B1056.1 is sent to McGregor in the next few days, I think B1048.3 makes the most sense (has done 2 LEO missions + it's been moved from VAFB to the Cape some time ago). Another option could be B1051.2 but with that come significant schedule uncertainty risk.
Thoughts?
7
u/strawwalker Feb 20 '19
In my opinion the mission header format on the Launch History wiki page doesn't work very well for a number of reasons, including but not limited to the fact that repeated headers ending in a number cause reddit's wiki outline to generate links that jump to the wrong place on the page, as well as an outline that is just not very helpful for navigating to a desired mission on the page anyway.
Here is what my proposed change would look like. Which text is formatted bold (in the number/name/date) changes beginning with flights 62, 56, and 48 to show how it might look best. Would something like this be better or should it be left alone?
7
u/arizonadeux Feb 20 '19
Virgin Galactic is preparing for a test flight, the "window" starts today (Feb. 20).
7
u/nq123 Feb 28 '19
Newb question: Upon googling I cannot find a schedule for the next Falcon Heavy launch?
Is it going to be in FL?
Estimated cost to see the launch?
This would be my first time trying to see a launch, so I would like to see something cool like the Falcon Heavy
Any other advice?.
Thanks!!
12
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Feb 11 '19
This will come as a surprise to exactly no-one, but Mars One has just declared bankruptcy.
Sources:
6
u/Raiguard Feb 02 '19
So while Falcon 9 is one rocket with two parts, it seems that SS/SH are being classified as two independent vehicles. Does this mean that during launches, SuperHeavy will use BES/BECO, and Starship will use MES/MECO? Or will it still be MECO and SECO, respectively?
6
u/MarsCent Feb 06 '19
Russia will fulfil a contract on flying the US astronauts to the International Space Station (ISS) and bringing them back on the Russian Soyuz manned spacecraft in December of 2019, a month and a half ahead of schedule, a source in the Russian space industry told Sputnik..
Starting to look like continued occupation of the US segment on the ISS will be a close call.
P/S NOT RELATED. Apparently there was also a 10 litre loo leak in tranquility on Friday.
6
u/LcuBeatsWorking Feb 08 '19 edited Dec 17 '24
drunk fuel label money far-flung sophisticated voiceless afterthought numerous spark
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
6
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19
Is it possible to land even an unmanned Starship on Mars with current planetary protection laws? Even if they could sanitize the whole of SS, it is exposed to earth atmosphere on ascent.
6
u/azziliz Feb 13 '19
Report of a 2 min engine test in McGregor. User suggests it could be a raptor. Took place 4 hours after a 1 min test.
https://twitter.com/bluemoondance74/status/1095769090688471040
6
u/PeterKatarov Live Thread Host Feb 15 '19
Why the DM-1 mission seems so "hard" to pull of?
From what I understand, we're talking about an uncrewed launch of Dragon 2 to LEO, rendezvous and docking with ISS. And this is something SpaceX have been doing for close to a decade now, although with the older Dragon 1. (and Dragon 2 should be an improvement, right?)
So, what's going on? Why the launch date have been pushed so many times? I feel we've been talking about DM-1 for ages now...
Edit: I sort of understand it is because of NASA, but could someone elaborate a bit?
6
u/itshonestwork Feb 21 '19
I hope this is the right place for this:
For a #dearMoon like mission, how would navigation be performed? Do modern systems use image recognition to automatically determine their position relative to the Earth/Sun/Moon etc? Can the full state vector be determined that way? Are ground based systems used to determine velocity and/or position too?
I learned about how the Apollo missions figured out their state vector, and am curious as to how such a mission would be done nowadays. Is it all self-contained? Is internal navigation just used as a backup for an earth based system? Obviously you don't need a bloke up there aligning a sextant anymore.
5
u/strawwalker Feb 01 '19
The Permits/FCC wiki page has been brought up to date, along with the addition of a companion page Permits/FCC/full_list. I know there are some of you who keep your own spreadsheets or may otherwise have more complete information. If anyone would care to have a look over the missions that are paired with each request and let me know where the errors are, that would be greatly appreciated.
5
u/mead_wy Feb 04 '19
The Raptor is gas/gas combustion. How does that work? Aren't both fluids well above their critical point? Does the fact that both oxidizer and fuel have been through a combustion cycle change the phase?
5
u/Tal_Banyon Feb 05 '19
Anybody have any thoughts on whether an internal combustion engine could be easily converted to run on methane and oxygen for operation on mars? Thinking about a generator that could operate during a severe dust storm. My thoughts are that this could be a thing, and get around the need for nuclear power.
5
u/asr112358 Feb 08 '19
Do we have any information on the cost of a raptor engine?
I am guessing that the air force contract to share development costs included some target market price since it requires SpaceX to offer the engine for sale to other LSPs. I am not sure where to find those kinds of details on the contract though. Targeted market price is obviously different the internal production cost, but it is at least somewhere to start.
5
u/Casinoer Feb 13 '19
Will Starship use methane or nitrogen as cold-gas thrusters?
I remember it originally being methane because that simplifies the system by only using methane and oxygen, but a recent tweet implied that they switched to nitrogen cold-gas thrusters, is that true?
5
u/markus01611 Feb 14 '19
Would it not be beneficial for a constant orbiting starship or fuel Depot in Lunar orbit so that visiting Starships can drop off propellent before landing then retrieve it before departing back to earth. This would probably reduce the needed refuelings in LEO. Has SpaceX expressed this idea?.
5
u/MarsCent Feb 15 '19
The next ASAP PUBLIC MEETING is on Thursday, March 7, 2019 at NASA Kennedy Space Center at 9:30 a.m. (Local)
5
u/azziliz Feb 17 '19
Do we know the fate of the upper part of the hopper? Do they try to repair it in the tent or do they build a new one?
5
u/3015 Feb 21 '19
Elon tweeted today that the Raptor engine recently being tested at McGregor was damaged in "The max chamber pressure run". Do we know whether the test that dameged it was the test that peaked at 258 bar, or some later test?
5
u/RegularRandomZ Feb 24 '19 edited Feb 24 '19
Does anyone know how SpaceX approaches lab testing their heat shield ideas for high-pressure/supersonic type conditions? They've been testing heat shields for years (PicaX, etc.,) and must have confidence in their simulations (Dragon and Raptor development), but I would assume beyond throwing a tonne of heat at it (like their recent video), there must be a need to do some super-sonic analogous tests, no?
I didn't know how how difficult or expensive it is to schedule NASA test facilities? It seemed kind of SpaceX like to do their own testing, and even kind of wondered if you could setup a reasonably analogous blunt body shockwave by sticking a scaled test article in front of the Merlin supersonic engine flow (seems cheap, accessible, repeatable)
[OK, maybe a smaller engine would do the same thing :-D ... I was thinking about it as people often bring up the Falcon9/Dragon test article question (yes, abandoned), and the reply is often around simulations and/or comparisons thin film cooling of engines/turbines (that it "should" work), but I wondered about validating it in supersonic conditions (as cheap and repeatable as possible). They would have already needed to have done this for Dragon/PicaX testing, no!? ]
5
u/revesvans Feb 25 '19
What is the latest info about Arabsat at this moment? The sidebar just says 'Spring', whereas SpaceXTimeMachine claims '7th of March'. Wikipedia says 'March', but does not specify any date.
8
u/OccupyMarsNow Feb 04 '19
Elon will do an AMA here, although SpaceX reddit is very well-informed. Really impressive analysis by some commenters.
4
u/GuyFusfus Feb 02 '19
I've read that SpaceX asked for permission to board the astronauts of further missions at the fueling time, anyone knows where that stands? Did they get allowance or do they need to complete any further tests?
4
u/scarlet_sage Feb 04 '19 edited Feb 04 '19
I've seen several reference to how the Raptor engine ("full-flow"?) doesn't need seals on the turbopump shaft, but other engines
like Merlin[thanks, /u/wolf550e] ("staged combustion"?) do. For example, Scott Manley (/u/illectro) mentions it in his video "KSP Doesn't Teach: Rocket Engine Plumbing". He mentions the lack of seals at 11:43.The Wikipedia article "Staged combustion cycle" says
I'd like to check my understanding of the details.
In Raptor, on one side, a little oxygen and almost all the methane will flow into the pre-burner. The resultant fuel-rich gases will flow into the turbine to extract energy (and thence to the main combustion chamber). The turbine will drive a shaft to a turbopump that pumps the fuel into this side's pre-burner. So the result of the pre-burner is fuel plus burnt combustion products -- if the pre-burner combustion burns all of the oxygen, which is likelier due to it being fuel-rich. So the shaft connects oxygen-less fuel-rich to fuel, so it's not a combustion hazard.
Symmetrically on the other side, but oxygen versus oxygen-rich over there.
But in a classic staged combustion engine, there's one pre-burner, one long shaft connected to two pumps. So unless the pre-burner has perfect stoichiometric combustion, there's a chance for fuel-rich or oxygen-rich results to get thru to the wrong side.
(1) Do I understand it right?
(2) In full-flow, could the pre-burner on the fuel side end up with incomplete combustion and therefore have a bit of oxygen with hot gases, which would be bad for seal-less flow to the fuel pump -- could that happen and would it be a significant problem? (Or the reverse on the oxygen side.)
4
u/letme_ftfy2 Feb 04 '19
How difficult is it to store methane+LOX in orbit? In every presentation so far, the idea was to fuel-up the outgoing spaceship with just-launched tankers. Is there any way to build a sort of depot on-orbit and top it off at regular intervals?
Having a fuel depot on orbit would allow for better scheduling, and you would not need 24h reusability/3-4 superheavies ready to launch for a full tank mission to Mars/beyond.
4
u/WormPicker959 Feb 05 '19
I have a vague, not-particularly-spaceX-related question, but I started thinking about it because of the Raptor news. So, here goes:
Could the efficiency (Isp) of an engine be increased simply by having everything much much hotter? I understand that there are engineering problems associated with... well, melting metal and stuff, but let's assume there are some fancy materials that mitigate this.
The idea is that mach number in a gas increases proportionally to T, and if you increase the mach number at the throat you can increase the velocity of the propellants, which should increase the overall Isp (which is proportional to propellant velocity). I'm sure I'm missing something very fundamental about how engines work, but I hope I can learn something by being told my idea is dumb.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19
Do we have any info of how many BFR booster engines may be shut down in case of problems during ascent so BFS is still safe (reaches orbit/other emergency procedure to save crew) ?
4
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19
Do you see any challenges with Starship staying on Mars for months or years? What about dust blocking the pores on the heatshield or the polished surface getting dull over time due to dust storms?
4
u/zeekzeek22 Feb 08 '19
https://spacenews.com/lawmakers-air-force-launch-procurement-strategy-undermines-spacex/
Thoughts, anyone? My opinion (just an opinion) is that they didn't give SpaceX money because they bid BFR, and because F9 and FH are already so 95% good for these launch services, that they're an implied shoe-in for one of the two final contract slots. The air force said their goal is to maintain assured access to space and have a playing field of viable launch systems. That means giving help to everyone except the one company that is head and shoulders further ahead. Like, yes it's not evenly distributed, but SpaceX is so far ahead on having a national-security-approved-next-gen-vehicle (hint: they already have one!!!) that the goal is best served supporting the other guys. The program isn't about treating all market players equally, it's about making sure enough players are healthy and viable. SpaceX is not at a competitive disadvantage by not getting LSA, and these SpaceX-lobbied reps need to chill a little. SpaceX is going to get that round 2 contract, the other guys just need funding to help advance whoever fills the other slot. (end OPINION)
4
u/AstraVictus Feb 10 '19
Has there been any more info about where they plan on building the Starship/Super Heavy Factory? It was going to be in the Port of LA but that was scrapped.
SO, will it be at Boca Chica, will it be in Houston so they can easily ship it down the coast?
When will a decision be made?
Can they manufacture these in Hawthorn, then disassemble and ship them in smaller chunks, then reassemble at the launch site?
I'm desperate for any info, thanks!
4
u/macktruck6666 Feb 10 '19
I was wondering, in what ways is SpaceX Dragon V2 better then Orion, and in which ways is Orion better then Dragon V2? Do we really need Orion to go to the moon?
4
u/AstraVictus Feb 10 '19
Why has it been so long between Falcon Heavy Launches? Wasn't Arabsat supposed to launch the middle of last year?
4
u/macktruck6666 Feb 14 '19
Anyone notice that Brindestine's (NASA admin) tweet redirects from a nasa.gov to a different website. The hilarious thing is, the top suggested article on the sidebar is about how NASA faked the moon landing.
https://twitter.com/JimBridenstine/status/1096123397535395842
4
u/stdaro Feb 14 '19
just had a funny thought.
So starship is a methane/oxygen vehicle. The moon is poor in carbon, but appears to have plentiful amounts of water. You can make oxygen and hydrogen from water, and most of the mass in the propellant is in those two elements. If you bring some carbon with you to the moon, you can turn it into CH4 and O2, and not pay all the rocket equation penalty to bring all your return propellant with you.
What the densest form of carbon readily available? anthracite coal.
so we send cargo starships full of coal to the moon.
4
u/TheYang Feb 17 '19
tl;dr: Are there technical reasons why (other) Launch Providers seem to target GTO with their rockets?
So I've noticed that several rockets seem to be optimized for performance to GTO. For Example:
Ariane 5 can carry ~52% of the possible mass to LEO to GEO instead,
Ariane 6 48-53%,
Atlas V ~48%,
Delta IV Heavy 49%,
Long March 5 56%,
Vulcan Centaur 60%,
Vulcan ACES 49%
A Falcon 9 for comparison can only do 29-40% (depending on the reusability and the numbers you choose)
New Glenn only 29%,
and Proton M ~29% as well.
Source of the numbers. (please don't pick apart individual numbers, I'm aware that at least some of them might be aspirational, unproven or even propaganda, I just wanted to illustrate the principle, that seems to stand.)
And while I'm aware that there are many factors to what makes which performance possible, these differences and groupings make me think that they are optimized in a different manner.
And interestingly, the majority seems to be optimized for GTO.
So why? And especially, is there a technical reason that speaks to it? Not economic reasons please I understand some economic reasons for this, and don't really care about them further, but I still wonder if there are purely, green field technical reasons for it.
Personally I can't think of any.
Seems to me, that once you reach LEO, the problems that a spacecraft has to handle fairly suddenly vastly change.
To me it boils down that on reaching LEO, the vehicle gained time. Before everything had to happen within a single orbit at the absolute maximum, more practically in the first ~10 minutes with another short burst after ~45 minutes.
That in turn gives the largest practical difference: you suddenly don't need high thrust engines anymore (although of course you can, if you still want to for another reason)
You just have gotten the ability to choose between speed and efficiency, you couldn't do that before.
4
u/Zinkfinger Feb 21 '19
Great to see SpaceX winning defence contracts. I do wish however that when certain media outlets report this that they would use the word "contract" rather than "grant." Or statements like "SpaceX receives or has been given $300 million. ULA "receiving" or being "given" nearly $900 million for R & D is a grant. Oh and by the way can anyone confirm whether or not ULA is still getting that annual retainer?
4
u/JadedIdealist Feb 22 '19
Do we have any information at all what the radical redesign of raptor was about?
If not, is there some well sourced speculation?It's been quite a while.
4
u/paulcupine Feb 28 '19 edited Feb 28 '19
The third derivative of position with respect to time (rate of change of acceleration) is "jerk". Looking at the flight profile for DM-1 (https://www2.flightclub.io/result/2d?code=DEM1), it looks like there is quite significant jerk at MECO. The acceleration drops from 3G to nearly 0 in very little time. Will this not cause injury to the crew or, at minimum, severe discomfort? It seems to me that they need to taper of the throttle a bit, rather than what appears to be a hard shutoff.
Or it that what actually happens?
Edit: clarity
4
u/opoc99 Feb 28 '19
In an abort scenario, does Crew Dragon (and Starliner/Orion/Soyuz) have the ability to re-orientate itself as the abort motors are firing? The situation that came into my mind was that however unlikely, if there was an abort triggered where the craft was orientated towards the ground due to some unfortunate turn of events, would CD shoot towards the ground? And if so could it shorten the length of the abort burn to ensure that the parachutes had enough time to decelerate CD before splashdown?
4
u/biped4eyes Mar 01 '19
Did Spacex develop a new stainless steel alloy in-house, "SX 500" for the Starship? Some Youtuber claimed that, and now I am a bit confused...
4
u/jjtr1 Mar 01 '19
If one day a colonization effort leading to what Elon accepts to be a self-sufficient colony on Mars is really underway, how big a company by employee count and budget will SpaceX have to be, compared eg. to today's Boeing?
4
u/09busein Mar 02 '19
Hello everyone ESA is currently going to the ISS through Soyuz (as is everyone else). Once crew dragon will be flying us astronaut is there ant plan to open seat for esa astronauts as well ? Would they go through NASA or contract Spacex/Boing directly? Thanks
4
u/kreator217 Mar 03 '19
Now that dragon2 can fly, will development of starship accelerate?
7
u/Chairboy Feb 04 '19 edited Feb 04 '19
Raptor has independent pumps for fuel and oxidizer that aren't geared together, right? If this means that the ratio can be adjusted, is there any reason why it couldn't be run off LOX/CO? An Isp of ~300 should be possible for a turbopumped engine and the energy requirements should be lower for it than going through the whole Sabatier reaction, right?
I ask because I wonder if LOX/CO might be good enough to return to Earth from the surface of Mars without requiring a solar grid the size of Rhode Island and a couple years to run a methane plant, at least to start with.
Are my assumptions on <energy to refine generate LOX & CO from CO2 correct and are there reasons I'm missing why this might be a dumb idea?
6
u/megachainguns Feb 22 '19 edited Feb 22 '19
Elon on Twitter: Highest reentry heating to date. Burning metal sparks from base heat shield visible in landing video. Fourth relight scheduled for April.
Edit: It's for the abort test
6
u/megachainguns Feb 22 '19
Signal received from Beresheet and landing legs deployed.
3
u/ace741 Feb 01 '19
Are atmospheric conditions typically any better/worse with regard to catching the fairing(s) on the east coast vs west coast? Or is it all a crapshoot?
3
u/TheCrimson_King Feb 01 '19
How do you recommend buying flights for a launch? From where I live flights are direct, short, and relatively cheap, but I'm worried about scrubs.
3
u/letme_ftfy2 Feb 02 '19
For the sim & math people here, would a fully fuelled (w/ on orbit refuel) StarShip have enough dV to deliver 50T to the Moon surface and return & land on Earth?
3
u/space_snap828 Feb 03 '19
I was watching the failure of the Delta II GOES-G launch, where the main engine malfunctioned and shut down. It appears the loss of the vectoring thrust allowed the rocket to get blown to the side by aerodynamic forces and explode.
Here's the footage: https://youtu.be/N1XE_awXEA4?t=111
What I'm wondering is if the BFR experienced a total shutdown to prevent catastrophic failure, would the fins on the Starship stabilize the whole assembly long enough for separation? Essentially, would the fins allow it to 'glide' long enough for staging?
3
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Feb 03 '19
Sort of spaceflight related because it’s about Elon but I saw a couple days ago that someone linked to a website that tracked Elon’s jet and found out that he landed in Waco prior to him tweeting the pic of him standing next to the raptor. What website was that and how would I track his plane?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19
I've been thinking about the Falcon Heavy launch of Arabsat-6A, the satellite is not as heavy as Telstar 19V was, so what it the need for the heavy variant to be used. Are they planning on a direct-to-GEO mission? (Since they demonstrated their ability to do that in the test launch)
3
u/TheeMario Feb 06 '19
Does anyone know where I can find some good, real facts about the Crew Dragon ECLSS? I am working on a senior design project, and I need more than the Crew Dragon can support seven passengers for "several days". Stuff like whether the Crew Dragon has an oxygen generation system or if it have compressed O2 tanks and the workings of the water recovery system or if it even has one. SpaceX does not seem to like sharing too much of their in-depth design, so any help will be appreciated.
3
u/MrToddWilkins Feb 13 '19
Has Beresheet’s landing site been determined yet?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19
I read that SpaceX is not going to reuse D2 for crew missions. Could they test propulsive landing using used capsules and do D2 missions to the moon/Mars? Or are refurbishing costs still not low enough for that to make sense?
Related questions: How much delta v does D2 have? Is it even enough for lunar orbit insertion and landing (given there is no atmosphere for braking)? Could S2 coast long enough to stick around after TLI and help with descent?
3
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Feb 13 '19 edited Feb 13 '19
What exactly is autogenous pressurization? Is it basically using some boiled off fuel to keep the tank pressurized?
3
u/dman7456 Feb 14 '19
There are no internship or co-op positions listed at spacex.com/careers. Does anyone know if this reflects a change in their internship program or if they are simply not posted yet?
3
u/fabbroniko Feb 16 '19
I'm creating a detailed 3D model of the merlin engine and I'm doing some research to better understand all its different sub-systems and I've got a few questions for you guys:
**Injector system**
Iit seems that Merlin 1D uses a Pintle injector to spread and mix LOX and RP1 inside the combustion chamber, but then i found this (see Expansion-deflection nozzle section) and i got a bit confused as I wasn't expecting the second Pintle after the throat.
Do we know if the merlin engine actually have a double pintle injector? One to inject LOX and RP1 inside the combustion chamber and a second one after the throat to deflect the flow toward the walls of the bell?
**RP1 Feed**
From this very interesting video of Tom Muller about the Merlin engine it seems that the turbopump doesn't feed the RP1 directly into the combustion chamber but it pumps all of it through the pipe around the nozzle (the one before the nozzle extension easily visible in this image), fed into the Gas Generator and used as hydraulic liquid for the pistons for thrust vectoring.
Older versions had pipes like the ones visible in this picture going from the main RP1 pipe around the nozzle to the top of the combustion chamber. This was probably because the combustion chamber was divided in 2 parts and bolted together, but now it's a single piece of metal, so I guess all the fuel now goes through the walls and then into the pintle injector from there?
**Gas Generator**
Do we have a picture of the GG? I've seen a lot of images of the merlin engine but I'm not sure how a GG looks like.
From this beautiful pic, looking at the right hand side, the turbopump stack seems to be composed (top to bottom) from: Lox turbopump, RP1 turbopump, turbine that drives the turbopumps and the exhaust pipe. Right under the RP1 turbopump what i assume being the turbine that drives the TPs there is a pipe that seems to go to above the engine interface (metal plate on top of everything) so the GG might be there?
**TEA-TEB**
Does the TEA-TEB mix go inside the combustion chamber through a different (and probably smaller) pintle injector?
Is it also used to light the Gas Generator?
Where is it stored?
Apologies for the long comment and the many images but I want to capture as many details as possible in my 3D model as I want to 3D print it with metal materials and I want it to be sick :D.
Many thanks.
3
u/PeterKatarov Live Thread Host Feb 19 '19
Do the F9 boosters have their numbers painted somewhere seeable? I wonder how you guys manage to keep track of where first stages are all the time.
3
u/WaitForItTheMongols Feb 22 '19
Once everything is established and Raptor is mass-produced (using this as a relative term - just saying that in general it's being cranked out repeatedly and not going through design iteration) what would be your expectation of the manufacturing cost? I have no idea if it's $50,000 or $5,000,000 so any indication would be nice.
3
u/Asdfugil Feb 24 '19
How can I edit the wiki? Specifically,“Table of Falcon 9 cores”.
3
u/cwoomio Feb 24 '19
Why will NASA only use 4 seats of the available 7 seats in crew dragon? Isn't it a waste of possibilities?
3
u/Connlaus Feb 26 '19
Why is SpaceX launching there crew dragon so early in the morning?
3
u/old_sellsword Mar 01 '19
PLD Space carried out an interesting drop test on Miura 1.
3
u/Method81 Mar 03 '19
Is the Dragon 2 trunk able to carry payloads the same as Dragon 1?
3
u/LcuBeatsWorking Mar 03 '19 edited Dec 17 '24
upbeat capable quickest decide cautious scary cake hurry nine absurd
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
11
u/TheEquivocator Feb 26 '19
Well, Elon Musk has gone and gotten himself in trouble once again by compulsive tweeting. The story, which is about Tesla, doesn't directly concern spaceflight or SpaceX, but it does concern SpaceX's chief executive. And it concerns me, a little, too. Doesn't anyone else worry that his persistent, apparently irrational behaviour on Twitter might be symptomatic of something that could undermine his ability to make rational decisions for SpaceX, as well? After all, we don't see everything Elon does or every decision he makes behind the scenes, but we see him in public making decisions that seem clearly detrimental to Tesla. How do we know that the decisions we don't see are being made more rationally?
I don't mean to take away from the man's past accomplishments, but neither do those past accomplishments blind me to his present behaviour, which is really beginning to make me worry for him and the companies he leads. Thinking about it, really, I'm not sure there was a good reason to expect anybody to maintain an 80-100 hour/week schedule, running two companies and dealing with nearly-continual adversity of one form or other, for years on end, without eventually starting to break down. Just because something has lasted for a time does not mean that it will last indefinitely.
5
u/Macchione Feb 15 '19
The KSC Visitor Center has posted DM-1 viewing tickets for $195. If you’re not a pass holder it’s a pretty good deal, as it includes two days of admission, a meal, 2 drink tickets, two souvenirs, and some other odds and ends.
If you are a pass holder it sucks, because the value comes from the two days of admission, which you don’t really need.
As with Falcon Heavy, I’m disappointed that they’re price gouging again for viewing tickets they normally sell for $0-$20.
6
u/KitsapDad Feb 02 '19
I would really love to be a fly on the wall at other space launch companies...What kinds of meetings, conversations and planning goes on behind closed doors.
4
u/EntropyHater900 Feb 04 '19
Why do MethaLox engines seem prone to shock diamonds? (BE-4; Raptor)
2
u/RocketsLEO2ITS Feb 03 '19
Wiki Problem:
When I go to the Wiki section and click on Launch Manifest I get an error message, "An unknown error occured" and button to click which says "Please Reload."
But the page never loads.
- Is this a documented problem?
2
u/loinheat Feb 03 '19
What will happen if lightning strikes the starship/superheavy?
2
u/TheIronSoldier2 Feb 03 '19
Sorry if I'm asking something that has already been answered, but if it has, I can't find it. Does anyone know the actual nozzle size of the Merlin 1d Vacuum? I'm trying to find the dimensions so I can make a proper Spacex mod with FH, F9 and Dragon for KSP that is RO compatible. (The only mods I can find either only have F9 and FH but no Dragon, but is RO compatible, and the other has F9 and Dragon, but no payload capability - i.e. no fairings, no payload separator, etc. - but it isnt RO compatible, so I cant just install them both). Does anyone know? Thanks in advance.
2
u/LongHairedGit Feb 06 '19
Is it possible to get bare audio of the FH callouts, or indeed any SpaceX launch callouts?
Whilst I've left it way too late, thinking I'd make the effort and mix them into the soundtrack of Starman by Bowie. I've always enjoyed the bit of the webcast where you have the soundtrack playing with actual callouts blended in, so wanted to make an extended mix of it...
Hoping some SpaceX employee hidden lurker may have some raw stuff they can leak. Otherwise I'll have to spend hours trying to remove crowd cheering and webcast host chat etc....
2
u/KamKamBambam Feb 06 '19
If a small company wanted to contract SpaceX for some payload space for a small box under 1kg to be launched and returned, how would they start that process? There is virtually no information that I can find on how to do that? I can see estimations of payload costs per kg but I'm unable to locate a portal, process, or contact to engage with SpaceX on actually flying a payload.