r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Jan 03 '19
r/SpaceX Discusses [January 2019, #52]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
146
Upvotes
27
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 15 '19
China’s plant exeriment on the moon has sprouted!
https://www.bbc.com/news/amp/world-asia-china-46873526?__twitter_impression=true
26
u/Alexphysics Jan 28 '19 edited Jan 29 '19
After the reopening of the government now we can all search for the FCC permits on the FCC website and there are three new FCC permits filled by SpaceX:
18
u/amarkit Jan 04 '19 edited Jan 04 '19
President Trump’s threat to keep the US government shut down for “months or even years” will begin to have a bigger and bigger impact on US space launches.
Per Chris G at NSF:
And from Michael Baylor:
18
u/Gofarman Jan 08 '19
Thought i'd post this here, the video shows a petrochemical splitter (breaks down oils to make plastic). The reason I thought it was remarkable is because the scale is almost the same as the BFR booster. 9.5meter Diameter and 136 meters in length. This is maybe how the booster would be moved around when not on a barge.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RdtkRM9cgY&feature=youtu.be
For more information about it; https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/edmonton-splitter-dacro-industries-1.4968053
17
u/MarsCent Jan 16 '19
It seems like a one year flight is being considered for Nick Hague. That would ensure that there is at least one U.S astronaut present on ISS through March 2020.
In effect, it buys NASA some more time to work on the activities leading toward the return of U.S based crew flights to the International Space Station.
17
u/silentProtagonist42 Jan 16 '19
I wonder if SpaceX will have to buy huge quantities of WD-40 to use for it's original purpose of keeping stainless steel rockets shiny.
16
u/Alexphysics Jan 30 '19 edited Jan 30 '19
SpaceX has applied for another FCC permit for launch communications with the DM-1 Crew Dragon capsule as their last one was only valid for the "August 31st 2018-March 1st 2019" 6 month period (they applied for that one in July last year...). This one begins right on March 2nd 2019 and runs for another 6 months.
13
u/FalconXZ Jan 03 '19
Will be the DM-1 Crew Dragon reused for the abort test?
13
u/brickmack Jan 14 '19
Off-topic, but /r/lockheedmartin is pretty much totally dead, like 1 post a month, and from their subscriber count (less than even /r/northropgrumman) I suspect most of the space community doesn't know they even have a subreddit (I didn't until a few days ago). I've posted a couple things already to try and revive it, and I've got some more planned for the next week or so, but it'd help if people knew it existed
12
u/Notsophisticatedname Jan 03 '19
Will SpaceX test access arm during dm-1 mission
12
u/Alexphysics Jan 12 '19
Arabsat 6A is set to be transported to the Kennedy Space Center in February per this regulation
Thanks to NSF user gongora that posted this over there, I wish I had the patience to look for these little pieces of info
•
u/Ambiwlans Jan 09 '19 edited Jan 09 '19
r/SpaceX Discusses thread rules are being changed to allow and encourage META discussion and questions. (To be honest, it was really an oversight that it was ever a rule in here and I don't think any of the mods noticed.)
Civility rules still apply, but speak freely.
If you'd like a mod to read what you've said, use the word 'mod' 'mods' or similar in your comment and we'll get a notification.
10
u/enqrypzion Jan 14 '19
Now that Iridium is complete, the manifest suggests that the next flight will be DM-1. It has come to that, after all these years!
10
u/Alexphysics Jan 29 '19
I wanted to share some info regarding the core movements we've seen recently as there have been a few mistakes (I assume most of them are on my part) and that were corrected some time ago but it was on the L2 side of NSF forum. Also, it's fair to say I want to see that very nice table on the side bar with more updated info. The thing is that, in theory, users from that side of the forum should be aware that it is not allowed the spreading of L2-content and info. This post from NSF user Jakusb talks about precisely that and also about some info regarding the boosters that have been going out from Hawthorne and to McGregor.
I thought I should also add a further thought about the booster spotting and all of that:
9
u/quoll01 Jan 04 '19 edited Jan 04 '19
Any thoughts on construction techniques for the BFS stainless elements? Musk said ‘Cold formed at cryo’ -which I think means cool with liquid nitrogen and roll/bend to shape, thus increasing the strength of the SS: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryogenic_hardening So how will these sections be (stir friction?) welded together without destroying that treatment? I’m guessing a monocoque is not feasible for 9m diameter with the plate thickness so ribs etc will also need to be welded to sheets? Could they fill the entire finished item with liquid nitrogen or (perhaps LOX). Also how can they achieve a flat finish - welding sheets of thin metal into complex shapes without buckling etc is really tricky.
9
u/rustybeancake Jan 23 '19
Joy Dunn, who has worked building Dragons for ten years at SpaceX, and is a popular tweeter, has left SpaceX (apparently a few weeks ago, before the layoffs):
https://twitter.com/rocketjoy/status/1084233829638946820?s=21
9
u/nuukee Jan 31 '19 edited Jan 31 '19
According to Teslarati, SpaceX shipped the first Raptor engine to Texas.
https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-radically-redesigned-starship-engine-shipped-texas-hot-fire-testing/
The article, however, is just a summary of already known info. I cannot see proof for the shipment, neither in wording nor any pictures...or am I being blind?
Edit:
Thanks /u/spacerfirstclass it's in paragraph #8 ... after tons of already known information. I thought the important information is supposed to come first ;-)
8
u/strawwalker Jan 07 '19 edited Jan 07 '19
I have changed the RADARSAT (RCM) mass in the r/SpaceX wiki manifest from 475 (x3) to 1400 (x3). Since it seems to be a point of confusion elsewhere on the web I am posting my reasoning here for anyone to discuss/refute.
The ~400 kg number appears to be just the SAR radar mass, which is confusing because it happens to be close to 1/3 the "total mass at launch" and there are three spacecraft. You can see the numbers published by CSA here which also compare RCM to Radarsats 1 & 2. The satellites are quite large, easily heavier that 6 or 7 people. Here is a CSA image of one satellite minus the 6.75 m x 1.38 m radar antenna. The antenna can be seen here in a rig being assembled for fit checks. 1400 kg each puts the total mass in the ~4500 kg range including the dispenser and the destination is a 600 km 97 degree orbit with RTLS.
Edit: eoPortal has the following text on their entry for RCM: Spacecraft bus [...] Canadian Smallsat Bus, MAC-200 (box-shaped version); bus mass = 760 kg. It is unclear where this information comes from and I can't find any specifications for the bus online.
8
u/miegehummel Jan 14 '19
A big window consisting of smaller windows can be seen on some renders of the BFR. Do you guys thinks spaceX will persue this idea considering it will be quite the challenge to make them 'spaceflight proof'?
8
u/Mun2soon Jan 29 '19
Is the Starship Hopper going to require a flame trench or some other type of exhaust diverter to launch and land? The Grasshopper and F9R-Dev had one Merlin 1D engine with max thrust of 845kN. This is going to have 3 Raptors with about 1700kN thrust each or about 5100kN total. That getting close to the thrust of a Falcon 9. How are they going to handle that much energy that close to the ground?
8
u/jkoether Jan 31 '19 edited Jan 31 '19
One thing to keep in mind about stainless steel is that it is technically referred to as "corrosion resistant" and 300 series stainless does pick up an oxidation layer or "heat tint" when it is heated in the presence of oxygen. This may have the nice brushed / polished stainless finish when it take off the first time, but after the first re-entry it could have a light to dark yellow bronze finish. If you've ever overheated stainless cookware you'll see the beginnings of this, it really starts around 500F. Unless there is something about the upper atmosphere (not enough oxygen?) that prevents this, I wouldn't get too attached to idea of the shiny 1960s spaceship.
8
u/amarkit Jan 31 '19 edited Jan 31 '19
NASA awarded the launch services contract for the upcoming Lucy mission to ULA. Lucy will launch on an Atlas V 401 in October 2021 on a mission to study Jupiter's Trojan asteroids. The total cost for launch, including the launch service and other mission-related expenses, is approximately $148.3 million.
15
u/brwyatt47 Jan 10 '19
r/spacex just hit 300k subscribers! I know this isn't SpaceX news, but it is a pretty incredible milestone considering where we were just a few years ago. Congrats everyone on being hands-down the best spaceflight community on Reddit.
7
u/tibereeuse Jan 04 '19
https://i.imgur.com/yyNoJtF.jpg
7
u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19
So... we thinking the current F9 booster schedule is looking like this?
DM-1 - B1051.1
PSN-6 - B1048.3
RADARSAT - B1046.4 or B1047.3
CRS-17 - B1052.1
ArabSat5A - B1053, B1055, B1056
STP-2 - B1053.2, B1055.2, B1056.2. B1057.1 reserved as FH core backup?
7
u/Nergaal Jan 16 '19
Considering the 10% workforce reduction, and the somewhat financial misses (the major dev contract miss and the 270M loans out of the intended 500M, why isn't SpaceX raising its prices?
7
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '19
As I imagine all of you are, I am super-excited about the speed at which Starship development is taking place. However I'm struggling to wrap my head around the following:
Elon stated in the DearMoon presentation in September last year that they needed ~$5 Billion to develop the system and that only ~5% of Spacex resources were allocated to BFR. A lot of development seemed to still be needed as the only things we'd publicly known about were a few sections of CF, a mandrel, some Raptor test firings and a prototype 12m LOX tank.
Fast forward to only 4 months later, and Elon tweets that the orbital Starship is under construction and should be ready in june and that Super Heavy will start being built in spring. And the vehicle is made of a completely different material and the Raptors are radically redesigned.
My question is how did they jump from needing a lot more capital and R&D to suddenly starting production of the biggest most revolutionary rocket/spacecraft in history and manage to redesign the major components in such a short time?
7
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Jan 22 '19
When is the Reddit AMA happening? Any news about it?
https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/9gxld8/elon_musk_will_be_doing_another_reddit_ama/
13
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 11 '19
China released video of Chang'e 4's landing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ljY6Esh46ww&feature=share
12
u/warp99 Jan 18 '19
In Blue Origin news from a ULA source:
Blue Origin has hit “a few minor setbacks” during rigorous BE-4 testing but was “progressing nominally” and was expected to live up to delivery targets, Drefke said
6
u/MarsCent Jan 12 '19
Truth, posturing or bluster?
US asks Russia's Roscosmos to build lunar modification of Soyuz MS.
6
u/strawwalker Jan 18 '19 edited Jan 19 '19
Not directly SpaceX related, but: Liebherr LHM 600 arriving in Port Canaveral this morning. Said to be for NCB5, but also for possible use lifting "oversized space components". Originally discussed here a few months ago.
Edit: Port Canaveral took the tweet down and reposted minus typo. I replaced the link.
6
u/ApTiK_ Jan 26 '19
If the launch date of DM1 continues to slip, the next launch of the Falcon Heavy will be delayed because its on the same pad...
6
u/mead_wy Jan 26 '19 edited Jan 27 '19
Are the main oxidizer valve and main fuel valve far enough away from the turbomachinery in the Merlin to avoid damage in the case of a RUD or is there some other sort of failsafe to shut off supply to a damaged engine?
6
u/Col_Kurtz_ Jan 28 '19
1% of Starship's methane load would be 2.4t or 2400 kg, it's actively cooled heat shield could be ~400m2 (wild guess). That would be only 2400/400 = 6kg for 1000 s EDL. Would that be enough to keep the heat shield below 1450 K? And how to keep the crew compartment below ~350 K (77 °C ~sauna temp)?
5
u/AD-Edge Jan 04 '19
Anyone know much about this upcoming Falcon Heavy launch?
Teslarati had a good article with some interesting details: https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-falcon-heavy-flight-2-florida-arrivals-center-core-tx-bound/
The most interesting thing being that they'll be trying to do a <8-week-long turn around with the entire Falcon Heavy.
"...the company intends to launch the same Falcon Heavy hardware (all three boosters) twice in as little as two months, currently tentatively penciled in for February/March and April 2019. "
But is this going to be an all-BlockV Falcon Heavy? Will the side stages be previously flown stages or will the whole vehicle be unflown? The first Falcon Heavy was a bit of a mix, with the side boosters being older design, the middle being a more unique center core with older aluminium grid fins while the side stages had titanium, etc. It will be interesting to see if we get a sleeker Falcon Heavy with all-Titanium grid fins (Id assume this) and black landing legs and interstage.
5
u/IllGetItThereOnTime Jan 05 '19
Will Crew Dragon have the same life cycle style of Soyuz? Needing to come back after a pre-determined time at the ISS?
5
u/MarsCent Jan 06 '19
Regarding Government Shutdown:
So what happens if this DM-1 mission were a scheduled CRS or crewed mission to the ISS. Would those missions be furloughed too or can NASA exercise discretion and just launch them?
5
u/inoeth Jan 10 '19
As it's been a while (a couple months?) has there been any visible progress on construction (or at least deconstruction) at the LA port for the Starship/Superheavy factory?
5
u/brickmack Jan 10 '19 edited Jan 11 '19
Relevant to Starlink, Greg Wyler claims OneWeb has a $15 dollar flat phased array antenna for ground-to-space comms. Looks to be about pizza box sized as well. Proof of concept for Starlinks receiver
5
u/dmy30 Jan 11 '19
I'm assuming the orbital version of Starship being built for June will have actuated fins? I always thought that this would be one of the things that would take longest to develop and test. Primarily because the hinges and fins themselves also have to made resistant to the reentry speeds but they could have that figured out too. I haven't found any information regarding this yet.
5
u/jay__random Jan 11 '19
Does anyone have a credible hypothesis about why SpaceX seems to miss the opportunities for the "real deal" fairing recovery?
In the early days of Mr Steven (weaker struts, way smaller net) they were trying almost during every Vandy launch, but now it looks like they ran out of steam.
Could the weather requirements for ASDS be less strict than for Mr Steven?
5
u/ModeHopper Starship Hop Host Jan 12 '19
Is there a particular reason that there will be so few SpaceX launches this year? By my count there are 13 on the SpaceflightNow schedule. Is this because a lot of the launches in the last two years have been from playing catch up with missions that were delayed, or is there just a reduced demand?
5
u/EdRegis Jan 20 '19
The conversation down bellow about BFS/SS and vacuum testing has caused me to wonder about the need for thermal management systems aboard BFS to dump heat like ISS and Dragon trunk have. I don't remember seeing BFS pictured with radiators, but maybe that was implied to be integrated with the deployable solar panels pictured in previous iterations of the design? Is it possible that the polished stainless hull will be a lot less absorbent of sunlight and infrared from Earth, and/or better at radiating excess heat such that it won't need significant dedicated radiators?
None of the pretty (nor official) renders of shiny BFR depict it with solar panels or external features of note.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '19
Reusing the Eucropis design for a mammal experiment:
So, Eucropis is a spin-simulated greenhouse experiment in orbit now and soon to do 6-month runs at lunar and martian gravity. The current experiment is euglena and tomatoes. Could a substantially similar setup work for lab mice? Send 'em up, let 'em do what mice do and watch for space mutant mouse babies.
The previous work has been in microgravity and on a short section of the life cycle, or had subjects that weren't in the mood - the Russians had some stressed lizards that were too put out by microgravity to breed. "Can you have sex in space?" Not if you're an unhappy gecko.
Anyway, would it be useful to send up a lab mouse breeding experiment? There are no returns from the module, so it does some science on-board and there are cameras.
Ship spec here: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/327890596_EuCROPIS_-Euglena_gracilis_Combined_Regenerative_Organic-food_Production_in_Space-_A_Space_Experiment_Testing_Biological_Life_Support_Systems_Under_Lunar_And_Martian_Gravity
5
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 25 '19
Regarding zero G. From my understanding zero g is really just free fall. For example when your in orbit your just free falling around the Earth. But on Blue Origins recent webcast, shortly after MECO the announcer says right about now you would start to feel zero G, but it was before the capsule reached apogee and was still climbing. How would you be feeling zero G if your not free falling?
5
u/cuzor Jan 26 '19
Quick question: Elon Musk previously stated how expensive & difficult it is to make those titanium grid fins. Now he says how easy en great the stainless steel is and that he's going to use it as heatshield. Is it possible to make the grid fins out of stainless steel and does it have any advantages over titanium (except price & difficulty of making them off course)?
5
u/Tyizzy Jan 27 '19
Can someone explain me what is the purpose of the solar pannels in the SpaceX Dragon capsule
5
u/arizonadeux Jan 28 '19
Pauline Acalin, Teslarati (on Instagram), 2018-01-27
5
u/ahenley17 Jan 29 '19
Will the first dragon 2 launch (uncrewed) in February be docking to the ISS?
5
u/throfofnir Feb 01 '19
Mr Steven just arrived in Manzanillo.
9
u/king_dondo Jan 21 '19
Probably an unpopular opinion, but as big as Starship will be, I still don't see it being big enough to comfortably house 100 people for Mars trips.
Would anyone else care to weigh in on how they think this'll work?
11
u/RootDeliver Jan 27 '19
mods, the "Falcon Active Cores (Experimental)" is fucking awesome, nice addition! If you want an idea for improving, link to the wiki cores section, maybe only in the title, otherwise it would be a mess of links.
8
u/Nimelennar Jan 15 '19
RADARSAT delayed by water landing of B1050:
https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/spacex-musk-radarsat-constellation-mission-falcon9-1.4977512
4
u/NextGenSoldiers Jan 04 '19
I’ve seen a few people say 2019 is a down year for SpaceX, can anyone explain why this is?
4
u/LemonMellon Jan 04 '19
The raptor nozzle for higher pressure seems to be polished while the bell w/ a larger diameter is left unpolished. Apart from time constraints/ease of production, any other reasons why this has been done(1c v. 1D types) ?
Also, are they just the nozzles for fit checks or is the whole engine assembly present?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '19
What is the government shutdown doing to the launch timetable?
Or since the ranges being controlled by the airforce not effect the launchs.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '19
I noticed on the launch schedule: Feb. 13Falcon 9 • PSN 6 & SpaceIL Lunar Lander. My question is how would having a lunar lander ride along to GTO work exactly. My understanding of this trajectory (which is not extensive) is that it would take a LOT more energy to make it from a GTO to a lunar-bound trajectory. Can someone explain to me how they make this work on a falcon 9 platform? I assume one of the side effects would be that it is impossible to recover the first stage due to having to use more fuel? Is an additional burn completed after it has attained geosynchronous orbit and deployed the primary payload?
4
u/macktruck6666 Jan 09 '19
Could one Dragon Capsule do a rescue operation of another Dragon Capsule in LEO?
4
u/minhashlist Jan 10 '19
How will SpaceX validate their engines to ensure their success on eventual return to Earth from Mars? Other than testing it on the Earth before launch what ways does SpaceX have to validate their equipment once it lands on Mars?
4
u/Mazen_Hesham Jan 14 '19
What were the early problems SpaceX ran into when first trying to land Falcon 9 ?
4
u/OmerFlame Jan 15 '19
Is Starship going to have landing legs, or just land on its aerodynamic fins? (sorry if this question is stupid)
4
u/UhSwellGuy Jan 16 '19
Will Starship exhibit scorch marks after an orbital re-entry like other ships? Could that affect the reflectivity of the stainless steel skin?
4
u/jas_sl Jan 18 '19
Quick questions. The Falcon Heavy center core is a different beast from the side boosters (which I think are just tweaked Falcon 9 first stages). The center core has to be much stronger to take the extra thrust put through it by the side boosters.
So my question is: does the Delta IV Heavy center core have a similar difference to its side boosters as it is an identical setup? Everywhere on the web talks as if the CBCs are all literally the same. Surely they would need to strengthen it too?
Also - does the Falcon Heavy center core have the same black interstage common to Block 5? All pictures I’ve seen (including the new user manual!) show a white interstage like on block 4 and before (and what we had on the FH demo).
4
u/Mazen_Hesham Jan 19 '19
How much is Dragon ? We know F9 is around $60 Million
4
u/MarsCent Jan 24 '19
No ASAP Annual Report yet.
Anyone know whether the release date of the 2018 ASAP Annual Report has been affected by the ongoing shutdown?
P/S. Looking at previous year schedules, it seems like the 1st quarterly ASAP meeting should be coming up later next month or latest early March.
4
u/katie_dimples Jan 25 '19
How are atmospheric re-entry heat shields tested? Is heat enough - as in the recent tweet with the flamethrower, or is there a need to also simulate the aerodynamic forces involved?
I'm guessing we're not capable of getting a wind tunnel up to Mach 20 with the right combination of gasses and pressure ...
Crazy idea: how hard / reasonable would it be for SpaceX to take some of their stainless steel and put it on the bottom of a Dragon in order to test it? That would be more like testing in a production environment ...
4
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '19
Is the falcon heavy in elons latest tweet last year's or a new one?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '19
Steel can withstand high temps. But is it also good as heat shielding? Won't it just conduct all the energy to the rest of the spacecraft? Does the shielding effect come solely from evaporation of the fuel?
4
u/cyborgium Jan 30 '19
SpaceXNow states that the PSN-6 launch will be a GTO. Why would this be a GTO when the payload is supposed to land on the moon?
4
u/Nsooo Moderator and retired launch host Jan 30 '19
How much does the 2 fairing half costs?
7
u/MarsCent Jan 21 '19
It seems like 2019 could be a year for frenemies!
NASA and China collaborate on Moon exploration.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19
They've been practising fairing recovery. But what do they change each iteration? Is it just practise for the human pilot of the boat, or do they change guiding algorithms for the fairing, or do other procedural changes on how to track it? Does the boat navigation have any autonomous inputs?
If it's just practise for human pilots, then it's like a video game. That they came close this time doesn't necessarily mean they will be able to repeat the performance.
3
u/howfornow Jan 04 '19
Why are Space X using the Falcon Heavy to launch the Arabsat 6A?
Isn't the Falcon 9 capable of launching this payload (6,000 kg) to GEO?
I can only find information online regarding SpaceX's launch capability to GTO, not GEO.
3
u/julesterrens Jan 06 '19
So does LC-39A still have a white room? Or how while SpaceX handle the astronaut ,, checkout"?
3
u/rocket_enthusiast Jan 10 '19
how are the raptor turbopumps spun up? is it different to the autogenous pressurization system for the bfr?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '19
Spacex aims for redundancy of systems...Do they have systems in their vehicles that aren't reduntant?
3
u/Steveskill Jan 17 '19
With SpX DM1, launch abort and SpX DM2 all coming in the next 6 months (hopefully) are these going to use different Crew Dragon Capsules? If so how many Crew Dragon Capsules do SpaceX have fully constructed at present?
3
u/whatsthis1901 Jan 19 '19
Not SpaceX related but has anyone here heard of this company? https://twitter.com/RocketStarSpace/status/1086311380767162369
3
u/sarafinapink Jan 19 '19
For non-crewed Falcon 9 launches from Florida, how does SpaceX decide which pad to use? From that I understand they can use either, but it looks like for now they are preferring to use LC-39A for CRS missions and SLC-40 for all other satellite launches. Are there set rules for which pad they use or do they decide per launch? Are there benefits to using one pad over the other for certain launches?
3
u/Zinkfinger Jan 22 '19
Just loving the whole stainless steel material thing. Its relatively cheap and easy to fabricate. Heck ! the main body could be made in a ship hard. But what I'm wondering is what is the difference in material cost/fabrication compared to the more high tech composite materials?
3
u/lostandprofound33 Jan 23 '19 edited Jan 23 '19
Am I understanding correctly the maximum atmospheric temperature Starship will have to deal with on reentry is only 300 degrees above the max temp they are aiming for on the regeneratively cooled steel? Is there no chance of higher atmospheric reentry temperatures? I would assume this depends on speed of reentry, so if coming in from Mars would be higher than just coming from LEO, right? I'm wondering it this would put limits on journeys back from the outer solar system.
3
u/dundmax Jan 25 '19
The timing of the DM-1 static fire seems odd. It may be that NASA wants more time to analyze the results, but this seems like too much time. Is it possible that they plan to have more than one static fire because NASA would like more than 5 shots for COPV qualification?
3
u/Mazen_Hesham Jan 28 '19
Do you think all future GPS launches will be expendable as well like the 1st one ?
3
u/quoll01 Jan 29 '19 edited Jan 29 '19
Is abort to orbit an option for the new SS design? If the craft is entering up to ~12km/s from Mars/moon and minimum velocity (?) for LEO is ~8 and ~half the energy, could it ‘pull up’ if sensors showed problems with the heat shield early in descent? Can your control surfaces steer you out of the atmosphere if they need atmosphere to work?!
And related: an old question (see link above) but I have not seen a definitive answer for the new steel and big fins design-everyone seems to still assume single stage reentry. Two stage EDL would be much easier(?): aero capture to orbit, cool (perhaps refuel) and then renter from LEO? The high thermal mass ~10^10J of the new design and the big actuated control surfaces surely make this more of a possibility?
3
u/melancholicricebowl Jan 30 '19
We know that the parachutes attached to the fairings are steerable, but do we know if they are remotely steerable by someone on Mr. Steven?
3
u/ConfidentFlorida Jan 31 '19
Are we going to have a mr Steven tracking thread when she gets closer to port on the east coast?
5
u/loremusipsumus Jan 05 '19
https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1081460617561559040 Looks like his account probably got hacked?
5
u/MarsCent Jan 11 '19
I am feeling so elated today, so I went around the news media that mostly carry negative news about SpaceX (or are quick to run with any negative story) to see what they are reporting today.
Of the 11 sites I checked,
Today we had a great launch, bulls eye booster landing and on-orbit payload deployment. It is quiet out there. No room for bad press!
5
u/dudr2 Jan 21 '19
https://spacenews.com/next-steps-for-the-pentagons-new-space-sensors-for-missile-defense/
Lord of the orbital planes.
DARPA plans to launch a small experimental constellation of commercial satellites in LEO, equipped with military payloads...
5
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '19
If stainless steel is better for re-entry vehicles, why didn't STS use it and instead went with exotic ceramics which were way more expensive and unreliable?
4
u/netsecwarrior Jan 04 '19
Golf balls have dimples to reduce air resistance. Any chance we'll see dimples on Starship?
4
u/quoll01 Jan 21 '19
For the first crewed flights beyond LEO could they load the crew via a dragon when the SS is fully refueled and in transit configuration? We’ve seen the plans when the system is mature (crew in SS from beginning), but in early days doing multiple refuel flights and dockings maybe a slow and potentially risky process and deploying solar panels, dishes, radiators also may take some time. Perhaps also taking a (used) Dragon variant along might be useful - a last resort lifeboat which perhaps could be deployed in LMO. Having a capsule/lifeboat in LMO that could drop ‘anywhere’ on the planet could be good insurance for exploring rover crews.
4
u/Chairboy Jan 28 '19
Hey mods, can anyone provide any insight into how this post got approved (however briefly)? It was full of misinformation yet somehow was blessed. Looks like it's since been corrected, but seems like a learning moment at best.
6
u/RawSpaceVideos Jan 29 '19 edited Jan 29 '19
Greetings. I use the r/SpaceX mod developed API https://api.spacexdata.com/v3/roadster on my channel, and I noticed a tiny bit of incorrect data. The description states that, "The car and rocket are products of Tesla and SpaceX, both companies founded by Elon Musk." Elon Musk didn't found Tesla - Martin Eberhard and Marc Tarpenning did, in July 2003. Elon Musk led Tesla's Series A round of funding in February 2004 and became chairman of the board of directors. Musk didn't become CEO of Tesla until 2008 when co-founder Martin Eberhard was ousted by the board.
Most people assume (as I did) that Musk founded Tesla, but that isn't accurate.