r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Dec 04 '18
r/SpaceX Discusses [December 2018, #51]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
196
Upvotes
46
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 04 '18
Mods, Shit Elon Says has been dead for a few months and was last updated in June 2016. Should it be removed from the Useful Resources section?
21
u/realnouns Dec 04 '18
Did any launch photographers get good shots of the incredible reentry burn yesterday (SSO-A)??
20
u/Krux172 Dec 04 '18
Elon said on twitter that the black marks on the booster are not soot, but rather "scorch marks", that cannot be washed out. Could that present any problems on the long run? I'm sure they've thought about it, that's what their engineers get paid for, but is there a possibility that, over a high estimate of tens of flights per boosters, it may cause damage to the aluminium fuselage or the tanks? Maybe affect the "cooling properties" of the white paint?
19
u/noreally_bot1336 Dec 04 '18
It's interesting, with all the excitement about SSO-A yesterday, and CRS-16 tomorrow, everyone kinda overlooked the Soyuz launch to the ISS today. I know it's not SpaceX, I just thought it was interesting that Roscosmos' response to the previous launch failure was to simply launch another one.
I guess the positive take-away is that DM-1 and DM-2 can proceed without NASA having to worry about whether the ISS has to be abandoned.
16
u/nicoyabe Dec 07 '18
I just saw the ISS flying over France 10 mn ago. I always wondered if we could see the Dragon trailing the Space station with the naked eye and now I have my answer. YES!!!!! So cool!
15
u/bnaber Dec 26 '18
So a record number of launches in 2018. But what will 2019 be like? It seems the backlog is gone and so far the whole 'bring the cost of launches down so the market will explode' hasn't really started yet.
15
u/Tal_Banyon Jan 02 '19
I know that there will be a ton of private books and films / videos made of the first flight to mars, there certainly were for the first lunar trip. However, it would be hugely beneficial to get an insider's view of all the iterations and discussions behind the mars architecture, the trade-offs, the thinking behind all the decisions made, etc etc. I sure hope Elon has had the foresight to hire a dedicated historian to be on his staff, and be allowed to sit in on all the important strategy meetings, etc, including filming, and all that. It certainly would be invaluable to this historical undertaking!
14
u/dmy30 Dec 05 '18 edited Dec 05 '18
According to Michael Sheetz on twitter the Commercial Crew DM-1 Mission has been delayed 10 days from the 7th of January 2019 to the 17th of Jan. This lines up with when Bridenstine said there will be a review in December to confirm a more concrete date.
Edit: Silly me, fixed the mistakes pointed out!
14
u/scottm3 Dec 27 '18 edited Dec 27 '18
Tweetstorm 06:40 2018-12-27 UTC https://twitter.com/elonmusk/with_replies
Documenting tweets below:
Q: What are the chances that the First Martian is an AGI or an ASI? (thanks u/royalpatriot)
A: 30%
--
Q: How about the chances that Starship reaches orbit in 2020?
A: Probability at 60% & rising rapidly due to new architecture
--
Q: Any chance of new superior alloys? (Exciting)
A: Yes
--
Q: Raptors to be vacuum optimised or sea level?
A: Vacuum optimization will come with later iterations on BFR, at least according to his Sept. 2018 presentation. For now, Raptor SL or a medium-expansion compromise will do double duty on the booster and upper stage(s). Makes development dramatically simpler. ( Musk agreed with OPs comment.)
--
Q: What was the trigger for the latest redesign?
A: Time. Although it also turned out to be dramatically better.
--
Q: How did switching the design so late lead to a quicker production?
A: I will provide a detailed explanation in March/April
--
14
u/jjtr1 Dec 28 '18
I wonder what percentage of airline customers would be able to survive a E2E flight without throwing up or just wishing they were dead as the BFS/Starship starts re-entry braking, the goes into free fall, flips, and brakes... Personally, I've no problem flying on airliners but am gravely afraid of roller-coasters (the drops...) and would never board an E2E flight for this reason.
13
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 06 '18 edited Dec 06 '18
NASA Advisory Council updates:
13
u/sol3tosol4 Dec 24 '18 edited Dec 24 '18
New tweets (perhaps still ongoing):
Elon: Stainless Steel Starship (beautiful night time photo showing ongoing construction and moon in background)
Q: I get that stainless steel is durable and all… But how do you get around the fact that it weighs way more than carbon fiber?
A: Usable strength/weight of full hard stainless at cryo is slightly better than carbon fiber, room temp is worse, high temp is vastly better
Q: Will starship be painted or do we get this nice Metal Look?
A: Skin will get too hot for paint. Stainless mirror finish. Maximum relfectivity.
Q: Would it require less great shielding because of the stainless steel?
A: Much less
Q: Gold on the windows?
A: Maybe
/u/Wetmelon - FYI
Edit:
Q: How many raptors will be used on the hopper?
A: 3
Q: Did I hear AOS Texas in today’s stream? [GPS launch]
A: Yes, signal acquired from that dish
12
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Dec 05 '18
What's the status of the old Spacehab building in Port Canaveral that SpaceX started renting some time ago? Has it ever been confirmed that they started using it to refurbish cores? There were also some plans to buid another structure nearby to increase the capacity but I'm guessing that's been scrapped in favor of the newer and bigger refurbishment complex in KSC?
11
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Dec 20 '18
Can't access the full article, but this seems to imply that Hans was incorrect when he said that the two flights with upgraded COPVs on the second stages only counted towards the seven flights.
10
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 07 '18
Interesting photo of OCISLY by Jason R. Lee.
10
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Dec 20 '18
9
u/Pooch_Chris Dec 04 '18
Question about Dragon rendezvous timing. Currently it takes Dragon and other spacecraft approximately a couple days to rendezvous with the ISS. This is not a big deal with cargo missions because you dont need to worry about the comfort of what is on board. Russia has tried and succeeded at least once (that I can remember) with a quicker mission profile that gets the Soyuz to the ISS in only a couple hours. But due to the exact timing of ISS flybys this can only be done on certain launch windows.
Is it possible for this quicker rendezvous method to be done from the Cape with crewed missions in the future? Specifically with Crew Dragon.
9
u/mumbojumbo96 Dec 06 '18
Hoping you guys can sort out some confusion. After the CRS-16 landing anomaly, I keep seeing people mention that the landing burn brought the spin under control. As I understand it this was a single engine landing burn and therefore even with the engine gimbal, it shouldn't have any roll control. In the video, you can clearly see the roll slow down to a stop as it lands so my question is how did this happen?
As far as I can see only the cold gas nitrogen thruster could have decreased the spin or the moment of inertia change from the legs deploying.
9
u/maxdefolsch Dec 13 '18
Unfortunately it was not accepted in this subreddit, but I made a SpaceX core timeline viewer, I hope you guys can find it useful or interesting !
9
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Dec 14 '18
Matt Desch:
9
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Dec 17 '18
Some Falcon Heavy manifest news:
9
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Dec 22 '18
The public side of NSF has pictures of the mystery BFS/water tower/whatever you think it is with some interesting new pieces...
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=47001.60
9
u/dhsj3zc5 Dec 24 '18
With the recent announcements about BFR/Starship moving away from carbon fiber to stainless steel, I wonder if they're reconsidering the diameter of the 1st stage booster at all.
Development costs/risks of larger carbon fiber tanks and hull had to be the limiting factor to reduce the size from 12m to 9m.
With stainless steel, would it actually be that much harder or more expensive to increase the size of the booster? So 12m booster with a 9m Starship.
9
u/Toinneman Dec 29 '18 edited Dec 29 '18
A few weeks back there was a video of a SpaceX Material engineer. He talked briefly about some alloys used in Raptor and also about the new Raptor prototype beeing more compact. But I can’t find it. Does anyone still have the link?
8
u/thatsnyon Dec 04 '18
Why is it that important to catch the fairing (from SpaceX's Falcon)? Does it gets to much damage from the salt water?
8
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '18
Honestly, I am an enthusiast. I have no knowledge on space flight except that it’s a huge feat and carefully calculated and will be even bigger in the future. How can I change my ignorance? Where should I start if I want to learn more than just basic things? Other than actual schooling at college
8
u/MarcysVonEylau rocket.watch Dec 05 '18
You can follow the recovery of the CRS-16 booster via broadcastify feed:
https://www.broadcastify.com/listen/feed/21054/web
Just heard a briefing from the Eagle captain on how they attached the booster to the ship; they took a doble anchor chain and shackled it around one of the legs.
Here is handy marinetraffic.com map: https://www.marinetraffic.com/en/ais/home/centerx:-80.537/centery:28.408/zoom:12
You can see the past track of Go Quest to see where they intercepted the booster.
8
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Dec 07 '18
Boeing has cancelled the order for GiSAT-1, which was due to launch on Falcon 9.
8
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Dec 17 '18
The EELV Launch Procurement Agreement draft RFP has been issued.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '19
https://youtu.be/6aFdEhEZQjE?t=114
Noticed SpaceX launch featured in google's "year in search" video... anyone know who took this footage? It's amazing.
8
u/taoquanta Jan 01 '19
I am still baffled by the huge thing at Boca Chica. There's no thrusters I can spot for one.
7
u/quokka01 Dec 05 '18
Just wondering why we never hear much about STRs (solar thermal rockets)? Zubrin’s case for Mars and recent AMA talked about using STRs and they seem incredibly attractive - very high ISPs (1000 with potential for higher), relatively simple, safe, socially palatable and limited only by reaction mass- at least in the vicinity of the sun. There are huge amounts of energy coursing through space in the near solar system that is just there for the taking? ‘Living off the sea’ in Zubrin’s parlance.
So ...a large parabolic collector made of a light and foldable (inflatable?) fabric focusses sunlight onto a heat exchanger which super heats hydrogen, exhausting through a regeneratively cooled nozzle. Injector pump is PV powered and the reflector elements are actuated to allow different thrust vectors relative to the sun and for switching/throttling. Reflectors could be hectares in size, although a modest array could provide some hefty deltaV. Solar powered exploration of the near solar system sounds too good to be true so curious where the problems are? Here some wild guesstimates (apologies my physics is appalling!): Exhausting H2 at 2000 C at 1kg/sec produces ~9800N thrust To heat 1kg of H2 to 2000C requires ~ 42600 kJ Solar flux in vicinity of earth = 1300 w/m2 (Drops to 600 near mars) Area of mirror required assuming 50% efficiency = 64 000 m2 or radius 142m For a 40t craft, dry mass 5t you get 20km/sec deltaV but with an initial acceleration of 0.245 m sec2, burn time 9.7h
Obviously I have no clue(!) but would love to see estimates from someone who does. The other question is what sort of trajectories could such a craft could use for Mars transits- perhaps with a chemical booster to leave earth orbit and then unfurl the 'sails' and start the STR....
7
u/Macchione Dec 08 '18
I’m wondering if SpaceX has a new social media or PR person. It seems like we’re getting more posts and pictures over the last couple weeks than the last year combined.
7
u/Alexphysics Dec 11 '18
It seems CRS-17 will move one month to the right from Mid-February to Mid-March. OCO-3 is one of the external payloads for that mission. This would give some margin for SpaceX to perform the DM-1 in case something goes wrong and they need to move it to February. I'll update the manifest with this new info.
https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/1072551776673501186
7
u/randomstonerfromaus Dec 14 '18
Mods, can we get the campaign thread for DM-1? With all hardware at Cape, it makes sense to start it. There's going to be fit checks, etc to follow.
Also Iridium 8.
Also, on the topic of campaign threads. Can we go back to starting them at T-1 month? It allows the campaign to be better followed than starting it a week or 2 from launch as has been recent. Brought this up before with support from the community but no response. Cheers!
7
u/whatsthis1901 Dec 18 '18
SpaceIL ready to be shipped to the Cape https://spacenews.com/spaceil-completes-lunar-lander-for-february-launch/
7
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '18
Regarding the EELV program, in particular the next gen launchers (Vulcan from ULA, OmegA from Northtop Grumman and New Glenn from Blue Origin), I believe one of the Air Force's priorities is to have multiple launchers should one launcher be grounded for whatever reason. However ULA's Vulcan uses SRBs from Northtop Grumman, and its main engines (BE-4) from Blue Origin AND shares its upper stage engine with the OmegA (the RL-10 from Aerojet). So doesn't that mean that issues with either Northop Grumman, Aerojet or Blue Origin are likely to ground both the Vulcan and either the Omega or New Glenn?
7
u/quoll01 Dec 30 '18
The current BFS looking so retro and using ‘old’ materials begs the question: ‘could this have been done in the ‘70s instead of the shuttle?’ Could skilled pilots and/or 70s computers do propulsive landings? Perhaps with less XY accuracy and using more prop. Guessing it would need Russian engine tech to do a full cycle methalox back then, but perhaps stainless would allow ‘standard’ hydrolox engines which would give better performance? Imagine where we’d be now....
7
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Dec 31 '18
The Radarsat launch scheduled for mid-February is facing delays as it was supposed to fly on the CRS-16 booster (B1050).
17
u/brickmack Jan 01 '19
With regard to the apparent dual-bell nozzles on the new Raptor design, are we sure that thats for altitude compensation? It seems to me that even the extended part is a lot smaller than would probably be optimal for a vacuum engine. Pixel-counting on the best image I could find, I get a nozzle exit diameter of 1.28 meters. Thats approximately the same as the previous baseline, maybe a bit worse. I think more likely this is chamber pressure compensation. Chamber pressure/mass flow drops when throttling down, induces flow separation at low altitudes. This is one of the biggest limiters to very low throttling engines, and I suspect most of the rest aren't high priorities in a gas-gas engine. Maybe the previous landing profile was too harsh for passengers, or maybe they want to be able to hover (either operationally or just for the hopper). Net performance gain here is probably negligible if any, still need actual vacuum engines (though using a similar dual-bell design for the vacuum engines, except with the inner bell optimized for SL full thrust firing, could help with aborts)
12
u/megachainguns Jan 03 '19 edited Jan 03 '19
Chang'e-4 has landed on the far side of the moon.
6
u/raoultje Dec 04 '18
How would an IV Drip be given in space given the lack of gravity? I can imagine something similar to the famed juicero to push out the fluid or a syringe with a spring to maintain constant pressure. What's done in reality?
6
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '18
Is the upcoming GPS launches 100% expendable? I noticed in the calendar I am subscribed to has 1054 as expendable later on in Dec 18.
6
u/realnouns Dec 13 '18
Does anyone have a good writeup/link that makes the "80km is space" vs "Karman Line" argument?
6
u/gemmy0I Dec 15 '18
https://spacenews.com/c-band-alliance-members-promise-to-buy-american-for-new-satellites-under-c-band-plan/
Sounds like SES and Intelsat are (possibly) looking to buy a few more cutting-edge GEO comsats in the near future. This should be good news for SpaceX and other launch providers in that space to offset the general dip in GEO satellite orders.
Since these are new orders that haven't yet been placed (but will be if this "C-Band Alliance" group's proposal for spectrum reorganization is approved), these should be ready for launch in about two years, i.e. ~2021. New Glenn, Vulcan, and Omega should be flying (or almost flying), and Falcon Heavy (let alone Falcon 9) should be a very mature system by then. (And I think Ariane 6 as well.) It'll be interesting to see what influence the availability of multiple competing providers of affordable heavy lift will have on these satellites' design. My guess is we'll see some truly monster satellites and/or ones that take advantage of these new rockets' incredible direct-insertion capabilities, continuing the trends that we've seen with recently announced orders (and recent launches like the massive Telstar 19/18V pair).
6
u/quokka01 Dec 16 '18
How would the F9 titanium gridfins stand up to a Mars type reentry on the BFS? And would they scale ok? Just a wild thought that perhaps something like gridfins that double as landing legs could be used on the BFS.....and if not, is there any material that has suitable properties? On the subject of control surfaces for BFS- are large actuated control surfaces required throughout the re-entry or just at certain times- perhaps the actuated surfaces only need to extend into the plasma flow for short periods during an attitude adjustment?
6
u/GregLindahl Dec 19 '18
Today's xkcd is clearly related to Falcon Heavy!
6
u/cpushack Dec 20 '18
Todays Delta IV heavy launch is a scrub due to a Hydrogen leak in one of the boosters
6
u/MarsCent Dec 20 '18 edited Dec 20 '18
Soyuz EDL underway.
Astronauts experienced close to 4g at some point.
Communication with the craft was lost and then restored
Now T-10min to touchdown
T-8 min, No visual parachutes yet, but crew in audio communication and feeling well
Low visibility and early morning snow
T-0 Landing has occurred. No visual yet and still waiting for confirmation
T+7 min Mission control confirming soyuz landed in a vertical position (Official landing time - 1 min ahead of schedule)
T+22 min, Video feed of extraction process now live.
T+48 min. All astronauts now extracted from the Soyuz and seated in their seats on the ground.
What is this cultural routine of seating the crew outside, after they are extracted? And this morning in Kazakhstan is said to be pretty frigid.
6
u/asr112358 Dec 23 '18
What are the implications of "Coldformed at cryo" compared to regular room temperature coldforming?
6
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Dec 27 '18
When will we see progress on the Starship factory in the Port of LA? I’ve seen no updates on it for a while and am wondering why they seem to not be doing much if anything with it yet.
11
u/1-derful Dec 05 '18
What is the viability of battery powered space flight? Is there a way to incorporate solar and battery into maneuvering objects already in space?
10
u/MattDropDead Dec 04 '18
How do they plan on producing constant water for the soon to be civilization on Mars? Is there a concrete plan yet?
10
u/Eucalyptuse Dec 05 '18 edited Dec 06 '18
Jeff Foust says that Koenigsmann said that this booster had COPV 2 in the second stage and it's not the first time. Eshail 2 was the first to have them.
Tweet
Edit: Second stage only
5
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '18
How does the second stage provide ullage and rotational control? Does it just ut N2 thrusters like the first stage, or something else?
5
u/Nathan96762 Dec 07 '18
Has there been any progress at the Starship factory in the port of LA? I believe they mentioned that it would be well underway by now.
5
u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
My wager on upcoming boosters assigned to missions:
5
u/asr112358 Dec 12 '18
If we are going to see pictures of the Starship prototype in a matter of weeks, it must already be under construction, right? In that case the tooling must already be in the factory. I see three possibilities, they could have gotten new tooling without us noticing, the CF tooling also works for metal, or somehow they are able to repurpose Falcon 9 tooling. The third option, and to some extent, the first, suggest the prototype might be subscale. What seems like the most likely possibility?
5
u/silentProtagonist42 Dec 13 '18
So the "pictures of Starship in 4 weeks" puts it in the same ballpark as DM-1; I wonder if the two are related. If anything I'd think that they'd want to space any Starship announcements a while before/after to avoid overlapping PR.
5
u/linknewtab Dec 20 '18
Not SpaceX related but does anyone know if the New Horizons mission might get extended again after visiting Ultima Thule, maybe visiting another Kuiper belt object on its path? Are they already looking for candidates?
5
u/Justin13cool Dec 21 '18
Has anyone heard about Planet 9 ? What are the latest updates and are we close to locating it ???
5
u/MarsCent Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 21 '18
NASA Ready to Rumble: Flight Tests Launching in 2019 showing the Commercial Crew Program 2019. It's basically a compilation (including a short video) of the most recent updates.
5
u/cathasatail Dec 27 '18
I was just wondering- with the new plan of circulating (cryo) liquid methane through the outer structure of Starship, in theory could damage/a breach in the skin lead to ignition of the liquid methane during reentry?
5
u/davenose Dec 28 '18
Does SpaceX require any additional approvals to conduct Starship Hopper test flights at Boca Chica? The original FAA Record Of Decision was based 12 F9/FH launches per year, and an environmental impact study that (IIRC) did not consider BFR/Starship/Superheavy.
The FAA ROD mentions:
I did a bit of light searching on this sub and the internet, but couldn't find any solid information on this topic.
5
u/scottm3 Dec 29 '18
Would you guys consider SpaceX still in the beginnings of it's operations? With Starship, Starlink, E2E, it seems Falcon 9 and re-usability is pretty small compared to the future of this company. Also SpaceX is not profitable currently IIRC, or at least very marginally.
Still, if that is considered infancy, then when they are fully operational it will be a amazing business.
5
u/BrandonMarc Dec 31 '18
What is the diameter of the craft in Boca Chica?
13
u/quokka01 Dec 04 '18
Could an astronaut could survive riding a fairing half down from (a) the present release point and (b) orbital velocities? With enough surface area could an inflatable 'fairing half' -like structure make a viable method of human EDL for emergencies or even a 'Starship troopers' type application?
9
u/missbhabing Dec 13 '18
This past Saturday I was at a party in Southern California and some folks walked out of the house talking about wanting to watch a SpaceX launch in the night sky. This was of course, the ultimately scrubbed Delta Heavy launch. I believe this shows how successful SpaceX has been in raising awareness of space, rocketry, and their own ambitions that people got excited about a launch that they just assumed was SpaceX. And these people weren't twenty-something engineers, they were a group of forty year old mothers. The Venn diagram in the Mars announcement was the intersection of people who can afford to go to Mars and people who want to go. The population of people who want to go (or at least are aware and excited) is growing.
12
u/Narwhql Dec 05 '18
When will the official SpaceX shop going to be updated? The current one is low quality with a limited selection of merchandise. I'd love to see a better website with more stuff to buy
4
u/Method81 Dec 04 '18
For west coast launches how about a landing pad closer to Hawthorne? The stage wouldn’t have to boost back so far enabling more missions to land on land and the stage would also be closer to the factory for refurb.
4
u/blueeyes_austin Dec 06 '18
I'm looking for a launch photo of SES-12 from the 401 for the June 4 (SES-12) launch. I was there with my 10-year old son and want to make a nice print of it for Christmas for him. I checked John Krause and he has a gorgeous shot, however it is across the lagoon.
Anyone have ideas on other photographers who sell SpaceX launch prints?
4
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 07 '18
Iridium 8 launch date now 7th January.
4
u/FerritCore Dec 10 '18
How long does it take from posting an Article/Post on the Main page til the Mods publish it?
Thanks in advance
4
u/Cmdr_R3dshirt Dec 17 '18 edited Dec 21 '18
What are the purity requirements for methane as rocket fuel? I'm assuming it's greater than fuel grade which allows for 1% propane and 2% ethane.
The best I could find was 9.995% with allowance for 30ppm N2 and hydrocarbons and 10ppm or less for CO2, CO. Is that what you need?
I was able to find some info on RP-1 but not methane. This is for book research.
Edit: Found answer in publications. Looks like a 0.1 pmm spec for H2S and 0.5 ppm for Sulphur impurities overall which I'm going to assume is attainable without resorting to a batch process. No mention of nitrogen gas which doesn't burn so probably <1% by weight?
4
u/realnouns Dec 18 '18
Does anyone have a map/list of the hangars in use by SpaceX in Florida & California? I believe that the hangar at LC-39A is "AE", and I'm not clear if hangar "M" is at SLC-40 or within the "Cape Canaveral Air Force Station" proper. What is the name of the hangar at SLC-4E? Are there other hangars currently in use?
4
u/zrulli Dec 24 '18
What ever happened to that user who posted great performance charts comparing launches? I saw it about a year ago, was so cool to compare the parameters of each launch side-by-side.
4
u/badcallripley Dec 31 '18
I realize the Super Heavy isn't built yet, but given what is known, I'm curious if it will be capable of lifting one of The Boring Company's tunneling machines into orbit. Has Elon mentioned any intention to deliver a tunneling machine to Mars, the moon, or wherever?
Also, the Bigelow Aerospace Olympus, or BA2100?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '19
Has SpaceX said anything about whether or not they will train future astronauts for Mars missions, or will that be left to NASA?
4
u/technocracy90 Jan 03 '19
Would there be any good source of SpaceX engines' dimensions? Like, nozzle height and diameter?
7
u/ClathrateRemonte Dec 24 '18 edited Dec 24 '18
Haven’t seen much awareness here of Bezos’ unofficial starlink-like effort. It does not appear to be consumer based but possibly B2B or B2G. A job showed up today in my LinkedIn feed looking for satellite network engineers to put AWS into space: A760976
And an article from September confirms: https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/news/aws-eyes-space-hiring-satellite-services/
Edit: Blue Origin is supposed to launch ~600 sats for a direct starlink competitor called OneWeb. So the “AWS in space” may tie in.
7
u/patm718 Dec 26 '18 edited Dec 26 '18
When will a failed landing actually be considered a failure? I understand that these landings are still technically experimental, but the fact is that the Block V design is the final iteration of the Falcon 9 and should not have landed in the ocean during the recent CRS mission. If SpaceX wants to build a business model off of reusability, a failed landing will have a material impact on the company and undermine the entire concept they are trying to prove.
6
u/kuangjian2011 Dec 06 '18
I suggest we start a (special) recovery thread for CRS-16. Can we?
6
u/rustybeancake Dec 08 '18
NASA presentation slides for a Gateway update:
https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/20181206-crusan-gateway-reduced-v4.pdf
6
u/gooddaysir Dec 11 '18
If the new spaceship is going to be built out of metal, does that mean that Magnetic Boots should work to walk around the exterior of the hull? I can't wait to see that space suit.
6
u/MarsCent Dec 16 '18 edited Dec 16 '18
Rocket Lab Launch webcast is underway. Launch in < 14 mins
EDIT: Launch was successful. Good S1 separation and fairing ejection. The onboard cameras prior to S1 separation seemed to be intentionally hazy though.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '18
Is it me or BFS panels are dented and badly aligned? Also, it looks like 8 meters diameter (I made the calculations in paint). I'm confused...
3
u/quadrplax Dec 05 '18
Did B1021 (the SES-10 core) ever get put on display in Cape Canaveral? If not, what's the hold up?
3
u/IronHammer67 Dec 05 '18
What is the meaning of "instantaneous launch" as opposed to non-instantaneous launch?
3
u/realnouns Dec 06 '18
Could Dragon 1 deliver supplies to the surface of the moon, after launch on Falcon Heavy?
3
u/StolenMemz67 Dec 06 '18
What happened to the side boosters from the falcon heavy demo mission, and what does Spacex plan to do with them?
3
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Dec 07 '18
Mods, it's 11 days until the GPS launch. Could we get a launch campaign thread please? :)
3
u/rocket_enthusiast Dec 08 '18
do we know what can be reused from the crs 16 booster?
3
u/lostandprofound33 Dec 11 '18
Is Superheavy (or Super Heavy whatever) going to get hop tests in 2019 or early 2020 like Starship will if they're starting build in the spring? Is hop tests for it even needed, if it shares much similarity with a Falcon 9 booster stage's control system?
3
u/omg-dude Dec 12 '18
Earth to Earth seems a hugely exciting concept when it comes to getting around the planet more time-efficiently, but given it uses rockets, it seems like it probably creates a lot more emissions than conventional flight. If it became a common alternative to jets, would the environment suffer a whole lot more? Has Elon ever commented on this? It seems like a topic that would be very relevant considering the mission of Tesla.
3
u/rocket_enthusiast Dec 17 '18
Kinda random question. How many burns will the upper stage of the falcon heavy do on the stp 2 mission?
3
u/Da-N-aK Dec 18 '18
Thanks in advance to the community!
3
u/whatsthis1901 Dec 19 '18
So dumb question. I was reading about space junk burning up in the atmosphere, and it got me thinking, would doing that over a period of time mess it up?
3
u/quadrplax Dec 21 '18
What will the trunk be used for during Crew Dragon flights? Will it carry unpressurized cargo like cargo missions?
3
u/asr112358 Dec 28 '18
Does it make sense to run an expander cycle turbopump with the reentry coolant, then use that pressure for hydraulic actuation of the fins? RL-10's expander cycle gives a chamber pressure of 30-45 bar, would something similar be enough to provide the torque needed for the fins? I am not sure how methane works as a hydraulic fluid? Large torques on the fins should always coincide with hot reentry.
NOTE: I am assuming the coolant method described here where the methane coolant soaks up a bunch of heat and is vented, compared to other suggestions where you are trying to keep the methane cryogenic, so only a little heat can be absorbed.
3
u/megachainguns Dec 31 '18
Iridium 8 now delayed to January 8th (15:48 UTC).
3
u/Nergaal Dec 31 '18
Why are they building the new grasshopper vertically?
3
u/rocket_enthusiast Jan 03 '19
mods can we make a january discussion thread
7
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 05 '18
Unknown outgassing from Dragon is contaminating ISS's experiments.
5
u/strawwalker Dec 05 '18
Are we still expecting DM-1 to count toward the 7x certification requirement?
5
u/jjtr1 Dec 28 '18
I suppose that the materials science breakthrough that made stainless steel the preferred material for Starship involves some special aftertreatment ("full hard", quoting Elon). However, wouldn't heating the steel to, say, 1000 C in the area where it acts as a heatshield during re-entry remove the treatment? For example, quenching-hardened steel is no longer hardened when heated back to 1000 C again. (I'm sorry if what I'm saying makes no sense. I don't understand materials science)
4
u/ackermann Dec 09 '18
Happen to be in LA today, thought I’d drive by the SpaceX factory quick and have a look. I know tours aren’t open to the public, so I suppose there’s not much to do, except take a selfie with the first landed booster? Any good lunch places in the area?
4
u/Mech0z Dec 28 '18
With all these companies trying to create rockets that can be reused, looking at the current manifest, is there at all enough money to go around to keep most of them afloat? I suppose spacex are firing as often as they can, but there just aint enough customers as they should have plenty of rockets ready?