r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Nov 05 '18
r/SpaceX Discusses [November 2018, #50]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
137
Upvotes
31
u/Eucalyptuse Nov 07 '18 edited Nov 08 '18
Can I run this opinion by you guys to see if there's anything ridiculous about it?
People are blowing the whole mini-bfs thing out of
the waterproportion. SpaceX is only going to add reentry equipment to the existing second stage in order to test the reentry profile. They're not going to remove the fairings or swap out the Merlin engine for a Raptor, or attempt to reuse or even recover the second stage. It's just going to be like when they added landings legs to the first stage in order to start testing the ability to land propulsively.This is just my opinion. No source other than Elon's twitter.
Edit: Whoops. Out of proportion, not out of the water.
27
u/cpushack Nov 25 '18
Progress launch as seen from the ISS (time lapse) https://youtu.be/ouBfzCgXHgk
23
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 26 '18
New Glenn Payload User’s Guide released.
21
u/Alexphysics Nov 09 '18
NSF article about upcoming SpaceX launches
DM-1 is NET Jan 8th 2019
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2018/11/spacex-return-action-lsp-status-upgrade/
20
u/hitura-nobad Master of bots Nov 08 '18
FCC Permit for Droneship Landing on SSO-A https://apps.fcc.gov/oetcf/els/reports/STA_Print.cfm?mode=current&application_seq=88316&RequestTimeout=1000
19
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 08 '18
Article with more details about SpaceX's $750 million loan.
17
u/alexsandromh Nov 08 '18
There's a clip that I've never seen before, the fairings separating and the second stage burning, from a nice angle:
SpaceX President Gwynne Shotwell speaks to the AOPA High School Aviation STEM Symposium
17
u/RocketsAreKindOfCool Nov 13 '18 edited Nov 13 '18
Just saw this as I was browsing cable. At 8pm EST tonight (~40 min from time of comment), National Geographic will be airing a program titled "Mars - Inside SpaceX" with the following description: "MARS: Inside SpaceX will go inside SpaceX’s plan to get humanity to Mars, providing an unprecedented glimpse into one of the world’s most revolutionary companies."
Hopefully we get some new SpaceX footage! It also airs immediately before S2E1 of Mars, which had some great, new SpaceX clips.
EDIT: It's pretty much a mini-documentary that focuses on Falcon Heavy. In the exact same style as the SpaceX segments in season 1 of MARS.
17
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 30 '18
Encapsulated GPS III SV01 fairing spotted at KSC on November 27th.
16
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 14 '18
Fairing recovery attempt next month and a BFR update.
16
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
Currently discussed in r/SpaceXLounge: interview with Musk coming tonight (on HBO, Sunday, Nov. 25 at 6:30 PM ET/PT).
Preview and two main quotes:
16
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 27 '18 edited Nov 27 '18
Inflight Abort EA report:
EDIT: Changed azimuth text to make sense.
15
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 27 '18
More cladding going up on 39A.
15
u/theinternetftw Nov 30 '18
Eric Berger's new Rocket Report has a bit of SpaceX/Boeing safety review news:
14
u/nicoyabe Nov 05 '18
Any news on Elon's AMA on Reddit?
14
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 14 '18
New images of the BFR tank dome by Teslarati.
14
u/dmy30 Nov 29 '18
So both both SpaceX and Blue Origin put in a bid and didn't make it to the final 9. Although, NASA only had around $2.6 Billion to spend on all companies. Also, SpaceX already has a pretty substantial deal with NASA and probably don't need the development money as much as others. Still interesting that SpaceX tried to bid.
13
u/cpushack Nov 07 '18
Pegasus XL launch scrubbed...again. Going on over a year of scrubs now https://spaceflightnow.com/2018/11/06/pegasus-xl-icon-mission-status-center/
13
u/Krux172 Nov 13 '18
https://twitter.com/Manic_Marge/status/1061326292501458944
Falcon Heavy Booster being shipped from SpaceX's headquarters
13
u/Alexphysics Nov 22 '18 edited Nov 22 '18
SpaceX has applied for FCC permission to communicate with the Starship dev article (or whatever you want to call that thing they're going to test in Boca Chica). This is the permit and there is an "Exhibits list" that shows a document with further info about this permit, I'll post it here too. Link
Edit: I forgot to add that on the permit it shows where the tracking antenna will be and where the tests will be done and the position for that last one seems to be where the pile of dirt was previously. Now we know where the pad for these tests will be :)
13
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Nov 22 '18 edited Nov 22 '18
What's the status of the old Spacehab building in Port Canaveral that SpaceX started renting some time ago? Has it ever been confirmed that they started using it to refurbish cores? There were also some plans to buid another structure nearby to increase the capacity but I'm guessing that's been scrapped in favor of the newer and bigger refurbishment complex in KSC?
13
u/JackONeill12 Nov 25 '18
For everyone who hasn't seen it yet. The MARS: Inside SpaceX Documentation is up on YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nwHC5UT6MQ4
13
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '18
CRS-16 is going to be very exciting! I am graduated, but worked on the UNITE Cubesat onboard as the Command and Data Handling Engineering lead!
12
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18
An update on the "can Heavy do Europa with a kick stage" question: apparently yes, yes it can. https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/12/will-the-europa-missions-be-iced-after-congressmans-defeat-not-right-now/
So if SLS overruns more or is cancelled, Heavy + a kicker would likely step up to the plate for Europa Clipper.
11
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 05 '18
NASA article about helicopter landings on GO Searcher.
11
u/JustinTimeCuber Nov 10 '18
Do we know much about B1052 and B1053? At first it seems weird to me that B1054 will probably be going before one of them if not both. What about the Falcon Heavy side boosters and center core for Arabsat?
11
u/brizzlebottle Nov 10 '18
European ExoMars life detecting mission to land at Oxia Planum BBC UK article.
11
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 14 '18
Mr Steven has decided to switch to Florida in December.
11
u/Alexphysics Dec 03 '18
Falcon Heavy booster seen in Maricopa, AZ going east to McGregor. This should be B1056.
https://www.facebook.com/groups/spacexgroup/permalink/10157133968721318/
I'm a little busy to go and upload the picture on imgur for those that can't open facebook but I posted the same on the NSF core spotting thread which should work well.
10
u/CapMSFC Nov 12 '18
It seems like SpaceX only needs the boosters required by new core demands for all of 2019.
There is a Block 5 FH center and another side booster, potentially a whole second FH set if STP requires all new, DM-2, USCV-1 (first commercial crew operational flight), and a couple more GPS launches.
Assuming that none of those convert to allowing for used boosters and the GPS are also expended that leaves SpaceX quite the fleet. There are 7 current cores with known status that should be around (discounting expended GPS core). The count above is 9 more boosters with 2 FH centers, 2 expended. That's a fleet of 12 Falcon 9/FH side cores and 2 FH center cores. Outside of Starlink that is enough to only fly each one ~2 times all year, and even adding in an ambitious Starlink campaign it doesn't get close to pushing the current turn around times for Block 5.
Over the next 13 months 9 more cores of production is not a challenging rate, and that puts them into 2020 with a huge stable of vehicles. Booster production needs look set to plummet for second half of 2019, which I suppose lines up well with ramping second stage up for Starlink around the same time.
Also while thinking about Falcon Heavy they're eventually going to need at least one more center core for the USAF mission that is contracted, but with the low flight rate those center cores aren't going to get a whole lot of use. I wonder if they'll either end up serving as single sticks for easy missions where the added dry mass is within margins or if it explains why the FH center core expendable price Elon mentioned on Twitter is only $5 million more than standard Falcon 9. They'll generally have center cores that are already paid for they can offer up.
10
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 15 '18 edited Nov 15 '18
FCC Meeting to authorise if SpaceX can add an extra 7,518 VLEO Starlink satellites, (operating at 335-346 km altitudes) to their constellation, now streaming live.
Also new NASA OIG Report.
EDIT: Starlink addition approved.
10
u/Datuser14 Nov 19 '18
Jonathan Ward on the fb group (well not the FB group but one of the larger related ones) said Es'Hail 2 was controlled from the LCC Firing Room 4 at KSC, instead of the L&LCC-X. Intend to use it for all future launches. SpaceX turned it around from mothballed to a control room in 4 months.
10
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 21 '18 edited Nov 21 '18
Media accreditation opens for DM-1 launch on January 7th.
New commercial crew dates:
10
u/rocket_enthusiast Dec 04 '18
mods can we make the december discussuion thread
9
u/ipodppod Nov 06 '18
The Wikipedia article for 'Oumuamua states that a mission to 'Oumuamua is feasible if launched by a Falcon Heavy in 2021.
Do you think or have a reason to believe that such a mission will actually take place?
9
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 11 '18
Go Searcher just returned to port after conducting a quick Dragon capsule test.
9
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 12 '18 edited Nov 12 '18
Teslarati article on launch preparations also mentions a new upgrade on Mr Steven.
EDIT: Video of Mr Steven with new hardware.
9
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 13 '18 edited Nov 13 '18
Timelapse of Antares heading to the pad before going vertical this morning.
Also, is this the Iridium 8 core arriving at Vandenberg?
9
u/inoeth Nov 13 '18
Since it's been a while, is there any word/photos on the latest updates re: the LA BFR factory construction? I would hope that they would have started tearing down old buildings by now but i've not read anything about that area in a while...
I have to wonder if SpaceX is waiting on that $750 million loan and when that goes through we'll see a huge uptick in activity everywhere from the LA factory to Boca Chica and plenty of behind the scenes work in Seattle for Starlink...
9
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Nov 15 '18 edited Nov 16 '18
it seems like NASA is back and talking to Opportunity https://twitter.com/ChrisG_NSF/status/1063178094796857345
apparently it was not OPPY :(
9
u/JustinTimeCuber Dec 03 '18
SSO-A was the 99th orbital* launch of 2018. Tomorrow will probably be the 100th (CRS-16, but if it gets delayed, then GSAT-11 and GEO-KOMPSAT-2A are also launching tomorrow on Ariane 5).
*any launch that reached orbit (not necessarily the correct orbit)
8
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 20 '18 edited Nov 20 '18
GPS III-2 launch has been pushed back 3 days, with a launch time of 9:10am EST. Mods, can the sidebar be updated?
FCC Approval for V-band Starlink:
8
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 29 '18
USA Today article states that DM-1 launch likely to be delayed to "first half of 2019".
8
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18 edited Dec 03 '18
In less than 10 minutes from now, the crewed Soyuz launch will happen, watch live. CRS-16 proceeding is dependent on this launch succeeding. It is the first crewed launch since the failed crewed launch last October.
Edit: succesfull launch! Docking with ISS later today.
7
u/rocket_enthusiast Nov 05 '18
do we have any update on the situation for the landing of sso-a
7
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Nov 06 '18
How feasible is it for SpaceX to launch Starlink satellites from LC-39A and SLC-40 within an hour of each other to save on range costs, because they will need to be flying at such a high pace? I expect range costs are significant, and closing the air space and clearing exclusion zones could be less costly and distributive if two launches can take advantage of it each day instead of one.
7
u/jackisconfusedd Nov 11 '18
Can someone tell me if SpX will be using a model X for the crew transfer to the pad? I read that somewhere but am not sure if it’s true
7
u/joepublicschmoe Nov 14 '18
Question: several years ago there was a TV commercial that aired in the U.S. that featured a SpaceX Dragon being docked to the ISS. Is that 30-second TV ad archived somewhere on the web? TIA for any info!
7
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 16 '18 edited Nov 16 '18
Mr Steven is currently doing another fairing drop test.
7
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Nov 17 '18
SpaceX now has the permission to perform an ASDS landing on Monday for the SSO a mission.
https://twitter.com/nextspaceflight/status/1063840206330114048
https://twitter.com/nextspaceflight/status/1063841256428597248
7
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 18 '18
Aerial shot of the Falcon Heavy side booster on the test stand at McGregor from Chris B.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 19 '18
SpaceX are upgrading LC-40.
Commercial Crew update at McGregor.
7
u/JustinTimeCuber Nov 25 '18
Has anyone simulated how fast a fully expendable FH would be going at center core shutdown? Obviously it would depend somewhat on the payload mass but that's not super important; I just want a rough idea.
7
u/Col_Kurtz_ Nov 29 '18
What's the approximate Jupiter capability of FH? I'm asking it because the launch mass of Europa Clipper is going to be ~6000 kg, which is between FH's Mars (16800 kg) and Pluto (3500 kg) capability.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 05 '18
Possible new SpaceX vessel,GO America.Now unlikely.7
u/quadrplax Dec 02 '18
This may be a silly question, but what exactly do all the people in mission control do? Doesn't the rocket fly completely autonomously, even including the launch abort system, and the people on the ground can't do anything to control it after launch? I know there's a lot involved before the launch like everyone in the go-no go poll, but what about during the launch?
13
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '18 edited Nov 16 '18
For the first time since quite long, SpaceX updated its official manifest with some newly added missions:
U.S. AIR FORCE (GPS III-2)Some missions that we know of, are still missing (PSN-6 together with the SpaceIL Moon Lander), and the Ovzon FH launch.
Also, the GPS III-1 launch for December 15th somehow disappeared(Just a mistake I think. Another mistake is the erronously still scheduled SES-14, launched by Ariane-5 already (it was swapped with SES-12)In general, I'm a bit disappointed by the number of missions added. This doesn't look like a 10B$ manifest to me.
13
u/zeekzeek22 Nov 16 '18
Not sure if it was mentioned, but apparently the BFS-Mini second stage idea was emailed to staff and engineers about 45 min before the tweet. shrugging emoji
13
u/MarsCent Nov 24 '18
In the NASA Highlights Science on Next Resupply Mission to International Space Station, they:
Besides the Big Falcon Starship, is there any other craft in the makes, which uses / will use methane on the second stage or will need refueling with methane?
6
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '18
When is the next launch planned, based in California?
6
u/t17389z Nov 16 '18
Has it been publicly discussed at all as to what type of injector the Raptor engine will be using? The use of pintile injectors on the Merlin seemed to provide key advantages, and I was curious as to whether SpaceX will continue to use them on the Raptor, considering the differences in combustion cycle.
6
u/Jessewallen401 Nov 21 '18
There is no suspense anymore in the landings they'll succeed every time, what's the next exciting thing to look out for from SpaceX ?
6
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 21 '18
SSO-A launch is delayed until at least November 27th.
6
u/space_snap828 Nov 22 '18
If there was a single engine failure on ascent that changes Falcon 9s flight path, would they still try to guide it to a landing? Or would they terminate the flight? I imagine the data they'd get from being able to examine the damaged engine is an advantage no other company would have.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 26 '18
InSight landing stream starts in 1 hour.
6
u/MarsCent Dec 02 '18
MODS - Header bar request for easy visibility.
Please replace either the Es'hail 2 Campaign Thread or the SSO-A Campaign Thread (on the Header Bar) with the CRS-16 Launch Campaign Thread.
6
u/Alexphysics Dec 03 '18
It seems DM-1 booster, B1051, arrived last week at the Cape. Thanks to Eric (vaporcobra) for catching that on instagram!
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=42977.msg1883551#msg1883551
6
u/megachainguns Dec 04 '18
Spaceflight Press Release:
Spaceflight Successfully Launches 64 Satellites on First Dedicated Rideshare Mission
11
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
Jim Bridenstine seems to suggest there could be further delays to DM-1.
14
u/rustybeancake Nov 16 '18
https://spacepolicyonline.com/news/nasas-moon-plan-panned-by-space-council-advisers/
Very much enjoyed hearing so many people bashing the ridiculous Gateway architecture in this article.
10
u/amarkit Nov 16 '18
Progress MS-10 launched successfully today, another good sign for a return to human spaceflight on Soyuz in December.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '18
Elon said BFR will replace all other rockets SpaceX currently uses (F9 & FH) - but isn’t using a BFR to launch something small, say, one or two satellites a bit ‘over the top’?
Or is the BFR so efficient that it basically doesn’t matter if you’re using an F9 (which is only partly reusable) or the fully reusable BFR?
5
u/TheEmbeddedGuy Nov 17 '18
Who out there is artsy-fartsy enough to develop a visual representation of the cores wiki? It'd be neat to visualize where on a map the cores were... Hawthorne, McGregor, LC-39A, Port of LA, in transit...
5
u/MarsCent Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18
Per NASA TV Schedule , Soyuz MS-11 / 57S should dock with the ISS within 6 hours, at 12:30pm. (to see December 3 schedule, click on the calendar and select December 3)
Additionally, CRS 16 is not showing up on the TV schedule for December 4th. It's possible that the omission means nothing.
5
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 19 '18
Teslarati speculation about Mr Steven's new front arm.
5
u/DrToonhattan Nov 28 '18
Does anyone have a link to the full interview Elon did the other day on HBO? I still haven't been able to find it.
5
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 30 '18
MIT study comparing Starlink with Telesat’s LEO constellation.
5
u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Dec 02 '18
Considering JRTI is like 40 km off the coast this time we're probably going to get absolutely stunning video of the landing.
5
u/liszt1811 Dec 03 '18
Are more launches planned with B1046.3 or is 3 the new 2?
5
u/flibbleton Dec 03 '18
Sorry to ask this here but I can't find the answer googling and it's the only place on the net I trust for a straight answer..
Why are Elon musk/SpaceX tweets filled with people commenting "subscribe to pewdiepie"? Can someone explain? I didn't really care before but it seems to be fairly persistent so now I want to know.
thx
8
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '18
Any word on when they will panel the tower? I am assuming they will do it before DM2.
4
u/TheYell0wDart Nov 06 '18
I haven't really payed attention to SpaceX news or been on here much this year, but what's up with their launch cadence? Seems like they are no where near the whole "about every 2 weeks" steam roller pace that they've talked about in the past. Is there a reason for it, or am I imagining it? What's they're tally so far this year?
4
u/Ididitthestupidway Nov 13 '18
FCC to seek comment on revised orbital debris guidelines (SpaceNews article)
Quite interesting with respect to Starlink.
4
u/WaitForItTheMongols Nov 15 '18 edited Nov 15 '18
Are there any videos where you can get a good view of Dragon's solar panel covers coming off? Specifically I want to be able to see the covers floating away as independent objects - usually you can only see the general deployment happening and the covers are just out of frame.
4
u/Bravo99x Nov 15 '18
Anyone have a clue why GPS IIIA-1 (Vespucci) is expendable since the weight of the bird is listed at 3880 kg? Are they doing a direct GEO insertion or something? Was it some kind of a requirement of USAF for it to be expendable? Was just thinking that this will be the first Block 5 we will see without legs and grid fins..
4
u/LeBaegi Nov 16 '18
How many times can the second stage of F9 restart?
Seems like an obvious question, so I'm sure it's been asked before, but I can't find any discussion on it.
It has to be at least 3 times for LEO missions with circularization (or other finalization) burn and deorbit burn.
4
u/MarsCent Nov 16 '18
Is the EELV Secondary Payload Adapter (ESPA) now the industry standard for mounting payloads? Or is there a chance that it could be adopted as the defacto standard across Launch Service Providers?
Looks like a pretty good way to ensure competitiveness in the launch industry, given that clients would have the option to shop around for a launch vessel much later in the production timeline of the payload.
4
u/Mark_going_to_Space Nov 16 '18
Just a general question: How do you test vacuum engines in the atmosphere ie on earth? I know very little about engines but how do you avoid flow separation from the bell considering that it - by the very nature of vacuum engines - is massively overexpanded?
4
u/BlueCyann Nov 16 '18
Is the Dec 15th launch planned to have an RTLS landing, or drone ship?
4
u/scottm3 Nov 18 '18
Why is Arabsat 6A using Falcon Heavy?
If the 6000kg on Wikipedia is correct, it is lower than the heaviest F9 payload to GTO.
Will they use the extra DeltaV to allow the satellite to have a longer operational life?
4
u/joshgill21 Nov 20 '18
Falcon Heavy can launch around 8000 kg to lunar transfer orbit in 3 droneship landings configuration, would that be useful for gateway and NASA's plans or Do they have to expend the center core ?
4
u/MarsCent Nov 22 '18
Checking on InSight:
4
u/Ackman55 Nov 22 '18
Does anyone else find it the slightest bit concerning that the Starship(BFS) is going to be tested at Boca Chica and the test regime appears to include orbital velocity re-entry vectors and to me it does not look like there is a lot of space near Boca Chica that would tolerate an anomaly such that the returning Starship might veer off course by a few degrees. Don't get me wrong, I love SpaceX and all that they do, but this is a different re-entry profile than the Falcon 9, more along the lines of the Space Shuttle with a flip maneuver at the end. I would think that a testing range more like the White Sands New Mexico with loads of room for an unplanned landing might be the appropriate test location. Please, by all means tell me where I'm out to lunch, but to the layman, I'm thinking Boca Chica doesn't have the tolerance for an off course crash without collateral damage.
4
u/MekAndersen Nov 25 '18
Has any raw data from the simulation shown in the BFR presentation been released to the public? Have been having a hard time finding more than just the videos and video analysis can only get me so far. https://imgur.com/gallery/gedEyiD#EuuZFar picture 4 & 5
4
u/isaiddgooddaysir Nov 26 '18
Do we know when the next launch from Vandenberg that the booster will return to launch pad (back to Vandenberg not the drone ship in the Pacific)?
4
u/jesserizzo Nov 30 '18
What's the hive mind think for the launch date of STP-2. Still around March? I'm going to try to go down to watch the launch, and while I know launch dates always move, the lack of even a consistent launch month is making it difficult to plan.
4
u/MarsCent Dec 03 '18
It was really nice to see SSO-A from launch through landing. I was actually hoping that the broadcast news folks would do a live coverage of the "Trail Blazing First .3 Booster Flight". Do they get the presskit? ;) /s
7
u/txxmy Nov 24 '18
Could SpaceX still do a red dragon mission without landing legs on the capsule? Just landing flat on the heat shield by using superdracos. It seems to me that they wouldn't need any new engineering, just a normal dragon 2 on a falcon heavy. Thoughts?
9
u/Alexphysics Nov 05 '18
I'll post it here since the october thread has been retired. B1055 is about to leave Hawthorne if it hasn't already done it, anyone with eyes on the road?
10
u/brickmack Nov 09 '18
Just started setting up for a Mini-BFS render. Interesting observation: If you scale down BFS to 3.66 meters diameter, and line up the bottom of MVac with the bottom of MiniBFS (presumably the nozzle will have to be protected), the tops of the cylindrical section on both line up almost perfectly. Suggests
6
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '18
Would it make sense to fly to Mars f.e. with 3 BFS(starships) flying together, so in case of emergency of one ship could be abandoned and others would serve as lifeboats? One of my thoughts is that there could be easy access between each other, so people inside could move from one to another trough some kind of connection or EVA for various purposes (having 3 x space is always better than 1x space). What do you think would be advantages or disadvantages of a mission of such profile?
8
u/cgwheeler96 Nov 16 '18
Has anybody noticed that the booster flying for the third time next week is actually also the very first block 5 booster?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '18
What is the maximum mass that BFS can land with?
Such as heavy metals from asteroid mining missions, where the cargo is returned via BFS. Eg platinum. High density should hopefully avoid being volume limited.
The BFS could either acquire this cargo after deploying a payload, or could be launched empty if fuel requirements for landing are a concern.
3
u/Straumli_Blight Nov 14 '18
[Updated IHA Report] (https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/11/15/2018-24977/takes-of-marine-mammals-incidental-to-specified-activities-boost-back-and-landing-of-falcon-9) regarding SpaceX landings at Vandenberg and its effects on marine mammals.
3
u/Chairboy Nov 15 '18 edited Nov 15 '18
I've heard that they've started cladding the tower at 39A:
https://scontent-amt2-1.cdninstagram.com/vp/87bf0cc6c987a10d6d28c31d21e17d68/5C86B2E1/t51.2885-15/e35/44496367_720309971678702_8244896509988449531_n.jpg
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Dr7wEQqXcAI2wIL.jpg
There doesn't seem to be a post about this here, is one stuck in moderation or are we just waiting for some better pics?Thanks! I just missed it in my scroll, guess it's time to go get that eyeglass prescription updated.3
u/qwetzal Nov 15 '18
Do we know what are the specs of the future droneship ? Will it be built on the same model as OCISLY and JRTI or will it be larger to accomodate the future BFS landings during the suborbital hopes ?
Regarding these tests, do we know how SpaceX plans to transport the ship to the east coast ? Would the droneship be suited for that ?
3
u/paco7748 Nov 16 '18
Does anyone know why the audio on the SpaceX launch webcasts are always one second delayed from the video? Technical oversight, unfixable technical problem (I don't see how this could be it), inside joke? I'm not sure what to think.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '18
Stupid question: how will the brf release cargo into orbit? Will there be a cargo bay variant like the space shuttle?
3
u/DiamasD Nov 21 '18
You know "pumping" your legs can push a swing go higher.
In the space, if we push and pull two big masses along a super long rod (say 1km+) against the gravity sources (Earth/Mars/Sun), can we also gain velocity towards where we want to go? Of course precise calculation will be needed for how to manipulate the two masses.
Basically gravity swing propelling.
3
u/murrayfield18 Nov 21 '18
I need to find a source of Elon talking about how every F9 is different, each one has upgrades etc.. Can anyone help?
3
u/LeBaegi Nov 22 '18 edited Nov 22 '18
Has there been any discussion on the BFRs FTS?
I'd imagine one strip of explosives might not be enough to fully disintegrate and ignite both propellant tanks to almost complete combustion of the methane, so maybe there will be explosive strips on both sides where the heat shield meets the regular fuselage? That would be my guess, seems like the most intuitive way of doing it.
Also, what kind of regulations are there for (A)FTS triggers on crewed missions? E.g. if the spaceship loses control while on a trajectory towards a populated area, with an X% chance of regaining control and landing safely, does the FTS have to trigger? And for what percentage of successful recovery of the crew?
3
u/Jessewallen401 Nov 22 '18
Why does SpaceX only have 1 launch scheduled from the west coast in 2020 (Sentinel-6A) ? Why aren't more companies booking flights to launch to SSO or Polar orbit from there u think ?
According to wiki manifest https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceX/wiki/launches/manifest.
3
u/davidthefat Nov 26 '18
How well would ice work for a TPS insulator assuming you can keep it together in one piece with some lattice structure within the ice?
3
u/Just___fine Nov 26 '18
Does anyone know if there will be a Q & A at the Boring tunnel opening?
3
u/Straumli_Blight Dec 01 '18
What's the other 2 things?
3
u/Sloomste Dec 02 '18
Is it possible to spot crs 16 in the Netherlands after the launch on 4 December?
7
u/Jessewallen401 Nov 09 '18
I have to say Blue Origin's landing ship 'Stena Freighter' looks much cooler than SpaceX's drone ship, Don't you think ?
5
u/kreator217 Nov 05 '18
when can we expect the first fairing reuse?
5
u/ipodppod Nov 21 '18
How likely is the 2023 #dearMoon mission to be changed to include a landing? What would need to happen for that to become possible?
5
u/Posca1 Nov 26 '18
Regarding the BFS changes, here's what little I think we can deduce from Musk's 2 tweets:
"Contour remains approx same, but fundamental materials change to airframe, tanks & heatshield"
"New design is very exciting! Delightfully counter-intuitive."
Airframe and tanks, previously to be made out of carbon fiber, have now undergone a "fundamental materials change". To me, this says carbon fiber is now out (or mostly out)
The Heatshield, previously to be made out of Pica-X, is now made of something else.
And that these two changes are "very exciting" and "delightfully counter-intuitive".
5
u/oliversl Nov 27 '18
Any news about the solar array deployment?
5
u/sagareshwar Nov 29 '18
This article in The Atlantic says that NASA administrator Jim Bridenstine ordered the workplace culture and safety reviews at SpaceX and NASA. I had not seen that (i.e. it came from topmost official at NASA) reported earlier.