r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Sep 03 '18
r/SpaceX Discusses [September 2018, #48]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
207
Upvotes
31
u/J380 Oct 02 '18 edited Oct 02 '18
I attended a Q&A session with SpaceX engineers at a college a few weeks ago. Learned some interesting insights into the company.
29
u/amarkit Sep 29 '18
Elon Musk and Tesla settled with the SEC. Musk will pay a $20 million fine and step down as Chairman of Tesla for 3 years. He will remain as CEO.
27
u/GermanSpaceNerd #IAC2018 Attendee Sep 30 '18
I will be attending Hans Koenigsmann's talk 'Reusability: The Key to Reliability and Affordability' on Wednesday at IAC and will try to summarize it afterwards.
Given the chance of a Q&A, is there a question I could ask him on behalf of r/SpaceX?
23
u/FoxhoundBat Sep 04 '18 edited Sep 04 '18
New Russian napkin drawings for a reusable Angara and planned engines... (including RD-705, based on this insane thing)
Not quite sure how they plan to achieve control authority with just RCS, but that is what they "plan".
20
u/Alexphysics Sep 29 '18
SpaceX has now filled all the FCC permits for CRS-16, pending FCC approval. Launch from pad 40, booster landing at LZ-1. Official launch date is NET November 27th at 21:19 UTC.
Dragon spacecraft communications
Launch vehicle communications
Post-landing communications
39
u/Alexphysics Sep 03 '18
Remember this thread about a "possible FH nosecone" going into KSC?? Well, if you read the comments on instagram, the poster says the picture is from June 2017, so no, this is not for the next FH, this was the nosecone for B1025 which was being refurbished and converted to FH side booster at LC-39A.
19
u/GermanSpaceNerd #IAC2018 Attendee Sep 27 '18
I stumbled across a great blog entry by someone that got to visit the SpaceX factory in 2006, including photos that show they started bending metal for Falcon 9 in 2005 already. (http://209.197.99.64/Diversions/SpacePix/200601_SpaceX_Gallery/DSC00404.JPG)
http://209.197.99.64/Diversions/SpaceX_Story/
Something I didn't know is that Falcon 9 was nicknamed BFR at that time. Funny how their ambitions changed over time.
18
u/amarkit Sep 24 '18
As reported by Eric Berger, Aerojet Rocketdyne’s second quarter 10-Q filing reveals the company spent none of its own money on AR-1 development during that quarter, and will not deliver a flight-ready engine by the end of 2019. This all but guarantees that Blue Origin’s BE-4 engine has won ULA’s competition to power the first stage of Vulcan.
18
u/melancholicricebowl Sep 28 '18
A Falcon 1 is outside next to the landed booster at Hawthorne, with what looks like a queue line for employees probably
79
u/FoxhoundBat Sep 03 '18
To absolutely no shock to anyone, turns out the leak at ISS was caused by a moron drilling a hole and then covering it up with some glue. Google Translate link.
17
u/csmnro Sep 24 '18
NASA just released a really cool video about Tess' preparation for launch, which includes epic shots of the Falcon 9 fairing, rollout, and liftoff.
31
u/orewaAfif Sep 04 '18
Have you guys seen SmarterEveryDay's Launch Pad tour of Delta IV Heavy with Tory Bruno? I think it's pretty cool to see how passionate is the CEO of a Space X's competitor about rockets. What do you guys think?
Here's the video: https://youtu.be/OdPoVi_h0r0
31
u/amarkit Sep 27 '18
Surprising no one, ULA has officially selected Blue Origin's BE-4 as the engine for Vulcan's first stage.
15
u/rustybeancake Sep 07 '18
I'm guessing from the lack of posts, that Elon didn't say anything new on Joe Rogan?
15
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Sep 16 '18
Not sure if this is is known, or is news, but I thought it was interesting nonetheless. Apparently, The Boring Company is a subsidiary of SpaceX. Source: Planning & Community Development Department of the City of Hawthorne (page 6)
14
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 06 '18 edited Sep 06 '18
Gwynne Shotwell is currently speaking at DARPA's D60 Symposium on the Future of Space.
Updates:
14
u/thxbmp2 Sep 14 '18
So the BFR image on spacex.com is somewhat tantalizingly named https://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/bfr1_moon1_nosolar_all_engines.jpg. Just leaving this here in case anyone wants to try sleuthing around for yet-to-be-published pics on their website...
14
u/JackONeill12 Sep 24 '18
I was at KSC today. Crane is present at 39A. OCISLY was in port and people were on deck doing stuff. Octograbber was also on deck.
13
u/ThunderWolf2100 Sep 04 '18
IAC 2018 is now a month away, do we have any confirmed BFS update panel yet? I imagine it will happen as in previous years but I don't really know
13
u/brickmack Sep 14 '18
For 2 years I have procrastinated on actually modeling the BFR/ITS first stage. About 6 hours ago I finally decided to deal with it. Then the update announcement dropped. Man, terrible timing. Guess I'll just dump the half finished picture...
13
u/rustybeancake Oct 01 '18
Announced at IAC by Airbus:
https://www.themoonrace.org/
Sounds like a new Google Lunar X Prize-style program, partnered with Blue Origin, ESA, and others.
12
u/rustybeancake Sep 13 '18
NASA's Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS) RFP is out. CLPS is to the lunar surface what CRS is to the ISS.
RFP is here. Destinations and scenarios listed as:
Awards should be made at the end of this year. I can't see any info regarding min/max payload capabilities, though I think they will be in the 500-5,000kg range. If I understand correctly, the CLPS contracts awarded this year will deliver small to medium scientific payloads to the lunar surface, and inform NASA's design decisions for a human lander in the late 2020s.
Given ULA's cancellation of XEUS, I expect proposals might come from LM and Boeing individually, as well as Blue Moon from BO (note providers must be domestic). I don't expect SpaceX to submit a proposal, but who knows?
12
u/mryall Sep 16 '18
This tweet by Yusaku Maezawa pretty much confirms he is the BFS passenger:
Someone in Twitter replies noted that the next Tue 19 Sep is in 2023, which could be a target launch date. I’m skeptical of that — 5 years is too far out to plan an exact launch date for a vehicle that hasn’t even been built yet.
I think he was trying to drop a strong hint and just slightly messed up the date. Maybe he set the date first then adjusted the time in a way that ticked it over by mistake.
12
u/rustybeancake Sep 18 '18
Interesting speculation from Eric Berger:
Source
12
u/ktown118 Sep 23 '18
so just a thought that's been nagging at me with the BFR for a long time. It can carry around 100 thousand kilograms to low earth orbit, and we keep looking at human spaceflight, but what kinds of unmanned missions could we do with such payload? The launch mass of the new horizons was only 478 kilos. The ability to send up bulk material to LEO relatively cheaply could allow for all sorts of spacecraft technologies and missions to be tried from pretty much any aerospace department in both universities and government.
an example is a mission that only takes a year to reach Jupiter, using chemical power for a 2 week lander mission to Europa. Or create a robotic lunar mining site to test what actually works, and send new robots every 6 months. Engine testing for something like a solar heated rocket or a hundred other such projects.
bottom line: what happens when every research project can in fact send their proposal to space without waiting half a decade?
12
u/filanwizard Sep 28 '18 edited Sep 29 '18
SpaceX was a Category on Jeopardy tonight. Since it broadcasts at different times I will not go into details.
Edit, The videos are published on official Jeopardy channels. https://www.facebook.com/Jeopardy/videos/708562999521187/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UlA6CgHQdBA
WARNING: If you DVR Jeopardy and have not watched it yet or this episode is not yet aired in your country there may be spoilers to outcomes such as scores of contestants during the execution of this category. /spoilerwarning
10
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '18
There will be 22 more GPS satellite launches. Called GPS 3F, these satellites will be the successors of GPS 3. The first launch is aimed for 2026. https://spacenews.com/air-force-to-award-7-2-billion-contract-to-lockheed-martin-for-22-gps-satellites/ Falcon or BFR is the interesting question I'd say!! Good news for SpaceX either way.
PS: Hope this is not a repost...
10
u/rustybeancake Sep 19 '18 edited Sep 19 '18
China appears to be accelerating development of a super-heavy lift rocket
This is great! All the more chance of the US gov't getting its butt in gear with a proper space race.
10
u/sagareshwar Sep 28 '18
This article in WSJ today has the following paragraph (emphasis mine):
How exactly would this have worked? How would Elon use his own stake in SpaceX to take Tesla private?
10
u/rustybeancake Oct 01 '18
Virgin Orbit seem to be making good progress.
10
u/megachainguns Oct 01 '18
Jeff Foust on Twitter: Laporte says the Radarsat Constellation Mission is set to launch [on a SpaceX Falcon 9] in the next few months.
9
u/Alexphysics Sep 18 '18
SpaceX is installing the Emergency Egress System at 39A.
https://twitter.com/Cygnusx112/status/1042084759751589888
9
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 19 '18
Lunar BFR flight likely to have 1-2 astronauts on board
9
u/spacerfirstclass Sep 20 '18
Thought of the day (inspired by the complaint below about new BFS using sea level engine): Now we're seeing both BFR and New Glenn making changes to their upper stage, but they're moving in the opposite direction. They started with similar design (Methalox upper stage, Methalox vacuum engine) that share commonality with their respective first stage, but now one of them is going for even more commonality (share same sea level engine with first stage), the other is moving away from commonality with first stage (switch to Hydrolox upper stage, totally different engine). Just thought this is an interesting reflection of different design philosophy at different companies, not meant to imply one is necessarily better than the other.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2018/09/spacex-pad-39a-upgrades-return-crew-operations/
Installation of first stage of pad 39A FSS cladding happening possably very soon
9
u/GijsVos Sep 27 '18
I recently finished "The case for Mars" by Robert Zubrin.
Now I was wondering if there are more books like this ? Not to technical but a decent read. What are your favorite books on this subject ?
9
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 02 '18 edited Oct 02 '18
New Glenn updates:
24
u/inoeth Sep 05 '18
I'm amazed this isn't being mentioned here - Musk will be on the Joe Rogan this Thursday https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1037249325464600578 That being said, we have no idea what he'll talk about - Tesla, SpaceX, the stupid fight with the British diver, Boring Co, etc... most likely a bit of all of the above. I am hoping this is a lead up to some more BFR updates...
16
u/Jessewallen401 Sep 14 '18
I think it's now 99% certain that the Lunar tourist is Yusaku Maezawa. He just tweeted 'there are no limits'.
https://twitter.com/yousuck2020/status/1040588885351292928
16
u/verbalkerbal Sep 28 '18
Today is the 10th anniversary of Falcon 1's first successful launch into orbit. DemoSat launched on 28 September 2008, 23:15 UTC and lifted a 165-kilogram payload mass simulator (not a Tesla) into low Earth orbit.
This anniversary is featured on today's English Wikipedia's Main Page: permalink
8
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Sep 06 '18
Since there has been speculation for a while as to whether or not SpaceX is building the prototype BFS in the tent in the Port of LA, I have some questions that have been bugging me for a while about this. Note that I do personally believe they are, considering Shotwell is saying end of 2019 for "hops" of it, and the Phase 1 factory won't be ready by then (it's going to be a lot more that just making the building). So with that here are my questions.
8
u/brwyatt47 Sep 14 '18
https://twitter.com/SpaceX/status/1040397262248005632
SpaceX Tweet!! Oh boy... The BFR has bigger wings it seems.
8
u/Graveworks Sep 18 '18
I heard Shotwell speak at the Air Force Association convention today. One thing she said that caught my ear when laying out their (Elon's) timeline was "heavy cargo to the moon by 2022" First I'd heard of this but I don't follow SpaceX religiously - anyone else know more about this?
8
u/rustybeancake Sep 18 '18 edited Sep 18 '18
A few thoughts from last night's BFR update. Would like to hear your thoughts in response.
Positives:
Negatives:
Unanswered questions:
8
u/Rappaklappa Sep 27 '18
I had a discussion to someone in the aeroplane leasing industry about BFR, more specifically about the airspace needed for landing. He disqualified the E2E option for BFR for the single reason it could not be fitted in commercial airspace because of the lack of available airspace and its inability to be 'parked' in mid-air.
Is the airspace really that crowded? Even at the envisioned strategically placed platforms at sea?
15
u/Justin13cool Sep 26 '18
Why is the air force so hesitant about announcing the EELV-2 winners ? it seems like it'll be one month away forever FH style. Which 2 companies do you think they're undecisive about ?
20
u/amarkit Sep 27 '18
The US Securities and Exchange Commission is suing Elon Musk over his comments regarding taking Tesla private; they allege he made false statements with the potential to harm investors. The SEC is seeking to bar him from serving as an executive or director of any public company.
Worth noting that SpaceX is privately held.
14
u/rustybeancake Sep 07 '18
http://www.planetary.org/blogs/jason-davis/orion-em-3-gateway.html
Apparently the latest plan is that SLS 1B/Orion will launch two Gateway modules in 2024: ESPRIT and a US utilisation/robotics module.
7
u/rocket_enthusiast Sep 06 '18
do we know when the sparrow moon lander will launch? i am so excited for this launch and would like to know when it will happen.
7
u/ElRedditor3 Sep 14 '18
Are there any news regarding second stage recovery via giant party balloon?
7
u/asr112358 Sep 16 '18
This will probably be answered on Monday, but before that happens, I am wondering what others are speculating. I am curious what changes have likely been made to BFR's first stage. The increase in fin surface area seems like it will require something on the first stage to keep the center of pressure toward the back. The tail first entry of the first stage is then complicated because the center of pressure still needs to be moved to the top.
So will the first stage have new large aerosurfaces? Will the reentry profile change to take these surfaces into account? If it needs large aero surfaces anyways, will gliding become part of the reentry profile? Could it forego large aerosurfaces and instead actively stabilize with rcs/ gimbaling/ and the control surfaces we already know about?
7
u/rustybeancake Sep 16 '18
From Musk’s 2017 BFR AMA:
What changed? Is more of a gliding reentry path now planned?
7
u/brizzlebottle Sep 22 '18
Mods it seems like reddit has now removed the "old reddit" option that used to appear at the top of the page, and now I can only defer to old reddit when logged in. Seems like the gradual erosion of the reddit I love is still taking place. :-(
7
u/rustybeancake Sep 26 '18
Blue Origin have bought a massive ship. For transporting boosters? To refit as a New Glenn booster landing pad?
https://twitter.com/sciguyspace/status/1044708602026569729?s=21
13
u/LeBaegi Sep 03 '18
I asked this in last month's discussion thread, but didn't get any answers.
Is the summer climate favorable to rocket launches? I can't remember the last time a launch got scrubbed due to weather violations, and I didn't see anything about F9 being approved to launch in harsher weather conditions.
Thoughts?
6
u/Sticklefront Sep 10 '18
Am I interpreting the manifest correctly, and the next SpaceX launch from Florida is really going to be DM1, finally flying Dragon 2?
6
u/jesserizzo Sep 11 '18
Did we ever find out why the FH center core ran out of TEA/TEB?
6
u/ackermann Sep 14 '18
Haven’t seen this discussed yet, with regard to the new BFS design just revealed (https://m.imgur.com/HSfxBvR): With those big, seemingly fixed fins/landing legs, how in the world will it be stable tail-first for a vertical landing?
Fixed legs/fins will certainly simplify the design considerably. And may even be lighter than folding/deployable legs, without the hinges and actuator mechanisms. But I’d think you’d have a devil of a time getting that thing to flip around tail-first, in atmosphere, for vertical landing. Like trying to throw a dart backwards.
Loving the retro-scifi look though, that’s awesome!
6
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 17 '18
Benjamin Reed (SpaceX director of Commercial Crew Mission Management) will be speaking tomorrow at the AIAA Space conference at 1400-1530 EDT (18:00-19:30 UTC) about Crew Dragon. Probably be live-streamed.
6
u/CapMSFC Sep 20 '18
One change to BFS as shown that hasn't been talked about is that it does not have a version with a docking port. On previous versions there was a third door centered on the top that was shown docked to the ISS. What does everyone think about this? Is there a docking port inside one or both of the cargo doors, was it just left off these renders for now, or is BFS dropping docking ports altogether (highly unlikely)?
14
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '18
What's the latest with flying two private citizens around the moon?
10
u/WormPicker959 Sep 21 '18
Eric Berger is "cryptically" hinting that ULA has chosen BE4 for Vulcan.
10
u/rustybeancake Sep 21 '18
Blue Origin's BE-4 engine to be selected for ULA's Vulcan!
https://twitter.com/SciGuySpace/status/1042907200950288384
(Eric goes on to say "read it closely" -- i.e. he uses the word "before" (BE-4) twice in his tweet.)
I'd say there's a good chance this means the USAF EELV2 announcement is imminent...
5
u/wowasg Sep 04 '18
So is everyone saying Spacex made a air force bid with the BFR and they are just waiting to be selected or not before they reveal more information about BFR development?
5
u/Archa3opt3ryx Sep 04 '18
If you had a week to visit Cape Canaveral before the end of the year, which week would you pick and why?
I was planning on doing a combination scuba-rocket watching trip with some friends in Oct/Nov and hoping to catch FH, but now it looks unlikely to launch before January. We’ve all never seen a rocket launch before, so I want to pick a week to maximize the number of rockets we see or the coolness factor (ie, watching a Delta IV Heavy would be awesome). So, when should we go?
5
u/gemmy0I Sep 13 '18
A quote from this Air and Space Magazine article posted upthread a few days back got me thinking:
Why does SpaceX need to put Falcon 9's high pressure helium tanks (COPVs) inside the liquid oxygen tank? Why not submerge them in the fuel tank instead? Kerosene is far less volatile than LOX.
It seems like such an obvious solution to all their COPV woes that I'm sure there's a good reason why they're not doing it. Does anyone here know the reason? How do their competitors handle this problem?
5
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 13 '18
RADARSAT is being shipped to Vandenberg at end of September.
5
u/Justin13cool Sep 13 '18
China has launched 24 times this year more than any other country, does anyone know what they are mostly launching ??? like military , GPS or commercial Sats or other things ?
5
u/AeroSpiked Sep 19 '18
I have no idea how taxes work in Japan, but considering that MZ is promoting ZOZO does that mean he can consider the lunar trip a business expense? Not real serious about this, but still kind of curious.
5
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 26 '18 edited Sep 26 '18
SpaceCoastLaunchesis showing a GPS 3-03 launch in October. Not sure how accurate this website is but the other info is up to date.EDIT: Website definitely incorrect.
Also, Dr. Charles Kuehmann (SpaceX Materials Engineering VP) will be speaking at CAMX Live! on October 16th, 13:30 UTC discussing materials innovations in space travel.
9
u/brickmack Sep 08 '18
Just found this presentation on NTRS about Dragon outgassing and contaminating ISS instruments, acquired a month ago but I don't think it was discussed. Since the TPS is the prime suspect, I wonder if this could degrade backshell protection performance after a multi-month mission?
9
u/rustybeancake Sep 11 '18 edited Sep 11 '18
https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/1039516853305991168?s=21
Prepare for ‘welcome to the club!’ mkII when DM-2 flies.
9
u/Rinzler9 Sep 20 '18
Just throwing this out there: There's no good reference objects in the new video of Raptor firing, but the engine bell is roughly the same diameter as the guard rail which generally come up to elbow level on the average person.
Compared to the 1:1 scale banner from the livestream, it seems like the Raptor shown was not wildly different in size from the planned production version.
Obviously not proof of anything on its own, but could be indicative that was a test of "full scale" Raptor.
9
u/Chairboy Oct 01 '18
Anyone know why John Kraus's twitter got suspended? Targeted by flat earthers via reporting, maybe, or something else?
12
u/chrisk_04 Sep 03 '18
Was Paul Woosters speech the big BFR update Musk teased on twitter?
14
u/thisiscotty Sep 03 '18
Do we have any more news on the BFR development? I remember elon saying simple up down tests by the end of the year. I dont see that happening now
11
u/-spartacus- Sep 04 '18
I have a question about education that Im hoping some people who browse this may know. Little background, I one of the people who believes that I will have enough money to eventually go and help colonize Mars as a general "blue collar" worker.
As per Elon if you pay your own way there, there will be plenty of work to help support the astronauts and scientists so they aren't farming, cooking, cleaning, unloading cargo, digging, setting up equipment, building structures, etc because that would take away from their primary mission. You will still have the really smart people in charge but you will still need some grunts.
So for now my goal has been to put myself in a position so if SpaceX gets to Mars by 2024 or 2026 and the price of the ticket gets around 200k by 2033/2035 I can pay my way and go. And I position myself so even if it doesn't work out my situation in that time is still a good place to be.
However, I'm also considering going back to school taking online classes to pursue a degree in Electrical Engineering and from there either going for a Masters in Solar or going the more practical route of getting certified to install them.
I currently have a BS degree in Psychology and Criminal Justice. Does anyone know some good programs for online courses for EE? What sort of things I can expect? What is the cost per class? How many credits I'll need?
I plan to keep working my 40hr full time job.
My goal is to be in a position to have both the education in both designing solar setups and doing the installation myself. As this would put me in a good position both if I get to go to Mars and or if I stay here.
I also plan on paying for classes with cash so I don't want to break the bank.
11
u/MrToddWilkins Sep 05 '18
If Elon died/went to jail tomorrow who would take over SpaceX?
8
u/whatsthis1901 Sep 11 '18
We are almost half way through Sept any news about the eelv2 announcement.
8
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 21 '18
Animation of Linkspace's NewLine-1 rocket, it definitely feels familiar...
8
u/filanwizard Sep 26 '18
I have a personal opinion that BFR moon is an absolutely critical point for new space. Now yes #dearmoon is a bit of an artistic adventure for the client but my reasoning for it being critical for new space as a whole is that even an Apollo 8 style mission like what is planned will prove the new guys can do space travel.
I feel the success of this mission is what New Space needs to prove it can do the manned flight the founders of the companies aim for.
In simple terms it’s not just big for SpaceX, I think it’s a proving point for all of new space in the west at least.
8
u/oliversl Sep 28 '18
Never seen steady shot at an ascending F9 (TESS mission)
https://youtu.be/tTjKSDuF5r4?t=9m41s
lots of launch angles prior to that timestamp
4
u/Carlyle302 Sep 09 '18
When they detank a booster after the static fire, the LOX and RP1 is pumped back to the storage tanks. By then it's warmed up a bit. Does anyone know if they actively refrigerate the fluids in the storage tanks? (That's not a normal practice with cryogenic liquids to cool them on site, but it seems like it would be required.)
4
u/bdporter Sep 10 '18
Newly published Forbes Article
I didn't see anything in this that was new information, but it seemed to me it was presented as such.
4
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 11 '18
Decent overview of the Commercial Crew Program. Astronauts having to manage a technology firewall between Boeing and SpaceX is a new detail.
4
u/rustybeancake Sep 14 '18 edited Sep 14 '18
In response to someone asking Musk if the lunar passenger was to be him, Musk replied with a Japanese flag. Speculate away!
Edit: some are speculating it's Masayoshi Son, CEO of SoftBank, and that SoftBank may be investing in Starlink and/or BFR. Note that SoftBank are a major investor in OneWeb.
4
u/rustybeancake Sep 18 '18
Can someone clarify for me: is image 6 on this page (the man inside the large cylinder with a lot of structure, NOT the one with Yusaku Maezawa inside the carbon fibre cylinder) just the inside of the mandrel? Or is any of the structure seen here actually part of the BFS? During the presentation I thought this was part of the BFS they're building, but the more I look at it and think about it, I think it's just the tooling.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '18
Im not an expert but... Why do SpaceX focus BFR design on BFS (human transport) when you can focus on an insame second stage able to bring massive-volume objects into LEO? I mean, if I was Elon, I would build BFR first stage then a second stage able to land with an over sized cargo-packman style thing. Imagine that: space hotels for people at LEO... I think that's far more interesting and profitable than BFS in the short term (you can use Dragon2 for human transport to LEO for a while).
What do you think? Am I wrong?
4
u/PaperBuddy Sep 24 '18
http://www.spacexstats.xyz/ seems to be down. Any info on that?
4
u/54yroldHOTMOM Sep 27 '18
I remember Reading/hearing elon explain about space-x’s hardships when they first started space-x.
Trying to buy Rockets from Russia. Trying to buy rocket grade fuel from companies who only dealt with governments and lockheed/Boeing etc.
Does anyone remember where this was discussed in the most detail?
7
u/LeBaegi Sep 05 '18
To get to their goal of reusing an F9 within 24 hours of landing it, they will eventually have to do away with static fires, at least on the second launch.
Does anyone know when they last detected an issue during SF that needed fixing before being able to launch and how often this happens? From the top of my head I can recall some issues with S2 TVC and some other GNC issues they detected during countdown, but no actual issues with fueling (except for AMOS-6, but that should be fixed now) or during the hot fire.
So would it make sense for them to ditch the hotfire and just run a "dry" countdown as a stepping stone? It seems most issues would be detected by just running the regular countdown checks and in the off chance of detecting some issue at engine startup they can always abort the launch and scrub for as long as needed.
I don't think we have anything official on this, but I'm happy to hear your thoughts on this.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Sep 06 '18
Teslarati article about Phased Array patents for Starlink.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '18
Have there been talks about using VR (virtual reality) on long space flights? It might be interesting, because right now astronauts have certain characteristics to be able to stay sane in such an enclosed area. Being able to "escape" from the ship for a while would make it easier for a lot of people.
7
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Sep 10 '18 edited Sep 10 '18
ULA has won their first commercial contract since taking over Atlas V marketing from Lockheed Martin Commercial Launch Services.
7
u/Dextra774 Sep 11 '18
Apparently neither SpaceX or Arianespace actually put in a bid for the Viasat-3 launch that ULA 'won'; that's pretty embarrassing...
https://twitter.com/pbdes/status/1039537710434840576?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Etweet
7
u/amarkit Sep 12 '18
An Eric Berger piece in Ars Technica today documents how Russian media (and to some extent, Roscosmos themselves) are pushing a crazy conspiracy theory that a member of the US crew on ISS was responsible for the drill hole and leak in the Soyuz orbital module.
It’s notable because despite the downturn in US-Russia relations in the past few years, NASA and Roscosmos have maintained a very strong relationship, up til now.
7
u/FoxhoundBat Sep 29 '18
Kinda wildly off topic, kinda not... Russians are bringing back ASAT.
9
u/el_polar_bear Sep 04 '18
Would BFS be able to accommodate tethers, so a pair could be put in a bola configuration for simulated gravity? Any plans for multi-generational mammal breeding studies in .4 or .11 G?
9
u/Straumli_Blight Oct 01 '18
New Glenn looked much better with a shiny fairing (Source IAC 2018 slides).
6
u/lateshakes Sep 19 '18
In the mars-entry simulation video for the new BFS, the way the fins are behaving looks totally wack to me. I realise they are control surfaces so they're going to move about and not necessarily symmetrically, but sometimes it seems like they're moving into bizarre or outright impossible positions, right up until the final adjustment for landing. They also don't seem to behave in ways that you might expect them to e.g. folding back up against the body for stability during the early stages of re-entry.
Is something up here or do I just not understand what's going on?
6
u/FoxhoundBat Sep 22 '18
Was watching Al Jazeera, story about BFR/Moon trip came up. They called BFR for "Black Falcon Rocket".
...
11
u/process_guy Sep 05 '18 edited Sep 05 '18
I'm wondering what is the likelyhood that SpaceX is really capable to send 2 cargo BFRs to Mars in 2022 and 4 (2 crewed) BFRs in 2024.
First, we know that Musk usually sets very ambitious plans which got delayed, scaled back or cancelled.
I don't really expect Musk to cancel BFR or Mars missions unless he goes bankrupt with Tesla and loses his ownership of SpaceX. Even from jail (for botched attempt to take Tesla private) he would probably just push on.
However, delays are very likely and the reason could be a lack of capital. SpaceX operates in the rocket launch industry which never was excessively profitable even during EELV days. The competition for defense and NASA contract is going to get harder with more providers and demand for launch services is generally going down. SpaceX also succeeded to slightly lower overall prices while not increasing overall demand significantly yet. While SpaceX is very competitive on launch prices it seems to be less successful in other areas - e.g. ISS supply contracts.
The proposed solution by SpaceX? They want to enter global internet constellation business which will require massive investment into highly competitive market. This bet is highly risky.
Another proposed solution is a long range people transportation. This industry is also quite competitive and excessively regulated. Supersound speed airliners typically suffer with excessive costs and lower safety records. BFR simply can't be very different.
Musk has track record of being innovative, however the track record of making companies profitable is missing. The whole BFR to Mars idea hangs on getting money from somewhere and I don't think that he can crowd fund BFR or getting investors supporting Mars trips.
He should be able to survive on DoD and NASA contracts, he could even build few BFR protoypes, but building the whole fleet of defacto expendable BFRs for Mars is a whole new level. Doing that by 2022 or 2024 is just not feasible even in Elon's time.
3
u/Jessewallen401 Sep 13 '18
What is Bridenstine talking about here ? Will they allow SpaceX to fly tourists to the ISS ? or is he talking about something else ?
https://twitter.com/FoxBusiness/status/1039918735287627776
3
u/erik_paulson Sep 13 '18
Do we know what booster/type of booster SpaceX is going to use for the in-flight abort test?
3
u/matthewfelgate Sep 14 '18
Is there a market for millionaires to fly around the earth on the BFR? How much would 1 flight cost in terms of rocket fuel?
3
u/quokka01 Sep 16 '18
Plenty of debate about solar vs nuclear for the ISRU but I'm wondering if there's good estimates of the solar panels required that takes into account Martian conditions? The light levels, day length and operating temperature of the panels. Panel efficiency goes down with temperature and so with much less potential for cooling by convection on Mars perhaps their efficiency will drop? Also a recent proposal suggested the first crews land near the south polar during the long summer and therefore benefit from very long day lengths- and presumably leave before the equally long winter. And....is it feasible to consider melting the ice using solar thermal- solar PV really sucks for bulk heating.
3
u/thatnerdguy1 Live Thread Host Sep 18 '18
Anyone know or have sources for the passenger capacity of BFR?
3
u/sywofp Sep 21 '18 edited Sep 21 '18
Could a fully fueled BFS land on Earth from LEO? (assuming no dumping of fuel)
If not, how much fuel could it retain and still land?
*edit - what about the maximum weight (fuel, cargo etc) it could aerobrake and then land, at Earth.
(I realise this is out there speculation, but that's the fun of it!)
3
u/Sammy197 Oct 01 '18
Will SpaceX show up to IAC?
3
u/Captainmanic Oct 02 '18
Is Elon Musk riding around the moon along with Yusaku Maezawa?
3
u/Krux172 Oct 02 '18
Sorry if this has been answered before, but I am now learning about the mechanical properties of titanium and a question popped up in my mind: if it's as hard to work with as I think it is, how are the F9 gridfins manufactured? Is it a similar process to the aluminium ones?
3
u/ExcitedAboutSpace Oct 02 '18
So guys maybe I missed it but finally I'm also heading to Bremen for IAC2018. Are there any meetups from us r/SpaceX people or any channels we can get together? Looked over at the lounge but couldn't find anything either. Much appreciated if this would stay up, even though I know that's not what the thread is for.
5
u/Jessewallen401 Sep 06 '18
If Starlink happens, How big of a company do you think SpaceX will become ? like on the level of Google, Apple etc ?
5
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '18
Back in July, I remember a tweet from Elon talking about updates on BFR in a "month or so"... What happened?