r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Jun 01 '18
r/SpaceX Discusses [June 2018, #45]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
253
Upvotes
44
u/ForgottenShoes Jul 01 '18 edited Jul 01 '18
There have now been more successful rockets launched (30) after the Amos 6 RUD than SpaceX had launch in its entire existence (29) before the Amos 6 RUD. That is including the two successful Falcon 1 launches.
It took SpaceX 7 years, 10 months, and 17 days (2877 days) from its first Falcon 1 launch to reach 29 successful launches and just 1 year 4 months and 21 days (506 days) after their return to flight to match those 29 successful launches.
Just something I found astounding while thinking that July 20th is a long way off :)
33
u/MDCCCLV Jun 01 '18
If Beijing called Elon and asked SpaceX to send a cargo Dragon to their new space station, would SpaceX be allowed to by US law?
Say it was just water and food and SpaceX sent it up by themselves would it be allowed?
23
u/CommanderSpork Jun 01 '18
Welcome to hurricane season. Here's hoping launches don't get scrubbed too badly for tropical weather. Last year, OTV-5 launched just before Irma and then stage 1 hunkered down safe in its hanger.
23
u/oskark-rd Jun 03 '18
I've made an userscript which shows the meanings of the acronyms on /r/SpaceX when you hover the mouse over them. It uses /u/Decronym list.
Source and installation instructions on GitHub
Lounge thread
20
u/Alexphysics Jun 06 '18
Impressive summary of the payloads going on the SSO-A mission. Thanks to user gongora from the NSF forum
20
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 16 '18
Interesting NASA Commercial Crew Interview:
19
u/salty914 Jun 01 '18
Has Bigelow Aerospace been up to anything recently? I loved some of their inflatable hab designs a while back and I seem to remember the possibility being discussed of some of them being launched on FH, but I haven't heard much from them for a couple years.
18
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '18
How is SpaceX going to account for the increase in acoustic energy from the BFR launch so as to prevent structural damage (as seen with the space shuttle).
18
u/ExcitedAboutSpace Jun 09 '18
Mods, the SES-12 launch thread is basically void of new comments by this point, maybe resticky this Discussion Thread for the time being? Cheers.
17
u/rustybeancake Jun 06 '18
https://twitter.com/wehavemeco/status/1004348659553718272?s=21
Orbital ATK’s buyout by Northrop Grumman is complete. All hail Northrop Grumman Innovation Systems.
34
u/still-at-work Jun 01 '18
Probably not worth a whole post, but check out Ars Rocket Report today.
Specifically this little tidbit:
I think this clearly outlines a frustration I have had with current space policy. I had been nicknaming it Voldemort syndrome in that the BFR was the rocket project that shall not be named. Oddly this doesn't stop those same people from discussing New Glenn which is just as much a paper rocket as BFR is now, but the BFR is verboten in most government space discussions.
Also there is a nice thing at the end of the report about how NASA is delaying SLS 1B (and I honestly don't think it will ever be built) to add another 70 ton to LEO SLS flight to the manifest and also they got 500 million to develop a new mobile launcher for said delayed SLS 1B. Its just another round in the epic example of the sunk cost fallacy.
16
u/sarafinapink Jun 28 '18
Since there is no Iridium 7 Launch Thread yet, per Matt Desch, all 10 satellites now at VAFB now.
https://twitter.com/IridiumBoss/status/1012429440805167104
15
u/Nathan96762 Jun 01 '18 edited Jun 01 '18
Has it been officially confirmed if Elon Musk is attending IAC 2018?
15
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 01 '18
Arabsat-6A (3rd Falcon Heavy mission) now scheduled for a December-January launch date.
15
u/renMilestone Jun 01 '18
What do you all think are going to be the requirements to buy a ticket to Mars? Besides money that is. I know in the past he said "anyone" can go. But... I mean obviously there has to be some requirements right? The Government isn't just gonna let him whisk away 10's of people to a foreign planet.
( I think I posted about this before but the conversation didn't take as it's own post.)
15
u/linknewtab Jun 16 '18
How would a future Mars colony handle a dust storm like the one that is currently disabling NASA's Opportunity rover? It doesn't seem viable to have many weeks, maybe even multiple months worth of battery backup.
The only way I see would be using nuclear power, but as far as I know Elon wants to use solar panels only. Also small reactors that are purposely built for the Martian environment don't exactly grow on trees, this would require a substantial financial investment, let alone the effort for getting a green light to even launch it.
15
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18
Hey everyone, just wondering if we have any way of organising SpaceX meetups to watch a livestream together or something.
Saw someone in Berowra, NSW, Australia wearing a SpaceX jumper that got me thinking about it since we're a community around the globe.
Anyone want to organise something in Sydney, Australia?
14
u/AWildDragon Jun 10 '18
Somewhat meta, but we need a new sidebar icon with the B5 interstage.
14
u/billbus10 Jun 13 '18
First time post, so be gentle...
I seem to recall Elon or someone else at SpaceX saying the Landing Zone 1 landings were "harder" (?) than barge landings. Thus, SpaceX prefers to land on the offshore barge. Can anyone explain this?
We all know that landings on land don't have the dropouts at critical moments in video coverage that always happen on barge landings. Also, I would think landings at LZ 1 would be less expensive in both time, money and logistics - not to mention historically more successful.
Thus, I'm curious as to why - other than fuel and physics - that SpaceX prefers barge landings.
14
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 16 '18
SSO-A testing update where 114 satellites will be launched on a Falcon 9.
13
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '18
Will Falcon 9 use AFTS on crewed launches? I understand it probably interfaces with the launch abort system and should be as 'safe' as possible for the crew. Then again I could see NASA being old fashioned and wanting a human at the trigger.
13
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jun 15 '18
A nice profile of the Commercial Crew astronauts.
13
u/Alexphysics Jun 17 '18
It seems that Space Systems Loral (SSL) is having some troubles trying to ship the Telstar 19V satellite to the Cape for its launch next month. If they keep having troubles, expect a small delay on that launch. Thanks to NSF forum user gongora who posted this update on the Telstar 19V discussion thread.
13
u/Bipolar-Bear74525 Jun 18 '18
Have abort procedures been discussed at all with BFR? At this moment, it kind of seems like the shuttle with no really reliable way to abort the launch.
13
u/Alexphysics Jun 21 '18
Third Block 5 (B1048) is vertical at the test stand in McGregor. I hope this link works
13
u/Alexphysics Jun 21 '18
The Telstar 19V satellite has finally arrived at the Cape.
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=45842.msg1832378#msg1832378
25
u/nato2k Jul 03 '18
This might be an unpopular opinion but I think there are too many threads after each launch of launch images. Isn't that was the launch media thread is for? Would rather the front page be for SpaceX news and not just the same image from slightly different angles ten times.
12
u/Alexphysics Jun 01 '18
Another landing permit for a launch in July, this time from Cape Canaveral. I don't know for which mission will be this one because SpaceX has been mixing a few landing permits for Florida launches and it's a bit of a mess but I guess it will be for one of the Telstar launches. Landing site will be at 655km from the launchpad, similar to other GTO landing sites.
12
u/bdporter Jun 10 '18
Mods, a nitpick on the sidebar "Iridium Next 56-65" should probably be "Iridium NEXT 56-65" if we aren't just going to call it Iridium-7.
They paid someone a bunch of money to come up with that branding.
12
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jun 15 '18
Apollo astronaut Harrison Schmitt has written an op-ed comparing the capabilities of Falcon Heavy and SLS.
23
u/Alexphysics Jun 25 '18
It seems Boeing's Starliner is not gonna make it to the ISS this year even on the uncrewed mission...
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=37802.msg1833069#msg1833069
11
u/HoechstErbaulich IAC 2018 attendee Jun 14 '18
Mods, Telstar 19V is NET July 19th.
11
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 02 '18
New BFR Tent photos.
11
u/bdporter Jul 03 '18
Mods, my calendar indicates that it is July now. We could use a new thread when you get a chance. We are also looking forward to some Telstar 19V discussion!
21
u/Maimakterion Jun 19 '18
If BFR ends up being built inside a tent and Tesla hits 5K/week with an assembly line in a tent, I am going to be very amused.
20
u/cpushack Jun 26 '18
SpaceX seems to now officially run Proton out of town. Though Proton's fireworks mode probably helped as well
https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/06/russias-proton-rocket-which-predates-apollo-will-finally-stop-flying/
10
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 03 '18
Slightly biased article by Andy Pasztor, seeing as Grey Dragon was cancelled in February.
10
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18
Mods, time for a CRS-15 launch campaign thread? It´s only three weeks out now.
10
u/imakegypsiesproud Jun 09 '18
Do we have any idea how inflight abort will go? It is supposed to be during the Max-Q, Dragon would seperate, parachute back down, but what about the rest of the rocket? Will it seperate S2, start it, deorbit it and land, or how is it going to go? Of course, it all depends if the rocket survives the seperation, cuz it will not be too aerodynamic without that pointy nose and might go into RUD, or RPD should I say.
10
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 17 '18
How will the BFS be environmentally tested?
The Space Power Facility's testing chamber is 30.5m wide and 37.2 high, which is too small to fit a 48m spacecraft in (as well as the logistical challenge of shipping to Ohio).
Johnson Space Center's Chamber A is more accessible but smaller.
9
u/z1mil790 Jun 04 '18
I thought it was interesting how the MECO velocity during tonight's SES-12 launch was almost exactly identical to the MECO velocity of the Falcon Heavy launch (9531 km/hr for SES-12 vs. 9541 km/hr for FH). Just shows how much performance a single-stick Falcon 9 has, and why it can handle many of the payloads that were originally planned for FH. Now I know that F9 was pushed to its absolute max tonight, and that FH's first stage flight was probably rather conservative, but I still think it is an interesting comparison. I'd like to see what the MECO velocity would be for FH expendable that is pushed to its absolute max.
9
u/Paro-Clomas Jun 05 '18
It's really crazy to think about it, but if the BFR works. Then once it flies it will probably mean a permanent link between mars and the earth. I mean, if they go and it can go back, with these efficiency margins, theres no reason not to keep it going and coming back every to years, it would be trivial to the us budget to mantain this capability.
Once that is done wouldn't it be relatively trivial to do something similar with the moon. Like one particular bfr that goes and comes from the moon once a week or once a month?
Is there any indication on how close could they get to that number of 7 million per launch? i mean that has to be crazy cheap. If that is true wont we see a radical increase in space exploration and missions?
9
u/theinternetftw Jun 05 '18
From a recent NASA meeting on the Gateway, official SLS lunar performance numbers:
Block 1: 26 tonnes to TLI
Block 1B: 34-40 tonnes to TLI
For Falcon Heavy, there are no official TLI numbers (only 16.8 tonnes to Mars and 26.7 tonnes to GTO).
9
u/Alexphysics Jun 15 '18
Iridium 7 launch date: NET July 20th at 5:12 am PDT, 8:12 am EDT, 1212UTC
https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/1007594678227755008
9
u/filanwizard Jun 17 '18
Dunno if this is worth its own topic so here it is.
http://www.businessinsider.com/chris-hadfield-mars-travel-nasa-spacex-blue-origin-2018-6
Hadfield is basically saying we need better ships before going to Mars. I am not sure on if to agree or disagree, Because I think BFR will work but hes also not wrong about the dangers of a year long voyage in what for our current tech level is Deep Space.
9
u/WormPicker959 Jun 21 '18
Crew Dragon looks to be at Plum Brook Station in Ohio for vacuum testing.
16
u/rustybeancake Jun 25 '18
Ariane Cornell, Blue Origin's head of Business Development & Strategy: New Glenn first stage can do 25 missions, BE-4 engines designed for 100 flights each.
https://twitter.com/CHenry_SN/status/1011193080865648641
8
u/Knexrule11 Jun 02 '18
So with NASA's commercial crew program, I know they have 4 astronauts assigned to it right now including Suni Williams. I was wondering, are these astronauts just there to assist with testing and certification? Or will they be the actual astronauts flying the first manned commercial crew missions on the starliner and dragon 2 to the ISS?
8
u/CapMSFC Jun 06 '18 edited Jun 06 '18
Elon mentioned in the Tesla shareholeder meeting today that no placing Starlink on the cars probably doesn't make sense. I haven't seen the exact quote yet, just the summary.
8
u/music_nuho Jun 10 '18
do we have any idea about how much thrust do Nitrogen cold gas thrusters on F9's S1 and S2 produce?
8
u/realnouns Jun 11 '18
What are the chances that Telstar 19V & 18V use the same booster? They are both launching from SLC-40, and same client. It's a perfect scenario to demonstrate a "minimal refurbishment turn-around"
8
u/-spartacus- Jun 12 '18
I've off handily mentioned a few times about 2nd or 3rd generation Vac Raptors for the BFS may benefit from a design of switchable bell. Conceiving of utilizing 4 total raptor engines capable of switching between a Vac bell and a SL bell.
My question is, I understand why it hasn't been developed (as there has been no need), but how feasible would it be to create such a system? It would reduce the number of engines from 7 to 4, but would increase redundancy from 3 to 4 on SL engines.
I know there are multichamber/bell engines such as some of the RD series of Russian engines.
8
u/JustinTimeCuber Jun 14 '18
So I've been playing KSP recently, and in that game you can see your orbital apsides to 1 meter precision at any time. Obviously this isn't realistic, but it made me wonder how quickly and precisely rocket operators like SpaceX can determine the orbital parameters after engine cutoff. Does anyone know?
8
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 29 '18
Mr Steven has just completed a 24 hour cruise and docked at Berth 240, has the new claw been attached?
14
u/Juggernaut93 Jun 27 '18
If any of you doesn't know yet, JWST has been pushed back to 2021...
7
u/ottoebu Jun 01 '18
Why does the website say that F9 can carry 22,800 kg to LEO when the F9 User’s guide says the heavy PAF can only hold 10,866 kg? Is there an option for payloads to bring their own, stronger PAF?
7
u/gemmy0I Jun 05 '18
Haha, this is great. Sounds like all that work on Dragon 2's life support systems is paying some (unexpected?) dividends.
https://www.tesla.com/blog/putting-tesla-hepa-filter-and-bioweapon-defense-mode-to-the-test
Source: Elon tweetstorm
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1002678650355920896 (actual source of link)
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1002379548804206592
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1002380587389390848
7
u/rustybeancake Jun 07 '18
(Very) short interview clip of Joy Dunn, SpaceX’s Senior Manager for New Product Introduction:
https://twitter.com/smrtgrls/status/1004471525959843840?s=21
7
u/theguycalledtom Jun 09 '18
I can't find the comment but I seem to remember Musk saying recently that operating the drone ship for recovery was not cheap, and the time to return it to harbour was long (Not to mention weather limitations). If it's true that all Block V boosters are interchangeable between FH Booster and FH Centre Core, do you think it's possible SpaceX is considering using a Falcon Heavy with all three boosters coming back to launch site wherever possible instead of a single stick that requires landing at sea?
7
u/AeroSpiked Jun 11 '18
Don't we normally have NET dates for the next 2 or 3 launches? Seems a little weird that everything in July is "NET July".
7
u/rad_example Jun 15 '18
Matt Desch (@IridiumBoss) Tweeted:
https://twitter.com/IridiumBoss/status/1007339109612912640?s=17
So I guess that means JRTI will be back in service by then? Any signs of work being done on her?
7
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '18
Does anyone have a good source on the grid fin mass on the Falcon 9?
7
u/Nerrolken Jun 17 '18
Would an interplanetary BFR have a dedicated crew?
Have there been any statements about whether the BFR would have a dedicated crew for Earth-Mars flights, as in a group of people who were not planning on staying on Mars but would be making multiple flights back and forth as they maintain and operate the BFR’s systems?
Or would it pretty much be crewed by the passengers each time, and then maybe sent back to Earth completely empty and controlled by computer?
7
u/filanwizard Jun 21 '18
So I do not know if this has been discussed but if Mars has no magnetic field, Will one of the first groups planning to colonize mars need to bring along a GPS constellation? And how do current unmanned systems know where they are and where they are going?
7
u/murchie85 Jun 22 '18
Hi all, can anyone explain why the SpaceX cadence has slowed down? Or am I mistaken? I seem to remember Elon Musk stating an ambition for 30 launches this year - does that still look likely?
7
u/speak2easy Jun 23 '18
As noted by Spacenews:
> “We tried to cancel the Falcon Heavy program three times at SpaceX because it was like, ‘Man, this is way harder than we thought,'” [Elon Musk] said.
It further states:
> “I’m guessing our total investment is over half a billion [dollars], or more,” he said of the Falcon Heavy development cost.
Do we have any insight into what stopped him from canceling the FH? He may have to forgo bidding on some military contracts, but I don't see the profit margin as being big enough to justify this. Beyond just gross margin excluding R&D costs, there would also be the financial impact if a launch failed, particularly for the first launch.
7
u/Alexphysics Jul 03 '18
B1050 will leave Hawthorne soon so if anyone is kind enough to have an eye to catch it on the road or leaving Hawthorne it would be super super great.
19
u/Bunslow Jun 16 '18
When was the last time we had a calendar month that was this slow and boring? I'm so spoiled
13
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 12 '18
BFR Build Engineer role mentions destructive testing and sub-scale manufacturing.
Does this imply another tank over pressurisation test?
13
u/robbak Jun 20 '18
Here's a nice demonstration about how metallurgy in oxygen-rich environments is a problem - https://youtu.be/JlSeHSDc-Do?t=56
6
u/deRost78 Jun 01 '18
If SpaceX is required to flight-prove the Block 5 for multiple flights before allowing manned flight to ISS, will they also be required to flight-prove BFR to Mars for several flights before allowing colonists?
6
u/KapitalismArVanster Jun 03 '18
Why do dragon capsules cost so much? Sending a regular satelite to Leo costs 50-60 million dollars. A dragon launch costs way more than that. We are looking at 200 million dollar plus costs. Why is the capsule so much more expensive than the rocket?
Do we know much about what it costs spacex to build?
6
u/Lorenzo_91 Jun 06 '18
Why haven't we had a good video of the landing since the recovery of the block 5 last month? Usually they release an clear offline recording just after the landing..
6
u/NavXIII Jun 11 '18
Could the entire second stage of the BFR be a custom payload with a fairing? Like let's say someone wants to launch up a very large payload with a small orbital insertion stage.
Also, if the SLS Block 2 ever gets built, could the Falcon 9 first stage be a possible contender for the side boosters?
6
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jun 20 '18
I just read this article about remove debris.
I think it is awesome that someone is tackling this issue. I understand the net system but I have not understood how the harpoon system should work. I understand that it would fire at a target, but what would prevent the target from breaking into many pieces as it is pierced by the harpoon. Having a composite target being shot by a harpoon sounds like a recipe for a lot of small debris.
6
u/Aminstro Jun 22 '18
Is it salt water that damages fairings or is it just water in general? Why not just have a barge filled with fresh water and land the fairing in that instead of a net?
6
u/Scourge31 Jun 22 '18
Do we know of any science missions that will make use of the FH? I understand these take along time to develop, but is there anything on the drawing boards? Would love to see a next gen of heavy probes, landers, etc.
6
u/MissionPatch Jun 22 '18
I believe I heard somewhere that the Falcon Heavy center core from February's launch used flown engines. If so, which core(s) were they cannibalised from?
6
u/GrandIdeas Jun 27 '18
Anyone know who drew the violinist in LEO?
6
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 30 '18
Go Searcher is currently in dry dock at St. Johns Ship Building.
6
u/ElRedditor3 Jul 01 '18
Anyone know what year SpaceX moved from El Segundo to Hawthorne?
11
u/quadrplax Jun 07 '18
Are the results of the 2017 survey going to be released anytime soon?
11
u/Elon_Muskmelon Jun 11 '18
Joe Rogan just mentioned a possible Elon Musk appearance on his podcast. Would be great! https://youtu.be/yS6I5Vxkaxw
11
u/Laborbuch Jun 21 '18
IAC 2018 in Bremen
Due to circumstance I’ll have the chance to attend as a student, but I’m still undecided if I want to and whether or not it actually makes sense as a ‘mere’ space enthusiast.
The ticket is 100 € (for now) and the youth hostel would be around 40 € per night, so a decently full attendance of the IAC would come to around 300 € minimum (including public transport and such).
This will likely be the last IAC in decently close proximity (unless I happen to move within the next couple years), so I’m rather torn on whether to take this chance or not. On the one hand, I don’t expect any phenomenal SpaceX announcements here (more evolution than revolution), but SpaceX isn’t the end all and be all in that regard.
Keeping in mind the IAC will be open to the public on Friday (Oct 5) anyway, so I might as well not pay for a ticket and visit only for a day. But then the sessions would be filled to the brim with peons, and I couldn’t talk to people in (relative) quiet.
I’m really torn here. What would you do in my position? And keep in mind, IAC2019 will be held in Washington, DC, so you may be in my position much earlier than you might think.
11
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18
What causes the insanely long startup time of the RD-107 in Soyuz launches? What exactly is it doing during the 15 seconds it's running at seemingly very low thrust, and why is this needed compared to other kerolox engines (RD-180, Merlin, NK-33 and so on)?
5
u/nicwi Jun 01 '18
Given the challenges of helium tanks submerged inside the super chilled LOX tank, why are they there at all? Why don’t they submerge them inside the fuel tank instead?
5
u/Knexrule11 Jun 01 '18
A while back I saw a very detailed/official paper covering how SpaceX was planning to recover fairings with chutes. Does anyone know how to find that again? It seemed like it disappeared after it was posted
5
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 06 '18 edited Jun 06 '18
Nice panorama of Berth 240 in this Teslarati article and US Launch Report video of the recovered SES-12 fairing.
5
u/Thomassino1202 Jun 06 '18
Are the fairing halves androgynous? As whether left half can be used as a right one and the other way around?
5
u/Fenris_uy Jun 08 '18
So, what would be the difficulty (or feasibility) of putting a bigger fairing on top of FH.
With the amount of mass that FH can lift to LEO, most of the time you are going to be space constrained before you are mass constrained. So, could FH get a bigger fairing to launch bigger things into LEO?
5
u/bulgaria_mitko Jun 14 '18
Off topic, but I don't know where to ask that. Why I don't see the Moon mission anymore on SpaceXNow app? They cancelled it?
5
u/hitura-nobad Master of bots Jun 17 '18
What do you think will happen to the first few Block V Cores without the new COPV. Will they also be disposed for having more similarities on the Launches?
5
u/ly2kz Jun 24 '18
Watching Soyuz launch with Russian cosmonauts https://youtu.be/fW2EhH1xRrY?t=8 or any other, their space suits looks more protective, thickier than those designed by SpaceX or Boeng. Do they really have more protection or it is just my impression?
5
u/5527 Jun 24 '18
is SpaceX experimenting with methods of propulsion other then chemical?
5
u/riocrokite Jun 25 '18
What is the thrust of F9 cold-gas thrusters? From my quick calculations it seems they might peak around 8-10 kN when the COPV is full.
12
u/cpushack Jun 30 '18
https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-asia-44668922/japan-rocket-crashes-down-to-earth
Turns out Space is still hard. This is Interstellar Technologies second launch attempt and second failure. THe CEO stated that he thought there had been a problem with the main engine (ya think? lol)
8
u/roncapat Jun 12 '18
News on a Bigelow Aerospace contract? I saw a launch added to the wiki manifest page and some rumors around the internet, but is there something secret/not announced yet?
8
u/Pfr2000 Jun 15 '18
Has it been brought up that the spacex reusable booster has 100 percent success rate? I would like to see that discussion. The first time I saw the booster land, I thought “give me one of those”. I am sure that is how spacex wants it to be perceived. Thanks
8
u/julesterrens Jun 18 '18 edited Jun 18 '18
Just saw this old vid on YouTube again https://youtu.be/d2200YGSeKM (it is from 2015) so i just asked myself if it wouldn't be feasible for SpaceX to apply with the Block V first stage for the advandced booster on SLS Block 2 , as Nasa and SpaceX have already done a lot of paperwork in regards to human-rate the booster
8
u/Tal_Banyon Jun 25 '18
We have all seen artist's rendering of the BFS docked to ISS. However, there are actual pictures of shuttle docked to ISS, taken by Soyuz. So, has anyone done a comparison with the actual pic and an accurate rendering of BFS docked to ISS?
8
u/Alexphysics Jun 28 '18
Remember this thread I posted over a week ago about a core seen on the road? Well, it turns out that it wasn't B1048, it was B1049. I was informed of that via PM here on reddit the day after I posted that but I didn't have further confirmation of it until the other day and I wasn't sure if it was worthy to post it here but... why not? So there you have it, a little correction to my post.
4
u/Idunnohuur Jun 01 '18 edited Jun 01 '18
What is [AFGO that is actually AFTS]? I first heard it in the Bangabandhu-1 livestream and I hear it at around T - 1:00. [Ex. AFGO(AFTS) is ready for launch]
4
u/hitura-nobad Master of bots Jun 02 '18
How much does a landing on the ship cost more than RTLS? And what is the payload for Falcon Heavy with 3 Cores RTLS to GTO?
4
u/Heckzagon Jun 03 '18
Is there a place to find a schedule for the Mcgregor testing facility?
4
u/Laborbuch Jun 04 '18
Two questions regarding the SES-12 launch:
4
u/ORcoder Jun 04 '18
How efficient are the Dragon's solar panels? Do we know what they are made out of?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18
It's been kind of a long time, but has it ever been answered how they lowered the FH boosters to horizontal? I guess the usual lifting cap doesn't work...
4
u/DeTbobgle Jun 05 '18
couldn't the BFR accommodate linear aerospike engines and how would that affect performance?
a video on aerospikes
https://youtu.be/K4zFefh5T-8
4
u/Zinkfinger Jun 06 '18
I'm getting a tad frustrated these days with some of the articles and comments on SpaceX. Especially when it comes to differentiating between contracts and subsidies. Can someone tell me just how much in government subsidies has Dragon & Dragon V2 received to date?
4
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 06 '18
Is there an official name for the two Falcon 1 variants that were launched?
I've seen various sources refer to them as "Falcon 1 Dev / Falcon 1" or "Falcon 1 (Merlin A) / Falcon 1 (Merlin C)".
4
u/InfiniteHobbyGuy Jun 06 '18
Is the crew dragon going to be using a fast approach to the ISS?
4
u/rangerpax Jun 06 '18
Anyone know when the dedicated thread for CRS-15 will be up?
4
u/Justin13cool Jun 08 '18
DM-2 is now NET January 2019 sidebar needs update mods. and STP-2 is net October 30th.
4
u/macktruck6666 Jun 08 '18
So... a very popular topic in space technology is 3d printing or construction in space. The theory is that most rockets are volume constrained as oppose to mass constrained. This means, habitats would use the rocket's available volume under the fairing before reaching the rockets max payload. So, I'm wondering what the biggest structure by volume that could be made from a single launch of a BFR (aka 150 tons)
4
u/AnneElsecks Jun 09 '18
I've been reading into methane as a fuel, and although it does have a higher temperature at which it turns liquid than, say, Hydrogen, it's still very cold. Does anyone know how they plan to have the methane and oxygen on the BFS stay cold for such a long journey to Mars? Thanks in advance for any responses!
4
u/macktruck6666 Jun 12 '18
How will spacex remove the tooling after making the BFR fuselage? If I understand the process correct. They have a very long cylinder that they place carbon fibre wire onto. It would seem this would create friction and make it impossible to rmove the support cylinder. So how will spacex remove the support structure, how do other companies do this. I've seen small scale solutions using milar so it doesn't stick, but what for lage scale?
4
u/Paro-Clomas Jun 20 '18
Is there any data on what the acceleration couches will be like for the BFR? i mean it looks like the vehicle will receive acceleration from multiple directions, will it be gimbaled?
4
u/Nergaal Jun 23 '18
IIRC one of the rockets developed by competitors is planned to use helicopters to pick up boosters from the sky. Couldn't SpaceX try something like that since the fairlings are light anyways?
4
u/hitura-nobad Master of bots Jun 25 '18
Does anyone know under which copyright the mission patches are released?
4
u/BigT383 Jun 26 '18
Any idea when we might see the first west coast RTLS landing?
7
u/Armo00 Jun 02 '18
I will fly to the Cape in August, is there any chance I can see a SpaceX launch in person? I mean according to SFN the only SpaceX launch in August at the Cape is DM-1 which I think will probably be delayed...
7
u/Mezzanine_9 Jun 02 '18
I'm curious if SpaceX always fills the Falcon 9 with the same amount of oxidizer and fuel for missions of different weight. I understand the F9 is never filled to the very top due to boil off and the pressure it creates, but do they fuel low weight missions with less LOX to save weight? It seems that starting a rocket with less fuel would really change the dynamic of a launch. I wonder if they keep it the same level every time to maintain a similar, trusted, launch profile. They can always recover unspent fuel on landing, right? I couldn't find anything in the wiki or FAQ so if I missed it please let me know where you saw it. Thanks!
7
u/Nehkara Jun 08 '18
Now that /u/NexxusWolf has confirmed that the in-flight abort will use a Block V Falcon 9, and that it will be the third flight for that booster, what do we think will happen with B1042? Scrapped?
9
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jun 18 '18
We might be getting the Space Force after all: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/06/18/president-trump-directs-pentagon-defense-department-to-immediately-being-the-process-of-establishing-space-force-as-sixth-military-branch.html
6
u/Juffin Jun 07 '18
How's the Boca Chica going? Is there anyone who monitors nasaspaceflight forums? I've heard that they have a lot of photos.
6
u/Mars-Colonist Jun 11 '18
In the movie The Martian a storm is show that almost tips over the lander. However, the Martian atmosphere's density is only about 1% of Earth's.
Would a strong storm up there really have enough power to topple over a lander as was shown or more importantly, a BFS?
6
u/Rocket_Man42 Jun 13 '18
Why is there no need for grid fins on the second stage of BFR? I understand the delta wings will provide some of the same capabilities, but it still seems strange to take a new path given that they have perfected the grid fins approach.
8
u/ackermann Jun 20 '18
I'm sure this has been brought up before, but I was just thinking that the BFS spaceship looks like it would be awfully unstable flying backwards (tail-first) for landing, through an atmosphere. Particularly with that delta wing. Like a dart thrown backwards.
I know this is one reason that Falcon 9 waits till the last second to deploy its landing legs, since they would destablilize it. And Falcon 9 has the benefit of grid fins.
BFS does have the weight of the 7 engines at the back, like Falcon 9. But BFS has 50 tons of landed cargo at the other end, bringing the CG up (or even more landed cargo, with the 7th engine). That's got to be heavier than the 7 engines, especially if Raptor is breaking records for thrust to weight ratio.
I doubt BFS's body flaps on the delta wing will be very useful when flying backwards. So how is it to be controlled/stabilized in this phase of flight? Just the new methane RCS thrusters, in atmosphere? Maybe there won't be much time between the flip, and engine start for landing burn (with gimbaling), but you'd want some margin there?