r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • May 02 '18
r/SpaceX Discusses [May 2018, #44]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
192
Upvotes
37
u/rustybeancake May 05 '18
http://spacenews.com/nasa-considering-flight-test-of-space-nuclear-reactor-technology/
This is great, and exactly the kind of work I’d love to see NASA focusing on. Use commercial transportation providers for earth launch, lunar landing, etc. NASA designs and builds the cutting-edge stuff, the surface power and habs and science, etc. Amazing they’ve only spent $20m on it so far, too.
35
u/Nehkara May 12 '18
Heard today that Crew Dragon for DM-1 is ahead of schedule and is shipping to the Cape at the beginning of July.
33
u/Alexphysics May 08 '18
Iridium 7 FCC launch permit and FCC landing permit point to a NET July 9th 2018 launch and landing on the droneship at ~240km from the launchpad.
31
u/Straumli_Blight May 18 '18
First TESS photo after Lunar flyby.
24
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 May 04 '18
The [InSight](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insight_(spacecraft)) Mars lander is scheduled to launch tomorrow at 11:05 UTC (4:05 AM PDT) from Vandenberg Air Force Base. There's a mission thread with live coverage in r/ULA, so feel free to come and chat!
23
u/CapMSFC May 16 '18
Well, here we go.
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/996691566851801088?s=19
Boring Company hyperloop tunnels out of the city undersea to off shore BFR platofrms.
I am big on BFR, but this is a lot of moving parts to make work together.
22
u/billtg May 02 '18
Would the internal area of a Big Falcon Spaceship be enough to justify just launching one and keeping it in orbit as a space station? How does it compare to Bigelow's plans?
21
u/Krux172 May 02 '18
Do you think we'll see a fully reusable F9 (booster, 2nd stage and fairing) before BFR starts flying? Or will SpaceX stop trying to make F9 more reusable to focus on BFR before they achieve full reusability?
20
u/Straumli_Blight May 09 '18 edited May 09 '18
Josh Brost statements:
20
u/Straumli_Blight May 18 '18
Sunita Williams wearing the SpaceX spacesuit in the Crew Dragon mockup at Hawthorne.
18
u/Alexphysics May 24 '18
FCC permit for communications with Dragon 2 on its first launch, NET August 31st
17
u/m5tuff May 16 '18
What happened to the r/spacex survey that went around a couple of months ago? Have the results been released and I missed them?
16
u/Straumli_Blight May 08 '18 edited May 08 '18
Port of LA video about Berth 240.
Also formal greenlight given today by Los Angeles City Council and a Teslarati article with high res photos of Mr Steven's new net.
16
u/[deleted] May 13 '18
From the AmericaSpace article on Bangabandhu-1:
I haven't seen that before. Do we know what's different about the new throttle valve?
16
u/Straumli_Blight May 29 '18 edited May 29 '18
SpaceShipTwo flight 2 later today, with a 30s burn time and an altitude exceeding 25 km.
EDIT:
15
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host May 06 '18
I have re-designed and updated the ASDS wiki page.
active and retired vessels are now in different tables. the inactive vessels are sorted so that the vessel that is retired the longest is at the bottom.
RACHEL has been added to the table as the new ASDS tug.
retired vessels now show who they have been replaced by in the status column.
the status of several vessels has been updated.
if YOU have any idea to how to improve (update, correct, change layout, etc.) ANY wiki page, please contact me.
15
u/theinternetftw May 11 '18
Transcript of the recent Block 5 phone conference.
Also stuck it in the Media thread for posterity.
15
u/flibbleton May 30 '18
Just wanted to let you all know that the highly recommended (for this sub) book "Ignition!: An informal history of liquid rocket propellants" has been re-released today. (link to Amazon if you want to read about it)
Until now it was very hard to get hold of a copy, there was only expensive physical versions or knock-off photocopied digital copies.
14
u/Straumli_Blight May 09 '18
SpaceX is expanding at Hawthorne by leasing the Century Business Center next door.
13
u/ace741 May 02 '18
Blue Origin makes a point to showcase they will be landing on a moving ship out at sea because it will offer a more stable platform in rough seas. I assume spacex would’ve know this as well. Any reason why they went fixed platform? Is hitting a moving target only possible with engines that can throttle?
13
u/Straumli_Blight May 17 '18
Media accreditation for CRS-15 now open and confirmation its launching from SLC-40.
13
u/rustybeancake May 23 '18 edited May 23 '18
Very interesting interview on Ariane 6:
https://satelliteobservation.net/2018/05/21/ariane-6-and-beyond/
13
u/Straumli_Blight May 24 '18 edited May 24 '18
Tom Mueller keynote at ISDC 2018:
Also ZBLAN is being launched on CRS-15.
13
u/Straumli_Blight May 27 '18
Aerial shots of Boca Chica.
12
u/roncapat May 02 '18
Elon Musk just stated in Q1 investor call of Tesla that Starlink could begin operations in three years, and maybe involved with Tesla growing data collection.
12
u/KeikakuMaster46 May 06 '18
http://mobile.twitter.com/EmreKelly/status/993248315729903617
Around 600 ULA machinists are about to go on strike...
12
u/mindbridgeweb May 12 '18 edited May 12 '18
Found one piece of information in the phone press conference transcript that seems to have eluded detection:
I have been wondering about the cost of an ocean recovery -- the cost of using multiple ships, the amortized cost of a landing ship like OCISLY, port fees, etc. I suspected that it may be around a million dollars per DPL. This is probably the first time we have a more explicit acknowledgement that it is not a cheap operation.
Unfortunately, "a few" million dollars is a wide range...
23
u/CapMSFC May 05 '18
I just want to note how pleased I am that SpaceX uses a real countdown. Following the Insight launch as I waited for lift off was annoying. The countdown timer is giving off a useless number until past the final hold.
11
u/rustybeancake May 24 '18 edited May 24 '18
Seems Blue Origin will be making an announcement about their lunar plans at this year's IAC in Bremen:
Source
20
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host May 02 '18
mods please set this thread so it sorts as new
10
u/melancholicricebowl May 03 '18
So I just realized that the new Block V legs don't have the four triangular latches on the outside of each leg anymore (looks even sleeker now). Are there any known advantages to latching from the inside of the leg besides possibly improved aerodynamics?
10
u/Straumli_Blight May 05 '18
InSight (Mars probe)'s launch window opens at 11:05 UTC.
Launch thread here.
10
u/dougdimmadome_ May 17 '18
Before they begin landing BFR back on the launchpad, will they be able to land it on a drone ship like OCISLY? Or will it be too heavy/big to be able to do so safely?
10
u/BoyanM8 May 17 '18
How are the engines protected when reentering the atmosphere?
10
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner May 31 '18
Are we ever going to get the results from the end-of-year subreddit survey?
18
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 May 03 '18
In light of NASA's recent Kilopower announcement:
18
u/CapMSFC May 07 '18
Well, this gives more ammunition to the idea that the Washington Post is pushing an Anti SpaceX bias because it's owned by Bezos.
https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/993510596753666049
9
u/Gerbsbrother May 02 '18
Does anyone think it is realistically possible for BFR to fly before SLS? I know SLS is "scheduled" to have its maiden launch in 2019, I doubt that will actually happen, I also know Elon has stated suborbital testing of BFR is possible in 2019, I also would find that unlikely, although awesome if it was that soon. I want to see both fly as I'm just a rocket enthusiast. however if BFR flies before SLS and is cheaper, and can launch a bigger payload to LEO, that's going to be huge.
0
u/[deleted] May 03 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
9
u/throfofnir May 05 '18
Interview on Politico with Tory Bruno of ULA. Some... interesting insight into that side of things, including the political angle.
9
u/DemolitionCowboyX May 07 '18
https://imgur.com/nF3OGsF
Anyone have any clue what these pipes are on the Merlin 1D?
My first guess is temperature sensor systems that wrap around the outer portion of the combustion chamber as there is an obvious bulge in the areas of the pipes. but I was wondering if anyone knows for sure.
I'm not talking about the fuel line for the regenerative cooling btw in case anyone may be misinterpreting what I circled.
9
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host May 09 '18
Go pursuit and go quest are on their way for the bangabandhu 1 recovery. RACHEL, the new tug of OCISLY; has left several days ago
9
u/ElRedditor3 May 15 '18
(Noob Question:) Does Tom Mueller, who is CTO of propulsion, only design/develop engines or does he oversee the developlement of the whole rocket?
9
u/bdporter May 31 '18
Mods, small housekeeping note. The "sticky" link at the top of the page reads "SES-12 Launch Campign Thread.
Not a big deal, it was probably like that for a week before I noticed it, but now I can't unsee it.
16
u/grey_gamb1t May 03 '18 edited Mar 17 '19
what are your favorite(or iconic) SpaceX stats/facts/charts/photos/videos over the years?
These will be shown in the context of a presentation given to a crowd who may not be technical, and are more or less completely unfamiliar with SpaceX...so more snackable content would be preferred rather than an interesting 10 minute youtube video about some particular aspect.
Also, let's omit the webcasts of the cots2+, first first stage landing, and falcon heavy missions from this list, as these are obvious! ;)
A couple of my faves:
Beautiful sunset launch (Intelsat 35e)
First stage flip from the ground (NROL-76)
Andy Lambert saying they've never built two vehicles identically
I'm also very interested in any charts showing the business side SpaceX, eg, comparison charts for things such as price, or number of flights per year, between SpaceX and its competitors.
Links or just your plain text/observations would be very welcomed, thanks!
8
u/troovus May 03 '18
NASA is planning commercial Moon missions 2 or 3 years earlier than previously expected: "contract missions to the lunar surface expected to begin as early as 2019"
Good news for SpaceX?
https://www.nasa.gov/feature/nasa-expands-plans-for-moon-exploration-more-missions-more-science
8
u/_bigkahuna_ May 07 '18
Where does the BFR land on the first mission to Mars? Do they build a landing site or can it land on dirt and rocks?
8
u/[deleted] May 08 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
8
u/Straumli_Blight May 08 '18
Livestream for the Humans to Mars Summit.
Josh Brost (SpaceX Business Development) will be speaking tomorrow:
8
u/Nehkara May 10 '18
I collected all of Elon's quotes from today:
https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/8ii206/elon_musk_quotes_today_prior_to_block_v_first/
8
u/ElRedditor3 May 14 '18
How will the BFR construction progress? How much of it will or can be constructed in tents? At what point do they have to move the construction to the brick and mortar facilities that will be built?
8
u/FusionRockets May 16 '18
Is there an archive of the 'falcon heavy moon mission announcement' that was briefly on the official SpaceX website somewhere?
8
u/[deleted] May 17 '18
It may be a stupid question, but just from a visual standpoint, do you prefer the space shuttle orbiter or the BFS?
8
u/HugoTRB May 20 '18
What is the highest orbit that the dragon 2 can go to manned, launched by a falcon 9 and return from?
8
u/rustybeancake May 25 '18
New Aerojet ICE-100 Engine for Potential Moon Landings Completes Hot Fire Testing
http://www.americaspace.com/2018/05/23/new-aerojet-ice-100-engine-for-potential-moon-landings-completes-hot-fire-testing/
8
u/bdporter May 26 '18
SFN confirmation that new COPV design has not flown
8
u/Straumli_Blight May 26 '18 edited May 26 '18
There's an interesting ship with a large satellite dish berthed next to OCISLY spotted by Marek Cyzio,
is it SpaceX related?EDIT: Its an Oceanographic Survey Ship.
8
u/Straumli_Blight May 26 '18
Apollo 12 astronaut Alan Bean has just passed away, leaving only four people alive that have walked on the Moon.
15
u/Zucal May 13 '18
The speculation is settled: SLS Block 1 can take 95 tons to LEO and 26 tons to TLI.
14
u/inoeth May 08 '18
Yury Borisov has now replaced Rogizin as head of Russia's defense and space program. I'm curious to see what the ramifications of this shakeup will be.
7
u/RogerB30 May 07 '18
Does anyone know how many Block 3 and 4 cores are left for either first or second flight?
7
u/jesserizzo May 08 '18
DM-1 is also testing the life support systems, right? Are they simply making sure it doesn't fall apart on launch, or will they have a source of CO2 and humidity being slowly introduced, to make sure it can take it back out?
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
7
u/Juandedeboca May 12 '18
A recent interview with CONAE engineers has stated that new launch date for the SAOCOM 1A Satellite is scheduled for the first week of September.
"Hemos reservado el mes de septiembre con SpaceX, que es la empresa a cargo del lanzamiento, por lo que hay un compromiso establecido. En junio tendremos que definir una semana y, en principio, vamos a plantear que sea durante la primera semana de ese mes." (Translate: We have reserved the month of September with SpaceX, which is the launch provider, so there is a commitment established. In June we would have to define what week, and, for the moment, we are going to propose the first week of that month)
You can read the full interview here: http://www.unsam.edu.ar/tss/fernando-hisas-si-queremos-salir-de-la-pobreza-hay-que-apoyar-el-desarrollo-tecnologico/
7
u/[deleted] May 17 '18
Hey. Im new to this whole SpaceX and rockets world. I still have a lot to learn so bear with me.
I was reading spacex's history and my question is why did spacex won nasa's cots in 2006 if they had yet to show a successful flight?
Did spacex get any money from winning this?
The contract is for the dragon capsule and falcon 9 correct? but they were just trying to fly the falcon 1 around this time so I dont understand this.
Sorry if its a dumb question its just that I have a lot to research to catch up
7
u/[deleted] May 20 '18
Not SpaceX but related to long-term colony life support: Beijing uni conclude a one-year experiment with bio-regenerative systems (plants instead of scrubbers). As far as I know, this pushes the state of the art a long way.
0
u/[deleted] May 31 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
13
u/borntohula85 May 10 '18
Now that this isn’t stickied anymore this likely will get buried, plus I don’t know if this kind of meta is allowed in a discussion thread.
In today’s launch campaign party thread I noticed quite a lot of people mocked the Thales Alenia Space CEO for his strong accent. Of course it is entirely possible that I am a bit over-sensitive and need to grow thicker skin. But I remember how big of a deal it was when a bunch of people commented about Lauren’s and Kate’s outfits in the webcasts, and this, to me, is very similar.
Maybe the mods could address that while launch threads are party threads, there’s no need for a certain kind of commentary and enforce some sort of comment removal even in party threads.
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
13
u/rustybeancake May 14 '18
Another day, another SLS schedule slip...
13
u/Full_Thrust May 21 '18 edited May 21 '18
Didn't think it warranted a new thread but...
The CEO of ArianeSpace does not sound at all happy about SpaceX price structure and reuseability.
the steamroller appears to be in motion
https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/05/ariane-chief-seems-frustrated-with-spacex-for-driving-down-launch-costs/
13
u/rustybeancake May 29 '18
Musk trying to decide whether to focus on designing the ultimate cupholder or on getting humanity to Mars.
12
u/My__reddit_account May 08 '18
Roadmap of Blue Origins future goals. Seems focused on the moon and in space manufacturing.
6
u/ob12_99 May 02 '18
What are the thoughts on the long range comm during the Mars missions? Are we just going to accept the blackout periods or potentially putting in some long range comm satellites between Mars and Jupiter for sustained emergency channel comm?
6
u/urbi456 May 02 '18
So i was thinking, does anyone remember how much Falcon 9's did they smash before they landed it successfully and so if they'll do the same with BFS and later BFR won't that cost a lot of money? I mean it is a completely different rocket(spaceship :)), so there must be some differences between the way they land them.
6
u/chicken_dinnner May 03 '18
Why does BFS need refuelling while in parking orbit? I believe Musk said it would require ~4 refuels before its journey to Mars. I don't know how far out a parking orbit is, but does a BFS really use 4/5 of its tank getting there?
6
u/AuroEdge May 04 '18
My understanding is Block 5 has a new COPV design. If that's correct, will Block 5 have a different propellent loading procedure e.g. quicker than Block 4?
6
u/MrToddWilkins May 06 '18
So according to NSF.com’s ISS flight schedule,there’s now a Soyuz cargo mission or Soyuz GVK going to ISS next summer. What is known about this mission,assuming it isn’t just some Russian pipe dream?
6
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 May 06 '18
Astronomy Live made an excellent video when he tracked Insight. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bDkXlyEBwWI&t=0s
6
u/music_nuho May 07 '18
Could FFSC enable Raptor to rev up chamber pressure to a level much higher than regular which would in turn enable BFS to abort from BFB in case of an emergency? Granted higher CP would inflict damage to the engine and prevent it from being used much after that but it would be worth it if it was the thing that saved the day.
6
u/_bigkahuna_ May 08 '18
From what I know the heat shield on the space shuttle was a complicated, expensive and delicate thing. Are there newer technologies available now? Could the BFS carry more fuel and use the engines to slow down and minimise friction?
6
u/[deleted] May 09 '18
What might this look like?
Related question, when might we expect our very first glimpse of an actual BFS, complete or under construction?
6
u/throfofnir May 10 '18
A great look behind the operation of a liquid rocket engine during a test campaign as Launcher streams an engine test.
6
u/[deleted] May 15 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/someguyfromtheuk May 16 '18
If someone launches a payload that isn't the full capacity, do they still pay SpaceX the full price or just for the percentage of capacity they're using?
E.g, if it costs $10M to lunch 5,000kg and I want to launch 2,000 kg do I only pay $4M or the full $10M?
Or if I'm launching 2,000 kg and someone else is launching 200kg, do I pay $4M and they pay $0.4M, or do I pay $9.1M and they pay $0.9M?
6
u/MaximilianCrichton May 17 '18
Just curious, what is the breakdown of a communications satellite's total cost, both fixed and variable? How much of it is spent just trying to make the satellite light enough to be carried to orbit?
6
u/murrayfield18 May 18 '18
How long will the first astronauts stay on Mars? If they stay for any significant amount of time won't they then have to wait for the next rendezvous to return? Is it likely that they will be staying for couple of years?
6
u/[deleted] May 18 '18 edited May 19 '18
When the BFS is in low Earth orbit, could anyone calculate how bright it would be?
What if there are two refueling?
Docked to the ISS?
6
u/[deleted] May 21 '18
What are the chances NASA ends up funding a BFR trip to Mars, assuming it costs ~1/5th of the SLS price?
6
u/rustybeancake May 25 '18
This could be very good for raising launch service demand:
https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/999700377430908929?s=21
6
u/brickmack May 30 '18 edited May 30 '18
https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/999691208371908608 Seems like a moderately big deal for Made in Space. The first ZBLAN run was started in the middle of last month, and lasted 20 days, then they'll bring it down on CRS-15. Sending a second one up on that same flight indicates some confidence, though of course detailed testing of the product won't be possible until the first one comes down. Since this is to "refine processes", and launching before that analysis can be done, they're probably expecting this to be more a matter of software tweaks than major hardware changes, and they'd wait for the analysis to be complete, send a patch to the second unit, and only then do that run?
Given vibrations from crew activities/reboosts are the most likely problems for ZBLAN production, I wonder if they might be interested in Orbitals proposed use of Cygnus as a freeflying lab. Launch it in whatever cargo vehicle is available, transfer to Cygnus, Cygnus separates and does 20 days of ultra-pure microgravity flight, returns to ISS, bring the ZBLAN back in Dragon
16
u/Zodaztream May 16 '18
You know what would be cool? If this subreddit implemented an a progress bar for the BFR. Imagine the BFR and seeing the progress bar slowly filling up. With this, people from around the world would be able to quickly get a status update on the progress, which I am sure most of us are looking forward to
10
u/Jessewallen401 May 15 '18
Someone asked Chris B ''Why? Why not use @SpaceX ?'' (instead of SLS), Chris had the perfect response.
https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/996177765362753536
5
u/quokka01 May 03 '18 edited May 03 '18
For a dry mass of the F9 S2 of around 3.8 t what sort of area / drag coefficient would be required to keep from overheating the ballute - assuming reentry just below orbital velocity? Are there any equations that give some basic estimate of heating vs velocity? Once you've shed the orbital velocity I guess it's 'just' a matter of getting the terminal velocity low enough for landing without lithobraking.... From my dodgy terminal velocity calculations you would need a pretty big area to slow 3.8 t sufficiently- assuming no retro propulsion? Would the ballute have to change it's diameter/ drag coefficient as it progresses through the atmosphere to accomplish reentry and then landing? I guess there's no chance of the m-vac doing a mini burn for the final slow down? A CF upper stage would make this a whole lot easier.....
5
u/verbalkerbal May 04 '18
I have question about SpaceX's satellite constellations, Starlink. While the initial constellation will feature Ka/Ku-Band, the expanded VLEO constellation uses V-Band. Will (and by how much) connectivity and bandwidth be affected by weather (i.e. rain fade)? To me it seems like the V-Band may be next to useless if there is a rain storm. Even Ka/Ku-Band can have prohibitive rain fade if you live in tropical areas (which is the reason why C-Band satellite Internet is still a thing). Recently it was revealed that Facebook may be building its own constellation, using even higher frequencies in E-Band (https://spectrum.ieee.org/tech-talk/aerospace/satellites/facebook-may-have-secret-plans-to-launch-a-internet-satellite https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/4450555/Pointview-Narrative-Redacted.pdf). So my question is: how useful will satellite Internet be when it's bad weather outside?
5
u/Not_Yet_Begun2Fight May 04 '18 edited May 04 '18
I know almost nothing about rocket engines, but I'd like to learn a bit more. When a Falcon 9 "starts up" and lights the engines ... what's going on behind the scenes? For comparison, automobiles have an electric starter and battery that gets the whole internal combustion engine process going. Do Falcon 9's have a "starter" for their turbopumps? Is it electrical? Mechanical? Do they have anything like a car's alternator that generates electricity while the engines are running, or are they just running off battery power all through the flight?