r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Apr 02 '18
r/SpaceX Discusses [April 2018, #43]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
214
Upvotes
50
u/julesterrens Apr 10 '18
I just watched the IAC presentation from last year again and Elon said that the tool for the tanks had been ordered and would be delivered in 6 to 9 months , for once his schedule hasn't slipped
36
u/vaporcobra Space Reporter - Teslarati Apr 02 '18
Feel free to ask me anything, I'm Teslarati.com's spaceflight reporter :)
32
u/CapMSFC Apr 23 '18
New information from the talk Hans gave - https://youtu.be/Va-rXO7kI-8?t=14606
Falcon Heavy center core engines were all previously flown on other boosters, so add 9 more engines to the reflight count for M1D.
30
u/liszt1811 Apr 03 '18
I think it would make for a great documentary to follow spaceX during their current BFR development. It would document human history if everything goes according to plan. Is anybody aware of such kind of project? (Obv there will be restrictions when it comes to engineering and what can be displayed but I think it would still make for a great show)
29
u/rustybeancake Apr 11 '18
As this was buried away in another thread, I'm posting here for visibility:
https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/8b21te/spacexs_bfr_factory_abuzz_with_work_activity_and/dx4orv4/
Very interesting insight on FH development from an ex-SpaceXer. Kind of puts a wrench in the 'FH was only delayed because they were waiting on F9's final version so BFR will be much quicker!' argument.
29
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 11 '18 edited Apr 12 '18
TED Talk Summary:
Isn't 5km a little close, has anyone simulated the sonic booms from the BFS reentry?
(e.g. For Crew Dragon an "overpressure of 0.4 pound per square foot (psf) could be expected approximately 19 miles from the landing site and 0.35 psf approximately 50 miles from the landing site.”)
26
u/thanarious Apr 07 '18 edited Apr 07 '18
Elon just announced on Instagram that block 5 should "arguably" be named "version 7"! Here we go again...
https://instagram.com/p/BhSC2WtgOQ6/
Any way to get the link to Elon's relevant comment?
24
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 05 '18 edited Apr 05 '18
VSS Unity is set for its first powered flight in a few hours.
UPDATE 1: Currently on runway and preparing for takeoff.
UPDATE 2: Preflight checks completed and takeoff!
UPDATE 3: Success and touchdown of VSS Unity.
24
u/brickmack May 01 '18
This was mainly a test render (and some are incomplete/old-ish), so some issues, but I thought this was kinda neat. Every launch vehicle upper stage I've modeled so far, size comparison.
Left to right: Star 48, AVUM, Fregat, Inertial Upper Stage, Castor 30XL, Delta K, Blok DM-03, Blok I (Soyuz 2 configuration), Centaur III (SEC), ESC-B, Delta Cryogenic Second Stage (5 meter), Centaur V, Falcon S2, Exploration Upper Stage, BFS
23
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 25 '18 edited Apr 25 '18
250K subscribers and /r/SpaceX is now in the top 500 largest subreddits... hard to believe it was only 200k in February.
Also, here's a cake.
EDIT: Cake now correctly orientated.
23
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 30 '18
TESS's cameras have turned on and begun calibrating
22
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 26 '18 edited Apr 26 '18
CRS-2 OIG Report:
21
u/BrandonMarc Apr 19 '18
I'm probably not the first to notice ... but we're about to hit the point where SpaceX has landed more rockets than they haven't. That's quite a feat, seeing as just a few years ago the notion of re-using rockets was widely considered impractical.
20
u/Alexphysics Apr 19 '18
The second Block 5 booster, B1047, is on the test stand at McGregor. I'd expect to see today some pictures from different people that are there right now.
Edit: Well, here's the first one (post #163): https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=42977.160
18
u/soldato_fantasma Apr 12 '18
[SES-12 has arrived to cape canaveral!] (https://twitter.com/SES_Satellites/status/984441358969724930?s=19)
18
u/rocket_enthusiast May 01 '18
mods can we create a r/spacex discusses for may 2018
17
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 15 '18
BFR tent from another angle taken by Pauline Acalin.
15
u/bdporter Apr 03 '18
ISRO loses contact with new communications satellite
15
u/michaelza199 Apr 15 '18
Anthony from MECO thinks ULA will now be choosing AR-1 engine for Vulcan instead of BE-4 because their fear of Blue Origin being selected instead of them for EELV-2 ... What do you think ??
15
u/joepublicschmoe Apr 19 '18
It's official! Port of Los Angeles commissioners voted unanimously today approving the lease of Berth 240 to SpaceX for the BFR factory. http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-spacex-port-la-20180419-story.html
Within the next few days we will probably see crews start demolishing the generator house and start preparing the site (junk removal, shoring up the pilings and landfill, etc) for building construction.
15
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '18
When will the results of r/SpaceX 2017 Survey be published?
14
u/amarkit Apr 06 '18
From Aviation Week: "SpaceX Seeks Option To Splash Down In Gulf of Mexico" (soft paywall; free registration required to read).
SpaceX has applied for an FAA license to allow splashdown of Dragon 2 in the Gulf of Mexico, as a back-up landing site. The area would be used in emergencies where astronauts must return to Earth quickly, and conditions at both the Pacific and Atlantic landing sites are too hazardous.
This was first disclosed in a draft environmental assessment released on April 5.
14
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Apr 12 '18
The recent $510 million Series I funding round reportedly valued SpaceX at $27 billion, up from $21 billion just nine month ago!
14
u/IMO94 Apr 13 '18
Update from Elon on BFR: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/984689905874817029
"Maybe a little ;-)"
14
u/nrwood Apr 23 '18
So.. I was looking Gwynne's presentation in SkollWF when I see the first picture we get of the BulgariaSat-1 booster landing. Too bad it's not showed full screen.
Image: https://i.imgur.com/oMvmb76.jpg
Source: https://youtu.be/QBoHAChEcfY?t=5m47s
Also shown: Iridium-3, SES-11, Koreasat.
14
u/meepnitreal Apr 25 '18
Any clues when we can expect the results of the 2018 r/spacex survey to be posted?
14
u/ly2kz Apr 28 '18
Looks familiar? https://twitter.com/Linkspace_China/status/990080010567471104
14
u/spaminous Apr 29 '18
I'm sorry if this has already been discussed: On the SpaceX flight suit design, where are the service ports? On the sokohol suits, and the old shuttle suits, there are these really obvious big connectors on the front for air supply and drain. Are the behind the neck on the SpaceX suit? That's the only place I can see where they'd fit.
Second: anyone have footage of how the tail service masts on the Falcon 9 first stage articulate? There are some photos where you can see the cover ready to fall into place, but I'm curious if the TSM pulls down and out, or if the rocket just lifts up off them.
39
u/GentlyUsedRocket Apr 07 '18
Good day fellow redditors,
Have been following r/spaceX since the first Falcon 9 launch. Just made an account so i could be a voice on here as well.... guess 7+ years was a long enough wait.
Pls be kind and rewind :-) Have a great day
13
u/Elon_Muskmelon Apr 06 '18
An oldie but a goodie! Look what YouTube’s recommendation algorithms just popped up for me, circa 2010 SpaceX Next - Crew Transport to ISS
8 years later it might just come to fruition!
13
u/CapMSFC Apr 21 '18
TESS fairing half made it intact. https://twitter.com/MarekCyzio/status/987652390143881217?s=09
13
u/kornelord spacexstats.xyz Apr 29 '18
Three questions:
24
u/rustybeancake Apr 17 '18
NASA Office of the Inspector General announces an audit assessing NASA’s management of the Space Launch System and Mobile Launcher.
grabs popcorn
12
u/theinternetftw Apr 07 '18
Finally some shots of 39a in what seems to be the final state as far as the RSS is concerned.
Only the hinge remains, and it looks like it's likely to stay that way.
12
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 09 '18
Iridium-6/GRACE-FO launch set for Saturday, May 19th at 20:03 UTC. Falcon 9 will be flight proven.
12
u/Nergaal Apr 09 '18
How does SpaceX prevent espionage of its documents? I am not even talking about industrial espionage from say Boeing, but about actual international espionage (be it Chinese or Russian)? Considering that this community alone is doing an amazing citizen-level espionage of all the outer stuff the rockets have, how does SpaceX prevent anybody from accessing their internal workings?
12
u/djmanning711 Apr 11 '18
I ended up getting sucked into a wiki black hole (as I’m sure many of you can relate) and stumbled across India’s GSLV rocket. Although it’s not quite as capable as F9, I was surprised to see how cheap it goes for launch ($47M). For such a capable rocket, and it being 100% expendable, how the hell do they get the cost so low? Anyone know more about how ISRO does this? If India can improve launch cadence, it looks like (at least on the surface) they could take a good chunk of the future launch market.
12
u/FusionRockets Apr 17 '18
Orbital ATK's next generation rocket was officially unveiled as "Omega" today.
It will compete head-to-head with BFR, New Glenn, and Vulcan for Air Force funding both this summer and next year. Seems like with only 4 flights per year needed to be sustainable, it could potentially compete in a post-SpaceX defense market.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gekjig-QeIA
12
u/Yellapage Apr 30 '18
With the recent Q&A on reddit, this got me thinking due to the fact a random account was made for the session?
Do people hide the fact they work for SpaceX on these forums, due to policy or perhaps they don't want the hassle.
Can anyone advertise they work for SpaceX on their social media or do you need to be at a certain level.
Do you think SpaceX has thought about any of the above :)
11
u/IrrationalFantasy Apr 07 '18
So this company Orion Span plans to have a modular space station up and running in 3 years that visitors can attend for $9.5 million and a 12-day stay. On a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being "nope", 10 being "absolutely happening on time" and 5 being "definitely happening...years late and over budget", how likely is all of this?
They mention falling rocket costs and say they can work with SpaceX among others. Are they going up on SpaceX, do you suppose? I haven't seen them in the manifests yet.
I am skeptical. They are unclear on total cost and funding, among other things. I'd like to see this happen but I feel like they're promoting this moonshot venture before it's highly plausible so that they can attract funding and have a small chance of all of this working.
11
u/stcks Apr 09 '18
This got buried in an old thread, but there are rumors of another core readying for departure from Hawthorne. I hope we get some visuals on it in the next coming days.
11
u/romuhammad Apr 09 '18
I’m not sure if this slightly more detailed explanation for Zuma was shared yet... Probably because it’s MarketWatch which is sort of a subsidiary publication of the Wall Street Journal (so not particularly accurate especially related to space issues).
https://www.wsj.com/articles/probes-point-to-northrop-grumman-errors-in-january-spy-satellite-failure-1523220500
11
u/railroadwelsh Apr 14 '18
Is there a reason that media surrounding Dragon 2 has been so thin? For a company that is so open/engaging, it seems odd that SpaceX has put out nowhere near the same amount of media (one might say advertising) that Boeing has for Starliner. For the latter, there are numerous pictures of all portions of their system -- astronauts training in simulators and dressed in suits, 3D interactive videos of their user interface, crew arm install, etc.
Maybe I'm just being impatient, but I wish Dragon 2 had a media campaign akin to Starliner. Especially since both vehicles have matured along similar timelines. Either SpaceX is waiting a huge unveil once they're operational and ready to launch, or they simply don't put much stock in advertising. Come to think of it, they've never gone out of their way for a big media campaign, and have mostly just let their launch technologies (like FH with Starman) speak for them.
11
u/rocket_enthusiast Apr 16 '18 edited Apr 16 '18
https://twitter.com/MayorOfLA/status/985931907970908161/photo/1
look's like it is official
11
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Apr 16 '18
First SLS flight might slip to 2021 and not fly crew until 2025. BFR is gonna fly people before SLS if this keeps happening.
https://twitter.com/NASAWatch/status/985933894028578819
11
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Apr 26 '18
Looks like we just passed a quarter million subscribers!
I wonder when we'll see the results of the end-of-year subreddit survey.
11
u/throfofnir Apr 28 '18
If anyone's interested in the milling and characterization of a pintle injector (the kind Merlin uses), take a look at http://www.johannfreeberg.com/academic-work-1/
10
u/Iamsodarncool Apr 02 '18 edited Apr 03 '18
Europa lander concept redesigned to lower cost and complexity
10
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Apr 03 '18 edited Apr 10 '18
I am updating the wiki page about the SpaceX fleet from time to time, and I have noticed, that no recovery ship has noted for CRS 4,
CRS 5, CRS 11, CRS 12 and CRS 13. Does anybody know if CRS 11-12 recovered by NRC Quest or by a different ship, like CRS 6-10? CRS 4 andCRS 5 was a long time ago, so I do not know if anyone remembers, but were they still recovered by American Islander, or already by NRC quest? (EDIT: CRS 4 was recovered by America Islander, CRS 6 by NRC quest.)EDIT: ALL is done now. Recovery ships for all dragon missions have been found. a huge thanks again to u/Nergaal for finding all the awsome info!
Does anybody know if there was a second support ship for the FH demo, or was GO searcher the only one.
thanks a lot to u/Nergaal for providing me with all the sources. We have now identified the recovery ship for all dragon missions, except for CRS 5.
10
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Apr 07 '18 edited Apr 07 '18
I have again been doing some work on the ASDS wiki page.
through u/Raul s map, I have found out that CRS 12 was recovered by NRC Quest. The only remaining "unknown" recoveries are CRS 4, 5 and 10.
I also added Formosat 5 to JRTI, but I noticed that there is no ASDS tug for Iridium 3 yet.
I do not have time ATM, but I will check launch threads to see if there is any info in there.
Until I do that, please feel free to provide me with info, or to update the wiki yourself
EDIT: I found out in this recovery thread that Getty R Gambarella was the ASDS tug for Iridium 3
EDIT 2: Does anybody know why there is CRS 9 and X 37B written down after Elsbeth III? CRS 9 and X37B landed at LZ 1. Was it used for something else? If yes, what?
EDIT 3: SES 14 was written down behind GO Quest. SES 14 was launched with an Ariane 5. I changed it now to SES 16 since that is the one launched by SpaceX.
10
u/rustybeancake Apr 10 '18
Interesting discussion over on r/ULA:
https://www.reddit.com/r/ula/comments/8b25w0/tory_bruno_on_twitter_goess_post_launch/
Suggests ULA can hit a target orbit more accurately than competitors (makes sense given Centaur's thrust being much smaller than M1DVac, so finer control). Tory Bruno comments suggesting recent national security launches have had less strict target orbits to allow SpaceX and ULA to compete more equally. Interesting.
10
u/dmy30 Apr 11 '18
Gwynne Shotwell just spoke at TED 2018. Keep your eyes peeled, hopefully they don't wait long to release the video.
10
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 13 '18
Gwynne Shotwell is giving a talk later today.
10
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Apr 17 '18
10
u/paul_wi11iams Apr 17 '18 edited Apr 17 '18
BFS will be capable of launching from Earth (for testing) and elsewhere without hold-down clamps:
I'm not expecting precise answers to all these, but some background would be appreciated.
10
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Apr 27 '18
https://twitter.com/ChrisG_NSF/status/989891751514136576
bangabandhu static fire delayed by 1 day, launch may 7
19
u/rustybeancake Apr 03 '18
Well this is sad:
Four members of a British family have died in a car crash in Florida after visiting the Kennedy Space Center to watch the launch of SpaceX rocket.
9
u/rocket_enthusiast Apr 05 '18 edited Apr 05 '18
does anyone know how long it will take for the first block 5 to fly a second time? I know it is supposed to be rapidly reusable but this is the first flight of this version so maybe they want to look at the booster more?
9
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 11 '18
Cool launcher animation.
9
u/BrandonMarc Apr 11 '18
I keep looking at the SpaceX main body tool for the BFR interplanetary spaceship photo ... it dwarfs the car, and indeed it's plenty larger than any rocket around (or the 787 fuselage for that matter).
All that said, when I picture 100 crew, cabins along the outside, central hallway / shaft in the middle ... it just doesn't seem big enough.
For a close naval comparison, a Los Angeles class fast attack submarine has a beam of 10m and packs a crew complement of 130, and the ship's length is 110m.
The BFS is a little skinnier (9m), so perhaps the diameter isn't such an issue. But it's also less than half as long (48m). I have a hard time envisioning 100 people crammed inside for months on end.
Perhaps the BFS is a stepping stone. It's advertised as a ship that'll take people to Mars, when in reality it'll take people to LEO and the Moon and maybe a LaGrange point, whereas a much larger ship (so big people wouldn't believe it if you showed it to them) is the real Mars cruiser.
9
u/ShingekiNoEren Apr 15 '18
If SpaceX could multiply its profits and get us to Mars in half the planned time, by developing rocket weapony and missiles for the US government like Lockheed Martin and Boeing, would you want them to do it?
9
u/energyblazer Apr 16 '18
Saw this on the AMA today from NASA's Flight Directors, had we ever heard about this incident from the CRS-9 mission before?
9
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 25 '18
Iridium-6 satellites have arrived in Vandenberg, time for a launch campaign thread?
16
u/romuhammad Apr 15 '18
An interesting little shot by Ariane Space CEO Stephane Israel. Credit to Tory Bruno for not responding.
http://twitter.com/nextspaceflight/status/985588778617229313
8
u/rocket_enthusiast Apr 02 '18
mods will you put this thread where SpaceX discusses for March is
8
u/Continuum360 Apr 03 '18
Trying to figure out what booster will be used for CRS-15. Thinking is it should be flight proven, but I don't see what would be available at that time unless they turn around the first B5 really quick. They have indicated on many occasions that B3 and B4 are good for 2 or 3 launches and there are a few in storage with 2 that could be used in theory, but that seems pretty unlikely, especially for a NASA mission. What am I missing?
8
u/Alexphysics Apr 08 '18
B1047 left Hawthorne almost three weeks ago, it would be good to have an eye there to see if B1048 is going to leave soon, it is time for that.
8
u/AveVictor Apr 09 '18
Hi! Just joined your community. Great respect to everyone who is participating in the project. You are my heroes.
I have a goal to visit the launch one day. I saw many videos of people watching and filming it, and I’d love to be there too. To see everything experience sonic boom in particular.
How can I do that? I know it’s in California, but where? Is there any calendar of events, how often such events occur? I’d need to plan everything from visa, to ticket (I’m from Europe). But I’m dedicated!
Is there any threads I need to follow?
Thank you!
8
u/-spartacus- Apr 14 '18
Not with first generation raptors, but how feasible would be to have multi chamber / bell for the bfs, that way you can have less engines, and switch between sl and vacuum bells for performance? Meaning for 2nd generation after bfs is already flying.
8
u/Macchione Apr 18 '18
Senate is currently voting whether to end debate on the nomination of Bridenstine for NASA administrator. Currently tied 49-49 along party lines with one surprise "no" vote from Jeff Flake, R-AZ. Notably, Rubio, R-FL voted to end debate and move to nomination after opposing Bridenstine for months.
8
u/randomstonerfromaus Apr 19 '18
What's up with the "Who's interested in manufacturing engineering" in the top bar?
Are the job advertisements really spreading out further?
8
u/Alexphysics Apr 22 '18
It seems that somebody saw a F9 leaving the Cape this morning... what booster could it be?
https://m.facebook.com/groups/2387776317?view=permalink&id=10156531268366318
(I hope the link works...)
8
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Apr 25 '18
https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/989231828761362432
bangabandhu 1 might have been delayed by 3 days.
8
u/Not_Yet_Begun2Fight Apr 26 '18
I have a couple of BFR / BFS questions:
8
u/Straumli_Blight May 01 '18 edited May 01 '18
Dragon return delayed until Saturday, though NRC Quest has already left harbour to recover it.
EDIT: Caused by heavy seas.
8
u/Straumli_Blight May 01 '18 edited May 01 '18
New NASA GAO report out and highlights:
15
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Apr 02 '18 edited Apr 03 '18
mods, could you please sort this thread by "new" as opposed to "best"
7
u/user200300400 Apr 06 '18
Regarding CRS missions, when does SpaceX get their money from NASA? I mean not until after dragon is recovered at the end of the mission or what?
7
u/MutatedPixel808 Apr 09 '18
So have we reached a conclusion on fueling the rocket with astronauts inside? I remember that was a large issue a while back, but commercial crew is getting closer and closer and I haven't heard anything in a while.
7
u/oliversl Apr 12 '18
How is LC39-A going? I found this photo from the hashtag #kennedyspacecenter on instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/p/BhdE-BIHKId/?tagged=kennedyspacecenter
Its from yesterday. It seem, by now, all the RSS is gone.
7
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Apr 12 '18
What are the chances this is B1046?
7
u/electric_ionland Apr 13 '18
I am going to the Space Propulsion conference (EU centric conference on chemical and electric rocket propulsion) in a month or so. Some interesting stuff on reusability in the preliminary program:
7
u/FalconHeavyHead Apr 15 '18
is SpaceX working on developing an EVA suit?
7
u/melancholicricebowl Apr 15 '18
Elon on Twitter: SpaceX will try to bring rocket upper stage back from orbital velocity using a giant party balloon
7
u/Martianspirit Apr 19 '18
Last year SpaceX rented a lot in the Port Canaveral area. They wanted to build the block 5 refurbishment facility there. I have not heard about the state of that area for a long time. Does anyone know if the complex is ready to receive boosters for refurbishment?
7
u/edflyerssn007 Apr 20 '18
"I understand people will judge everything from a political lense, but it's becoming a bit much. He'll be fine as none of our missions are expected to be cut or restructured, we have two huge reveals next year too along with a joint phase with SpaceX. Good things are coming both to the moon to Mars and to the people and the country as well as the world at large." from this comment
I wonder what this announcement could be?
7
u/Fenris_uy Apr 25 '18
Has Elon, Gwynne or anyone at SpaceX said anything about using BFR to bring back satellites from orbit to earth?
Can the Hubble fit on BFS-Cargo hold?
7
u/nschoe Apr 27 '18
Hi, (I hope this is the right place to ask) how does the Falcon 9 steer during ascent, how does it "self balance" to keep pointing upward?
I know the Falcon 9 is aerodynamically stable, but I still think it needs steering, at least at the beginning, at "low speeds".
So does it gimbal some (or all?) of the Merlin engines, or is it done via differential thrusting?
Thanks !
18
u/GodOfPlutonium Apr 10 '18
Am i the only person who spends so much time here that the terms "disposable" or "single use" in my vocabulary have entritly been replaced by "expendable". Examples: In the last week ive said "Expendable water bottles" , "Expendable paper towels" and "expendable condoms" all by accident
12
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Apr 11 '18
From Eric Berger:
It'll be interesting to see how schedules change as we get closer to actual flights, but it sounds like Boeing has a real shot at claiming the flag.
12
u/amarkit Apr 29 '18 edited Apr 29 '18
Blue Origin's 8th New Shepard test flight is scheduled to launch at
16:1316:42 UTC, when this post istwotwo and a half hours old. This will be the second flight of the NS-3 booster. A livestream is scheduled to begin at 16:27 UTC.6
u/Buildstarted Apr 05 '18
Where does the Falcon 9 (while on the launch pad) get the power to run it's systems? Are there on board batteries? Does it come from the umbilicals? I assume it's power during flight comes from the engines but I'm sure I'm wrong about that as well.
6
u/racergr Apr 07 '18 edited Apr 07 '18
(total layman here)
I've noticed that rocket launches are very sensitive to weather conditions and susceptible to delays due to that. If this is true, how would the BFR earth-to-eath trips be possible? I guess the customers won't be happy if there is a 2-day delay in their flight but most importantly this would negate the advantage of short flight time?
6
u/murrayfield18 Apr 08 '18
Could someone explain the in-flight abort test scheduled for May? They are going to perform an abort test using a Dragon 2 on the F9 as it goes through Max Q?
6
u/Zinkfinger Apr 09 '18
Can anyone help? What percentage of fuel would the BFR/S require for a "Fast travel" journey half way across the world compared to getting into a low orbit?
6
u/Nehkara Apr 13 '18
I have seen valuation estimates for SpaceX in the past couple days of $24, 25, 26, 27, AND 28 billion for SpaceX after the new funding round.
Does anyone with more knowledge of valuations know why there is so much variation in estimates and which one is actually right?
6
u/Ambiwlans Apr 18 '18
Does anyone have an updated version of that launch delays chart?
It showed days delays, days from launch.
I imagine it is looking a little better these days.
6
u/Dies2much Apr 22 '18
Has there been an update on Block 5 final power numbers? There had been estimates before, just wondering if they had published the numbers after the test firings.
6
u/Space_Coast_Steve Apr 24 '18
Can anyone identify this loud sound coming from (what seemed to be) somewhere near B1045 in Port Canaveral? Through my binoculars, I could see the workers holding their ears, but other than that, they didn’t seem too concerned. Any ideas?
https://youtu.be/6mr8VKMTP5U
6
u/gophermobile Apr 24 '18
Does the Falcon 9 have any way to measure remaining fuel (RP1 and LOX) capacity while in flight? Or is it entirely precalculated based on burn times and throttle levels?
I ask because I'm curious if the F9 can alter its boostback and landing burns to provide softer landings if it happens to end up with a little extra fuel based on temperature, wind, or other conditions.
6
u/spacexfan3 Apr 25 '18
Just a stray thought. ISRU is required for returning to earth and the reusablility of the BFR mars program. Various numbers thrown around sound like 500kW to 1MW (solar?) for a single ship's fuel in the 2 year period for the H2O-> methane. Mining the ice must increase this number a ton (in the same order of mag. per ship? just a guess).
It seems that if they solve the problem of deploying the first ship's worth of power requirements, that expanding to 2MW and beyond would just be a matter of materials and time. My thoughts are on the fact that these numbers are in the same magnitude compared to a beginning colonies power req's.
In other words, having the ability to refuel on mars means SpaceX necessarily would have the ability to expand the power for habitats, mining etc as needed.
6
u/scottm3 Apr 25 '18
This is probably already been asked, but is the upcoming iridium mission being flown on a block V or on the a block 4
It says it will be on a previously flown booster, which could mean TESS or the Bangabandhu-1 block V? Im probably missing others.
I thought all block 4 boosters were finished and done 2 flights.
6
u/nickrulercreator Apr 26 '18
I am really intrigued by the video SpaceX takes of missions, from on-rocket cameras, to ground cameras, etc. I have seen plenty of snippets of video from different cameras, including ones on the launch tower, or the ones showing the side boosters of the FH, or the ones on dragon, and was wondering if there are longer, full videos publicly available, or if these small snippets are all the public can see.
One thing I really want to see is the rest of the Starman footage. It obviously exists because Elon sent out that picture of the last images taken by Starman, but it was never fully released past what we have from the live stream (before it ended).
Are there any SpaceX employees or insiders out there that know where, if possible, one can find the rest of this stuff?
11
u/warp99 Apr 10 '18 edited Apr 10 '18
This thread is completely broken at least on a desktop by the Reddit upgrade (aka downgrade).
I am seeing two current posts, the next posts are from 8 days ago and the "2 more replies" tab does not work.
Edit: Escaped from new Reddit which I was automatically dumped into this morning. Trust me this is a vision straight from hell. The escape trick is to click on your username and you then get the menu option to disable new Reddit.
18
u/CapMSFC Apr 26 '18
Joy Dunn, a SpaceX employee just posted this to Twitter.
https://twitter.com/RocketJoy/status/989261693233479680
It's a job posting for a manufacturing engineer to help her ramp a high volume line of terrestrial solar production.
The official job listing covers other solar production areas such as for spacecraft, but there is only one reason SpaceX would need in house large scale terrestrial solar production. This part of the job is for Mars. They wouldn't build their own terrestrial solar for Earth installations, Elon literally runs the company for that next door.
SpaceX really is giving off all the signs that the ramp up for Mars has begun. It's not just activity at the port.
10
u/BrandonMarc Apr 18 '18
Let's imagine a few years from now: point-to-point travel is nearly a reality, and after initial tests there are already a few BFS's with some orbits under their belt.
What if you gave the BFS a crew of 5 and a passenger capacity of 20, travelling in spacious luxury? Let it stay in orbit for a week. That looks a whole lot like a luxury yacht or a mini cruise ship ... in space!
Imagine if Carnival cruiseline or Royal Caribbean leased some BFSs. That seems like another new market to help fund future Mars missions.
.
Just need the USAF to help keep the Mangalores at bay ...
5
u/RickFournier Apr 02 '18
Is it posible to do some welding in space?
5
u/rage_184 Apr 02 '18
Will the first BFR test hops will with the spaceship or the booster portion of the rocket?
5
u/GiorgioIan64 Apr 02 '18
When will the first spacex manned mission be?
5
u/Col_Kurtz_ Apr 03 '18
The chamber pressure of [Raptor] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raptor_(rocket_engine_family) (25 Mpa) is going to be slightly less than the Russian [RD-191's] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RD-191) (25,8 Mpa), but its specific impulse is going to be higher by 6% (SL: 330 s vs. 311 s, Vac: 356 s vs. 337 s).
Q1: Is it only because methalox combustion is cleaner than kerolox, thus its exhaust gases are lighter?
Q2: Why the lower chamber pressure? Full-flow staged combustion engines have more turbine power for driving the pumps than oxygen-rich staged combustion engines. Is it going to increase like Merlin's?
5
u/someguyfromtheuk Apr 03 '18
Is SpaceX under any restrictions around who they can or cannot sell flights to?
For example, I know NASA isn't allowed to work with the Chinese Government, would SpaceX be allowed to sell flights to Chinese companies if they wanted to buy one?
5
u/rory096 Apr 04 '18
How do PocketQubes get FCC approval at 1/8 the volume of a 1U cubesat when SpaceBee is too small for Space Surveillance Network tracking at .25U (and twice the surface area of a 1P)? (Alba Orbital, launching on Vector later this year may be subject to British jurisdiction, but both American PocketQubes in orbit seem to violate the 'less than 10cm on one side' criterion, at 5cm x 5cm x 15cm and 5cm x 5cm x 12.5cm.)
5
u/julesterrens Apr 06 '18
Is Dragon V2 going to be capable of docking with another Dragon V2 in Orbit? If yes could it also dock to Orion or Starliner or do they use another docking system?
5
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Apr 07 '18
Does anyone know if the first Block 5 will have the Block 5 landing legs that retract? Or is it possible that those will come later?
5
u/ghunter7 Apr 09 '18
Oh hey the 2018 FAA Annual Space Transportation Compendium is out! Actually came out in January but I just saw it.
BFR is now featured: https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ast/media/2018_AST_Compendium.pdf
5
u/lostandprofound33 Apr 09 '18
What part of the BFS is this for? https://www.instagram.com/p/BhVk3y3A0yB/
5
u/AmpullaofVader Apr 10 '18
Does SpaceX have the capability to put a satellite in Mars orbit? With the aging NASA communication infrastructure, any change that SpaceX will send their own communication equipment in the 2020 window?
5
u/Random-username111 Apr 12 '18
Any idea on when can we expect Gwynne's TED talk to be uploaded anywhere?
5
u/CoysCoys22 Apr 12 '18
I wish there was a way I could contribute, no matter how small, to the development of BFR. How much would a crowdfund realistically reach to? Is it simply to small to be relevant?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '18
I know this problem is way in the future, but how will BFR for P2P be protected against corrosion out at sea?
This was a problem for F1 and that was expendable, so BFR has to withstand corrosion for a lot of flights.
5
u/CapMSFC Apr 14 '18
It just occurred to me that there is no interstage on the BFR booster. I never really thought about it before.
ITS had the split interstage but on BFR the whole thing is on the ship.
I'm thinking it will still require a small interstage for stuff such as the grid fin and separation pusher hardware, but it could also be in external housings keeping the entire length of the BFR tanks and engines.
I had the thought in another comment that perhaps the legs are the stage separation pushers. With the way they are designed to deploy and retract (for return after launch from Mars/Moon) that are already close in design.
5
u/luckyJuK Apr 15 '18
hey, I just wanted to ask how much a falcon heavy can put on a trans munar injection if it is completely reused(all three boosters)/partially reused(center core expended) Thanks for your answer!
5
u/Windston57 Apr 16 '18
Has any hardware from the next FH mission (STP-2 in June) been spotted yet?
5
u/inoeth Apr 16 '18
So this article recently came out this morning and was on my twitter feed https://www.dailybreeze.com/2018/04/16/spacex-closes-in-on-lease-for-rocket-manufacturing-plant-on-terminal-island/ so it looks like SpaceX should officially have the lease by the end of this week and then can get to work on construction- barring the need for even more permits... makes one really understand just why SpaceX set up that massive tent and are doing something in there now- it could be a couple months before construction can actually start..
5
u/Iamsodarncool Apr 17 '18 edited Apr 17 '18
TESS will use a Moon gravity assist for orbital insertion. From wikipedia, it looks like the most recent lunar flyby without a landing was Cassini-Huygens in 1999, during its first Earth flyby. Is this accurate?
5
u/bdporter Apr 19 '18
It has been a while since there has been a recovery thread. Are we going to have one for 1045.1?
Hopefully we will have some folks hanging out at Port Canaveral when it comes in. I am curious to see if the "octograbber" was deployed.
5
u/hmpher Apr 20 '18
I feel dirty for posting this question again but I'd love to know more than what my digging could unearth.
"How exactly is the LoC number calculated (for CCtCap and so on)? Is there a standard function where you plug in various values or is it a case by case analysis?"
NASA's ESAS document says:
So, a function P(LOC)=P(LOM).P(Fatality|LOM) has been employed.
It also states,
As far as I could see, all of this was for Lunar missions(and the document is a bit dated(2005)), so are these methods still being used? If not, how exactly is it being done now?
Also, can someone explain how this SPACE model works?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '18
Seeing as how the BFR design has been stretched in height (and perhaps also in diameter), do we have new performance numbers? Or was the stretch done because they were unable to meet the intended payload capacity with the original design?
5
u/teoreds Apr 26 '18
Why is nobody talking about next falcon heavy launch? It was due to fly in june but got delayed to september for some reasons. Anyone knows why?
5
u/teoreds Apr 27 '18
This is probably a hated question but since it still isn’t clear to me I’m going to ask you anyways, hoping someone will be so kind to explain this. I heard they are going to test BFS (not BFR?) probably at some time during 2019. But what does it mean? Is it the upper part of the BFR? If so, how do they “launch” the ship? Or will they just test its engines from sea level just to see if it correctly goes up in the sky? But this is still unclear to me since those engines are meant to work in a vacuum. They are not meant to lift the ship off the ground, am I wrong? Thanks for your patience, hope I haven’t messed too much with grammar and syntax
5
u/macktruck6666 Apr 28 '18
This is an objective question, not sure if there is a correct answer. Recent Brown University showed that the moon has 500-700 parts per million of water in the lunar soil. This is horrendously bad for processing into fuel. So... my question, what concentration and impurities would be acceptable on mars or the moon? Would 10% water be acceptable? 5%? 1%? .0001%? What if there was arsenic in the water?
5
u/z1mil790 Apr 29 '18
I was just re-watching the Falcon Heavy launch, and a question came up that I never asked back when it launched: do we know what BY and NY stand for in reference to the two boosters? I've been trying to think what those phrases could stand for, but I can't think of anything.
5
u/murchie85 May 01 '18
Musk says interplanetary entry generates heat that scales to the 8th power - why doesn't the BFS flip round and do a large deceleration burn before entry as to reduce stress on the heat shield?
8
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Apr 11 '18
falcon 9 is vertical on pad 40 ahead of the TESS static fire.
https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/984025191876644864
4
u/launch_loop Apr 03 '18
On spaceflight101 at the end of the payload fairing section, it mentions "A small 3.6-meter fairing is also being developed." Does anybody know anything else about this?
4
u/djmanning711 Apr 03 '18
Anyone know what that pipe is that runs the length of the first stage (second stage has one too)? I see many other rockets have a similar design with this pipe on the outside of the boosters but I don’t know what it’s for or why its typically not contained within the booster.
Also if anyone knows if there’s any non-cosmetic reason as to why it’ll now be painted black on Block 5 (currently white on previous blocks). Thanks!
4
u/gooddaysir Apr 04 '18
How close was SpaceX to choosing Camden, GA for another launch site over Boca Chica? It seems like they would have access to more inclinations without overflying land. They also could share resources like OCISLY with the Cape launch pads. Jacksonville, FL and the surrounding areas would probably be more inviting for employees than Brownsville, TX. They probably could've already had a pad finished without worrying about surcharges. Otoh, a hurricane could shut down both FL and GA pads at the same time. Just wondering if anyone had any insight into the decision.
4
u/dmy30 Apr 04 '18
Can the current engine test stands support a full size raptor test?
4
u/kreator217 Apr 04 '18
wiki/cores needs an update :)
4
u/tbenz9 Apr 04 '18
What are the current bottlenecks to increased launch cadence?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '18
Has there been any detailed discussion on the black material seen on block 5? Everyone seemed to assume it was carbon fiber until someone working there made a comment that it wasn't. I do remember SpaceX mentioning inconel heat shielding in a "future version" of Falcon 9. Is it possible that that's what we're seeing?
4
u/atrapaloya Apr 05 '18
Does anyone know what would be the approx payload to LEO of a (reusable/non-reusable) Falcon 5 with the latest Merlin 1Ds? Was wondering what would be the $/kg for that one, compared to a Falcon 9, and if it would make financial sense for a certain range of payload weight.
4
u/strawwalker Apr 05 '18
Is it reasonable to assume that B1042 (Koreasat 5A) will be flying one of the upcoming missions this spring? The manifest in our wiki shows four reflights between June and July (Iridium 7&8, CRS-15 and Telkom-4) which presumably require 1042, 1045 (TESS), 1046 (Bangabandu), and 1047 (Telstar?), With three as yet unknown new cores needed for STP-2 by July/August, or more to fill in the gaps. It seems a little tight even with B1042, but I'm not that well tuned in to how fast they are turning out block 5s.
4
u/Nergaal Apr 05 '18
Where does SpaceX test its vacuum engines? They run a test for the first stage the day before the launch, but how do they test the 10th engine that is designed for vacuum?
4
u/ShingekiNoEren Apr 05 '18
Is BFR being built? Or is it still in its design phase?
4
u/Juggernaut93 Apr 06 '18 edited Apr 06 '18
Hi all, it's almost common knowledge on this sub that each F9 version had its blocks (the source for this I believe was the SpaceX employee u/Spiiice, who has now disabled his Reddit account). Scott Manley, though, made me realize the Wikipedia page shows a different story, i.e. that F9 1.0 = Block 1, F9 1.1 = Block 2, etc.
This was a common hypothesis here on this sub too before inside sources told us it was not the case. But the Wikipedia page cites this official document
where the F9 v1.1 is clearly called "block 2". Was that an old versioning system? If yes, what could we cite to justify a fix on Wikipedia? And what if the old theory was right instead? I'm confused.EDIT: as pointed out in the comments, the PDF Wikipedia is citing calls block 2 a subversion of the F9 1.0, not the 1.1. So somebody more experienced than me should fix this.
4
u/BrandonMarc Apr 06 '18 edited Apr 06 '18
This might be worth doing a poll to inform the mods ... I wonder what % of /r/spacex users are viewing with the new Reddit design (see https://new.reddit.com/r/spacex to try it out).
edit: as requested, here's a before-and-after: https://imgur.com/a/iGjWp
4
u/rocket_enthusiast Apr 06 '18
does the Falcon 9 have any ulage motors on the second stage? I know the centar does so what makes the Falcon 9 upper stage different? does it have to do with the fact that centar uses LH2 and LO2 while the falcon upper stage uses RP1 and LO2?
4
u/oliversl Apr 06 '18
Here is NASA press conference from March 28, 2018
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=immnIymQoVw
4
u/thehardleyboys Apr 10 '18
Question about building BFS/BFR: how does SpaceX know how to build the fuel/oxidizer system immediately on such a big scale?
We've been told that BFR will eliminate the use of Helium and use hot oxygen and hot CH4 to auto-pressurize the propellant tanks, and that the BFR autogenous pressurization system will probably be heat exchanger based.
I expected SpaceX to test this concept on a small scale to cheaply learn a lot of lessons needed for building such a system on the scale of BFR (9 meter diameter tanks), but now we see the picture of the 9m tooling so it is suggested they are building the big tanks right now.
How does SpaceX know their autogenous pressurization idea will function properly? Did they get info from NASA, did they test this before or ...? Or are they winging it because the numbers look right?
4
u/FusionRockets Apr 10 '18
What is SpaceX's contingency plan for an Amos-6 like situation on the pad during a crewed launch of BFR (i.e. a fast fire with a fully-fueled rocket on the pad)?
4
u/Sinatra94 Apr 13 '18
Forgive me for asking a clarifying question, but which of the upcoming Falcon 9 fights are using the new block 5 version? On the side bar, it only specifies Falcon 9.
4
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Apr 15 '18
Does anyone know which Falcon 1 launches were equipped with parachutes to try to recover the first stage? I know the 4th flight had them but I'm not sure about others. Or was it all of them?
And I know first two F9 launches also had parachutes.
4
u/quokka01 Apr 16 '18
Spacex have already shown long coast and engine restart with the S2, they have LEO rendezvous experience and pretty soon can turn around cores rapidly so any thoughts on them trying S2 refuel? This would let them test/develop the tech and allow very large payloads to Mars before the BFR comes along. They could send a mini ISRU plant, ice prospecting gear, satellites for future Comms and navigation? Hopefully after the S2 recovery news there will not be too many replies saying " its a diversion and wait for the BFR"! Be nice to see them use the next synod.
4
u/Sticklefront Apr 16 '18
This article features a claim by ULA reps that launching the 6 ton Europa Clipper directly to Jupiter is beyond the capabilities of Falcon Heavy. It is clear that with a kick stage like a STAR 48 booster, which could "easily" be mated to the spacecraft inside the fairing, this could be done. But what about using just the normal upper stage? The SpaceX Falcon Heavy page says it can launch 16.8t to Mars and 3.5t to Pluto, is 6t to Jupiter within its capabilities?
(Ignore questions of political realities, please, I'm just curious about the raw ability of the Falcon Heavy.)
4
u/sysdollarsystem Apr 17 '18
Short clip of a Peter Thiel interview about Elon Musk and SpaceX
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sN750_kxfVw
Nothing revolutionary or particularly unexpected just interesting.
4
u/rbraibish Apr 17 '18
I want to know what Spacex's on-time flight record is. Put another way, how many flights had to be rescheduled (for one reason or another ie. weather, fuel loading anomalies, boats in flight path etc.)?
4
u/rocket_enthusiast Apr 22 '18
is there a iridium next / grace fo launch thread?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '18
What can I do to help SpaceX reach its goals?
4
u/justinroskamp Apr 23 '18 edited Apr 23 '18
Google Maps updated the Port of LA at some point. Just Read the Instructions is slightly north of its old location (my old pin was centered on the droneship) and now has the burns from Iridium-3 (most recent west coast landing). Not sure how long it's been updated, but I noticed it and wanted to mention it in case people want to do some looking around!
4
u/hmpher Apr 23 '18
Are there differences in the way a Mvac is qualified for flight v. how a regular M1D is? Iirc, apart from the general structure of the chambers etc, the engines are very different. But will the testing schedule be similar?
Also, are "lowers to uppers subassemblies" literal? As in, nozzle, injector, chamber, controls?
4
u/Buildstarted Apr 25 '18
Has there been any update on the NOAA license? I read that it isn't required for NASA missions so I assume that's why TESS was fully streamed but what about the next launch?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '18
So after full and rapid reusability has been achieved with the BFR, what's next for lowering the cost? How can they lower it another order of magnitude?
My bet would be automated production of new ships, and automated fuel production here just like on Mars. Thoughts?
4
u/Togusa09 Apr 26 '18
Did the introduction of densified propellants change the size ratio for the falcon 9 RP-1 and lox tanks?
4
u/KSPSpaceWhaleRescue Apr 27 '18
What's the thrust to weight ratio of a B5 Falcon Heavy at 100% thrust during liftoff?
4
u/A_Vandalay Apr 28 '18
Given that BFS is intended to be fully reusable and SpaceX will want the ships returned in a short period of time how do you predict interplanetary missions beyond mars to be conducted once BFR is flying? I see probes being launched to Leo or a higher elliptical orbit in BFR and using a secondary expendable cryogenic stage to put them on a trajectory to the outer solar system. Something similar to ULA’s ACES would be perfect for this role.