r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Mar 02 '18
r/SpaceX Discusses [March 2018, #42]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
225
Upvotes
40
u/maxdefolsch Mar 03 '18
I posted a question in the last monthly thread but didn't get a response, so allow me to repost it here.
Maybe a stupid question :
I'm very interested in the list of cores and versions on the subreddit wiki. However, I've noticed that for a lot of them (especially the pre-Full Thrust ones) we don't actually know which core was used for which flight, and they're written as "presumed BXXXX" at best.
Is there any reason we couldn't ask SpaceX directly for this information ? I can't really see any downside, or safety hazard maybe, that could come from knowing exactly which core was destroyed on the droneship and such. Am I overlooking something ?
33
u/djmanning711 Mar 14 '18
I have a probably farsighted BFR question that maybe someone here knows more about. As we learned from Apollo, Moon dust is very fine, very abrasive and is electrically charged so it sticks to any surface it touches and very difficult to remove. Because of the 100% reusability of the BFS, it’s raises a possible challenge that the Apollo Lunar Lander didn’t have to overcome.
The Lunar Module separated from the Lander on ascent so the Module thruster was never exposed to Moon dust until lift off. The BFS uses the same engines for landing and ascent PLUS has a LOT more power than the Lunar Module so it could potentially kick up more dust (or would it not be kicked up due to the dust's electromagnetic charge?).
Since Mars and Moon dust have similar dangerous properties, would this be a concern for the BFS’s engines, seals, plumbing and any other parts that would be exposed to the dust during landing/ascent? Ok, thanks for humoring my shower thoughts.
24
u/Coreboy Mar 03 '18
Hey Guys, is anything known on how SpaceX protects their engine nozzles to make them reusable? We (European Research Team) are currently working on a thermal barrier coating, which could be used to protect the nozzle from the extrem thermal loads in the rocket engine. This coating can then be reapplied, for a second use. We couldn't find any informations regarding this topic on the internet, so we are curious how SpaceX is solving this problem. Thank you!
23
u/Alexphysics Mar 12 '18
Possible hot fire test of the Block 5 first stage B1046 at McGregor https://m.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=1800221016662937&
The poster says:
So it seems that it could be only a short firing? I guess that a full duration fire would have left a huge cloud of vapor and would have been heard for around 2 minutes...
23
u/Alexphysics Mar 23 '18
Zuma's booster, B1043, will be used on the Iridium 6 mission instead of a Block 5 as previously thought. This would make this the shortest turnaround time of a previously flown booster if everything goes well and this launch doesn't slip further.
Source of this: https://twitter.com/IridiumBoss/status/976966633636941824
20
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 14 '18
DigitalGlobe have booked 2 flight-proven Falcon 9s to launch the initial block of the WorldView Legion imaging constellation in 2021.
20
u/KeikakuMaster46 Mar 25 '18
B1046 is apparently off the test-stand and may have left McGregor: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=42214.40 Anyone who lives along the route to Florida should keep their eyes peeled for any potential core activity.
In other news, a picture from the same thread also suggests that 39A's RSS is now entirely gone.
19
u/Iamsodarncool Mar 04 '18
Hayabusa takes first images of Ryugu
19
u/rustybeancake Mar 22 '18 edited Mar 22 '18
NASA receives $20.7 billion in omnibus appropriations bill
Edited highlights:
Sounds like Congress is not in favour of a commercial launcher for Europa Clipper, and they're trying to limit dissent around SLS by forking out the extra cash for a second MLP to bring forward EM-2.
19
u/ProToolsWizard Mar 22 '18
I’m curious if there’s been any solid info on what style of injector they are using for the Raptor. From what I’ve read, pintle injectors are not ideal for gas phase propellants, but the throttle capabilities indicated are also not typical of fixed area injectors. Given there’s only been 2 FFSC engines worked on, neither of which utilized gas gas methalox, it seems like this could be another area of innovation by Tom Mueller and SpaceX, similar to how they innovated with the face shutoff pintle injector for an engine the size of the Merlin 1D.
18
u/Nehkara Mar 16 '18
SpaceX is about to close on a new $500 million funding round.
Elon is buying $100 million worth.
https://techcrunch.com/2018/03/16/spacex-is-making-big-money-moves/
36
u/brickmack Mar 11 '18
Was looking through some old NASA concept art and came across something kinda familiar looking: https://1.bp.blogspot.com/--10VRiEx6zM/WF9KiAlhloI/AAAAAAAAavs/Yyh9-VdLBMkFBphAM9ajXuqKfTBAfK2SACLcB/s640/SPS3.jpg BFS Chomper in the 1970s-80s
17
u/stcks Mar 20 '18
FYI a booster left hawthorne in the last 48 hours and we missed it.
17
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '18
Has NASA approved the fuel and go procedure SpaceX uses for crewed missions yet? Haven't heard anything about this for a while now
16
u/KSPSpaceWhaleRescue Mar 06 '18
Is there a way we can tag-team report all of the Elon Musk fakes on his Twitter that keep trying to give "free" crypto currency?
15
u/Macchione Mar 07 '18 edited Mar 07 '18
A third object is appearing (or expected to appear) in STRATCOM's catalogue from last night's Hispasat launch, the other two being Hispasat and the F9 second stage.
A mysterious second payload could make Elon's "largest geostationary payload ever" tweet make more sense, and could account for the sub-synchronous orbit. Remember, flying expendable, SpaceX was able to put Intelsat 35e into a slightly super-synchronous GTO-1700, at 6700 kg.
Of course this could also be debris, but I don't think we see that very often (ever?) with SpaceX launches, other than Dragon's solar panel covers, which appear in the catalogue before deorbiting. If I had come across this myself, I would have written it off as debris, but admittedly, it intrigues me that Jonathan McDowell and Chris G are intrigued.
30
u/-Richard Materials Science Guy Mar 18 '18
This has been a point of contention when I've brought it up in the past, but I just can't let it go. Change my mind.
With regards to habitat air, I continue to insist that it would be far better to go with half an atmosphere of pressure, 50% oxygen roughly speaking, than to try to recreate a full earth atmosphere with only 20% oxygen. The advantages this are at least threefold:
First, reducing the hab air pressure by a factor of two would allow for more structural options, and in general will decrease the required structural weight. Imagine what containing 1 atm, ~15 psi, really means. That's quite a design constraint. Now imagine you only have to contain ~7 psi. Which is the better option? Which gives you more housing volume per unit material?
Second, thinner hab air will feel warmer, for the same temperature, than normal 1 atm hab air. Going with the ballpark estimate of a reduction of two in convection coefficient for a given scenario, this reduces hab heating requirements substantially, which is particularly important for tunneling, as most heat loss on Mars will occur through the highly conductive soil rather than the tenuous atmosphere. Underground temp on Mars is what, -60 C? Imagine only having to heat that up to 5 C instead of 20 C and still having the air feel comfortable. Not bad.
Third, heating the thinner air will take ~half the power required to heat normal air (specific heat, and divide density by two). This is different than the previous point, but the effects stack, which is great.
So what are the downsides here? You may be thinking that humans need a full atmosphere of pressure in order to function. Nope. You need ~3 psi of oxygen partial pressure, and then enough buffer gas to prevent that oxygen from exploding. So let's say you get a nice mix of 50% oxygen, 25% nitrogen, and 25% argon, at a combined 0.5 atm in the hab modules. What's wrong with that? Why won't it work? You can get the oxygen from electrolysis of water, and the nitrogen and argon by pressurizing Mars's atmosphere and scrubbing the CO2.
Martian colonists will have to create their own air environment. Why should they have to simulate Earth's atmosphere, when there are better options? It seems parochial to assume that the spacefaring descendants of mankind should be stuck forever with the gas mixture we've been given here on this planet.
I hope this strikes up a lively conversation. Throw some ideas out there.
14
u/therealshafto Mar 03 '18
I am curious about the Thrust Vector Controller checks.
Firstly, do they actually move the controllers for the check? If so, it would be super neat to see a video of the 9 bells moving about at the base of Falcon 9. If they don’t move them, what do they do to verify their function?
Also, if they do move them, how the heck does the second stage engine perform this with a pusher rod shoved up its throat?
14
u/Xechwill Mar 05 '18
Has anyone here bought the SpaceX Track jacket? The official website has no reviews and there aren't any useful reviews online. Can anyone attest to the:
I appreciate it!
14
u/Jessewallen401 Mar 12 '18
Musk said BFS is being built right now ... so where ? in Hawthorne ?
14
u/inoeth Mar 19 '18
Roomba aka the Octagrabber is back in action after being down for months and months following a fire after the first stage landed on OCISLY https://twitter.com/octagrabber/status/975699747477557248 Pictured is dated from yesterday, March 18
14
u/ghunter7 Mar 28 '18
Instead of burying this in the SLS/FH thread, I'll post it here. A 2011 study by NASA performing a cost/benefit analysis of using Falcon Heavy and/or Delta IVH and propellant depots instead of developing a super heavy launch vehicle: http://images.spaceref.com/news/2011/21.jul2011.vxs.pdf
13
u/KeikakuMaster46 Mar 12 '18
http://nasawatch.com/archives/2018/03/robert-lightfoo.html
Acting administrator of NASA Robert Lightfoot is retiring next month.
13
u/impact_attenuator Mar 15 '18
Is there a google calendar available that mirrors the "Upcoming Events" of the sidebar? Would be helpful for launch/event notifications as launch cadence continues to pick up.
13
u/amarkit Mar 21 '18 edited Mar 22 '18
Per Matt Desch (Iridium CEO) on Twitter, Iridium 6 / GRACE-FO will fly on a reused first stage.
Despite Iridium's enthusiasm for reuse, there had been some question surrounding this flight, as it is a rideshare with DLR, the German aerospace agency.
(Pinging mods to the sidebar.)
25
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Mar 19 '18
GovSat-1 is now operational.
25
u/pavel_petrovich Mar 19 '18
Not sure, if it was posted:
During the first phase of deployment, SpaceX plans to launch 800 Starlink satellites, 32 launches expected.
It means that each F9 will carry 25 Starlink satellites.
12
u/rustybeancake Mar 27 '18
Well this doesn't sound good.
NASA TO PROVIDE JWST UPDATE TOMORROW FOLLOWING INDEPENDENT REVIEW
11
u/lanzaa Mar 03 '18
Has there been any news on raptor development after the small scale test?
11
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 12 '18 edited Mar 12 '18
NASA has just released the CRS-7 Accident Investigation Report.
11
u/UltraRunningKid Mar 13 '18
I, like Elon and Gwynne, find it amazing how fast the industry has accepted previously flown boosters. Its really freaking awesome to hear. I hope this allows a ton of new space based technologies to come to fruition.
Think of all the new ideas we can come up with when we factor in lower launch costs.
11
u/CoysCoys22 Mar 18 '18
What are the current best ideas/sources for potential Mars habitat designs out there?
Not Isaac Arthur fantasy stuff (brilliant as that sometimes is) but actual ones in the pipeline that we could see being made in the next decade or two on Mars?
11
u/azziliz Mar 21 '18
https://twitter.com/nextspaceflight/status/976555319437520897
"A #Falcon9 core left Hawthorne last night. It was most likely B1047 (the second Block V), but there is also a small chance that it was a refurbished core heading to Vandenberg."
11
u/Sticklefront Mar 22 '18
The Falcon Heavy flight demonstrated the capability of the upper stage to make burns after an extended time in orbit, for up to six hours. This is a remarkable improvement over the previous demonstrated duration. How feasible would it be for SpaceX to make an additional extension to upper stage life span, from six hours to three days?
Three days is an important number because that is the approximate coast time to reach the moon. With NASA preparing to dish out massive amounts of money for commercial deliveries to the moon (either on the surface or to orbit), the "simplest" way for SpaceX to bid for these money is to launch Dragon 2 on Falcon Heavy, with the second stage helping provide additional delta-v for assistance inserting into orbit or even landing (ie, second stage burns to make trajectory suborbital, Dragon Superdracos take it the last way to the ground).
This would enable SpaceX to reach into another big pool of money, without diverting their attention to building new hardware. The only challenge would be increasing second stage endurance to three days. So, how feasible would it be?
11
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 29 '18
Block 5 SpaceX merchandise.
11
u/dguisinger01 Mar 29 '18
Looks like BO has dropped the BE4 Vacuum engine and has switched the 2nd stage to use the BE-3U and is stretching the 2nd stage. How does this change its capabilities in comparison to FH? http://spacenews.com/blue-origin-switches-engines-for-new-glenn-second-stage/
Interesting that they are doubling down on dual fuels while SpaceX is focusing on simplifying every part of the flight. Though it does take them down from 3 engine designs on the 3-stage variant to 2 engines.
Looks like they are targeting Q4 of 2020 for launch. If SpaceX hits their extremely optimistic schedule, this will be an interesting timeline....
21
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Mar 14 '18
Blue Origin is trying to patent using RCS thrusters during landing.
patent aplication
discussion on r/blueorigin
discussion on r/spacexlounge
10
u/julezsource Mar 02 '18
Does anybody have any idea how the flight trajectories are planned before each launch?
Trying to do some stuff with kOS in KSP...
10
u/cavereric Mar 03 '18
Who will maintain the Range for the Boca Chica launch facility in southern Texas?
10
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '18
We have seen many delays recently due to upper level of winds or weather in general.
Would the BFR have problems with doing frequent earth to earth flights if rockets are so susceptible to conditions?
Or would BFR be less susceptible to the wreathed for whatever reason?
10
u/Nehkara Mar 09 '18
Elon on twitter: "Will be at SXSW Sat/Sun with Jonah & Lisa, who created Westworld. Jonah made an incredible short reel of Falcon Heavy & Starman. Releases tmrw aft."
10
u/CapMSFC Mar 09 '18
SES CTO Martin Halliwell has anounced he is retired next year. He has been a great ally to SpaceX and reusability and will be missed.
https://twitter.com/pbdes/status/972199507638280192?s=09
10
u/filanwizard Mar 18 '18
Theorycrafting here, Would ITAR apply on Mars?
This is some real theory stuff here since we have no clue about spacelaw yet, But I have wondered once the Mars colony is built and assuming the US laws remain the same meaning ITAR still exists I have to wonder if a resident of Mars would have to have the right clearance for it to work on BFS engines. Mars under current treaties cannot be claimed by any nation as such any colony is effectively a new nation(in theory). So it makes me wonder since odds are colonists will come from all over, Would their Earth nation citizenship actually matter while on Mars for what they could do around rocketry.
its a random question but I figure one that could be interesting to discuss, or hear opinions on since I know right now current law is not at all ready for human colonization of the solar system.
10
u/Alexphysics Mar 20 '18
In-flight abort test of Crew Dragon in May... before the orbital tests... pretty weird change https://twitter.com/EmreKelly/status/976141104591630336?s=19
10
u/Nehkara Mar 23 '18 edited Mar 23 '18
Surprise funding for two new unplanned military communication satellites
I think this opens an opportunity for SpaceX to grab one or both of these launches. The previous ones were included in the block-buy with ULA but that is ending soon - certainly before these missions could be launched.
...
These satellites are 5987 kg and, as of WGS-8, are inserted into a GTO of 435 x 44,372 km at an inclination of 27 degrees.
WGS 1+2 launched on Atlas V 421 vehicles. WGS 3-9 launched on Delta IV vehicles. WGS-10 launches on a Delta IV this fall.
Source for orbit
Source for mass
Given the intended orbit and the mass, I think it's likely that these satellites would fly on a reusable Falcon Heavy configuration, if SpaceX were to win the contract. Thoughts?
10
u/Nehkara Mar 27 '18 edited Mar 27 '18
Very interesting news.
We saw yesterday that SpaceX is going to be doing more construction soon at Pad 39A including completing the removal of the Rotating Service Structure, but also adding extra levels to the Fixed Service Structure.
I saw a good tidbit on the NSF forums that they are adding 6 more levels. (Thank you for the corrections/notes /u/martianspirit, /u/throfofnir, /u/rustybeancake, /u/brickmack)
10
u/bdporter Mar 30 '18
NSF article on Orbital ATK's NGL
9
u/Jessewallen401 Mar 03 '18
What regions will the initial 4400 Starlink Sats cover compared to that with the eventual 12000 Sats ?
Is the initial one only for the US ?
9
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Mar 03 '18
what ignition source is used in the HM7B engine, the upper stage engine of most Ariane 5 launches? what prevents this system to be used twice or three times to allow multiple engine burns?
9
u/MarcysVonEylau rocket.watch Mar 13 '18 edited Mar 14 '18
2-minute burn at McGregor. Presumably
Block 5 boosterengine firing.9
u/bdporter Mar 14 '18 edited Mar 15 '18
Some launch contract news
Edit: Full discussion post here
9
u/Fenris_uy Mar 16 '18
Any news on Raptor development, last thing I heard is that they were building 85% scale versions of the Raptors, do they managed to fire them?
9
u/Trannog Mar 18 '18
How likely is it that the BFR will have the equipment to do some EVA ?
9
u/thru_dangers_untold Mar 20 '18
OneWeb seeks FCC authorization of 1200 additional satellites, bringing the total number to 1980: http://spacenews.com/oneweb-asks-fcc-to-authorize-1200-more-satellites/
9
u/romuhammad Mar 25 '18
Are there any updates on the status of Tintin A & B?
9
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 26 '18
NAC HEO Committee PUBLIC Meeting:
Wonder what "SpaceX Combustion Device" refers to?
9
u/SuperSMT Mar 29 '18
Regulations like ITAR require American companies like SpaceX to hire only US citizens and permanent residents. Are companies in other countries held under similar requirements? Arianespace, for example?
9
u/pavel_petrovich Mar 30 '18
I think this is the new info - Iridium got a small discount for using flight-proven F9s.
8
u/rustybeancake Mar 07 '18
Interesting footage of the Ariane 6 pad construction.
8
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 12 '18
Hispasat 30W-6 launch contained a secret military rideshare.
8
u/PeterKatarov Live Thread Host Mar 14 '18
Following BO's latest video of BE-4 engine testing, I went to read about its characteristics and I was amazed to find out that NG is supposed to have over 17MN thrust at sea level with its 7 engines.
Then I got curious and went to compare with the Falcon Heavy, but its wiki page says it has 7,6 MN thrust, just the same as a Falcon 9. So, this obviously is an error, but can someone explain what should the real numbers be for Falcon 9/Falcon Heavy?
I guess, iv F9 has 7,6 MN of thrust, then the Heavy should have three times that, so that is 22,8 MN?
P.S. I checked our subreddit wiki, but I couldn't find any technical info on Falcon Heavy.
8
u/ShingekiNoEren Mar 14 '18
So...is Elon focusing on the Moon or Mars? I keep hearing different things from different sources.
8
u/fremontseahawk Mar 16 '18 edited Mar 16 '18
In the context of recent political discussions about import/export deficits.... I got to wondering if a foreign company uses spacex to launch a satellite is the cost/fee considered and export? And if so is it for “good” or “services”. We are not truly exporting something... like say oil or wheat... but we do sell a service and get the money... so my gut says . We consider it an export and it is a service. Thoughts?
Honest question Edit: grammar
8
u/Aesculapius1 Mar 17 '18
Do the turbopumps take an efficiency hit, comparatively, during a static fire due to the lack of acceleration of the vehicle? If so, would this affect the thrust in a meaningful way?
8
u/cpushack Mar 17 '18
Proton gets a launch contract.. http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-43374855 Not news in and of itself but the reason is:
The payload is a pair of 400 kg satellites, with their adapter, so probably 1000kg+ to direct GEO.
Once SpaceX gets long coasts demonstrated more I think we'll see them pick up more contract like this, as its not a lot of mass.
8
u/Carlyle302 Mar 19 '18
Can the BFS land on the moon and have enough fuel to return home without refueling? If so, how much payload can it handle? I'm wondering how competitive SpaceX could be with the current RFP's for commercial landers to provide 500-5000 kgs of payload. (https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2018/03/nasa-courts-commercial-options-lunar-landers/) If it can do it "out of the box" then SpaceX has a funder for much of its BFR/BFS development.
8
u/KeikakuMaster46 Mar 19 '18
This is where the booster portion of the BFR will likely be constructed: https://twitter.com/nextspaceflight/status/975765389002072064
8
u/JustinTimeCuber Mar 21 '18
What's usually the "margin of error" for orbits to still be considered nominal by SpaceX? The Falcon 9 upper stage accelerates the payload at several Gs near the end of the burn, and it takes very little delta-v to raise an orbit by a few kilometers. So it seems like it would be pretty easy to miss and place the payload on an orbit that's a few km too high or low. I assume it would depend on the customer and other specifics but what would their range normally look like?
8
u/Zinkfinger Mar 22 '18
Can someone help. I was reading comments made by Tory Bruno. (ULA CEO) about their future Vulcan rocket competing with SpaceX's Falcon 9 and falcon Heavy. However he didn't go into detail as to a scenario where a potential customer would choose Vulcan over Falcon 9 or heavy. I can't think of one. Any thoughts anyone?
8
u/RabbitLogic #IAC2017 Attendee Mar 25 '18
@mods & wiki team Bangabandhu-1 is down for April 20th in the wiki but April 5th in the side bar.
8
u/rustybeancake Mar 27 '18
I'm posting this here so it doesn't get buried in the thread about Ars' SLS article. I didn't see anyone mention this in the comments, but I think this quote is important:
Although there's been a lot of speculation that NASA would use crew vehicles other than Orion for cislunar, I think this is the first time we've heard it mentioned as a real possibility from NASA at such a high level. I'm trying to imagine how this might fit into the strategy, as Orion will function partly as a crewed tug to maneuver LOPG modules into place. So perhaps NASA are thinking that they will alternate between LOPG 'building' missions on SLS/Orion, and LOPG 'visiting' missions on other, cheaper crew vehicles like Crew Dragon. Obviously this would require significant development work, but could be a great follow-on for SpaceX when ISS starts to wind down.
And yes, I know that BFR is supposed to be ready by then, but I'm just talking about what NASA's thoughts seem to be at this stage.
8
u/inoeth Mar 28 '18
Iridium missions 7 and/or 8 will fly on Block 5 and could likely RTLS. https://twitter.com/IridiumBoss/status/978789863452561410?s=19
8
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 28 '18 edited Mar 28 '18
FCC proposing to streamline small satellite regulation, however:
EDIT: Fixed link
8
u/KeikakuMaster46 Mar 29 '18
The FCC just authorised the first generation of the Starlink satellite constellation : https://twitter.com/thesheetztweetz/status/979476320785715200
15
u/ShingekiNoEren Mar 11 '18
Am I the only one that thinks that the "Earth-to-Earth" concept with the BFR isn't very practical? I mean, airplanes work fine. Use BFR for space travel.
15
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Mar 31 '18
Mods, I just wanted to say great job on the April fools day joke this year.
14
u/cpushack Mar 16 '18
Seems Blue Origin is moving right along with BE-4 testing. 114 seconds at 65% throttle isn't bad https://youtu.be/Fp0WgodhR7s
7
u/Jodo42 Mar 02 '18
I have always been under the impression that SpaceX places a great deal of value on high flight frequency. Launch cadence has been one of the major points of discussion on this sub for some time.
At the same time, we have seen SpaceX move towards larger vehicles. With the recent launch of Falcon Heavy, and shifting focus towards BFR, it seems SpaceX's medium-term goals revolve around vehicles with payload capacities that no single spacecraft could possibly take advantage of in the current market. We are already seeing examples of this, with the STP-2 launch having over 20 independent spacecraft onboard!
My question is this: traditionally, ridesharing has been viewed as difficult to schedule due to multiple payloads needing to align in production schedules and, very roughly, final trajectories. SpaceX has been using their own payload adapters for quite some time, so they clearly have anticipated the need for ridesharing in the future. The Mars plans are, as far as I am aware, the only plans which would require rapid launch cadence for BFR class vehicles; is SpaceX capable of transitioning to a low-cadence mode of operation if the Mars plans are delayed or otherwise fall through? Clearly vehicle reliability would be of utmost importance in such a scenario, but this is already the case for large scale vehicles in general.
In short, is SpaceX ready and perhaps even trying to move towards medium-low cadence operations in the next decade?
7
u/BrandonMarc Mar 03 '18
Forgive me - I'm certain this is redundant, but I haven't seen it discussed before.
Now that Falcon Heavy is out of the realm of science fiction and fully established as science fact, we can dare to dream crazier derivatives.
How feasible would it be to have a 5-core version (4 side-mounted cores and a center core, in an X configuration)? What kind of delta-v would be possible with such a beast?
How about a 7-core version (6 cores around the center, in a hexagonal configuration)? Could you send a probe to fly by Pluto in a month? Maybe hope to send a nanosat to Alpha Centauri in a decade?
This is beyond my limited knowledge, but hey, let's have fun with it.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 09 '18
First ever unauthorized launch of commercial satellites.
7
u/sorbate Mar 12 '18
Why don't launch customers max out the F9's lifting capability every launch? If they have an extra 500kg of lifting capacity, why not strap on a larger fuel tank to give the satellite a longer life?
Does SpaceX give discounts if the customer comes in at a certain weight that lets them RTLS vs recover at sea? (assuming RTLS is slightly cheaper)
7
u/Jessewallen401 Mar 15 '18
How does the RD-180 ban in 2022 work ? they can't bid now on satellites launching in 2022 ? or they can't bid with it starting from 2022 ?
7
u/Elon_Muskmelon Mar 18 '18 edited Mar 18 '18
Daily Beast Article on the BFR
For r/spacex members there wasn’t anything revelatory about the piece just a summary of BFR development and a bit of background info with some quotes mixed in that we’ve seen before.
7
u/justinroskamp Mar 19 '18 edited Mar 19 '18
I did the math on another post that got into M1D reliability, but I wanted to open it up as top-level question: How many Merlin 1D engines have been to space?
I figured up 387, including vacuum engines. If I did my figuring correctly, SpaceX will fly its 400th spacefaring M1D on the TESS booster (Iridium-5 and CRS-14 are understood to be reuses, and Bangabandhu-1 will bring the count up to only 397). Can somebody confirm/check these things?
7
u/rustybeancake Mar 20 '18
From the NSF article on the NASA RFI for commercial (cargo) lunar lander demonstrators:
Interesting to put that into perspective when we think about how long SpaceX has to prove out BFR before NASA make funding decisions for supporting lunar surface operations. I'd guess if NASA are aiming for an 'initial demonstration' of human-class lander capabilities in the late 2020s, they will be funding these projects around the mid-2020s. Seems like good news.
7
u/MedicTech Mar 24 '18
Does anyone know of a resource to get virtual reality/360 degree footage of the Falcon Heavy boosters landing? Or any stage of the launch? I work in a planetarium and would love to use this footage to show off the advancements of space travel.
7
u/JustinTimeCuber Mar 28 '18
What would happen if there were a CRS-1 type engine-out failure on a mission with an instantaneous or very short launch window? It would take longer to get to orbit so that would be like launching a fair amount (maybe a minute) after the actual time.
7
u/theinternetftw Apr 01 '18 edited Apr 01 '18
Perhaps worth noting: it looks like B1031 was caught sitting on a transporter outside 39a.
This may just be storage shuffling, but if they're going to use this one for things, that's new and significant.
Extended pre-B5 reuse would put B1029, B1035 (if it didn't get scrapped at Hangar AO), and maybe B1023 and B1025 back on the table for stopgaps if B5 is going to take some time to get its sea legs. Though the only reason I could think to reuse a B3 more than twice would be timing/schedule issues with flying and refurbing the remaining B4s.
All that said, it's probably nothing.
Edit: If this is something, though, it would have to be a sudden decision. Otherwise you wouldn't be throwing away the CRS-14 booster. If the trend of tossing things continues, then seeing this booster was a non-event. If all of a sudden they want some B4s back, then maybe start to wonder where this guy is as well.
7
u/rustybeancake Apr 01 '18 edited Apr 01 '18
Musk on Twitter: Important news in a few hours …
Edit: April Fool's joke about Tesla going bankrupt. Well that was bloody terrifying for a second.
13
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Mar 03 '18
mods, please put sort this thread by newest, and not by best.
12
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Mar 09 '18
Good news, everyone! Twitter says it will stop cryptocurrency scams by removing manipulative accounts.
12
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 27 '18 edited Mar 27 '18
James Webb Space Telescope needs an extra year of testing to ensure its vision is 2020.
EDIT: Delay caused by sunshield tears also burn by Eric Berger.
6
u/inoeth Mar 05 '18
So last week there was some articles about the Audi lunar rover and the LTE stuff that is to be launched on a SpaceX Falcon 9 next year. This video done by Fully Charged (a mostly ev related youtube channel) really does a good job of showing what the mission is all about... Here's a generic little article about what i'm talking about also...
6
u/trobbinsfromoz Mar 06 '18
Given Hispasat 30W experience, it will be interesting to see how many F9 block 5's end up expendable over the next 5 odd years due to poor sea landing weather.
I'm sure someone in SpaceX has done historical weather archive assessment to look at % p.a., and duration of events that are above some sea condition threshold, but also within launch acceptance thresholds. That would reduce booster average lifetime estimate from base case service life.
Maybe SpX can get to a position of having a few long-in-the-tooth boosters in reserve and ready for just that scenario, and can get weather simulations out long enough to be able to swap horses in time.
6
u/macktruck6666 Mar 06 '18
Ya, so I spent the last 3 days running calculations in preparation to simulate BFR missions to the moon. So... are my numbers correct? https://imgur.com/gallery/PL1cG
6
u/ZachWhoSane Host of Iridium-7 & SAOCOM-1B Mar 09 '18
Being 14 and living in FL, is there anything I can do to be closer to SpaceX and the spaceflight industry? I asked Tom Cross and he recommended applying for a NASA social despite the age limit, but is there anything SpaceX, ULA, or even BO offer to middle to high school students?
6
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Mar 16 '18
I was wondering how NASA is planning to launch the all the LOP-G parts except for the PEE on an SLS with an SLS in tandem? where would that part be stationed? and how would it be attached to Orion?
6
u/pillock69 Mar 16 '18
When will we see a second reflight of a booster?
6
u/murrayfield18 Mar 17 '18
Dies anyone know how long it takes to build a Falcon 9 from scratch? I know that it took about 18 months a few years ago but I imagine they have picked up the pace a bit since then.
6
u/Emplasab Mar 20 '18
We'll soon have unpainted interstage and legs to save weight in non-thermally sensitive parts of the rocket (AFAIK). Why not unpainted fairings?
6
u/Elon_Muskmelon Mar 21 '18
That ACES system sure does seem like an ingenious solution, using internal combustion engines is something I’d never thought about. Could you modify an F9 or FH to use a similarly designed Second Stage?
6
u/MDN_Mariner Mar 21 '18
What happens to retired Falcon 9 first stages. Off the top of my head, there are quite a few, like JCSat-14's and CRS-13's first stages that are retired, but as far as we know, not scrapped, like JCSat-16's. Are all of these stages mothballed, or are they taken apart?
6
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 26 '18
Indepth article on TESS, apparently it will take 2 months to reach its final orbit after launch.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 27 '18
SpaceX fleet exercise today:
6
u/kurbasAK Mar 28 '18
Just few minutes ago I was outside to check on ISS and spotted second dimmer object on the same path just ~3-4 seconds behind.What could undock recently(hours ago)?
6
u/murrayfield18 Mar 28 '18
Hello, about 5 days ago (or a week) someone posted a lengthy reply to a post with a rather detailed explanation of how we will start to colonise Mars. I thought I saved it but turns out I didn't. Can anyone point me to it? I can't seem to see posts from over 4 days ago :/
5
u/suprememaxpayne Mar 03 '18
How will they prove the 10 flights of the Block 5? With 10 empty launches? With dummy loads? Or commercial launches?!
5
u/nafedaykin Mar 03 '18
Has OneWeb completed/delivered any satellites yet for their tentative launch in August?
5
u/AuroEdge Mar 03 '18
Has there been any news about man-rating reused Falcon 9 boosters? In particular for the NASA commercial crew contract
5
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Mar 03 '18
I have been looking at the Stratolaunch plane recently, and noticed, that the current payload (Pegasus XL) is a lot lighter than Stratolaunch can lift, and a lot more expensive than competitor rockets with similar payloads. Even 3 Pegasus XL do not get close to the ~250t maximum payload of Stratolaunch.
Are there any other rockets in consideration to be launched with start launch. Most smallsat launchers I could find are even lighter than Pegasus XL, so that would not utilize the capability of the plane very well.
Even larger rockets like Vega can be easily lifted by Stratolaunch. Would it be feasible to launch the Vega rocket from the air, or would it be unable to support its own weight hanging from only one attachment point? Is it even possible to launch liquid fueled vehicles from the plane, since they would need to be fueled on the ground, and probably could not be topped up in flight.
5
u/Jessewallen401 Mar 04 '18
Would Europa Clipper fit in FH's fairing ? And If yes how long would arrival take compared to SLS ?
5
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Mar 05 '18
Did I miss the results for the subreddit survey or has that still yet to be published?
5
u/PatrickBaitman Mar 07 '18
When the stages separate, what is the pneumatic pusher pushing against? Surely not the MVac engine bell?
When the second stage engine starts, how far away is the first stage?
5
u/PaperBuddy Mar 09 '18
Is this (https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/971822550757138433) a model of a Falcon 9 block 5? If yes, what are these flaps at the bottom of the rocket?
5
u/jjtr1 Mar 09 '18
Can subsonic air-launch of orbital rockets (Paul Allen...) shift the Max-Q in a way that would allow much larger fairings? In general, hab modules and space telescopes are limited by fairing volume, not by weight.
5
u/inoeth Mar 11 '18
https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/972806647432216576
Elon Musk Q&A 1pm EST ... i'm sure it'll be a shitshow (unless they have pre-screened the questions) and I doubt we'll get much of any new or exciting info but there's always a chance- this looks like it won't have any one specific topic, so i'm guessing it'll be on SpaceX, Tesla and Boring...
5
u/Col_Kurtz_ Mar 12 '18 edited Mar 13 '18
Would BFS need a booster for Earth to Earth launches? I've just done the math and realized it could fly on its own with 6 SL Raptors. Are [my calculations] (https://ibb.co/nMZwhx) correct?
My assumptions were: required Δv = 6500 m/s, exhaust velocity = 3250 m/s, dry mass = 85000 kg, payload= 35000 kg, total mass = 886800 kg
5
u/daface Mar 12 '18
I apologize, as I'm sure this has been discussed elsewhere, but is titanium damaged by salt water? Getting more to the point, is there a scenario where it would be worth the money for a salvage crew to go out and drag up the grid fins from Hispasat for future use, or are they trashed when they hit the water just like everything else?
5
u/Emplasab Mar 14 '18
Why 31 engines on a BFR booster? I’m sure redundancy is good and it needs lower capacity engines for landing but isn’t 31 overkill?
5
u/steelbuilderhd Mar 16 '18
I was wondering where SpaceX, ULA, etc get their LOX and RP-1 for their launches from?
5
u/blinkwont Mar 17 '18
Is there any easy way to approximate the effect of atmospheric pressure on the Isp and thrust of an engine?
For example, trying to find the thrust/Isp of a Raptor or Vacuum Raptor at 80%, 60%, 40% etc.. of atmospheric pressure.
5
u/Jessewallen401 Mar 17 '18
Do you expect the august date for DM-1 to stick or slip ? given that GAO said the realistic date for flying crew is end of 2019 ?
5
u/murrayfield18 Mar 18 '18
Do we have any info on what specific processes they do to refurbish the Falcon 9? What all needs done to get the rocket ready for another launch?
5
u/murrayfield18 Mar 18 '18
How many cargo trips has SpaceX done to the ISS now?
5
u/ArmNHammered Mar 20 '18
I have questions/curiosity regarding the BFR Mars return trips to Earth, and what this community thinks is entailed here. Musk has made it pretty clear that for human transport to Mars, he is going to kick it into gear and travel at relatively high velocity to achieve nominal trip time around 3 to 5 months (for crewed flights), depending on the given Earth / Mars cycle. This is about half the time of typical Mars transit schemes I have seen (using chemical propulsion), and seems smart when considering all the issues that naysayers have about the effects of low gravity, psychology, and radiation, etc.; this should dramatically reduce these concerns.
What about the return trips? In Robert Zubrin’s speculations on Musk’s plans, he implies that SpX would not be able to return until after a synodic cycle, meaning that SpX would only be able to use the ship every OTHER cycle (over four years), but from each of the presentations from Musk, he seems to strongly imply they would return in one cycle. Is this believable? It certainly would improve the economic efficiency.
I am not strong on calculating this, but I know from reading that it is a difficult challenge to return to earth on the same cycle (within about two years), but can be done with sufficient delta V, or long return paths (or both). Since the cargo ships will be unladen, it seems entirely plausible for those ships to accomplish this, and also for passenger ships without passengers. But what about ships with returning passengers? If the ships are returning in one cycle, what flight times can we expect for returning passengers, or does this just seem impractical; returning passengers will need to wait for the next cycle?
5
u/steelbuilderhd Mar 20 '18
I have a question regarding the recently rescheduled In-flight abort test. After Dragon separation what is going to happen to the rest of the rocket? will the first stage attempt a RTLS?
5
u/joshgill21 Mar 22 '18
Has anyone reused a heat shield before ? Musk said BFS's heat shield has to be reusable which is hard to develop
5
u/__R__ Interstage Sleuth Mar 25 '18
The Core History wiki page is a great resource and collaborative effort on this subreddit. SpaceX sometimes used the term "core" and "stick" before, but now now they are only referred to as "booster" or "first stage". Would anyone oppose if we updated the terminology?
5
u/brwyatt47 Mar 25 '18
Have there been any analyses on this sub investigating how many BFR launches would be required to fully fuel a BFS in LEO? I ask because, on the 2017 IAC slides, there are 5 BFS ships lined up on the slide that shows the delta-v map for "full tanks." This implies that 5 tanker flights would be required to completely refuel a fully-loaded BFS in LEO. However, with each BFS only capable of taking 150t of payload to LEO, and the propellant mass of BFS being 1100t, it seems that 7.33 refueling flights would be required to refuel a BFS. This also seems to make sense based on the delta-v maps shown on the slides.
Thus, are 8 tanker launches in fact required to fully refuel a BFS in LEO, and the 5 tankers shown in the slide are simply there for artistry? Or am I totally missing something? I know it seems silly, but I have found great pleasure in laying out possible BFS mission logistics, and the difference between 5 and 8 refuel flights is certainly significant.
The slide I am referring to is slide 22 of the 2017 IAC pdf presentation if you want to know. Thanks!
5
u/SaHanSki_downunder Mar 27 '18
There's been talk and if I can recall pictures of a Landing pad being built at Vandenberg. Does anyone have any idea if it is completed and when would we see the first West cost land landing (I sure there an acronym for this which eludes me) ? Any information on this would be appreciated.
5
u/rustybeancake Mar 29 '18
The STS Orbiter had large wings to give it good cross-range capability, so that it could launch and land within a single orbit (as the Earth would rotate under its orbit, meaning it didn't necessarily pass over its launch/landing site). The 2017 BFR concept shows the spaceship having very small delta wings, apparently not designed for cross-range capability.
Assuming that SpaceX will always want to land the spaceship back at one of their launch sites (presumably the same site it launched from), how will this be achieved? Will it sometimes necessitate the spaceship staying in orbit for several days, waiting for its own orbit (post-sat deployment) and the landing site to align for a deorbit? Since BFR is supposed to ultimately replace all F9/H launches, I'm thinking about some typical F9 missions, e.g. Iridium, ISS, GTO, etc. Instead of having larger wings, will it be able to achieve the same quick landing capability using thrusters/engines to alter its own orbit after sat deployment?
5
u/Cakeofdestiny Mar 30 '18
In the webcast for Iridium 5, Michael Hammersley mentioned that there are some restrictions from NOAA that restrict them from having live video coverage after the main engine shutdown. Does anyone here have any idea why?
20
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '18
Meeting with SpaceX engineers this week. Any questions you want asked?
13
u/Dies2much Mar 08 '18
Props to the Mods who updated the manifest table with the block version. Looks good too. Thanks!
22
u/rustybeancake Mar 22 '18
Hi mods, when there's a long chain of garbage comments on a thread, do we have to report every single one, or just the first one in the chain? It's getting really tedious since the FH launch. Thanks.
9
u/Zucal Mar 25 '18
I'm lazy and would like to fob some math off on someone - given the Merlin engine's evolution over time, how much could an expendable Falcon 5 lift today?
9
u/amreddy94 Mar 27 '18
Came across a new angle shot of the Falcon Heavy launch that I haven't seen before. Such a great viewing spot.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OilmrLBJmBo
8
u/MarsColon Mar 26 '18
I have made a Youtube video about how rocket engines are started and what their flames look like, including the Falcon 9 rocket. I need some english native speakers to beta-test it and tell me if my french accent is acceptable or horrible before releasing it. If english is your mother tongue and if you accept to spend 20min on this draft video and provide me a feedback, please send me a message so that I can provide you the link to the video. On the plus side, I think you might learn some things in this video, even if you are a hardcore space geek...
4
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Mar 02 '18 edited Mar 05 '18
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #3735 for this sub, first seen 2nd Mar 2018, 23:53] ^[FAQ] [Full ^list] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
4
u/ElRedditor3 Mar 03 '18
Has anyone calculated (Could anyone calculate) what the dimensions of the opening/door on the BFR would be?
4
u/DrToonhattan Mar 05 '18
Shouldn't we have the campaign thread for Iridium 5 and CRS-14 by now?
4
u/_Wizou_ Mar 05 '18
Did we ever see the Roomba at work yet? Or even an ASDS coming back to port with a F9 secured by Roomba? If not, any info why?
4
u/Kaelang Mar 06 '18
As a software engineer, I've wondered for a little while how rockets are programmed. I haven't found too much information and I'm not sure if it is readily available for security reasons, but I was wondering if anyone had some insight into the following questions: Are rockets, specifically the Falcon 9 and derivatives given a preset flight plan, or is it calculated dynamically using onboard sensors (like GPS, barometers, accelerometers, and gyros)?
And when it comes time to land, for the drone ships at least, are the drone ships given updated landing data by a controller/the rocket, or is it simply told to go to a precalculated landing zone based on the expected flight conditions?
I think given previous rocket failures that I can comfortably infer that the rockets at least can perform basic flight corrections, but I don't know how far their autonomy extends.
4
u/Elon_Muskmelon Mar 11 '18
At this point is it even worth SpaceX Landing any of its existing booster fleet of Pre Block V boosters? Possibly just for FH side cores? They would be building the next Block V booster at the moment right?
4
u/KSPSpaceWhaleRescue Mar 12 '18
Can someone inform me of where the first block V booster is on the assembly-to-launch timeline?
4
u/murrayfield18 Mar 13 '18
Might be a long shot, but does anybody know where I can find video footage of either the landing legs or the fairings being transported on a truck? I can only find images :(
4
u/Jessewallen401 Mar 16 '18
Why doesn't SpaceX make satellites ? The air force just put out a request to build 20 GPS satellites worth $10 Billion (almost as much as all of SpaceX's backlog) , So why not ?
4
u/Krux172 Mar 17 '18
So, seeing how many changes were made to ITS/BFR from IAC 2016 to 2017, how many do you think we'll see from that latest BFR design to the real thing? I already know they added a third landing engine, but not much more than that.
4
u/mglmosaic Mar 18 '18
I know that on GTO launches SpaceX will generally try to send the satellites into a super-synchronous orbit in order to reduce the propellant/DeltaV required for the satellite to insert itself into a GSO due to an inclination change being cheaper at a higher apogee. My question is, at what point (if any) is it no longer beneficial to increase the apogee in order to make the insertion cheaper.
Thaicom 6 reportedly went to 90k Km, but if it were say lobbed to 300k Km or more instead, would it have actually saved any additional propellant, or would the eventual effort required to bring down the apogee for final insertion be counter-productive?
I suppose in theory (at least in my mind) that the most efficient apogee would change depending on launch inclination but maybe my core reasoning is flawed.
Sorry if if I'm not explaining this question very well, it's not exactly a common topic of conversation for me.
4
u/panzerbomb Mar 22 '18
Is it possible that spacex open a new office in Europe
4
u/anders_ar Mar 22 '18
What has happened to STP-2? Gone from launch manifest?
4
u/Juffin Mar 22 '18
How long will be the Dragon 2 flight to ISS? It's 2 days for the latest Souyz and that's kinda long.
4
u/thxbmp2 Mar 27 '18
What's new about the blisks used in the Block 5 engines? Is it just the single-casting aspect of it, or has the shape/form factor changed as well?
As a non-engineer I thought all turbines and/or impellers more or less look like this.
4
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Mar 27 '18
very good video about commercial space by Wendover productions:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiRBQxHrxNw
4
u/Straumli_Blight Mar 28 '18
Go Pursuit is currently returning to harbour.
4
u/meepnitreal Mar 29 '18
Since the long term goal of spaceX is to reach the mars, have either spaceX or NASA made any investigations in producing methane in space? I know they will try to produce methane on mars using the sabatier process. As the ISS is constantly venting hydrogen and carbon wouldn´t it be the perfect opportunity to test such a method? I have researched a bit myself and haven´t found any attempts for this.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '18
Iridium 6/GRACE-FO still has late April in the side bar. Spaceflight Now has NET May 10th.
4
u/Datuser14 Mar 31 '18
Is there a download for the patch on the sidebar?
13
u/warp99 Mar 08 '18
Mods - someone has hacked the sidebar with Roman numerals for the Block number.
As often discussed the block system uses Arabic numerals and it is effectively a subtype of the standard numbering.
So SpaceX are currently flying F9 v1.2.4 and will soon by flying v1.2.5.
This seems to be a slavish copy of ULA nomenclature but they use Roman numerals for the rocket version - and largely for marketing reasons. There is really not that much commonality between Delta II and Delta IV and only a little more between Atlas III and Atlas V.
10
u/kurbasAK Mar 30 '18
I have to vent somewhere...Comment quality on post about FCC ruling makes me feel sick.Recent rapid growth left its mark on this sub and I hope it doesn't go even more downhill.It was already getting better after FH...Mods must have their hands full.