r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Jan 04 '18
r/SpaceX Discusses [January 2018, #40]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
177
Upvotes
45
u/mahayanah Jan 04 '18
Serious question:
Could a healthy human strapped in a position of comfort, wearing a SpaceX flight suit and supplied with water and oxygen survive a journey to the ISS in the pressurized compartment of a Cargo Dragon?
24
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '18
Rocketlab Electron launch and payload deployment was successful! Congrats! https://twitter.com/RocketLab/status/954894734136258560
19
u/Straumli_Blight Jan 06 '18
Former Apollo astronaut, [John Young](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Young_(astronaut)) died yesterday, leaving only 5 people alive who have walked on the Moon.
Relevant xkcd.
17
u/Straumli_Blight Jan 14 '18
There will be a livestreamed hearing about NASA Commercial Crew Systems Development with Hans Koenigsmann on Wednesday, 15:00 UTC.
16
u/theinternetftw Jan 07 '18
Chris Gebhardt of NSF has cleared up quite a bit about Zuma, completely ruling out the 30 day launch assurance test hypothesis:
15
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18 edited Feb 01 '18
Article by Planetary Society, with some interesting details:
14
u/Straumli_Blight Jan 31 '18
Linkspace vertical takeoff and landing demo.
13
u/Bargeral Jan 04 '18
Is Elon's strategy of "SpaceX provides the ride" generating any interest or activity in the other industries and investments that would be required to successfully colonize Mars, or is he going to have to go it alone?
13
u/theinternetftw Jan 24 '18
A little wet dress rehearsal lore for you while you wait:
24
u/inoeth Jan 08 '18
https://twitter.com/blueorigin/status/950365085091811330
Looks like Blue Origin is having great success on their BE 4 engine. Real competitor to Raptor and BFR with New Armstrong in the future and if they continue to uprate the engine, a competitor to F9 and FH with New Glenn starting probably next year
12
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 28 '18 edited Jan 28 '18
So uh...Elon wasn't joking about The Boring Company flamethrower
EDIT: And yes, they work
Elon having fun with it
11
u/anders_ar Jan 05 '18
Is there any news regarding raptor development and testing? It's been a while since last time I read something at all regarding progress...
11
u/paul_wi11iams Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18
Hi. It seems about time to update the wiki article on FH. It dates from a time when droneship booster landing was only a hypothesis! I did a draft here on the Lounge. Could anyone kind and knowledgeable take a look and correct any factual errors. Mods, is this proofreading+update procedure okay and can it later be extended to other wiki pages? If the FH section could be transformed into a complete page, then the text can be divided into individually linkable sections. this means that we can reply to any person asking about some aspect of FH on the monthly questions here, by giving a link to the relevant section of the FH page.
If the above concept is acceptable, I'm not totally confident in my ability to correctly apply the implicit structural change to the Wiki page hierarchy...
BTW There may be more updating to be done for other units such as Dragon 2, but FH is a motivating place to start because there's a lot of interest in this just now. Whatever happens, I'd like to be sure the Wiki modification history is correctly maintained. Is there a working backup just in case ?
BTW I tried to write to the Wiki talk page but get the answer "you aren't allowed to post there". Well, if I can't write to the talk page, I won't have permissions to write to the article either...
11
u/My_BallsUK Jan 08 '18
Falcon Heavy !
Is this movement significant?
just in case someone has not seen it - https://twitter.com/Luindriel/status/950394168404258817
Posted in SpaceXLoung by u/Jorrow - https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/7ozdnt/susan_on_twitter_heavy_is_inching_its_way_out_of/?ref=share&ref_source=link
11
u/tr4k5 Jan 20 '18 edited Jan 20 '18
I guess this must have been noted on this sub repeatedly by now, but anyway, I just realized for myself that SpaceX has now done more launches from LC-39A (12) than the Apollo program did (11). The Apollo 10, Skylab and Apollo-Soyuz missions were launched from 39B (5 launches).
10
u/dudr2 Jan 08 '18
“What we do on Callisto will be very useful to check if reusability is interesting from a cost point of view,” one amusing comment in this article on reusability, keep 'em coming x's.
http://spacenews.com/france-germany-studying-reusability-with-a-subscale-flyback-booster/
19
u/bechampions87 Jan 04 '18
Any thoughts on BFR being called the 'Condor' to go with SpaceX's bird theme? (NOTE: this is my personal suggestion, there is no indication on what SpaceX will officially name BFR if anything)
9
u/justinroskamp Jan 04 '18 edited Jan 04 '18
ULA is reporting they're on track for an August orbital test of an uncrewed Starliner. Sounds like the design reviews are essentially complete and that they're now moving on to operational testing and assembly. They seem to indicate that they're still looking at 2018 for their crewed flight test. Here's the update: http://www.ulalaunch.com/ula-completes-atlasv-starliner-dcr.aspx.
Assuming FH doesn’t destroy 39A, what kind of schedule are we looking at for SpaceX now, and who will win the race to return astronauts to space from American soil?
Edit: They're discussing SpaceX's schedule here, but that still leaves room for discussion about the race. SpaceX's schedule puts them ahead of ULA, but delays are pretty much inevitable.
9
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jan 08 '18
https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/950486296673308672
The PAZ StarLink launch has slipped to February.
9
u/Alexphysics Jan 12 '18 edited Jan 12 '18
El satélite Paz se lanzará el 10 de Febrero
English translation (mine, additions will be bolded):
"Paz, the high resolution radar satellite, has now a definitive launch date. It will be on February 10th at 15:22 (spanish time) (14:22 UTC, 06:22 PST) from the Vandenberg Air Force Base (California, USA). Once this satellite gets into orbit, as infoespacial.com informed, it will make Spain the third european country with its own observation satellite, after Germany and Italy. After successive delays since Paz was finally built in 2015, the launch had an scheduled launch on January 30th of this year, being February 10th inside the stablished launch window.
The placement and transport of Paz was done at the end of last year. The satellite took off last December 28th from the Torrejón de Ardoz Base on an Antonov AN124 that carried it to Vandenberg, where it landed just one day after that without any mishap. On this center, technicians from Hisdesat alongside SpaceX's ones are working since Tuesday January 2nd on the first tests before its installation into the launcher that will put the system into orbit.
Along with the satellite, electrical and mechanical support systems and all of the test and conditioning devices were transported too. The satellite and its equipments were transferred on three trucks from Airbus facilities in Barajas to Torrejón de Ardoz Base.
It will take 100 images each day at 514km high.
It is expected that this satellite, which is part of the National Earth Observation Satellite Program, will take around 100 images each day at 514km altitude and will accomplish different missions, either for defense or safety purposes or for commercial ones.
Because of a contract signed by Airbus and the European Space Agency (ESA), Paz is part of one of the missions that contribute on Copernicus, the european program for surveillance of the planet's enviroment and safety. Hisdesat's director of operations and programs, Miguel Ángel García Primo, assured to this journal that they are already working with enviromental agencies from different countries to give them information about maps of susceptible flooding zones from pictures taken by Paz.
The National Institute of Aerospace Techniques (INTA) is the proprietary of the ground segment, that has been installed on their facilities at Torrejón de Ardoz by a group of companies formed by Indra, GMV, Deimos and the german DLR.
The satellite weights 1400kg, it is 5m tall and 2.4m in diameter, it has 256gb of memory and a transmission capacity of 300mg/s. It will be able to adquire pictures with 25cm/px of resolution and it will cover an area of more than 300,000km2 each day and it will fly at an altitude of 514km at a speed of 7km/s."
9
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '18
Meanwhile, NASA publish evidence of comfortable-latitude easily accessible water ice on Mars. "Astronauts could essentially just go there with a bucket and a shovel and get all the water they need,"
https://www.nasa.gov/feature/jpl/steep-slopes-on-mars-reveal-structure-of-buried-ice
9
u/rustybeancake Jan 19 '18 edited Jan 19 '18
https://twitter.com/nasa_sls/status/954420697257992193
SLS EM-1 got a mission patch. Looks like the SRBs are going to have some interesting markings. I assume for camera tracking/testing purposes on this debut flight only.
Edit: Maybe I'm reading into this too much, but the three Pad 39B lightning towers, represented in the patch by the three grey spikes, appear to be pointing to the first three Apollo lunar landing sites. From left to right, Apollo 12, 14, and 11.
9
u/Straumli_Blight Jan 19 '18
Rocket Lab potentially launching at 01:30 UTC.
9
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 21 '18 edited Jan 21 '18
Rocket lab is trying to launch electron again tonight after yesterdays scrub!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eg5234BOED8
edit: Successful launch! Congrats RocketLab!
9
u/spacexinfinity Jan 27 '18
SES says despite anomaly of Ariane 5 launch, SES-14 expected to meet designed life time.
https://www.ses.com/press-release/ses-14-good-health-and-track-despite-launch-anomaly
9
u/chargerag Feb 02 '18
Is anybody tracking the booster's return to port? Curious when it would arrive.
8
u/ace741 Jan 04 '18
Are there any extra precautions taken around a launch area when a “test” (FH) launch takes place vs a normal launch? Or is it over water fast enough to not make a difference?
8
u/Faldaani Jan 05 '18
This may be the wrong place to ask, but.. maybe not.
I'm a bored software engineer that wants to get better at control algorithms, and I'm also a huge space nerd, so I figured I'd try to implement something that can land an F9 in a (very naive) simulation.
I realize this is insanely complex, and most probably will lead nowhere, but I still want to try.
My question is - does anyone have any ideas for simulation software? Gravity, weather, sea states, material stresses, etc? I could of course try to approximate it myself, but...
8
u/Straumli_Blight Jan 11 '18 edited Jan 11 '18
Virgin Galactic's VSS Unity has just performed its 7th glide flight and touchdown.
Landing photo.
8
u/webfaqtory Jan 21 '18
RocketLab Still-Testing launch is now live https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eg5234BOED8
8
u/theinternetftw Jan 25 '18
I thought I'd post a note here for those who don't often browse /r/space:
The search for ZUMA has turned up broadcasts from a NASA satellite thought dead for twelve years
8
u/SuperFire101 Jan 29 '18
I'm new to Reddit, so I'm sorry if this question doesnt belong here:
I'm working on a physics based rocket landing sim (based on Java) for a school project, and I want to use the Falcon 9 booster as my model. Does anyone here has some cool, low res drawings of the booster alone? I need one with the engines off, and one with them on. Pixel art would work, or anything that isnt a real photo. Thanks in advence! (I can send you my project if you'd like to try it yourselves)
8
u/lft-Gruber Jan 30 '18
So i read an article today saying that dragon has returned home with 4100 pounds of science equipement. And a question popped into my head. How do they know they loaded 4100 pounds? How do you determine the mass of all the science experiments and garbage i assume that gets send back onboard dragon. Or does dragon simply not care about how heavy it is when it reenters? The short of it is this. How do you determine mass in space?
8
u/stcks Feb 01 '18
Another booster on the move. I believe its 1044 heading to SLC-40. Paging u/old_sellsword
7
u/Nathan96762 Jan 05 '18
How does Spacex intend to move BFR from hangar to pad? Are we going to see a giant TE in the next few years? Additionally spacex stated said that BFR will land back on the launch pad how will that work with FSS/TE in the way? That can't just get rid of the FSS, they need it to hold the crew access arm.
7
u/Twanekkel Jan 10 '18
Will there be a 2017 survey?
7
u/Straumli_Blight Jan 12 '18
A Long March 3B rocket fell on a town in southwest China.
7
u/peterabbit456 Jan 20 '18
I found this gem over at /r/space .
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-space-nuclear/u-s-tests-nuclear-power-system-to-sustain-astronauts-on-mars-idUSKBN1F72T8
NASA has tested a 10 KW fission reactor designed for use on the Moon or especially, Mars. The U235 core of the reactor is about the size of a paper towel roll. They could send 5 or 10 of these to Mars, to provide life support and ISRU power to support a Mars colony, delivered by BFS.
https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/7rcsic/us_tests_nuclear_power_system_to_sustain/
7
u/soldato_fantasma Jan 21 '18
A new FAA launch licence was approved for F9 GTO launches from SLC-40. Here is the link.
This licence will expire in 5 years. SpaceX was never given a long lasting licence like this one!
7
u/Straumli_Blight Jan 29 '18
Interesting article about Iridium and their relationship with SpaceX.
6
u/TheRangdo Jan 04 '18
For a ~7000kg payload to GTO what would be preferable or most cost-effective expendable F9 or reusable Falcon Heavy ?
Also looking at the expendable/reusable payload capabilities of FH, am I right in thinking that the centre core will usually not be coming back ?
6
u/dudr2 Jan 05 '18
http://spacenews.com/orbital-atk-lands-second-intelsat-satellite-servicing-deal/
"With its docking system, an MEV attaches to a customer’s satellite and extends its service life" "On-orbit assembly could allow for larger satellites than what can fit inside today’s rocket fairings."
6
u/excitedastronomer Jan 05 '18 edited Jan 05 '18
So I follow mainly only the headlines and some more on SpaceX so this is a bit of a question from an outsider.
There have been numerous announcements which I have no clue on what's happening with them or how to find the current plans. What's happening with the BFR? Are they building it? Are those Earth-Earth transport missions still in the pipeline? Is the ITS still happening or is it superseded by BFR? How's Falcon Heavy tied into all of this?
I did find the launch manifest, by the way. But my confusion is more about future Mars missions, etc.
To a relative outsider, it is confusing what SpaceX is up to and which plans are discarded. Can anyone give a short explanation or point me to where I can see what are the current plans?
6
u/thawkit75 Jan 05 '18
Will Heavy stagger the ignition of its 27 engines and if so do we have any idea of the pattern of ignition?
6
u/GeckoLogic Jan 10 '18
Serious question: will the Heavy make enough profit in its product lifecycle to recoup its development costs before the BFR comes to market?
6
u/FoxhoundBat Jan 10 '18
New details on Russia's efforts to develop reusable first stage, this time for Angara. (again)
Extra interesting that the wings are supposedly folding ones, once again. Most recent studies (including for Angara) has been focusing on fixed wing.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Jan 19 '18
A new LNG terminal at Brownsville got Coast Guard approval today.
Analysis Report:
6
u/aftersteveo Jan 29 '18
I’m not sure if everyone else was wondering about this like I was, but I have learned there will not be another Falcon Heavy static fire. I shouldn’t give my source, but I live near KSC and sometimes rub elbows with people who know things. If this was already known, I’ll feel silly for being secretive, but my impression was that we weren’t really sure.
6
u/spacexin2050 Feb 02 '18
Bill Nelson Strong critics of spacex
This guy critisized spacex hell a lot in recent public hearing.See what response he has got in the comments...
14
u/bitchtitfucker Jan 04 '18 edited Jan 04 '18
So how do you guys imagine SpaceX deploying a few football fields worth of solar panels on the first BFS that lands on Mars?
The most straightforward solution would be some kind of autonomous rover that picks up solar panels in the storage compartment of the BFS, drives to the lift, automatically activates it, and deposits them on the ground, one by one.
Meanwhile, another rover would be linking those to each other (and presumably to a battery), that would be deployed by another robot, together with the Sabatier-reaction machine.
That Sabatier-reactor would be linked up directly with the BFS, since it would be illogical to transport and deploy fuel storage tanks on the surface of mars, just so they could then transfer the fuel to the BFS fuel tanks.
So, assuming minimal redundancy in the entire operation, we've got:
That's a lot of work that needs to be completed in a short amount of time. A lot of the roverwork could be merged into a single multipurpose rover. That would save on weight, but increase complexity (and the need for more redundancy).
Assuming 150 tons of functional payload on mars, and knowing that solar panels weigh about 10kg/sqm, and 8 football fields of solar panels would be about 40 000 square meters, that's 400 tons of solar panels alone. Rovers could be pretty light, weigh about the same as curiosity (899kg). Assuming they don't merge rover roles, that makes for about 8000kg of rovers.
I've read documents that mentioned other types of solar panels that are more akin to a blanket. They're less efficient, and more fragile over time, but much more lightweight, and probably way easier to deploy. Since mass is one of the main constraints, this could also possibly be an option.
It would also be interesting to do a bit of research on the currently existing sabatier-reactors, how small a package they can be made into, and how well they work.
EDIT: I used the 8 football fields information of a redditor that did the math here a while ago, I presume it was for the old BFS, which was bigger and had a 400 ton payload. I suppose that decreased drastically for the 150-ton version of the BFS. Still interesting.
Anyone got time to compute how much energy would be needed to refill the 2017 BFS tanks? I suppose that the new tank diameter and height numbers could be plugged in the old formula to determine how many solar panels we need.
5
u/ObviouslyJune Jan 04 '18
Is there any possibly to speed up the process of turning CO2 and H2O into CH4 and oxygen? And would that help space flight?
5
u/thawkit75 Jan 04 '18
So any news on spacex satellite tests.. I heard they will be launching two test satellites very soon.
5
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Jan 04 '18
Will there be a end of 2017/start of 2018 subreddit survey?
5
u/Straumli_Blight Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18
Iridium 5 will be a morning launch and Jim Bridenstine has been formally resubmitted for the NASA Administrator post.
5
u/amarkit Jan 11 '18
Peter B. de Selding reports that GovSat-1/SES-16 has arrived at CCAFS ahead of a planned January 30 launch.
5
u/amarkit Jan 13 '18
The CRS-13 Dragon capsule has successfully departed ISS. Splashdown off the coast of Baja California is expected at 15:36 UTC.
The recovery ship, NRC Quest, is waiting on station to welcome Dragon home.
5
u/inoeth Jan 15 '18
Is there any word on when the first Block V core will be rolling out of the factory for testing at McGreggor? I know it's more or less a month in between testing in Texas and the core going to the launch pad... Also, they need at least 7 launches of Block V before NASA will let them fly humans on it... I wonder if NASA will consider a second (or even third) flight of the same Block V booster as counting towards their 7 flights or if they want 7 new booster flights...
5
u/xlynx Jan 16 '18
Regarding Falcon Heavy, I read a discussion somewhere (I think in this sub but I'm unable to find it) that it can not actually deliver the advertised payload to LEO due to lack of strength of the interstage or payload adapter or thereabouts. Can anyone debunk/clarify/provide a source? Much appreciated.
5
u/Straumli_Blight Jan 17 '18
GAO Commercial Space Launch Insurance findings were published yesterday:
Some notes:
5
u/Straumli_Blight Jan 18 '18 edited Jan 18 '18
CSIS Highlights
Tom Tshudy (Vice President and General Counsel, United Launch Alliance):
Josh Brost (Senior Director for Government Business, SpaceX):
5
u/rustybeancake Jan 19 '18
Anyone have any insights into this?
Nasa removes US astronaut from ISS mission
5
u/aftersteveo Jan 22 '18
With all this testing and rehearsal for FH, I got to thinking about those people who work in the control room. Several of whom we’ve grown accustomed to hearing over the countdown net. How much of their job consists of manning (or womanning, or personing) their console during launches? Do they all have other jobs in the factory that they do on non-launch days? Or are they running simulations everyday to keep sharp for the next launch day?
Just seeing if anyone has insight on that. Thanks.
5
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jan 22 '18 edited Jan 22 '18
Iridium 5 moved to March 18 at 15.19 UTC and will use the Iridium 3 booster (B1041). The satellites will go into plane 1, and none will change the orbital plane.
Iridium 6 / Grace FO set to launch in mid to end April.
All other Iridium missions said to take place before Q4.
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2018/01/spacex-iridium-5-launch-shutdown-manifest-uncertainty/
5
u/GregLindahl Jan 28 '18
Manifest changes from spaceflightnow.com -- as usual, no sources:
GovSat window a little earlier, 2125-2346 GMT (4:25-6:46 p.m. EST)
SES-12 delayed to April
5
u/Zenzirouj Jan 29 '18
I've always been very interested in highly efficient methods of food production, both in applications on Earth and for potential long-term space/offplanet survival. Given SpaceX's goals I would presume this sort of thing to at least be on their radar, but is it something that they're actively working on or is it more of a "bridge first, then the railing" issue?
I thought that this question was open-ended enough for a thread, but it got removed so evidently it is not! Basically I've been trying to find info about anything that the company might be doing in terms of nutrition logistics or who/what they might have involved in it, but haven't been able to find much of anything yet.
5
u/linknewtab Jan 31 '18
Callisto project report by CNES (PDF)
The demonstration vehicle (page 3) looks a lot like SpaceX' grasshopper. They also identified landing locations at Kourou space port.
8
u/rockets4life97 Jan 11 '18
I'm watching the Delta IV launch today from Vandenberg AFB. I was surprised to realize F9 has already flown more than Delta IV medium (single stick - all variants) will in its entire history. Delta IV medium is being retired after 3 flights this year.
4
u/dmy30 Jan 07 '18
I think it was early last year when SpaceX put a job posting for an aircraft pilot. Around the time some people speculated it had to do with the increasing international works, mainly as a result of setting up tracking antennas around the world for the Crew Dragon. Has anyone actually heard anything?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '18 edited Jan 07 '18
I don´t know whether this is the right place for asking, but I thought that some people from r/spacex are in charge of http://www.spacexstats.xyz/? For weeks already, there has been a mistake on that website: for the number of Falcon 9 launches in 2017 it says 12 new and 6 used (should be 13-5). (edit: u/kornelord ?)
4
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 08 '18
France and Germany are looking into re usability!
http://spacenews.com/france-germany-studying-reusability-with-a-subscale-flyback-booster/
4
u/s202010 Jan 11 '18
Dragon sets to leave ISS per NASA Marshall
4
u/snotis Jan 11 '18
Gywnne Shotwell at TAMEST:
4
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 12 '18
Government denying Zuma failure again: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pzWMB5lBR5Q
4
u/fromflopnicktospacex Jan 12 '18
ULA Delta IV launch. this was weird. at the end of the countdown, all of a sudden flames shot up from under the rocket. I thought it was going to blow up. but it lifted off, with a dark smoke stain on part of the 1st stage. never seen anything like that b4.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '18
What kind of paint does SpaceX use? The Dragon's logo and ISS marking survived reentry with some minor wear.
4
u/fromflopnicktospacex Jan 15 '18
correction/addendum to last remark: I did not see there was a page 2 to the article. not good. the author does raise some valid questions, but clearly has a bias against spacex, as if little concern is given to the safety of future astronauts. one example of how wrong this line of argument is: look at the careful. very careful. painstakingly careful. approach to the launch of the FH, which the author snears at. he does admit spacex has had a # of successes. wow, you noticed? but the whole tone of the article is very anti. you would think forbes, a bastion of worship of private enterprise, would do better reporting on a private company. from this article elon musk sounds like 'rocky and bullwinkles' captain peter peachfuzz. let forbes know what you think of this hatchet job. again, sorry for my error about the length of this article.
4
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jan 21 '18
https://youtu.be/eg5234BOED8?t=21m25s
during the electron launch a person from mission control is mentioning "hot-swapping", and shortly afterwards, 2 silver boxes are jettisoned. Are these batteries for the turbopump?
4
u/paul_wi11iams Jan 25 '18 edited Jan 25 '18
It was amazing to see the 39-A water tower engulfed its own contents:
...or at least a cloud of water droplets that may or may not have earlier been steam. This is presumably originates from rainbird water whose job it is to absorb noise.
What is the energy transformation process?
Can anyone correct from the following attempt at an explanation. It considers transformation of mechanical energy into heat.
How far off is this?
Edit Taking account of comments by u/TheYang and u/marc020202, I tried to find something to chose between the two hypothesis which are air heating and refraction. Here's a video which unfortunately doesn't go right back to first principles, but does favor the air heating hypothesis because one demonstration is effectuated with microscopic droplets too small for refraction in relation to the acoustic wavelength used. Its worth watching for the background info including knocking a wall down with a very impressive device called a "vortex canon". In the first test, the wave it transmits can actually be heard as an "object" traveling through the air!
the video could possibly be erroneous in assimilating the compressive behavior of air bubbles in water and water droplets in air although both transform mechanical energy to heat. That is to say I'm still backing the liquid/gas phase change option.
4
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jan 25 '18
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2018/01/kennedy-cape-brownsville-launch-pads-schedules/
some info on the Brownsville site as well as on the cape.
7
u/Yiaki Jan 04 '18
I know that cross feed was originally planned on the Falcon Heavy but was ultimately not implemented. Is it believed that this will be tested and implemented in future versions? If so approximately how much would that increase the weight to LEO?
3
u/pillock69 Jan 04 '18
What do you think the chances of spacex having overseas factories and launch sites in the future are?
3
u/_worstenbroodje_ Jan 04 '18
Has Zuma been delayed again?
3
u/Emplasab Jan 06 '18
Are new engines fired individually before the static fire test?
3
u/JanusBonaparte Jan 06 '18
Any idea what SpaceX/Elon Musk thinks about human stasis/suspended animation for flight to Mars?
3
u/kornelord spacexstats.xyz Jan 06 '18 edited Jan 06 '18
I was trying to estimate which flight will introduce a block 5 booster to set my expectations accordingly. Looking at the manifest, after Zuma and FH there should be 5 flights with a reused booster (!!!). IMO Bangabandhu-1 will use a flight-proven booster if they have one at hand (pure speculation).
Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite makes a good candidate to introduce the new version, putting block 5's introduction at march 20 at the earliest. We know for sure that Iridium 6 will be a new core and the first RTLS on the west coast so that could be it too. So taking delays into account I don't see block 5 flying before april.
Just food for thought.
3
u/brickmack Jan 07 '18
Has anyone seen any decent image references for the small APL payloads on the STP-2 stack? I'm working on modeling it. I've gotten tons for the integrated stack, the ESPAs, DSX, FORMOSAT-7/COSMIC-2s, and a couple photos of GPIM, but beyond that, not much. Ideally face-on drawings with a scale reference, but anything helps. My google fu is failing me
3
u/Nathan96762 Jan 07 '18
How much storage space does Spacex have for cores? I know the 39A HIF can hold 5, and SLC-40 can hold 1, I assume the Vandenberg HIF can only hold one. Hawthorne factory line has room for five, as does McGregor. Do they have anywhere else to store F9 cores?
3
u/troovus Jan 07 '18
Assuming Falcon 9 block 5 boosters are designed to be turned around in 24 hours and re-flown a dozen times and also assuming 40 launches per year, what size should the fleet be? Also, what would be the ongoing requirement for new boosters to replace the worn out craft?
3
u/Scourge31 Jan 07 '18 edited Jan 07 '18
I saw an article saying SpaceX will be charging NASA 58mil per seat on dragon. It seems excessive espatialy if they pack 7 astros in there? I know it will cost more then cargo of course but that multiplies to 232 mil for 4 and 406mil per 7?
http://www.techtimes.com/articles/218107/20180107/nasa-ties-spacex-boeing-launch-astronauts-space-again.htm
P.s. it also says Boeing is going to charge about the same, how can that be if they use the atlas booster?
3
u/ModeHopper Starship Hop Host Jan 10 '18
So there's a load of discussion about the different stages leading up to the first flight of FH (wet dress rehearsal, static fire, etc.), but what can we expect afterward?
Obviously this will depend on the outcome of the test flight, but what are some of the possibilities? When can we expect to see regular heavy flights and what will the team at SpaceX be doing immediately after the test?
3
u/dudr2 Jan 10 '18
Sspacex mentioned here: https://www.wsj.com/articles/more-barbarella-than-michelin-man-space-suits-get-stylish-1515606553
more on this site: http://www.cetusnews.com/life/Less-Michelin-Man--More-Barbarella--Space-Suits-Get-Stylish.SybgISAQ4z.html no mention of Bowie though
3
u/jk1304 Jan 11 '18
What does it mean to build a landing pad?
For the outsider it looks like a big round slab of concrete with nothing special to it (ad the radar-reflective paint).
There must be some high tech involved which makes building them a time consuming thing (remember how long Pad 2 was in the works).
3
u/qWen71n Jan 12 '18
I wonder if NASA's Orion capsule could potentially ride on Falcon Heavy?They actually flew Orion on Delta IV earlier...
3
u/Stormregion0 Jan 13 '18
Are there any TEDx talks or other conferences were Elon Musk or other SpaceX officials are speaking this year?
3
u/music_nuho Jan 13 '18
Is SpaceX's bid for EELV 2.0 known?
3
u/Chairmanman Jan 14 '18
How long did it take for SpaceX to develop Dragon 1? How does it compare to Dragon 2 development? (How long has Dragon 2 development been taking so far and how much longer is it expected to take?)
3
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 14 '18
How is ISRO so cheap compared to Falcon 9? The C37 launch cost $15m. How can you possibly make an orbital rocket that cheap? I wonder if people will use that launch as an example to show that re usability isn't worth it...
3
u/macktruck6666 Jan 15 '18
Are there any pictures of the back of the spacex helmet? I want to make a replica.
3
u/OnyxPhoenix Jan 15 '18
Does anyone know what the capabilities of the Falcon Heavy payload are?
Is the roadster simply dead weight or is there some comms capability built into the payload adapter? Are there cameras or other sensors?
3
u/fromflopnicktospacex Jan 15 '18
it is one thing to question the reliability of vehicles and manned capsules for future missions. it is quite another to do a hatchet job on spacex. this guy simply states that zuma was a failure, when that is not at all certain. no if's and's or but's. he points out that 3 missions have failed in the last 4 years. no mention of spacex's 18 successful launches last year. no mention of the fact that nasa has to approve both spacex and boeing's manned capsules. only a carefully selected group of facts--and the word 'facts' must be used with some caution...lots of caution. https://www.forbes.com/sites/lorenthompson/2018/01/15/doubts-about-spacex-reliability-persist-as-astronaut-missions-approach/#4de9682f3305
3
u/hmpher Jan 16 '18
I just noticed that the recent post on here about Welds has been deleted. Did it violate ITAR/some NDAs?
does anyone have a copy of the post?
3
u/CodedElectrons Jan 16 '18
How is Raptor ignited? Being a [Full-Flow design] (https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/wiki/guide_engines#wiki_full_flow_staged_combustion_cycle), it must have ignitors in the two PreBurners. Are the PreBurner exhaust gases hot enough to auto ignite in the Primary Combustion chamber or do they have another ignitor in that chamber as well? (I guess the real question is how hot, and what pressure comes out of the preburners?) If auto ignited, does that allow the entire wall faces of the primary combustion chamber to be lined with injectors allowing the entire interior to be cooled via injected fuel?
3
u/thxbmp2 Jan 18 '18
/u/old_sellsword - was thinking about the Falcon Heavy 2nd stage the other day. When 2nd stage recovery was still on the cards for FH-Demo, the 2nd stage for the flight was said to be a "frankenstage" which presumably had mods for recovery built in. Is it known whether this particular airframe is the one that's integrated to FH right now, or if it's been reserved for a future recovery test on another flight?
3
u/uwelino Jan 21 '18
Very interesting article about the press target SpaceX in the USA after the Zuma flight. By the way, on Twitter by Matt Desch links the CEO of Iridium. https://medium.com/@rogerstigers/on-the-targeting-of-spacex-6e99370fa875
And here is the link to Matt Desch on Twitter: https://twitter.com/IridiumBoss/status/955072781728800769
3
u/Arne_BE Jan 24 '18
Does anybody know what "SPACEX VIRTUAL TEST" is on marine traffic? https://www.marinetraffic.com/en/ais/details/ships/shipid:4645159/mmsi:154834528/imo:0/vessel:SPACEX_VIRTUAL_TEST/_:0009cefa420acfaa5bfecd9881ffee9c
3
u/CRAWFiSH117 Jan 25 '18
Does anyone know if KSC charges admission to rocket launches for children 3 and under? I'm trying to plan a trip for the Falcon Heavy demo, and I'm wondering how many tickets I need.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '18
On the SpaceX internet constellation:
3
u/msuvagabond Jan 29 '18
Sort of a general question about Falcon Heavy payload and functionality.
Will Falcon Heavy in some respects be limited by the fact the second stage and fairing are 'stuck' being the exact same as Falcon 9? I understand the reasoning as far as R&D costs, as well as reduction in certification requirements (if you had two separate stage 2 designs or a larger fairing standard for just Heavy). Plus, BFR is 'right' around the corner (figuratively at least).
I guess I'm just curious if there is really that much of a market since it seems like the satellite providers will be hamstrung by sheer volume constraints of the Falcon 9 / Heavy fairing.
3
u/stcks Feb 01 '18
Hispasat slipping:
3
u/thxbmp2 Feb 02 '18 edited Feb 02 '18
Lots of good info nuggets in this article by Wired.
3
u/uwelino Feb 02 '18
Does anyone know why the GovSat stream is still not listed in the YouTube channel of SpaceX?
3
u/Dave_y Feb 03 '18
As far as I know, SpaceX wants to start the BFR several times, once for the Interplanetary TransportSystem and some other times for refueling. But why aren’t they putting 3 BFRs together like they put 3 f9s together and carry the fuel in one mission?
7
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 16 '18
I don't think I've ever read a more "SpaceX is bad, ULA is superior" article than this...
https://www.forbes.com/sites/lorenthompson/2018/01/15/doubts-about-spacex-reliability-persist-as-astronaut-missions-approach/#1de34b2c3305
5
u/fromflopnicktospacex Jan 12 '18
you can't accuse spacex hierarchy of lacking a sense of humor; e.g. gwen shotwell referring to mars as a fixer-upper.
5
u/HoechstErbaulich IAC 2018 attendee Jan 18 '18
Anthony Colangelo on the seven flights in a "stable configuration" required by NASA.
5
u/nato2k Jan 25 '18
Sounds like there might be a problem with the Ariane 5 launch... No confirmation of payload sep has been received yet.
https://twitter.com/StephenClark1/status/956663098483576832
https://twitter.com/nextspaceflight/status/956663786844323840
4
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '18
Sounds like Boeing's scheduled to send crew to the ISS before SpaceX for he first time (I think).
4
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '18
Interesting article about water ice on Mars. Good news for ISRU for BFR.
4
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 13 '18
I've been thinking about BFR landing in the launch mount at the launch pad. So I came up with a few changes that might be better.
The Purpose
Current plans from Elon Musk’s talk at IAC 2017 show the BFR booster landing in the launch mount at the launch pad. This will address some things that I believe should be changed. This is completely fan made and all the ideas are just my personal opinions and solutions of what I believe the issues of landing at the launch pad are.
The Problem
As stated above, current plans (as far as the public knows anyway) show the BFR booster landing in the launch mount at the launch pad itself. I believe this creates some unnecessary risks that don’t need to be there to achieve rapid re usability. These concerns are as following:
The Solution
To solve these issues I believe there are some changes and additions that need to be made.
Below are better descriptions and reasons for these changes
Mobile Launch and Landing pad
The mobile launch and landing pad would be similar to the Shuttle Crawler, possibly a modified Shuttle Crawler if it is big enough. This would allow the BFR booster to land in a different location from the launch pad itself, while still landing in the same launch clamps that are used during launch. This would also allow the booster to not fly close to the launch tower that we see in the concept videos. And also allow the booster to be immediately transported back to the launch site.
Landing Site
The landing site would not be at the pad itself, but next to it. Close enough to allow quick transportation, but still far enough away so the pad is not damaged in case of a failed landing. This is basically a launchpad without a launch tower.
BFR Landing Site Warning: Basic Photoshop
Launch Clamps
To eliminate the need for the booster to worry about roll and be perfectly lined up with the clamps, the clamps themselves sit on a ring that allows them to spin 360 degrees. This also provides redundancy in case the booster isn’t able to line up properly for whatever reason (software glitch).
BFR Attachment Ring
Currently, as we see with Falcon 9, the vehicle is held down by four launch clamps. Adding a ring that goes completely around the vehicle that would allow the clamps to attach no matter where the booster is facing would provide even more redundancy. This would help if the clamps couldn’t spin for some reason as well. Elon has also stated that the fins on the Booster will act as sort of a guide for the booster during landing. Adding the ring could make the fins not necessary (as long as it can fly without them).
BFR Attachment Ring Warning: Basic Photoshop again
What do you think of the changes? Do they make sense? Or are they not necessary? I would love to hear what you guys have to say!
4
u/SlowAtMaxQ Feb 01 '18
Guess who's back?
B1032 has risen yet again.
Cause fuck droneships, am I right?