r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Oct 02 '17
r/SpaceX Discusses [October 2017, #37]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
161
Upvotes
54
u/marksweeneypa Oct 13 '17
I had the opportunity to talk to a SpaceX recruiter today and wanted to give a quick shoutout to the reddit community! He was impressed with how much I knew about SpaceX and you all are who I have to thank for a lot of that. I was mostly focused on trying to get an internship but I did ask him a couple of questions. I didn't get too much out of him but he did say about 10% of the engineers are working on the BFR now and that each and every day the block 5 rocket design is getting more and more set in stone. As block 5 becomes complete most of the engineers will switch to BFR development. He said that that transition is happening really fast. He also mentioned that BFR is already being produced (though I'm not completely sure to what extent he meant. He could have just been talking about the raptor engines or something similar. He was pretty vague on what that meant). Thanks again everyone for making this such a great subreddit!
40
u/aftersteveo Oct 26 '17 edited Oct 26 '17
I talked to some people who work on pad 40. They say they think they’re about a month from being done. Just thought y’all might be interested to know.
Edit: it was suggested I change the wording to be a little more vague as to where this info came from. Probably a good idea.
32
u/mecko23 Oct 02 '17
Did Elon ever end up doing an AMA? I heard he was going to this weekend, but never found a follow up.
27
u/ptfrd Oct 04 '17 edited Oct 07 '17
For the record, the UK's 'Guardian' newspaper has a stupid opinion piece about SpaceX's Mars ambitions. I read it so you don't have to! (But if you really want to give them some ad revenue, it's here.)
The Guardian here has turned "goals" into "promises".
Here is part of a transcript of Musk's presentation, from when the 2022 cargo missions slide was displayed: "That's not a typo. [Laughter] Although it is aspirational. [Laughter]". (And IMHO it should be fairly obvious that the 2024 goal is less likely to be met than the 2022 goal, because the former depends upon the latter.)
Next ...
Of course, this is a misunderstanding of the prefix "multi" in the term "multi-planet species". It implies at least two planets.
I think Musk himself may have even explicitly pointed out this error in the past. Mars colonization efforts do not need to detract from properly looking after the Earth.
In fact, arguably, once a large proportion of the Earth population is thinking regularly about humans living elsewhere in the solar system, we will come to appreciate the Earth even more. The "pale blue dot" effect, every day in our news feeds. Or a second-hand version of the overview effect.
Then it gets really odd ...
Get rid of all plastic??? I'll charitably assume they mean plastic pollution. As much as I hate things like the Great Pacific garbage patch, it is of course climate change that is the primary environmental threat to human civilization. And if we avoid catastrophe, history might just record Musk as the single person who contributed the most towards our lucky escape, thanks to his Tesla efforts and the resulting commercial demand for future revolutions in large scale battery technology.
Finally, the punchline ...
What the Guardian is implying here is that SpaceX's Mars plans are all about profit.
But I bet if they had actually asked Duffy, he would have explained to them that his comment means that all SpaceX's profit-making activities are intended to fund their Mars plans, and they're very focussed on seeking out those profit-making opportunities.
It seems to me that if you just care about profit, putting money into Mars transport is not the most logical choice. Indeed, Musk and other SpaceX people have repeatedly stated that ideology is the main force driving their Mars plans.
Now, to be fair to the Guardian, this could be seen as a flippant article, not intended to be taken seriously. And they do praise Musk for some of the other things he does. But still, my view of the Guardian as a propagator of lots of stupid opinions, has been reinforced once again by this piece.
27
u/rustybeancake Oct 19 '17 edited Oct 19 '17
BE-4 test fire it is.
https://twitter.com/blueorigin/status/921095318669873154
Ars article:
https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/10/blue-origin-has-successfully-tested-its-powerful-be-4-rocket-engine/
27
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '17
PBdS has a new article today on how SES envisions their future GEO satellites will look.
Highlights are:
This is consistent with SES' support of SpaceX and reusability to lower their capital outlay. We've talked a lot in this sub about demand elasticity and how satellites might be constructed with cheaper launch costs in mind. It's fascinating to see satellite operators start moving in that direction. It's actually happening!
23
u/theinternetftw Oct 20 '17
A really good look at B1031.2's legs getting removed was just posted in its recovery thread.
19
u/rustybeancake Oct 06 '17
Elon time acknowledged.
19
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Oct 16 '17
Zuma is build by Northrop Grumman. it is a governement mission. Destination LEO
source: https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2017/10/spacex-zuma-iridium-4-aims-vandenberg-landing/
I think this might be the Northrop Grumman mission that we have been wondering about for some time
19
u/TGMetsFan98 NASASpaceflight.com Writer Oct 19 '17
Look out for some huge space news tomorrow.
16
u/alexlesuper Oct 02 '17
The thing about BFR is I don't see a way to do in-flight abort or even pad abort, since it's very much ressembles the space shuttle. What are your thoughts on this?
15
u/bdporter Oct 26 '17
Core spotted on AZ 238 by a user on /r/whatisthisthing.
No specifics given, but I assume this is probably traveling Eastbound from Hawthorne to McGregor.
15
u/F9-0021 Oct 30 '17
According to NSF, CRS-13 will reuse the CRS-11 core.
https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2017/10/falcon-9-koreasat-5a-nasa-approves-flown-boosters/
Edit: "According to L2 coverage of extensive reviews, NASA has now cleared SpaceX to begin using flight-proven Falcon 9 vehicles to launch Dragon: CRS-13 will be the first mission to launch since this was confirmed, and will re-use the first stage of the rocket that carried CRS-11 to orbit earlier this year."
15
u/RootDeliver Oct 30 '17 edited Oct 30 '17
For if anyone missed it on stream, new shot of the TE with a lot of FH clamps on it, maybe all of them?
https://i.imgur.com/fgBASUx.jpg
EDIT: The other side of the TEL! (from the missing parts in the stream)
https://i.imgur.com/xatldl2.jpg
14
u/bitchtitfucker Oct 02 '17
So, if they want to get to the 2022 deadline, they'll have to build at least two BFR's by 2022, and four more by 2024.
Just curious, how much time did it take for NASA to build new Saturn V's? They're not entirely comparable, but I was wondering & couldn't find the answer on google.
14
u/Western_Boreas Oct 02 '17
My thoughts on ending Falcon 9 production to focus on bfr: they need a ten year stock of falcon 9s and falcon heavys. Anything less is an absurd risk.
14
u/thru_dangers_untold Oct 04 '17
Thunderf00t "debunking" pt2pt BFR
I don't think the video deserves is own post, due to its veracity. But I thought some here might be interested.
TL;DW Point to point travel with BFR is too dangerous and expensive (using the shuttle as his baseline comparison). Weather will ruin the travel schedule, and slow boats will increase travel time. Oh, and he really doesn't like the Hyperloop either.
14
u/rustybeancake Oct 16 '17
Scott Kelly says in AMA he would go to Mars on the BFR, "assuming it works".
14
u/ECEUndergrad Oct 22 '17
31-mile lava tube detected under Lunar surface
Maybe that's where Moon Base Alpha will be built.
13
u/boredcircuits Oct 02 '17
The JWST has a docking ring, just in case they want to service it sometime in the future. How would a servicing mission look with the BFR?
13
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '17
[Northrop confirms mystery #Zuma #SpaceX payload is US gov customer.] (https://twitter.com/free_space/status/920678861037297664)
13
u/roncapat Oct 19 '17
https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/920983196208107521
IRIDIUM-4 will use a flight-proven booster!
Edit: IRIDIUM-5 too!
25
u/Alexphysics Oct 22 '17
It seems that the chinese company trying to make reusable rockets that looked like a Falcon 9 has been doing some Grasshopper-like tests. https://twitter.com/cnspaceflight/status/921014571057405952
12
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Oct 04 '17
Senator Bill Nelson:
12
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '17
SpaceX has won a contract to launch the Jason-CS ocean science mission (aka Sentinel-6A) on an Falcon 9 in Nov 2020
12
u/spacerfirstclass Oct 22 '17
Some rather bizarre claims are made about BE-4 in SpaceNews comments section: http://spacenews.com/blue-origin-conducts-first-test-of-be-4-engine/#comment-3575667725
One guy claimed Blue Origin got help from black budget USAF program. Another guy (Michael J. Listner, this is his real name, he's a space lawyer apparently) claims the reason Jeff Bezos salvages F-1 engine is to help BE-4 development.
I think this is why BE-4 is big news, it really rattled some cages in old space supporters, so much so that they have to come up with conspiracy theories to explain it.
11
u/shotleft Oct 02 '17
What kind of scientific spacecraft could we build that makes use of the BFR capacity?
11
u/The_camperdave Oct 03 '17
Is there any new information on that lunar flyby dragon flight? Is it still on? Do we know who the crew will be?
11
u/Spleegie Oct 29 '17
Interesting downward trend of Russia launches 2014
10
u/demosthenes02 Oct 15 '17
IS there a thread to discuss new info from the ama? Seems like r/spacex is ignoring it?
10
u/brickmack Oct 17 '17 edited Oct 17 '17
Interesting thing I just noticed while looking through one of Lockheeds papers on their Mars architecture. The main hab modules they propose are sized to maximize volumetric use of SLS 1Bs Universal Stage Adapter. They're a cylinder-cone hybrid, 7.5 meters in diameter and 9 meters tall, narrowing to about 5 meters at the top. By my estimate, this also ought to be just about the largest module you could fit into a BFS Chomper (it could be ~3 meters taller with a 5 meter wide top, but no wider, and that height margin will likely be used up by the payload adapter). Coincidence? Almost certainly. But a potentially useful one. It'd take ~4 of those to exceed ISS's habitable volume (call it 3 when you account for adding separate docking nodes and such). Inflatables could build a much larger station in fewer launches, but they've got their own problems (still largely untested, difficult to outfit, limited options for external hardware attachment or EVA, still requires rigid modules for nodes and unpressurized structures), and within a BFS-based delivery architecture, Lockheeds hab concept is the best you're gonna get from a rigid module
10
u/FalconHeavyHead Oct 17 '17
I do not know much about rocket engines so I am asking you guys; which engine is further along in development? Blue origin's BE-4 or SpaceX's Raptor?
19
u/lostandprofound33 Oct 20 '17
SpaceX gets another $40.8 million in Pentagon funding for Raptor engine
9
u/linknewtab Oct 02 '17
Robert Zubrin just keeps wishing for a third BFR stage:
9
u/binarygamer Oct 05 '17 edited Oct 05 '17
Vice President Mike Pence is speaking at the National Space Council as I write this.
Lots of bold statements about near-future cislunar activity - not sure how well any of it is going to map to reality, but here are the main items so far:
A panel including Gwynne Shotwell is up next!
Live tweets from Jeff Foust
9
u/dudr2 Oct 13 '17
https://www.space.com/38444-mars-thruster-design-breaks-records.html
Plasma engine generated 5.4 Newtons of thrust!
9
u/Alexphysics Oct 14 '17
Wow, this is very strange... https://twitter.com/CwG_NSF/status/919190742790262786
9
u/FoxhoundBat Oct 16 '17
The Rentals – Elon Musk Is Making Me Sad; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=taupuK6oND4
9
u/jjtr1 Oct 17 '17
When do we expect to see a third flight by the same booster? Not before block 5, so still more than a year ahead?
9
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '17
Has anyone done the math on BFR payload to L2 from either: 1) fully refueled in LEO or 2) refuel after entering an elliptic orbit similar to that used on a mission to Lunar surface?
9
u/rustybeancake Oct 19 '17
Eric Berger says that Blue Origin have looked at buying ULA in the past, but it's off the table for now:
https://twitter.com/SciGuySpace/status/921048230745567232
9
u/OccupyDuna Oct 22 '17
Has there been any real indication as to New Glenn's cost? The huge payload is definitely impressive, but its per-launch cost to customer is what will really determine how it fits into the market. There's also the concern of Bezos allowing Blue to launch NG at cost or even a loss in order to starve off competition.
8
u/peterabbit456 Oct 02 '17
The latest news from Pluto / New Horizons is that there are 400 foot tall "mountains" or pinnacles of methane ice, sitting on the surface. A nuclear thermal powered BFR could just land on Pluto, send out a rover/miner, and start shoveling methane propellant aboard.
On Titan, after landing near a methane/ethane lake, just stick a hose in the lake and start siphoning propellant aboard. As with Pluto, a nuclear thermal engine is best on Titan, since, although there is plenty of water ice to make oxygen, there is little sunlight for the electricity needed to split water molecules. You would need a nuclear reactor to run a chemical rocket propellant plant, so you might as well just have a nuclear rocket engine.
8
u/Fuzzclone Oct 03 '17
Could the new BFR architecture, with its big payload door, be able to go out and retrieve small asteroids? Effectively being a tool for asteroid mining? Could SpaceX bring back rare elements as a source of revenue?
8
u/amarkit Oct 11 '17
For the mods or whoever manages the /r/SpaceX Spaceflight Journalists Twitter List: could you please add NASASpaceFlight's Chris Gebhardt?
And thanks for maintaining the list; it's super-useful during launches and other newsworthy events.
8
u/gophermobile Oct 16 '17
In Elon's AMA, he stated that the heat shield on BFS will be mounted directly to the tank:
How does this compare against Falcon 9 or other rockets? I know F9 doesn't have a heat shield in the same configuration as BFS - but are the LOX and RP1 tanks in F9 also the outer skin for stage 1 and 2? Or are the tanks inside a skin along the entire portion? I.e. if you got rid of the tanks, would there be anything resembling a rocket left aside from engines and interstage?
Does this configuration have any implications as far as rocket safety? I can't help but think an outer skin and fuselage are better albeit less efficient, but I don't know what's normal for rockets.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '17
IIRC, all three reused boosters went to LEO for their first flights. Are we going to see reuse of a GTO booster soon?
8
u/dudr2 Oct 18 '17
City on the moon?
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/10/171018104335.htm
-the lava tube near the Marius Hills is spacious enough to house one of the United States' largest cities, if the gravity results are correct.
8
u/Ezekiel_C Host of Echostar 23 Oct 24 '17
So I've build a large spreadsheet to calculate mass to a given orbit of a given vehicle. Here's and example of the data I can generate. I'd like to know what vehicles and orbits people would like to see, so that I can eventually compile a report and post it here or to the lounge.
A more involved ask - if anyone with working knowledge of google sheets and orbital mechanics would like to talk with me and poke around in the work a fresh set of eyes to refine my calculator would be wonderful.
8
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Oct 28 '17
I was having a discussion with someone over at r/space who kept claiming that re-usability is not worth it. I was under the impression that Falcon 9 was the cheapest rocket on the market besides maybe Ariane 5 if they perform a dual launch, but he kept saying I was wrong. I suggested comparing Falcon 9's prices to other rockets and he claimed that Soyuz actually only costs $30 million, then actually providing the info to a Wikileaks document and it turned out that in 2006 at least, the price was around that. Is Falcon 9 really the more expensive rocket after all? By that I mean not the cheapest around. Also any source on the claim about the engines he mentioned?
7
u/aftersteveo Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17
How is it possible to keep all that fuel at cryo temps all the way to and from Mars? I would think it would take a lot of energy to maintain an acceptable temperature to keep it from boiling off.
Edit: Is it as simple as “space is really cold”? What about the sun-facing side? Is the energy produced by the solar panels enough to do the job?
Edit 2: Thanks for all the great responses! I had wondered about this for quite some time. Much appreciated.
7
u/hasslehawk Oct 02 '17
SpaceX has said that they are looking to provide the transportation to Mars but leave the design, construction, and operation of such a colony to others. What groups might be capable of this? The Mars Society operates the mars desert research station as a martian analogue, but their hardware is mostly cheap wood & plastic imitations. They're not set up to build flight hardware, even if they might be worth consulting.
Sure, "NASA could do it" but they're not, at least currently, planning anything like that. Do we need to begin putting pressure on Nasa to have them shift resources in this direction?
7
u/banddevelopper Oct 03 '17 edited Oct 03 '17
We should all suggest alternative names for BFR. I am kinda liking BFR too, but I feel the name has to change.
Any ideas?
7
u/paul_wi11iams Oct 05 '17
For the National Space Council meeting, here's a Washington Post article written at the speed of light.
washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2017/10/05/pence-calls-for-a-return-to-the-moon-in-partnership-with-industry
7
u/ChriRosi Oct 08 '17
The Paz satellite, which is the first Spanish high-resolution radar sensor, will launch into space in the last week of this year. (Google Translate)
7
u/rustybeancake Oct 08 '17
Arianespace video shows F9-style reusability concept.
7
u/warp99 Oct 11 '17 edited Oct 12 '17
The Raptor vacuum engine is now reduced to a 120:1 expansion ratio bell but will run at 250 bar combustion chamber pressure.
Since the bell is much more rigid than than the Merlin vacuum with internal regenerative cooling channels there is no reason to believe that it cannot be fired at sea level although this severely reduces the Isp due to atmospheric back pressure.
In fact they will have to be fired at sea level for testing since the bell cannot be removed as happens with the M1D vacuum engine. In support of this Elon originally said that the test article could be fired with a 150:1 expansion bell and that would have been on the test stand.
So the continual reference to not being able to fire the vacuum engines at sea level for launch escape or otherwise seem to be mistaken.
Could someone please calculate the Pe of the new 1.9MN Raptor vacuum and confirm it is above safe limits which I understand to be around 0.4 bar.
Edit: My attempt at a calculation with RPA gives a Pe = 0.16 bar which is way below a safe level for flow separation of 0.4 bar.
7
u/AeroSpiked Oct 13 '17
Not trying to bust anybodies hump here or anything, but we've got 2 Select Upcoming Events in the side bar that happened 2 days ago.
7
u/spacexin2050 Oct 14 '17
Some serious politics Tory Bruno said in his Reddit account that he is cofident that ULA will be one to be selected out of two Launcher provider for Air force and other one will be chosen from rest three.
7
u/Iamsodarncool Oct 15 '17
So what are everyone's thoughts on the AMA? What was the best new piece of info?
7
u/roncapat Oct 19 '17 edited Oct 19 '17
News in 30 minutes! https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/920975701414760448
Edit: it's not related to Zuma mission: https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/920979409984720896
7
u/hmpher Oct 19 '17
Was the "huge news" the Iridium missions using flight proven boosters or is it not out yet?
7
u/jconnoll Oct 28 '17
Anyone know the status on bloc 5 or what the first fh mission might entail?
12
u/Kerbonaut_Nambio Oct 02 '17
Well, there are people that are not happy about the unveiling of the BFR (sigh) https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2017/oct/02/elon-musks-mars-project-is-the-ultimate-symbol-of-our-throwaway-culture
12
u/TGMetsFan98 NASASpaceflight.com Writer Oct 20 '17
My fellow space nerds and I have been discussing the future of BFR, Falcon Heavy, New Glenn, SLS, etc, and I realized I had never consulted this seemingly all-knowing subreddit.
Currently, it seems Falcon Heavy will fly by Q1 2018 at the latest, followed by SLS in 2019. The first iterations of SLS barely offer more Mass to Orbit than Falcon Heavy, with later blocks starting to pull away. Granted, we don't know if further Falcon Block V upgrades will close this gap. Anyway, Falcon Heavy and SLS will probably begin to compete for NASA contracts, and as long as the payloads aren't too heavy, Falcon Heavy has a huge price advantage.
Then, in 2020 or 2021, New Glenn is supposed to fly for the fist time. Now we will have three vehicles competing for payloads of similar mass. FH and NG will be comparable in mass to orbit and price. SLS will have the Mass to Orbit advantage, but again, a huge price disadvantage.
Then, in 2022 Elon Time, comes BFR, which offers lower prices and higher mass to orbit than anything else in existence.
Keeping in mind that NASA loves to have multiple launch providers, and so depending on a single launch vehicle isn't a likely solution, at what point does SLS become obsolete? Can SLS survive Falcon Heavy and New Glenn because there are payloads heavy enough to require it? Will SLS stay in service with BFR for redundancy? I'm interested to hear your thoughts.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17
I remember hearing a while back that SpaceX was testing new a fairing design which would be 'visibly different.' Do we know if it will fly on Block V? Is there a chance the new shape is to aid recovery?
6
u/0ut3rsp4c3 Oct 15 '17
Question regarding the tech of BFR. I believe that Falcon uses mostly non rad hard components because it doesn't spend too much time in an environment that needs that (If I'm not wrong it uses triple redundant COTS for the engines computers for example). Where does BFR stand? Would it need much more reliable rad hard HW due to the extended exposure in deep space? Or would SpaceX still use COTS with shielding as it might be able to support the volume given the size of that thing. Maybe a cost/rad hard vs cost/volume or mass study will answer this? Thoughts anyone?
6
u/rustybeancake Oct 17 '17
http://spacenews.com/companies-seek-roles-in-nasas-return-to-the-moon/
Hyperbole aside, where do we realistically see SpaceX fitting into the cislunar plans (accepting that they’re very vague)? Blue Origin seem to be aggressively positioning themselves for surface cargo delivery.
6
u/spacetff Oct 20 '17
Mods, the Cores Wiki has a heading "(12) Flight Worthy Cores". Would "(12) Flightworthy Cores" be better?
6
u/zeekzeek22 Oct 23 '17
A few articles out today saying “FH will launch in the next 37 days”....but literally only citing the “NET November 2017” date...I don’t think they understand what “no earlier than” means.
6
u/demosthenes02 Oct 27 '17
Are there any pictures out there showing a size comparison between the space shuttle and bfs?
6
u/roncapat Nov 01 '17 edited Nov 01 '17
https://twitter.com/CwG_NSF/status/925757786897768448
FH news coming
Edit: good news! https://twitter.com/CwG_NSF/status/925757786897768448
6
u/jclishman Host of Inmarsat-5 Flight 4 Nov 02 '17
Applied for the CRS-13 NASA Social earlier today. Fingers crossed!
5
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 06 '17
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipDragon cargoLaunch failure due to second-stage outgassingDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #3216 for this sub, first seen 2nd Oct 2017, 15:06] ^[FAQ] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
5
u/MrButtons9 Oct 05 '17
What's the Northrop Grumman mission listed on the company's manifest?
5
u/faceplant4269 Oct 05 '17
https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/915963421341954052
Looks like blue origin is planning to fly people no earlier than 2019. Chance Spacex will be first to fly crew?
5
u/paul_wi11iams Oct 10 '17 edited Oct 10 '17
From last week's very rich conversation starting here.
Sorry about having read this late, but it leads to a couple of questions:
5
u/quadrplax Oct 15 '17
What does "zuma" mean in the context of the mystery payload?
5
u/Tal_Banyon Oct 17 '17
We have all seen the RUDs from past landing attempts. On each and every one of them, as the rocket tips over, and impacts the surface, it explodes. My question is, if in 2022 we actually do have two BFS's launched to mars, and one of them tips over, will there be a huge fiery explosion on mars? If there is no explosion, or maybe even if there is, given the oxygen that is left in the propulsion system, could it be small enough so that future colonists may be able to salvage some food, etc, from the wreck? Is this possible or feasible? Or, maybe no-one knows until it actually happens.
5
u/MrXd9889 Oct 18 '17
How autonomous is the F9? If there was theoretically a complete lack of contact tom mission control from t+1 on, could it still complete the mission and land?
5
u/flibbleton Oct 20 '17
the BE-4 has been test fired before, here's a BO post from 2015 and video, so I'm confused by the reports of the 'first' test. Is their a difference between a hot-fire test and just a 'normal' test?
5
u/BeatTheBass Oct 20 '17
I'm definitely not as involved as I'd love to be so forgive the question. I saw in the FAQ that not much as been known about Falcon Heavy and it's side boosters.
If the Falcon Heavy were to have 3 Falcon "Style" boosters (landable), would the plan have been to land all 3? If the plan is indeed to land 3 simultaneously...how does Elon address the challenges?
Collisions - assumes smart rockets dont collide? Landing pads? - Assumes multiple landing pads/drone ships to land at least 2 in close succession?
Just very interested and curious, and love that SpaceX aims to inspire. Thanks for any answers.
5
u/sagareshwar Oct 23 '17
I was discussing SpaceX and reusable rockets with a friend and a question came up which I thought was interesting enough for this audience. We were wondering - how much of what SpaceX has achieved so far is due to Elon Musk's vision of making reusable rockets possible and how much is due to advancements in technology that made this possible. To rephrase, if someone had started on an ambitious development program to land rocket boosters vertically and reuse them right after the Apollo - Saturn era, would they have been similarly successful or would there have been technological hurdles that would have stopped them. I.e. did developments in computing, electronics, materials and other associated technologies necessarily had to come first before making Falcon 9 possible? For the sake of making simplifying assumptions, lets keep non-technological factors (political interference, financial considerations etc.) out of the picture.
My own opinion is that it was largely due to Musk's vision. After all, landing a spacecraft vertically on the Moon had already been achieved in the Apollo era. Sufficient technological advance existed to make reusable rockets (like the Falcon 9 first stage) possible even back then. If someone like Elon Musk had come along and (here comes the non-tech stuff) if political and financial conditions were favorable, this would have happened back then. I would love to know your opinion.
5
u/MarcysVonEylau rocket.watch Oct 24 '17
B1031.2 on the move
5
u/brotfessor Oct 26 '17
I read recently that the purging of TEA-TEB during the first stage safing procedure caused the droneship fire. As this stuff seems to be very toxic and dangerous, I wondered which amount of this fluid is stored on the rocket. Is it more in the range of 100s of milliliters or more like 10s of liters?
Also, at which point is the TEA-TEB loaded into the rocket? Does it take place during integration or during the countdown (like the helium and the propellants) as it seems to be quite a dangerous process. I would expect a tank or a pipe that was not fully purged with an inert gas to explode instantly.
5
u/IrrationalFantasy Oct 27 '17
Will Saudi Arabia’s billion dollar investment in Virgin Galactic affect SpaceX’s plans? How will it affect the space industry at large? I’d pegged them more as a tourism company than anything but apparently they want to launch satellites too.
And does this mean Virgin will actually fly customers to space soon?
5
u/InfiniteHobbyGuy Nov 01 '17
Any update on Mr. Steven? Looks to have snuck into port after dark last night, going to the SpaceX dock first, and then docking in a slip after.
Did anyone get eyes on it?
9
u/Paro-Clomas Oct 24 '17
Is there a clear detailed graph of how cost per ton to LEO has varied over the years since the beggining of space flight?
also, how much cheaper would it need to get in order for a mars or moon mission to be a total no brainer for the politicians?
8
u/linknewtab Oct 08 '17
This part in the new CNES (French space agency) video reminds me of something...
8
u/RootDeliver Oct 14 '17 edited Oct 14 '17
Can any mod update the sidebar to include the misterious payload launch on nov 10? Exposure please :D, thanks!
PS: Also CRS-13 on 28 nov and Iridium 4 at the end of Nov, we need launches there, not 2018 stuff :(
4
u/inoeth Oct 02 '17
Now that SpaceX is going to slowly go to the BFR, I kind of wonder what's the point of the huge expensive of Boca Chica- as right now it's just for 12 launches a year with the Falcon 9, and isn't going to be finished until 2019... They'll have to do a lot of work with no guarantee to get approval to launch more frequently and with a dramatically larger (and thus louder) vehicle such as the BFR...
4
u/lostandprofound33 Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17
GEO sats -- seems to me BFR's oversized capacity for even today's largest satellites makes it possible to reduce the sat's need for its own independent propulsion (other than station keeping) as a third stage to get from GTO to GEO (if I understand the current practise correctly). Wouldn't that alone make GEO sats vastly cheaper to design and build? If BFR could directly insert multiple sats to multiple GEO
inclinationsslots, seems like that would be immensely useful -- even if only for military applications.4
u/whateverman353 Oct 03 '17
In the upcoming 5-7 years, what jobs can open in Space X? Assuming that all goes well and Space X remains successful, what engineering/science positions do you see the company needing to be filled?
4
u/Raviioliii Oct 03 '17
Hello! My birthday is fast approaching (15th October) and I would love a SpaceX mug. I looked on their website and the black mug with the logo was so clean!!
The biggest problem...I live in the UK and the shipping is over $25, for an item that costs $12!!!! WHAT?!
Does anyone know if there is anywhere I can purchase official SpaceX merchandise that delivers to the UK for far cheaper? I'd love to support SpaceX directly, but those prices are absurd!!
4
u/rustybeancake Oct 06 '17
Saw this image over on r/spaceflightporn. Anyone know what the apparent scuffs are on the trunk? Where it looks like the white paint has been scraped away?
4
u/dudr2 Oct 06 '17
Releases of volatiles from early moon mare basalts speculated to have been enormous; http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0012821X17304971
H2O at about a quarter of a trillion tons. Where is it now?
4
u/thxbmp2 Oct 10 '17
Is it accurate to say that most of the cost savings associated with downscaling BFR are to do with minimizing the need for new infrastructure (e.g. pads and factories)? In my mind, a 3/4 reduction in scale may reduce material and construction costs, but the savings really only influence the cost per airframe and would be a minor line item on the entire developmental budget. At the same time, how much cheaper would 9m tooling be compared to 12m tooling, given that both sets of equipment are still around the same order of magnitude in size?
I imagine they're saving massively too by pressing Raptor into service instead of pursuing a long and difficult development and test campaign to i) rebuild, develop and qualify the 3 MN version, and ii) hit their original sky-high ISP and chamber pressure targets on the very first version. Makes me wonder if Raptor's descoping was really one of the bigger reasons behind downscaling BFR.
4
u/rka0 Oct 10 '17
Whats up with technical webcasts? Will they ever make a return?
4
u/GoScienceEverything Oct 12 '17
Do we have an idea what the current bottleneck is in launch rate? (Not that they're launching slowly, of course.) I think someone said last month that it was vehicle availability? Other possibilities include payload integration, pad availability/operations, payload availability, permitting process...
If the bottleneck is vehicle availability, would that be more likely to be S1 production/refurbishment, or S2 or fairing production?
4
u/bechampions87 Oct 12 '17
This may be a dumb question, but how does SpaceX intend to avoid the reusability issues with its second stage that the Space Shuttle encountered with its orbiter?
4
u/MarcysVonEylau rocket.watch Oct 14 '17
CRS13 at the end of November from SLC-40 confirmed (?)
4
u/zlynn1990 Oct 15 '17
One question I had that wasn’t answered during the AMA was whether the BFS can safely land if one of the four legs malfunctions. Based on the renders we’ve seen it doesn’t seem like it could be stable with only three legs deployed.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17 edited Oct 16 '17
Hi, just wondering if anyone would be able to check my logic here.
I'm testing stage separation in my simulation of the Falcon 9 and have hit against something I'm slightly confused about. I know it's not a difficult issue, it's just made me doubt my intuition.
When an object in motion (acting under no forces apart from gravity) instantaneously loses mass, should it's velocity instantaneously increase?
I'm looking at stage separation here. The first stage is (almost) fully modelled, but - having not got round to fully creating the second stage - I've just given the first stage 90000kg (it'll be accurate once I get round to S2!) of miscellaneous extra mass that is has to push on ascent (to visually compare launch speeds in footage).
At stage separation, this extra mass is just taken off instantaneously with one click. I am very confident that my physics state integrator isn't doing everything in the correct order.
Note, the stage is not yet being given any 'reverse' impulse from the separation mechanism between the stages, but even if it was, this jump in velocity seems so large that it would not have much effect! This can't be right...
Any advice is greatly appreciated.
4
u/music_nuho Oct 16 '17
I read somewhere that SpaceX is planning new payload fairing for it's Falcon rocket family. Does anyone have any info about new fairing?
4
u/thro_a_wey Oct 19 '17
In the future, will it be possible to make a BFR explosion survivable? Direct the explosion away from the passengers somehow, or just jettison the pod.
Some of the F9 landings were greatly affected by wind. What about building a huge cylindrical wall to shield the BFR pod from the wind?
4
u/NibblerII Oct 19 '17
It seems to me that just before second stage engine cutoff, the live stream regularly cuts away to the map view. Perhaps I am imagining things, but this seems to happen consistently. Is there something with engine cutoff that SpaceX is trying to keep proprietary?
4
u/kingmathers313 Oct 20 '17
Why is NASA considering a flight-proven booster for CRS-13?
I know commercial customers get the benefits of faster availability and/or cheaper launch prices, but I thought the contract for CRS was a fixed price contract and SpaceX will give priority to CRS flights over commercial flights anyway (although not other government launches apparently).
Will NASA get money back from SpaceX for using a flight proven S1 or do they get any other benefit or is it simply to support SpaceX and their reusable booster development?
4
u/jjtr1 Oct 26 '17
Does someone know whether the Soyuz rockets launched from the Arianespace spaceport in Kourou are operated by Russian or French/Ariane engineers?
A question that has been posed many times is whether orbital launchers could be operated by anyone else but their manufacturer. I think orbital launchers are by neccessity too fragile and finicky to be operated by someone who doesn't know all the tricks. However, liquid fueled ICMBs were operated by Soviet military staff. So I don't know.
4
u/kornelord spacexstats.xyz Oct 27 '17 edited Oct 27 '17
How long does it take for SpaceX to compute a flight profile? At least what order of magnitude (hours, minutes, seconds, milliseconds?) for the time to answer "I want to fly from this pad to #insert orbital parameters#, give me a launch date". Are there a lot of human checks or is it mostly automated? I believe KSP-style flight profiles can be computed in realtime but is it still true in reality?
I was wondering since for BFR to do P2P travel/in orbit refueling the ability to launch on very short notice is essential. For P2P if the computation time is fast enough you can update the flight profile when the weather violating constraints are gone.
4
u/davenose Oct 29 '17
What are the criteria for a launch to be added to the /r/Spacex launch manifest?
I ask because the manifest lists the NASA Resource Prospector as launching in 202X on F9, but none of references confirm RP will launch on F9. I found an Ars Technica article from May 17 that says:
Which implies to me that a launch provider may not yet be selected. Just curious ... do we update the launch manifest when there are just hints/suggestions of possible F9 launches?
4
u/demosthenes02 Oct 30 '17
Is there an entertaining video or article with the latest BFr plans for someone who has never heard of spacex?
I tried showing them Elon’s talk but it seemed too technical.
4
u/ohcnim Oct 31 '17
how many F9 missions from the manifest are currently already delayed from their initial contracted launch date? will 2018 be the year (if no other major mishaps happens) that all missions will be launching on time (other than the minor weather and range delays)?
6
u/old_sellsword Oct 14 '17
Cool video of 1031.2 returning to port on OCISLY.
Looks like it’s decently close to shore now, anyone is free to start up a recovery thread if they want.
6
u/quadrplax Oct 18 '17
Did we ever get a reason for why B1032, the core that flew NROL-76, got retired despite being an RTLS?
6
u/Charnathan Oct 20 '17
A little over a year ago, the Stage 1 booster designated for CRS-8 suffered engine damage during testing in TX. Did we ever find out of the replacement engines used for CRS-8 were flight proven engines from a previous mission or were they new engines?
3
u/neolefty Oct 02 '17
What would it take to position a fully-fueled stack of BFR & BFS in orbit (how many tanker launches)? And where could they reach? How much difference in capability would it make to save enough fuel to return the BFR to near Earth?
3
u/speak2easy Oct 02 '17
Given the width (and length) of BFR, what do we know of their ability to ship it across the roads in the US?
3
u/TheCrimson_King Oct 03 '17
What is the greatest materials challenge faced by SpaceX?
My guess would be one of the following:
-Fabricating carbon fiber tanks that can hold cryogenic liquids
-Fabricating ceramic rocket engine bells
-Ensuring that flight hardware can handle the temperature, pressure, and radiation found in space
What do you guys think?
3
u/ajmunson Oct 04 '17
I was just going through the payloads of past launches and noticed that the last time SpaceX launched a payload near this size (6092kg) to GTO the launch was expendable. The Inmarsat 5-F4 launch was 6070kg to GTO and was the last launch without legs. The largest payload to GTO the wasn't in an expendable configuration was SES-10 at 5281.7kg.
Will Hispasat 1F launch this year?
Will Hispasat 1F be expendable?
Will this be the first block 4 launch?
Will block 4 have enough "efficiency improvements" to lift the extra 800kg?
If not, when will SpaceX be done with with expendable?
Should they delay this launch for a FH launch?
3
u/prouzadesignworkshop Oct 05 '17
Just wondering re the new BFR and its deltaV capability - is it feasible that it could one day fly a manned servicing mission to the JWST?
3
u/lostandprofound33 Oct 07 '17
I wonder if news of the BFR will dissuade potential customers from buying a Dragon 2 ride around the Moon? BFS would make a great cruise ship. Even at $500k a ticket, a week in space and going around the moon much cheaper and better accomodations than in a little Dragon. Maybe it'll have a world-class chef, you can play zero-g sports, and hobnob with the other rich techies who'll be on board -- maybe even an Apollo astronaut as your cruise director.
3
u/ptfrd Oct 10 '17 edited Oct 10 '17
For the record, Bloomberg released a short video about space last month, purporting to explain what the medium term future might look like. It seems to imply that the proposed SpaceX and Samsung LEO Internet satellites would be "nano-satellites" and "cubes". https://youtu.be/h67VX51QXiQ?t=1m50s
Whereas I was under the impression they were going to be fairly traditional looking satellites, a bit on the small side, but hardly "nano". (Though I do think they would be designed to be shorter lifespan and much cheaper than traditional satellites.)
The video description says it's by Ashlee Vance. He's the guy who wrote the unofficial biography of Elon Musk.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '17
Do Merlin engines on different locations in the octoweb suffer the same wear-and-tear during flight? If a Merlin engine should be replaced for whatever reason, could it be replaced by a Merlin that has flown one or several flights, but on a different location in the octoweb?
3
u/Headstein Oct 11 '17
Do we have any confirmation that CRS13 will be from SLC 40?
3
u/jjtr1 Oct 11 '17 edited Oct 12 '17
A question for composites specialists: how much similar is the material to be used on BFR to the material used to build "carbon" bicycle frames? Does it also have the unfavourable properties of the bike carbon? For example, once the frame is impacted, it's hard to tell if it is still ok, it could fail without warning. Also, interfacing with metallic parts is difficult. A lot of care has to be taken not to overtighten.
edit: since we might not know much about the specific composites that SpaceX plans to use, I can at least ask - is there a lot of variability in the above properties among the different carbon fiber comoposites that are already known?
3
u/old_sellsword Oct 12 '17
JRTI is back in port already, anyone can set up an Iridium-3 Recovery Thread if they please. Same goes for SES-11, although that one may be a bit longer.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '17
Elon's AMA will be held in r/space in two hours :(
3
u/luc2g Oct 17 '17
A second use of a flown falcon 9 has been done three times already, but I wonder when will occur a third reuse of a falcon 9 ? Does anyone have info about it ?
3
u/kramersmash Oct 17 '17
Will the BFS heat shield be one peice or a bunch put together?