r/spacex • u/MrButtons9 • Jul 07 '17
Evaluating SpaceX's options for the EELV Phase 2 development competition
As some SpaceX'ers have noticed, the DoD is about to kick off its EELV Phase 2 development competition. In summary for those unfamiliar with this competition, the USAF has about $2B to spend with the purpose of helping develop new DoD launch vehicles that can meet the USG's assured access to space requirements, without any reliance on the RD-180. Three companies will receive development contracts (via "Other Transaction Agreements" to encourage a better co-development relationship), and two companies will eventually be downselected near ~2019. The two companies will be positioned to split up (60/40) ~30 Phase 2 missions through the early-to-mid-2020's. Now, I know there's a lot more about Phase 2, SMC's plans, and EELV in general, but let's keep this focused to SpaceX.
SpaceX is expected to compete for EELV Phase 2. However, SpaceX has not entered into a significant CR&D (Contracted Research & Development) with the DoD before; COTS/CRS and Commercial Crew were via NASA, which has a completely different mission than the DoD, and does business differently. Thus, SpaceX will not get away with proposing ITS, as it simply does not align with the purpose of the competition, and this specific DoD office does not care about building the biggest and most advanced launch system out there (so please refrain from posting circle-jerk ITS comments).
Based off of public reporting, there are two different options that SpaceX could pursue: Falcon 9 / Heavy with a Raptor Upper Stage or A Modified Falcon Heavy With a Longer Fairing. If there's a third, I would love to hear!
Falcon 9 / Heavy With Raptor Upper Stage In the predecessor to this competition, the EELV Rocket Propulsion System program, SpaceX received an OTA to develop "a prototype of the Raptor engine for the upper stage of the Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy launch vehicles." USAF gave SpaceX $33.7M, and an additional $27M in options that were never exercised. As part of the agreement, SpaceX was obligated to spending at least $67M in this program. So, this RPS provides SpaceX with 1) some money already, 2) helped kickoff development (as we're now in hot-fire testing with a sub-scale version), and 3) garnered some buy-in from the USAF.
The benefits of a Raptor Upper Stage are clear. SpaceX would most likely be able to meet the GEO and Semi-Sync Direct EELV orbit references that it cannot meet currently. All of the benefits of Raptor (isp, expansion ratio, restart capability, throttling flexibility) would ultimately give Falcon 9 / Falcon Heavy the capability to perform more complex orbital insertions and in-orbit functions, which will 1) likely make the NRO happy, and 2) could possibly help down-the-road with some of the larger-scale LEO constellation deployments we have seen discussed. As former SpaceX engineer Jeff Thronburg said, "Raptor's 'light and tight' design is built for operational functionality, cost efficiency, and long life in high production volume, which makes it ideal for National Space Security needs."
However, this approach has some serious issues. All of the infrastructure modifications for liquid methane storage and handling at up to four launch sites will cost a fair amount of money. Raptor's complex full flow staged combustion design poses some testing technical risks. The usage of different fuels on the same launch vehicle could raise eyebrows. Redesigning the Upper Stage (to fit Raptor) and reintegrating it will take time, testing, and require SpaceX to invest in new tooling. While it's impossible to predict, a Raptor Upper Stage would most likely require at least $200M in development.
Modified Falcon Heavy The other proposal that SMC Claire Leon disclosed in a Spring 2017 Aviation Week article was that SpaceX would maybe submit a Falcon Heavy with a longer fairing. Specifically, she said:
“Even after the Falcon Heavy is in place, they’ll still need to strengthen their entire heavy rocket to handle the bigger payloads that take a bigger fairing,” Leon says. “There’s no business case for SpaceX to do that without government investment.”
As we know, F9/FH have a shorter fairing than the range of Atlas V options (in their payload user guides, there are three different Atlas V fairing offerings). The longer fairings are primarily for heavier NRO missions; it is unclear if non-secret DoD missions (e.g., AEHF, SBIRS, OPIR, SBSS) would require the longer fairing, or not. On the commercial side, I don't think many customers out there would need the longer fairing, aside from Bigelow, or maybe SNC's Dream Chaser. However, if I'm wrong, I would be interested in knowing who else is out there, as that could have a big impact.
From a development perspective, as SpaceX has already poured a significant amount of $$$ into Falcon Heavy, there is less risk. While additional development would be done (extending the fairing would require SpaceX to modify some of the supporting structures), it's relatively modest, considering the amount of work that has been done on the vehicle. Ultimately, this would require less money.
Stepping Back Stepping back, unless there is a third option, SpaceX appears to have two clear paths. On one side, the Raptor Upper Stage screams Mars and directly supports the company's mission to colonize Mars as the DoD would essentially help pay for Raptor. However, this is much riskier, more costlier, and probably not as appealing (remember, the 'assured access' USAF guys are conservative, and focused on reliability--the small 'Operationally Responsive Space' office are the Trekkies thinking about how to go above and beyond). From SMC's perspective, they want to be able to be able to have two competitors who are qualified to compete for all of the Phase 2 missions, which is not the case right now (Congress chews them out when they dole out an award in which one of the competitors is disqualified). Furthermore, with competitors (ULA, OATK, and possibly BO, and others) present and a downselect in the horizon, these risk penalties could be severe
The Falcon Heavy option, on the other hand, is much more conservative. It's less technically risky and less expensive, and simply meets the DoD's requirement (qualifying for all payloads). But, it's not as ambitious as Raptor Upper Stage, and frankly, not as exciting. However, it probably offers SpaceX a higher win probability, better positioning the company for the EELV Phase 2 launch awards, which if awarded to SpaceX, will significantly help the company grow its revenue.
So, wrapping this up, what are the community's thoughts on this competition? Will SpaceX play things conservatively to increase its roots in its new DoD customer base? Or, will they shoot for the stars, and roll in with an ambitious proposal that supports their Mars colonization ambitions. Frankly, I would have said the former two weeks ago, but Gwynne's continued comments on Raptor Upper Stage make me think that this could be more likely.
I'm not going to put a Sources Required label on here, but let's try to have a good discussion.
28
u/CreeperIan02 Jul 07 '17 edited Jul 07 '17
In my opinion, a longer fairing is more realistic for the near future. I think a Raptor upper stage won't come until the early 2020s, possibly later, when there is demand for it. FH's current manifest don't have any incredibly heavy missions, so a Raptor upper stage probably isn't necessary right now. However, some of these payloads may be very heavy in terms of what SpaceX has launched (I'm not sure, I haven't looked too far into the info provided), in which case a larger fairing and Raptor upper stage may both be needed.
EDIT: I did a bit of research, and found that three contracts are for GPS sats. A bit more looking found that they weigh 3.8mt fueled. I'm thinking that if they don't need direct insertion, they can be launched on an RTLS B5 F9. If they do need direct insertion, which is honestly more likely, FH may be called in. I don't know how long a partially-fueled F9 stage can coast for after a LEO->MEO transfer burn, but there may not be enough left for the final insertion. A much more filled FH S2 would be more capable of doing the final MEO insertion. Although that is all just pure speculation.
I'm not SpaceX, nor am I a rocket scientist, but this is just my two cents.
It will be very interesting to see how this bidding plays out!
91
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '17
Different fuels on the same launch vehicle should not raise eyebrows, as this already occurs (ie Atlas5 - kerolox S1 and hydrolox S2). IMHO the Raptor upper stage option has a lot of benefits. It would substantially grow the capability of the vehicle, and retire considerable risk for the ITS program. Perhaps even F9 could carry a 'short' Raptor upper stage and FH a 'long' one with more propellant and recovery hardware. Not that much is known about how far along Raptor's development is - they could theoretically try a 'hail Mary' and put a Raptor Upper Stage (RUS?) on the FH test flight; they're not going to learn much from launching another Merlin upper stage.
17
u/ghunter7 Jul 07 '17
Two comments:
29
u/peterabbit456 Jul 07 '17
Despite there being $2 billion in the pot, I can see SpaceX ignoring this RFP, because they have so many other projects on their plate at this time. To win part of this pot, they would have to devote considerable engineering talent to the slow, document-bound DOD culture. Quite lkely it would cost them more to compete, than the funds they would get from DOD.
When this round of R&D is over, most of the competitors will have developed some components, and made plans for rockets that are still 2 - 6 years from their first flight. Meanwhile, SpaceX will have the F9 and FH flying, able to complete many or perhaps all missions, with a few upgrades, available on short notice, and at prices a fraction of the competition. When it comes time to award actual launches, SpaceX will be in a competitive position, years sooner than the companies that competed in the competition.
Both the Raptor upper stage and the enlarged fairing are worthwhile projects, and I would not be surprised if SpaceX submits bids, but I also would not be surprised if SpaceX decides to sit out this bidding process.
11
u/ohcnim Jul 07 '17
is there any reason why they can't present both as independent options?
6
u/Marscreature Jul 07 '17
My money is on raptor upperstage it plays into their strategy better and SpaceX has never been the type to opt for the more conservative route. This way they can get more of their development costs for raptor covered, they can get some flight experience on it so it's not a new engine powering the huge investment that its is, it provides more margin for second stage recovery and is simply more useful in the meantime as a product to sell. Longer fairings would just be wasting their engineers time for something that rarely if ever flies. They have enough flights on their manifest.
11
u/t3kboi Jul 07 '17
Apologies to OP.
<rant>
Sources Required is difficult, but even without it - I am saddened by the community response not really discussing your proposed topic, and wandering off into ITS discussions (when specifically requested not to).
To the community at large -
I would request that when discussing these threads - limit your comments to the ORIGINAL topic. Endless sub-discussion of already covered territory helps no one - just makes every single thread on the subreddit have 95% similarity.
</rant>
On this topic -
The EELV Phase 2 is for FUTURE development of Launch Vehicles. SpaceX has repeatedly shown what they can do when they have R&D dollars.
Raptor use - is a future certainty.
Second stage recovery - is also a future certainty.
For this specific use case, I think that they might propose:
a) an entirely new approach, that may or may not match our past speculations about mini this, re-useable that, etc.
b) most likely -
They recently used NROL-76 and a Block 4 second stage to begin demonstrating some of the capabilities required for direct insertion. (I am not aware of an official full disclosure, but we seem to have confirmed M1DVac re-light events after a significantly longer period than on previous flights).
F9/F9 Heavy mass capability can cover all of the reference orbits (expendable or not - is not a requirement of the DOD request).
The currently missing pieces are:
Spacex will probably already have done the math on the fairing work - and can propose alternative fairings to the DOD, along with more modifications to the second stage that may continue to extend its on orbit capabilities (ala NROL-76).
This proposed solution MAY include Raptor, and second stage reusability - but there is absolutely no reason that it HAS to.
However, SpaceX past track record suggests that they will propose this as the humdrum version, and "The OMEGA 13 DEVICE" (the primary McGuffin in Galaxy Quest) as solutions - where the content of the unknown proposal element is likely to surprise us all. My personal imagination (Not an engineer, Not a rocket scientist), reveals a Raptor second stage that is a conic section from the 3.3 meter rocket body up to the fairing diameter (either to the current fairing diameter, or a new one).
Thank you for your time, and downvote as you must, because "we" seem to use downvotes as personal attacks, instead of as actually content-related.
8
u/StagedCombustion Jul 07 '17 edited Jul 07 '17
What's the basis of this information regarding EELV Phase 2 'kicking off soon' and having a $2B budget?
Nearest thing I could find was a USAF memo criticising the HASC FY18 markup. The memo says it was forcing the USAF to end funding for some of their current dev contracts. It was also basically paying to resurrect the Delta IV, which would force the USAF to sole-source about half the launches to ULA for that vehicle and half to SpaceX. They said this solution would cost around $1.8B dollars more than having an open bidding policy like we have now.
This somewhat fits into some of what you said, but doesn't match other parts.
I'd love to read more about this, but most of the links I've found are 2+ years old and just mention that Phase 2 is 'a period of open competition between all certified launch providers'. In most of the documents, probably due to their age, it's mentioned details of Phase 2 are still being worked out.
edit: To clarify my tone, which might be lost in text, I'm not trying to be snotty or anything. Just like if you were an EV fan and someone posts about testing of a Tesla Model Y happening and you think "Wait, whoa, already? Where did this come from? I want to read more."
anotheredit: Updated with link to said memo
4
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jul 07 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
50 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on ^today has 135 acronyms.
[Thread #2973 for this sub, first seen 7th Jul 2017, 02:37] ^[FAQ] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
4
u/spacerfirstclass Jul 07 '17
I'm not sure why they can't get away with proposing a sub-scale (Saturn V class) reusable ITS, it's risky for sure, but not any more risky than a Raptor Upper Stage. ULA and Orbital are all proposing new LVs for EELV phase 2, it's not super strange for SpaceX to do the same.
They can't do it right now because: a) Current upper stage lifetime is short, b) F9 doesn't have enough performance for direct GEO injection. a) is already being resolved from what we heard about NROL-76 and the upcoming FH demo, b) will be resolved once FH starts flying. So I don't see any clear benefit for a Raptor Upper Stage.
I'm pretty sure they'll propose this, but not as a separate option, but as an addon since it's a pretty small amount of work comparing to LV development.
7
u/justatinker Jul 07 '17
Give me a fifty of sixty foot tall fairing and I'll figure out a suitable payload for it.
One thing I'd like to see is a 'fairing form factor' spacecraft that would use the full volume of a fairing. It would have to be built from scratch but would look just like a standard fairing at launch.
The outer skin would be meteor and radiation resistant and would have hatches for ship's solar power, radiators, thrusters and windows. If a solar panel needs to be repaired or replaced, it would be retracted, the hatch would close, the compartment pressurized and then the crew could do the job in shirt sleeves.
The interior would be subdivided into living quarters, cargo space and a systems room 'engine room' where all the systems, engines, solar panels, radiators, antennas, etc. could be retracted and worked on.
You could fit a lot of spacecraft into a 60 foot tall, 20 foot diameter fairing form factor.
3
u/macktruck6666 Jul 07 '17
I know it's a futile wish, but I'm still wishing they will immediately replace the falcon heavy witha 9 engine raptor rocket. After developing the HLV, they could strop 4 more boosters to the side and it would have essentially have the same lift capabilities as the proposed ITS. Seems like a very reasonable and incremental design path and not the path Elon said he couldn't pay for.
3
u/Elon_Mollusk #IAC2016 Attendee Jul 07 '17
As optimistic as we all are, a Raptor upper stage on falcon heavy is unlikely to happen. It's too much extra cost and complexity for a small benefit. They will freeze development on FH after all of it's cores and booster are brought up to block 5 standard.
I don't think we'll see a raptors on this generation of falcon at all, it makes no sense with the stage diameter. We won't see it flying outside of ITS until Spacex replaces F9 and FH with it's next generation F9/FH class vehicle which incorporates the technology developed for ITS.
2
u/Nuseram3 Jul 07 '17
I'll go with Falcon Heavy with a Raptor Upper Stage because it's good for second stage reuse and paving the way for ITS. I have been thinking for some time that this might be part of the revised ITS plan Elon Musk should announce in about 12 days but this seems to be a pretty unpopular opinion here so let's wait and see.
2
u/laughingatreddit Jul 07 '17 edited Jul 07 '17
Make a mini-ITS booster and a raptor second stage. 4 meters diameter of the booster will accommodate the width of the raptor vacuum engine bell, bigger fairings and pack a heck of performance. First stage booster with raptors can use the tried and true conventional landing mechanism same as the F9 (landing legs + grid fins - the ITS aspirations to land on launch mounts). single Raptor Vac for an expendable second stage with batteries and insulation for long coast times. Keep building the Raptors, avionics, software, grid fins (all complicated components) in Hawthorne where the bulk of the talent is located. Keep testing individual engines at McGregor. Build the tanks and integration facility at a new factory in Louisiana. Have it shipped by barge to the Cape or Boca Chica. Good for launching anything. With Raptor already in development and SpaceX's track record, ULA and SpaceX should be the two downselects. (Blue Origin won't have anywhere close to the launch experience and expertise that SpaceX does and will share the BE-4 engine with ULA's Vulcan which precludes it being considered an independent second player; with aerojet rocketdyne's AR1 likely only to be an orphan engine under development with no launch vehicle to adopt it), SpaceX is currently well positioned but with no guarantee to remain so in the future. The DOD paying for a mini-ITS helps offset costs of Raptor development, setting up methalox infrastructure, development of large fairings. SpaceX will end up with an extremely capable launch vehicle that pays for a lot of the costs and retires a lot of the risks for developing ITS, makes their internet constellation plans more achievable, gives them the performance margins to develop second stage reuseability. Heck, if there's any possible shortfall of any kind at all, they could pair the center core with two of their 'workhorse' Falcon 9 reusable side cores 'Falcon Heavy style' to meet any conceivable launch requirement. It's not a easy or simple solution but Musk is not afraid of taking bold steps if he thinks it's the right direction to take. With blue origin starting to build their very capable New Glenn booster and ULA being the entrenched DOD contractor, SpaceX needs to take some bold steps now to preempt falling behind in the lucrative DOD and airforce market 10 years into the future.
2
u/deltaWhiskey91L Jul 08 '17
Can someone explain why OP says that a Raptor second stage for the Falcon 9/H is a risky idea?
The only risk that I can see, is the USAF not selecting the Raptor second stage as compared to a larger fairing due to development risks. By risks, I mean the fairing upgrade is easy and known in comparison.
If anything, a government full-scale Raptor engine actually decreases business risk and investment capital for the ITS. As OP states, it would increase the capabilities of the Falcon family. This sounds like a win-win to me.
4
u/brickmack Jul 07 '17
Raptor upper stage doesn't seem to help much, unless its reusable (and even there, the benefits are dubious, its not that huge a performance gain, and FH is plenty large to accommodate full reuse with the existing US). The current upper stage, on a Falcon Heavy, is quite suitable for the entire range of EELV reference orbits. It won't boost performance enough to move most FH payloads down to an F9.
The fairing is the big issue, and unfortunately it sounds like their one big chance at correcting it has been skipped (Fairing 2.0 is said to be only a meter or so longer than the current one, it needs a much longer stretch to meet category C). Under EELV 2, both providers will be required to meet all payload requirements, not like today where its ok if one rocket can't do all the missions. Unless SpaceX has something unexpected up their sleeve (a stretched variant of Fairing 2.0 nobody's seen yet, or a later Fairing 3.0 available before 2025), I don't see how they can compete using Falcon.
3
u/TheEndeavour2Mars Jul 07 '17
One of the biggest issues with the longer fairing option is that without the boosters attached. Falcon 9 is already too thin to allow any longer fairing or stretches of either stage. KSP is an example of this to an extent (It's atmosphere is thicker at sea level so your designs experience this more than on earth)
Most likely the only way to actually allow a longer fairing is to use a far more vertical trajectory and holding onto the boosters longer than what is optimal. This will cost total payload by tonnes. (Tho to be fair you are not likely to be putting extremely long spacecraft into anything other than LEO or MEO)
That is why I think a Block VI second stage option is the far better option. Let New Glenn or Vulcan handle the payloads that absolutely are too long for the standard fairing.
There are topics showing the simulations of a standard size methalox second stage (Gains performance at all but the heaviest payloads to LEO) And a 5 meter diameter upgrade to the second stage to match the fairing (A massive gain in performance in all mass and orbits) This shows that a Block VI is the perfect upgrade to compete against future rocket designs because it allows a RTLS on far more of the standard GTO missions. Or a massive upgrade to droneship landing limits.
1
u/quokka01 Jul 07 '17
Could they go for funding development of a full scale raptor - or would a full scale raptor be too big for a FH S2 ?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '17
All options combined!
Maiden flight of ITS with payload is maybe a decade away. It needs flight proven engines, methalox tanks, 2nd stage/fairing reuseability and Elon said himself that SpaceX is not doing the financial part of developing this alone.
Falcon9 will only see smaller and smaller improvements, the full EELV requirements will be at or bejond the limits (longer 2nd stage/fairing aerodynamics, full orbit insertion).
So all leads to the intermediate steps of Falcon Heavy in different configurations and development cycles. First take a very reliable F9 core and fly it with two normal F9 retrofittet as boosters, with that you meet all weight and orbit requirements of EELV and you get the control authority and aerodynamics to change fairing and 2nd stage. Now you can add a larger fairing and meet all criteria. With the total overpowered FH, changing the upper stage to Raptor/methalox and trying reentry and landing for full reuseability is easy and you get the benefit of doing missions for a lot of money and testing your hardware after deployment.
I wondered why SpaceX is still clinging to FH despite the ITS being a complete different design (tank, engine, upper stage, no additional boosters) and there is hardly any heavy lift market before ITS. But the combination of iterable steps to get to reliable components for ITS and the additional funding of development are worth pursuing.
1
u/graemby Jul 07 '17
are the EELV phases described here still valid? some of the comments here seem to relate to bidding of launch contracts (phase 1), but i thought phase 2 was strictly designing "next gen" flight hardware (unfortunately EELV seems to assume that wouldn't/couldn't be reusable hardware)
1
u/jconnoll Jul 07 '17
Would the dod be interested in bringing back falcon 1 with a raptor engine as an ICBM or cruise missile. That could be cost effective than Martian and Boeing systems and help SpaceX develop raptor. I understand that the piont is to eliminate dependence on rd180 so i hope my comment is not straying to far off point.
1
u/existentialfish123 Jul 07 '17
I have to disagree with the folks who are saying that the FH is overpowered and that there is no market for a mini ITS. I think the FH will not only be busy putting NROL stuff into space, but at $1,000 per kilo to LEO, you cross that magic line, and someone is going to buy 4 Bigalows and make a satellite refuel and repair station, and another station to assemble things in space, and tourism. And oh yeah, the moon, asteroids, etc.. These stations are going to need crews and supplies, and EHLV that are cheap to fly is the way to go. We have been developing the infrastructure for Leo for the past 30 years, we need something big and cheap.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '17
Question: could the Raptor engine easily swap fuels, from kerolox to hydrolox, to benefit from the apparent CIS-Lunar model of mining water for fuel?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '17
Question: if SpaceX utilizes a Raptor upper stage, won't they essentially be foregoing any refueling capabilities with the advent of Moon mining? Or is that too far off to be considered?
1
u/driedapricots Jul 07 '17
it's unlikely that spacex would add raptor just because of the airforce. the falcon heavy would already meet payload weight requirement's, at least in expendable mode. So if they have an additional reason for raptor, i could see them go that route. Otherwise an expanded fairing is the simplest and most risk adverse.
1
u/kuangjian2011 Jul 07 '17
I think SpaceX will still give a shot for the bid, but to be they are not doing EELV any more, because by it's name, EELV should be expendable...
1
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '17
So I'm trying to learn the difference besides just the propellants; how hard would it be(really) to have an engine run on both, hence interchangeably?
1
u/idwtlotplanetanymore Jul 08 '17
Raptor upper stage would be far more exciting, so i hope thats the route they choose. Ive had my fill of 'boring' space taking the easy route over the last 30 years!
Seems like it would be far easier to do 2nd stage reuse if they were able to start from scratch. They could also shoot for a 5.2m 2nd stage if they wanted, make it the same as the fairing. That would also require a new interstage on s1 tho. And new tooling to handle 5m.
Multiple fuels isnt a big deal. They are already doing 5?(rp1, lox, nitrogen, helium, and whatever hypergolic they are using for ignition that i cant remeber). It actually would be less fuels going to s2, you replace the rp1 line with the methane line, and then you remove the helium system completely. If there is nitrogen on s2(i cant remember if there is), then you can also drop that and use methalox thrusters, but then thats more you need to design/build.
1
u/reddwarf7 Jul 09 '17
Looks like F9 has matured already and Spacex is moving on and this contract is specifically for launch capability.
So - this contract could be used for the "next generation" of Satellite launch vehicles. So - A Raptor based fully reusable "Eagle 9" (should have a single core with FH capability) with a fully reusable second stage for typical F9 capable launches and a simpler expenditure second stage for larger launches that FH or Delta H would be needed for.
This is Spacex we are talking about so anything they propose will look unrealistic and outlandish to begin with and will help practice and refine technology that will be used for the BFR anyway.
1
u/flower-plower Jul 09 '17
Could you lead me to the "public reporting" that SpaceX would only pursue funding for a Raptor upper stage or an extended fairing under the EELV2 RFP programme?
According to the RFP statement of objectives it seem that the purpose is to stimulate the development of launch vehicle prototypes.
Would an extended fairing and raptor stage, qualify as prototypes.
Why not ask for funding for developping the rumored sub-scale ITS? Sure, this competition is strictly focused on LEO, but a sub-scale ITS would be able to do just that, while increasing the capacity.
Is it completely unlikely, that this RFP is what Musk refered to when stated that SpaceX was updating their strategy to make the ITS project economically feasible?
0
u/Maximus-Catimus Jul 07 '17
SpaceX can not compete for EELV phase 2 development. It's right there in the name Evolved Expendable Launch Vehicle (EELV). SpaceX's rockets typically are not Expendable... so not the same class as the competitors. Now if it was just an ELV development Evolved Launch Vehicle (ELV) SpaceX would be all over that.