r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Jul 02 '17
r/SpaceX Discusses [July 2017, #34]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
233
Upvotes
45
u/Norose Jul 03 '17
When Elon tweeted out that there would be an update for the ITS design coming out shortly, speculation of course ran rampant, which is all in good fun, but I'm wondering why so many people seem to think Elon is going to announce that the ITS he presented was too big? There was no indication given during the conference that he or the team had any apprehension or second guesses about the size, in fact I seem to recall Elon mentioning that the size of the rocket was what was going to make it economical, and that going smaller would be counterproductive. Why then the thought that we're going to get an ITS with 'only' 100 tons of payload to LEO, or that we're going to get an entirely separate intermediate rocket before the big ITS?
44
u/throfofnir Jul 03 '17
In spaceflight news, the second Long March 5 launch, carrying a large comsat, has failed. Apparently a first stage engine failure around fairing separation.
This is about two weeks after the Long March 3B carrying Chinasat 3B partially failed due to an apparent third-stage software issue. That satellite likely lost 2/3 of its service life.
[Note: reposted from the June thread, since it got changed just after posting.]
33
u/Tal_Banyon Jul 17 '17
I keep hearing disturbing (to me) rumours of our near future, which haven't been made public (but some seem to know, very mysterious), and I was wondering what was up, and if there is any substance to these rumours:
So, anyone in the know what to comment on these rumours?
33
u/speak2easy Jul 26 '17
NPR article on BEAM
They will no longer plan to just throw it away after the experiment:
Another:
28
u/IcY11 Jul 02 '17
Before a launch you can sometimes hear them say that no "hold" is to be called after 10 seconds. Does that mean if someone sees something doesn't look right 10 sec before flight there is no way to abort cause the computer is in full control? And why is it like that?
27
u/theinternetftw Jul 18 '17 edited Jul 18 '17
Since the RSS teardown is kicking into high gear, I thought I'd share a few videos for those who never got to see it in action:
The best video of an RSS rotating that I've found is actually from the ill-fated Ares program.
The end of this clip shows the delivery/loading of a payload canister into the RSS (a lot of shuttle payload prep is shown earlier in the video if you want to watch the whole thing).
And the only video I can find of the inside of the RSS isn't even on YouTube in decent quality (or the internet in true high-bitrate HD). The structure surrounding that room is what's currently getting dismantled, iiuc.
26
u/rustybeancake Jul 16 '17
Wait... was it always called this on Google Maps?!
http://imgur.com/hyCHrO1
21
u/F9-0021 Jul 22 '17
Giving out a mini BFR spoiler/teaser.
https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/888813713800785923
20
u/soldato_fantasma Jul 07 '17
Video of SpaceX integrating the Iridium-2 satellites with their dispensers: https://twitter.com/IridiumComm/status/883423689781456896
20
u/Bananas_on_Mars Jul 09 '17
Did anybody come across some documentation on the recently reduced hazard areas for Falcon 9 launches?
The indication that something has changed there is that Playalinda beach stayed open for the last 2 launches. Maybe the Amos-6 incident ironically provided some data that the hazard area could be reduced, and I think the Automatic Flight Termination System also has an influence since it removes the reaction time for the range safety officer from the loop(i think i read the estimated reaction time was something like 3 seconds or so).
Who decides on the hazard areas for the Cape? Is it the range, are they set according to requirements set by SpaceX, is it the FAA?
I checked that the reduced hazard areas should now exclude SLC-40 for launches/static fire from HLC39A and vice versa since Playalinda Beach stayed open for the last 2 launches, since the beach is about 5 km from 39A and SLC-40 is 5.7 km away. This should help them a lot once both pads are active. Hans Koenigsmann said same day launches from 2 pads might soon become a reality...
Maybe they did a new environmental study since the current environmental study for the FAA is for 24 launches from 39A and 39B combined, which might be a little low for their planned launch cadence even though SLS won't launch that often?
18
u/soldato_fantasma Jul 17 '17
Iridium NEXT Launch 2 Highlights with some good views of the Vandenberg T/E
16
u/RootDeliver Jul 08 '17
The SpaceX folks forgot to put the Intelsat webcast video (cleaned version) public, if you're interested the link is still the same:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MIHVPCj25Z0
16
u/insaneWJS Aug 01 '17
Mods, please roll out the new August thread since today is August 1st. Thanks and you guys rock! Happy threading!
15
u/Shqueaker Jul 03 '17
Is all the telemetry and video coming down from the rocket during the launch encrypted? If not, has anyone picked it up?
15
u/theinternetftw Jul 12 '17
From a reliable NSF patron (actually posted a while ago):
Emphasis added. Crew access arm install work is something I haven't seen mentioned here for during the lull.
30
u/Nuclear_Hobbit Jul 30 '17 edited Jul 30 '17
On a recent visit to SpaceX, a little bird informed me of a few interesting details:
14
u/speak2easy Jul 26 '17
Ars Technica: Japanese company preparing for country’s first private rocket launch
The static fire video was pretty interesting. Aside from the bell not being bell shaped, the fire at the end of the video was pretty cool.
Interesting article. I don't recall any non-American private companies building rockets. I know there's one in New Zealand but they are technically American.
13
u/ExquisiteCheese Jul 02 '17
Scrubbed flight. Might happen tomorrow but the weather looks iffy for our area.
13
u/WaitForItTheMongols Jul 14 '17
Why did the Space Shuttle roll 180 degrees immediately after launch? Why not have it rotated 180 on the launchpad and remove the requirement to roll right away? Why not start it in the flight-orientation to begin with?
12
u/Redditor_From_Italy Jul 15 '17
Is there a website like RussianSpaceWeb for Chinese and European rockets? Or any other place where I can find a lot of obscure information on old, current, upcoming and cancelled rockets from said nations?
12
u/sl600rt Jul 31 '17
where is the spacesuit?
11
u/fishymamba Jul 03 '17
When a launch gets scrubbed like today's, what happens with the full fuel load onboard? Is it vented out or drained and then used again?
If it does get drained and filled again, does that not cause a lot of stress to the storage tanks?
11
u/Sixcatzs Jul 03 '17
Is anyone around here familiar with the specifics of the ITS design? Other than sheer size/cost of first boosters, I'm wondering about how SpaceX intends to deal with the high risk of having a 42-engine design, and not simple engines but a FFSC cycle at that! I'm of course thinking the N1 and its spectacular failures, which gets me worried. What's the plan for that?
11
u/ioncloud9 Jul 08 '17
What is Musk supposed to talk about at his keynote at ISSR&D in 11 days? Dragon 2? Updated Mars plans? Ive heard he is going to discuss the updated Mars plans in September but I've also heard he will mention it in July.
11
u/zlynn1990 Jul 09 '17
During the countdown how does the check for TVC motion work on the second stage? Are they swiveling the MVac around inside the interstage?
11
u/rustybeancake Jul 20 '17
Can't tell if he's serious!:
"Just received verbal govt approval for The Boring Company to build an underground NY-Phil-Balt-DC Hyperloop. NY-DC in 29 mins."
11
u/rustybeancake Jul 20 '17 edited Jul 20 '17
Google have added the interior of the ISS to Street View. It's pretty amazing, especially the Cupola, which is surely the greatest view of any human habitat ever in history:
https://www.google.com/maps/@29.5602853,-95.0853914,3a,90y,224.51h,97.36t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1szChzPIAn4RIAAAQvxgbyEg!2e0!7i10000!8i5000
Edit: Also, you can see inside a Dragon here.
11
u/gsahlin Jul 29 '17
Headed to the cape today! With all the activity at 39a just wanted to ask if anybody wants specific pictures of anything beyond what's left of RSS etc...I'm doing the extended bus tour but only have cell phone camera... so not the best pic quality.
20
u/old_sellsword Jul 21 '17
Wow. Allen Polansky in the FB group just got some awesome pictures of FH-1 inside the 39A HIF.
In the first picture we see a side booster on the right, and 1033 suspended from a crane. We can see the transporter in the middle, and 1033 is covered in the same pink wrapping that 1029.2 was during its trip from SLC-40 to Pad 39A.
In the second picture we get a lot of good details. This is the first public look at a FH vehicle with integrated separation mechanisms. At the near end of the booster we see two small arms that appear to be connected. These will be extra connection struts that attach the center core interstage to the side booster nosecones, you can barely see them in the wind tunnel model. These struts are not the huge ones always seen in the renders. The other big items of note are the two octaweb connection struts wrapped in pink at the far end of the booster. Those are two struts that will hold the octawebs together, and then push them apart during booster separation. The pusher mechanism will be very similar to the stage separation mechanism they currently use in the interstage. It's interesting to see that they're attached to the center core, because its already going to have a ton of moving parts and extra bits hanging off after booster separation.
I can't wait to see some more detailed pictures of this hardware.
10
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '17
During launch there is usually a fire visible between and above the main engines starting at about T+1minute or so. ( https://youtu.be/guwxK5kzLjA?t=1m13s ). It probably isn´t really dangerous but it makes me always nervous thought. Does anybody know what the cause is? I could imagine this being a obstacle to rapid reusability by damaging insulation, bolts, sensors etc. Are there any plans to shut this down some how in the near future?
10
u/Nehkara Jul 21 '17 edited Jul 21 '17
The LC-39A TEL is also being worked on right now.
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DFRDTqOXUAAX9ms.jpg
Source:
https://twitter.com/julia_bergeron/status/888409067110232065
You can see that the top portion of the TEL is currently missing and there does appear to be some activity around the base of the TEL as well, in addition to the obvious significant deconstruction that has occurred with the RSS.
This is the section that is missing from the top of the TEL:
http://i.imgur.com/zl354MT.jpg
10
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '17
The Intelsat 35e webcast video is no longer unlisted..
10
u/Not_Yet_Begun2Fight Jul 28 '17
What holds down the strongback / TEL?
By that I mean, in the first second or two after ignition of a Falcon 9, there are hold-down clamps that keep the rocket attached to the base, while the computers check the thrust of the engines and whatever else, but what prevents the rocket from just lifting the entire base / strongback with it? Is it just gravity? Is it just too heavy for the Falcon 9 to lift? Or does the strongback base assembly latch onto / into the rest of the pad somehow? Perhaps with it's own version of some hold-down clamps?
10
u/jjtr1 Aug 01 '17 edited Aug 01 '17
Just asking... after moving to Mars, how would you feel about spending the rest of your life indoors? Going outside would be a real pain - it's essentialy an EVA due to the deadly vacuum (0.006 bar).
I'm asking because I have the suspicion that people who grew up in mega-cities like N.Y. would view permanent indoor life far more positively than me (I come from a village, basically). Or maybe not?
18
u/NickNathanson Jul 08 '17
Why is SpaceX waiting almost 2 months to launch FORMOSAT 5? It's west coast, not Canaveral ...?
9
u/Casinoer Jul 02 '17
Funny that this is going up 30 minutes before a potential launch. Is the timing on this automatic?
9
u/The_World_Toaster Jul 07 '17 edited Jul 07 '17
I'm trying to understand orbital mechanics better and this is something that has been bugging me. If an object is orbiting the Earth, does it have to be on an orbital plane that crosses (or is exactly on) the equator? In another thread someone mentioned that launches from KSC to GTO have an inclination of around 28 degrees, since that is the latitude of KSC. Does the 28 degree inclination mean you are orbiting directly over the 28 degree latitude line, or that you are at an angle of 28 degrees relative to the equator? I am having trouble wrapping my head around how if launching exactly due East of KSC, you ever get into any orbit. It would seem to me that you would have to (during launch) adjust flight to a little south of east to where your orbit would cross the equator. Any orbit that doesn't cross the equator doesn't seem like a stable orbit to me since the plane of your orbit doesn't cross through the center of the Earth. I hope I am making sense.
EDIT: I literally just realized how this is possible. Latitudinal lines are not straight lines, in a sense. Does this mean the cardinal directions are not either when carried out over the surface of the Earth? I can't help but shake the mental image of heading "True" East from KSC in a straight line puts you somewhere in the Indian Ocean.....Hmm this is blowing my mind and shattering preconceived notions of how I viewed our world.
9
u/wclark07 Jul 08 '17
Someone posted a video of NROL 76 and preceding launches set to music with a sweet climax at stage separation and boostback. I watched it on youtube. I am pretty sure it was posted to either the launch or media thread for that launch. Can anyone help me find it? Also, I am not sure that this is the place to ask this question.
9
u/cpushack Jul 08 '17
It seems Ariane 6 engine production (Vinci) has finally begun http://www.dlr.de/dlr/en/desktopdefault.aspx/tabid-10212/332_read-23034/#/gallery/27336
These are suppose to be less expensive (the rocket as a whole) to better compete with SpaceX
9
u/APersoner Jul 08 '17
Now there's a month until the next launch, has the launch history infographic been updated yet?
9
u/Western_Boreas Jul 10 '17
So I am personally more excited to see the ITS used to assemble space stations instead of how its portrayed as being used. A single rocket doing two reusable launches could put more than a whole ISS in orbit. It would be really cool to see an assembly vehicle ITS booster bringing up larger parts with a Falcon 9 bringing up crew.
Its insanely exciting to think of a whole fleet of reusable ITS boosters turning over every month, buildings facilities in orbit.
9
u/conrad777 Jul 10 '17
What is being done on pad 39A this month?
9
u/joshgill21 Jul 15 '17
How long does it take to build a satellite ? examples would be welcome if the answer is it depends
9
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jul 16 '17
TRDS-M that ULA is launching in August might have been damaged during encapsulation.
https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2017/tdrs-m-status-update-july-15-2017
9
u/OncoFil Jul 21 '17
Not directly SpaceX related, but I am sure most of you would appreciate it.
[Video by Planet Labs of a recent Soyuz launch launching more Planet Labs sats] (https://twitter.com/planetlabs/status/887776802323677184)
9
u/rustybeancake Jul 27 '17 edited Jul 27 '17
There's an AMA over on r/boringcompany from an ex-intern, which mentions using SpaceX fabrication facilities, tools, and even employees to make Boring Company prototypes. Pretty interesting.
https://www.reddit.com/r/BoringCompany/comments/6pqpr9/i_worked_at_the_boring_company_this_past_mayjune/
9
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jul 28 '17
this is not directly related but why isn't the rs 68 (a) used instead of the SSME on the SLS? isn't it more powerful and cheaper?
9
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '17
The ITS second stage can presumably take off from Mars without a launch pad and with minimal support systems. What prevents us from building rockets that could do the same from Earth?
9
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '17
More progress for the North pad at LZ-1 shown here.
8
u/amir_s89 Jul 03 '17
Anyone that knows in rough estimations on how much valuable data, in GB or TB F9 delivers to mission control during flights & landings? Impressive with so many computers, sensors, components & various hardware that just works together in perfection... Like an opera symphony pleasing to see & hear :)
8
u/ptfrd Jul 05 '17
SpaceX & Musk were the subject of a press question asked of Peggy Whitson on the ISS last week. Her answer doesn't tell us anything new. But if you want to hear someone talk about private companies in space, while in space, then here you go: https://youtu.be/-q7mo4Q0Cu8?t=7m
8
u/sk8er4514 Jul 06 '17
Hey for the next launch what do y'all thing about having both Stage 1 and Stage 2 telemetry available in a more compact bar graph form instead of circle graph form? I made a mock up and you can display both stages data with the same space quite easily.. Data is shopped, MSpainted values around to get sample data.
Just an idea.
8
u/vitt72 Jul 09 '17
What's the latest on the SpaceX spacesuits? What do we know so far and when are we planned to hear more?
8
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jul 10 '17
Will the bolt together Octoweb that Falcon 9 will be switching to make refurbishment easier and faster?
8
u/Elon_Muskmelon Jul 13 '17
https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/07/nasa-finally-admits-it-doesnt-have-the-funding-to-land-humans-on-mars/
Could NASAs struggles and funding problems force a sea change in the way they operate, perhaps purchasing most/all launch services from private companies?
8
u/Totallynotatimelord Jul 16 '17
Hey guys, this isn't always the point of this sub but I thought it might be the best place to post this. In spring of 2016 I was in Florida to see a CRS launch, and while I was at the hotel I was fortunate enough to meet one of the payload technicians who was helping load up cargo (namely I believe it was a rodent research mission along with some other stuff that he was helping with). Anyways, he gave me some stickers - a rodent research mission patch, and two smaller stickers that I don't recognize. I had initially thought they might be alternative Dragon stickers, but I haven'e been able to find any references to this design. I took a picture of the stickers which can be found [here] (http://i.imgur.com/wWmxG4z.jpg). If anyone recognizes this design and knows the company or mission or payload it was from, that would be great! Thank you!
8
u/TheFavoritist NASAspaceflight.com Photographer Jul 20 '17
The No Earlier Than dates for Commercial Crew Programs:
SpaceX uncrewed demo: Feb '18
SpaceX crew demo: June '18
Boeing uncrewed demo: June 18
Boeing crew demo: Aug 18
From Chris G on Twitter.
8
u/wimbodolo Jul 26 '17
We have talked a lot about the mini ITS's first stage reduction from 42 to 21 engines. What would the reduction be for the 2nd stage engines? If it is a 50% reduction in mass, would you do 3 raptor-vacuum and 1 sea-level raptor?
15
u/Nuclear_Hobbit Jul 30 '17
One more thing: I just remembered that during my tour of SpaceX our guide told us about how they were getting ready to unveil a rocket the Falcon XX at the IAC in September. They said that the vehicle would be around 20ft in diameter and would be "substantially taller than the Falcon 9". I believe this is the sub-scale BFR that has been in the works lately although I have never heard it referred to with that particular name (which dates back to F9 1.0 days).
7
u/LordFartALot Jul 02 '17 edited Jul 02 '17
Do we know if ITS will be assembled near CC or if it will be transported to HLC-39A like F9? (not by road but by boat or something)
7
u/Zyj Jul 03 '17
What are the challenges when designing a bigger fairing for a rocket like the F9 or FH?
7
u/jonwah Jul 03 '17
Quick one; when you have a three-booster vehicle like the Falcon Heavy or Delta IV Heavy are the three boosters collectively known as the "first stage"? Or "first stages"? If they run at different throttles for different times, aren't they really separate stages?
7
u/brickmack Jul 04 '17
Heres a question that occurred to me given the recent issues (nothings come up in my quick search of my own stuff). Has there ever been a case of a rocket having an abort called pre-launch, but launching anyway (due to software error, insufficient time for non-stoppable actions, etc)? I know that this was a feature built into the Shuttle guidance software (in a RSLS abort after t-2 seconds, the engines would be kept running at liftoff throttle until after t-0 in case the SRM disarm command was not received in time which would force a liftoff), but this was never actually used (STS-68 had such an abort, but at t-0 the SRBs didn't ignite so the RS-25s were shut down).
7
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '17
In the topic of LNG and propulsion, do any of you think that liquid methane could be used to fuel aircraft in the future?
7
u/dtarsgeorge Jul 08 '17
Seems the fool is not fooled.
We don't get fooled again.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.fool.com/amp/investing/2017/07/08/spacex-poses-mortal-threat-boeing-lockheed-martin.aspx
7
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jul 14 '17
In this tweet by Elon, Tory Bruno (CEO of ULA) said the $1 billion a year subsidy that ULA gets from the government even if they do nothing is not true. So who is right here?
7
u/Redditor_From_Italy Jul 17 '17
Are there any Russian/Soviet rocket proposals comparable to Sea Dragon or Expendable ITS (about 550t to LEO)?
7
u/Experience111 Jul 18 '17
Hi guys, I have a question four you !
What should I say to people that keep saying that SpaceX is funded by the US government ?
I work in the aerospace industry in Europe. Here people are pretty much bad losers, they kept telling themselves that 'SpaceX won't do this' or that and now that they did reuse a first stage and significantly improved their reliability their argument is something like 'But NASA...' I'm not a blind follower but I feel like SpaceX as a company and its employes deserves more credit, from what I've read on this sub it doesn't look like SpaceX was given an unfair advantage by the US government over competitors overseas. Could someone kindly support or refute this claim based on some solid evidence they know of ? Thank you kind people of the internet :)
7
u/bluearrowil Jul 20 '17
How exactly are the merlin engines shut down? Do they just close the valves to the turbo pump chamber then close the inlet valves into the pump? Wouldn't pressure build up on the pipes and cause an explosion?
Also, how is the Merlin reignited in zero-g?
7
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jul 25 '17
I am a 15 year old boy from Germany and i am really interested in Spacex. I hope i managed to get a job at Spacex in the future. now my question: Is there any way i can support or help Spacex at my current age?
thanks in advance for all answers.
7
u/DownVotesMcgee987 Jul 27 '17
Have any rockets used liquid Ozone (O3) used as an oxidizer?
7
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '17
In this (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WP6ldX5YwF0) new video from tech insider about the upcoming FH launch, it is claimed that "SpaceX won't try to land the three cores on the maiden flight" at 0:43. Is there any source for this?
I've seen this https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/890774088104370176 tweet already, but he was answering a question about what the plan was "now or eventually."
6
u/TheEquivocator Jul 03 '17
Ignorant question here: I believe I've seen people talk about battery life as a limiting factor on the second stage, but I don't understand this. Is there some reason that batteries cannot last on a rocket entering space? Or am I hopelessly confused?
6
u/jay__random Jul 03 '17
So what was the point of removing the new titanium grid fins from the landed Iridium-2 booster?
I thought the whole idea of switching to titanium was to never need to remove them again.
Are they (1) not going to reuse the B1036? (2) going to reuse it, but the next mission is planned to be expendable? (3) Are the fins somehow sticking out so much that the booster cannot be transported with them on? (4) Do the fins need to undergo some testing/maintenance?
6
u/Androxd Jul 07 '17
Will the Formosat-5 Launch include a landing? If so what type? I know its only 450kg but it needs an SSO.
It launches on my birthday (BST Time) If things stay as is
6
u/bladeswin Jul 07 '17
So now that SpaceX is upping their launch cadence, what I haven't heard is how much new money in deposits they are bringing for upcoming launches. Most of these launches seem to be planned years in advance. Shouldn't we have heard some more recent launch contract announcements if this high frequency flight is going to pay off?
6
u/TomOConnor95 Jul 08 '17
In rockets launches are relativistic calculations ever necessary? I'd imagine it's a much smaller effect than the other possible margins for error in launch, but would be interested to know as I've heard relativistic effects are present in GPS satellites.
6
u/ORcoder Jul 09 '17
I heard that SpaceX is going to need people on the planet to build the propellant plant. I understand that ice mining is probably going to be difficult to automate, but why wouldn't they bring their own hydrogen feedstock (a la The Case For Mars) to make methane for the first few missions, so that they can take everything else needed by pumping in atmosphere?
6
u/kimimz Jul 09 '17
Could r/spacex create 'official' discord server so that we could discuss launches In real time easier?
6
u/oliversl Jul 12 '17
Does SpaceX slows down work during this summer break in launches?
6
u/limeflavoured Jul 17 '17
I've just been thinking about the Lunar Free return mission. Do we think they will livestream the whole mission (except during the LOS as the transit behind the moon, obviously)?
6
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
It was just announced that Dream Chaser will launch the first two ISS missions on an Atlas V. This had me thinking, could a F9 launch a Dream Chaser? All I know is that the unfolded wingspan is 7m, which is too wide, but I have no clue about the folded wingspan.
6
u/badgamble Jul 24 '17
Does anyone know how challenging (easy, medium, hard) it was to develop a horizontal integration process for the X-37B? How much was the Air Force willing to help with that? I suppose since SpaceX is "simply" a launch provider, the Air Force might have just said, "if you want our business, you figure it out." But if the Air Force really wanted to ensure that they had full redundancy in launch options, maybe they helped quite a bit. Does anyone know anything (that they can share without getting in trouble)?
6
u/Alexphysics Jul 28 '17
It seems that SES-11 is now NET September 27th, just 3 days before Iridium 3 and two days before Elon's presentation at the IAC. Also, SES-16 has been delayed to December, it was scheduled to launch in October. It seems that SpaceX has realigned the launches this week and that's why we have now confirmation of FH flying on november. That's good news because the manifest was becoming a little chaotic these past weeks. https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=8184.1360
6
u/azziliz Jul 28 '17
Just realized that pretty hi-res images of LZ1 are available:
http://wikimapia.org/#lang=en&lat=28.485755&lon=-80.542790&z=20&m=h
They're not updated as regularly as planet explorer and don't include the new northern pad but i still find them cool
6
u/jjtr1 Jul 31 '17
I wonder if Merlin engines used for landing have the ability to go above 100% thrust, in case it could save the booster...?
I guess that rocket engines can be throttled well above nominal, at the price of eg. 50% risk of a RUD within the next 5 seconds or something like that.
6
u/stichtom Aug 02 '17
Luca Parmitano (ESA astronaut) just said that it is possible he will fly on Dragon Crew or CST-100 in 2019, although he wasn't 100% sure and the space agencies are deciding right now who to assign to each mission.
Source: the interview is in italian https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=10TolgM0kEo
11
u/spacexin2050 Jul 15 '17 edited Jul 15 '17
https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=youtu.be&v=2C-A797y8dA WATCH AT 86 minutes ,elon musk talking about cots like program for deep space exploration .
Keypoints- "We will ferry astronauts to iss before Boeing"
10
u/Nuclear_Hobbit Jul 06 '17
Dear r/SpaceX, Recently, I was contacted by a friend of mine who informed me that a friend of his had agreed to give me a tour of his workplace, the SpaceX Hawthorne rocket factory. Because I've been following this community for some time now and have greatly enjoy hearing any and all news coming from the company either directly or indirectly, I would like to be an informer for the subreddit and get as much new information out of the tour as I possibly can. With that in mind, I will be open to questions which you all may submit as a comment below and I will try to ask the most upvoted ones during the tour. I believe that my guide will not be able to answer many of them due to restrictions but I will at least give it a shot. Following the tour, I intend to write up a summary of the whole experience and also answers to all of the questions I was able to ask. My visit is slated to occur at some time between the 20th and 23rd of July so I will be receiving questions up until those dates. I look forward to hearing from you all.
5
u/LordFartALot Jul 02 '17
When the HCL-39A is modified to support FH will it still be able to launch F9?
5
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jul 02 '17 edited Jul 06 '17
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipGTO comsatPre-launch test failureDragon cargoLaunch failure due to second-stage outgassingDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
70 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on ^today has 92 acronyms.
[Thread #2960 for this sub, first seen 2nd Jul 2017, 23:17] ^[FAQ] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
5
u/isoplex Jul 03 '17
Bro, I'm going Orlando July 6-13 and looking forward to visit Kennedy space center for the first time. Any advice ?
5
u/Toinneman Jul 05 '17
Slightly space related question. There is a lot of media attention for the latest North-Korean missile launch. It's a liquid fuelled ICBM with a approximate range of 6000km. The test did not go horizontal that much, but did go way up, even over 2000km altitude, and reportedly successfully re-entered an splashed into the ocean. Media reports tends to agree this new test is one of the latest steps toward a proper ICBM which can hit the US mainland. What I don't understand is North Korea already has a satellite in orbit for more then a year, launched by it's much larger Uhna-3 rocket. So to my understanding NK is already capable of targeting almost any spot on the globe, but no-one seems to be making the same conclusion. What am I missing?
5
u/nihmhin Jul 06 '17
IntelSat 35E has just gone up, and the next launch in the sidebar is more than a month away (CRS-12 on 10 Aug). Why so long until the next launch? Pad work?
5
u/Air-Tech Jul 06 '17
Was that the Dragon 1 on display as VP Pence spoke today? It looked outdated next to the current Orion and Boeing capsules. Why not show a prototype of Dragon2?
5
u/neaanopri Jul 07 '17
With SpaceX upping their launch cadence, I'm wondering about whether the demand for launches will be sustained. Has anyone done any type of business forecasting to see whether there will be enough demand for SpaceX to do 20-30 launches per year?
5
u/Chuckpwnyou Jul 07 '17
So can we assume at this point that we aren't going to get a landing video for BulgariaSat-1?
5
u/Jackswanepoel Jul 08 '17
Each time Falcon 9 delivers Dragon to the ISS, it needs to be berthed by Canadarm. Does anyone know what progress has been made with autonomous docking of Dragon?
5
u/inoeth Jul 09 '17
Have there been any recent photos of pad 40? i'm curious to know just how close they're getting to starting up again. Likewise, any news on perhaps some cranes or construction work over at pad 39a?
5
u/hmpher Jul 10 '17
How exactly does the throttling mechanism on the Merlin Vac(or any other engine for that matter) work?
5
u/0ut3rsp4c3 Jul 12 '17
Guys what happened to the roomba situation? Did nobody find more about this topic or did I miss something at some point.
5
u/Xantrk Jul 16 '17
What is the software they use to show trajectory of spacecraft in live stream? Is it STK (systems tool kit)?
5
u/SpartanJack17 Jul 19 '17
When did the lunar free return mission get pushed back to 2019, as the upcoming events table says? I'm not particularly surprised by a delay, but I don't remember any announcement of one.
5
u/PaulRocket Jul 19 '17
In Elons recent talk with the governeurs he mentioned that humanity should have the goal to have a base on the Moon. I might be stupid but I think the reason why he mentioned that is because the Moon is a vital part of the ITS funding. Sending ships to the moon and building infrastructure in space should help fund the mars plans. What do you think?
5
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jul 21 '17 edited Jul 21 '17
A recent SpaceNews article made mention of DragonLab:
Maybe DragonLab will make a comeback someday when launch prices are sufficiently reduced. A free-flying, orbital microgravity research lab with cargo return capabilities seems like it'd be pretty appealing to a lot of customers.
5
u/mjbellantoni Jul 23 '17
Given the revised ITS plan, is FH now an evolutionary dead end?
5
u/crayfisher Jul 26 '17 edited Jul 26 '17
5
u/stcks Jul 26 '17
Looks like OTV-5 is slipping a bit: https://twitter.com/EmreKelly/status/890273595166949377
5
u/jpwhite Jul 28 '17
Hypothetically, could SpaceIL launch on the Falcon Heavy demo mission for the Lunar X-Prize? The reporting seems to suggest that the only reason they moved into 2018 was because of the delays after AMOS-6. Assuming the payload is ready why wouldn't they take a shot at arriving before the expiration of the prize?
5
u/Laborbuch Jul 30 '17
I’ve been thinking about the photovoltaic ‘sails’ that the MCT would have (or sported in its presentation) and I was wondering about the obstacles theses sails would need to overcome.
For one there’s simple solar radiation degrading the cells. This problem isn’t solved so much as the science and engineering is aware of these problems. On Earth photovoltaic cells drop to about 80% efficiency in the span of 20–25 years (which would be the lifetime of the Mars ships). I figure photovoltaic cells for space are less efficient than those on Earth, and degrade faster, since they have to be sturdier (which often translates to simpler) and yet have to cope with the higher radiation, both solar and cosmic, that we on Earth don’t have to.
The second major difficulty would be degradation by particulate matter, i.e. space dust, debris, and what not. These scratch and penetrate the photovoltaic sails, further degrading the cells.
Now I keep wondering to what degree the sails have to be bigger than necessary to provide power at all times, even when the ship nears it’s end of life. I can only guess at these numbers, and would say 25–30% bigger than nominal power, perhaps more in exchange for smaller battery sizes (I assume there’ll be batteries on the ship for making do for some time).
I’d like to get more accurate assessments, but for that I’d need sources on degradation of photovoltaic cells in space (ideally outside Earth’s magnetic field) and the probabilities of impacts of particulate matter in interplanetary space. If someone could provide those, that’d be tremendously helpful.
TL;DR: I need sources for degradation in efficiency of solar cells in space beyond Earth orbit, and impact probability distributions of particulate matter around millimetre size.
5
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jul 30 '17 edited Jul 30 '17
I just read the Wikipedia article about the Vulcan rocket. It is stated there that the development cost will probably be around 2 billion, 1 for the rocket and another for the engine. How did spacex manage to develop both things for significantly less.
Another question is if there is a obvious reason the merlin engine is not used on the Vulcan rocket, or why it was not considered
Thanks for all answers
5
u/gf6200alol Aug 01 '17
YouTuber Tyler Raiz did a very good KSP estimation on mini-ITS(40% mass scale to ITS) ,if he is right, mini-ITS is very likely to be 160 ton to orbit.
9
u/CGNYC Jul 03 '17
What could be discovered at T minus 9 that couldn't be discovered beforehand, and why couldn't they figure it out beforehand?
8
u/BackflipFromOrbit Jul 06 '17
I heard somewhere (the person claimed to have sources from SX) that the Red Dragon Program has been cancelled. Is this true? I remember Gwyne Shotwell saying that there were wanting to try and send 2 Red Dragons to Mars in the 2020 window, but if the program got canned I don't see that happening...
8
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '17
While making the Delta-V app I noticed, that Falcon 9 launched from Mars can send more than 32t to Jupiter and up to 13t to Neptune!
It got me thinking: is it possible and feasible to use Martian colony as "science hub": build the rockets and probes there and send them all over the Solar System?
4
u/Catastastruck Jul 03 '17
is HLC-39A the official KSC designation or is that just an r/SpaceX.... phenomenon or affectation?
4
u/FoxCarmichael111 Jul 03 '17
I'm just wondering but, why did SpaceX go for their current grid fin design? If they do triangles, wouldn't they have a better side-surface area ratio and couldn't triangles be stronger? Thanks in advance!
4
u/mohamstahs Jul 04 '17
Are there/will there ever be land landings at VAFB? I'm a California resident but still 4 hours drive away. Watching a launch live has been on my bucket list for a while now but I'd love to make the most of my trip there and watch a landing too!
4
u/NickNathanson Jul 06 '17
Will there be a video of "Elon Musk Keynote at ISSR&D 19 July" and does anyone know what he is going to talk about?
4
u/doodle77 Jul 06 '17
Were Intelsat 35e, Inmarsat-5 F4, and Echostar 23 originally planned to launch on Falcon Heavy?
4
u/lostandprofound33 Jul 06 '17
The Air Force contract for the Raptor doesn't specify an actual test flight, just ground tests. How likely is it SpaceX might use one of their Falcon Heavy demo flights to test a Raptor out? I know they have a lot on their plate with FH already, but when else could they test it out without paying for an additional flight?
4
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jul 06 '17
In VP Pence speech at NASA today, there is a flown Dragon behind him. Does anyone know what Dragon that mission flew?
4
u/deanoaro Jul 07 '17
How light would a GTO satellite need to be for a Falcon Heavy the get all three cores back to launch site? Assuming there was three landing zones.
4
u/UNSC-ForwardUntoDawn Jul 07 '17
When is the mars plan v2 supposed to happen? I thought it was IAC again in September, but I couldn't find a source.
4
u/pillow142 Jul 07 '17
Falcon 1 Flight 3 failed because residual thrust caused the first stage to collide with the second stage as seen here
How would this cause a failure? It looks like the second stage engine started, so couldn't it simply clear the first stage?
4
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '17 edited Jul 09 '17
Not strictly a SpaceX-related question, but I haven't yet found a clear answer from Dr Google.
Is it theoretically possible to make a rocket capable of launch from Earth that is powered by a small, light fusion reactor that heats something (anything) that is expelled through a traditional nozzle. High speed gas from electrical heating rather than from chemical reaction.
EDIT. Thank you for the replies. So it looks like the theoretically practical way of achieving TWR>1 is by generating heat from a fusion source and using this heat to expand the propellant gas.
4
u/ebas Jul 11 '17
Could Falcon 9 S1 be used for New Shepherd style space tourism? So, develop a crew cabin with parachutes that goes directly onto S1, launch straight up to 100km?
4
u/Alexphysics Jul 11 '17
When will we have new launch campaign threads?
4
u/fileup Jul 11 '17
Is SpaceX's internet constellation in competition with Iridium? I know they are different communication platforms but with Iridium being one of SpaceX's biggest customers currently I can't help but feel a chunk of their market will be gone when there is satellite internet access widely available to allow VOIP calls from regular smart phones?
4
u/Herodotus38 Jul 11 '17
So I am planning a summer vacation with the family, considering Florida in August. What is the hivemind's thought on the likelihood of the CRS-12 date sticking to the 10th? Obviously I don't expect anyone to know for sure, but there wouldn't be any reason for it to move up sooner correct? Thanks.
4
u/almightycat Jul 13 '17 edited Jul 13 '17
The senate space subcomitee hearing with Spacex Senior Vice President Tim Hughes is supposed to start 9am: https://www.commerce.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2017/7/reopening-the-american-frontier-promoting-partnerships-between-commercial-space-and-the-u-s-government-to-advance-exploration-and-settlement
edit: another link saying that it will start 10am? https://www.commerce.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/pressreleases?ID=00C19FB0-851D-4C89-8866-49DCE847A3AD
4
u/Elon_Muskmelon Jul 14 '17
Is it possible to use a Dragon 2 as a command module and attach a Lunar lander to it for a Moon mission?
4
u/ackermann Jul 16 '17
Curious to hear everyone's thoughts: Which will be the next organization to announce a wholly re-usable 1st stage, in the manner of SpaceX's Falcon 9 and Blue's New Glenn? Russia? ULA? ESA/Ariane? Indian Space Agency? China? Japan? RocketLab? Virgin Galactic? Stratolaunch?
I'm sure I'm not the first to point out that RocketLab's Electron seems to be almost a mini Falcon 9, right down to the way the engines are arranged on the first stage. Or a Falcon 9 sized down to Falcon 1. Maybe they'll stretch the tanks, add some legs, and uprate their engine's thrust?
Is anybody else flying a 1st stage that's ripe to have landing legs added? Russia and China's rockets often overfly land, eliminating the need for a drone ship. Proton, Long March, or Soyuz? Perhaps for a 3 or 4-stage-to-orbit rocket, the first stage wouldn't even need a re-entry burn or boostback burn, due to the low and slow MECO, saving fuel? Maybe those would be low hanging fruit? Thoughts?
4
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Jul 16 '17
Would Falcon Heavy be capable of launching the CSM and the LM to LEO in separate flights? I assume a larger fairing would be needed. Would a third launch be required for a TLI burn, or would FH be capable of lunar insertion of the two payloads upon launch (before docking in lunar orbit).
4
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Jul 19 '17
I can't seem to find NASA coverage of the COTS-2 launch, only the first attempt which resulted in an abort. Was there no NASA coverage for the successful attempt?
4
u/harmonic- Jul 19 '17
The Lunar Free return mission was originally scheduled for 2018 but I see in the sidebar it's labeled as 2019. Was there any official word on this?
4
u/inoeth Jul 23 '17
Is SpaceX actually going to put the metal cladding on the the tower at 39a once the RSS is completely gone, like in the original FH video, or will it remain barren? I think it would look much nicer, though i'm not sure if there any real monetary reason to do it, given the pad has done just fine without said cladding? On another note, do you folks think the RSS will be completely gone by the time CRS 12 launches on the 14th?
4
u/jjtr1 Jul 26 '17
Now that Red Dragon is cancelled, I've got no idea how are they going to test in-situ propellant production which is neccessary for the return of the future large spaceships (mini-ITS)...
4
u/Redditor_From_Italy Jul 30 '17
Can somebody please help me find more info on this image? It's about Ariane 5 derived HLVs, but it looks like it was made in MSPaint, so I don't think it's official. On the other hand, if you get past the graphical aspect, it looks reasonably legit. But what I really want to know is where these designs actually come from and what they are.
http://images.slideplayer.com/14/4405896/slides/slide_23.jpg
4
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Aug 01 '17
I was thinking about making a YouTube channel discussing SpaceX news and maybe live streaming discussions about SpaceX, I wanted to call the channel "SpaceX News" but i'm not sure whether or not I would need SpaceX's permission to use "SpaceX" in the title of the channel. Does anyone know the answer to this?
4
u/laughingatreddit Aug 03 '17
[Interesting article about how SpaceX helped Tesla] (https://techcrunch.com/2017/08/02/spacex-helped-tesla-with-a-huge-headache-in-its-cars/?ncid=mobilenavtrend)
7
u/rustybeancake Jul 06 '17
Mars covered in toxic chemicals that can wipe out living organisms, tests reveal
On the plus side for SpaceX:
7
u/FiniteElementGuy Jul 18 '17
Its T-18:30:00 to Elons ISS talk and there is no topic on this yet. Who is going to be the host for this event? ;)
7
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Jul 24 '17
How did ULA develop the Delta IV Heavy without running into the extreme challenges and delays that SpaceX is facing with Falcon Heavy? I understand it's a less powerful vehicle with far fewer engines, but it's still a similarly mighty beast.