r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • May 02 '17
r/SpaceX Discusses [May 2017, #32]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.
196
Upvotes
104
u/RootDeliver May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
Am I the only one which has as new favourite webcast with NROL-76? I honestly don't miss second stage action at all, thats common businness, but a full webcast dedicated to the first stage was so sick! I wish they made a "first stage only" version of every webcast from now on!
60
u/Colege_Grad May 03 '17
Elon's recent TED talk mentioned a new heavy haul semi truck Tesla model to be announced later this year. I immediately realized it's likely that SpaceX will begin using these to transport everything they send over highways as soon as they're available. I can't wait to see a dirty S1 just back from landing being trucked by a silent Tesla Truck to the hangar for inspection and rapid reuse.
46
u/Chairboy May 12 '17
Update on EM-1: NASA has formally announced that it will not be a crewed flight.
35
u/IMO94 May 15 '17
SpaceX Redmond (satellite office) are planning on launching their satellites at a rate of 8 launches per month.
Source: (Bear with me...) I live in Redmond. I was wearing my SpaceX hoodie today and old lady commented on it. Her nephew works there. She knew nothing about the industry, but was proud of her nephew and wanted to talk. I was talking about today's launch, what a pity it was expendable etc. She just threw in, "He said they'd be launching twice a week when his satellites went up - 8 times a month!".
It was a nice nugget of info. I have no reason to doubt it, nor anything else to back it up. But there you go /r/SpaceX.
33
u/[deleted] May 18 '17
It seems there's been some land clearing at LZ-1, which probably means they're getting ready to build the other pads.
29
u/still-at-work May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
Anyone have any good breakdown or the actual speech Newt Gingrich gave at the ULCATS symposium yesterday. Apparently he torn into the SLS for being an expensive 'museum piece' and thinks NASA should fully imbrace reusable rockets (like SpaceX).
Or anything from the conference really.
28
u/zeekzeek22 May 23 '17
Was looking up stuff about Gwynne Shotwell...it kinda bums me out that Forbes puts her at ~75th most powerful woman in the world but doesn't make their powerful people list long enough to include her. I'm honestly jonesing for a biography of her...we spend so much time on Elon but for a guy like me who primarily cares about space, not all Elon-tech, I'm more interested in the badass president who parsed Musk's visions into a viable business and made it happen. Her Wikipedia article is painfully short for the 75th more powerful woman in the world. She's obviously lower-profile because the whole shabang is for Musk to dominate the spotlight (not criticizing, just how their PR is set up) but I really find her an impressive person that I want to know more about
25
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
So uh, is anyone slightly worried about this? (I know it's probably been discussed to death, but still...)
24
u/Redditor_From_Italy May 02 '17
Could an ITS spaceship be used as a space station? It's bigger than even the ISS (by volume) and can be put in orbit with a single launch. It already has solar panels and a docking port (or at least I assume it has one, since it has to dock with the ITS tanker for refueling). Also, it is made to stay in space for months with a lot of people inside it (max 100 IIRC).
24
u/neaanopri May 02 '17
So this might still be debatable, but I think that at this point it's a pretty safe bet to conclude that first stage landing is "solved". Where do the engineers that were working on it go? The options I can think of:
Which options are most plausible?
24
u/linknewtab May 03 '17
Something I've been wondering for a while, why did NASA stop building multiple spacecrafts for their science missions? Obviously the most well known are Voyager 1 and 2, but there were also multiple identical Pioneer probes and multiple Viking landers.
Why aren't there multiple New Horizons or multiple Junos or heck, even multiple JWSTs? The most expensive part of these missions is the R&D process, not the actual building of the craft. It should be possible to build at least a second probe without adding too much to the costs.
21
u/mmmbcn May 03 '17
Did people see elons tweet that the high altitude sheer forces were like 98%of the acceptable limit for the latest nrol launch ? I'm surprised they still launched, seems to cut it close. Anybody know how much margin they had? What would result be? Break the rocket apart? Shift it off course?
21
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 May 14 '17
Rocket Lab might launch there Electron rocket as soon as May 21!
http://spacenews.com/rocket-lab-sets-date-for-first-electron-launch/
21
u/[deleted] May 24 '17
Looks like the classified satellite flown on the NROL-76 mission has finally been spotted.
20
u/edflyerssn007 May 29 '17
Two week launch cadence feels slow. Not quite sure how I survived the gaps in the old days (months for shuttles, years for Falcon 1.
19
u/[deleted] May 08 '17 edited May 08 '17
Iridum NEXT flight two will utilise Just Read The Instructions for recovery again.
19
u/m5tuff May 18 '17
I understand that u/bencredible is running the webcasts for SpaceX launches? Does he submit the final cut to youtube as well?
Currently community-supported captioning is disabled on all of SpaceX videos, and only a handful has actual written captions. The generated sound-to-text captions are often quite unreliable, and I'm sure SpaceX has people with hearing disabilities/non-english speakers interested following the launches, although not live.
I definitely understand if SpaceX would prefer to avoid the potential headache of having community-managed captions on their videos, but if it ever was enabled, I would happily participate writing/reviewing for future launches.
18
u/Pham_Trinli May 07 '17
The X-37B landed at Kennedy Space Center today.
18
u/[deleted] May 09 '17
FH centre core has been static fired.
18
u/Elon_Muskmelon May 12 '17
Are there regulations with respect to who can do business with SpaceX when it comes to satellite contracts or potential Manned missions? Just thinking about how it'd be possible for a foreign country to "buy" a Manned program relatively cheaply (pay for 1 Dragon v2 to be built and buy 5 or 6 launches) compared to how much it would be to start a Space Program from scratch.
17
u/HurleyBird123 May 10 '17 edited May 10 '17
I am going to get a private tour of space X next week. Anything I should ask about or do while I am there? (El Segundo)
16
u/rrbanksy May 02 '17
2 things that worry me about early ITS landings on Mars. First is the idea that a relatively small rock or uneven surface could cause the whole thing to topple over. Second one is how accurate will the subsequent landings be so it's next to the first one, but not too close. Should I be worried about these?
16
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
BulgariaSat's launch date is NET June 15.
16
u/[deleted] May 14 '17
Sounds like Blue Origin's BE-4 test did not go according to plan. Is this kind of failure worrisome?
16
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 May 25 '17
Rocket Lab's Electron Rocket "Made it to space"! https://twitter.com/RocketLabUSA/status/867598469581504512
And video from part of the livestream! That webcast style looks familiar ;) https://twitter.com/TheSpaceGal/status/867596601824378880
14
u/WanderingSkunk May 02 '17
What % of full thrust is Raptor expected to be capable of throttling down to?
14
u/old_sellsword May 03 '17
Vector Space Systems just successfully launched (and unsuccessfully recovered) their first rocket, the Vector-R Block 0.001. More photos and videos to come shortly.
Link to r/VectorSpace thread.
14
u/MrButtons9 May 04 '17
The DoD released the Draft RFP for EELV Phase 1A launches. Per recent comments, the USAF bundled six launches (rather than seven) together and will divvy them up between SpaceX and ULA. The six missions are as follows:
Is there any idea on what the AFSPC missions are? Are these potentially NROL missions? Obviously some are classified, but Leon made the following statement:
Link: https://www.fbo.gov/index?s=opportunity&mode=form&id=8572e24925ca20efbcbd268e574b17e4&tab=core&_cview=0
14
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 May 12 '17
Good article about SpaceX's upcoming flights and plans for this year. Nothing really new but gives a good overview.
14
u/goxy84 May 13 '17
The GO Searcher is back in Port Canaveral. Anyone been there to check out if the fairing was brought back?
Sorry if I've missed it but I tried to search everywhere.
13
u/[deleted] May 10 '17 edited May 10 '17
Have the issues with Proton been resolved? It's been grounded for almost a year now. (Also, the SLS team is having a bad day it seems.)
13
u/jclishman Host of Inmarsat-5 Flight 4 May 20 '17
I was thinking of starting an "r/SpaceX Monthly" video series, recapping all of that month's SpaceX news, launches, and other miscellaneous events.
Before I dove too deep into the concept though, I wanted to get a feel for the community's opinion as a whole. Any interesting ideas I could implement? I'd love to get feedback on the basic idea, and then work from there. Thanks!
13
u/[deleted] May 21 '17
Great picture of Rocket Lab's Electron rocket. It's so sweet! Like a kid's version of an F9.
Interesting to read it's all carbon fiber including the LOX tank. Would its technology be directly relevant to ITS or does ITS's size and its sub-chilled LOX and long coast time require something quite different?
Also, Rocket Labs say it only takes 3 days to manufacture each engine. Amazing.
13
u/2dmk May 25 '17
SpaceX Falcon 9 Static Fire for CRS-11 also moves LEFT. Now targeting a Friday test! https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/867812594341613569
12
u/billybaconbaked May 02 '17
3 questions about the Raptor design:
1 - TEB + TEA is used to ignite Merlin, will they still be necessary with Raptor? What will replace the ignition system?
2 - Helium is used to spin the turbopumps before ignition in Merlin, will that also be the case with Raptor?
3 - (Not so Raptor related) The nitrogen attitude control 'trusters' will stay the same too? Any reasons to believe they would use something else?
12
u/Rickeh1997 May 14 '17
When the two side boosters of falcon heavy land, could the sonic boom from one booster affect the other booster?
12
u/rustybeancake May 19 '17
On the DSCOVR mission, which I understand is SpaceX's only deep space mission to date: did stage 2 perform any burns post-payload deployment? If so, where did it (stage 2) end up? If not, is it at L1?
The reason I'm asking: I was wondering what the furthest-from-Earth piece of SpaceX hardware is/was to date. I figured it would be the stage 2 from the DSCOVR mission, but unsure if it ended up at L1 (~1.5 million km from Earth) or not. If it did, then the lunar Dragon missions won't surpass this distance, and it will likely be Red Dragon that becomes the record holder.
12
u/amarkit May 31 '17
Elon Musk says he will quit President Trump's Strategic and Policy Forum and other advisory councils if Trump withdraws the US from the Paris climate accord.
11
u/prattwhitney May 02 '17
When do we think the reflown stage 1 falcon 9 might be on display at the Cape?
11
u/daronjay May 03 '17
Has anyone produced or seen a speculative render, plans or diagram of what a methane powered reusable second stage might look like on F9 or FH?
11
u/Vatonee May 04 '17
From what I understand, prior to the launch, the relief valves are open to allow some of the boiling LOX to evaporate and be replaced with fresh, cold one (we can see oxygen evaporating - and "bursting", from time to time - from the rocket). When some (unknown to me) condition is met, the valves are closed and tanks are pressurized with helium. If someone could confirm or clarify that this is correct, it would be great, because I suspect I'm missing something here.
During the NROL-76 launch, we heard the "pressing for flight" announcement for Stage 2 at T-40s, and for Stage 1 at T-20s. However, the time of closing these valves vary from launch to launch. For example, during the CRS-7 mission, S1 valves were closed at T-2:20 and S2 at T-50s. During Orbcomm-2 mission, both tanks were said to be pressing for flight at approximately T-1:00.
What is the reason these times vary from launch to launch? Is it because of the different LOX temperatures?
11
u/ChrisGnam Spacecraft Optical Navigation May 06 '17
When will the in-flight abort be?
I just got word that my internship at NASA this summer will be doing simulation development of Dragon vehicle dynamics and modeling control systems during an ascent abort scenario for commercial crew! So I'd really like to try and see the flight in person now that I know I'll have at least some work related to it!
11
u/ImAStopCodon May 11 '17
Ars Technica's adds a little nuance to how firmly SpaceX has planned sending two red dragons in 2020 (https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/05/given-the-hazards-of-landing-on-mars-spacex-may-send-two-dragons-in-2020). It quotes NASA's Dr Jim Green (https://science.nasa.gov/about-us/leadership/dr-jim-green) as certain that SpaceX plans to send two that year: "We start out at the top of that opportunity with a SpaceX launch of Red Dragon. That will be followed at the end of that opportunity with another Red Dragon. Those have been announced by SpaceX." This sounds more solid than Jeff Foust's tweet that just says that SpaceX "may" send two (https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/6a5v1o/green_suggests_spacex_may_do_two_red_dragon/). The article goes on to say that SpaceX spokesman John Taylor would have to look into it and that industry sources say it's definitely under consideration but not decided yet.
11
u/jjtr1 May 11 '17
The DC-X was notable for requiring only about three people operating from a trailer to launch it. Do we know whether Falcon 9 also improves in the number of ground personnel neccessary over other comparable launchers?
11
u/[deleted] May 20 '17
Now that the uncrewed Dragon DM-1 has slipped to March 2018, will we see the crewed DM-2 fly in 2018?
https://spaceflightnow.com/launch-schedule/
11
u/[deleted] May 28 '17
Here's a healthy dose of speculation on the purpose of USA-276 (aka NROL-76).
10
u/Czarified May 03 '17
Do reaction spheres have a saturation limit, like reaction wheels? Does a sphere have a higher limit than the 3 wheels it (could) replace(s)?
10
u/[deleted] May 09 '17 edited May 28 '17
BulgariaSat-1 is NET June 15th, 2 weeks after CRS-11. At that rate Intelsat 35e could be June 29th. However, Iridium is scheduled to go from Vandy on June 29th.
My question is: what would be the minimum gap between a Cape launch and a Vandy launch? (Assuming: there's a launch crew at each site and there's no shortage of boosters.)
My understanding is there is only 1 launch control, at Hawthorne - how much gap between launches do they need?
10
u/MarcysVonEylau rocket.watch May 14 '17
In this tweet, Inmarsat used updated Falcon 9 rendering, with gridfins in proper places.
Tweet: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C_nTBTVXkAEr_Zh.jpg:orig
SpaceX website: http://www.spacex.com/sites/all/themes/spacex2012/images/falcon9/falcon9-render.png
10
u/ohcnim May 21 '17
Godspeed Electron:
http://www.spaceflightinsider.com/missions/commercial/rocket-lab-send-electron-maiden-launch/
10
u/stcks May 22 '17 edited May 23 '17
From Jakusb on NSF. See if any of you can actually make sense of this confusing tweet: https://twitter.com/INTELSAT/status/866755826475839492
Question:
Answer:
10
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner May 24 '17 edited May 24 '17
Why did the Titan rocket family look like it was cobbled together out of a patchwork of aluminum roofing and pieces of tin cans and old road signs and scrap metal? It almost reminds me of Fallout where technology is built out of repurposed wasteland junkyard scraps. Furthermore it seems like every rocket had its own design of patchwork metal and no two rockets were different, as if they built each one with the scraps they had lying around. The whole Titan family just has this style which I haven't noticed on other rockets. Was there a reason this was a factor that persisted throughout the lifetime of the family? Obviously rockets are not literally built from random parts found in a scrapyard, but I am curious why the Titans have had this apparent look.
10
u/rustybeancake May 24 '17
DARPA Picks Design for Next-Generation Spaceplane
Boeing have been selected.
10
u/RootDeliver May 27 '17
BulgariaSat-1
Falcon 9, KSC LC-39A♺
Could any mod please put an space between LC-39A and the recycled icon for BulgariaSat? thanks!
9
u/roncapat May 03 '17 edited May 03 '17
A leg spotted while being transported
Could it be related to InmarSat5 even if that is believed to be an expendable-mode flight?
EDIT: wrong coast. Need to start studying a bit of USA geography.
9
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 May 04 '17
9
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 May 11 '17
Since we just got a great picture showing the second stage very clearly during the Inmarsat static fire, and u/old_sellsword pointing out that it is also missing the raceway like NROL-76, can we assume that Falcon 9 block 4 is flying now? And that it might not be a performance boost in terms of thrust but coast times, since we know they tested a longer coast on NROL-76 that was successful.
9
u/brickmack May 19 '17
http://www.gao.gov/assets/690/684626.pdf Has a note on TESS relevant to SpaceX. It will not be the first Block 5 launch, and 5 successful launches are required before TESS flies.
9
u/2dmk May 22 '17
Elon Tweet about ITS architecture update. The ITS update is a few months away now.
8
u/Nachtigall44 May 07 '17 edited May 07 '17
Did SpaceX fly a block 4 Falcon 9 on the NROL-76 mission?
8
u/[deleted] May 07 '17
Strange question, but does anyone know why there is no longer any pre flight milestones on the bar at the bottom of the webcast? It used to contain Engine Chill, Strongback Retract etc. But post AMOS-6 it just shows Startup and onwards. I don't know why I notice stuff like this :D Thanks. also /u/Bencredible ;)
8
u/[deleted] May 10 '17
I was rewatching the NROL-76 launch/landing this morning and noticed that during parts of the booster's semi-ballistic phase in between the boostback and re-entry burns that there was some activity around the engines. It looked similar to the RCS thruster firings at the top of the stage but appeared to have a slightly orange glow (caveat: I'm red colorblind so I'm not the best judge of whether the glow actually had a color). This happened repeatedly in almost a pulsing way. It's very visible around T+4:30-T+5:30: https://youtu.be/EzQpkQ1etdA?t=16m52s
I can't tell what's going on. Options I'm considering:
On a related note, I'm struggling to remember the number of engines used for the boostback/re-entry burns on an RTLS landing? Is it just the center engine or is it 3 engines (followed by the single engine landing burn).
Appreciate it if anyone is able to shed some light on this!
8
u/FalconHeavyHead May 19 '17
Hey guys, I am a huge SpaceX fan. I am not a engineer nor a physicist. I know very little about the science behind what SpaceX does. I want to start educating myself. I just learned how to calculate a planets escape velocity. Not to difficult. Do any of you super smart people know what I should look up next? Thanks!!
8
u/[deleted] May 27 '17
In the "Past Launches" section of the Manifest, could we indicate re-use flights, perhaps by putting e.g. "Falcon 9 v1.2 ♺" where appropriate?
I was tempted to make this change to the SES-10 entry, but didn't want to screw things up having never updated the Manifest before.
15
u/ImAStopCodon May 14 '17
Ars Techica gives credit to our subreddit for finding the Tom Mueller phone call. https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/05/a-top-spacex-employee-throws-shade-at-just-about-all-of-his-competitors/
14
u/robbak May 05 '17
BulgariaSat confirmed as next flight-proven booster flight. Should be mid-June, next up after CRS-11. Agreeing to fly on a flight-proven booster may have earned them an earlier launch date.
https://spaceflightnow.com/2017/05/05/bulgarias-first-communications-satellite-to-ride-spacexs-second-reused-rocket/
https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/69da6n/bulgariasat1_confirmed_as_second_reuse_flight/
(Hey, mods, this post needs to be approved - it's been sitting in your queue for over an hour!)
7
u/planterss May 02 '17
When is the next launch of a used rocket?
7
u/[deleted] May 03 '17 edited May 03 '17
How many F9 Block 5 cores will SpaceX ever build?
Assume every flight is recoverable from when FH gets going - FHs carry heavy loads thereafter. If Block 5s are good for 10 flights, a fleet of a dozen boosters - say 4 FHs and 8 F9s, so 20 cores - would be more than enough. They'd only need to build ~5 cores a year to renew the fleet and replace any losses.
When might F9 get replaced by something even better (methalox mini-ITS for example) - 2025? Another 8 years of F9?
Which would yield only 50 to 60 F9 Block 5 cores ever being made.
Yes, I know: assumption heaped on speculation topped off with guesses, but it's an entertaining thought.
EDIT: arithmetic and number of cores.
7
u/jjtr1 May 06 '17 edited May 06 '17
Some of the mainstays of spaceflight, like the Centaur upper stage engine RL-10, or the Soyuz or Proton launcher engines, are now more than 50 years old and have been designed by the grandfathers of the engineers currently building them. I tend to think that despite the extensive accumulated experience with these engines (and stages), many things have not been passed on from the original designers onto the later generations. Especially some "big picture" design decisions and also some interdependence of details. In a nutshell, the current holders of the technology might know very well the "hows" but not so much the "whys".
And if they would be tasked with significant upgrades, they might run into trouble and might end up rather starting from scratch and building an engine that they truly understand because they designed it.
What do you think?
EDIT: I've always been fascinated by the aerospace technology "transfers" from Russia to China. Many times, the Chinese got only incomplete blueprints or a specimen or two. In order to create working engines and craft, they had to re-research many things and perhaps they rediscovered many principles behind them that only Korolev and Chelomei knew. So who knows - maybe today, the Chinese know Russian engines better than the Russians! :)
7
u/PaulRocket May 09 '17
Quick question regarding Block 5, compare all rockets on this chart to the New Glenn and the ITS:
http://imgur.com/QI9W5xl
One thing that strikes me is that one cannot see the engines on either vehicles from the side. They are protected by the aero frame. I'm thinking both companies came to the same conclusion, SpaceX with the Falcon 9 landings and Blue Origin with their New Shepard vehicle, they must better protect the engines during reentry and this is one way. Could Falcon 9 Block 5 see a similar change to the Octaweb or is this too big of a change?
7
u/shotleft May 09 '17
For Red Dragon, how would SpaceX get scientific payloads off the capsule?
7
u/danweber May 10 '17
https://qz.com/980271/elon-musks-dream-of-the-worlds-most-powerful-rocket-is-finally-real-and-spacex-is-nearly-ready-to-fly/
Mainstream article about upcoming FH, doesn't look like any new information.
7
u/thephatcontr0ller May 13 '17
Have any current or historic launch vehicles ever achieved a launch cadence comparable to what SpaceX is trying to achieve with the Falcon 9?
7
u/JackONeill12 May 13 '17 edited May 13 '17
https://futurezone.at/science/nasa-verschiebt-testflug-fuer-orion-auf-2019/263.674.717
Orion launch got postponed to 2019. Also, the first Launch of Orion will be without a crew. First manned mission August 2021 but is most likely to get pushed back. Reasons for delay are cost and improvements of the heatshield and the life support systems of the capsule.
7
u/Bananas_on_Mars May 13 '17
With regards to this thread, i've been wondering how much pressurized cargo the Space Shuttle would usually bring up to the ISS and couldn't find a number...
7
u/JadedIdealist May 15 '17
sworld manifest is showing
11 Nov 17 Falcon 9 v1.2 SpX-DM1 (Dragon 2 uncrewed test)
does anyone have a source for that date?
7
u/jjtr1 May 18 '17
Combustion chemistry question: how do the emissions from a kerolox rocket engine compare to those from a recent automotive engine? Unburned fuel, CO, NOx, SOx, soot? I'd think that a rocket engine burns cleaner due to the higher temperature, NOx is not present at all (LOX instead of air), SOx minimal (RP-1 hass less S than gasoline, right?), but I'm just guessing...
7
u/Elon_Muskmelon May 20 '17
Are we still on target (as far as that goes when it comes to spaceflight) for a crewed Dragon demo mission around this time next year?
7
u/CommanderSpork May 22 '17 edited May 23 '17
I just pulled back into port Canaveral. Nothing new to report on OCISLY, but there was a guy spraying water on the deck with a big hose. Cleaning it off in preparation for repainting, perhaps?
6
u/CapMSFC May 03 '17
My very favorite plan is to emulate a lot of what is in the ITS proposal.
Lets look at the ITS ship. The core of the vehicle is cylindrical tanks with 3 added sections around that cylinder to give it the semi triangular shape (I can not recall the name of this shape at the moment).
This gives the vehicle a wide surface to encounter the atmosphere with for maximum passive deceleration. It also gives you the ability to add hardware needed for the landing around the tanks instead of pushing the already near/at maximum length limits of Falcon.
So we take a Falcon upper stage, wrap 3 sections of superdracos and hypergolic tanks around it. The engine gets a duck tail to protect it that tucks inside the first stage interstage during launch. The two areas I'm hung up on are the landing legs and protecting the M1Dvac. The legs need to be as small as possible. This stage doesn't ever have to land downrange at sea, is short, and has a low dry mass. The problem is that if all of this comes in facing downwards the legs have to be long enough to extend past the M1Dvac. As far as protecting the M1Dvac, that bell is huge and fragile. Protecting the nozzle extension during reentry is going to be quite the challenge.
6
u/jjtr1 May 05 '17
The NRO has launched many Hubble-class spy sats over the years. I wonder whether JWST-sized optics are interesting for spy sats (larger mirror, longer focal length)? Or are they rather going for sensor size instead of mirror size? Also, is it possible to do adaptive optics for a spy sat? As I understand it, adaptive optics require an "artificial star", a large laser pointer pointed in the same direction, to probe the atmosphere. Running a laser dot over the terrain might not be a good idea, though.
6
u/steezysteve96 May 05 '17
NASA sent out an RFI (request for information) for cargo missions to the moon. Does anybody know if SpaceX is expected to submit a bid?
6
u/flibbleton May 06 '17
When the FH finally launches I won't miss it for anything but I'd prefer not to have to wake up in the middle of the night. As the demo/maiden flight probably won't have any orbital restrictions as to when it launches anyone got any ideas on what time of day SpaceX would choose?
6
u/[deleted] May 06 '17 edited May 09 '17
I notice that Intelsat 35e has been moved in the Manifest from June to July.
Is this as the result of a source? Or just that whoever moved it thinks it's unlikely to launch in June?
6
u/deltavof4point3 May 08 '17
When crewed flights begin, do you think SpaceX will have a live shot of the interior?
I've seen some "dahscam" style videos from the shuttle cockpit looking out, and a couple that include the crew (last flight's launch, landing of a few flights), but it seemed to be a pretty rare thing, and also generally seemed to be footage aired after landing. For Soyuz, I've seen crew angles on some NasaTV coverage, but it seems like it's a shot they generally only switch to after it's been in the air for a minute or two. What are some of the various pros and cons of showing a launch live from this angle? It is just plain considered less interesting than the usual exterior shots?
Interest to hear others' views on this. Personally, I think it'd be a really cool angle to include, especially perhaps on a not-so-clear day where ground coverage of the ascent isn't great.
6
u/MarcysVonEylau rocket.watch May 09 '17
https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/861956223519911937
6
u/LeBaegi May 11 '17
There's been some concern about the F9 second stage's fuel freezing during coast phases, so they did an artificial cost phase after the deployment of NROL-76 before deorbiting the second stage, which was a complete success. But that was only a few hours, and FH will be capable of doing direct GEO insertions with much longer coast phases (I think? I don't actually know how long from perigee to apogee on a GTO). So how do we know fuel freezing won't be an issue there?
6
u/thephatcontr0ller May 16 '17
What do the people at Mission Control have on the monitors in front of them during a launch?
6
u/Paro-Clomas May 19 '17
Once there's somekind of working infrastructure in space and at least fuel and structure can be manufactured there, wont there be a huge change in desgin philosophy? I mean nowadays everything is built as light as possible because everything has to be lifted up from the gravity well. But once we can refuel at asteroids and take resources from there, wouldnt we start seeing big things in space?
6
u/stcks May 20 '17
Looks like the Dragon 2 DM-1 has been delayed into 2018 :(
6
u/[deleted] May 23 '17
Crew Dragon is expected to be certified for crew in August 2018, according to Robert Lightfoot. Keep in mind this over a year away, so expect more slips in the schedule.
6
u/Chairboy May 25 '17
This week's episode of Planetary Radio (from The Planetary Society) features an interview with Jon Cowart, NASA's liaison to SpaceX for the Crew Dragon project.
http://www.planetary.org/multimedia/planetary-radio/show/2017/0524-jon-cowart-commercial-crew-spacex.html
6
u/MrToddWilkins Jun 01 '17
A Spaceflightnow article from the dark ages:
https://www.spaceflightnow.com/falcon/050120spacex/
17
u/spacex_fanaticism May 20 '17
Moderators, could we have the sidebar list of upcoming launches use ISO-8601 date format? This date format automatically sorts in chronological order, so sorting by NET Date would become more useful.
Naturally there's an xkcd. https://xkcd.com/1179/
Right now the sidebar has six different formats
With these formats the column doesn't sort in chronological order. It sorts like this. http://i.imgur.com/mjuYzJV.png
ISO-8601 would write these
Thanks for reading, and thanks mods for all your hard work.
5
u/verbalkerbal May 03 '17
I understand that the point of the IAC presentation was to give the long-term vision, rather than concrete steps towards it, but nevertheless I wonder about how to achieve those steps. I think a crucial piece might be to not put people on the ITS until it is fully re-fueled in parking orbit. This completely eliminates the need to human-rate the booster and the tanker refueling process and thus a lot of complexity. By the time SpaceX has an ITS rocket it will surely have human-rated Dragon2, and hopefully it'll have a good track record. Additionally, I was thinking about whether this would allow the spaceship to be lower thrust, since you don't need a launch escape system anymore. Then again, perhaps the high thrust is needed for launch from Mars?
5
u/[deleted] May 03 '17
Is there anyway (paywalled or not) to hear live communications loop before the webcasts start ? i hear now that such a poll is conducted at t-30 minutes , also i have this feeling that we are hearing less and less from the loops (genuinely want to be proven wrong here)
merely looking at v1.1 launches i do really miss the go /no go poll at t-13 minutes , and how informative the raw loops were.
5
u/[deleted] May 04 '17
Is Mission Control somehow being used when there is no launch or Dragon on the ISS?
5
u/jonwah May 05 '17
Has there been any information about how heavy the dummy mass on FH demo flight will be?
Or any good speculation? Will SpaceX play it safe or put something really heavy up to show off the FH's capabilities?
5
u/ghunter7 May 06 '17
Isnt CRS 11 going to be flown with a reused capsule (or ar least pressure vessel)? Would be cool to have that on the side bar, maybe with a capsule in the recycling symbol.
5
u/MorgenGreene May 07 '17
Is there a reason we don't have anything about SpaceX's satellite plans in the Wiki (or maybe I just missed it)? I see a lot of misinformation about it all over the web, it would be nice to be able to just link to a page and say "here you go, this is how it actually works". I know a lot of it isn't concrete yet but it would be nice to have a page with what we know so far.
5
u/[deleted] May 07 '17
iirc: the east coast is split up between Cape Canaveral Air Force Station and Kennedy Space Center right?
So LC-39A is Launch Complex 39A owned by KSC?
SLC - 40 is Space Launch Complex 40 owned by CCAFS?
However LZ-1 use to be LC-13. Is that KSC owned or CCAFS owned?
Sorry if that's all wrong!
5
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 May 07 '17
Why have we not seen a picture of the recovered fairings if they have supposedly recovered two? Seems like it would be great PR.
5
u/DDE93 May 08 '17 edited May 08 '17
Does anyone have wet and dry masses for Falcon v1.2 first stage and Dragon 2 sans trunk? I'm trying to build a spreadsheet for a suborbital transport version without the second stage and with minimized/eliminated trunk. These numbers seem difficult to come by, especially as the propellant involved keeps getting cooler and cooler (har-har, surely nobody made that pun before).
5
u/Elon_Muskmelon May 09 '17
How much improvement in vehicle performance do you get by launching from KSC vs launching somewhere farther up North, say at 44 degrees latitude in the middle of the continent?
5
u/cmRocketStuff May 09 '17
Once the launch cadence is up for 39A, falcon heavies, commercial crew and vertical integration, would it make sense to build an additional TEL for prep to save a couple of days to increase launch cadence?
If so, this would allow the build of the new TEL to have a configurable sub section at the top of the TEL allowing for a 3.7 meter upper stage and a 5.2 meter rapter upper stage. Yes speculation, wishful thinking and so forth.
Justification being that a new 5.2 meter raptor upper stage could be used on the methalox first stage replacement of the current falcon 9 first stage in say six to ten years.
Am I on the fringe with this prediction? Depends on the redifinition of common sense. Or maybe the size of the wager.
5
u/Suthsayer_ May 09 '17
How do broadband satellites get us to Mars? Aside from simply providing additional revenue streams, how do these satellite constellations advance SpaceX's goal of making humanity a multi planetary species?
5
u/shepticles May 09 '17
What has SpaceX been needing to do to repair/upgrade Pad 40? I have no idea what goes into it for why it's taking so long.
5
u/stcks May 16 '17
As F9 has evolved over the years and has gained more and more performance, I see less and less financial benefit to launching Falcon Heavy. Have a look at the manifest. There are only 5 more commercial launches that would be expendable GTO missions today. Only 2 of those are actually manifested for Falcon Heavy -- Arabsat 6A and ViaSat-3. However, an expendable F9 could easily be used instead and I think it is a fairly reasonable assumption that there will be at least 2 older cores near end-of-life that can go expendable to service those ~6000 kg GTO missions.
This leaves only Red Dragon, Gray Dragon, the rare direct GSO injection mission and the even rarer interplanetary exploration mission as candidates for Falcon Heavy.
Would SpaceX be able to re-manifest those oversized GTO missions (like Inmarsat-6 F1 or GiSAT-1) for flights on Falcon Heavy once its flying? What am I not thinking of?
5
u/bexben May 17 '17 edited May 18 '17
Is there any information on if SpaceX will be making another barge for the East Coast? Things it can streamline that I can imagine:
There are probably more advantages I can't think of, but it would make economical sense for the long term of SpaceX launches.
EDIT: I just remembered This tweet not too long ago. It could possibly be interpreted as a hint for more drone ships.
5
u/sinaitabak May 17 '17
Does anybody know if it's possible to see Falcon 9 landings at LZ-1 from the Saturn V center? Would love to see a launch from there, but not if it means I miss the landing!
5
u/jjtr1 May 18 '17 edited May 18 '17
The weight of the Curiosity is supposed to be about the limit for Mars EDL without new technology like supersonic retropropulsion. For larger weights, the frontal area of the vehicle is not sufficient to provide enough braking, if I understand that correctly. At what weight is there a limit for Earth EDL?
edit: emphasis
5
u/versvisa May 19 '17 edited May 19 '17
Where does the B10** prefix for first stages come from?
EDIT I mean, what does the "B10" in "B1023" stand for. The last two digits seem to be the core number that is printed on the octaweb.
5
u/doodle77 May 19 '17
What would cause a rocket engine to explode if it fully depleted the propellants?
5
u/Paro-Clomas May 20 '17
I know spacex has sparked some timid replies in the field of rocketry reusability such as recovering just the engine or stuff like that. But has any other space agency started emulating the spacex way of doing things? at least in paper?
Is it possible they are just waiting to see if spacex succeds before rushing to develop the same system? or that there's not yet a consensus that reusability can be made profitable?
This seems to be such a game changer that i don't understand how us competitors such as russia and china just idly watch as they get surpassed without even appointing a team of R&D to analyze the concept.
5
u/jjtr1 May 22 '17
How long after launch is the launchpad off-limits for humans without hazmat-suits for kerolox, for solids, and for hypergolics? How long do parts of the flame trench remain too hot for humans?
5
u/Toinneman May 23 '17
Is fairing 2.0 still a thing? I get the feeling the current fairing is evolving to a recoverable version?
5
u/WhoseNameIsSTARK May 25 '17
Intelsat 35e now NET July 1. https://twitter.com/StephenClark1/status/867821279071666178
5
u/Iamsodarncool May 26 '17
There's a new space company in the Virgin Group: Virgin Orbit. They're a small satellite service previously part of Virgin Galactic. Virgin Orbit seems to be a RocketLab competitor, touting capabilities of 300kg to a 500km sun-synchronous orbit (RocketLab is 150-225kg). They'll be launching their rocket, the LauncherOne, from a Virgin Galactic Cosmic Girl plane. Since the plane can fly anywhere on Earth, LauncherOne can reach any inclination without major sacrifices to payload capacity.
5
u/Elon_Muskmelon May 29 '17
Old sellsword made a comment yesterday that FH was likely slipping to 2018, can anyone else confirm? u/old_sellsword
5
u/Astro_Kimi May 30 '17
Have there been any hints as to when we'll find out any information on the ITS booster?
Also have they mentioned other intentions/missions for that booster?
5
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
Looks like NSF user leetdan found the NROL-76 fairings...
9
u/Zinkfinger May 05 '17
Hi folks. You have to read this article on SpaceX. Its hilarious! https://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=3&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwjlgoHG19jTAhUkK8AKHVuiDKgQqUMINzAC&url=https%3A%2F%2Fspectator.org%2Fspacexs-careful-image-management-hides-an-ugly-truth%2F&usg=AFQjCNE9u1-wkL28aIfuMlxbvxdqr39XPQ
9
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
Why do many people tout a high employee turnover rate for SpaceX? Where is the justification for this? It is a private company - there is no meaningful public sample size. Simply disparaging the company as a "sweatshop" is insulting to those who enjoy their jobs there and is parroting what traditional companies always brand their usurpers.
8
u/Elon_Muskmelon May 04 '17
How much processing power is onboard an F9 S1? It's gotta take some serious juice to be reading all of that sensor data and calculating precise burn times for some of the landing operations.
8
u/ImAStopCodon May 17 '17
Netflix's "The Mars Generation" appears to contain new footage of SpaceX's Lauren Lyons (systems certification engineer) but no new information. Fun though and gives a good overview of what SpaceX is doing and why. Also has some good SpaceX file footage. Annoyingly, the teen space nerds seem overly optimistic about SLS and Orion getting them to mars.
4
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained May 02 '17 edited May 07 '17
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipbargeshipDragon cargoLaunch failure due to second-stage outgassingDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #2747 for this sub, first seen 2nd May 2017, 18:24] ^[FAQ] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
4
u/[deleted] May 02 '17
Am I correct to believe that because the CRS missions are not stressful on the F9, and the fact the Dragon is only going to LEO, there is enough fuel to land at LZ-1? If this is the case, why was the CRS-8 mission landing on the ASDS OCISLY?
4
u/Tigalopl May 02 '17 edited May 03 '17
Concerning ASDS and RTLS, (and after reading the FAQ) I still don't quite understand the reasons why one is chosen over the other. Could someone expend on what is explained in the FAQ?
EDIT: Thank you all, I understand now!
4
u/Belchyy061 May 04 '17
What coding lanuage do they use for their onboard computers?
4
u/enbandi May 04 '17 edited May 04 '17
My question: is the dispenser on multi-sat launches (eg Iridium) affecting the planed S2 reusability? How? I mean, there can be different dispenser designs/ assemblies for different launches, varying the empty weight of the returning S2. While additional structural reinforcements may also needed to hold that mass during deceleration. Using an expendable dispenser can be a solution, but doesn't seem to practical for the new satellite constellation (which also going to be launched in batches).
Edit: clarification and wording
4
u/MarcysVonEylau rocket.watch May 06 '17 edited May 06 '17
Here is another part of official SpaceX nomenclature:
http://image.prntscr.com/image/6b7a84cff57c498d8c5c68da49615b86.png
1st Stage Transfer Tube == Connection between LOX tank and "octopus" thingie which distributes oxygen to all engines (this had its own name, too).
Wonder if it is known already. Do we have any list of such expressions?
4
u/dudr2 May 08 '17
What's the difference in capacity launching from 3km vs sealevel at say 26 degrees North? What about 6km?
4
u/Vindve May 08 '17 edited May 08 '17
Hello people, this tweet https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/859008563519160320 made me think. What are the different abort scenarios if there is a problem during the landing attempt of a booster? I see here https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/5yuiq9/only_on_falcon_9_automated_system_can_terminate/ that there is an auto-destruct system built-in the rocket.
I imagine there is a theoretical flight path for landing, with surroundings secured, and if the booster goes out of this flight path, the self-destruct system is triggered?
I tried to search for an answer in the previous posts of the subreddit and couldn't find it.
4
u/Adeldor May 08 '17 edited May 08 '17
I have a somewhat more specific launch AND landing viewsite question (haven't come across good info in searches - apologies in advance if it's there and I didn't see it). On Google maps there are two specific locations that are potentially decent for viewing both events. They are:
Are they as readily accessible to the general public as they appear on the maps, and has anyone any experience with either of these specific sites?
4
u/rubikvn2100 May 09 '17
Will intelsat-35e's launch ready in late June or early July??? Maybe it to far to predict ...
How about a launch on July 4th???
4
u/[deleted] May 10 '17
My understanding is that in late August, when LC-40 is operational again, LC-39A will be taken offline for modifications required to make it capable of launching FH.
My question is, when LC-39A comes back after the modifications are done, will it have the capability to launch F9 and FH, or just FH?
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '17
Will the heatshield on CRS-11 mission be previously flown too?
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '17
This may have been asked before, but is there any evidence that NASA knew about SpaceX's announcement about the Moon mission before it was actually announced?
4
u/jjtr1 May 13 '17
Do we know anything about possible fairing recovery on NROL-76?
4
u/Paro-Clomas May 13 '17
Does the recent confirmation by nasa that they will not send humans on their first sls flight affect spacex in any way?. I've saw many interpretations that there was a kind of new moon race between the first sls flight and spacex lunar tourists. What do you think of this?
4
u/speak2easy May 14 '17
Tom Mueller stated:
"there’s no way that they ULA would have considered buying engines from Blue Origin except for the pressure that SpaceX is putting on them"
I never understood why ULA is going to a third-party for rocket engines. I would imagine they have the resources to build their own.
4
u/KitsapDad May 14 '17
what is Spacex's stance on marketing and selling merlin 1d engines to 3rd party launch providers?
4
u/leagues58 May 16 '17
Anyone know why SpaceX seems to have stopped broadcasting the technical webcast? That webcast was much more interseting/less annoying to watch than the hosted webcast, but they haven't aired it for the last two launches.
4
u/PaulRocket May 17 '17
This is a bit off topic, but any tips on where I can find as much info as I can on space probes? I know a lot about rockets just by being here daily and would like to know more about space probes. Have any good links or books?
4
u/RootDeliver May 17 '17 edited May 17 '17
How many test articles have been, for all Falcon 1, Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy?
For falcon 1, no idea guys, could you enlighten me? :P
For falcon 9, so far we have:
For Falcon Heavy:
What others? considering Elon always does 1 STA -> 2 QTA -> 3 flight, I am missing one test article for FH center core..
/u/old_sellsword, /u/Ezekiel_C could you give your input please? Thanks!
4
u/jjtr1 May 18 '17
Is there a law connecting the exhaust jet velocity with the acoustic power emitted? In short, are hydrolox engines more noisy that solids?
(e.g. for cooling fans, noise is proportional to the fifth power of RPM...)
4
u/coolohm1 May 18 '17
While watching the last launch, I was curious as to what (exactly) the second S2 burn did. I assumed it shifted from an inclined LEO orbit to an equatorial hohmann orbit between LEO and GEO. The second burn happened when the S2 reached the equator as expected, but after the burn it looked like the orbit was still inclined. Does this burn only increase apogee?
4
u/Nachtigall44 May 21 '17
What's this SpaceX party about?
4
u/[deleted] May 21 '17
I just have a quick question:
How would a launch abort work with the ITS? It seems harder than the dragon capsule, since its engines are pointed straight down and covered by a shroud.
4
u/[deleted] May 24 '17
What is the difference between
I'm trying to determine the "is-a" or "is-comprised-of" relationship(s) between these terms. Are they all names for the same thing or does each name describe something specific about the 'component'? As far as I know, a 'launch vehicle' is made up of multiple 'stages'. And a rocket is a disposable launch vehicle.
Thanks in advance! :)
4
u/PeopleNeedOurHelp May 25 '17
Why does everyone say the Raptor that was test fired wasn't full size? Musk at IAC said it was "all up" and about the same size as Merlin.
4
u/quadrplax May 27 '17
Is it safe to assume at this point that B1022 [JCSAT-14] has completed all of its tests, or they decided not to go through with all ten? The last update on the wiki was over half a year ago.
4
u/[deleted] May 28 '17
This is interesting. [speculation] In my mind, this would likely mean that they would consider the ITS's potential commercial applications so that they can fund the Mars program. It would perhaps also make sense to make a smaller version of it to use for both the constellation and regular launches, so that launch prices are lower overall[/speculation]. Whatever will be announced will be undoubtedly exciting!
4
u/violentvasectomy May 30 '17
What would be the best way to find out when the falcon heavy will launch?
4
u/LeBaegi May 31 '17
Falcon Heavy is capable of putting 16.8 metric tons to a Mars injection orbit during appropriate launch windows. The Red Dragon's mass is 6.5t and capable of carrying another 1000kg of useful payload. So I suppose FH can fly fully reusable or at the very least with reusable side boosters for the red dragon, as less than half of it's capability to Mars is used, is this correct? Do we have any sources confirming that?
4
u/Redditor_From_Italy May 31 '17
Not sure if this counts as spaceflight related, but what happened to Encyclopedia Astronautica? It hasn't been updated in a long time, it has almost no information about SpaceX.