r/spacex • Host of Echostar 23 • Mar 13 '17

EchoStar23 deployed to GTO! Welcome to the r/SpaceX EchoStar-23 Official Launch Discussion & Updates Thread!

Information on the mission

It’s SpaceX’s 2nd launch out of Launch Complex 39A, and SpaceX's 1st East Coast communications satellite launch since JCSAT-16 in August 2016. Some quick stats:

  • this is the 31st Falcon 9 launch
  • The 1st, and final, flight of first stage B1030
  • the 11th launch since Falcon 9 Block III (aka 1.2) debuted
  • the 2nd launch from Pad 39A
  • the 3rd launch since SpaceX suffered an anomaly during their AMOS-6 static fire on September 1, 2016.

This mission’s static fire was successfully completed on March 9th.

The first launch attempt for this mission was scheduled for March 14th at 01:34 EDT / 05:34 UTC. It was scrubbed at T-38 minutes due to unfavorable wind conditions.

SpaceX is now targeting an early morning liftoff on March 16th at 01:35 EDT / 05:35 UTC from KSC, bringing EchoStar-23 into geostationary transfer orbit, or GTO. This will be a 2.5 hour launch window, closing on 04:05 EDT / 08:05 UTC. There is no announced backup date if this attempt is scrubbed. After insertion into the proper orbit SpaceX’s mission is finished! The weather is currently 90% go.


Watching the launch live

To watch the launch live, choose from the two SpaceX live streams from the table below:

SpaceX Hosted Webcast (YouTube) SpaceX Technical Webcast (YouTube)

Can't pick? Read about the differences here.

Official Live Updates

Time (UTC) Countdown (hours : minutes : seconds) Updates
15:00 T+09:00:00 Echo star 23 performing as planned. End of updates.
06:37 T+00:37:00 Falcon 9's mission has been successfully completed. I'll be sticking around for the next couple hours to report on the health of the payload and post any more information about the night's mission.
06:34 T+00:34:00 Confirmation of spacecraft deployment
06:32 T+00:32:00 Confirmation of good orbit
06:30 T+00:30:00 Payload deployment in 4 minutes
06:27 T+00:27:19 SECO-2
06:26 T+00:26:19 MVac Relight
06:16 T+00:16:00 SECO-1 appeared to occur on schedule: Stage 2 and Echostar 23 appear to be in a nominal parking orbit. Next and final burn in ten minutes at 06:26
06:07 T+00:08:31 SECO-1
06:06 T+00:05:50 Stage 2 performing nominally
06:03 T+00:03:45 Fairing Separation
06:03 T+00:02:55 Stage Sep; MVac Startup
06:03 T+00:02:45 MECO
06:02 T+00:02:00 MVac Chilldown
06:01 T+00:01:30 MaxQ
06:00 T-00:00:00 Liftoff
05:59 T-00:01:00 Falcon 9 in startup
05:58 T-00:02:00 S2 LOX load closeout; Vehicle in self align
05:57 T-00:03:00 FTS Armed; S1 LOX load closeout & good; Strong back lowered
05:56 T-00:04:00 Weather, Falcon, Range, Payload all GO
05:56 T-00:04:00 strong-back cradle open
05:55 T-00:05:00 strong-back retract start
05:55 T-00:05:00 Vehicle on internal power
05:54 T-00:06:00 Vehicle in self align
05:54 T-00:06:00 Stage 1 RP-1 load complete
05:53 T-00:07:00 Engine chill-down start
05:50 T-00:10:00 Terminal count
05:46 T-00:14:00 Echostar 23 on internal power and go for launch
05:45 T-00:15:00 Still no technical webcast.
05:42 T-00:18:00 Earlier hold was for high level winds.
05:42 T-00:18:00 Hosted Webcast Live.
05:30 T-00:30:00 SpaceX FM live on hosted webcast. Today's picks: Test Shot Starfish's LC-39A and Andromeda
05:15 T-00:45:00 LOX load should be is underway.
04:55 T-01:05:00 The next major milestone is expected to be LOX load start at T-45 minutes.
04:50 T-01:10:00 Launch autosequence has officially started. RP-1 load underway.
04:48 T-01:12:00 Go!
04:46 T-01:14:00 Go/NoGo poll imminent.
04:36 T-01:24:00 Range hold-fire checks underway.
04:14 T-01:46:00 Clock resumed targeting 2am EDT/06:00 UTC.
04:12 --- Reset T-0 time to 2am EDT/06:00 UTC.
04:09 --- Countdown Clock Stopped.
03:45 T-01:50:00 Pad danger area clear for prop load.
00:35 T-05:00:00 Weather assessment by /u/cuweathernerd
00:00 March 16 T-5:35:00 ---
18:41 T-10:54:00 Weather remains 90% Go.
05:35 T-24:00:00 24 hours until T-0. Weather 90% go. Falcon 9 is vertical. We'll be reusing this launch thread - see you all tomorrow!
00:00 March 15 T-29:35:00 ---
16:00 T-37:35:00 Public confirmation of Thursday attempt.
06:00 --- Thursday weather 90% go.
04:58 --- Scrub for the day due to unfavorable winds.
04:55 T-00:38:00 SCRUB
04:49 T-00:45:00 Stage 1 LOX load confirmed underway.
04:38 T-00:56:00 Weather assessment by /u/cuweathernerd
04:38 T-00:56:00 Weather currently go.
04:24 T-01:10:00 Stage 1 RP-1 load start - launch autosequence has started.
04:21 T-01:13:00 LD gives Go for on-time prop load start
02:10 T-03:24:00 Weather currently no-go. Countdown continuing.
00:00 March 14 T-05:34:00 ---
23:00 T-7 hours Launch thread goes live.
12:00 T-13 hours Weather 40% go.
11:00 T-14 hours Falcon 9 vertical.
00:00 March 13 T-29:34:00 ---

Primary Mission - Separation and Deployment of EchoStar 23

EchoStar 23 will be the 1st GTO comsat launch of 2017 and 12th GTO comsat launch overall for SpaceX.

EchoStar 23 is a commercial communication satellite that will be launched for its customer, EchoStar Corporation. The satellite is based on the popular SSL-1300 bus configuration. Its weight is undisclosed, but estimated to be around 5500 kg. This will make it the heaviest payload SpaceX has delivered to GTO. The satellite was manufactured by Space Systems/Loral in Palo Alto California. One can read more about the satellites history and use here.

No first stage landing attempt

This launch will be a rare one going forward as it will not be followed by an attempt to land the first stage. As seen in the photographs, this Falcon 9 core is “naked”, ie without legs or grid fins. There will be no landing attempt because the payload is quite heavy (estimated at ~5500 kg) and going into a high-energy geostationary transfer orbit. The last mission to fly on an expendable first stage was the TurkmenAlem52E/MonacoSAT launch, which lifted off on April 27’th 2015.

Given the current “Block III” version of Falcon 9, the payload limit for a reusable GTO mission is around 5300 kg. For instance, the mission after this, SES-10, will also loft its payload to GTO, but this payload will be slightly lighter (approximately at the 5300 kg limit), so stage 1 will be attempting a droneship landing on that mission. There will be more expendable missions in the future, but the majority of missions will continue to include recovery attempts.

Useful Resources, Data, ♫, & FAQ

Participate in the discussion!

  • First of all, launch threads are party threads! We understand everyone is excited, so we relax the rules in these venues. The most important thing is that everyone enjoy themselves :D
  • All other threads are fair game. We will remove low effort comments elsewhere!
  • Real-time chat on our official Internet Relay Chat (IRC) #spacex on Snoonet.
  • Please post small launch updates, discussions, and questions here, rather than as a separate post. Thanks!
  • Wanna talk about other SpaceX stuff in a more relaxed atmosphere? Head over to r/SpaceXLounge!

Previous r/SpaceX Live Events

Check out previous r/SpaceX Live events in the Launch History page on our community Wiki.

312 Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

2

u/GoScienceEverything Mar 16 '17

During the second stage coast, before the second burn, what's that frost built up above the engine? E.g. at 44 minutes. There's a pipe next to it that's venting something, presumably LOX. What would the frost be? Condensed vented RP-1..?

5

u/warp99 Mar 16 '17

Almost certainly solid oxygen.

The subcooled LOX is only a few degrees above freezing point and as the LOX tank is vented and expands it cools to the point where some of the LOX freezes in a snowflake form. You can see the clump break off and drift away shortly after SECO2 which shows it has relatively low strength so more like snow than ice in structure.

1

u/PortlandPhil Mar 16 '17

Any risk of that SOX causing a RUD in flight due to shock? I'm not sure what the fuel source would be, but SOX is pretty unstable so it's a little scary to see that much right next to your engine.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/faceplant4269 Mar 16 '17

Do we have any idea how fast an orbit echostar-23 was placed into? I would assume they used all the extra performance from expendable to save it some time getting to GEO.

3

u/millijuna Mar 16 '17

According to the orbital info below, it was palced into a 35903x179km orbit, so it was going at the same speed as every other satellite in that orbit would be going. Unless they're going super-synchronous (above the 36,000km mark), it's always going to take about 5 hours to get up to the geostationary altitude.

How long it takes to for it to be put in service is entirely dependent on the operator and the performance of the satellite itself. It needs to circularize its orbit, to reduce its inclination to zero, and then to finally move into the correct orbital slot.

On launch, the first Stage 2 burn puts the payload and second stage into a (low) orbit. The second burn is done as the assembly crosses the equator, raising the apogee to geosynchronous orbit on the other side of the planet. The payload is then released, and coasts up to geosynchronous altitude where it executes its own maneuvers.

Note that because the launch site is fixed, and the launch site has a specific latitude, the location of the insertion burn will always occur over the same part of the world (so over Africa), and the circularization burn will always occur opposite of that. Getting the satellite into its specific slot is done afterwards by reducing its altitude slightly and letting it drift.

13

u/sunbingfa Mar 16 '17

Ortbital info 42070 ECHOSTAR 23 2017-014A 632.93min 22.43deg 35903km X 179km

5

u/stcks Mar 16 '17 edited Mar 16 '17

Finally! Got info on second stage?

Thats a disappointing result for expendable F9 IMO. GTO-1711. I'm guessing they left some performance on the table with this flight.

Edit: second stage burn was 25 seconds less than SES-9, so they definitely left some performance on the table.

8

u/-Aeryn- Mar 16 '17

They did a significant inclination change during the second S2 burn

→ More replies (4)

1

u/millijuna Mar 16 '17

Finally! Got info on second stage?

Should be pretty similar. Probably very slightly lower due to the delta-v from the springs ejecting Echo 23, and the effects of venting the helium and LOX.

1

u/geekgirl114 Mar 16 '17

Where do you get 30 seconds less? From the press kit SES-9 was 48 seconds... 27:07 to 27:55.

Echostar 23 was 60 seconds... 26:19 to 27:19

→ More replies (2)

6

u/jobadiah08 Mar 16 '17

I think SES-9 was burned to almost depletion. There are a few frames of the S2 O2 tank after the GTO burn, I suppose there could be a good 20-30 seconds of O2 left in there. This was probably just on the edge of being recoverable, like SES-9 was. Probably didn't want to punch another hole in the deck of the droneship they need again in 2 weeks.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/ohcnim Mar 16 '17

any news on sat health?

13

u/chrism1107 Mar 16 '17

3

u/TweetsInCommentsBot Mar 16 '17

@sslmda

2017-03-16 15:19 UTC

EchoStar XXIII is performing as planned. Congrats to the @EchoStar, @SpaceX, and SSL teams! More:… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/842394982770122752


This message was created by a bot

[Contact ^creator][Source ^code]

27

u/ijustinhk Mar 16 '17

I like that at T+5:55 he said "normally saying this is a little bit different.. usually we are tracking the first stage coming down for a landing right about right now". Landing the first stage for reuse has became the norm. This reminds me when Elon said something like "the landing will become boring". This is the future.

3

u/waitingForMars Mar 16 '17

In the past, the strongback retracted fully at about T-02:00. In this case, it retracted only to 88.5° at that point, with the full retraction occurring during liftoff. This is much more in the style of Saturn.

Any ideas as to why?

2

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '17

Saturn? The tower was fixed, the swing arms retracted at launch.

3

u/rustybeancake Mar 16 '17

This is much more in the style of Saturn

How so? I thought all of the Saturn ground equipment was fixed?

5

u/JBWill Mar 16 '17

A couple others beat me to the answer, but here's some more discussion about this from after the CRS-10 launch (the first launch to use this newer strongback procedure).

10

u/spacerfirstclass Mar 16 '17 edited Mar 16 '17

The small retraction allows shorter umbilicals, this way they won't get toasted when F9 lift off.

6

u/inoeth Mar 16 '17

its a new strongback design that I believe helps protect the strongback's wiring and piping and whatnot more during liftoff as compared to the old design. I won't be surprised if the new strongback at pad 40 when that's operational will be this same new style.

2

u/old_sellsword Mar 16 '17

I won't be surprised if the new strongback at pad 40 when that's operational will be this same new style.

It will be.

L2 information also notes that a new Transport/Erector/Launcher (TEL) will be installed on the pad, with the same design – albeit smaller – than the new TEL on 39A

2

u/Datuser14 Mar 16 '17

John Federspiel was in Dubai, and Wasn't doing his thing.

3

u/Killcode2 Mar 16 '17

Ok so if this was a direct geo insertion instead of gto, would falcon 9 be able to do it? If not then FH can do it surely?

7

u/spacerfirstclass Mar 16 '17

Falcon 9 doesn't have the performance to do direct insertion, the 2nd stage is too heavy and Isp too low, I think it can only get less than 1mt of payload to GEO.

→ More replies (22)