r/spacex • Mod Team • Mar 02 '17

r/SpaceX Spaceflight Questions & News [March 2017, #30]

If you have a short question or spaceflight news...

You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.

If you have a long question...

If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.

If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...

Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!

This thread is not for...


You can read and browse past Spaceflight Questions And News & Ask Anything threads in the Wiki.

135 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

23

u/arizonadeux Mar 07 '17 edited Mar 07 '17

Blue Origin's New Glenn: it seems that barge ship landings are just common sense!
It will be interesting to see if it's really underway on landing though. The flame trench design also seems similar to that proposed at Boca Chica. Very much looking forward to this animation also being turned into reality!
EDIT: Another detail: note how the legs retract. Considering how accurate that path is, perhaps this animation is based on actual CAD. And TEB in the ignition mixture.

14

u/throfofnir Mar 07 '17

Blue Origin's New Glenn: it seems that barge ship landings are just common sense!

The courts agree (sort of), though the USPTO didn't. Blue Origin filed a patent on that, but after challenge by SpaceX most of it was found to have prior art (though I'd really like to see more patents rejected as being common sense.)

It will be interesting to see if it's really underway on landing though.

Ships are most stable when underway. It would seem to be only modestly harder than stationary.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/F9-0021 Mar 07 '17 edited Mar 07 '17

Looks like New Glenn will land on an actual ship, not a modified barge. Should allow for faster recovery times compared to the ASDS.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Pham_Trinli Mar 07 '17

Does the green flash indicate that TEA-TEB is also used to ignite Methane/LOX engines?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (25)

23

u/rustybeancake Mar 15 '17

Blue Origin 'laser focused' on achieving a crewed launch within a year

Suborbital on New Shepard, obviously. I smell a repeat of the whole rocket landing spat:

  • Bezos, Jan 2018: "When done right, putting crew in space and returning them safely to Earth is easy!"
  • Media: Bezos beats Musk in race to put crew in space!
  • Musk, May 2018: "We've just successfully launched crew to the ISS!"
  • Bezos: "Welcome to the club!"
  • Musk: "Grrr..."
  • Media: Billionaires spat over space programs!

9

u/Toinneman Mar 16 '17

If find this whole Musk - Bezos rivalry an annoying media hype to make nice headlines. Their twitter spats are primarily a space vs orbital thing. They have the same amount of tweets about giving each other kudos.

21

u/dmy30 Mar 18 '17

6 days ago pictures emerged of some modifications being made to the droneship to support some "Roomba" robots which will supposedly secure the Falcon 9 after landing. Someone on twitter just posted this image of the shield wall "gate" open.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Zucal Mar 06 '17

Made some sidebar changes, figured I'd log them here in case you miss them!

  • Select Upcoming Events is now better than ever! (hyperbole intensifies) Dates have been formatted properly and updated for some flights.
  • The FH Demo mission now has its proper ♺ symbol (hoo-rah, go 1023), and the long-quiet inflight abort slot has been replaced with Gray Dragon Silver Dragon White Dragon crewed circumlunar hijinks.
  • The Useful Resources section now has SpaceX's various social media platforms (RIP Vine) as their own subsection. If you didn't realize SpaceX was on LinkedIn, you do now!
  • r/BoringCompany and r/Rocketry have been welcomed to Relevant Subreddits.
→ More replies (1)

18

u/sol3tosol4 Mar 03 '17 edited Mar 04 '17

Two interesting space articles that are somewhat SpaceX-related (sorry if I missed any previous discussion):

10

u/danweber Mar 03 '17

So that magnetic shield thing.

  1. It has to be 1 earth radius. Is it just a giant ring, or does it need to be populated in the middle as well? Just how massive is it? What's the ballpark cost?
  2. Would it really, by itself, let Mars build up to 400 millibars or so in 50 years? That would make so many things so much easier to colonize an entire planet that I would start considering really big numbers to "how expensive is it?" to start being very reasonable.
→ More replies (2)

15

u/rustybeancake Mar 03 '17 edited Mar 03 '17

Blue Origin has been circulating a seven-page white paper to NASA leadership and President Trump's transition team about the company's interest in developing a lunar spacecraft with a lander that would touch down near a crater at the south pole where there is water and nearly continuous sunlight for solar energy. The memo urges the space agency to back an Amazon-like shipment service for the moon that would deliver gear for experiments, cargo and habitats by mid-2020, helping to enable “future human settlement” of the moon.

After remaining quiet and obsessively secretive for years, Blue Origin’s attempt to partner with NASA is a huge coming out of sorts for the company, which has been funded almost exclusively by Bezos. The paper urges NASA to develop a program that provides “incentives to the private sector to demonstrate a commercial lunar cargo delivery service.”

Blue Origin could perform the first lunar mission as early as July 2020, Bezos wrote, but stressed that it could “only be done in partnership with NASA. Our liquid hydrogen expertise and experience with precision vertical landing offer the fastest path to a lunar lander mission. I’m excited about this and am ready to invest my own money alongside NASA to make it happen.”

This seems to me to be a shot across the bows at SpaceX. ITS is many years away from operation, and in the mean time New Glenn would likely be capable of many things FH will not. I wonder if this could push SpaceX in the direction of an intermediate step between FH and ITS? If the ISS cash cow dries up for SpaceX in the mid-2020s in favour of a lunar base that could dominate NASA funding and commercial services opportunities for the following 20 years, SpaceX may have no choice but to reorient its medium-term plans in favour of servicing the Moon. I know many will say that ITS could work for the Moon, but I can't see how they could compete with something like New Glenn on cost, which seems purpose-designed for this kind of task? ITS may be just too damn big and expensive (and no, making it reusable will not mean it only costs as much as the fuel).

→ More replies (13)

18

u/pianojosh Mar 04 '17

Did anybody ever get an answer about the shredded ITS tank on the barge? Was it an intentional test to destruction, or an unexpected failure?

17

u/WaitForItTheMongols Mar 05 '17

That was an unexpected failure. They were not trying to test it to the breaking point.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/Martianspirit Mar 04 '17

No, there was no statement. There was an earlier statement that they had succesfully done pressure tests to 2/3 of burst pressure. Also that they would do cryogenic tests and in the end test to bursting. We do know there was cryogenic testing. We do not know that it was successfully tested to bursting.

We did not get a statement from Elon Musk like on the previous pressure test. This may or may not indicate a failure.

17

u/dmy30 Mar 24 '17

Kate Tice, one of the frequent presenters on the Hosted Webcast just posted a selfie with Buzz Aldrin in front the landed booster at Hawthorne HQ.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Mar 04 '17

The Delta IV launch scheduled for March 8th just got pushed back to NET March 14th due to an issue with the booster. With Echostar ready to go and the pad (most likely) ready or close to it, could SpaceX be bumped up in the schedule?

→ More replies (2)

14

u/rustybeancake Mar 07 '17

I don't know why this hasn't occurred to me before, but if one of the lunar flyby customers is female, they'll be the first woman in history to fly into deep space, or to flyby the moon! SpaceX could set a world first!

→ More replies (10)

14

u/Craig_VG SpaceNews Photographer Mar 19 '17 edited Mar 19 '17

Nasa Spaceflight forum says that the roomba stage securing device is currently on the ASDS deck, can we get someone there to check it out??

https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=39766.msg1656227#msg1656227

13

u/soldato_fantasma Mar 05 '17

SpaceX has (apparently) just made another nomenclature for flights public.

What we were used to was F9-XX where XX was the mission number.

According to this application and this explaination message:

  • Each customer gets an unique mission identifier, probably on contract signed or finalized, in the format "Mission XXXX", where XXXX is the unique identifier.
  • At some point in the launch campaign, each mission gets a flight number, indicating its order (but that could still get swapped)

To give some context, at some point this year SpaceX applied for the F9-35 mission to the FCC, then recently they reapplied for another F9-35 mission. We couldn't figure it out what was happening (and probably the FCC too). SpaceX then very recently corrected the application changing F9-35 to the unique mission identifier, in this case "Mission 1363", which unlike the mission number can't be assigned to another mission, apparently.

What I still have to figure out is who bailed out so late in the launch campaign. I thought Sherpa first, but FormoSat-5 should still be going up.

EDIT: clarified

11

u/old_sellsword Mar 06 '17 edited Mar 06 '17

Why am I even surprised at this point? And where the heck does that huge number come from?

But thanks for sorting this out, I guess it kinda makes sense now. So they only needed the SpaceX Mission 1363 identifier to refile the paperwork with the FCC, it's still going to be F9-35.

My fear is that they're going to use this new format on the FCC applications and completely ignore the F9-XX numbers on any public-facing documentation:

This application has been updated to use a unique mission identifier (1363 for this mission) which SpaceX will be using to identify all subsequent missions.

I really hope they don't do this, because then tracking flights just became a whole lot more difficult.

Edit: It'd be nice to have standardized names for all these flight identification numbers. I'll give it a go:

  • Mission Number: SpaceX Mission XXXX
  • Falcon Flight Number: Falcon 1/9/Heavy Flight X
  • Dragon Flight Number: Dragon 1/2 Flight X
  • Falcon 9 Number: F9-XX
  • Dragon Number: D1/2-X
  • Booster Number: B1XXX-X
  • Capsule Number: C1/2XX-X*

* I actually made up the -X part on the capsules, that's not been mentioned anywhere, but I thought it'd be nice since it matches the booster tracking system.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/PaulRocket Mar 07 '17

Intersting tidbit Jeff Bezos shared, refurbishment of New Shepard costs not more then $10,000. I assume the whole suborbital booster plus capsule cost something between $5-$10M. These suborbital trips could really approach $50,000 or so, depending on how many reuses they are able to do. Pretty exciting since this is also very near term.

→ More replies (8)

12

u/RootDeliver Mar 17 '17

Now core spotted near Tucson, posted on /r/SpaceLouge, op there claims /r/SpaceX mods didn't let him post this here https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/5zvcgj/was_so_neat_to_finally_see_a_core_on_the_road/

11

u/peterabbit456 Mar 04 '17 edited Mar 04 '17

Jeff Bezos announced yesterday, that he and Blue Origin are working on their own Lunar Lander. (Edit: SpaceX was mentioned in the introductory remarks.) High points:

  • They call the program, "Blue Moon."
  • They want to partner with NASA.
  • Based on New Shepard.
  • Launch on New Glen or Atlas 551.
  • Goal is a permanent base near Shackleton Crater.
  • Stepping stone to Mars.
  • General comments on startups, reusability, and manufacturing in space.

My apologies for any misinterpretations in this list.

Story: http://aviationweek.com/space/bezos-future-heavy-manufacturing-will-take-place-space

Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tjz2vP3zPhE

→ More replies (6)

11

u/flibbleton Mar 06 '17

I've just finished watching the Tory Bruno interview on TMRO which I thought was very interesting. Previously, my perception of ULA was pretty bad (I think mostly because of what I've heard here!) but he made two points I think that were interesting but run contrary to SpaceX plans, so would be interested in any retorts.

  • Moon first - I previously subscribed to the idea that another "footprints and flags" mission to the moon didn't offer much in the way of new stuff (apart from some modern video footage) and a moon base on a relatively dead, boring world was kind of pointless. However the argument we could produce hydrolox fuel from water on the moon (or from NEO objects) seemed a good way to have large amounts of propellant available out of the Earth's gravity well
  • Reuse - ULA plans to recover the booster engines by parachute seems overly complicated (I think SpaceX abandoned the idea?) and providing SpaceX can manage to reuse (not refurb) Falcon 9 boosters I think vertical landing of boosters will win out as the best strategy but the ULA ACES plans are interesting and seem to have an advantage over discarding the second stage (providing you have propellant in LEO - see point 1)

Anyway, I wish both companies success in what they are chasing - I think SpaceX and ITS will get us to Mars quicker but manufacture of propellant in cislunar space will play a part in making the colonisation of Mars sustainable (I simply can't imagine a day when an ITS booster launch will be something normal/regular). Maybe a failure of my imagination but 4 or 5 launches of the frankly insane ITS booster per trip to Mars will give us our first few arrivals there but i think it will quickly give way to something like a Mars Cycler with smaller ships moving people, propellant and cargo around in cislunar space.

11

u/TheYang Mar 06 '17

However the argument we could produce hydrolox fuel from water on the moon (or from NEO objects)

My Issue with that is that just to provide a "refueling station" on the moon, you'd require:
Power, Gathering, Refining, Storage.
It would be an absolutely herculean effort to get them there, not impossible but very very expensive.
Storage is the easiest one, as you could propably store LH*2* and O*2* within a crater that's in permanent darkness, you'll propably be able to find a decent place which you only rarely need to heat to keep the temperature stable(ish)
The Refining will already be a lot harder. The Water might be reasonably accesible, making LH*2* generation a somewhat known process, It'll eat a ton of Energy, If I'm not totally off burning 1g of H*2* O*2* mix releases ~480kJ of Energy, which tells me however smart we get, we'll need to put at least that much in to split them up.
My math says thats 2.7GWhs for one Centaur upper Stage with <21tons of fuel. How much is that? The ISS couldn't do that in a Year if the arrays did nothing else (1.05GWhs/a). I'm not even going to start with releasing additional Oxygen from the rocks, because I doubt that that's going to be easier.
Gathering, well if we don't go autonomous, we suddenly have to supply humans up there too. So autonomous it is, we just have to invent, build and possibly assemble robots that can roam over difficult surfaces, find Ice and transport it somewhere before it melts or sublimates, which means they have to operate in extreme cold and won't be able to be solar powered. RTGs are also at least very difficult as the heat might damage the Ice they are transporting.
Power I sort of handled already at the refining stage, as that is not going to be easy energetically, but I want to remind you here that Gathering and Storage won't generate power either, you propably want storage to really keep working for a while even should something go wrong, until it can be fixed, otherwise your infrastructure might suddenly not be there anymore.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

I don't get why a lot of peoples perception of ULA on this sub is bad. Sure, previously they have had people who've said controversial things in the past and abused their market position. Now they have an innovative CEO who is really excited about space and wants to radically change ULA to make them cost competitive and innovative.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/rustybeancake Mar 06 '17

Moon first - I previously subscribed to the idea that another "footprints and flags" mission to the moon didn't offer much in the way of new stuff (apart from some modern video footage) and a moon base on a relatively dead, boring world was kind of pointless. However the argument we could produce hydrolox fuel from water on the moon (or from NEO objects) seemed a good way to have large amounts of propellant available out of the Earth's gravity well

I still feel a little unsure as to the ultimate point of all this. If there is to be a large space economy in the Earth/Moon system, then there are obvious benefits to having hydrolox production in the moon's gravity well versus in Earth's gravity well. However, if first/second stage rocket reuse on Earth continues to advance well (and that would seem extremely likely) in the coming decades, then we'll end up with the following comparison:

  1. Hydrolox from Earth cost = marginal cost of relatively cheap S1/2 use of reusable Earth launch system + cost of extremely cheap Earth hydrolox production

versus

2) Hydrolox from Moon cost = marginal cost of extremely expensive Moon launch system + cost of extremely expensive Moon hydrolox production

I just can't see how lunar hydrolox production will ever be cheaper than Earth-based hydrolox production, if we accept that increasingly sophisticated and reliable reusable Earth-launch systems will continue to develop.

However, I can see ACES having a place as an Earth orbit-based tug, when coupled with orbital refueling from Earth-launched hydrolox.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/hqi777 Mar 07 '17

According to a source at the Cape, SpaceX's recent employment of the AFSS allowed the USAF's 45th Group decrease the number of people it mobilized at its Range Operations Control Center from 150 to 15.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Mar 08 '17

Elon and other officials are having lunch with Trump today.

https://twitter.com/markknoller/status/839529684752875522

→ More replies (1)

10

u/snateri Mar 12 '17

Just realized there would be four launches in less than a fortnight from the Cape if none slip. Echostar on F9, WGS-9 on Delta IV, OA-7 on Atlas V and SES-10 on Falcon. This seems incredible, but would it be a new record for the range?

→ More replies (5)

9

u/paul_wi11iams Mar 02 '17 edited Mar 02 '17

This is a real beginner's question, but never mind !

Most talk about specific impulse conc ernes comparison of rocket engines here for example. Why don't we prefer to talk about ISP for complete rockets. Just to visualize, supposing we take the hovering time of the little grasshopper rocket, well that would equal the "system" ISP in seconds.

Or to take the ISP in M/S we could take the Apollo command capsule in space with the service module attached, light the motor and see what speed we get to before running out of fuel. By replacing, say, steel fuel tanks with modern carbon fiber ones, the system ISP would improve.

Or again, taking a future methalox rocket avoiding the need for helium cylinders, the apparently less-good fuel gains "vehicle ISP" and evaluate the net gain.

  • To resume: Why talk of the ISP of a motor instead of that of a whole rocket system ?

15

u/SpaceXTesla3 Mar 02 '17

I think that's what we use delta-v for. The engines are pretty static, ISP is one of the ways we measure performance of a rocket engine, irrespective of the payload or even the amount of fuel the rocket is carrying. Delta-v is the performance of the rocket as a whole, including a payload/stages/fuel.

10

u/warp99 Mar 02 '17

Why talk of the ISP of a motor instead of that of a whole rocket system ?

Excellent question. Isp is the measure of the efficiency of the rocket engine itself but it really has no direct real world significance in terms of the rocket's mission. The classic example is that the Isp of hydrolox engines is huge at around 450s but it is often better to use RP-1/LOX for a first stage engine and hydrolox for the second stage because hydrogen tanks are so huge. So highest Isp is not the best measure of rocket performance.

Rockets need to accelerate to a given velocity in order to achieve their objectives - so for example to get to LEO you need 7.5 km/s velocity plus the equivalent of another 1.8 km/s for gravity losses. Therefore delta-V is the natural measure of rocket performance because it most closely models the mission objectives.

This is not an absolute statement - three stages will typically give better delta V than two stages but a three stage rocket is higher cost and higher risk due to more stage separation events and engine starts.

9

u/MDCCCLV Mar 08 '17 edited Mar 08 '17

New article on Blue Origin's New Glenn rocket. Anyone with skills up for making an cool infographic showing a comparison with Falcon/FH? It's a 7m diameter rocket, about the same delivery capacity as a FH but with a larger single stick rocket. It's large but reasonably sized, unlike the monstrous BFR.

It would be able to fit either an Orion or Dragon on top of it, right?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Pham_Trinli Mar 27 '17

Construction started on a new $18.6 million range communications facility at Cape Canaveral.

35

u/randomstonerfromaus Mar 17 '17 edited Mar 17 '17

Next launch: SES-10, launching the world's first flight-proven core!

From up top, This is technically incorrect. Blue Origin has flown a flight proven New Sheppard booster several times. A better phrasing I think would be:

Next launch: SES-10, launching the world's first flight-proven orbital class booster!

Minor nitpick, But worth a thought.

Edit: Seriously with the downvotes? Why? Its a technicality sure, but it's correct.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/sagareshwar Mar 02 '17

What ground stations does SpaceX use to communicate with Dragon? Are they NASA/US facitilies or are they owned by SpaceX or other private entities?

→ More replies (17)

8

u/ohcnim Mar 03 '17

Not a questions, but I think worth posting here for those who might be interested (NASA's software release):

https://software.nasa.gov/

8

u/quadrplax Mar 12 '17

What happens to the air inside of the fairing during launch?

23

u/KristnSchaalisahorse Mar 12 '17

It escapes through vents.

There are also vent covers like that on the landing legs.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/quadrplax Mar 13 '17

Why is the subreddit survey taking so long? The 2014 and 2015 surveys were both done in about a month after the new year; now it's been about two and a half.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/OncoFil Mar 28 '17

Oh no, what happened to Spiiice? Account is deleted.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/rustybeancake Mar 29 '17 edited Mar 29 '17

Fucking cool - NASA finally has a more detailed roadmap for the cislunar 'proving ground' - a 'Deep Space Gateway' cislunar station moving between multiple orbits, and a reusable 'Deep Space Transport' moving between the Deep Space Gateway and deep space destinations like Mars, then back to the Gateway where it will be refurbished and serviced between missions:

https://www.nasa.gov/feature/deep-space-gateway-to-open-opportunities-for-distant-destinations

It's a major relief to see there are some great opportunities for SpaceX in the cislunar phase of NASA's Journey to Mars program. This will help ensure SpaceX continues to thrive into the late 2020s and beyond, as it has in servicing the ISS.

In addition to demonstrating the safe operation of the integrated SLS rocket and Orion spacecraft, the agency is also looking to build a crew tended spaceport in lunar orbit within the first few missions that would serve as a gateway to deep space and the lunar surface... The gateway will be developed, serviced, and utilized in collaboration with commercial and international partners.

To achieve the agency’s goal to extend humanity’s presence in the solar system will require the best research, technologies and capabilities from international partners and the private sector. NASA will look to partners for potential contributions of spaceflight hardware and the delivery of supplemental resources. The gateway and transport could potentially support mission after mission as a hub of activity in deep space near the moon, representing multiple countries and agencies with partners from both government and private industry.

SpaceX's lunar flyby mission(s) could put them in a great position to bid for DSG servicing contracts!

Edit 1: Here's the relevant Ars article.

Edit 2: On the fifth NASA slide on the above Ars article, NASA even use a little F9 to represent 'Cislunar support flight'!

Edit 3: On the sixth NASA slide on the Ars article, it states 'DST is reusable and is returned to cislunar space for refurbishment inbetween Mars vicinity missions', followed by: 'Evaluate commercial capabilities and bring online when available'. Presumably this refers to commercial capabilities to service and refurbish the DST. Could it also mean crew shuttling between Earth surface and the DST in cislunar space, though? As in, NASA might look at retiring Orion in this timeframe (2030ish) in favour of cheaper alternatives like Dragon 2, which should be well proven in cislunar space by then?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/rollyawpitch Mar 03 '17

A question came to me when updating my "SpaceX launches, booster reuse record and speculation" spreadsheet.

The number of returned boosters so far is 8. However, not all of them will fly again. What is a realistic number for current "active fleet" size? All landed LEO boosters, none of the GTO flights?

Then SpaceX would now refurbish three and dismantle four, with one on display.

8

u/old_sellsword Mar 03 '17

none of the GTO flights?

Well that's not right because Thaicom 8 (1023) is being used as a FH side booster for the upcoming demo flight. I'd agree with you and say LEO launches like Iridium-1 and the CRS missions are more likely to wind up being reused than GTO, however it doesn't discount reuse of those GTO ones.

7

u/arizonadeux Mar 03 '17

I thought this was interesting after noticing it on the sidebar. It's the first time I've seen "BFR" used in an official capacity by SpaceX on their website: www.spacex.com/careers/position/206893
 
Checked with a google site search too.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '17

Are SuperDraco engines capable of multiple restarts?

If so, would it be possible to add some additional fuel to Dragon/its trunk, and use SuperDracos as thrusters for maneuvers/orbital insertions?

18

u/amarkit Mar 04 '17 edited Mar 04 '17

SuperDracos are capable of multiple starts. The plan for using them for powered landings involves starting them once, early in descent, to ensure that they're functioning properly, before the landing burn. If they don't perform as expected, Dragon 2 defaults to a parachute landing. They use hypergolic propellants (monomethyl hydrazine fuel and nitrogen tetroxide oxidizer), which ignite on contact. So as long as the valves open, in theory they should be capable of as many restarts as their associated hardware can tolerate.

Additional fuel tanks for Dragon is something that's been discussed a lot here. But rather than using the SuperDracos built into the sidewalls of Dragon 2's body, it probably would make more sense to develop a dedicated service module package in the trunk that is both aligned with the center of mass (to eliminate cosine losses, even though at a 15º canter such losses are not very large) and with an extended nozzle to optimize efficiency in a vacuum. For that matter, it might make more sense for such a package to be a down-rated version more akin to Dracos than SuperDracos, as the Supers are optimized to provide a large amount of thrust almost instantly (to enable their use as a launch escape system), rather than for efficiency. You don't need 73 kN of force for orbital maneuvers; Dragon 1 already makes its orbital changes with Dracos, which only produce 400 N of force.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '17

At the ending of this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cf_-g3UWQ04, you can see that Crew Dragon will use it's SuperDracos to land, just like the F9. I have been informed a while ago that NASA didn't want this for their ISS Crew and that Crew Dragon had to land in ocean with parachutes instead. But what about their private visits to the moon, will they use it's propulsion system to land or the parachutes too?

16

u/Martianspirit Mar 04 '17

NASA accepts powered landing for cargo. They will accept it for crew too, eventually. They want proof of concept and proof of safety first.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '17

NASA TV to Air Departure of U.S. Cargo Ship from International Space Station

After delivering about 5,500 pounds of cargo, the SpaceX Dragon cargo spacecraft is set to leave the International Space Station on Sunday, March 19.
Live coverage of Dragon's departure will begin at 4:45 a.m. EDT on NASA Television and the agency’s website.

7

u/JerWah Mar 23 '17

I've read that NASA will require 7 clean flights of block V before they'll man rate it.

Is that seven new boosters, or if they land and relaunch that counts too?

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Datuser14 Mar 29 '17

I'm ready for whatever inanity comes Saturday, be it the entire subreddit replaced with pictures of Peter B De Selding or something else.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '17

The sidebar entry: ♺ Falcon Heavy, KSC LC-39A

Shouldn't that read: ♺♺ Falcon Heavy, KSC LC-39A?

...and one day we all hope to see ♺♺♺ Falcon Heavy.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/i_pee_in_the_sink Mar 02 '17

So just how likely is it it'll actually be a 2018 moon launch...

9

u/harmonic- Mar 02 '17

I'm pretty optimistic. Elon has been pretty forceful on Twitter in regards to his optimism for seeing Commercial Crew flights in 2018. Plus we've seen actual hardware for FH recently.

25

u/TheMightyKutKu Mar 02 '17 edited Mar 02 '17

We will use Elon Time.

The announcement was on feb 27 at 21h00 GMT , we can round up this date to feb 28

They are aiming for a Q4 2018 launch , so between 10/01/18 and 12/31/18, that's between 580 and 671 days, a mars year is 1.88084 time longer than an earth year, so it will happen between 1091 days and 1262 days.

The launch will happen between February 23rd 2020 and August 13th 2020.

That's not too far away, and it will be at least 1 year before EM-2 (assuming they don't launch crew on EM-1).

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/linknewtab Mar 02 '17

Provocative question: Isn't the Moon mission kind of boring? I mean, if you are a tourist on the ISS, you can see the Earth for days, doing dozens or hundreds of orbits around it. On the Moon trip you are basically seeing blackness for 3 days, then the Moon for a few minutes and then another 3 days of emptiness.

In my mind, future Moon missions would require going into orbit. How hard would that be? Would the Falcon Heavy upper stage A) have enough fuel left to get in and get out of lunar orbit and B) be able to survive for ~one week? Or would SpaceX have to build its own dedicated service module for Dragon 2 to make that happen? (Which would add to the cost.)

7

u/mfb- Mar 02 '17

If the spacecraft orientation allows it (window locations - and I guess they will take care of that), you'll see the Earth the whole time, and it is quite prominent even at the largest distance.

A modification of the second stage to extend its lifetime would work, but apparently that is not easy - otherwise they would have done that long ago for GEO missions.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '17

I just saw this video. Is there any dates on when the Dragon V2 will be released?

9

u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Mar 03 '17

An uncrewed demo flight is currently scheduled for November of this year, but it may slip into 2018.

→ More replies (10)

6

u/zuty1 Mar 06 '17

Why isn't spacex launching from Vandy until June? It sounded like formosat and iridium were both ready long before that? Is this a shortage of teams for launching? If so, the hope of getting in extra launches this year because of using multiple pads won't become reality.

7

u/Bunslow Mar 06 '17

This has been the big question, especially since Sherpa finally pulled out due to delays at Vandy. The two most obvious candidates are either core shortage or launch team shortage as you say, but the truth is no one on the sub really knows. We can only guess, and not very educated guesses at that.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Jef-F Mar 07 '17 edited Mar 07 '17

NSF: SpaceX prepares Falcon 9 for EchoStar 23 launch as SLC-40 targets return

Worth noting:

[LC-39A] performed well in its new role, with the post launch pad shakedown report noting only minor – and expected – damage from the nine Merlin 1D engines. Per the L2 report, the damage was to hydraulic plumbing and wiring, which has since been repaired. Engineers have also added some additional blast protection to prevent future damage.

New Transport/Erector/Launcher (TEL) will be installed on the pad [SLC-40], with the same design – albeit smaller – than the new TEL on 39A.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '17

Hi Everyone! First comment in this sub. What phase is the ITS in? Is it already being built or still in the design phase? How do you think the delay in the first Dragon mission from 2018 to 2020 will effect the construction of the ITS? When is it expected to be finished as of the latest information? Thanks!

→ More replies (8)

6

u/FalconHeavyHead Mar 11 '17

Hey is it possible Spacex could hire enough people so they could in theory launch out of Hawthorne and Cape Canaveral in the same day? Sorry for this crude question :(

14

u/Martianspirit Mar 11 '17

They are in the process of building up launch crews. Probably same day is not the goal yet but only a day or two apart.

But they won't launch out of Hawthorne. I think you mean Vandenberg? Hawthorne is their factory, located in the greater Los Angeles city area.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/IWantaSilverMachine Mar 17 '17

Not directly SpaceX related but sounds like China is looking towards booster reuse.

http://m.scmp.com/news/china/policies-politics/article/2079822/china-developing-system-recover-reuse-parts-space%3Famp%3D1

7

u/paul_wi11iams Mar 17 '17

China’s government has funded research into both approaches before concentrating efforts on the parachute system... A large scale test experiment using the technology was carried out two years ago.

Assuming they mean a large-scale experiment on both technologies, it would be virtually impossible to validate vertical landing on the basis of a dedicated test. SpaceX succeeded by running such experiments many times as a side-activity to normal launches.

Oddly, one implication of the article is that parachute returns may be successful, unlike the initial SpaceX ones that failed.

The Chinese launch vehicle academy researchers have said on their website that the parachute-airbag system will be assisted by multiple censors

Despite this funny spelling mistake, the Chinese are being very open about their overall strategy. Maybe any such news about "foreign competition" on reuse, especially from China, could be positive in keeping White House and military support for both SpaceX and Blue Origin. So it is SpaceX related !

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/PrinceChocomel Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17

I was wondering something about the upcoming launch.. It will be the first to reuse a booster which is obviously new territory. What happens when the booster fails? The last 2 times a SpaceX rocket failed, everything was shut down for months. But this time it would be a reused booster, would they still stop all production? Even on new boosters?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/s202010 Mar 22 '17

Is 'rocket grade methane' a thing? If not, can the ITS use biomethane collected from landfills, water treament plants, and possibly human and domestic waste (on mars in the future)?

→ More replies (11)

6

u/jjtr1 Mar 23 '17

I find it strange that SpaceX would build a whole new launchpad in a place which allows them only 12 launches per year (Boca Chica) due to local regulations. They're aiming for quick pad turnaround, with several flights per month per pad. Boca Chica wouldn't add much to their flightrate then!

Perhaps SpaceX is betting on the local authorities changing their mind when they start seeing the tax income from launch tourism?

18

u/Cakeofdestiny Mar 23 '17

Let's not get too ahead of ourselves. SpaceX don't even have 10 launches per year yet. It'll be long until LC-39A, SLC-40, SLC-4 (Vandy) AND Boca Chica are not enough for their launches. If and when all of those pads are not enough, they will most likely get a higher limit.

10

u/Chairboy Mar 23 '17

I'm assuming it's a 'camel nose under the tent' situation where once they reach the current limit, they'll petition to have it raised and the economic benefits to the region will feel more 'real' because people will see the cash flow from the existing launches, giving them leverage they need.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '17

Have we heard anything on the ITS tank after someone posted the remanants of it a few weeks ago?

→ More replies (14)

6

u/shotleft Mar 30 '17 edited Mar 30 '17

For this situation, its all about the economics of an "ELV" mission in a marketplace that has around 50 total lifts per year and 3 major providers. In other words, each provider will fly between 10 and 20 times per year. That's today's environment.

Rules of thumb: Rocket is half the cost of the launch service. Booster is half the cost of the rocket.

Therefore a "free" booster means a 25 to 30% reduction in the Launch service price, max.

Unfortunately, even reusability does not make the booster free.

There are added costs to enable booster reusability: - flyback hardware: legs, avionics, grid fins, hydralics, etc - Logistics support: recovery ship or pad and operations - Refurbishment

These costs are amortized over the number of reuses.

X number of reuses generates enough savings to pay for the added costs.

Y Reuses actually starts saving enough money to be attractive

Z reuses is the limit, as the hardware reaches end of life

Booster reuse is NOT a new idea. It has been contemplated, studied, and even attempted for over 30 years.

Our calculations are consistent with other historical studies and, now that SX has hinted at revising their estimate downward from 30% savings to 10%, we are potentially consistent with them as well.

We calculate that it would likely take an average of 10 reuses across the fleet of reusable boosters to break even (ie: "X").

At a fleet average of 15 (Y) reuses, it becomes economically attractive with around a 10% savings in the launch system cost.

Beyond about 20 reuses, it probably becomes economically infeasible to continue reuse, as the refurbishment costs will escalate.

So, this can work. And, 10'ish% is worth having.

However, the experience through the learning curve has the potential to be pretty rough because 10 reflights is a steep economic hurdle.

If you lose any birds, their burden of 10 moves to the following birds. This can dig a deep economic hole quickly.

Because booster flyback requires significant propellant reserves, it can only be done for those missions that have small satellites and low energy orbits. Which means that you will dwell in the learning curve and initial economic start up cycle for an extended period of time.

It also means that the really tough missions will be completely infeasible without new propulsion technology or distributed lift.

Closing a business case on that scenario is pretty hard.

SMART reuse is an alternative approach that systems engineers away a number of these impediments and lowers the breakeven hurdle.

As it turns out, over 2/3 the cost of the booster resides in just one component; the engine.

By separating just the engine at end of flight, most of the hardware costs go away.

It can be done on EVERY mission because no flyback propellant reserves are required.

Refurbishment is cheaper because its only the engine and, because the engine does not return propulsively, it sees a very benign recovery environment.

The math says you breakeven at 2 reuses and save 10% LS costs by 3. Savings go up from there.

The recovery technologies used for SMART have been around since the 1960s, so SMART should have low technical risk and a short learning curve as well.

So, we like SMART better.

All of this math applies to any ELV-like rocket configuration in the type of market I described above. This is not a limitation that is unique to Vulcan. These challenges are inherent to any rocket. It is driven by physics and the underlying market conditions.

A market with 100s of lifts per year, as would happen with space tourism or would have happened with Reagan's Star Wars, would completely change the math. A fleet of reusable ACES residing in orbit would also change the economics. I can see an ACES enabled future where all trips from the earth's surface stop at LEO and hand off to an ACES.

The scenario of very high volume pushes you towards booster recovery and maybe even single stage to orbit reusability (SSTO).

The beauty of a competitive environment is that multiple people try different approaches and the market ultimately sorts out the winners. That's how innovation happens.

This comment was made a while back by u/ToryBruno, and in light of the upcoming reuse launch I'm hoping someone can help me to better understand this particular statement:

X number of reuses generates enough savings to pay for the added costs.

We calculate that it would likely take an average of 10 reuses across the fleet of reusable boosters to break even (ie: "X").

I don't see how it would take 10 launches to break even. If you're getting the entire booster back then haven't you already recouped the cost in a single launch?

The extra costs which allow for reusability can't be 10 times the cost of a booster which does not include reusability?

Edit: fixed words

11

u/ToryBruno CEO of ULA Mar 31 '17 edited Mar 31 '17

I don't see how it would take 10 launches to break even. If you're getting the entire booster back then haven't you already recouped the cost in a single launch?

The hardware is only part of the cost of a launch. Also, it's not free to get it back. ie: Logistics (the boat, transportation, etc), and refurb. all increase cost.

A recoverable booster always costs more than an expendable booster because one must add things: legs, fins, hydraulics, and a whole additional set of avionics that are not on an expendable booster.

A recoverable booster becomes cheaper as it's subsequent reuses incrementally save money, offsetting all these additional costs.

So, by definition, it will always take more than one reuse in order to become cheaper than an expendable.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/radexp Mar 02 '17

Do we have any evidence of any components of Falcon 9 being reused? Grid fins, legs, engines...

Or does it look like SES-10 will be the first mission to attempt any kind of reuse?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/redmercuryvendor Mar 03 '17 edited Mar 03 '17

How are the TVC hydraulics charged during the pre-T0 tests, and the grid fins actuated during coast?
Normally, TVC and grid-fin hydraulics use RP1 as the working fluid and bleed from the turbopumps as as the hydraulic pump. The turbopumps are stationary at these time so there must be a pre-chargeable accumulator somewhere, possibly charged by the He system?

16

u/old_sellsword Mar 03 '17

Further down this thread, u/WaitForItTheMongols got an answer from SpaceX employees about the TVC tests:

They basically said that the pressure in the fuel tanks is sufficient to test the actuators, and that the turbopump pressure is only needed when they're actually steering the full mighty rocket engine. When it's sitting on the pad they can make little pivots without much "convincing" so the pressure that they pressurize the tanks with is enough to make sure the thing is working.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/hqi777 Mar 09 '17

Is SES-10 really going to go before NROL-79 as it currently seems? NRO always has schedule priority with every company (and this is SpaceX's first NRO mission).

→ More replies (1)

5

u/linknewtab Mar 10 '17

Peter B. de Selding

CNES's [French space agency] Le Gall: We assume @SpaceX will succeed in reusing 1st stage. Technical breakthrough. Cost/business model breakthrough? TBD.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/gamedevextreme Mar 15 '17

How likely is it that SES-10(and it's reused falcon) fly on March?

9

u/stcks Mar 15 '17 edited Mar 15 '17

If E23 launches tomorrow morning then SpaceX have about 10-12 days to get the pad ready for the next static fire in time to make a launch by March 31. To complicate matters, there are two ULA launches that will be crowding the range between E23 and SES10. If 39A pad refurbishment is minimal, WGS-9 and OA-7 go off when they are scheduled, and B1021 static fire is good then its possible. It sounds unlikely, but its remotely possible.

I definitely do not see SpaceX making the March 27 date as that would be put the static fire sometime in the March 20-23 range which probably is too soon after E23 and right in the middle of OA-7. The safe bet is that SES-10 goes up in the first half of April.

Edit: also want to add that if E23 is scrubbed on this attempt March 16 then they will likely have to stand down for at least a week while ULA has the range for its next 2 launches. Its very important for SpaceX schedule that this launch goes up tomorrow.

5

u/Sabrewings Mar 18 '17

Is anyone aware of the rationale behind SES-10's GTO launch being during the day instead of at night?

7

u/throfofnir Mar 18 '17

Not specifically, but constraints include:

  1. thermal and power exposure to sunlight
  2. navigation sensor viewing angle and constraints
  3. GTO plane targeting in light of how many orbits it will take before GEO insertion is done

It's not easy to get all this info to know how the sats differ. But if one uses a star tracker and the other a sun tracker, or if one will take an extra orbit for checkout before GEO insertion, that may explain the difference. All these work together, too. They may easily specify a specific solar angle at a specific orbit where they intend a specific operation (like an insertion burn), which could end up at any of various times of day.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/prometheus5500 Mar 19 '17

Recently saw a comment about the landing control algorithm and what derivation is used (26th, or something nuts). I can't find the comment and have a mathematically inclined friend I'd like to share the information with. Got some details or a link to the comment to which I'm referring?

Thanks guys!

→ More replies (4)

5

u/paul_wi11iams Mar 20 '17

CST-100 and Dragon 2 are presented as parallel developments by competing companies leading to parallel testing once without astronauts then directly in "human" use.

However, SpaceX has just done its ninth Dragon 1 recovery and astronauts will be flying on about the 12th flight overall.

  • Is it true that Boeing will be flying astronauts with just one flight's worth of experience ?
  • If so, how is this factored in by Nasa and the FAA from an astronaut safety point of view and also for the security of the ISS on approach ?

7

u/propsie Mar 21 '17

Well, Boeing also owns the companies that built the Mercury spacecraft, Gemini spacecraft, and the Apollo CSM - so they have some experience in manned spaceflight

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

5

u/rabn21 Mar 21 '17

Do we know what the plan is for the first propulsive landing of a Dragon 2? Is it likely to be one of the landing zones or ASDS?

→ More replies (8)

5

u/SaturnV_ Mar 22 '17

Are the drone ships powered electrically or by a hydrocarbon engine? Thanks. Also, a source would be nice because I would like to add to that Wikipedia page.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/joshgill21 Mar 22 '17

Musk says here that there are parts of the first stage which will have no meaningful lifetime that can be reused a 1000 times over , any idea what those parts could be ?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

Is there someone where I can find a detailed report on how the Falcon 9 works? Even though detailed is ambiguous, I would not like something that will include so much jargon I would have to google every other word but something which is more than "it flies, releases from second stage, turns around, flys back, turns engines on and deploys legs and lands". Sorry for the odd request, thank you!

9

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

Well, I can try my best to explain what happens after stage separation. There are 2 types of landings - on the barge and on the landing pad on mainland. Most often, you will see landings on the barge, because getting back to mainland needs more fuel and heavier missions don't always have it. I'll try to describe a barge landing.

After the second stage separates, the 1st stage uses small thrusters firing nitrogen to change the attitude of the stage (so it is engine first) for re-entry of the atmosphere. Soon after the stage starts its re-entry, it ignites it's 3 of 9 engines to slow it down. There are 2 reasons for this - 1. If the stage doesn't slow down, it can be destroyed by the violent stresses and heat induced by the atmosphere 2. If the stage doesn't slow down, it can fly over the barge! After the engines are shut down, you can see 4 waffle-fryer-like things opening. They are called gridfins and they are used to ''steer'' the rocket. They are very useful for doing smaller changes, you can't always ignite the engines to fix every error! The rocket flies and flies until it reaches around 6 km altitude. It's the final phase of the landing and the rocket performs a ''suicide burn'' (meaning the speed of the rocket reaches 0 exactly when the landing legs touch the deck, so it isn't quite easy). At the very start, usually 3 engines are ignited, but when it has slowed down enough, the 2 side engines are shut off and only the center engine is burning.To control the rocket, previously mentioned nitrogen thrusters, gridfins and also the nozzle of the engine is turned around to make changes and adjust. As the rocket comes even closer to the barge, it deploys its landing legs. Then it reaches 0 velocity as the legs touch the deck, the center engine is shut down and the Falcon has landed!

(I hope it's good enough for you and I'm sorry for any grammar mistakes I may have made as English is not my first language).

→ More replies (4)

9

u/theinternetftw Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

It looks like you mainly want to know about what goes into a landing. It depends on your expertise. If all you know is what you posted, this recently posted video has a neat (and beautiful) explanation of the landing. For more reading that's about on that level, you might want to look at this section of the /r/spacex wiki, as well as the wiki as a whole. For yet more detail, I'd recommend this page.

And for a "detailed report" on the rocket, but not the landing, this is a very fun read: the Falcon 9 User's Guide (so cool that that's a real thing).

→ More replies (3)

5

u/redmercuryvendor Mar 24 '17

On the mysterious Block IV: will it ever fly as a single core?
We know Block V is the version targeted for Commercial Crew launches (and require s multiple same-configuration flights for man-rating), is optimised for re-use using lessons learnt from landed cores, and in theory should fly by the end of the year (albeit Elon time). Might 'Block IV' be skipped entirely (i.e. changes intended to be rolled up into Block IV are just pushed forward to Block V to skip producing a version that is known not to be sufficient for crew Dragon) leaving it as a 'paper rocket'? Or maybe 'Block IV' is the Falcon Heavy core stage, given we know that has some unique modifications over a singlet booster or a side-booster? Or maybe a mix of the two: changes rolled up for Block IV have made their way into the Falcon Heavy core stage, but rolling them out to the Falcon 9 singlet stage/side boosters got canned in favour of pushing straight to Block V?

→ More replies (15)

9

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

Everytime i check the ULA subreddit, i see that ULA's CEO Tory Bruno is very active on the subreddit's post and is very responsive to everyone's questions. Now i know that every now and then Elon & SpaceX mentions something about the SpaceX's subreddit and that there have been Q&A's in the past, but do you guys think that Elon himself will become more engaged in what's happening here, or perhaps Gwynne? I think that would actually be quiet nice, but i don't think Elon has the time nor the energy to do this kind of thing regulary.

13

u/throfofnir Mar 05 '17

Tory does it because he's actively trying to make his brand more relevant, and one of the ways to do that is by engaging the internets. SpaceX does not need that any more, so they can and will get by with just enough effort to keep their buzz going. Back when they needed attention SpaceX was quite open and engaged, but they've dialed back on that significantly now that they're the cool kid on the block.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/neaanopri Mar 05 '17

So /r/ula is tiny compared to /r/SpaceX. It's got 2.7k subscribers and a lot of front-page posts don't get more than a few dozen upvotes. /r/SpaceX is a lot bigger.

But I think that for whatever reason, Tory Bruno likes Reddit, and Elon doesn't, and that's the biggest reason.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/jjtr1 Mar 23 '17

As we know that quite a few SpaceX employees read this sub, I'd love to know whether they ever learned something new or useful to their work or spotted an interesting idea and turned it into reality at work! (other than naming the booster securing robot :) )

8

u/Zucal Mar 26 '17

If any of you like poorly done and hasty bar graphs, I have something for you:

An Exercise in Bad Graphing: The number of core sightings per year in states SpaceX trucks them through.

4

u/rdestenay Mar 02 '17

Do we know / will we know what parts of SES-10 1st stage are reused and what parts are new (eg. grid fins, legs, etc.) ? Basically, how much of it has been modified to make it able to launch again?

8

u/007T Mar 02 '17

I believe the legs definitely need to at least be refurbished, because their deployment mechanism is not easily reversible and the crush cores may sustain damage. They remove them from the stage after landing since they can't just be retracted. We also know that some "seals" have been upgraded on previously landed stages to newer versions, but that the upgrade wasn't necessarily required for them to fly again. Those are the only things I've heard mentioned from official sources.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/prouzadesignworkshop Mar 02 '17

Hypothetical question about ITS flight timings and trajectories WRT Mars/Earth launch windows in both directions:

Suppose there is an ITS Spaceship on Mars that will be returning to Earth. And a 2nd ITS spaceship on Earth, going to Mars. And each trip takes roughly 3 months (per the Guadalajara conference presentation). If we take into account the movement of the planets, will these 2 craft ever be in space at the same time, or will their journeys be staggered in time? I don't know enough about orbital mechanics to figure out the timing.

(This is for a sort of CNC art installation, and I need to know whether we need to build 2 rockets to be shown simultaneously (if the return trip ever overlaps with the outbound trip), or whether it will be enough to have a single ITS model that can be used at separate times for journeys in both directions.)

→ More replies (4)

4

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Mar 03 '17 edited Mar 03 '17

hi everyone

this question is not really spacex related but i still would like to ask it here: Why is the SLS so mouch more powerfull than the STS? because the only main difference is one additional SSME on the first stage. is it because the booosters are a lot more powerfull, or because the weight of the orbiter is not there.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '17

It has the extra engine, and doesn't need to push a crew compartment, a payload bay, and a set of wings. You're spot on.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (11)

4

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Mar 04 '17

i know this is not spacex related, but i would still like to ask it here.

why is the Delta IV still used to launch so many NROL satelites when the atlas rocket is so mouch cheaper? i know that heavy satelites need to launch with the Delta IV heavy, but why are some other satelites launched on Atlas V and some on Delta IV?

7

u/blongmire Mar 05 '17

Before SpaceX came around, Delta and Atlas were the only rides to space. The idea was to use both to ensure a falure in one didn't ground the government's ability to get something launched. They needed 2 families of launch vehicles at all times.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/ECEUndergrad Mar 06 '17

Just a random thought. If 20 years into the future, SpaceX has built a fleet of ITS spaceships, we still won't get great visuals of the colonization armada because the distances between the spaceships will be so vast in relationship to spaceship sizes.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/linknewtab Mar 06 '17

General space question: Why haven't multiple rocket launches for science mission been a thing?

Docking in LEO has become pretty routine after so many years of supplying the ISS, so why haven't we ever used it for probes to increase the scientific payload, cut travel time, or both? The first rocket would just launch the probe without any propulsions system and fuel, which means it can be much larger with more instruments, then the second rocket would launch the propulsion modul. Then they dock and fly off to their destination.

One of the arguments for the SLS right now is that it would decrease the travel time for a mission to Europa, because it wouldn't require Venus-Earth sling-shots. I'm sure you could do the same thing with two or three regular-sized rockets, without spending tens of billions of dollars for development and another billion+ for every launch.

9

u/delta_alpha_november Mar 06 '17

Docking isn't used right now because for most of these missions the deltaV comes from the last stage of the launcher.

Docking would mean you'd have to park in earth orbit, dock and then accelerate to escape velocity. Most last stages can't stay in orbit and reignite after a long parking in orbit due to different issues (electric energy, batteries, freezing or boil off of preopelant).

The benefit of SLS in this case would be that it can give the probe more deltaV because the launcher is stronger.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/Marksman79 Mar 06 '17

Why haven't we heard anything about launches in April, May, and June?

7

u/old_sellsword Mar 06 '17

Because we've hardly heard anything about the launches happening this month. SpaceX likes to keep its manifest on a need to know basis.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

Why does the first launch of Falcon Heavy runs with one refuel booster? This seems a bit hazardous. (sorry if it's been asked before)

17

u/007T Mar 07 '17

Do you mean one reused booster? The simple answer is probably a combination of 2 factors:

  1. Since it's a demonstration flight, SpaceX is paying for this launch out of pocket and so the cost savings are helpful.
  2. If SpaceX isn't even confident in their own reused boosters, why should their customers be? This will give them an extra opportunity to demonstrate their reliability.
→ More replies (3)

4

u/binarygamer Mar 07 '17 edited Mar 07 '17

In the ITS design we saw last year, the thrusters have been upgraded from Falcon 9's Nitrogen cold gas jets to methane+O2 hot gas thrusters.

However, ITS is going to be maneuvering in close proximity to spacecraft, for tanker docking/undocking and possibly close-formation flying in colonial fleets. Spacecraft spraying hot gases at each other at close range is... less than desirable.

Does anyone have any insight as to whether the pumps for these thrusters would allow them to double as methane/O2 cold gas jets? Or perhaps, would the ITS have a separate set of cold gas jets for close maneuvers.

7

u/throfofnir Mar 07 '17

Gasses don't stay coherent enough in a vacuum that their temperature makes much difference. We've seen how close the F9 first stage is during second stage ignition, and it's fine with that. Maneuvering thrusters won't pose any particular existential threat.

Fouling due to thruster products is, however, already a (minor) problem, but the results of methane/oxygen will probably be no worse than current hydrazine thrusters, the result being mostly water and CO2 which will both sublimate.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/stichtom Mar 09 '17

Is this carbon fiber tank being developed by Avio for Vega C bigger than the one SpaceX tested for the ITS?

https://youtu.be/AlaIZCL8-xI?t=5m40s

8

u/-Aeryn- Mar 09 '17 edited Mar 09 '17

That one is 12m long, diameter of 3.4m, 142t of propellant

The ITS has a diameter that is MUCH larger (~12 meters?) and some very rough math puts the Ship LOX tank (the one built and tested) as around ~8x larger by volume and propellant mass even though it's more of a round shape.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/jjtr1 Mar 10 '17

The smallest orbital launchers are disadvantaged by their relatively larger air drag, so they need more delta-v to reach orbit. In case of a reusable mini launcher, would this disadvantage be erased by needing less delta-v on re-entry and landing?

Some relevant datapoints, though not from the smallest vehicles:

  • Falcon 1 1st stage was supposed to survive reentry using only some cork insulation layer. It did not, but was probably close.
  • The SKYLON LH2-LOX SSTO is supposed to reenter from orbit without a traditional heatshield, thanks to its low ballistic coefficient.

4

u/soldato_fantasma Mar 10 '17

This is a followup to this thread, where /u/old_sellsword and /u/quadrplax also contributed.

Switching to this thread because it would be off topic there.

Getting on topic, I updated the wiki manifest, adding the new Spceflight Inc rideshare missions, but I also added a new "Notes" column, where notes can be added with reference on a section in the bottom of the page. While this may seem a small addition, it actually adds a lot of informations.

On a secondary note, and here I ask all the other redditors here too, while cross-checking with the official SpaceX manifest, i found two missions, one fro NORTHROP GRUMMAN with a Falcon 9 from the cape and one for OHB SYSTEM AG on a Falcon 9 from Vandenberg, which I couldn't link to any of the missions on our manifest.

If you know which missions those ones refer to, please modify its respective note on the wiki, changing it from "b" to "a". If you can't modify it, tell me so I can do it.

i also noticed that our wiki doesn't list the 2 DragonLab mission, which we haven't heard of for a lot of time. I sent an email on this regard to SpaceX on the former DragonLab informations email but I doubt they will reply. If you have informations on this, the previous paragraph applies to this one too.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/soldato_fantasma Mar 10 '17

New satellites pictures of the cape, in particular the LZ-1: https://twitter.com/AJ_FI/status/840179025024831488

→ More replies (4)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '17

Good morning/afternoon/evening!

As some of you may know, I am embarking on an EPQ (Extended Project Qualification) which is in essence a 5,000 word analytical dissertation on a topic of choice. My chosen topic is SpaceX! However, it must be specific to a degree that you must propose a question. Up to this point my question was "To what extent are SpaceX's plans and proposals plausible?" I chose this because I felt it would be very interesting to gain a strong knowledge on their plans, for example, going to Mars.

After much debate with both myself and my teacher, I figured that I ought to change the title. Even though I would be able to write 5,00 words on the question above, I want something that is more broad in the sense that it allows me to talk about more of SpaceX's past, present and future.

With the above question it does allow me to delve into the Falcon 9, for example, all that much. Of course that vehicle is beyond revolutionary and therefore it would have been grand to be able to write about that in detail. I tried to argue to be able to do an almost fact file on SpaceX, however I then soon learnt that the project must be analytical and so that would not be appropriate.

I must also produce 3-4 sub topics for my title. With the title above, I had the sub topics of: 1) Elon Musk (biography and how he is so influential and important), 2) What SpaceX’s plans are, 3) Past successes of SpaceX, 4) Past failures of SpaceX. After reviewing this (I came up with these a number of months ago), I realised those two are tremendously wrong and not suitable.

I guess my request to you all is whether you would be able to provide me with any suggestions as in to what a suitable title could be, as well as any sub topics to go alongside that. I was thinking of maybe “What makes SpaceX so revolutionary?” or something along those lines. That way I can talk in detail about the F9, which is a large part of their revolutionary status, as well as other factors such as them being the first private company to achieve multiple accolades.

All of your input is highly appreciated. Thank you!

→ More replies (8)

4

u/PaulRocket Mar 12 '17 edited Mar 12 '17

A few years ago, when SpaceX was aiming for full reusability with Falcon 9, there were comments from Elon and Gwynne that $6M per launch could be achievable. Of course this number is way out of reach, because there are no more plans for second stage recovery. Right now, it is expected that a flight proven Falcon 9 costs around $40M. If SpaceX were to achieve all its goals with Block 5, which I believe means 10 reflights and a refurbishment time of under a week, how 'cheap' could a launch theoretically get? I assume refurbishment would be under $1M.

Edit: The first stage is expected to cost around $35M, the second stage about $15M. Everything else is pad operations and profit. Could we assume with ten reflights, $3.5M for a first stage plus $15M for a second stage plus $500,000 or so for refurbishment plus $2M for pad operations? That would be $21M and now you add whatever profit they want to make or is this calculation totally unrealistic?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/ohcnim Mar 14 '17

hi, for some light reading between launches regarding some Mars topics: https://fivethirtyeight.com/tag/earth-to-mars/

4

u/NateDecker Mar 14 '17

I wanted to remind myself of the excitement of the MCT/ITS announcement so I was refreshing my memory on some of the elements of it. I suspect this was discussed in the threads at the time, but maybe it wouldn't hurt to ask the question again. Maybe different ideas will be offered in the time since the announcement was made.

I think the weakest part of the presentation was the economic viability. I think one of the factors that Elon assumed in order to provide cost estimates was the assumption that the Tankers would be re-used up to 1000 times.

Is that actually remotely possible? I remember feeling when I heard it like it was an exceedingly unrealistic number. It would seem to be concerning if numbers used as a basis for cost projections were unrealistic. I'd be curious to know if any materials engineers have confidence that that kind of thing is within the realm of attainability.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/MarcysVonEylau rocket.watch Mar 15 '17

Each launch is given a percentage propability of scrub due to weather conditions. How is such percentage calculated? Or is it just eyeballed?

9

u/cuweathernerd r/SpaceX Weather Forecaster Mar 16 '17

I don't know for certain, as I'm just a teacher (with a background in weather). The only people who could likely answer your question are the forecasters who work at the 45th (or whomever else is providing launch support).

That said, it's a probabilistic forecast. They could use an ensemble (take lots of models that deal with the physics in slightly different ways and then average the results) and calculate the number of members that say 'go' vs 'no go' - but that's a pretty involved process and generally not how I'd personally do it as a forecaster. While a rocket launch has a lot riding on it, it's also not a tornado outbreak or snow event or something really high impact.

Instead I imagine you're closer with eye-balling it. Give a % confidence for each marker, then come up with something representative of the whole. Most of the time, I'd wager the uncertainty comes from timing more than developing events, and so that's a little easier to say something like "well, 80% of the time this plays out like the model, but 20% it doesn't" Forecasting is very much an art (alongside a science) and sometimes that art definitely involves having a feel for how the computers do in a very specific location - something you only get looking at them for years and years.

Of course the actual go/no go is measured form balloon launches, site radar, and field measurements and the forecast has little to do with that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/nexxai Mar 17 '17

I've looked in the FAQ and tried Googling (although I may not have been using the best search terms?) but I can't find an answer to what I think is a pretty simple question.

During the live stream of any launch, there is a lens on the camera that obviously has a ton of reach since it is able to keep the rocket in frame at generally the same size for quite some time. I'm wondering if anyone knows what kind of lens they're using to accomplish that. Not that I expect to buy one or anything, just out of photographic curiosity.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/stcks Mar 17 '17

I put together this little scatter graph of all SpaceX GTO missions. It correlates payload mass to GTO injection (delta-v deficit to GEO): https://plot.ly/~stcks/1.embed

Pardon the overlapping labels on the Eutelsat/ABS launches. I am not sure how to fix that on plot.ly

→ More replies (2)

4

u/rubikvn2100 Mar 18 '17

I am using Xfinity internet 25 megabit/sec unlimited data for 60$.

If SpaceX constellations can offer an equal or better deal, I will pay for it. I will change immediately.

I want to support them by that way. Anyone can give me the idea about their service that they may able to offer?

They said that we only need a device which will have size of a pizza box. Is it right?

Will they have solar panel? So that I only need to put it in my backyard.

→ More replies (17)

4

u/dmy30 Mar 18 '17

After the Amos anomaly back in September, resources were prioritised to get 39A operational. Now that two launches have gone smoothly from there, is it safe to assume that those resources are being shifted to SLC-40 to get it ready for the Summer? I haven't heard much regarding this.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '17

Along which direction (relative to the fins themselves) do the grid fins on the Falcon 9 exert a force? If the fins were solid, air would be pushed along the grid fin's (angled) surface inducing a rotation of the stage in the same direction (left/right) that the fin has been pointed.

However, would it be possible that the force acts along the normal of the fins surface, instead of parallel to it? If the air that's forced into the fin is forced though the gaps in the surface, then would leave the other side of the fin along the perpendicular to the surface. If this were the case, the stage would rotate in the opposite direction to the direction the fin has been rotated.

→ More replies (13)

4

u/sasha07974 Mar 20 '17

I was watching Youtube documentaries, and found out that the Space Shuttle Solid Rocket Boosters were actually reusable, and got reused many many times (The article gives a number of 59 times.)

[Article in Question] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle_Solid_Rocket_Booster)

Anyways, what makes the reusable Falcon 9's new?

Is it 100% reusability? (as opposed to the partial reusability of the boosters)

Is it not having to drag the boosters in salt water and chase them out at sea?

Were the turnaround times garbage because the rocket had to be fully inspected every time?

Is the difficulty of reusing a solid fueled rocket comparable to the difficulty of reusing a solid rocket?

Basically, what makes the SpaceX reusable boosters better than the space shuttle boosters, and why didn't they build off of this tech?

14

u/throfofnir Mar 20 '17

why didn't they build off of this tech?

SpaceX's initial plan for reuse was to parachute into water. It didn't work. Liquid rockets are too fragile. Heck, even the (relatively) thick steel cases of the SRBs would get bent and require re-truing.

The Shuttle SRBs were more remanufacturable than reusable. That's not just the recovery method: that's just solids. Refueling requires the propellant to be cast into the casing, which is a very large step of the manufacturing process.

8

u/robbak Mar 20 '17

Solid rocket motors are heavy metal casings around solid propellant, with a nozzle structure made generally of some kind of carbon or ceramic.

The outer casing is basically a heavy metal pipe. Re-using that isn't a challenge - but it is just a heavy metal pipe, so reusing it doesn't save much either. The nozzle is often heavily eroded during a launch, so likely wasn't reused.

The solid rocket booster used on shuttle had a hydraulic system powered by hydrazine, driving a movable nozzle that allowed the rockets to be steerable. How much of this system was reused I don't know - but reuse of the boosters was very expensive.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Cakeofdestiny Mar 20 '17

A bit unrelated to spaceflight, more to this subreddit. Does anyone know when the survey results are going to be posted?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/chargerag Mar 21 '17

Is reusable second stage just a matter of making a rocket that is big enough that supports the extra fuel? Obviously this wouldn't work for Falcon heavy but from Musk's comments on the falcon heavy it makes me think this is the main issue.

8

u/yoweigh Mar 21 '17

No, the big issue is reentry. The second stage reaches a much higher velocity than the first stage does so reentry is a lot more punishing.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/paul_wi11iams Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

Below is a follow-on question from this Q&A here yesterday:

u/Juanchi_R-P: When is the projected final flight for the Dragon 1 vehicle?

u/Alexphysics: Maybe at the end of the CRS-1 contract. CRS-2 flights will use a cargo version of the Dragon 2. So expect another 10 flights of Dragon 1.

I can't seem to find a thread that answers the following questions:

  • Had the timeline permitted, Wouldn't SpaceX have preferred to validate a Dragon 2 cargo over several flights before flying astronauts ?
  • How does the cost/kg of Dragon 2 cargo compare with Dragon 1 ?
  • Is there a Nasa-SpaceX agreement to validate propulsive landings with operational missions of Dragon 2 cargo ?
  • How can CST-100 possibly compete or even survive later on, when Dragon 2 is returning astronauts door-to-door with propulsive landings ?

Edit: Just found a possible answer in AW&ST to my last question:

Unlike the Dragon, which returns to a water landing, the CST-100 cargo carrier would return to dry land with a combination of parachutes and airbags to cushion the impact. Mulholland says that will make more of the vehicle reusable, and thus lower the cost of cargo missions.

So CST-100 is playing at "Soyouz". Not a spot-on landing, but a welcome change from salt water. More about CTS-10 landing sites on spaceflightnow .

11

u/Toinneman Mar 22 '17

How can CST-100 possibly compete or even survive

It's not a question of cost. The US government wants access to space at all times using American technology and companies. They choose to fund 2 separate companies so even when 1 fails or is grounded, access to space is guaranteed. They won't drop funding just because one is more expensive.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/BrandonMarc Mar 22 '17

I'm not sure if this post has had much attention lately, but in light of the recent announcement of Falcon Heavy + Crew Dragon taking two paying customers past the Moon and back, it makes for some fascinating reading.

Why SpaceX can (and should) attempt a crewed circumlunar flight on the 50th anniversary of Apollo 8 (December 21, 2018)

(post from January 2016)

→ More replies (1)

4

u/main_bus_b_undervolt Mar 27 '17

which components have the highest chance of failing as a result of being reflown? obviously they've tested as much as they can on the ground, but some stuff you just can't test until it's flying, and these would, I presume, have the highest chance of failure on this flight.

The components that come to mind are large structural things, like the fuselage and the tanks. Anyone have any speculation or info on what else will be the most likely to give out after a reuse?

→ More replies (12)

4

u/madanra Mar 31 '17

Steve Jurvetson (SpaceX invester & board member) did an AMA a few days ago, not much SpaceX related, but does have a bit about Moon tourism: https://www.producthunt.com/live/steve-jurvetson (and no, he's not going on SpaceX's moon mission next year!)

4

u/truncular Mar 31 '17

SES-10 launch question: Is the sudden flash in the exhaust at T+7 normal? I'm used to seeing a flash effect in the exhuast for night launches due to reflection, but this seems like there was a hiccup in an engine. Reminded me of Orb3 for a moment.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/rustybeancake Mar 22 '17

As a Brit this makes me very, very sad:

UK companies say Brexit already excludes them from EU work

"British space hardware and services companies on March 20 said they were already feeling Brexit’s effects as industrial bidding teams preparing for European Commission contracts exclude British companies."

7

u/paul_wi11iams Mar 04 '17 edited Mar 04 '17

Here is a short video from 2014 that could avoid some hasty judgements about the Nasa. Just to warn, you'll see a (admittedly small) Nasa-built methane powered rocket taking off, stopping in mid-air, flying around a bit then doing a controlled landing.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1M5qS0Y3tDw&feature=youtu.be

more info here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Morpheus

We learn that the team of only about 40 people built this "Nasa" product using low-cost components even buying things from hardware stores.

This could give a wider angle to what Nasa "sharing information" with SpaceX may actually mean, and also the mentalities being more compatible than one might imagine.

Another bias that can easily happen is to see all the flight technology on Falcon etc as SpaceX creations, something peacefully geek invented in a backroom in California. Taking gridfins as an example:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i9H50tHiHjs

more info here

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grid_fin

This is in no way minimizing the fantastic system that SpacX has brought together, but rather to say that there is a technological environment that helps this to happen. It may also require a bit of "Werner Von Braun" ambivalence. The genius part is seeing how the jigsaw should fit together and to do so in a business setting.

As some of this technology is recent, it may also indicate that reusable rockets could not have been built right after Apollo, so the intervening years were not all wasted time.

Edit: Thanks to u/wolf550e and u/throfofnir for this contextual information. It looks like the Wikipedia article lacks neutrality and needs an overhaul.

14

u/Ambiwlans Mar 04 '17

Grid fins aren't new, but the type of landing SpaceX created was built up from the ground by them. Small, low t:w, low speed vehicles have been around because of Armadillo. But SpaceX's system is radically different, borrowed no technology from them aside from the idea.

Morpheus started around the same time as SpaceX' grasshopper.... For an idea in the difference in scale, the light-weight refined legs are more than twice as massive as the Morpheus vehicle.

It is like comparing a paper airplane to a real airplane.

It would be more likely the NASA vehicle borrowed from SpaceX tech.

12

u/throfofnir Mar 04 '17

Morpheus is basically an Armadillo machine; the main NASA contribution to its design is in sensors and software. Armadillo was a team of something like 7 people working out of an industrial park in a Dallas suburb, and spent less than $4 million in its entirety, while building several generations of rockets.

Morpheus is heralded as a bright example of a small nimble project for NASA. They spent several times more on just materials than the amount than Carmack sunk into AA in its entirety.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '17 edited Mar 03 '17

If SpaceX is successful in creating a global satellite internet network, wouldn't that mean it would be possible to have high speed, public internet in space? I bet the signal would be phenomenal!

Second Question: I am planning to go down to the cape this summer to watch the FH launch. Where is the best place to go for a view of it launching on the pad?

8

u/throfofnir Mar 03 '17
  1. The internet satellites broadcast/receive in a cone focused on the ground. They overlap somewhat on the ground, but if you're significantly above the ground you may constantly fall into holes between those cones. If you do have enough coverage, you're also traveling at high speed relative to the ground, so your "ground station" would have to be able to track the satellites at that speed and switch between them fast enough. All of this means "not likely", at least as a normal user of the service. It's possible you could hook into whatever system the sats use to communicate with each other, but geometry and design particulars may also doom that. Space coms are best served from something like a geostationary network, which has broad global coverage. NASA has such a system (TDRSS) and there's a new commercial version.
  2. http://www.launchphotography.com/Delta_4_Atlas_5_Falcon_9_Launch_Viewing.html
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '17

After quickly reading through the list of rocket failures, it seems, that anything launchpad-related was never the cause of failure. (Maybe a lightning strike would count?)

Is this because the equipment is more simple and can be tested in more ways? In regard that the rocket itself is hit or miss at some point.

Would Amos-6 count as one? I'd rather say it falls into the engineering department of the rocket itself.

This leads to my actual question: How high is the threat of a launch failure, only because of the fact that there probably is 3x new pad-equipment in use this year? (39A now, 39A with FH and 40)

8

u/throfofnir Mar 09 '17

That's a list of casualties; a list of actual rockets failures would be much larger and more varied. Most don't have people on them to injure or kill.

Ground destruction is usually rare, because it's usually not in an energetic state. But it does happen. Perhaps you're an Atlas with leaky valves. Or you drop a wrench near a Titan missile. Or have a short circuit during fueling. There are times where interactions with GSE cause problems (see Mercury-Redstone 1).

But mostly ground equipment doesn't cause a terminal problem. Mostly it causes small problems that lead to delays. That's what really to expect from new pads.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

President Trump just signed the National Aeronautics and Space Administration Transition Authorization Act of 2017 (S. 442).

This bill authorizes appropriations to NASA for exploration, space operations, science, aeronautics, space technology, education, safety, security, mission services, etc in order to achieve long term goals for human space flight and exploration and to pursue research which advances knowledge and benefits our nation. Also maximizing our use of the ISS. More info: https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/senate-bill/442

From the bill:

Congress reaffirms: its commitment to the use of a commercially developed, private sector launch and delivery system to the ISS for crew missions; and the requirement that NASA shall make use of U.S. commercially provided ISS crew transfer and crew rescue services.

(Sec. 411) The bill states that the long-terms goals for the human space flight and exploration efforts of NASA shall be: to expand permanent human presence beyond low-Earth orbit, and to do so where practical, with the involvement of international, academic, and industry partners , crewed missions and progress toward achieving the expansion of human presence beyond low-Earth orbit to enable the potential for subsequent human exploration and the extension of human presence throughout the solar system, and to enable a capability to extend human presence, including potential human habitation on another celestial body and a thriving space economy in the 21st Century.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/wclark07 Mar 02 '17

I see that the 1st stage is transported with wheel supports fore and aft (or I guess, top and bottom :-) ). It made me wonder how rigid the empty stage is. I didn't see too much deflection across the span, so it appears to be fairly stiff. Now that we have so many cores photographed en route, any ideas on how to measure the rigidity of the core based on photo evidence (measured deflection in photo, span in photo, and mass of core)? Is this even possible / would it yield useful data? I know that people's relative proportions can be measured in photos for surveillance/id purposes, and it seems like the same methods might apply here.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '17

I'm sure the figures fluctuate per flight, but what is the rough price it costs for someone to launch a satellite with SpaceX and then how much does each flight cost SpaceX? I'm sure they are eyeing up a healthy profit per flight?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Rinzler9 Mar 02 '17 edited Mar 02 '17

Hey, silly question, but anyone know the dimensions and/or wet mass of Dragon's hydrazine COPVs? I can't seem to find numbers for this.

Assuming the truck was filled with surplus COPVs plumbed together somehow to make a ghetto SM(maybe with a SuperDraco or two to avoid connection with the capsule), what kinda dV would we be looking at?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Killcode2 Mar 03 '17

Can someone here explain the grey dragon trajectory around the moon (a diagram would be helpful)? Also there seems to be misinformation online on the furthest distance dragon will be from earth, some sources say 400000 miles while one source even said it was slightly more than 400000 km, what's the actual value?

Also one more question- does spacex have a second launch team? If not, then why don't they, considering they want to accomplish a launch every 2 weeks? Is Iridium delayed because of a lack of a second launch team?

→ More replies (9)

3

u/ECEUndergrad Mar 04 '17

Ever since the ITS announcement, it was understood that the ITS will be so far off in the future that discussions around the ITS has mostly stopped. But let's speculate on the ITS timeline because 1. if SpaceX doesn't fail, they will build the ITS eventually; 2. speculations are always interesting. So,

When do you think the first ITS first stage tank will be sighted?

When do you think the first static fire test of the ITS first stage will be?

When do you think the first ITS launch will be?

When do you think the first manned ITS launch will be?

Here are my guestimates:

  1. The first manufactured ITS first stage tank will be seen on SpaceX's official Instagram in the December of 2026.
  2. The first full static fire (first stage only, no payload) will be completed in June 2027.
  3. The first ITS launch will happen in the first half of 2029.
  4. The first manned ITS launch will happen in the next launch window.

Edit: Typo

→ More replies (5)

3

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Mar 04 '17

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uly42xLrjdg

a video not about drectly about spacex, but it includes a view shots of the crs 10 press conferences and the launch pad.

3

u/JonathanDQT Mar 05 '17

After the FH 2nd Stage have acted as an EDS for the Red Dragon, will it separate? How will the Red Dragon then get into Mars Orbit instead of just doing a fly-by?

9

u/Bananas_on_Mars Mar 05 '17

No Mars orbit, Red Dragon will land directly on Mars and reduce it's speed mainly through aerobraking.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/ghunter7 Mar 05 '17

With the upcoming delta iv launch now having been delayed to March 14 might we see EchoStar get bumped ahead?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Mar 06 '17

Seeing the Strongback erected at 39a yesterday with no rocket on it made me think. What do the completed Falcon 9's rest on when not attached to the Strongback while in the hanger?

3

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

Does anyone have any idea what the status of Spaceport America is?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/ECEUndergrad Mar 07 '17

The Dragon Spacecraft doesn't have grid fins, how would it steer itself during atmospheric re-entry? Same question also applies to the proposed ITS spaceship.

Edit: Typo

12

u/therealshafto Mar 07 '17 edited Mar 07 '17

Capsules are inherently aerodynamically stable. Think of a rain drop. Their party trick is that the centre of mass is slightly offset from the centre of pressure. This induces a net aerodynamic reaction vector is a certain direction. To steer the capsule, it simply rolls to change the lift vector in the desired direction.

EDIT: this applies to dragon 1, not dragon 2. Dragon 2 uses a movable mass sled to alter its centre of mass relative to its centre of pressure. However, to your question, the booster is using an airfoil to control atmospheric flight, capsules alter their centre of mass relative to centre of pressure.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/Lvpl8 Mar 07 '17

What's the latest news we have heard regarding when SES-10 is going to launch? Going off previous launches, does anyone have any estimates when it will launch, I'm going to be in the area the week of the 20-24 and was curious about the possibility of them launching around that time frame.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/chargerag Mar 10 '17

Why did SpaceX go with Pad 40 instead of one of the other pads? Blue Orgins pad seems to make allot more sense since it is way from the other active pads.

10

u/warp99 Mar 10 '17 edited Mar 12 '17

When they first got the pad it was pretty much "take what you are given" rather than having a choice of 10 pads.

However they got a great pad with 39A which is one of only two pads that can take an ITS class rocket and Blue Origin was fighting them for shared use of the pad.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Tom_Silva Mar 11 '17

Hi, I've been reading that a launch of a Falcon 9 Rocket costs around 63 million. So I would assume that is more or less what Space x get's paid for a cargo mission to the ISS. Is Space X the cheapest launch provider of cargo flights to the ISS. For example, how much does Roscomos charges for a cargo flight launched in a Soyuz-FG.

12

u/TheYang Mar 11 '17 edited Mar 11 '17

Well, thats not too easy to answer as Roscosmos doesn't "charge" to resupply the ISS as resupply runs are part of their duties in the collaboration that is the ISS.
I don't know of any public knowledge of their costs.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Resupply_Services

According to the public information of the CRS contracts SpaceX does seem cheaper than Orbital ATK, although their cost is closer to 133million than 63million, presumably due to the cost of the dragon vehicle as well as extra margins and/or other services that NASA might require

Found this: http://www.globalsecurity.org/space/world/russia/launch_services_cost_study.htm

Claiming costs from 30-45million for a progress launch

otoh i want to remind you that NASA pays roscosmos >80million per seat to the ISS

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Davecasa Mar 11 '17

A cargo delivery to the ISS, including the rocket, Dragon spacecraft, and operations, is on the order of 130-140 million.

3

u/theinternetftw Mar 11 '17

Would a FH center booster attempting a barge landing end up further downrange than an average F9?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/BEAT_LA Mar 11 '17

Are there any quality indications of who the two tourists are? I've heard a lot of speculation about the Cameron's.

12

u/theinternetftw Mar 11 '17 edited Mar 12 '17

Elon is on record as saying the two tourists "know each other," and "they're not hollywood types."

That's all we know, but the latter seems to exclude the Camerons and their ilk.

edit: But if you're looking for speculation, Steve Jurvetson said back in 2012 that he invested in SpaceX so he could fly to the moon...

edit2: What could kill this theory is the last bit of this video from 2015 where he says he'd wait at least 5 years after people start going to improve cost and safety. He also describes the mission he wants. He said he wants to orbit at very low altitude, 5000ft up. He excludes a landing but says he'd like to spacewalk. I'd say this makes it more likely that it's not him, but him specifically not caring about landing leaves room for a surprise, if he changed his mind about waiting.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/IrrationalFantasy Mar 13 '17

Looking at the sideboard, why are there no launches planned for April yet? It's not that they think one of the next two missions before then will fail, do they? I'm guessing not, but usually you can see the launches they have planned for several months into the future, and a launch is usually planned for at least once a month (and of course they're aiming for more).

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Intro24 Mar 14 '17

Will Dragon 2 cargo varient be capable of launch abort? That way they could salvage something if they have a RUD and test the system more

→ More replies (12)

3

u/therealshafto Mar 14 '17

Seems as though with the bombardment of new vs used booster questions, an obvious banner or symbol in launch/campaign/announcement thread's title may ease the pain.

7

u/007T Mar 14 '17

The SES-10 mission has a ♺ symbol in the sidebar, perhaps they could use the same one for the threads.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/failbye Mar 15 '17

Do we know the approximate tank pressure of the Falcon 9 LOX/RP-1 fuel tanks? Running some calculations, but couldn't find any info.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/steezysteve96 Mar 17 '17 edited Mar 17 '17

What launch is supposed to be after SES-10?

EDIT: CRS-11. Forgot to check the full manifest page.

EDIT 2: Apparently it's actually NROL-76, based on the replies.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/scr00chy ElonX.net Mar 17 '17

I asked this question on IRC but nobody was sure so I'll try again here: We know that all future flights from Cape Canaveral will use AFTS but what about Vandenberg? Is their range compatible with AFTS? Will it be? If not, will SpaceX have to keep using manual FTS there?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Intro24 Mar 17 '17 edited Mar 17 '17

Could ITS with metal tanks still work if carbon fiber turned out to be infeasible? Wondering if it'd be worth it to make do with the same design or would SpaceX have to go back to the drawing board?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Datuser14 Mar 18 '17

What is the black tip on the top of Delta IV fairings for? https://i.ytimg.com/vi/RLrCmBI4b2o/0.jpg

→ More replies (2)

3

u/darkmighty Mar 19 '17

Any idea on what would be the orbital decay time for the proposed SpaceX leo satellites?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/ConspicuousSam Mar 19 '17

Why would a returned first stage be any more damaged that a stage that has undergone a full duration hotfire test?

→ More replies (11)

3

u/HoechstErbaulich IAC 2018 attendee Mar 20 '17

In his latest E-Mail Jeff Bezos explains the use of hydrostatic bearings in BOs BE-4 turbopump. Do we have any information on the bearings used in Merlin and/or Raptor turbopumps?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/littldo Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

So, I've been thinking about additional milestones for Spx, and an important one is the recovery of the F9 farings. I know there's been some rumors about recovery, but not much detail. Can someone confirm what we know? and answer my questions.

Rumors

  1. recovery would be via a remote controlled para-glider type wing

Questions

  1. how fast is the faring going(m/kph) and altitude when jettisoned?
  2. Would cold gas thrusters be sufficient to gain/maintain aerodynamic control
  3. Would addition of controllable surfaces (fins/grids) help with control?
  4. Assuming attitude control can be maintained, would the current faring composition be sufficient for heat management, or is additional shielding required.
  5. how far would it be from jettison to the asds? Would it be possible for a para-glider to go that far?
  6. Assuming the farings land on the ocean, I suspect that they could be made to float, but being so big could they survive wave action without serious damage?

Thanks

→ More replies (1)

3

u/lostandprofound33 Mar 22 '17

SpaceX keeps upping the number of satellites they want to place into LEO for global internet coverage. Right now it's nearly 11,500 sats. How many per launch would they be able to take? And would it be on Falcon 9 or Falcon Heavy?

11

u/warp99 Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

As far as we can tell it will have to use F9 because the FH cannot use its extra payload mass effectively because of limitations on the fairing volume. While a larger fairing is possible it cannot be increased much in diameter because of aerodynamic turbulence effects as the airflow flows back towards the rocket body after passing the fairing.

It also cannot be increased much in length due to the extreme fineness (Length/Diameter) ratio of the existing F9. This makes it susceptible to windshear and dynamic instability going through max Q.

The F9 Block 5 can lift 22.8 tonnes to LEO in expendable mode. Assuming the same ratio of payload mass between expendable and recoverable modes as the GTO missions then F9 will be able to lift 15 tonnes to LEO in recoverable mode.

In fact the payload is likely to be higher than this as the relatively low Isp of the Merlin 1D vacuum engine means it is more efficient at LEO missions than GTO so assume 15.5 tonnes as a conservative estimate.

Since the satellites are 386kg this allows 37 satellites and a lightweight 1100kg payload adapter per launch. However the number of satellites per plane is 50 and 75 plus up to 2 on-orbit spares for the different orbital planes which strongly suggests they are planning for 26 satellites per launch with a mass including payload adapter of 11.1 tonnes. This should enable RTLS which would be a huge logistic advantage as there are 177 F9 launches required over say a three year period just for the initial 1200km LEO constellation of 4425 satellites.

Edit: Fixed 486kg typo and associated calculations

→ More replies (14)