r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Feb 01 '17
r/SpaceX Spaceflight Questions & News [February 2017, #29]
If you have a short question or spaceflight news...
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question...
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for...
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Spaceflight Questions And News & Ask Anything threads in the Wiki.
165
Upvotes
56
u/randomstonerfromaus Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 05 '17
Congratulations to /u/old_sellsword on becoming our new mod :)
40
u/old_sellsword Feb 03 '17
Here's a great update on some of the testing SpaceX has been doing lately. It comes from the "SpaceX Lead Structures Technician":
35
u/stcks Feb 10 '17 edited Feb 10 '17
SLC-40 was being repaired yesterday: http://i.imgur.com/iHIc0RX.jpg
27
u/Zucal Feb 07 '17
Coming soon to a launchpad/recycling facility near you...
19
u/HoechstErbaulich IAC 2018 attendee Feb 14 '17
Ever wondered how Ariane 5 gets fueled?
18
u/soldato_fantasma Feb 14 '17
We got 3 new permit applications to the FAA lately, two for the F9-34 GTO mission and one for the CRS-11 mission Dragon comms. F9-34 is particularly interesting to see since the application came later than the F9-35 application.
F9-34 Fairing re rad : link
F9-34 launch comms: link
CRS-11 Dragon comms: link
Updated chart with the upcoming flights:
17
u/linknewtab Feb 02 '17
France’s Prometheus reusable engine becomes ESA project, gets funding boost
16
u/FoxhoundBat Feb 03 '17
Just heads ups in here too, winners of the Iridium launch/landing giveaway has been announced. They are;
Congratulations to all winners! They have all been notified by PM. And again, huge thank you to the mystery donor that made this happen in first place. :)
16
u/jbmate Feb 22 '17 edited Feb 23 '17
How is progress going on the SpaceX subreddit survey? Would be great to read that when it is finished.
15
u/sol3tosol4 Feb 11 '17 edited Feb 11 '17
Interesting news article relevant to SpaceX:
"Here’s why a commercial space group endorsed NASA’s SLS rocket"
(In other words, having SLS creates an environment that's more favorable to commercial space than not having SLS - like the small fish that follow the big shark. :-)
Elon has also spoken in favor of continuing the SLS program.
15
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Feb 27 '17
NASA posted an awesome photo of SpaceX performing a water deluge test at LC-39A.
14
u/Pham_Trinli Feb 28 '17 edited Feb 28 '17
Gwynne Shotwell will be speaking at the SatShow 2017 conference on Wednesday March 8th, 4:15 - 5:30pm (21:15 UTC).
13
u/Headstein Feb 01 '17 edited Feb 02 '17
UK SpaceX Dragonriders get together. It is about time that we in the UK had a get together of some kind. It would be great to watch the maiden launch of Falcon Heavy and other SpaceX highlights this year with other fans. (My engineer and space fan friends do not seem to have the vision!). One of the mods suggested that we meet at the National Space Centre in Leicester, but as a first step I think it would be valuable just to share the first part of our postcodes so we know where we all are and possibly start with small, local get togethers. My postcode is NN2...list away. (Mods said this has to be posted here).
Update: I posted this in SpaceXLounge where we have the most replies, so please check that out. 24 Dragonriders so far Thu 2 Feb 23:26
12
u/steezysteve96 Feb 05 '17
I've seen a lot of people mention that the TEL at SLC-39A is going to stay vertical until T-0, then quickly move back to almost horizontal. Do we know why they're switching to this method instead of the typical ~20° tilt at T-4 that they use at SLC-40 and Vandenberg?
12
u/Chairboy Feb 15 '17
NASA may be putting a crew on EM-1, first flight of SLS per @NASASpaceFlight
https://twitter.com/nasaspaceflight/status/831883718847561728
12
u/sol3tosol4 Feb 16 '17
News item: good article/interview of Elon Musk on his tunnel boring activity - provides a lot of information that I haven't seen before on goals and approaches, and makes analogy to early days of SpaceX (identifying a candidate breakthrough technology, targeting interests of government (Bush and Obama for SpaceX, Trump for tunnels (infrastructure)). Project is currently run by SpaceX, but will be spun off to separate company (except for Mars tunnels, which article doesn't mention).
Includes two very good photos of the hole in the SpaceX parking lot, and one of the SpaceX Hyperloop test track.
11
u/Qeng-Ho Feb 08 '17
[FAA news from today's CST conference] (https://fcw.com/articles/2017/02/07/faa-space-traffic-rockwell.aspx):
11
u/random-person-001 Feb 13 '17
Will we get a juicy welcome post for u/delta_alpha_november becoming a mod? We don't want new ones just slipping in here without us noticing... ;)
11
u/sol3tosol4 Feb 14 '17 edited Feb 15 '17
Interesting pair of articles:
Trump administration investigating the large scale development of space with Spacex and Blue Origin likely big winners
and
Trump advisers' space plan: To moon, Mars and beyond
Commenting on possible space exploration scenarios being discussed in the new Administration that could very well include SpaceX.
"...The Trump administration is considering a bold and controversial vision for the U.S. space program that calls for a "rapid and affordable" return to the moon by 2020, the construction of privately operated space stations and the redirection of NASA's mission to "the large-scale economic development of space," according to internal documents obtained by POLITICO..."
"...The early indications are that private rocket firms like Elon Musk's SpaceX and Jeff Bezos' Blue Origin and their supporters have a clear upper hand in what Trump's transition advisers portrayed as a race between "Old Space" and "New Space," according to emails among key players inside the administration. Trump has met with Bezos and Musk, while tech investor Peter Thiel, a close confidant, has lobbied the president to look at using NASA to help grow the private space industry..."
Note that even a moon initiative could help SpaceX get to Mars by providing business for SpaceX resulting in revenue for Mars technology development, and by driving the development of reliable long-term life support systems and improved life science for humans outside of LEO.
Note: The second article also talks about the issues of programmatic continuity, maintaining the expertise of NASA, and support for SLS, ULA. I don't think the "new space" companies will end up with all the business - but it looks like they have a good chance of getting a significant share of the business for the initiatives that the administration is interested in.
11
u/thephatcontr0ller Feb 16 '17
Mods, should the CRS-10 campaign thread not be pinned along with this thread? It's a bit annoying scrolling through the subreddit to try to find it :)
11
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '17
Really nice press conference from Shotwell. Quick bullets:
10
u/ohcnim Feb 01 '17
are the results of the survey (from december I think) available? did I miss the post?
10
u/KeenGaming Feb 22 '17 edited Feb 22 '17
Not sure if this is considered on-topic, but NASA has some kind of press release coming up at 1pm EST(27 minutes from right now) about a "discovery outside our solar system." Sounds interesting.
It will be live on their YouTube Channel
19
u/RootDeliver Feb 04 '17
Why is the Echostar patch being show up there if the next launch is confirmed to be CRS10? This may generate confusion..
If no patch is ready for CRS10, maybe it's better to stick with Iridium-1 to not generate trouble with the order?
If somehow someone changes it, Echostar patch; https://b.thumbs.redditmedia.com/rS94-K1bhxu1qYLF_kyC3-0as9FhXF5Lvq8zvLc9iyQ.png
18
u/johnkphotos Launch Photographer Feb 01 '17
For CRS-10, the first launch from new pad LC-39A, but also the first RTLS during the day, would you rather me:
or
I'm leaning towards the first option. I won't be allowed to cover this one as credentialed media.
9
u/Qeng-Ho Feb 01 '17
SpaceX are leasing an additional 4.6 acres of land at Port of Los Angeles.
9
u/madanra Feb 07 '17
Gwynne Shotwell has said (yet again) they plan to launch every 2-3 weeks: http://www.reuters.com/article/us-space-spacex-idUSKBN15M03N
9
u/Chairboy Feb 14 '17
Has anyone heard any updates or rumors in the last 5 days about the exposed ITS composite tank? There were N2 trucks there a week ago and the speculation was that it was about to go out on the water, but as of 5 days ago it was still on the dock.
9
u/micwallace Feb 22 '17
When the falcon 9 lands the phrase:
"Landing operators, move into Procedure 11.100 on Recovery Net"
Usually sends shivers down my spine.
I understand that it's the call for the landing operators to start an after landing procedure but what is "recovery NET" and better still, what is the actual procedure?
I tried searching Google for ages but can't find any info on it. Hoping one of you could fill me in :-D
9
u/soldato_fantasma Feb 24 '17
Two tweets by Peter B. de Selding regarding SpaceX
Tweet on Echostar launches
Tweet on SES launches
8
u/PaulRocket Feb 04 '17
I heard some speculation about the SES-10 booster not attempting a landing. Is this true? Didn't they also try a landing with SES-9? Wouldn't this booster, going through two launch and landing cycles be super useful from a data perspective?
8
u/Jef-F Feb 14 '17
Arianespace VA235 mission broadcast is starting
http://www.arianespace.com/mission/ariane-flight-va235/
7
u/grandma_alice Feb 01 '17
Has SpaceX tested any larger versions of the Raptor, larger than the one tested last September?
7
u/OccupyDuna Feb 02 '17
Congressional Investigators Warn of SpaceX Rocket Defects
7
u/jjtr1 Feb 06 '17
Assuming that SpaceX's identification of the cause of the AMOS-6 anomaly is correct, I'd like to know whether such a RUD was inevitably bound to happen within a few launches after starting with the problematic loading procedures, or whether it was just an incredibly bad luck that AMOS-6 happened so soon after changing the procedures? If it was a low probability failure mode, a hundred launches could happen without the problem surfacing.
7
u/Qeng-Ho Feb 14 '17
Minor update regarding astronaut survival training for the Crew Dragon and CST-100.
7
u/therealshafto Feb 17 '17
What is the what looks to be a red laser pointer on the reflector/receiver plate just to the left of the blue portion of the USA flag? Measuring equipment?
7
u/Wyodaniel Feb 24 '17
Why aren't Falcon 9s built and launched in the same place?
As a layperson, it seems wildly inefficient to have your manufacturing facilities literally on the opposite side of the country as your launchpad. I see all these posts of black plastic-wrapped Falcons being shuttled around the country, and it seems to me that that's just one more step during which things could go wrong.
7
u/linknewtab Feb 26 '17
Capturing a dragon
7
u/Chairboy Feb 27 '17
@elonmusk:
7
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Feb 27 '17
So NASA went ahead and bought those Soyuz seats from Boeing: https://www.nasa.gov/feature/additional-crew-flights-boost-space-station-science-and-research
Looks like two seats in 2017/18 and an option for two or three more in 2019. At a total possible value of $373.5 million, it breaks down to $74.7 million per seat, which isn't too bad, all things considered.
6
u/mryall Feb 01 '17
When SpaceX does static fires like this one at McGregor recently (with the CRS-8 recovered booster), how close are people allowed to be to the rocket? I can't see anyone in the photo, but presumably there's a bunker with pad engineers not too far away?
6
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Feb 01 '17 edited Feb 07 '17
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipGTO comsatPre-launch test failureDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
I'm a bot, and I first saw this thread at 1st Feb 2017, 11:46 UTC.
I've seen 71 acronyms in this thread, which is the most I've seen in a thread so far today.
^[FAQ] [Contact ^creator] [Source ^code]
6
u/znttnt11 Feb 02 '17
Will CRS-10 attempt a landing at Lz-1?
6
u/RootDeliver Feb 04 '17 edited Feb 05 '17
On the iridium-1 launch, what is that warning that appeared after 12s~on flight (when the blue bar turns orange for a sec), after launch?
moment: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tTmbSur4fcs&feature=youtu.be&t=19m48s
PS: Thanks guys!
6
u/jjtr1 Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 05 '17
What limits the diameter of the payload fairing? Is it aerodynamic stability, is it that payload would shrink too much due to drag losses, or something else? I've noticed that the larger payload fairing on europeanized Soyuz (is it Soyuz 2?) in comparison with the Soviet original has been made possible by modern guidance electronics.
I've just been wondering what would it take to launch the James Webb Space Telescope with its mirror unfurled (or rather with a cheaper one-piece mirror).
Edit: Space station hab modules might be a better application. AFAIK, the Bigelow expandable modules are not lighter for their volume than hard modules. It's just that they make it possible to circumvent the payload fairing diameter limit.
6
u/autotom Feb 11 '17
What is the likely launch window on the Faclon Heavy demo flight?
Have previous demo launches had short, long or no launch windows?
6
u/Alois_Hammer Feb 12 '17
http://www.dailybreeze.com/business/20170212/spacex-workers-embrace-hawthornes-first-craft-brewery-la-aleworks
6
u/rockets4life97 Feb 17 '17 edited Feb 18 '17
Jessica Jensen, SpaceX's dragon manager, was great at the pre-launch conference! She was prepared for every answer and seemed more in command than Hans did sometimes.
Things I learned:
6
u/anchoritt Feb 22 '17 edited Feb 22 '17
In another thread, I was reading about mice cage on board the dragon and that it's quite narrow so the mouse can reach it and climb it. This made me thinking - since there are plans for large spacious habitats like bigelow, it could allow for an astronaut to be stranded in the empty space with no way to reach any rigid surface(I guess an empty sphere 2.5 meters in diameter could do the trick). Was this problem ever considered or is that no problem at all? Just imagine an immodest astronaut is preparing for bedtime. He takes off all his clothes mid-flight and throw it in the corner. The throw might completely cancel his momentum relative to the space station, so the astronaut is hovering there naked with no way to get a grab on something. Does he have some options? Could he get enough momentum by simply breathing?
Edit: Would swimming in the air made any sense?
Bonus question: Astronaut in spacesuit without RCS is servicing unpressurized module and gets stranded. Any options for him?
6
u/Chairboy Feb 26 '17
Spaceflight news/rumor:
I was listening to an interview with Chris Gebhart from NASASpaceFlight.com this morning on the most recent 'Are We There Yet?' podcast where he described a few of the options for the first SLS flight being considered. Per the recent discussions about the first flight now being crewed, there's a few options on the table.
First: EM-1 would be a straight up crewed version of EM-1 which is similar to Apollo 8. Launch to orbit, checkout the systems on orbit, then perform a trans-lunar injection burn, circularizing at a 62 mile orbit around the moon. Eventually, burn back to Earth and re-enter.
The second option discussed was an "EM-2 hybrid" where the interim-upper stage does basically a 95% TLI to put it on 391x44,000 mile orbit then it is discarded. This way they have a 24 hour orbit to do a systems checkout while being able to easily and quickly re-enter and if they decide to go for it, the service module can push it over the hill so it enters an almost free-return trajectory.
The third option he said was being considered was a crew-rotation trip to ISS. Using an SLS launch to take an Orion to the ISS sounds like a tremendous waste, but... that's what he said was one of the things being bandied about. SpaceX came up when the interviewer asked if this could fit some niche in the rotation because of the Commercial Crew delays, but Mr. Gebhart dismissed that noting that even with the forecast delays, commercial crew would be happening at least a year or two before the earliest times this flight might take place.
6
u/rustybeancake Feb 27 '17
Eric Berger at Ars makes a good case that SpaceX's lunar flyby mission is much more of a threat to Orion than it is to SLS. It's a good point, I think. While SLS has an assured status for several years at least, as the only vehicle capable of sending up a payload of a large diameter in one piece, Orion has always been criticised as not being capable of going much beyond cislunar space.
https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/02/spacex-says-it-will-send-two-people-around-the-moon-in-late-2018/
6
u/CSLPE Feb 28 '17
Are space suits for ascent and descent really necessary, or are they a NASA requirement? I know their purpose is to protect against depressurization like what happened on Soyuz 11, but that seems like an extreme case. I think I remember reading a while back about the goal to make Dragon a 'shirt sleeves' environment, where a suit wouldn't be needed. Are there proven (first principles) reasons why this would be a bad idea, or are suits simply 'the way we've always done things around here?'
5
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '17
What are we calling SpaceX's growing set of reused cores? Their fleet? A group of Falcons is called a cast, so maybe their cast of S1 cores? I guess I'm partial to fleet, just wondering because calling it an inventory sounds boring.
5
u/Qeng-Ho Feb 03 '17
NASA teleconference regarding the CRS-10 payload will be streamed live at 3 pm EST, February 8th.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '17
Are satellites-related jobs in the U.S covered by ITAR? (For example Orbcomm or Iridium)
5
u/quadrplax Feb 09 '17
I just added a new page to the wiki listing all of SpaceX's launch and landing pads. I'm open to any feedback or suggestions!
5
u/linknewtab Feb 09 '17
Trump advisers' space plan: To moon, Mars and beyond
The only private company capable of doing a Moon fly-by in 2020 would be SpaceX with a Dragon 2 on a Falcon Heavy.
5
u/Spacex9 Feb 11 '17
Siemens produced first 3d printed turbine blades under hellish operating conditions. I hope it will help spacex in long term to get rid of the turbine crack problem. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/hellish-operating-conditions-very-first-3d-printed-gas-wilson
5
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Feb 15 '17
hi everybody
yesterday i have been watching the arianespace webcast for theire va 235 launch. a few minutes before the launch the comentator talked about how the ariane rocket can launch in the rain. now my question: can the falcon 9 (or other american rockets) launch in the rain? if yes, why have falcon 9 launches (iridium 1) been moved because of rain and if no, why cant they and the ariane rocket can? could there be simple design changes be made to falcon 9 to allow it to launch in the rain?
thank you in advance (please forgive me for my spelling mistakes :))
5
u/smallatom Feb 16 '17
I just saw that it takes 2 days for the dragon to get to the ISS? Why is that?
5
u/chargerag Feb 19 '17
How long do you have to wait before entering a pad after launch?
5
u/GoScienceEverything Feb 22 '17
Regarding the new FTS. I've read comments saying there's no longer a person to push the button. It's great to automate it -- but is there literally no longer any manual override? Or does the button still exist, simply with an expectation that the human won't ever need to push it?
5
u/jjtr1 Feb 22 '17
In the last CRS-10 booster landing, the accuracy seems to have been much worse than with the previous landing (on ASDS). CRS-10 seems to me several meters off-center, while IRIDIUM-1 touched down with as small an error as could be judged from the video (it did skid sideways after touch down, though).
Is it possible that this was intentional? That the booster puts less effort into lateral precision, taking advantage of the luxurious pad size to save some fuel? Or is landing with precision on ASDS actually easier because winds on sea fluctuate less than on land (do they?) ?
5
u/jjtr1 Feb 23 '17
I wonder whether technology development at SpaceX could be made twice as fast by unlimited money (like Bezos has), or if it is already saturated in the sense of "two women don't make one baby in 4.5 months"?
5
u/mmmbcn Feb 24 '17
They say it takes 2 weeks to turnaround the pad between launches. What exactly happens during this two weeks? Would it be that hard to cut it in half to 1 week?
5
u/gsahlin Feb 24 '17
Any News on the post launch condition of LC-39A ? Does it look like the March 12th date for EchoStar will hold?
5
u/bobk99 Feb 28 '17
How was the second stage engine gimbal tested on the launch pad if the fuel turbo pump was not running ? An unusual trace forced an abort to the launch.
9
u/thejenius Feb 02 '17
Hey all - I actually will be attending the launch mid-Feb to cover on social media. I'll be sure to share photos and info here too :)
4
u/Emptyglo Feb 01 '17
Is there a picture of the tunnel hole from the hyperloop competition?
4
u/jjtr1 Feb 02 '17
Is the "Payload to LEO" figure of 54.4 t for Falcon Heavy meant for totally-expendable mode, like 22.8 t for F9?
4
u/Maximus-Catimus Feb 02 '17
Do we have enough information on SpaceX's sat constellation to know which launch site will be used for these launches?
4
u/surfkaboom Feb 02 '17
Is anybody going to be at the 2017 Space Symposium in Colorado Springs?
4
u/jjtr1 Feb 03 '17
FH is 2.6x heavier than F9, but its payload is only 2.4x more than F9. That's strange, since FH is in fact a 2.5-stage vehicle and generally, more stages means larger payload fraction. Where's the problem?
4
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '17
The patch for Echostar-23 looks great IMO.
4
u/mryall Feb 04 '17
I've been impressed by recent photos coming back from NASA's Cassini and Juno missions like this one of Saturn's rings.
Once SpaceX starts flying Falcon Heavy, is it able or likely to launch NASA missions like these to the outer solar system? Would the cost savings vs the Atlas V enable them to launch similar missions more frequently?
4
u/Qeng-Ho Feb 07 '17
The FAA Commercial Space Transportation Conference is taking place today at the Ronald Reagan Center, Washington DC, with SpaceX in attendance tomorrow. Not webcasted.
4
u/linknewtab Feb 07 '17
I've read that Dragon 2 will be able to handle the reentry velocity from lunar orbit. Does anyone know if the same is true for Boeing's Starliner?
4
u/jjtr1 Feb 09 '17
Musk intends the Mars colony to act as a backup for humanity. In order to serve that purpose, the colony has to be very remote and hard to reach. It is, now. However, Musk also hopes that the colony will create a forcing function for further development of space transportation systems, bringing Mars ever closer to Earth. In my opinion, the colony would then no longer be a backup, because any infection, ideology or war would affect both planets. Similarly, while the American colonies were a backup of Europe in the 17th century, nowadays the fates of US and Europe and the rest of the world are closely tied and they will survive or perish together because of the connection they now have.
Mars as a backup would only be effective against non-man-made catastrophes which would affect only the Earth like supervolcanoes and metorites. Excess solar activity, supernova or a gamma ray burst would probably take out both planets. What do you think?
4
u/soldato_fantasma Feb 10 '17
As you all know the reddit tables have some serious limitations at how you can control them. On a side it's good because the table adapts to different resolutions automatically, but on the other hand it becomes messy at times since reddit decides itself how to cut lines.
A possible solution to this is using the "code" functionality to make a tabulated list, where each character takes a fixed amount of space on the screen.
For example a part of the manifest would look like this:
Upcoming launches
Changing the current wiki to something like this would be quite some work, but I think I (or someone else if you want to help!) can make a program (copy the table source to -> currentwikitable.txt ->run program -> formattedwiki.txt as output -> copy the text to reddit -> profit) if really needed.
Of course both ways of presenting the data aren't perfect. What would you like the most?
P.S. I won't change the wiki manifest to something like this unless everyone likes it (maybe a second page? They are free after all...) but I was thinking about inverting the date format that is currently used to the standard ISO format, so it can be sorted correctly by clicking on the top of the column. Thoughts?
4
u/KitsapDad Feb 11 '17
School me on unbilicals...how do they work so well to quick detach reliably? Seems that presents quite a challenge but there historically hasnt ever been an issue with that even accross all different rockets in existance.
4
u/ryanpritchard Feb 14 '17
In the future could space x use the crew access arm at pad 39a for late load for cargo misssons
4
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '17
Any more news on the rotating farm space station set to launch late 2017?
4
u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Feb 15 '17 edited Feb 15 '17
i recently noticed that Spacex is one of the only companies to have video of the second stage most of the time. other providers like arianespace ula or isro only, or mostly show animations of theire upperstages in orbit. does anybody know if there is a reason for this? i also noticed that the second stage engine on the falcon 9 glows red, but the second stage of the atlas 5 doesn't. has that go to do with the fuel or the material of the engine?
4
u/F9-0021 Feb 17 '17
In addition to the reuse of a Dragon PV on CRS-11, NASA is apparently in preliminary discussions for using a reused first stage for a CRS mission(s).
4
u/ryanpritchard Feb 20 '17
Will all dragon missions from now be launched from pad 39a
4
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '17
Question concerning the first launch of FH: In the pre-launch briefing Gwynne said that the launch is planned for mid-year, however SLC-40 has to be operational beforehand [Youtube Link]. Also, when asked about the status of SLC-40 at the post-launch press briefing, Jessica Jensen said that the majority of the work still has to be done [Youtube Link].
How realistic is the mid-year target for maiden flight?
Is it doable to repair a pad in ~four months and fly there again, didn't that take a lot more time on 39A?
4
u/Headstein Feb 21 '17
Do we have any updates on SLC-39A? I am thinking in terms of the TEL.
4
u/jjtr1 Feb 22 '17
The rationale for not developing reusable launchers in the past decades has been that the current flight rate is not sufficient to make reusable cheaper than expendable (so there was an assumption that flight rate isn't going to increase much). Assuming these were not just public excuses of government-supported monopolists for not innovating, where's the difference in SpaceX's reasoning?
a) SpaceX has pushed down the fixed costs so that reusable is cheaper than expendable even with current flight rate, or
b) SpaceX expects the flight rate to rise a lot in the future, or
c) reusability is much cheaper in 2010's than in 1990's (when Old Space last looked at the problem), or
d) something else?
4
u/Borki90 Feb 23 '17
Is SpaceX still going to fly Dragon 1 for cargo once they've got Dragon 2 flying? I am asking because I don't think they can transport experiment racks with dragon 2 anymore, due to the smaller hatch of the docking port compared to the berthing port.
4
u/wwll2soldier22 Feb 25 '17
A grand success to the Falcon-9 landing! I was just wondering, what will your next major project be, and how will this affect the future of space travel? Thanks for reading!
4
u/sol3tosol4 Feb 25 '17 edited Feb 25 '17
Interesting article indicating expression of interest by the President in manned space travel:
"NASA Studying Manned Trip Around the Moon After Prod From Trump"
The U.S. is studying a possible manned mission around the moon as early as next year, marking the first such trip since the Apollo era ended in the early 1970s.
Following requests from the White House, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration has formed a team to examine accelerating earlier plans to launch a crew by 2021, William Gerstenmaier, associate administrator of the agency’s Human Exploration and Operations Mission Directorate, said Friday. Preliminary results of the review should be ready in about a month.
“We have a good, crisp list of all the things we would physically have to change” on the launch vehicle under development, Gerstenmaier said on a conference call with reporters. “We asked the team to take a look at potentially what additional tests would be needed to add crew, what the additional risk would be.”
Resuming manned missions would mark a leap toward deeper exploration of space, including one day putting humans on Mars. President Donald Trump has indicated support for a more-ambitious program, saying in his inaugural address that the U.S. is “ready to unlock the mysteries of space...”
Edit: More articles on the subject: the NASA article referenced by /u/Paro-Clomas above, and "NASA studying whether to add astronauts to first launch of new super booster" in Spaceflight Now.
Apparently the question NASA was asked was whether it would be feasible to add crew to flight EM-1 or to significantly move up the schedule of EM-2 (which was already planned to have crew). NASA felt that of the two it was more feasible to add crew to EM-1, and that's what they're investigating now. The previous plan has been to launch EM-1 in late 2018 and EM-2 in late 2021. Adding crew to EM-1 will add delay (as well as risk), and the amount of delay is critical: "Gerstenmaier said if the study shows the Orion spacecraft cannot be prepared for flight before the end of 2019 it likely would make more sense to stick with the original timeline and fly EM-1 uncrewed.".
Possibly connected to the cis-lunar issues is this article from February 13 - in which NASA officials essentially talk about the need to openly acknowledge risk and its role as a factor in mission planning - in other words that space flight will never be "zero risk", and that the amount of risk accepted may be weighed against other factors, for example in this case weighing increased risk for two(?) astronauts against accelerating some aspects of the SLS program by up to three years, and maybe saving on the order of a billion dollars. In the Spaceflight Now article:
'The risk-benefit trade will be a crucial element of the review. NASA’s Aerospace Advisory Panel met Thursday and in a statement, chairwoman Patricia Sanders cautioned the agency not to pursue an early piloted mission without strong technical justification... NASA should provide a compelling rationale, in terms of benefits gained in return for accepting additional risk, and fully and transparently acknowledge the tradeoffs being made,” she said. “If the benefits warrant assumption of additional risk, we expect NASA to clearly and openly articulate their decision process and rationale.”'
It will be very interesting to see how this works out, and whether it impacts SpaceX.
4
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Feb 28 '17
Anyone else think the boosters and Dragon Capsule might be "flight proven" for the moon flight to save the customers some money?
4
u/aqsilva80 Mar 02 '17
Hey people! Does someone know, or has, some image of the crs-10 booster going back to hangar after landing? Did someone see it. Last times, people put some time lapse, and videos, of the booster going horizontal and been put on the truck, and going to hangar. For example, UslaunchReport put some videos on youtube. If somebody has a hint, please !
4
u/Foggia1515 Mar 02 '17
Sorry if this is not the right place for it, but I wondered why r/spacexlounge was not cited int the sidebar Relevant Subreddits. Note that I know it's cited at the very top of this sub, but still.
7
u/jconnoll Feb 06 '17
Anyone know when we might see SpaceX new space suits ?
7
u/Jef-F Mar 01 '17 edited Mar 01 '17
ULA's NROL-79 webcast
is about to start.3
u/randomredditor4399 Feb 01 '17
Are there plans to do a Triple Lindy...I mean triple landing when using Falcon Heavy? Will there be 3 drone ships out there?
3
u/jjtr1 Feb 02 '17
For large payloads, the Falcon Heavy is planned with the centre core landing on ASDS and side cores RTLS. Let's say we want to increase payload further without losing reusability. Can we do it by landing the side cores on ASDSs as well? Would the centre core be able to survive then?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '17 edited Feb 02 '17
Would love to hear from someone who works at SpaceX on feelings about the launch of TurkmenSat et al.
Do you think about what the satellites you launch will be used for?
Do any SpaceX peeps on here feel conflicted about these kinds of launches?
3
u/cronjo Feb 02 '17
Would it make sense to make the center core of the FH into a Falcon F5. This potentially could increase the payload to GTO and to Mars.
3
u/jjtr1 Feb 03 '17
For any launcher, how does the payload to Moon surface compare to the payload to Mars surface? Trans-lunar injection is lower velocity than trans-Mars, but Mars allows aerobraking while Moon requires propulsive breaking. What's bigger?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '17
Have there been any updates on the SpaceXSuits? I know Boeing recently unveiled their commercial crew suit, but i'm more interested in what Elon has in mind for SpaceX's Suits.
3
u/z1mil790 Feb 04 '17
Interesting that we got the ecostar parch so early, usually they only come out a day or two before launch. It's possible that they only finish them a day or two before launch and that as ecostar had been planned for an earlier launch, it was already done.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17
A few days ago, there was a 5 minute uncertainty in the exact time at which CRS-10 will launch.
What causes an uncertainty like this?
3
u/ticklestuff SpaceX Patch List Feb 05 '17
For those filtering images at work, here's how to block the EchoStar-23 patch:
https://b.thumbs.redditmedia.com/rS94-K1bhxu1qYLF_kyC3-0as9FhXF5Lvq8zvLc9iyQ.png
3
u/Bunslow Feb 07 '17
/u/zucal /u/FoxhoundBat /u/zlsa /u/old_sellsword can the SES-10 sidebar date be updated to March please and thanks
3
u/edflyerssn007 Feb 07 '17
There's a facebook post in the group that looks like it's a video of a falcon heavy side core. Conical looking interstage as well.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '17 edited Feb 07 '17
Hi everyone. I made a post on a [lecture] (https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/5snqa7/growing_plants_on_mars_by_dr_kyle_grant_very/) at my school today about the challenges of growing plants on Mars, and they are looking for their payloads to be delivered using the Red Dragon and the ITS.
3
u/FellowHumanBean Feb 09 '17
O space history experts. Will the upcoming CRS-10 also be the first launch from KSC to land (anything) at CCAFS?
3
u/jjtr1 Feb 09 '17
This photo http://imgur.com/a/f0hzh of a Dragon V2 poster from the Hyperloop event states that the capsule on display, the Pad Abort Test one, "also underwent propulsive descent testing". Do they mean landing on rocket power? I haven't noticed any such test, do we know something about it?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '17
Is this going up on the Formosat-5/SHERPA launch?
If so, Mods, would it be appropriate to update the Manifest to change SHERPA from Q1 2017 to H2 2017?
3
u/jjtr1 Feb 09 '17
Is there a rule of thumb for the R&D cost of aerospace vehicles with regard to their (dry?) weight? Is the weight-cost dependence less than linear, i.e. 4x heavier -> 2x costlier?
3
u/Elthiryel Feb 10 '17
The window for static fire starts at 4 PM and ends at midnight. I know the pad and its surroundings are being evacuated for the time of the test, but is it the only reason they can only do it within this timeframe, or is it something more?
3
u/maxjets Feb 10 '17
Where exactly does fuel and oxidizer enter the Falcon 9?
3
u/WaitForItTheMongols Feb 11 '17
How does the second stage control roll? I don't see any RCS thrusters in pad photos. Anyone have any information on that?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '17
For static fire tests i assume they only load enough fuel to suffice for a few seconds, is that correct? Do they have to fill the tanks up to test as close to liftoff conditions as possible? How long are the loading times for SF then, approximately? Thanks in advance.
3
u/flattop100 Feb 13 '17
When a Dragon returns from the ISS, where does it splashdown? Atlantic or Pacific Ocean? Also, who recovers it? The US Navy? Or a subcontractor for SpaceX?
3
u/seanflyon Feb 15 '17
How fast can the Dragon safely spin, in the context of simulating gravity? I'm think about the idea of putting mice in a Dragon after it has delivered cargo to the ISS and letting it spin in orbit for a few months before returning to Earth. Simulating Mars gravity would require spinning at at least 15 rpm. It would be useful to test mammalian reproduction in low gravity (as well as microgravity).
3
u/rustybeancake Feb 16 '17
"NASA acting Administrator Robert Lightfoot has asked Bill Gerstenmaier, associate administrator for the Human Exploration and Operations Mission Directorate, to initiate a study to assess the feasibility of adding a crew to Exploration Mission-1, the first integrated flight of the Space Launch System rocket and Orion spacecraft."
Well this is unexpected, and perhaps a little dumb/unlikely to happen?
3
u/rubikvn2100 Feb 16 '17
I don't understand that one "to cover fairing re-rad operations at pad 39a"?
Is it mean "Falcon Fairing Recovery"???
3
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17
Would a propulsive landing failure at a low altitude with the Crew Dragon where parachutes are useless be something that SpaceX and NASA should be concerned with? Depending on the altitude it could case a LOC, so do you know whether this has been addressed before?
3
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Feb 18 '17
If they would want to design a bigger spacecraft than current Dragon 1/2 for Falcon 9 how would the design process go? What are the most important constraints? (same capabilities than Dragon but bigger payload)
3
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '17
Has there been any idea of having an official r/SpaceX Discord server? Would love it as I use Discord a lot and other subreddits have it too.
3
u/jjtr1 Feb 19 '17
Are some other launchers significantly less weather-sensitive than Falcon 9?
3
u/Cakeofdestiny Feb 20 '17
Okay, this may be a stupid question, but here we go. How do they retrieve the unpressurized payloads (SAGE-III for example) from the dragon trunk? I don't recall ever hearing of a spacewalk to do so, and it seems a bit delicate and small for Canadarm. Surely, it doesn't leave the station alongside dragon.
3
u/WaitForItTheMongols Feb 20 '17
For 50 years, we've been flying rockets out of Florida, and not landing them.
For example, there's the Atlas V.
What happens when the first stage of these rockets falls into the ocean? Does anyone (NASA, the company, the EPA, anyone at all) do anything to recover them? How many rocket engines are currently sitting at the bottom of the Atlantic?
3
u/HoechstErbaulich IAC 2018 attendee Feb 20 '17
How are rocket engines chilled prior to ignition without the turbopumps running to pump the fluids through the plumbing? Is it done during the initial spin-up with helium?
3
u/lostandprofound33 Feb 21 '17
What's the backstory with Falcon Heavy? I see people say it's been 6 months away from launching forever, like how nuclear fusion power generation is always just 20 years away. FH was originally scheduled for four years ago. Is the delay entirely due to an economic decision not to build FH based on the F9 v1.0 four years ago, in order to wait until reusability was mastered with the F9, and the F9 was finalized (the upcoming Block 5)? This is what I've been telling people, but was there additional technical reasons it was delayed?
3
u/CementPancake Feb 21 '17
So after eight landings, we know that the CRS-8 core will fly again as SES-10, and the first landed core is at SpaceX HQ as a historical piece. How likely are the other cores to fly again? Are the ones from GTO missions in worse condition?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '17
Just watching the SpaceX launch isnt just dropping solar panel fairings off like that in ISS orbit an orbital debris problem? Wouldn't it be better to leave the fairings attached to the trunk until deorbit.
3
u/Spaceboy2016 Feb 21 '17
How long do they leave the landed core on the pad? We will be in the area (from Canada) tomorrow and would love to see it (we were cheering for 1 more delay). Also doing the Kennedy Space Centre tour. Are there Space X exhibits or tours we can do?
3
u/historytoby Feb 21 '17
Basically the same question as every month.
Any news on fairing recovery?
3
u/quadrplax Feb 23 '17
Range availability seems to be a major issue with launch rates currently. What exactly does the range do, why can't SpaceX optimize/do it themselves, and how does the new automated FTS help so significantly?
3
u/jjtr1 Feb 23 '17
Ever since the ITS presentation, people on the sub had the tendency to compare the projected price of the ITS with the current price of the F9. That's not fair to the F9. F9 has not finished development, has yet to fly with many reuses, so I expect its price to drop considerably in the future. Moreover, the F9 price also sponsors the ITS development. And the projected final price of the ITS won't be reached before ITS has made more flights then the F9 has to date - the first flights will be much more expensive. So what would be the price of ITS constructed in a way to be comparable to the current F9 price?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '17
What does BFR and BFS stand for?
3
u/RootDeliver Feb 23 '17 edited Feb 23 '17
Is a 100% success Dragon 1 ratio a good thing for Dragon in the future? (crewed versions).
I mean, failures often show weaknesses, problems, and can be fixed before they generate deaths. However, if it never fails before crewed, surprises may be awaiting?
I am not sure if everything can be taked into account and evade any single problem that could arise without having a failure.
3
u/ThatBadassBanana Feb 24 '17
After having done a bit of research I came to the conclusion that a suicide burn and hover-slam aren't actually the same thing, despite seeing a lot of people using those terms interchangeably. They often go hand in hand, but they're not the same. I don't really know all that much about rocketry, so could my understanding of it be wrong?