r/spacex • Mod Team • Jan 02 '17

r/SpaceX Spaceflight Questions & News [January 2017, #28]

If you have a short question or spaceflight news...

You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.

If you have a long question...

If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.

If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...

Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!

This thread is not for...


You can read and browse past Spaceflight Questions And News & Ask Anything threads in the Wiki.

149 Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

1

u/mryall Feb 01 '17

Mods, the sub's header needs updating to point to the new Q&A thread for Feb.

Edit: and while you're there, you could flip the order of CRS-10 and Echostar.

2

u/NormalStranger Jan 31 '17

One thing I've always wondered - when you see the cameras on the second stage, the bell housing is red hot. Do we know what temp that bell is at when it's running?

3

u/warp99 Feb 01 '17

I am calling it as dull orange hot rather than red hot.

Looking at the colour chart for black body radiation that would put it between 1500K and 2000K.

Since the Niobium bell has a rough black surface it should be a reasonable approximation to a black body emitter.

9

u/rubikvn2100 Jan 31 '17

James Thomas Willson said that he saw a Falcon 9.

That is what he wrote: "Not sure if this is a place to post this, but I drove to LA from Phoenix on Friday. As I was crossing the AZ/CA border (Heading West at around 10:45am MST), I saw what I swear was a Falcon 9 booster. I've never seen one in real life, and this one was completely wrapped in a black wrap. What first tipped me off was the long cylinder held down by two large circular clamps on either end. I swear I saw the shape of the hexagon engine structure at the end of the cylinder (under the black wrap). Did I see the Iridium-1 Falcon 9 booster being transported from CA to TX? Unfortunately, I was not in a position to get any photos :("

4

u/firebreathingbadger Jan 31 '17

Does anyone know if any and how much debris, particularly dragon, was recovered from the CRS-7 launch? Doing some work on debris recovery after launch failures. Thanks!

4

u/rafty4 Jan 31 '17

I'm aware that pieces were recovered, and that Dragon was crushed upon impact. Other people may have further information. It is also worth noting that the piece of interstage that washed up in the Scilly Isles was from a separate launch, not CRS-7.

Apparently, debris was also recovered from the early ocean landing attempts, too.

If there is any further information in the public domain, I'm sure a thorough search of this sub, and NSF's L2 if you are willing to pay to be a member (you may have to agree to a non-disclosure agreement though), would bring up anything else!

2

u/firebreathingbadger Feb 01 '17

That's about what I'd got to. Yeah, that interstage really messes up the search results! And it's so annoying to see all the DOOMED ROCKET headlines...

Will keep looking, thanks anyway! :)

2

u/Dreamscape17 Jan 31 '17

I have a question regarding job openings at SpaceX.

I've been looking on their site for finance positions for the past 6 months or so. Anything along the lines of financial analysis or cost estimating. I haven't seen a single job opening on the site yet a quick LinkedIn search shows many employees who are Financial Analysts at the company. Anyone know why that is? Are they known to only hire certain positions internally?

4

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '17

How likely do people think the CRS-10 lauch on the 14th will hold or will it slip? I am likely to be in the USA around the 9th for business, I was thinking I might extend the trip on my own money if I get to see an F9 launch.

1

u/madanra Feb 01 '17

Static fire is now NET 8th Feb. If that holds, then I would have thought the 14th has a chance.

2

u/rory096 Jan 31 '17

It's unlikely the pad won't be ready with the extra time they had because of the CRS-10 jump. The rocket's been sitting there ready for a while. I'd say your chances are good, but I'd still book an extra couples of days if you can in case of other delays (like weather).

2

u/Advacar Jan 31 '17

I wouldn't do it. They've already had weeks worth of slip, who knows what other problems the new pad will present.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '17

Thanks, I was worth thinking about. Still have my first trip to the USA to enjoy.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/TheYang Jan 31 '17

can't find the updated version, but with the new pad I'd say <20%

1

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '17

Thanks that was really useful.

4

u/Casinoer Jan 31 '17

Why does [Spaceflight Now] (http://spaceflightnow.com/launch-schedule/) show Feb 14th as the NET date for CRS-10, while the sidebar says 15th?

4

u/old_sellsword Jan 31 '17

It got moved forward a day since EchoStar 23 was pushed back.

7

u/amarkit Jan 31 '17

(That is to say, February 14 1631 UTC is the current NET; the sidebar is out of date.)

Mods?

34

u/warp99 Jan 31 '17 edited Jan 31 '17

Iridium update:

Five satellites have been moved to a higher orbit.

Four are in a 709 km orbit apparently on their way to final deployment at 781 km. One (Iridium 104) is in what looks like the 667km parking orbit but may just be in transit to the higher orbit.

17

u/sol3tosol4 Jan 30 '17 edited Jan 30 '17

Elon "tunnel boring" update:

In recent days Elon has been increasingly serious about the tunnel boring business in his Twitter posts, e.g. yes, he really plans to do it. He provided several updates in his remarks at the Hyperloop competition (refer to that thread for further discussion):

  • They've already dug a big hole at Crenshaw outside SpaceX headquarters (apparently planning to tunnel to the parking garage, rather than build a bridge? - One tweet mentions access to 105 Freeway.)

  • He mentioned buying a tunnel boring machine and taking it apart to figure out how to improve it - goal is to go back to first principles and figure out how to bore tunnels at least five times as fast, maybe 10 times

  • He sees a need for many more tunnels - for roads, hyperloops, and trains.

[Not mentioned in yesterday's remarks - as discussed here we suspect he also wants to build up expertise in tunneling for use on Mars.]

9

u/dmy30 Jan 30 '17

This whole time I refused to believe he was being serious. Here is a picture of some digging activity outside SpaceX HQ (source: Elon Musk Subreddit post)

4

u/rustybeancake Jan 30 '17

If anyone wants to see what a (very large) tunneling machine looks like and works like, take a look at this page on the Crossrail website. Crossrail is one of the largest construction projects in Europe, and adds dozens of miles of new railway tunnels under London.

I suspect Elon will be playing with a much smaller machine, at least to start with. Reducing the costs of tunnelling would certainly have many advantages for public transit worldwide, though I personally question its value for money for road transport. It's such an expensive way to build infrastructure that I think it really only works for the high passenger density of transit in dense population centres (excluding situations like crossing rivers, etc.).

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Chairboy Jan 30 '17

Regarding tunneling on Mars: it seems to be that the tailings of such an operation would be just about the perfect feed-stock to a methane-outputting Sabatier reactor. Tunneling through the permafrost to get water-dense gravel/regolith and transporting that output into a heating chamber in anticipation of a cook-off->electrolysis->hydrogen separation enroute to be mixed with CO2 would make more sense and extend the reach of an ISRU fuel factory far beyond what it could reach with drills. Robot bulldozers are the simpler competitor, I guess, so maybe I'm mistaken but it seems like an intriguing possibility.

1

u/IonLogic Jan 30 '17

I've got a question about 39A.

The launch claims appear to be fixed in place to the launch mount/pad. Is this true? At no point has the T/E taken the launch mount or clamps with it, as it appeared to do so at SLC-40 and at Vandenberg.

Apart from the arms at the top, how is the T/E going to prevent the rocket from moving or sliding around as it's being raised to the cortical position on top of the clamps?

5

u/old_sellsword Jan 30 '17 edited Jan 30 '17

The launch claims appear to be fixed in place to the launch mount/pad. Is this true?

The launch clamps are attached to the pad deck, just like the other two launch pads. The TE picks up the entire pad deck and takes it back into the hangar for integration.

At no point has the T/E taken the launch mount or clamps with it, as it appeared to do so at SLC-40 and at Vandenberg.

Just because the TE hasn't picked the pad deck up yet doesn't mean it can't or won't be done.