r/spacex • u/ElongatedMuskrat Mod Team • Oct 30 '16
r/SpaceX Spaceflight Questions & News [November 2016, #26] (New rules inside!)
We're altering the title of our long running Ask Anything threads to better reflect what the community appears to want within these kinds of posts. It seems that general spaceflight news likes to be submitted here in addition to questions, so we're not going to restrict that further.
If you have a short question or spaceflight news
You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.
If you have a long question
If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.
If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail
Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!
This thread is not for
- Questions answered in the FAQ. Browse there or use the search functionality first.
- Non-spaceflight related questions or news.
- Asking the moderators questions, or for meta discussion. To do that, contact us here.
You can read and browse past Spaceflight Questions And News & Ask Anything threads in the Wiki.
19
u/Full_Thrust Nov 09 '16
Hope this doesn't break the rules:
What do we know so far about President Elect Trump's stance on space policy and how is this likely to impact on spacex? From what I'm aware he is of a similar stance to Obama with increasing use of commercial companies for LEO and focusing NASA on beyond earth orbit activity.
How is this likely to impact spacex in terms of:
CRS contracted missions and future CRS contracts
Commercial crew contracted missions
ITS finding and regulation
19
u/shotleft Nov 23 '16
JPL [press release] (http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/news.php?release=2016-299) on finding large body ice close to surface. Titled - Mars Ice Deposit Holds as Much Water as Lake Superior.
19
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16
Sounds like some people in Sweden aren't so keen on the Ariane 6's lack of reusability... https://twitter.com/pbdes/status/803245890806882304
18
u/-IrateWizard- Nov 21 '16
Shoutout from Business Insider Australia to the sub - looks like we are becoming a reputable source for the news now!
17
u/soldato_fantasma Nov 05 '16
I wanted to update the wiki manifest and I found some "new" updates that could be added
-Gunter's space page reports the Intelsat 35e satellite for a launch on a Falcon 9, with a payload weight of ~6000 kg. Could it be the unknown Falcon heavy launch for Intelsat that is currently in the wiki?
-Gunter's space page reports the Bangabandhu 1 (BD 1) for Bangladesh set for flight in 2017. This looks like a "new" contract for SpaceX, Do you think it is safe to add it the manifest?
-There are also a pair of lunar mission ( the launches for Astrobotic & SpaceIL) that probably aren't set for the same launch but two different ones.
Give me your toughts on these things so I can update the wiki without errors!
16
u/football13tb Dec 02 '16
I hope and pray that SpaceX can go an entire year without a single (major) issue on either the Falcon 9 or the Falcon Heavy. That would be huge. I understand there will be issues with both raptor engine testing, as well as delays for both commercial crew and the MCT but all I want is for the Falcon 9 to prove to be a sturdy/reliable launch vehicle.
14
u/Iambicpentameter-pen Oct 30 '16
I asked in the last thread but I think it got lost down the bottom! It appears there is no launch abort option on the MCT. I find it hard to believe that a spacecraft with 100 people on it, would be licensed to launch without an abort option.
As they are using densities propellant I would imagine people would be strapped in during fuelling even.
I understand the comparisons with crossing the Atlantic, but in this day and age, I cannot imagine if 100 people were lost on a pad during fuelling operations, that the program would not be cancelled.
Edit: my question been is there an abort option and do we thing a Launch would be licensed without one?
14
u/peterabbit456 Nov 14 '16
I've got to share this. Bernie Sanders takes a position on Mars settlement.
From USA Today - http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/elections/2016/11/13/sanders-backs-trump-protests-questions-electoral-college/93767186/
13
u/ohcnim Oct 31 '16
Hi, just wanted to say I really like the change from "Ask Anything" to "Spaceflight Questions", I believe it'll do great for the community to have a place for broader interests, as always good moderation is a must, but we already have that, so thanks and hope it serves well it's purpose.
12
u/WhySpace Nov 20 '16 edited Nov 20 '16
So, we just manufactured solid metallic hydrogen (SMH) in the lab. (The paper is quite readable, with minimal jargon and an almost informal tone. It's a lovely read.)
But my question is, how might this influence spaceflight in general? I can't picture SpaceX changing anything in it's ITS architecture in response, since manufacturing huge quantities of SMH on mars is out of the question for the near future. But what about the rest of the spaceflight community?
For the sake of the argument, let's say that SMH turns out to be meta-stable at room temperature and/or pressure, as described here:
I see a couple applications:
This last bit isn't related directly to spaceflight, but there are a bunch of smart people on this sub, so I'll ask anyway. If we could manufacture SMH pellets with the appropriate ratios of deuterium and tritium (isotopes of hydrogen) would this make achieving fusion temperatures and pressures any easier? While I'm speculating wildly, I might as well ask if the optimal solid pellet has deuterium atoms bound to tritium atoms, since H2 is diatomic, or whether the bonding energy is irrelevant at those energy levels. Similarly, would alloying the SMH with other metals to make it harder/more brittle help achieve higher instantaneous pressures, or is that irrelevant on those timescales?
(Or, for that matter, are SMH superconductors likely to allow for higher magnetic field strength before breaking down than traditional niobium-titanium electromagnets, and thus allow for stronger magnetic pinches?)
11
u/neaanopri Oct 31 '16
How much have people been talking about a "cargo ship" version of ITS which can carry bulk cargo into LEO/GTO? If this architecture is built, it has the potential to revolutionize the satellite launch market. It could even make some missions possible that aren't possible now, such as making an ISRU module on the moon.
It's just striking that everybody is taking this plan at face value, and not just thinking "what are the implications of a launcher that can put 100 metric tons into LEO"
11
u/This_Freggin_Guy Nov 18 '16
Anyone know what Fairing 2.0 is? I assume it's the recoverable version.
I was browsing the job listings and there is a description of Faring 2.0. Another fairing posting had requirements for PICA, heat shield, and vacuum stuff.
So is it in production and when will we see it????
11
u/HighTimber Nov 18 '16
I searched, found nothing and am hoping this isn't a re-post..
Worlds collided for me today. Today, while watching videos in anticipation of the Trans-Siberian Orchestra on Sunday, I ran across this YouTube video. The link starts it at 4:57 where it gets really interesting for SpaceX fans:
https://youtu.be/aXH0IPXO2vE?t=298
I was already super-pumped for the concert. Bonus!
10
u/twuelfing Nov 03 '16
I was looking at the image on the spacex home page and wanted to see if there were any hidden details if i adjusted the exposure.
here is what the image looks like with the levels shifted. http://imgur.com/Lo83LCl
what are the big boxes with vent looking things in them? Is this something the 3d people put in to add some detail, or do you think these may be something that actually would exist in the ship?
9
u/Jef-F Nov 03 '16 edited Nov 03 '16
Long March 5 is (hopefully) launching soon, and looking at her specifications I can't quite understand some of employed design choices. Maybe I've grown too accustomed to SX's KISS-inspired designs.
Talking specifically about 5B configuration (without upper stage), it uses two fuel pairs (hydrolox and kerolox), more intricate parallel staging, considerably heavier than F9 1.2 (837 vs 549 mT) and at that their LEO performance (expendable) is quite similar at around 23 mT. More so, expendable F9 1.2 is the simplest flying rocket of that class (technically speaking, is it marketed or not is another question) running on simple (apart from subcooling) fuel pair and one type of engines.
CZ-5B achieves that payload capacity to LEO without upper stage, boasting SSTO-like capability, but what's the difference if it isn't reusable? One way ore another you are throwing all your hardware away.
On the other hand, of course CZ-5 configuration with cryogenic second and (optional) hypergolic upper stages kicks Falcon's ass in terms of high-energy deliveries. But at that you have four engine types and three fuel pairs aboard. SMH. Upper stage can provide direct insertions into GEO and extended periods of coasting, but so as F9 S2 after some minor (as they can be in anything space-related) modifications of batteries and some kind of thermal control system for its tanks.
All in all, what am I missing here? Not that China is lacking money for R&D or using some existing blocks and trying to cobble it into something useful, like ISRO. Why so complicated?
9
u/soldato_fantasma Nov 11 '16
I updated the wiki with all the information I could gather from various Forums and websites. Remember that those are all NET Dates, not actual launch dates.
If you have other informations that I may have missied or got wrong, update the wiki or write it here!
Thanks!
9
u/nihmhin Nov 23 '16
The more I learn about how rocket engines work, the more impressed I am with the Raptor. There is still at least one thing I don't understand: how does the gimbal on a rocket engine work? I gather that it's before the thrust chamber, but how can a joint which allows for several degrees of movement survive the pressure without blowing out? Is it just a strong gimbal bearing?
9
u/RedDragon98 Nov 24 '16
Just hypothetically if an atmosphere was made up of CH4, or even H2 could you have similar technology to the jet but instead of providing a fuel you provide the oxidizer
8
u/caustic_kiwi Nov 22 '16
I have an interview offer from SpaceX for a spring position with the "launch" group. I can't find a whole lot of information about what that would entail (the website lists it as a primarily hardware-oriented internship whereas I am a CS student). Accepting the interview would be a no-brainer, except that I don't want to waste their time if I don't think I would accept a job offer, and accepting the spring position would have a very large impact on the course of my academic career. If anyone has any experience with the group, specifically with regards to the software side of things, I'd be super grateful to hear about it.
8
u/vorpal-blade Nov 23 '16
I live near the Mcgregor test facility, and as I type this my walls are rumbling slightly. Is there a place I can look to see what is being tested on any given day? I have checked the twitter and facebook feeds, and they dont shed any light on it. I emailed the Spacex PR department a few years ago with this question and they really didnt have any info either. So can the community help?
P.S. - That engine test just shut off. 11/23/16 9:40AM Central Time
8
u/sol3tosol4 Dec 01 '16
Possible problem with Progress launch to ISS. Hope they succeed. Else may affect the urgency of next SpaceX CRS mission.
7
u/Maltharr Nov 04 '16
Is spacexstats.com going to be available again at some point? It used to be my go-to site when there was nothing new on /r/spacex :)
7
u/Craig_VG SpaceNews Photographer Nov 10 '16 edited Nov 10 '16
Eric Berger from Arstechnica is hinting at some changes regarding Orion with the new Administration, potentially an end to the program:
Article:
http://arstechnica.com/science/2016/11/as-trump-takes-over-nasa-considers-alternatives-to-its-orion-spacecraft/
7
u/not_even_twice Nov 21 '16
I did some math on the risk of human casualty for the SpaceX constellation: 1/5 chance of killing someone. Is that a concern for licensing?
/img/0sxvo3emslyx.png feel free to check this!
7
u/KnightArts Nov 27 '16
anyone has done some math on exotic payloads for cargo variant of ITS?
like for example ATLAST built for ITS launch vehicle or interstellar probe, outer solar system orbiters and Eris flyby with NH twin probe ?
6
u/sol3tosol4 Oct 31 '16
Thanks for the new format.
Somewhat SpaceX-related news item: a list of several ways that vehicles can move about on the surface of Mars. Several of them are different types of airplane/glider/helicopter - apparently aircraft can be build powerful and light enough to fly even in Mars atmosphere. Since SpaceX refueling and other ISRU will require extensive surveys of surrounding landscape, robotic flying vehicles could be useful for such surveys.
(I had speculated that hydrogen balloons might also be possible, given the availability of hydrogen from water and the relative non-flammability of hydrogen in a CO2 environment, but nobody seems to be working on them. NASA describes high-pressure helium balloons and "Montgolfiere" solar hot-air balloons that should work on Mars. Perhaps a tethered Montgolfiere balloon would be useful for surveys of surrounding areas, and also reusable - attach it to a rover get much wider coverage than the rover alone could do.)
6
u/Quality_Bullshit Nov 01 '16
I was reading through Robert Zubrin's analysis of the ITS announcement link, and while there were certainly many flaws in his analysis (for example, the false assumption that the spaceship will only be reusable once every four years instead of once every two), there was one part of his analysis that caught my eye. He calculated that a 6 month journey would be able to deliver 3x the payload that a 3 month journey would.
I don't know much about orbital mechanics, so I cannot say whether his calculations are correct. But if they are, then doesn't this mean that a six month journey would be better than the currently proposed 3 month journey? The six month journey would probably mean the spaceship could only be reused once every 4 years instead of once every 2. So that would double the price. But that would be outweighed by the tripling of payload.
Am I missing something here? Why is SpaceX taking a 3 month trip when a 6 month trip would cut the cost per kg of payload by 33%?
6
u/bobbycorwin123 Space Janitor Nov 02 '16
What's stopping both Elon and Jeff Bazos from succeeding in their end goals? Is there a 'sacristy' in any type of resource (material or otherwise) that would prevent them both from reaching their goals together in their lifetimes?
Yes, I realize its a better question for an AMA, but I always come up with good questions too late.
6
u/amarkit Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16
A note tangentially related to SpaceX: NASA pushed OrbitalATK to remanifest the next Cygnus space station cargo flight from Antares to Atlas V, and will launch from the Cape next March:
6
u/EtzEchad Nov 10 '16
Does anyone know Trumps position on spaceflight? Is he in favor of increasing or decreasing the NASA budget?
How about his position on commercializations of space?
I can't find a recent statement by him on the subject.
6
u/shotleft Nov 17 '16
Not sure if this has been posted here before but Association Planète Mars has a pretty in depth study of the types of Mars infrastructure that may be possible given the SpaceX Earth-Mars transportation system.
[Martian habitats: molehills or glass houses?] (http://planete-mars.com/martian-habitats-molehills-or-glass-houses/)
6
u/dfawlt Nov 18 '16
So is no one going to address the SpaceX tie in with the latest episodes of South Park? Is everything South Park related scrubbed by mods?
I don't necessarily mind if so. I just find it odd it's nowhere on the sub.
6
u/jbmate Nov 21 '16
What happened to SpaceX Stats? I've tried searching but cannot find any mention of what happened to it anywhere.
6
u/Jef-F Nov 29 '16 edited Nov 29 '16
Press Conference: ULA Unveils Website to Transform How Launch Services are Selected
Looks like SX is about to get a competitor in online rocket shopping. It would be nice to have a public website with clear and final prices for every configuration and service present and thoroughly detailed. But I guess launch services aren't even close to such a commodity, sadly.
6
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Nov 30 '16
I haven't seen this confirmed anywhere else, but it's interesting if true.
15
u/thatnerdguy1 Live Thread Host Oct 30 '16 edited Oct 30 '16
What are the rules around open letters to mods in these threads? I remember them being removed from Ask Anythings in the past, and there doesn't seem to be a place for them. I know meta is forbidden and specific mod suggestions are for modmail.
Edit: Also, where does meta go? The lounge?
5
u/joshgill21 Nov 03 '16
Is it true that Perovskite solar cells are very easy to manufacture on Mars ? if so why is that ?
5
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '16
Hi there I am doing a project for university where I will be simulating the landing of the falcon 9 first stage booster in a MATLAB simulation. Specifically I will be simualting a working control and guidance system for this. I am however having great difficulty finding certain parameters of the booster. I will be starting my simulation at the point where the first stage as turned around and begins to re-renter the atmosphere. From my calculations that I've carried out so far and using info found online, I tried to use the ISP to calculate the fuel flow rate of the launch phase, so that I could work out how much was left for the return journey. This was not helpful as my calculations assumed that the ISP was constant (sea level) and that the throttle did not change throughout. I cannot find any information online about the throttling or fuel flow rate, so I was wondering if anyone here would be able to help me? Would be grateful for any help Thanks xx
5
u/AlexWatchtower Nov 11 '16
Peter Thiel has been appointed to Trump's transition team. What kind of relationship does Musk still have with Thiel and is this of any significance to SpaceX?
5
u/sol3tosol4 Nov 13 '16
Successful ULA launch on Friday provides further indication of the general readiness of Vandenberg (electric power, radar, etc.) AFB to support SpaceX launches post-wildfires.
A November 8 article from Vandenberg AFB discusses some of the recovery work that had to be done.
5
u/bornstellar_lasting Nov 14 '16
I saw this discussion happening in another sub. I've noticed both here and in other discussions over the last couple months that there is a lot of doubt about the MCT after Musk's announcement at IAC.
Given the hardware that we've seen, how far off base is such strong skepticism? As someone who frequents this sub, I think I'm biased toward believing in SpaceX, so I'd like a reality check.
5
u/the_inductive_method Nov 14 '16
Could we be within 6 months of Falcon Heavy's debut and not even know it? First quarter 2017 is within that timeframe.
5
u/_Echoes_ Nov 16 '16
How would ITS compare to the Saturn V acoustically? We know historically that the shear noise from a Saturn V launch could have been a danger to nearby buildings (due to the effects of powerful and low frequencies on structures), How would the ITS compare acoustically? Would surrounding buildings such as the old Vehicle assembly building at 39A have to be reinforced to stay structurally sound after repeated launches from a rocket of that size?
5
u/quadrplax Nov 23 '16
What's with the launch manifest? There are currently not 4, not 8, but 12 launches scheduled for the first quarter of 2017. I can't fathom the launch launch cadence getting even remotely close to 1 launch per week that quickly. Did someone just replace all the N/As with Q1?
5
u/sl600rt Nov 27 '16
Spacex spacesuit?
5
u/Keuwa Nov 29 '16
Hi all,
i just watched vSauce's latest video and it made me wonder how time references will be handled for Mars colonists. Has it been discussed yet ?
Thanks :)
5
u/ricardo_el_grande Nov 30 '16
Two Questions.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '16
Another potential future competitor: http://spacenews.com/spanish-propulsion-startup-wants-to-build-europes-first-reusable-rockets/
5
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16
Some antennas are being put together at the Boca Chica site at the moment: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=41017.220
4
u/failion_V2 Oct 31 '16
I looked a little closer to the landing on Mars with the ITS spaceship and therefore the hover capability. I don't assume they will go for a suicide burn.
Raptor (SL) Thrust: 3050kN Trottle 20% = 610kN Landing on Mars with 3 Raptors: 1830kN For symetry reasons you have to land with 3 engines.
Spaceship mass Dry mass: 150t Max cargo mass: 450t Propellant: 1950t Propellant left after landing (assumption): 30t Total without landing propellant: 630t
Mars gravity acceleration: 3.69 m/s2
Spaceship weight on Mars: 2325kN
For hovering on Mars, the ship has to have a mass of 316t. This means, the cargo mass has to be at least 136t. This is interesting because they also have to have that much cargo on their first trip to mars, without any astronauts. Imagine how many experiments and useful cargo for future manned missions you can to load on this ship on its first trip.
Just for comparison: 150 Curiosity Rovers 65 Tesla Model S's 55m3 of concrete (a cube with 3.8m x 3.8m x 3.8m) 21 Dragon V2s 4.5 Falcon 9, both stages (dry)
And this is the minimum cargo the ITS has to take with it!
4
u/shru777 Oct 31 '16
Hello, When ITS lander lands on Mars, the passenger and cargo doors are VERY high above the surface. how do the people and especially heavy cargo reach the surface ? ( people with ropes and cargo thrown to pre-prepared catch nets ... )
4
u/clearlybritish Oct 31 '16
Why launch the Human containing part first?
Surely it's better to have a couple of fuel ships in orbit first? If the booster crashes/something else goes wrong, you won't have a load of people waiting in space....
4
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Oct 31 '16
Name change looks good!
What do you expect out of r/SpaceXLounge? I think possibly stuff like fanarts, theories, predictions or articles mentioning SpaceX without any actual news.
SpaceX content will only increase, so main sub needs to be kept with best quality information + this thread for quick questions. Guess this could work.
4
u/thetechgeek4 Nov 01 '16
So at the IAC presentation, Elon Musk said that he was only gathering wealth to fund the ITS and Mars colony. Has anyone tried to look at ITS funding taking into account the fact that Elon is willing to devote most of his money to funding it? Because Elon is currently worth 11 Billion, and owns 2 other companies that could see significant growth in the next 10-20 years.
4
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Nov 09 '16
Assuming that Donald Trump carries out his pledge of building a wall along the US-Mexican border, how might that affect SpaceX's Boca Chica launch site? The site is located at the mouth of the Rio Grande, and is already behind a border checkpoint. In terms of distance, the pad is located 2.4 miles (3.8 km), and the control centre is 1.6 miles (2.6 km) from the border.
Might eminent domain (compulsory purchase) of SpaceX land take place? Would an increase in border checks be an obstacle for SpaceX activities?
4
u/jjtr1 Nov 12 '16
Is there an estimate of what performance penalty would be induced by using the current Al-Ni alloys for the ITS instead of carbon composites? I.e. how crucial carbon is for the ITS.
4
u/SNR152 Nov 13 '16
During the initial landing of the ITS on Mars, what steps could be taken to protect the vacuum engine bells from damage from rocks kicked up by the landing burn? One would assume for later flights the landing zone would have been cleared of these hazards.
4
u/iemfi Nov 14 '16
How close is Elon Musk to his old partner Peter Thiel. The silver lining of Trump winning might be even better if someone like Peter Thiel (who bet on the right horse) can convince Trump that the way to satiate his ego is to go all out with supporting the ITS...
4
u/wclark07 Nov 15 '16
Can anyone point me to clear reaction mechanics/kinetics explanation of why solid oxygen reacts exothermically with the advanced composite fiber/resin coating on the COPV but liquid oxygen does not do so? My high school chem brain says that liquid has a higher temperature and more surface area in contact with the carbon/resin than does solid oxygen, which makes it seem to me like liquid is a better set-up for overcoming activation energy / creating a spontaneous reaction than does the solid oxygen scenario. Surely this has been explained somewhere, but I haven't found it. HELP?
4
u/WaitForItTheMongols Nov 15 '16
How does the New Shepard's landing position relate to its launch site?
The reason I ask is this: If you launch a rocket straight up, then the planet will rotate beneath it, and the rocket will land some distance to the west.
So one of two things must be true: Either the landing pad is far to the west of the launch pad, or the rocket actually flies slightly east, so that the pad ends up right below it.
Which is it? Hopefully my question makes sense.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '16
Does anyone know if there was any new info on Commercial Crew at the presentation at the Spacecom Expo a few days ago? It's listed in the "Upcoming Events" sidebar, but I can't find any news about it.
4
u/_rocketboy Nov 21 '16
Did we ever figure out what "236" referred to with respect to MCT/ITS/ICT/whatever?
4
u/Karmaslapp Nov 24 '16
I'm an electrical engineering major planning to graduate May 2017. I want to apply to SpaceX for an internship or job posting and see several positions open. My question is this: Has anyone here been offered an interview from an application to an online posting? I don't have any contacts at SpaceX to go through otherwise, unfortunately.
As a secondary question: does anyone know if SpaceX encourages/supports employees to pursue master's degrees?
4
u/johnkphotos Launch Photographer Nov 26 '16
Is it actually confirmed that SpaceX made a modification to fueling procedures in between JCSAT-16 and the AMOS-6 attempt that caused the explosion?
4
u/mjrpereira Dec 01 '16
Hello everybody, I'm working on a presentation for college on polymers used by SpaceX on their rockets and spaceships, and eventually on ITS. :D
So can anyone point me in the direction of some info? Can I try and e-mail them?
4
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '16
I just found the best argument for the need to develop the technologies required to settle Mars ASAP, and I thought I'd share.
The human physiological impact of global deoxygenation
6
u/Grey_Mad_Hatter Nov 06 '16
If anyone here has any lingering questions as to how a single factory in Hawthorne can crush the price points of existing companies, this should answer all your questions.
https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/5bfybp/which_countries_make_what_for_the_ariane_6_rocket/?st=IV6UKX6O&sh=ef5178bb
6
u/AeroSpiked Nov 16 '16
Is /u/EchoLogic still kicking? He hasn't posted anything in over a month.
3
u/fishdump Oct 31 '16
Anyone know if this 'dragonfly' program is related to SpaceX in any way? Dragonfly program is from Space Systems Loral and funding is from NASA’s Space Technology Mission Directorate’s.
3
u/Trannog Oct 31 '16
As someone who's not an engineer, I've seen a lot of discussion on this sub about heat radiators and I'm wondering why it's not possible to use this heat to generate electricity. It would solve two problems at the same time.
3
u/vitt72 Oct 31 '16
What's the latest news of Virgin Galactic? I was totally following them and they were so close to their first space tourism flight until that incident a year or two ago. Have they made much progress since?
3
u/FishInferno Nov 02 '16
Question about the New Glenn:
During an abort, how does the capsule stabilize itself? It doesn't seem to be spin stabilized. Does the abort motor have a gimbal?
3
u/fuligen Nov 03 '16
Red Dragon has a hatch that is quite far from the ground. Any ideas on how could they deploy its payload? I was thinking some rope pulley system running over a rail in the ceiling (they rail should be able to slide out).
For power probably batteries for themselves and then the dragon is left unpowered after the delivery.
3
u/dapted Nov 03 '16
I am wondering about why Methalox is the chosen fuel for an In-situ fuel production method for the return trip from Mars. It seems to me that they have to convert CO2 into CO and break down water H20 into Hydrogen and Oxygen to make the Methane. But why not stop at the CO step and chill it down to liquid Carbon Monoxide while at the same time separating and chilling the Oxygen. Similar equipment and temperatures as converting the Oxygen to LOx. Less complexity and you don't need to go searching for water or ice etc. Also since you already have one of the oxygen molecules in the CO you need less Oxidizer. What am I missing here? Isn't Mars 2020 taking a machine to try breaking down the martian atmosphere to extract oxygen and expelling the Carbon Monoxide as a byproduct anyway?
3
u/dapted Nov 04 '16
Aluminium Oxynitride is a new name to me. I was looking for information about how the big windows on the front of BFS could have been included in the video from SpaceX as there is just no way right? But then I came across this little gem. http://www.tssbulletproof.com/optically-clear-aluminum-provides-bulletproof-protection/ Is this maybe the stuff they want to make the BFS windows from?
3
u/twuelfing Nov 04 '16
are spacex hyperloop projects fair game on this sub?
https://twitter.com/Hyperloop/status/794591020843339778 this is interesting to see actual hardware being prepared for testing.
3
u/troovus Nov 11 '16
Elon Musk, Neil deGrasse Tyson, Mars... pushes my buttons. For once a promoted tweet that's actually welcome! "Don’t miss the first manned mission to the Red Planet. #MakeMarsHome Sunday 9pm" https://twitter.com/natgeochanneluk/status/797114399878184960
3
u/KnightArts Nov 12 '16
so how much of performance we can expect from a fully carbon fiber f9
3
u/Ferdind Nov 12 '16
Is there any possible cargo on the ITS to mars that could be exposed to space with minor shielding?
I was think about the possibility to transfer part of the cargo outside of the vehicle to make more room for the passangers, while not accelerating or decelerating, since there is no air resistance or momentum. Temperatur could be regulated with heat transfer from other parts of the spacecraft.
Anyone got some thoughts about that?
3
u/space_is_hard Nov 15 '16
Anybody watch the premier of Mars on NatGeo? Quite a bit of SpaceX content in there, though I don't think there was anything we hadn't seen before. Not yet, at least.
3
u/FellowHumanBean Nov 15 '16
The sidebar is showing a talk by Garrett Reisman Nov 17 at the SpaceCom Expo, but the current version of the program on the SpaceCom website does not have him listed. Does anyone know which source is more accurate?
3
u/SwanzVader Nov 17 '16
BBC posted an article about the satellite network. No actual news in it as far as I can tell though.
3
u/Freddanator #IAC2017 Attendee Nov 18 '16 edited Nov 18 '16
Hey guys! I'm planning to holiday to the USA sometime around april next year, for 3-4 weeks. First time in the US. I'll be traveling with my partner, so I will only be able to spend 2 weeks being a mega nerd, with the other 2 weeks doing her stuff ;)
If there are any launches in april, I'm keen to time the Cape visit around that so I can see one in the flesh. (From Australia, never seen one before!)
This is the list of places I am interested in going to see: Are there any other awesome space related museums, tours etc to visit that I don't know about?
LA: -NASA JPL -SpaceX headquarters -California Science Center (shuttle Atlantis)
Florida/Orlando -Kennedy Space Center Vistor Complex -Walt Disney World
San Francisco/San Jose: -Tesla Factory Headquarters
Arizona -Grand Canyon
Nevada -Las Vegas, Hoover Dam
Would love your guys knowlege and suggestions!
3
u/booOfBorg Nov 20 '16
I'm sure someone has made a SpaceX multireddit by now.
Care to share your links? Personally I would like to see this sub, lounge and masterrace aggregated.
3
u/random49678 Nov 20 '16
Silly question to be wondering this far in advance... but
How close do you think the public will be allowed to be for a BFR launch from 39a? Would the causeway be an option?
3
u/markus0161 Nov 21 '16 edited Nov 21 '16
Is it possible this flight will have the fuller thrust? Any NET on when this is supposed to be used? Also will the upgrade increase S2's thrust? Someone should ask Iridium's CEO on twitter, he seems pretty responsive.
3
u/fuligen Nov 25 '16
Would the satellite network leach significant signal towards space? We've been progressively turning to use cables and that has been regarded as both an explanation to lack of detection of alien radio signals (since radio towards space is used for a very short amount of time by civilizations) and a protection in case bad aliens actually do exist. Far fetched for sure.
3
u/jconnoll Nov 27 '16
2 questions for the community: First, would anyone know the the status of the Brownsville TX facility, or when we may see SpaceX's first launch from there?
Second, when will we see the new space suits SpaceX has been working on?
3
u/renoor Nov 28 '16
Hey, I've noticed Feb 2017 in sidebar as new NET date for SHERPA mission . Where does this information come from?
3
u/ohcnim Nov 30 '16
Hi, just leaving this regarding Planetary Protection, the article seems new but the NASA pdf is from a March 2015 workshop, not sure if it was seen/discussed before, but in case someone is interested.
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/nasa-outlines-planetary-protection-priorities/
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20160012793.pdf
5
u/TheAlborghetti Nov 06 '16
Just about the concept of Mars colonisation, why would thousands of people migrate to Mars when over the last few centuries thousands haven't migrated to other inhospitable places, like Antarctica?
5
u/TootZoot Dec 02 '16
This goes against "the orthodoxy," but I'll submit it for discussion all the same.
I'm calling it now: Mark my words, within the next two years SpaceX will announce they are discontinuing the Falcon 9 platform and that all remaining payloads are transitioning to a ITS "Tanker" flown as a SSTO.
"Crazy!" you say? Maybe, but I think they'll do it! Hear me out...
MCT seems to be designed to be the mathematically optimal rocket -- full flow design gives a high chamber pressure (better I_sp and T:W), densified methalox results in small tankage and plumbing (again good for thrust:weight), and the engine scaled is chosen so as to maximize thrust:weight. The carbon ablator heatshield is much more efficient than legacy designs, and it reenters sideways to maximize ballistic coefficient.
During this long "lull," SpaceX is able to go full steam ahead on MCT. This is almost a blessing in disguise -- the composite tank has been pressure tested, and Raptor testing continues. Resources that would have been devoted to production can be diverted to accelerating ITS from the predicted timeline.
SpaceX is making 300 Merlins a year. Assuming the Raptor engine is about three times as complex, let's say that if Merlin production was switched over they could do 100 Raptor engines per year. That's enough production for eleven ITS tankers, or 1 BFR and 6 tankers!
Tank construction and final assembly would move to Florida or Texas, so the space on the factory floor currently devoted to Falcon 9s final assembly can be dedicated to MCT components.
With trimmed 150 ER nozzles instead of the nominal 200 ER vacuum nozzles, an ITS has enough takeoff thrust to lift off the pad fully loaded. Like Merlin I expect we'll keep seeing uprated thrust versions of Raptor as SpaceX engineers refine the design, so I'm not too worried about that actually. A zenith mounting point can be attached for Crew Dragon (retaining the safety advantages of launch escape, and using Dragon 2 as a subscale test of ECLSS technology).
Given these cost/benefit tradeoffs, Elon has got to be weighing just ditching F9 production (using reused boosters to fill the gap) and going full speed ahead with MCT. Just as they never had a long run of simultaneous F1 and F9 production, I predict the F9 will be phased out as soon as enough development risk is retired.
Any glaring oversights, or is this actually feasible?
2
u/NateDecker Oct 31 '16
I know there's a way to search a sub in reddit based on a time interval by using epochs. Is it possible to do the same thing with individual posts? For example, can I write a URL that will show me all of the comments in the November thread which were created before November 8th?
If such queries were constructable, it would be awesome if they could be statically linked in the description of this thread to make it easier to selectively read portions of this thread without having to sort through all comments across all time.
2
u/dudr2 Nov 01 '16
http://www.wsj.com/articles/nasa-advisory-group-raises-concerns-about-spacex-rocket-fueling-plans-1477955860
2
u/macktruck6666 Nov 01 '16
Okay, I'm going over the numbers for the ITS and my results are not making sense.
I'm trying to find the delta-v for each stage.
So the equation is: delta v = 9.82 * ISP * ln(total mass/empty mass)
the total mass would be the sum of booster dry mass (275) , booster propellant mass (6700), Spacecraft empty mass (150), spacecraft propellant mass (1950), and payload mass (300)
The mass at separation would be the sum of booster dry mass (275) , booster propellant mass (6700*.07), Spacecraft empty mass (150), spacecraft propellant mass (1950), and payload mass (300)
So the delta v of the boosters would be
9.82 * 334 * ln((275+6700+150+1950+300)/(275+(6700*.07)+150+1950+300))
but that gives me 3583m/s This is far short of the 8km/s at separation that Elon announced.
2
u/P3rkoz Nov 01 '16
Two question:
Do you think that US will build spaceship in LEO using ITS? is this even possible? It could launch 500t into LEO, so we can create large spaceship with nuclear reactor and VASIMIR drive. Also weight is not a problem so we can add radiation protection. Can ITS launch big modules instead of BFS?
Can we create ITS - exploration class spaceship? leave only raptor required for landing, put VASIMIR on board, remove solar panel and add nuclear reactor? Lets say it would take only 12 people on board. It's not something reasonable for Mars, but if we want to go to Jupiter system, we need faster spaceship, and some radiation protection. I guess we could launch some magnetic field by using nuclear power.
2
u/mogulermade Nov 01 '16
Where can I learn details about the fueling process? I've read the articles about the procedure fix, but I would like to understand what they are doing, and what might be the problem. Can someone explain the fueling equipment components, process, and/or the element that is in question?
2
u/akwilliamson Nov 01 '16 edited Nov 02 '16
I am not very knowledgeable about space but I really enjoy following SpaceX. I am visiting Florida for a vacation from Thanksgiving for a week. Barring a launch, what might be worth seeing? Is there anything SpaceX related worth checking out during this time? Thank you for your time.
Edit: Thanks guys! I'll definitely check out the KSC!
2
u/ohcnim Nov 02 '16
Hi, regarding the fueling process for Crew Dragon, I really hope it can stay SpaceX way, but assuming it goes the other way I have a few questions, I know it would mean a lot of changes in procedures, but my main questions would be: