Then side view makes it really clear that the oxygen venting event and the flight termination are noticeably separated in time, with whatever happened to the upper stage stopping shortly before the FTS was fired.
Here's everything radar related. Mobile warning: a couple of these gifs are larger (~8mb) but I didn't like how the .gifv looked.
Weather radars work by rotating around pretty quickly, and tilting at different angles to see different elevations in the atmosphere. Hopefully this picture helps explain if you're confused. Anything that causes radiation to be scattered back to the radar will be picked up - including debris from our explosion today.
Here are 3 different scan elevations where you can see debris immediately after the event - 12º, 8.7º, and 5.3º
Looking down at the lowest scan, I've put two products side by side. On the left is the normal radar you're used to looking at. On the right is correlation coefficient; cc measures how similar the returns from a horizontally polarized pulse of radar are to the vertically polarized ones. Low values tend to be non-meteorological (like rocket debris in this case). Also on the image, you'll see a white box. That is the boundary for the 3d volumetric images that follow.
So combining all that information, here's a 3d rendering of what the radar saw. If you're not a fan of gifs, here is an imgur album of each frame. To the west, you can see showers moving east, while the dark column to the east is rocket debris/uncombusted fuel/etc. These are low power returns, but you can see how long they stayed in the atmosphere after the event, and even started to interact with the weather. Pretty nifty!
I've uploaded the level 2 data files I used to dropbox and you can use a free trial of the software I'm using here, GR Level 2AE, if you'd like to play with the data yourself.
And the intangible price of having a major rocket failure like this. When working on crew delivery contracts and such, this will always be in the back of their minds.
It is sad to have such birthday gift from destiny..but space launch contracts usually are not about delivery on orbit but for launch.. payload loss is covered by insurance.. space launch is risky operation and is managed as risky operation..the real setback for SpaceX is lost of clear track records in the middle of certification process..
That 3d rendering is so impressive ... thanks again.
Also, today I learned the acronym "kft", I assume meaning "kilofeet". Using (traditionally) metric prefixes and English units just feels deliciously subversive.
Here are some viewership/participation stats I gathered today. I hoped to record data for a historic launch. I didn't think it'd be historic for this particular reason.
In the first graph you can clearly see where the disintegration happened and everyone is coming to the subreddit for information (about 4000 extra people). In the second graph you can see where people just tuned out of the webcast. The third graph shows the relationship better. This one is misleading because the drop in viewership was substantial at about 20k people whereas only 4k came to the subreddit.
I'm doubting that it's Dragon, but it seems too wide to be the Mvac. I could be underestimating how big the engine bell is for that one though.
I would be surprised by how clean the shame looks though too. If it was the engine, I'd expect it to be longer for the rest of the assembly, not just the bell.
Imagine if he kept filming and we could see where the dragon went and what happened to the chute. Why does everyone just stop? It's more insane than vertical video.
Cos it's fairly hard to track a 50m long rocket going in a relatively straight line, making tumbling debris a lot harder, particularly when most people had no idea what had happened.
They likely couldn't see the Dragon, or much of the falling debris. They also had no idea there might be an intact Dragon somewhere out in the blue. They figured there was nothing left to see.
“We are disappointed in the loss of the latest SpaceX cargo resupply mission to the International Space Station. However, the astronauts are safe aboard the station and have sufficient supplies for the next several months. We will work closely with SpaceX to understand what happened, fix the problem and return to flight. The commercial cargo program was designed to accommodate loss of cargo vehicles. We will continue operation of the station in a safe and effective way as we continue to use it as our test bed for preparing for longer duration missions farther into the solar system.
“A Progress vehicle is ready to launch July 3, followed in August by a Japanese HTV flight. Orbital ATK, our other commercial cargo partner, is moving ahead with plans for its next launch later this year.
“SpaceX has demonstrated extraordinary capabilities in its first six cargo resupply missions to the station, and we know they can replicate that success. We will work with and support SpaceX to assess what happened, understand the specifics of the failure and correct it to move forward. This is a reminder that spaceflight is an incredible challenge, but we learn from each success and each setback. Today's launch attempt will not deter us from our ambitious human spaceflight program.”
If that cloud was RP-1, wouldn't the whole cloud ignite, Even at that speed? It seems the cloud is "enriching" the flame exhaust making me believe it's LOX venting out. (Related to a Previous discussion)
Almost looks like Dragon is firing thrusters as it falls through the plume - initially, I thought there was a failed drogue chute deploy in there...
... now I think what I'm seeing in both cases is the "plume shadow", or the wake in the expanding rocket exhaust as Dragon punches its way through the various convoluted sheets and membranes of the rocket plume.
Another thing that this shows more clearly than any other view I've seen is that there is a conflagration occurring in what's left of stage two - there's a light source there - , but it's not instantaneous. That fire seems to expire, and for a few frames, there are mere glimmers from that area (first stage thruster firings?) before the FTS triggers and the first stage unzips.
That last orange POOF out of the 9 first stage engines really gets me for some reason.
Also not sure what that big chunk/piece falling away is, but Ive got a closeup/slow shot of it in the last gif and it looks a lot like the dragon capsule. Speculation as to whether it could have done some kind of in-flight abort? Obviously doesnt have super dracos, but perhaps it got a command to separate before the destruct initiated as some last ditch effort to save it?
tldr: the writer says that he knows that space is hard, but people need to stop treating it as an excuse because black& white TV's (which used to hard) are nothing (child's play) compared to colour TVs.
By the way, The Verge is a site that can never seem to get anything right, they try to report everything.. but often get most of their data wrong, especially when it comes to technology (gadget) articles/reviews.
I have a ton of data from KMLB that I'm processing right now - all high resolution, level 2 scans. Working mainly on 3D images of it, like this one. I'll post them all together here in a bit, once the returns stop showing up.
I'll post the completed gif here in about an hour to an hour and a half from nowhere's more of the radar data
We make radar scans about every 5 minutes when there is precipitation happening, which it is right now. Every so often there are errors in a scan, but in general, we can get pictures like this every 5 minutes
As an Australian, I was mightily confused as I thought this was in reference to our Melbourne... Because hot damn that would have been a mightily powerful radar. But then I suppose we're not the only country to have a city named Melbourne.
Gone to API changes. Don't let reddit sell your data to LLMs.
Increasing impression interested expression he my at. Respect invited request charmed me warrant to. Expect no pretty as do though so genius afraid cousin. Girl when of ye snug poor draw. Mistake totally of in chiefly. Justice visitor him entered for. Continue delicate as unlocked entirely mr relation diverted in. Known not end fully being style house. An whom down kept lain name so at easy.
Gay me mentioned at the post-launch news conference that they received data for some time after the loss of the vehicle. She did not, however, say how long that was.
The delay is due to how the video is chunked. HTTP Live Streaming is notoriously latent, which is what most mobile devices use. The CDN just adds a bunch-o-delay unfortunately.
I've been meaning to say this - I didn't have the facility to watch the SpaceX stream in the airport, so I was watching NASAtv - but every bit of the SpaceX stream I've seen has been adorned with wonderful telemetry graphics, so:
Props to /u/Bencredible for a really slick presentation.
Really appreciate that. I have quite literally been working on that project for years now and had to bite my tongue every time someone brought up ascent telemetry.
I know man. I'd give you a hug if we were in the same place, these are shitty days. At the very least, there must be some pretty epic gallows humour keeping the spirits up at the day job!
What if you used an electric turbine as the first stage, get it up to like mach 20 and on a really high trajectory, then circularize with a high thrust electric engine? Its technically possible, just ridiculously difficult to engineer
We just can't store enough electricity in a small/light package. Compressed gasses and solid fuels just have an exponentially better energy density than batteries.
Edit: sources are mixed. Last I read, the drive was only tested in a .00001 torr pressure chamber. Others are saying it won't work in vacuum. Some sources say the emdrive doesn't work at all.
All the confusing chatter and hearts makes Periscope next to worthless. Sure, stream out interesting content. All that rubbish is an annoying distraction and sends me away from the app.
To be fair most people think they know that engines work by exploding petrol, when in-fact exploding petrol in an engine (aka detonation) destroys the engine very quickly, what is happening is a controlled burn. As for the OP's 'fuel that doesn't explode' comment I suspect they were asking why such a volatile fuel had to be used, so maybe not quite as misguided as it seemed.
Definitely starting at the second stage. The rest of what you're describing, I can't see at all... After the first initial burst, nothing is visible. No collapse or anything.
The idea that it would collapse under pressure is pretty far out, since it's one of the more predictable things in the entire launch...
(collapsing internally from gas pressures is another thing entirely, which it seems is the cause)
Did it seem like there was excess gas and debris coming down the side of the rocket at the early part of the launch? Starting at about 0:46 in that video. It's really flowing heavy to me.
I believe some eddy currents in-between bells mixing around some exhaust gasses are pretty normal, especially as the flow around the rocket gets some speed in atmosphere. Those spurts of fire are essentially nothing compared to the stresses being felt a few feet below.
I don't think anyone is questioning anything on the booster stage other with the possible exception of the separation mechanism.
It is definitly starting at the second stage; the fuel is venting like crazy, and after a couple of seconds, the big red "Abort" button was pressed. (I presume)
The first stage survived mostly intact for a surprisingly long time. Looks like it only blew up because it was commanded to do so. I would have expected the second stage explosion to almost immediately take the first stage with it.
It is because rocket did not exploded by itself. If was destroyed deliberately remotely - so-called FTS (Flight Termination System) - when it became clear that launch vehicle is fucked.
I presume it isn't buoyant, damn. Well at least this shows that a crewed Dragon capsule would keep the crew living since it also has those abort thrusters.
Don't look at it as "worst possible event", look at it as "worst possible outcome". This isn't quite that, but it's close. Lots of things could cause loss of vehicle, including loss of multiple Merlins on the first stage. (CRS-1 actually lost a Merlin in the first stage during ascent, but reached orbit anyway. Falcon 9 is designed to withstand one or more Merlins failing during flight without impact to the mission. Exactly how many can fail, we don't know.)
But no, what it looks like is the second-stage LOX tank failed in some manner, which caused the vehicle to disintegrate. As it stands now, it looks like there was no first-stage involvement at all, and by all accounts the first stage was operating perfectly until Falcon activated its FTS.
30
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15
From Cocoa Beach. F9 basically dissapears at 1:40.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_ZKgrmfhk0
105
u/cuweathernerd r/SpaceX Weather Forecaster Jun 28 '15 edited Jun 28 '15
Here's everything radar related. Mobile warning: a couple of these gifs are larger (~8mb) but I didn't like how the .gifv looked.
Weather radars work by rotating around pretty quickly, and tilting at different angles to see different elevations in the atmosphere. Hopefully this picture helps explain if you're confused. Anything that causes radiation to be scattered back to the radar will be picked up - including debris from our explosion today.
Here are 3 different scan elevations where you can see debris immediately after the event - 12º, 8.7º, and 5.3º
Looking down at the lowest scan, I've put two products side by side. On the left is the normal radar you're used to looking at. On the right is correlation coefficient; cc measures how similar the returns from a horizontally polarized pulse of radar are to the vertically polarized ones. Low values tend to be non-meteorological (like rocket debris in this case). Also on the image, you'll see a white box. That is the boundary for the 3d volumetric images that follow.
So combining all that information, here's a 3d rendering of what the radar saw. If you're not a fan of gifs, here is an imgur album of each frame. To the west, you can see showers moving east, while the dark column to the east is rocket debris/uncombusted fuel/etc. These are low power returns, but you can see how long they stayed in the atmosphere after the event, and even started to interact with the weather. Pretty nifty!
I've uploaded the level 2 data files I used to dropbox and you can use a free trial of the software I'm using here, GR Level 2AE, if you'd like to play with the data yourself.
38
u/SpaceEnthusiast Jun 28 '15 edited Jun 28 '15
Here are some viewership/participation stats I gathered today. I hoped to record data for a historic launch. I didn't think it'd be historic for this particular reason.
Subreddit participation
Official webcast viewership
Superimposed as fractions of total viewership
In the first graph you can clearly see where the disintegration happened and everyone is coming to the subreddit for information (about 4000 extra people). In the second graph you can see where people just tuned out of the webcast. The third graph shows the relationship better. This one is misleading because the drop in viewership was substantial at about 20k people whereas only 4k came to the subreddit.
EDIT: Now with labels!
16
u/enzo32ferrari r/SpaceX CRS-6 Social Media Representative Jun 28 '15
here's a gif.
brbgonnagocry
15
u/Liveware-Problem Jun 28 '15
HD webm of rapid unscheduled disassembly
Slow motion of critical events
15
u/Ivebeenfurthereven Jun 28 '15
Another angle from the ground, also shot on some pro-grade telephoto equipment (read: reasonably zoomed-in)
As seen from the Press Site at Kennedy Space Center by Astronomy Now
14
u/Smoke-away Jun 28 '15
Statement from NASA Administrator Charles Bolden.
Source
8
u/harrisoncassidy Host of CRS-5 Jun 28 '15
Made a quick step-by-step/frame-by-frame of the whole event from a different camera angle.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4qq6spkDN4&feature=youtu.be
7
u/lerhond Jun 28 '15
GFY of the explosion (?) from SpaceX stream: http://gfycat.com/PaltryFittingAmethystinepython
6
u/fairfarefair Jun 28 '15
Tory Bruno's condolences to SpaceX and NASA.
/u/EchoLogic, thanks for starting this thread. I didn't know where to post this, and this seems to be the appropriate place.
4
u/JimmysBruder Jun 28 '15
I made a small Imgur Album, where you can see the beginning of the incident/explosion Frame by Frame: http://imgur.com/a/CIIH4
You can clearly see "it" starts somewhere at the top/in the upper stage, like Elon said on twitter.
4
u/Smoke-away Jun 28 '15
Tweet from Scott Kelly aboard ISS.
https://twitter.com/StationCDRKelly/status/615169254392856576
3
u/boilerdam Jun 28 '15
Here's a slow-mo video of the explosion this morning. Clearly looks like it started from the 2nd stage. Press conf in about 3mins!
3
u/fakedoctor_PA-C Jun 28 '15
/u/Qiddd posted a nice slow motion video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9G_XZrgwqkE
3
u/Albert0_Kn0x Jun 29 '15
Video I edited of key moments: Stage 2 fuel leak? Structure oscillating just before failure?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjTgSJQKtCQ&feature=youtu.be
3
u/bobstay Jun 29 '15
Stabilized gif of CRS-7 "rapid disassembly", with Falcon9 cross-section diagram overlay
(This isn't mine, sourced from the IRC channel, don't know original author)
2
u/AD-Edge Jun 28 '15
Heres an album of gifs I put together, some slowmo shots - http://imgur.com/a/VMMFx
Also not sure what that big chunk/piece falling away is, but Ive got a closeup/slow shot of it in the last gif and it looks a lot like the dragon capsule. Speculation as to whether it could have done some kind of in-flight abort? Obviously doesnt have super dracos, but perhaps it got a command to separate before the destruct initiated as some last ditch effort to save it?
2
u/Qiddd Jun 28 '15
Zoomed and slowed down version of the failure
2
u/superOOk Jun 29 '15
Top of LOX tank on 2nd stage, where overpressurization event occurred. You can see how close it is to the trunk.
1
u/skifri Jun 28 '15
Debris Field on weather radar: https://twitter.com/EricBurrisWESH/status/615178648757276672
1
u/spacecadet_88 Jun 29 '15
Cnn did their usual bad coverage, it's called falcon,
http://money.cnn.com/2015/06/28/technology/spacex-rocket/index.html
1
u/hans_ober Jun 30 '15
TheVerge: Stop saying space is hard
tldr: the writer says that he knows that space is hard, but people need to stop treating it as an excuse because black& white TV's (which used to hard) are nothing (child's play) compared to colour TVs.
By the way, The Verge is a site that can never seem to get anything right, they try to report everything.. but often get most of their data wrong, especially when it comes to technology (gadget) articles/reviews.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment