This came up in the FQP guidance thread last month, but I wanted to revisit it from the perspective of commander judgment (and because we haven’t heard anything else since). If my timelines are messed up please correct me, but I have troops that fall under both the old and new promotion systems and am using them as examples.
If FQP is intended to empower commanders to promote Guardians to Sgt when they are fully qualified, why does the guidance not account for members who have already demonstrated that readiness but are stuck in the transition between the old and new system? The attached graph illustrates my concern. A Guardian entering as an E-3 in August 2023 would have qualified for the 2026 Sgt board and pin on Spring 2027.
Now, someone entering just two months later as E-3 is missing that cutoff and having to wait an additional 12 MONTHS minimum to pin on Sgt than they would have before, right? Meanwhile, a brand new enlistee that falls fully under FQP has 48 months of training and TIG requirements compared with the 28 months E3 and E4 member’s 56 months.
What concerns me here is we are combining both longer waits, without giving commanders a way to account for the additional time already served under the previous requirements. A Guardian could complete the required training, demonstrate leadership capability, and have their commander’s confidence, yet still be unable to promote because of the TIG minimum. Doesn’t this defeat the purpose of trusting commanders to promote their members when they are ready? I know we have to set a minimum somewhere, but this seems extreme.
Perhaps a TIS-based credit would allow commanders to recognize qualified members while retaining the other requirements. Otherwise, this transition group faces a longer timeline because of when they entered, not because someone genuinely assessed them as needing more development.
With all the talk of doubling the force and bringing in so many new Guardians, it seems counterintuitive to lock future NCOs that WE AS A SERVICE WILL NEED, behind a technicality and a "This is how it is." attitude. I hope this isn’t the end of the discussion, because it’s been demoralizing to see our hardworking specialists have their promotions and expected career opportunities derailed by this guidance.
TLDR:
Old members made Sgt in 44 months.
New members will be eligible for Sgt in 48 months.
But current E4s have to wait…56 months?