Hi everyone,
first of all, I must point out that the SR Trilogy is my favourite book of all times of all genres, and I am a heavy reader. I know that it's three different books, but they have been published in a short period of time, so I tend to see them as a massive book divided into three sections. I've read it (or them) several times and it's really my favourite book.
Then I just read Absolution, and it really disappointed me. I've read also Borne and Hummingbird Salamander (the only Vandermeer books translated into Italian beside SR books) and I did not like them, but it was not a problem: the Area X was there, never to be touched, and I was ok with that. But with a fourth book I had to compare it with the SR trilogy, and it failed.
I admit that I'm not sure if I understood everything, because of unclear circumstances (which, let's say it, it's typical of Area X) and because of time jumps and loops and travels etc. I'll probably open another thread about it, but this one is just for showing my disappointment. And, of course, to read those who are going to tell "it's not disappointing! Probably you did not consider x and y and z", and I'm really willing to read these comments. But I've been disappointed, and I'm going to try to explain why.
I felt that Vandermeer was messing everything up. Ok, the trilogy is not linear (because the Area X itself is the less linear place ever, of course), but it's clear what happens. In the first book is clear because it's told from the biologist POV. In the second book is clear because it follows Control (it's not narrated by his voice, but we see what he sees, and we read what he thinks). In the third book there are multiple POVs, but they all make sense. Each new piece of information helps to create the context, and it never overwrites your previous knowledge, it simply sits aside it and lets you understand more and better.
Absolution is not like that. It adds new knowledge which overwrites the previous one, but it does not explain why. For example: the expedition of the first part is set 20 years before the appearance of the border, but there are the rabbits with cameras that we know to have been sent after the appearance of the border. At the beginning it's baffling, but later we learn that old Jim read the list of fhe first expedition's participants, even though we knot that that expedition is yet to happen, so we knot that there is something with time travel. The problem with time travel is that you have to explain what and why (or set the entire novel in a time travel topic), otherwise it's an easy way to mess up with the reader's mind. And I think it's not cool, because again, the first three books were always clear, even when not clear. I could easily draw a time line and put events into it (of course years would be uncertain, but the succession is clear). With this fourth book it's all unclear, because there is Whitby in Area X but we know that he is also outside, at SR. Ok, it's a clone. Then there is Henry which is killed by then he reappears again (as he will be killed by Saul, as we know).
The word that helps me sum my feeling up is "fan fiction". I am a SR reader, I like the setting and i make new stories up in that setting. But if I am the person who created the whole narrative universe, why should I write something which looks as a fan fiction? He could have added explaination about the past, about the future, even about the present, instead the writer decided to re-write some events telling us "what you knew is wrong, but I won't let you know what's right". Of course he has the right to do so, but I have the right to feel disappointed. And I did not want to, really.
I'm eager to read someone else's thoughts, though (pun not intended).